Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
A B S T R A C T
Robert H. DuRant, PhD, Ellen S. Rome, MD, MPH, Michael Rich, MD,
Elizabeth Allred, MPH, S. Jean Emans, MD, and Elizabeth R. Woods, MD, MPH
Objectives. Music videos from
five genres of music were analyzed
for portrayals of tobacco and alcohol
Introduction cent health risk and problem behaviors by
portraying adolescent role models engag-
use and for portrayals of such behav- Despite widespread pubUc health ing in these activities.^' Cognitive priming
iors in conjunction with sexuality. campaigns, tobacco and alcohol continue theory proposes that problem behaviors
Methods. Music videos (n = to be used by a substantial proportion of seen on television trigger additional infor-
518) were recorded during randotnly adolescents.'-'' Tobacco and alcohol use mation in memory related to the behavior
selected days and times irom four appear to be occurring at younger ages, being encoded.^^ Thus, viewing tobacco
television networks. Four female and and they are correlated with one another, and alcohol use by role models on
four male observers aged 17 to 24 as well as with other problem behav- television primes semantically related
years were trained to use a standard- iors.^-'^ This clustering of problem behav- thoughts and behavioral inclinations about
ized content analysis instrument. All iors is a particular concern with regard to tobacco and alcohol use. Social learning
videos were observed by rotating adolescents who initiate tobacco and theory explains the acquisition of unen-
two-person, male-female teams who alcohol use during early adolescence.^''" countered behavior by proposing that
were required to reach agreement on These data suggest that public health seeing health risk and problem behaviors
each behavior that was scored. Music approaches may need to target other on television both reduces inhibitions and
genre and network differences in sources of influence on these behaviors. desensitizes viewers, resulting in more
behaviors were analyzed with chi-
Adolescents have high normative positive attitudes toward the behaviors
squared tests.
expectations about many health risk and and enabling viewers to engage in behav-
Results. A higher petxientage problem behaviors, such as tobacco and iors in which they might not otherwise
(25.7%) of MTV videos than other alcohol use and sexual behaviors.''*-^' participate.^'' These theories have been
network videos portrayed tobacco Adolescents tend to overestimate both the supported by both experimental and quasi-
use. The percentage of videos show- number of their peers who engage in these experimental studies of the influence of
ing alcohol use was similar on all behaviors and their peers' norms concern- music videos on attitudes and behaviors
four networks. In videos that por- ing the acceptability of engaging in these of high school and college students.^^^"
trayed tobacco and alcohol use, the behaviors. There is evidence that adoles-
lead performer was most often the Although some content analyses of
cents with high normative expectations
one smoking or drinking and the use the portrayal of problem behaviors on
concerning health risk and problem behav-
of alcohol was associated with a high music videos have been reported, these
iors, indicating that they view these
degree of sexuality on all the videos. have been primarily of rock videos aired
behaviors as acceptable among their peers
Conclusions. These data indi- on Music Television (MTV). There is
or among a significant proportion of the
cate that even modest levels of population, are more likely to engage in
viewing may result in substantial those behaviors than adolescents with low At the time of the study, Robert H. DuRant,
exposure to glamorized depictions of normative expectations.'^i-^'^z Role mod- Michael Rich, S. Jean Emans, and Elizabeth R.
alcohol and tobacco use and alcohol els such as musicians, actors, and athletes Woods were with the Division of Adolescent/
Young Adult Medicine, and Elizabeth Allred was
use coupled with sexuality. {Am J have a substantial influence on adoles- with the Division of Neuroepidemiology, Chil-
Public Health. 1997;87:1131-1135) cents' normative expectations about health dren's Hospital, Boston, Mass. Dr DuRant is now
risk and problem behaviors when they are with the Department of Pediatrics, Brenner
observed engaging in these behaviors in Children's Hospital, Bowman Gray School of
Medicine, Wake Forest University, Winston-
the media, such as music videos.-^'--^^-^^ Salem, NC. Ellen S. Rome is with the Cleveland
When viewed in the context of sexual or Clinic Foundation, Cleveland, Ohio.
erotic scenes, these behaviors may be Requests for reprints should be sent to
viewed by adolescents as desirable. Robert H. DuRant, PhD, Department of Pediat-
rics, Brenner Children's Hospital, Bowman Gray
Adolescents are heavy users of tele- School of Medicine, Wake Forest University,
vision.2'''25 The entertainment industry has Medical Center Blvd, Winston-Salem, NC 27157.
