AISC Basic Design Value 1 Comparison

Based upon simplyfying assumptions and arbitary limitations. Direct use of the AISC Spesification may be less constrained and less conservative

Code Version AISC 360-05 (2005) AISC 360-10 (2010) AISC 360-16 (2016)
References References RELATED INFO
Condition ASD LRFD ASD LRFD ASD LRFD
Tension 0.6 Fy Ag ≤ 0.5 Fu Ae 0.9 Fy Ag ≤ 0.75 Fu Ae 0.6 Fy Ag ≤ 0.5 Fu Ae 0.9 Fy Ag ≤ 0.75 Fu Ae Page 26, 282 0.6 Fy Ag ≤ 0.5 Fu Ae 0.9 Fy Ag ≤ 0.75 Fu Ae Page 28, 299 For Ae, see Equation D3-1
Lb≤Lp 0.66 Fy Sx 0.99 Fy Sx 0.66 Fy Sx 0.99 Fy Sx 0.66 Fy Sx 0.99 Fy Sx See Note 1.
Strong Axis Lp<Lb≤Lr Use linear interpolation between Lp and Lr Use linear interpolation between Lp and Lr Use linear interpolation between Lp and Lr p  300ry /
LasdddddddddddFy
Bending Page 44, 302 Page 44, 323
Lb=Lr 0.42 Fy Sx 0.63 Fy Sx 0.42 Fy Sx 0.63 Fy Sx 0.42 Fy Sx 0.63 Fy Sx Lr and strengths when Lb > Lr
Weak Axis 0.9 Fy Sy 1.35 Fy Sy 0.9 Fy Sy 1.35 Fy Sy 0.9 Fy Sy 1.35 Fy Sy are given in the AISC Manual

Shear (In strong axis) 0.4 Fy Aw 0.6 Fy Aw 0.4 Fy Aw 0.6 Fy Aw Page 67, 325 0.4 Fy Aw 0.6 Fy Aw Page 70, 350
p p P P P P
Kl / r  800 / Fy 0.6 Fy Ag x 0.658 0.9 Fy Ag x 0.658 0.6 Fy Ag x 0.658 0.9 Fy Ag x 0.658 0.6 Fy Ag x 0.658 0.9 Fy Ag x 0.658
Compression Kl / r  800 / Fy 2 2 2 2
Page 31, 290 2 2
Page 33, 307 2
150,000 Ag / (Kl/r) 226,000 Ag / (Kl/r) 150,000 Ag / (Kl/r) 226,000 Ag / (Kl/r) 150,000 Ag / (Kl/r) 226,000 Ag / (Kl/r) P= Fy (Kl/r) / 286,000

AISC Basic Design Value 2 Comparison

Based upon simplyfying assumptions and arbitary limitations. Direct use of the AISC Spesification may be less constrained and less conservative

Code Version AISC 360-05 (2005) AISC 360-10 (2010) AISC 360-16 (2016)
References References RELATED INFO
Condition ASD LRFD ASD LRFD ASD LRFD
Tension 0.6 Fy Ag ≤ 0.5 Fu Ae 0.9 Fy Ag ≤ 0.75 Fu Ae 0.6 Fy Ag ≤ 0.5 Fu Ae 0.9 Fy Ag ≤ 0.75 Fu Ae Page 26, 282 0.6 Fy Ag ≤ 0.5 Fu Ae 0.9 Fy Ag ≤ 0.75 Fu Ae Page 28, 299 For Ae, see Equation D3-1
Rectangular HSS 0.66 Fy S 0.99 Fy S 0.66 Fy S 0.99 Fy S Page 56, 312 0.66 Fy S 0.99 Fy S Page 57, 335
Bending
Round HSS, Pipe 0.78 Fy S 1.17 Fy S 0.78 Fy S 1.17 Fy S Page 57, 314 0.78 Fy S 1.17 Fy S Page 59, 336
Rectangular HSS 0.36 Fy Aw 0.54 Fy Aw 0.36 Fy Aw 0.54 Fy Aw Page 71, 329 0.36 Fy Aw 0.54 Fy Aw Page 74, 354
Shear
Round HSS, Pipe 0.18 Fy Ag 0.27 Fy Ag 0.18 Fy Ag 0.27 Fy Ag Page 72, 330 0.18 Fy Ag 0.27 Fy Ag Page 75, 355
p p p p p p
Kl / r  800 / Fy 0.6 Fy Ag x 0.658 0.9 Fy Ag x 0.658 0.6 Fy Ag x 0.658 0.9 Fy Ag x 0.658 0.6 Fy Ag x 0.658 0.9 Fy Ag x 0.658
Compression Page 31, 290 Page 33, 307
Kl / r  800 / Fy 150,000 Ag / (Kl/r)
2
226,000 Ag / (Kl/r)
2
150,000 Ag / (Kl/r)
2
226,000 Ag / (Kl/r)
2
150,000 Ag / (Kl/r)
2
226,000 Ag / (Kl/r)
2 2
P= Fy (Kl/r) / 286,000

