Sie sind auf Seite 1von 17

TITLE XII 1.

Judicial- attachment or
DEPOSIT seizure of the property is
ordered;
CHAPTER 1 2. Extrajudicial-
Deposit in General and its a. Voluntary- made by the
Different Kinds will of the depositor.
b. Necessary-
Article 1962. A deposit is i. Made in
constituted from the moment a compliance with a
person receives a thing legal obligation;
belonging to another, with the ii. On the occasion of
obligation of safely keeping it a calamity;
and of returning the same. If the iii. Made by travellers
safekeeping of the thing in hotels or inns;
delivered is not the principal iv. Made by travellers
purpose of the contract, there is with common
no deposit but some other carrier.
contract. (1758a)
Characteristics of the Contract of
Contract of Deposit perfected: Deposit:

A deposit being a real contract is 1. Real contract;


deposited by delivery but an 2. Principal purpose is
agreement to constitute a deposit is safekeeping of the thing;
merely consensual, and being 3. Depositary cannot use the
binding upon mere consent. thing deposited except in the
two instances
aforementioned;
When can the object of deposit be 4. Only movable things be the
used? object;
5. It is a gratuitous contract
1. With the express permission except when there is an
of the depositor; agreement to the contrary;
2. When the preservation of the 6. It is either unilateral or
thing deposited requires its bilateral.
use, it must but only for that
purpose. Article 1963. An agreement to
constitute a deposit is binding,
Kinds of Deposit: but the deposit itself is not
perfected until the delivery of
the thing. (n)

1|Page
The agreement is however binding. 1. Contrary agreement;
2. Depositary is engaged in the
Article 1964. A deposit may be business of storing goods.
constituted judicially or
extrajudicially. (1759) Compensation; current rates in the
place where the deposit is
Distinctions between judicial and constituted.
extrajudicial:
Article 1966. Only movable
EXTRAJUDICIAL JUDICIAL things may be the object of a
deposit. (1761)
Origin:
-will of the parties - will of the Deposit, attachment and
court sequestration of real properties may
Status: be by annotation of lis pendens to
-there is contract - no contract the Register of property.
Purpose:
-custody and - to guarantee Article 1967. An extrajudicial
safekeeping the right of the deposit is either voluntary or
plaintiff necessary. (1762)
Cause:
-Gratuitous -Onerous Voluntary- there is mutual consent;
Subject matter:
-always movable -movable or Necessary-made because of
immovable calamity.
In whose behalf it is held:
- Depositor -Winner of the
suit CHAPTER 2
Voluntary Deposit
Article 1965. A deposit is a
gratuitous contract, except when SECTION 1
there is an agreement to the General Provisions
contrary, or unless the
depositary is engaged in the
business of storing goods.
(1760a)

General rule: Deposit is gratuitous

Exceptions:

2|Page
Article 1968. A voluntary deposit Note: As long as the depositor is
is that wherein the delivery is insane, he cannot compel the return
made by the will of the of the thing. He must act through his
depositor. A deposit may also be guardian or administrator.
made by two or more persons
each of whom believes himself The contract under this is voidable.
entitled to the thing deposited
with a third person, who shall Article 1971. If the deposit has
deliver it in a proper case to the been made by a capacitated
one to whom it belongs. (1763) person with another who is not,
the depositor shall only have an
Voluntary deposit- delivery of the action to recover the thing
object is made by the will of the deposited while it is still in the
parties. possession of the depositary, or
to compel the latter to pay him
Note: Depositor need not to prove his the amount by which he may
ownership of the thing deposited. have enriched or benefited
himself with the thing or its
Article 1969. A contract of price. However, if a third person
deposit may be entered into who acquired the thing acted in
orally or in writing. (n) bad faith, the depositor may
bring an action against him for
Form of contract of deposit: its recovery. (1765a)

1. Oral; Remedy of the depositor where the


2. Written thing is still in the possession of the
insane:
Article 1970. If a person having
capacity to contract accepts a Action for Replevin- to
deposit made by one who is recover or vindicate a thing.
incapacitated, the former shall
be subject to all the obligations The contract under this is voidable.
of a depositary, and may be
compelled to return the thing by SECTION 2
the guardian, or administrator, Obligations of the Depositary
of the person who made the
deposit, or by the latter himself Article 1972. The depositary is
if he should acquire capacity. obliged to keep the thing safely
(1764) and to return it, when required,
to the depositor, or to his heirs
and successors, or to the person