This paper was accepted September 26
often been accused of promoting adoles- 1996.
July 1997, Vol. 87, No. 7 American Journal of Public Health 1133
DuRant et al.
policy changes, such as the banning of 9, DuRant RH, Ashworth CS, Rickert VI, traditions in research on adolescents' ciga-
portrayals of tobacco and alcohol use in Newman C, Stability of the relationships rette smoking, Psychoi Rep. 1992;71:568-
music videos, as more explicit tobacco between anabolic steroid use and multiple 570,
advertising was banned from broadcast substance use among adolescents, J Ado- 22, Smoking and Health: A Report of the
lescHealth. 1994;15:111-116, Surgeon General. Washington, DC: US
television years ago. However, such a 10, Baily SL, Adolescents' multisubstance use Dept of Health, Education, and Welfare;
change would be difficult to implement patterns: the role of heavy alcohol and 1979, DHEW publication PHS 79-50066,
owing to the well-financed corporate cigarette use. Am J Public Health. 1992;82- 23, Goldstein A, Fischer P, Richards J, Creten
lobbies of these industries and concern for 1220-1224, D, Relationship between high school stu-
protection of the videomakers' First 11, Botvin GJ, Botvin EM, Adolescent to- dent smoking and recognition of cigarette
bacco, alcohol, and drug use: prevention advertisements, J Pediatr. 1987; 110:488-
Amendment rights, D strategies, empirical findings and assess- 491,
ment issues, J Dev Behav Pediatr. 1992-13 • 24, Klein JD, Brown JD, Childers KW, Oliveri
290-301, J, Porter C, Dykers C, Adolescents' risky
Acknowledgments 12, Johnston LD, O'Malley PM, Bachman JG,
National trends in drug use and related
behavior and mass media use. Pediatrics
1993;92:24-30,
This study was funded in part by the Massachu-
setts Department of Public Health, Tobacco factors among American high school stu- 25, Strasburger VC, Children, adolescents and
Control Program, and by the Health Resources dents and young adults, 1975-1986, television. Pediatrics. 1989;83:446,
and Services Administration, Bureau of Mater- Bethesda, Md: National Institute on Drug 26, Hansen CH, Hansen RD, Rock music
nal and Child Health (project MQ-MA 259195), Abuse; 1987, videos and antisocial behavior, Basic Appl
This paper was presented at the annual 13, Reducing the Health Consequences of Soc Psychoi. 1990; 11:357-369,
meeting of the Society for Adolescent Medi- Smoking: 25 Years of Progress. A Report of 27, Greeson LE, Williams RA, Social implica-
cine, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada the Surgeon General. Washington, DC: US tions of music videos for youth, an analysis
March 25, 1995, Dept of Health and Human Services; 1989, of the content and effects of MTV, Youth
DHHS publication CDC 89-8411, Soc. 1986;18:177-189,
14, Billy JOG, Rogers JL, Udry JR, Adoles- 28, Peterson DL, Pfost KS, Influence of rock
References cent sexual behavior and friendship, Soc videos on attitudes of violence against
Forces. 1984;62:653-678, women, Psychoi Rep. 1989;64:319-322,
1, Strategies to Control Tobacco Use in the
United States: A Blueprint for Public 15, Botvin GJ, Botvin EM, Baker E, Dusen- 29, Toney GT, Weaver JB, Effects of gender
Health Action in the 1990s. Bethesda, Md: bury L, Goldberg CJ, The false consensus and gender role perceptions on affective
