Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
1001
1002 SOIL SCI. SOC. AM. J., VOL. 48, 1984
20
2
60 iF
0 10
7 7
0 ---------
O 4 Ruptured at these
2 H2O content a.
Cured at these I-1 20 contents.
oven dried a ruptured.
.20 .30
WATER IN SOIL (kg kg- I ) .10 .20 .30
Fig. 4—Moduli of rupture of Portneuf soil following various pre- WATER CONTENT WHEN RUPTURED (kg kg -I )
treatments. Fig.5—Modulus of rupture as affected by leaching with tapwater
prior to forming cylinders.
measured by resistance to rupture, was associated with
presence of the water. clay platelets from making solid-to-solid contacts, par-
The Billings soil had moduli of rupture that were ticularly since the thin platelets may deform in re-
several times higher than those of the Portneuf when sponse to high osmotic pressures, leaving cushioning
the soils had water contents <6% (Fig. 5), but at water films of water between the solid surfaces. However,
contents > 20% more force was required to break cyl- when the tensions in the water increase, more of these
inders of Portneuf than of Billings soils. clay particles begin to make contact and bond and
The Billings had about 3% Na in its exchange ca- ultimately, since there are more contacts, there is
pacity while the Portneuf had practically no Na. To greater cohesion in the clayey than in the silty soil
compare the moduli of rupture at the same low ex- when they are dry.
changeable Na levels, samples of the Portneuf and the The suggested need for both mineral-to-mineral
Billings soils were leached with 20 pore volumes of contact and subsequent migration of bonding agents
calcic tap water. Samples of Portneuf soil were leached to those points of contact is compatible with findings
with a mixture of Na and Ca chlorides which would of Utomo and Dexter (198 lb) that rates at which soils
give exchangeable Na levels of 10%. These samples harden are greatest at intermediate water contents,
were then air dried, passed through a 2-mm sieve, and characteristic of the soils, and decrease when the soils
used to form cylinders for modulus of rupture deter- are wetter or dryer.
minations as before. The results for the Portneuf soil The long-term leaching process followed by air
are shown as the top two lines in Fig. 4. The 10% drying and fragmentation resulted in new aggregates.
exchangeable Na soil had the highest moduli of rup- The internal cohesion of these new aggregates is not
ture because the aggregates dispersed in the water with as great as that of the older ones. Consequently, when
low salt content which was used to wet the cylinders. they were wetted again in the lucite rings there was
However, the moduli of rupture also increased appre- more disintegration of the aggregates and greater co-
ciably for both the Portneuf and Billings soils which alescence of the soil into one large mass which has
were leached with 20 pore volumes of calcic tap water more resistance to rupture. Greater stability of aged
(Fig. 5) in spite of the fact that this leaching had low- compared to new formed aggregates has also been
ered the exchangeable Na level of the Billings from noted by Utomo and Dexter (1981a). Their new ag-
3% to < 1%. The crossing of the moduli of rupture gregates were formed by tillage of a moist soil which
curves, noted in soils with their original ionic com- was then sieved through a screen. Effects of aging the
plement, was just as definite for the soils leached with aggregates on aggregate stability were similar. They
calcic tap water. This indicates different types of bind- also found that aging aggregates prior to compression
ing forces in the two soils. substantially decreased their packing density, indicat-
A possible explanation of the different behavior of ing increased cohesiveness of particles in the aggre-
these two soils lies in their different textures. The Port- gates.