3|Page
who may have been designated Exceptions: When there is a
in the contract. His stipulation to the contrary.
responsibility, with regard to the
safekeeping and the loss of the Article 1974. The depositary may
thing, shall be governed by the change the way of the deposit if
provisions of Title I of this Book. under the circumstances he may
reasonably presume that the
If the deposit is gratuitous, this depositor would consent to the
fact shall be taken into account change if he knew of the facts of
in determining the degree of the situation. However, before
care that the depositary must the depositary may make such
observe. (1766a) change, he shall notify the
depositor thereof and wait for
Principal obligations of the his decision, unless delay would
Depositary: cause danger. (n)

1. Safekeeping; Depositary may change the way of


2. Return the thing when the deposit, but must notify the
required. depositor and wait for his decision.

Duty of safekeeping; Exception: Delay would cause


danger.
1. Diligence of a Good father of
family is required;
2. Responsible if the loss is
through his fault. Article 1975. The depositary
holding certificates, bonds,
Article 1973. Unless there is a securities or instruments which
stipulation to the contrary, the earn interest shall be bound to
depositary cannot deposit the collect the latter when it
thing with a third person. If becomes due, and to take such
deposit with a third person is steps as may be necessary in
allowed, the depositary is liable order that the securities may
for the loss if he deposited the preserve their value and the
thing with a person who is rights corresponding to them
manifestly careless or unfit. The according to law.
depositary is responsible for the
negligence of his employees. (n) The above provision shall not
apply to contracts for the rent of
General rule: Deposit with a third safety deposit boxes. (n)
person is not allowed.

4|Page
Duty of the depositary to collect use, it must but only for that
interest includes the capital when purpose.
due and to return whatever collected
to the depositor. Article 1978. When the
depositary has permission to use
Article 1976. Unless there is a the thing deposited, the contract
stipulation to the contrary, the loses the concept of a deposit
depositary may commingle grain and becomes a loan or
or other articles of the same commodatum, except where
kind and quality, in which case safekeeping is still the principal
the various depositors shall own purpose of the contract.
or have a proportionate interest
in the mass. (n) The permission shall not be
presumed, and its existence
Reason: as soon as the goods are must be proved. (1768a)
intermingled, each person’s portion
lose its identity and can no longer be Irregular deposit:
distinguished or separated from the
common mass, - Something consumable is the
subject of the deposit which
Article 1977. The depositary can be used.
cannot make use of the thing
deposited without the express Deposit of Money is really a Loan:
permission of the depositor.
1. When the money is
Otherwise, he shall be liable for authorized to be used by the
damages. depositary;

However, when the preservation 2. When there is an interest


of the thing deposited requires offered as compensation for
its use, it must be used but only the use of the money.
for that purpose. (1767a)
Note: Things received on deposit do
Two instance when the thing can be not prescribe.
used:
Article 1979. The depositary is
1. With the express permission liable for the loss of the thing
of the depositor; through a fortuitous event:
2. When the preservation of the
thing deposited requires its
(1) If it is so stipulated;

5|Page
(2) If he uses the thing contrary. However, the courts
without the depositor's may pass upon the credibility of
permission; the depositor with respect to the
value claimed by him.
(3) If he delays its return;
When the seal or lock is broken,
(4) If he allows others to with or without the depositary's
use it, even though he fault, he shall keep the secret of
himself may have been the deposit. (1769a)
authorized to use the
same. (n) When is a depository presumed to be
authorized to open a locked box:
Generally, depositary is not liable for
fortuitous events, except the 1. When the key has been
aforementioned. delivered to him;
2. When the instructions of the
Article 1980. Fixed, savings, and depositor cannot be executed
current deposits of money in without opening the box or
banks and similar institutions receptacle.
shall be governed by the
provisions concerning simple Note: If the sealed deposit is lost, the
loan. (n) liability or value shall depend on the
statement of the depositor, subject
Article 1981. When the thing to judicial scrutiny.
deposited is delivered closed
and sealed, the depositary must Article 1982. When it becomes
return it in the same condition, necessary to open a locked box
and he shall be liable for or receptacle, the depositary is
damages should the seal or lock presumed authorized to do so, if
be broken through his fault. the key has been delivered to
him; or when the instructions of
Fault on the part of the the depositor as regards the
depositary is presumed, unless deposit cannot be executed
there is proof to the contrary. without opening the box or
receptacle. (n)
As regards the value of the thing
deposited, the statement of the Article 1983. The thing
depositor shall be accepted, deposited shall be returned with
when the forcible opening is all its products, accessories and
imputable to the depositary, accessions.
should there be no proof to the