National Cancer Institute; 1992, NIH effect: predicting adolescents' tobacco use reactions to rock music videos. Sex Roles
publication 92-3316, from normative expectations, Psychoi Rep. 1994;30:567-583,
1992;70:17I-178, 30, Kalaf L, Dilemmas of femininity: gender
2, Healthy People 2000: National Health
16, Chassin L, Presson CC, Sherman SJ, Corty and the social construction of sexual
Promotion and Disease Prevention Objec-
imagery, Socio/(2, 1993;34:639-651,
tives. Washington, DC: US Dept of Health E, Olshavsky R, Predicting the onset of
and Human Services; 1991, DHHS publica- 31, Sherman BL, Dominick JR, Violence and
cigarette smoking in adolescents: a longitu-
tion PHS 91-50212, sex in music videos: TV and rock 'n' roll, J
dinal study, Appl Soc Psychoi. 1984; 14-
Commun. 1986;36:79-93,
3, Johnston L, O'Malley P, Bachman J, Drug 224-243,
Use among High School Seniors, College 32, Baxter RL, DeRiemer C, Landini A, Leslie
17, Collins L, Sussman S, Mestel-Rauch J, et
Students, and Young Adults, 1975-1990. L, Singletary MW, A content analysis of
al, Psychosocial predictors of young adoles-
Bethesda, Md: National Institute on Drug music videos, J Broadcast Electronic
cent cigarette smoking: a sixteen-month, Media. 1985;29:333-340,
Abuse; 1989, three-wave longitudinal study, Appl Soc
33, Madden PA, Brube JW, The frequency and
5, Middleman AB, Faulkner AH, Woods ER, Psychoi. 1987;17:554-573,
nature of alcohol and tobacco advertising
Emans SJ, DuRant RH, High risk behav- 18, Leventhal H, Glynn K, Fleming R, Is the in televised sports, 1990 through 1992, Am
iors among high school students in Massa- smoking decision an 'informed choice'? J Public Health. 1994;84:297-299,
chusetts who use anabolic steroids. Pediat- JAMA. 1987;257:3373-3376,
rics. 1995;96:268-272, 34, Grube JW, Wallack L, Television beer
19, Sherman SJ, Presson CC, Chassin L, Corty advertising and drinking knowledge, be-
6, DuRant RH, Escobedo LH, Heath GW, E, Olshavsky R, The false consensus effect liefs, and intentions among school chil-
The relationship between anabolic steroid in estimates of smoking prevalence: under- dren. Am J Public Health. 1994;84:254-
use, strength training, and multiple drug lying mechanisms, Pers Soc Psychoi Bull 259,
use among adolescents in the United 1983;9:197-207,
States, Pediatrics. 1995;96:23-26, 35, Minzel E, Kingery PM, Pruitt BE. Heuber-
20, Sussman S, Dent CW, Mestel-Rauch J, ger G, Hurley RS, Sources of drug
7, DuRant RH, Middleman AB, Spack N, Johnson CA, Hansen WB, Flay BR, information among adolescent students, J
Anabolic-androgenic steroid use by adoles- Adolescent nonsmokers, triers, and regular Drug Educ. 1991 ;21:95-106,
cents. Focus Opinions Pediatrics. 1996 2- smokers' estimates of cigarette smoking
245-252, 36, Strasburger VC, Hendren RL, Rock music
prevalence: when do overestimations occur and music videos, Pediatr Ann. 1995 24-
8, DuRant RH, Rickert VI, Ashworth CS, and by whom? Appl Soc Psychoi. 1988; 18- 97-103,
Newman C, Slavens G, Multiple substance 537-551,
use associated with anabolic steroid use 37, Calfirs MS, Carroll JL, Shmidt S, Viewing
21, Bauman KB, Botvin GJ, Botvin EM, Baker music-video tapes before taking a test of
among adolescents, N Engl J Med 1993- E. Normative expectations and the behav-
329:922-926, premarital sexual attitudes, Psychoi Rep
ior of significant others: an integration of 1993;72:475-481,