AISC Basic Design Value 3 Comparison

Based upon simplyfying assumptions and arbitary limitations. Direct use of the AISC Spesification may be less constrained and less conservative

Code Version AISC 360-05 (2005) AISC 360-10 (2010) AISC 360-16 (2016)
References References RELATED INFO
Condition ASD LRFD ASD LRFD ASD LRFD
Tension 0.38 Fu Ab 0.56 Fu Ab 0.38 Fu Ab 0.56 Fu Ab Page 125 Page 131
Shear (N bolts, per shear plane) 0.2 Fu Ab 0.3 Fu Ab 0.23 Fu Ab 0.34 Fu Ab Page 125 Page 131 Multiply by 1.25 for X bolts
Bolts

Slip Resistance (Class A, STD holes) 0.14 Fu Ab 0.21 Fu Ab 0.12 Fu Ab 0.18 Fu Ab Page 126 0.12 Fu Ab 0.18 Fu Ab Page 134 per slip plane
Bearing 0.6 Fu lc t ≤ 1.2 Fu db t 0.9 Fu lc t ≤ 1.8 Fu db t 0.6 Fu lc t ≤ 1.2 Fu db t 0.9 Fu lc t ≤ 1.8 Fu db t Page 127 0.6 Fu lc t ≤ 1.2 Fu db t 0.9 Fu lc t ≤ 1.8 Fu db t Page 135
Shear (all welds except CJP) 0.3 FEXX Aw 0.45 FEXX Aw 0.3 FEXX Aw 0.45 FEXX Aw Page 115 0.3 FEXX Aw 0.45 FEXX Aw Page 123
Tension 0.32 FEXX Aw 0.48 FEXX Aw 0.32 FEXX Aw ≤ 0.5 Fu ABM 0.48 FEXX Aw ≤ 0.75 Fu ABM Page 114 0.32 FEXX Aw ≤ 0.5 Fu ABM 0.48 FEXX Aw ≤ 0.75 Fu ABM Page 123 See Section J2 1a.
Welds

PJP Groove
Welds Compression (joint not
0.48 FEXX Aw ≤ 0.6 Fy ABM 0.72 FEXX Aw ≤ 0.9 Fy ABM 0.48 FEXX Aw ≤ 0.6 Fy ABM 0.72 FEXX Aw ≤ 0.9 Fy ABM Page 114 0.48 FEXX Aw ≤ 0.6 Fy ABM 0.72 FEXX Aw ≤ 0.9 Fy ABM
finished to bear) Page 123 See Section J2 1a.
CJP Groove Welds Strength equal to base metal Strength equal to base metal Strength equal to base metal
Tension 0.6 Fy Ag ≤ 0.5 Fu Ae 0.9 Fy Ag ≤ 0.75 Fu Ae 0.6 Fy Ag ≤ 0.5 Fu Ae 0.9 Fy Ag ≤ 0.75 Fu Ae 0.6 Fy Ag ≤ 0.5 Fu Ae 0.9 Fy Ag ≤ 0.75 Fu Ae
Connested Parts

For Ae, see equation D3-1

Shear 0.4 Fy Ag ≤ 0.3 Fu An 0.6 Fy Ag ≤ 0.45 Fu An 0.4 Fy Ag ≤ 0.3 Fu An 0.6 Fy Ag ≤ 0.45 Fu An 0.4 Fy Ag ≤ 0.3 Fu An 0.6 Fy Ag ≤ 0.45 Fu An
Block Shear 0.3 Fu Anv + 0.5 Ubs Fu Ant 0.45 Fu Anv + 0.75 Ubs Fu Ant 0.3 Fu Anv + 0.5 Ubs Fu Ant 0.45 Fu Anv + 0.75 Ubs Fu Ant 0.3 Fu Anv + 0.5 Ubs Fu Ant 0.45 Fu Anv + 0.75 Ubs Fu Ant
Kl / r ≤ 25 0.6 Fy A 0.9 Fy A 0.6 Fy A 0.9 Fy A 0.6 Fy A 0.9 Fy A
Compression
Kl / r > 25 Same as for W-shapes with Ag = A Same as for W-shapes with Ag = A Same as for W-shapes with Ag = A