6|Page
Should the deposit consist of thing has not been lawfully
money, the provisions relative to acquired by the latter.
agents in article 1896 shall be
applied to the depositary. (1770) Article 1985. When there are two
or more depositors, if they are
Self- explanatory. not solidary, and the thing
admits of division, each one
Article 1984. The depositary cannot demand more than his
cannot demand that the share.
depositor prove his ownership of
the thing deposited. When there is solidarity or the
thing does not admit of division,
Nevertheless, should he discover the provisions of articles 1212
that the thing has been stolen and 1214 shall govern. However,
and who its true owner is, he if there is a stipulation that the
must advise the latter of the thing should be returned to one
deposit. of the depositors, the depositary
shall return it only to the person
If the owner, in spite of such designated. (1772a)
information, does not claim it
within the period of one month, Article 1212:
the depositary shall be relieved A party can do something to
of all responsibility by returning the benefit of the other.
the thing deposited to the Article 1214:
depositor. The thing can be returned to
any them.
If the depositary has reasonable
grounds to believe that the thing Article 1986. If the depositor
has not been lawfully acquired should lose his capacity to
by the depositor, the former may contract after having made the
return the same. (1771a) deposit, the thing cannot be
returned except to the persons
Duty of the depositary when the who may have the
thing has been stolen: administration of his property
and rights. (1773)
- If he knows of such fact,
advise the true owner of the Note: If the depositor returns to a
deposit. depositor who is NOW insane, the
- May return the same to the depositary is discharged from his
depositor if has reasonable obligation if:
grounds to believe that the

7|Page
1. If the insane depositor has to the return or the removal of
kept the thing delivered: the thing deposited. In these
2. Delivery has been beneficial cases, the depositary must
to such insane depositor. immediately inform the
depositor of the attachment or
Article 1987. If at the time the opposition. (1775)
deposit was made a place was
designated for the return of the Note: When no fixed period for the
thing, the depositary must take return, withdrawal can be made at
the thing deposited to such any time without necessity of a
place; but the expenses for judicial order.
transportation shall be borne by
the depositor. Exceptions:

If no place has been designated 1. When the thing is judicially


for the return, it shall be made attached while in the
where the thing deposited may depositary’s possession.
be, even if it should not be the 2. When the depositary was
same place where the deposit notified of the opposition of a
was made, provided that there third person to the return or
was no malice on the part of the removal of the thing
depositary. (1774) deposited.

Rule as to place of return: Note: Should the depositary return


the thing despite the attachment or
1. Place designated; the opposition, he is responsible for
2. If no place designated, where damages.
the thing deposited may be.
Article 1989. Unless the deposit
Article 1988. The thing is for a valuable consideration,
deposited must be returned to the depositary who may have
the depositor upon demand, justifiable reasons for not
even though a specified period keeping the thing deposited
or time for such return may have may, even before the time
been fixed. designated, return it to the
depositor; and if the latter
This provision shall not apply should refuse to receive it, the
when the thing is judicially depositary may secure its
attached while in the consignation from the court.
depositary's possession, or (1776a)
should he have been notified of
the opposition of a third person
8|Page
Consignation- act of depositing the 1. to return the price he may
things due at the disposal of judicial have received;
authority. 2. to assign his right of action
against the buyer in case the
Justifiable reason for return: price has not been paid him.
If in bad faith:
1. Serious danger to property; 1. With damges.
2. Unbearably long time of
deposit.
SECTION 3
Note: If the deposit is made with Obligations of the Depositor
compensation, the return must be
done with proportional reduction in Article 1992. If the deposit is
the compensation. gratuitous, the depositor is
obliged to reimburse the
Article 1990. If the depositary by depositary for the expenses he
force majeure or government may have incurred for the
order loses the thing and preservation of the thing
receives money or another thing deposited. (1779a)
in its place, he shall deliver the
sum or other thing to the Right to Reimbursement
depositor. (1777a)
1. Duty to reimburse necessary
Duty of the depositary: expenses for preservation, if
the deposit is onerous.
1. Return the sum or proceed to
the depositor. Article 1993. The depositor shall
reimburse the depositary for any
Article 1991. The depositary's loss arising from the character of
heir who in good faith may have the thing deposited, unless at
sold the thing which he did not the time of the constitution of
know was deposited, shall only the deposit the former was not
be bound to return the price he aware of, or was not expected to
may have received or to assign know the dangerous character of
his right of action against the the thing, or unless he notified
buyer in case the price has not the depositary of the same, or
been paid him. (1778) the latter was aware of it
without advice from the
depositor. (n)
Duty of the heir;