neuf has 15% clay whereas the Billings has over 40% Blake and Gilman (1970) also noted increased ag-
clay. The clays are largely smectites whose individual gregate stability of fragments from newly compressed
platelets are so thin that they can be bent by small briquets when these were stored at constant water con-
forces. When pulled together by moderate tensions in tents. In their studies, when the water contents were
the water, the larger, bladder silt particles of the Port- high (i.e., 0 = 0.31 m 3 m-3), maximum stability ap-
neuf are probably forced into contact at a limited peared to be reached within a day, whereas at lower
number of contact points and bonds begin developing water contents (0.16 < 0 <0.24 m 3 m- 3) stabilities
at those points. The Billings, with more clay, has more were still increasing after several days. The effect of
interfacing of clay particles, but the osmotic swelling water content during storage on rate of cohesion de-
pressures may be sufficient to prevent most of these velopment is confounded in their studies with the ef-
1004 SOIL SCI. SOC. AM. J., VOL. 48, 1984
8 88 O 0 qq O
Son Water Suction
.1 e• to kPo Soil Weirs SUS tido 2 8 ItPo
r 7
91 rings
Portneuf
u--8(P, -PO
Modulus of
O Rupture
O
Modulus of„,
Rupture
0 0
W tas
0
0
0
The cohesional surface tension force may be esti- the air-water interface. Other factors in the more co-
mated by assuming that all pores emptied are spher- hesive Billings soil always caused more cohesion when
ical and have an air water interface around their cir- the soil was dry than when it was moist and thereby
cumference that exerts a surface tension. Then the masked the cohesive effect of the water.
contribution of a given pore of radius r, to cohesion As long as the pressure in the air exceeds that in the
of the sample is, at a plane through the middle of that water phase, water causes some cohesion of the soil.
pore, 2crirri. However, when the water pressure becomes equal to
The number of N; of such round pores in a given or greater than the air pressure and the soil becomes
size range ri < r < ri+1 per unit cross sectional area saturated, the water does not help soil particles to co-
of soil can be estimated from the fraction of the soil here, and freshly cultivated, weakly structured soils,
volume 0, emptied of water between suctions related such as the Portneuf, will slump or settle due to the
to r, and ri41 by the capillary equation. That is, force of gravity. The data in this study combined with
N, = 8,I 1(7 2 [4] those in the Utomo-Dexter and Blake-Gilman studies
indicate that this slumping and consequent increase
where = (ri + rui. 1 )/2 and 8, values are taken from in densities that occur in the saturated zone of irri-
water retention characteristics of the type shown in gated soils will be reduced if the aggregates formed by
Fig. 1. Following this procedure, this estimate of the cultivation are allowed to cure for a few days before
cohesional force F5 due to surface tension in the soil they are irrigated.
is
n O . n 0. CONCLUSIONS
E 2./ta= 20' . [5] Cohesion of soils as measured by aggregate stabili-
i=1 vr, I i;
ties and moduli of rupture increases with time. Cohe-
Following the procedures indicated in Eq. [3] and sional forces associated with water are in the range to
[5] the cohesional forces due to hydraulic pressure and be able to account for measured moduli of rupture in
surface tension were estimated for the Portneuf and moist soils. However, high moduli of rupture of soils
Billings soils from the water retention curves in Fig. such as the Billings, when oven dry, indicate forma-
I and are shown in Fig. 7 and 8, respectively. tion of solid phase bonds at particle-to-particle con-
These estimates of cohesional forces due to water tacts. Increases of aggregate stabilities and moduli of
indicate that their summation is large enough to ac- rupture with time of storage or "curing" under air-dry
count for the soil cohesion observed in the moduli of conditions, indicate that migration of bonding com-
rupture measured for these soils. However, the as- ponents to strengthen these bonds continues even when
sumptions inherent in these calculations make them there is as little as one molecular layer of water on the
overestimates of the cohesional forces due to water, mineral surfaces.
particularly when there are internal flaws or micro- These findings combined with those of other inves-
cracks in the samples, or water contents are low and tigators suggest that soils will disintegrate and slump
a major portion of the remaining water is held by forces less if a few days are allowed for freshly cultivated
other than capillarity. Under conditions described for soils to regain their solid phase cohesion before they
curves associated with the upright crosses in Fig. 4, are saturated by irrigation.
Portneuf soil has greater moduli of rupture when it is
moist than when it is oven dried showing that a sub- REFERENCES
stantial portion of the cohesion in this soil is due to 1. Blake, G.R., and R.D. Gilman. 1970. Thixotropic changes with
water phase tension and surface tension associated with aging of synthetic aggregates. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. Proc. 34:561-
1006 SOIL SCI. SOC. AM. J., VOL. 48, 1984