Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
ABSTRACT 1. INTRODUCTION
The implementation of ergonomics improvement is a new concept in Malaysian Ergonomics is a science of adapting environment to human capacity. In
society. This study is mainly focused on improving primary school furniture Malaysia recently, a rapid improvement has been done to improve the wellness
based on user centered design concept, hazard identification, risk assessment and health of either workers or people that have direct contact with interface.
and control (HIRARC), anthropometry and cognitive ergonomics. The result In Occupational Safety and Health Act 1994, under section 4 – 5 (Part 1-2)
from HIRARC assessment shows that ergonomics risk factors found to be directly refers to the importance of ergonomics, “To promote an occupational
significantly associated in contributing to musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) environment for persons at work which is adapted to their physiological
among school children particularly when using the existing furniture. From and psychological needs”.
the risks identified, development of ergonomics furniture was done by
identifying the preference of the student using a simplified questionaire. Ergonomics improvement tends to increase the safety and health in a workplace
Anthropometric data was collected to determine the specification of the and in addition improve output such as productivity and outcome of a working/
furniture based on the anthropometry of level 1 (standard 1 to standard 3 environment setting. Therefore in Malaysia, many of the ergonomics
children) and level 2 (standard 4 to standard 6 children). Using all the important improvement tends to focus on industrial and occupational setting but lack of
information, several 2D sketches and 3D mock-up model were produced and ergonomics assessment for school environment. Although few researches had
only one final design was selected based on the need of the students. The been done in Malaysia that revealed poor ergonomics environment in Malaysian
specification of the furniture was finally intergrated with anthropometric data schools, no action was taken by the government and Ministry of Education
for final design specification prior to final fabrication of prototype. (MOE) (Tamrin et al., 2004). In addition, currently no record of school
(infrastructures such as building, school layout, class room and the school
Keywords: ergonomics furniture, user centered design, cognitive ergono- children) had been designed or promoted on application of ergonomics.
mics, design process and primary school
Therefore, the research group had proposed 3 main parameters for ergonomics
improvement in Malaysian schools viz; 1) school building and layout – minor/
low cost adjustment of school building and class room to fit 95% of
schoolchildren anthropometry and school safety such as traffic flow in and
out of school, 2) desk and chair (classroom furniture) – to fitting 95% of
Severity of the risk of MSD among the respondents was determined using the
odds ratio (OR) and risk assessment (RA) method. The OR was determined
by using binary logistic regression adjusting for body mass index (BMI), sport
activities and history of previous accident. The severity of the risk was
determined using the Hazard Identification Risk Assessment and Risk Control
(HIRARC) method with four main processes in sequence.
The school furniture development process begins with the prioritization and
identification of ergonomics problem in selected classroom. The furniture
design and development process was based on methods and specifications
suggested by Chuankai & Yinghui (2004) and Hassan & Ahmad Rizal (2008).
Based on the problem identified, the idea of new design was created by
determining the concept and specification of the new furniture. The design
process began with proposed 5 idea sketches and only 1 sketch was selected.
In the next stage, the 2D layout of selected design idea was drawn and
technically drafted by hand and using Solid Works software.
The full scale 2D drawing integrated with proposed furniture dimension was
done to help in considering aspects of form, proportion and consideration of
accurate measurements and materials in the development of design. After that,
the 3D surfacing and details were done using Solid Work software. With the
2D and 3D drawing established, a real mock-up size model was developed Figure 3: Furniture Design and Development Process
The ethics of this study had been approved by Faculty of Medicine and Health
Sciences, Universiti Putra Malaysia Ethics Committee [Ref: UPM/FPSK/
PADS/T7-MJKEtikaPer/F01 (LECT_Oct11)].
4. RESULT
From the total respondents, 48% were males, 52% were females with the mean
body weight of 29.48 ± 10.12 kg, and mean height was 128.25 ± 10.59 cm.
The average BMI was 17.2 kg/m2. Most of study respondents were from Malay
ethnicity (92%) and the average parents’ income was RM 1,612 ± 1397.
Over 93% of the school children played sports either during school or after
school hours. The most popular sport was football (30%), followed by cycling
(23%), badminton (13%), netball (12%) and other sport activities such as
swimming and martial arts (9%). In addition, most of the children reported
having indoor activities (94%) such as playing computer game and watching
television before or after school hours.
A high majority of them (64%) reported that they travelled to school by vehicle
such as car, motorcycle and bus, only 10% of them cycled to and back from
school and a small fraction of the school children walked the whole way (to
and fro from school). Table 4.2 summarizes the overall demographic
information.