If in good faith: General rule:

9|Page
If the depositary suffers (1) Upon the loss or
because of the character of the thing destruction of the thing
deposited, the depositor should be deposited;
responsible for the loss sustained by
the depositary. (2) In case of a gratuitous
deposit, upon the death of
Exceptions: either the depositor or the
depositary. (n)
1. If at the time the deposit was
made, the depositor was not
aware of, or was not expected Effect of death:
to know the dangerous 1. If onerous, it is extinguished
character of the thing. but the thing must be
2. If at the time the deposit was returned.
made, the depositor knew of 2. If gratuitous, it is not
the danger BUT he notifies extinguished, unless
the depositary of the same. terminated by the heirs of
3. If at the time the deposit was depositor.
made, the depositary was
aware of the danger, even Note: Death here refers to the death
though he had not been of either the depositor or depoditary.
notified by the depositor.
CHAPTER 3
Article 1994. The depositary may Necessary Deposit
retain the thing in pledge until
the full payment of what may be Article 1996. A deposit is
due him by reason of the necessary:
deposit. (1780)
(1) When it is made in
Right of Retention compliance with a legal
obligation;
- If the depositor has not yet
paid the depositary of the (2) When it takes place on
necessary expenses incurred the occasion of any
for preservation. calamity, such as fire,
storm, flood, pillage,
Article 1995. A deposit its shipwreck, or other similar
extinguished: events. (1781a)

Article 1997. The deposit


referred to in No. 1 of the

10 | P a g e
preceding article shall be as strangers; but not that which
governed by the provisions of may proceed from any force
the law establishing it, and in majeure. The fact that travellers
case of its deficiency, by the are constrained to rely on the
rules on voluntary deposit. vigilance of the keeper of the
hotels or inns shall be
The deposit mentioned in No. 2 considered in determining the
of the preceding article shall be degree of care required of him.
regulated by the provisions (1784a)
concerning voluntary deposit
and by article 2168. (1782) Article 2001. The act of a thief or
robber, who has entered the
Article 1998. The deposit of hotel is not deemed force
effects made by travellers in majeure, unless it is done with
hotels or inns shall also be the use of arms or through an
regarded as necessary. The irresistible force. (n)
keepers of hotels or inns shall be
responsible for them as Article 2002. The hotel-keeper is
depositaries, provided that not liable for compensation if the
notice was given to them, or to loss is due to the acts of the
their employees, of the effects guest, his family, servants or
brought by the guests and that, visitors, or if the loss arises from
on the part of the latter, they the character of the things
take the precautions which said brought into the hotel. (n)
hotel-keepers or their
substitutes advised relative to Article 2003. The hotel-keeper
the care and vigilance of their cannot free himself from
effects. (1783) responsibility by posting notices
to the effect that he is not liable
Article 1999. The hotel-keeper is for the articles brought by the
liable for the vehicles, animals guest. Any stipulation between
and articles which have been the hotel-keeper and the guest
introduced or placed in the whereby the responsibility of the
annexes of the hotel. (n) former as set forth in articles
1998 to 2001 is suppressed or
Article 2000. The responsibility diminished shall be void. (n)
referred to in the two preceding
articles shall include the loss of, Article 2004. The hotel-keeper
or injury to the personal has a right to retain the things
property of the guests caused by brought into the hotel by the
the servants or employees of the guest, as a security for credits
keepers of hotels or inns as well on account of lodging, and

11 | P a g e
supplies usually furnished to TITLE XV
hotel guests. (n) GUARANTY

CHAPTER 4 CHAPTER 1
Nature and Extent of Guaranty
Sequestration or Judicial Deposit
Article 2047. By guaranty a
Article 2005. A judicial deposit or person, called the guarantor,
sequestration takes place when binds himself to the creditor to
an attachment or seizure of fulfill the obligation of the
property in litigation is ordered. principal debtor in case the
(1785) latter should fail to do so.

