Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Page 1
b. Duration of Duty Transportation Law Case Digests
1. Carriage of Goods
1. Macam vs. CA. G.R. No. 12524. August 25, 1999
2. Carriage of Passengers.
1. LRTA vs. Navidad G.R. No. 145804. February 6, 2003.
2. Dangwa Transportation Co. vs. CA. G.R. No. 95582. Oct. 7, 1991
3. La Mallorca vs. CA. 17 SCRA 739
4. Aboitiz Shipping Corp. vs. CA. 179 SCRA 95.
e. Defenses of Common Carriers
a. Fortuitous Event
1. Requisites
2. Participation of the Carrier
3. Fire
4. Hijacking
5. Mechanical Defects
b. Other Invalid Defenses
1. PHILAMGEM INS. Vs. MCO. G.R. No. 135645. March 8, 2002.
2. Pilapil vs. CA. G.R. No. 52159. December 22, 1989.
3. Fortune Express Inc. vs. CA. G.R. No. 119756. March 18, 1999.
4. Juntilla vs. Fantanar. G.R. No. L-45637. May 31, 1985.
5. Lasam et al vs. Smith. G.R. No. 19495. February 2, 1924.
6. Gacal et al vs. PAL. 183 SCRA 189.
c. Public Enemy
d. Improper Packing
e. Order of Public Authority
1. Mauro Ganzon v. Court of Appeals, et al. G.R. No. L-48757. May 30, 1988
f. Defenses in Carriage of Passengers
1. Employees
2. Other Passengers and Third Persons
1. Maranan vs. Perez. G.R. No. L-22272. June 26, 1967.
2. De Gillaco et al vs. Manila Railroad Co. G.R. No. L-8034. Nov. 18, 1955.
3. Bachelor Express Inc. vs. CA. G.R. No. 85691. July 31, 1990.
g. Passenger’s Baggage
Page 2
Transportation Law Case Digests
CHAPTER III – EXTRAORDINARY DILIGENCE
Rationale
How Duty is Complied With
Duty to Third Persons
Effect of Stipulation
Goods
Passengers (Gratuitous Passengers )
Extraordinary Diligence in the Carriage by Sea
1. Seaworthiness
a. Warranty of Seaworthiness of Ship
b. No Duty to Inquire
c. Meaning of Seaworthiness
d. Fitness of the vessel
i. Cargo worthiness
ii. Equipment and Manning
iii. Adequate Equipment
2. Overloading
3. Proper Storage
4. Negligence of Captain and Crew
a. Passenger Safety
i. Standard Vacuum Oil Co. vs. Luzon Stevedoring. G.R. No. L-5203. April 18,
1956.
ii. Planters Products Inc. vs. CA et al. G.R. No. 101503. September 15, 1993.
iii. Mecenas vs. CA. 180 SCRA 83.
5. Deviation and Transshipment
CHAPTER XI – AVERAGES
1. Average in General
2. Simple Average
a. Definition
b. By Whom Born
c. Example of Simple Average
3. General Average Page 6
a. Definition and Requisites Transportation Law Case Digests
i. Common danger
ii. Deliberate sacrifice
iii. Sacrifice must be successful
iv. Compliance with legal steps
b. Examples of General Average
c. By Whom Borne
i. Insurers
ii. Lenders on bottomry and respondentia
d. Who is entitled to indemnity
i. Magsaysay Inc. vs. Agan. G.R. No. L-6393. January 31, 1955.
ii. American Home Assurance vs. CA. G.R. No. 94149. May 5, 1992.
4. Proof and Liquidation of Average
i. Standard Oil vs. Castelo. G.R. No. 13695. October 18, 1921.
5. York-Antwerp Rules
Page 9
Transportation Law Case Digests