The result shows that the overall prevalence of MSD (life time) is very high From the assessment, the study revealed that 4 ergonomics parameters were
and above acceptable level (66.5% for level 1 and 73% for level 2). The study found to be hazardous to pupil namely; 1) un-ergonomically designed furniture
revealed that for life time prevalence of MSD, 33% of the children reported 2) awkward posture 3) prolong sitting 4) excessive loading. There are 7
that they had knee and leg pain (KLP) once in a life time followed by shoulder locations involving pupil main activities during school hour which are 1)
pain (SP) 32%, neck pain (NP) 31%, arm pain (AP) 20%, hip and thigh pain classroom, 2) sciences laboratory, 3) living skills workshop, 4) music room,
(HTP) 17%, upper back pain (UBP) 16%, elbow pain (EP) 14% and 11% of 5) audio visual laboratory, 6) canteen and 7) sanitary facilities.
them reported lower back pain (LBP) at least once in their lifetime. The study
also shows that KLP (32%) was the highest complaint among level 1 children, Among the children working activities, classroom learning indicates the highest
but level 2 children showed that NP was the highest (35%) compared to the risk level of 15 (high risk) compared to others. Through observation, all levels
other body parts. of school children ranging from standard 1 up to standard 6 were found using
Musculoskeletal complaints of within the seven days of interviewing also the same design of school furniture regardless of their body anthropometric.
showed slightly lower prevalence of MSD and the same trend was observed. The same design of chairs and tables was found in all classrooms, science
The result showed that the highest prevalence was KLP (16%), followed by laboratories and workshops. Table 3 shows the summary of ergonomics hazard
NP and SP (13%), AP (9%), HTP (8%), EP (7%), while both UBP and LBP identified in classroom environment.
reported 6% of the total samples for at least a day or more within 7 days of
MSD complaints preceding completion of the questionnaire. The study also The high risk indicated an immediate response that requires action taken to
showed the highest prevalence of KLP among level 1 (17%) and 2 (16%) control the hazard as in the hierarchy of control. As required in HIRARC by
compared to the other body parts. Details are shown in Table 2. Department of Occupational Safety and Health (DOSH), any corrective or
intervention program must be documented and further ergonomics assessment
Table 2: Prevalence Of MSD For Malaysian Primary School Children follow up is well encouraged.
In determining the risk factors of MSD among the primary school children in
Malaysia, Binary Logistic regression analysis (BLR) was used. Using each
body part and determinating risk, controlling of sport activities, history of
previous accident and body mass index, the risk factors indicated that furniture
and school bag showed an increase in odd ratio/risk from 1.67 (leg) to 5.25
(shoulder). This would indicate that the risk of developing leg pain was 1.67
times higher for those who carried heavy school bag (>10% body weight)
compared to those who carried less and the risk of developing shoulder pain
was 5.3 times higher among those who carried heavy school bag compared to
those who carried less. The result also indicated that the risk of developing
upper back pain was 4.6 times higher among those who used un-suitable
furniture (Table 4).
The design concept was based on the ergonomics problem of the current
existing furniture. Therefore, the furniture must be designed to reduce static
posture, awkward posture (bending, bending and twisting, bending of the neck
and shoulder), able to reduce the bag load carried by the student and equally
match with the anthropometry of the schoolchildren. A total of 5 initial sketches
had been proposed. From the sketches, only a single design was chosen by the
overall team after a series of discussion. This is to ensure that the design
would maximize the safety and health theme and their comfort ability.
The next step is to convert the sketches into 2D and 3D designs and also to
incorporate the anthropometric measurement for both level 1 and level 2. In
the 2D and 3D designs, all the relevant measurements were used as part of
design and development.
With the 2D and 3D model established, a real mock-up size model was
developed using simple wood materials. The mock-up model was made several
times with adjustment and modification until the final design suit the entire
research group especially in fitting the size and also to determine a better
method of improving safety issues such as accident that can cause bodily
injuries (Figure 5). Figure 4: Selected sketches for ergonomic school furniture
The overall findings of this study in identifying the risk factors and risk
assessment of ergonomics problem in school environment showed that school
children were highly exposed to early stage of MSD due to improper design
and dimension of classroom furniture especially chair and table used by the
children. The same findings were found in study by Gouvali et al. (2006) and
Parcells et al. (1999). Un-ergonomics furniture may lead to awkward posture
Figure 6: School furniture prototype (PR Ver. 1)
during school session as reported by Troussier et al. (1999).
Development of prototyping was one of the major parts of the research, in In conclusion, this study proposes new design and concept of school furniture
which the first prototype (PR Ver. 1) was based on the final data of the mock- in primary school. The findings in this study can benefit the Ministry of
up model. The final prototype was also assessed by the team members in order Education in improving the standard and to promote awareness in terms of
to assess any major defects and flaws of the final mock-up measurements. The safety and health and ergonomics of Malaysia schools. In addition, the findings
development of one set of PR Ver. 1 was done within (the time frame of in this study will be used to formulate the most cost effective ergonomics
approximately) 2 weeks. The basic prototype used most of the information improvement program for Malaysian schools in reducing the risk and
asked in order to follow the preference of the school children. preventing MSD among children. Finally, this research is very important since
it will translate research finding into profit from commercialization and benefit
According to Hassan & Ahmad Rizal (2008), the important aspects in industrial not only UPM but also to the National wealth in general.
design include quality of the product, aesthetic value, colors, ergonomics,