Article 2006. Movable as well as If a person binds himself


immovable property may be the solidarily with the principal
object of sequestration. (1786) debtor, the provisions of Section
4, Chapter 3, Title I of this Book
Article 2007. The depositary of shall be observed. In such case
property or objects sequestrated the contract is called a
cannot be relieved of his suretyship. (1822a)
responsibility until the
controversy which gave rise Article 2048. A guaranty is
thereto has come to an end, gratuitous, unless there is a
unless the court so orders. stipulation to the contrary. (n)
(1787a)
Article 2049. A married woman
Article 2008. The depositary of may guarantee an obligation
property sequestrated is bound without the husband's consent,
to comply, with respect to the but shall not thereby bind the
same, with all the obligations of conjugal partnership, except in
a good father of a family. (1788) cases provided by law. (n)

Article 2009. As to matters not Article 2050. If a guaranty is


provided for in this Code, judicial entered into without the
sequestration shall be governed knowledge or consent, or against
by the Rules of Court. (1789a) the will of the principal debtor,
the provisions of articles 1236
and 1237 shall apply. (n)

12 | P a g e
Article 2051. A guaranty may be reduced to the limits of that of
conventional, legal or judicial, the debtor. (1826)
gratuitous, or by onerous title.
Article 2055. A guaranty is not
It may also be constituted, not presumed; it must be express
only in favor of the principal and cannot extend to more than
debtor, but also in favor of the what is stipulated therein.
other guarantor, with the latter's
consent, or without his If it be simple or indefinite, it
knowledge, or even over his shall compromise not only the
objection. (1823) principal obligation, but also all
its accessories, including the
Article 2052. A guaranty cannot judicial costs, provided with
exist without a valid obligation. respect to the latter, that the
guarantor shall only be liable for
Nevertheless, a guaranty may be those costs incurred after he has
constituted to guarantee the been judicially required to pay.
performance of a voidable or an (1827a)
unenforceable contract. It may
also guarantee a natural Article 2056. One who is obliged
obligation. (1824a) to furnish a guarantor shall
present a person who possesses
Article 2053. A guaranty may integrity, capacity to bind
also be given as security for himself, and sufficient property
future debts, the amount of to answer for the obligation
which is not yet known; there which he guarantees. The
can be no claim against the guarantor shall be subject to the
guarantor until the debt is jurisdiction of the court of the
liquidated. A conditional place where this obligation is to
obligation may also be secured. be complied with. (1828a)
(1825a)
Article 2057. If the guarantor
Article 2054. A guarantor may should be convicted in first
bind himself for less, but not for instance of a crime involving
more than the principal debtor, dishonesty or should become
both as regards the amount and insolvent, the creditor may
the onerous nature of the demand another who has all the
conditions. qualifications required in the
preceding article. The case is
Should he have bound himself excepted where the creditor has
for more, his obligations shall be required and stipulated that a

13 | P a g e
specified person should be the left a manager or
guarantor. (1829a) representative;

(5) If it may be presumed


that an execution on the
property of the principal
CHAPTER 2 debtor would not result in
Effects of Guaranty the satisfaction of the
obligation. (1831a)

Article 2060. In order that the


guarantor may make use of the
benefit of exclusion, he must set
SECTION 1 it up against the creditor upon
Effects of Guaranty Between the the latter's demand for payment
Guarantor and the Creditor from him, and point out to the
creditor available property of the
Article 2058. The guarantor debtor within Philippine
cannot be compelled to pay the territory, sufficient to cover the
creditor unless the latter has amount of the debt. (1832)
exhausted all the property of the
debtor, and has resorted to all Article 2061. The guarantor
the legal remedies against the having fulfilled all the conditions
debtor. (1830a) required in the preceding article,
the creditor who is negligent in
Article 2059. The excussion shall exhausting the property pointed
not take place: out shall suffer the loss, to the
extent of said property, for the
(1) If the guarantor has insolvency of the debtor
expressly renounced it; resulting from such negligence.
(1833a)
(2) If he has bound himself
solidarily with the debtor; Article 2062. In every action by
the creditor, which must be
(3) In case of insolvency of against the principal debtor
the debtor; alone, except in the cases
mentioned in article 2059, the
former shall ask the court to
(4) When he has
notify the guarantor of the
absconded, or cannot be
action. The guarantor may
sued within the
appear so that he may, if he so
Philippines unless he has
desire, set up such defenses as

14 | P a g e
are granted him by law. The
benefit of excussion mentioned
in article 2058 shall always be
unimpaired, even if judgment SECTION 2
should be rendered against the Effects of Guaranty Between the
principal debtor and the Debtor and the Guarantor
guarantor in case of appearance
by the latter. (1834a)
Article 2066. The guarantor who
pays for a debtor must be
Article 2063. A compromise indemnified by the latter.
between the creditor and the
principal debtor benefits the
The indemnity comprises:
guarantor but does not prejudice
him. That which is entered into
between the guarantor and the (1) The total amount of
creditor benefits but does not the debt;
prejudice the principal debtor.
(1835a) (2) The legal interests
thereon from the time the
Article 2064. The guarantor of a payment was made known
guarantor shall enjoy the benefit to the debtor, even
of excussion, both with respect though it did not earn
to the guarantor and to the interest for the creditor;
principal debtor. (1836)
(3) The expenses incurred
Article 2065. Should there be by the guarantor after
several guarantors of only one having notified the debtor
debtor and for the same debt, that payment had been
the obligation to answer for the demanded of him;
same is divided among all. The
creditor cannot claim from the (4) Damages, if they are
guarantors except the shares due. (1838a)
which they are respectively
bound to pay, unless solidarity Article 2067. The guarantor who
has been expressly stipulated. pays is subrogated by virtue
thereof to all the rights which
The benefit of division against the creditor had against the
the co-guarantors ceases in the debtor.
same cases and for the same
reasons as the benefit of If the guarantor has
excussion against the principal compromised with the creditor,
debtor. (1837) he cannot demand of the debtor
15 | P a g e
more than what he has really (1) When he is sued for
paid. (1839) the payment;

Article 2068. If the guarantor (2) In case of insolvency of


should pay without notifying the the principal debtor;
debtor, the latter may enforce
against him all the defenses (3) When the debtor has
which he could have set up bound himself to relieve
against the creditor at the time him from the guaranty
the payment was made. (1840) within a specified period,
and this period has
Article 2069. If the debt was for expired;
a period and the guarantor paid
it before it became due, he (4) When the debt has
cannot demand reimbursement become demandable, by
of the debtor until the expiration reason of the expiration of
of the period unless the payment the period for payment;
has been ratified by the debtor.
(1841a) (5) After the lapse of ten
years, when the principal
Article 2070. If the guarantor obligation has no fixed
has paid without notifying the period for its maturity,
debtor, and the latter not being unless it be of such nature
aware of the payment, repeats that it cannot be
the payment, the former has no extinguished except
remedy whatever against the within a period longer
debtor, but only against the than ten years;
creditor. Nevertheless, in case of
a gratuitous guaranty, if the (6) If there are reasonable
guarantor was prevented by a grounds to fear that the
fortuitous event from advising principal debtor intends to
the debtor of the payment, and abscond;
the creditor becomes insolvent,
the debtor shall reimburse the
guarantor for the amount paid. (7) If the principal debtor
(1842a) is in imminent danger of
becoming insolvent.
Article 2071. The guarantor,
even before having paid, may In all these cases, the action of
proceed against the principal the guarantor is to obtain
debtor: release from the guaranty, or to
demand a security that shall

16 | P a g e
protect him from any
proceedings by the creditor and
from the danger of insolvency of
the debtor. (1834a)

Article 2072. If one, at the


request of another, becomes a
guarantor for the debt of a third
person who is not present, the
guarantor who satisfies the debt
may sue either the person so
requesting or the debtor for
reimbursement. (n)

SECTION 3.

17 | P a g e

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen