Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
com/
Hospitality Research
Sharia-Compliant Hotels
Joan C. Henderson
Tourism and Hospitality Research 2010 10: 246
DOI: 10.1057/thr.2010.3
Published by:
http://www.sagepublications.com
Additional services and information for Tourism and Hospitality Research can be found at:
Subscriptions: http://thr.sagepub.com/subscriptions
Reprints: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.nav
Permissions: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav
Citations: http://thr.sagepub.com/content/10/3/246.refs.html
What is This?
Sharia-compliant hotels
Received (in revised form): 14th May 2010
Joan C. Henderson
is an associate professor at Singapore’s Nanyang Business School, Nanyang Technological University, where she
has worked since 1997, specialising in tourism and hospitality studies. Before this, she lectured in travel and
tourism in the United Kingdom after periods of employment in the public and private tourism sectors there. Current
research interests include tourism crisis management and tourism development in the Middle East and Asia Pacific
regions.
© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1467-3584 Tourism and Hospitality Research Vol. 10, 3, 246–254
www.palgrave-journals.com/thr/
Downloaded from thr.sagepub.com at St Petersburg State University on November 14, 2013
Sharia-compliant hotels
recommended, permitted, disliked and forbidden Some advocates favour a type of tourism in
(BBC, 2002). It additionally informs financial conformity with the strictest rendering of
and business affairs (Saeed et al, 2001) and Islamic principles, confined to activities
Sharia law on which the judicial systems of sanctioned by religious leaders and
certain Islamic countries are founded. suppliers, which are owned and operated
Nevertheless, the ways in which the religion by Muslims and funded by Islamic financial
affects political, sociocultural and economic organisations.
structures and processes are not uniform and However, the concept can be defined more
there is scope for interpretation of meanings broadly to cover all travel by Muslims for
and applications. Theocracies, in which the whom religion is an important consideration,
state and religion are inextricably linked and albeit not necessarily a prime motivation
government is conducted according to reli- (Henderson, 2009). Several of these travellers
gious dictates, are exemplified by Saudi Arabia will be prepared to tolerate some deviation
and Iran. In contrast, the domains remain from Islamic teachings and lower their reli-
formally separate in the South East Asian gious-related expectations of service providers,
nations of Indonesia and Malaysia, which have such an option likely to be a practical necessity
majority Muslim populations. Islam is still a on occasion. It must also be recalled that Islam
pervasive force and growing Islamicisation of does make allowances for those away from
traditionally moderate societies outside of home concerning prayers, for example, and
Arabia has been observed, a move that is during the fasting month of Ramadan (Timothy
welcomed by some residents and politicians and Iverson, 2006). Whichever definition is
and resisted by others. Social restrictions employed, accommodation is central to the
imposed by the religion and degrees of tourist experience and Sharia-compliant hotels
conservatism vary according to the regime can be regarded as one dimension of Islamic
and more secular administrations, especially tourism.
if dealing with a multicultural citizenry, are
usually less exacting. Generalisations can, THE SHARIA-COMPLIANT
however, be misleading and individual HOTEL
Muslims may feel differing intensities of There are no formal criteria for Sharia-compli-
devoutness and attitudes towards its physical ance in the hotel sector, but scrutiny of state-
manifestations. ments made by industry practitioners and
The distinctive needs of Muslims in religious analysts reveals broad agreement about a set of
and other spheres impinge on tourism (Mansfeld attributes that are summarised in Figure 1.
et al, 2000; Syed, 2001; Henderson, 2003; Emphasis is often placed on the prohibition of
Weidenfeld, 2006). The phrase ‘Islamic alcohol, but Sharia-compliant implies a fuller
Tourism’ usually describes Muslim tourists commitment and is distinct from the notion
travelling to destinations where Islam is the of a dry hotel. Certain versions of Sharia-
official or dominant faith, often for reasons compliance insist on more stringent rules about
connected to religion (Organisation of the the segregation of sexes with separate cafes and
Islamic Conference (OIC), 2008). According restaurants, staff to serve only guests of their
to Al-Hamarneh (2008, p. 2), goals are ‘first, gender and unmarried couples barred from
the revival of Islamic cultures and the spread occupying the same bedroom. Art depicting
of Islamic values; second, economic benefits the human form must not be displayed. It may
for Islamic societies; and third, the strength- also be that regular seminars and preaching
ening of Islamic self-confidence, identity and sessions should be hosted and donations made
beliefs in the face of negative stereotyping in to charities, which help the Muslim commu-
comparison to other cultures and lifestyles’. nity. Ownership of properties by Muslims has
© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1467-3584 Tourism and Hospitality Research Vol. 10, 3, 246–254 247
Bidets in bathrooms
Sharia-Compliance
Prayer rooms
Islamic funding
also been mentioned as an additional require- Gender segregation and the allocation of
ment, in some cases. floors to men, women and families if
The lack of consensus about some facets of required complicate capacity planning and
hotel compliance indicates that, as with Sharia yield management and may have repercussions
law as a whole, there are ambiguities. A number for architectural and interior design. Rooms
of defining characteristics such as halal food and must be suitably furnished and fitted and
no alcohol are straightforward, but questions of spaces allocated for prayer. Staffing to ensure
finance and staff demographics are less easily both sexes are appropriately represented
answered. There is thus some confusion about and the productivity of the labour force is
the precise pre-requisites of a Sharia-compliant maximised is another problem. These consid-
hotel ( Javed, 2007; Hotelier Middle East, 2008a) erations could lead to extra costs and the
with a range of interpretations, indicative of a absence of revenue from often lucrative alcohol
spectrum of adherence and some have proposed trade can be deemed another potential draw-
a regulatory body to resolve uncertainties and back (Rosenberg and Choufany, 2009).
establish minimum standards. However, most of Marketers also confront dilemmas about how
the stipulations cited in Figure 1 are commonly to position the hotel and promote it to non-
accepted and have implications for operations as Muslim guests, which are described in a later
well as development and financing. section.
248 © 2010 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1467-3584 Tourism and Hospitality Research Vol. 10, 3, 246–254
Sources: Corporate websites; Hotelier Middle East (2008a–d); Rosenberg and Choufany (2009).
© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1467-3584 Tourism and Hospitality Research Vol. 10, 3, 246–254 249
international tourist destination. It is more not unduly prolonged, many currently periph-
cosmopolitan and open than its regional eral regions are forecast to record above average
neighbours and even other Emirates and has a growth rates as generators of and destinations
population in which expatriates outnumber for international tourism. Domestic activity is
locals (Henderson, 2007). Many of its larger set to expand too as economies advance and
hotels cater to diverse nationalities from around travel within the Middle East is predicted to
the world and sell drinks to both Muslim be especially buoyant in the longer term
and non-Muslim customers. They may have (UNWTO, 2009). Saudi Arabia is already a
dedicated female floors, but rigorous gender leading centre that can be attributed to its
segregation and dress codes are less observable. role in hosting over 8 million pilgrims each
Such a situation generates demand for Sharia- year (EIU, 2008), the haj to Mecca being
compliant accommodation among Muslim compulsory for all Muslims once in their lives,
visitors and especially Arabs who prefer to if financially and physically able to do so.
avoid any contact with alcohol, Westernised Elsewhere, Middle Eastern visitors are
entertainments and what are perceived to be welcomed because of their high spending
inappropriately dressed fellow guests within power and comparatively long length of stay,
their hotel. positive economic impacts augmented by a
Opportunities for Sharia-compliant hotel tendency to travel in large family parties
development in European cities have been (Heyer, 2008). Not all OIC members are as
hailed by Almalla, which includes the conti- wealthy as the oil-rich Gulf States, however,
nent in its plans, and Shaza has made reference and tourism investment and participation can
to possibilities in London and Geneva. Compa- be seriously impeded by lack of resources as
nies headquartered in North America and well as the presence of social and political insta-
Europe appear less enthusiastic, irrespective bility (Henderson, 2009). Inbound, outbound
of geographical location, with the exception and domestic tourism volumes and values
of Saudi Arabia. It has been reported that thus vary by country, but overall demand for
the concept is particularly problematic for hospitality services among Muslim markets has
their four and five star Middle East properties been said to be strong with good prospects
in Central Business Districts and at airports (Euromonitor, 2008). Sharia-compliance is
(Business Emirates, 2009). Nevertheless and judged by representatives of those at work in
despite the fact that not all projects are the industry to have great appeal for many
confirmed and the global recession that Muslims and to be viewed as essential by a
commenced in 2008 and its aftermath could significant proportion.
delay progress, there is evidence of escalating Initiatives have been facilitated by the avail-
support for the Sharia-compliance model. ability of funding categorised as Islamic, much
Various factors explain this interest, not least of it generated in the Middle East (Rosenberg
an appreciation of rising demand, and these are and Choufany, 2009). Issues of Islamic finance,
explored below. encompassing Islamic banking (Yunis, 2009),
have inspired some debate about whether the
TRENDS FAVOURING THE religion and modern finance are compatible,
ADOPTION OF SHARIA- but there is a conviction in Muslim societies
COMPLIANCE that business sectors should also conform to
Before the onset of recession, tourism for the Sharia. Main features include a proscription on
purposes of business and leisure had been the charging of interest and on most types of
growing steadily in many of the 57 states that speculative investment as well as investing in
make up the OIC in which Muslims are areas labelled forbidden, illustrated by alcohol
concentrated. Assuming economic recovery is and gambling. The sharing of risk and
250 © 2010 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1467-3584 Tourism and Hospitality Research Vol. 10, 3, 246–254
benefiting of the Islamic community at large and every guest not required to comply)’.
are other guiding principles (BBC, 2009; However, there will be ‘no perception of force
Islamic Finance.com, 2009). According to a or restriction, but rather a positive and inviting
representative from Lang LaSalle Hotels, ‘Sharia- communication of Islamic values, lifestyles
driven investors’ are seeking new opportunities and key aspects to Muslim and conscious life-
and the ‘range of Sharia-compliant investment style travellers alike’ (Almulla Hospitality,
products’ is widening to embrace suitable 2009).
hospitality assets (The National, 2009). A similar approach seems to have been
adopted by Shaza whose management talks of
DEALING WITH NON-MUSLIMS being ‘sensitive to Islamic considerations’ in its
The challenges for hotel developers and hotels that will be ‘integrated into the culture
managers posed by the implementation of of the region’ with a ‘service delivery based
Sharia-compliance are compounded if the entirely on Arab culture’ (Hotelier Middle
targeted clientele comprise both Muslims and East, 2008b). An executive said he prefers to
non-Muslims, endeavours having to be made ‘speak of the oriental spirit and the oriental
to satisfy the two groups and avoid any spirit happens to have Sharia compliance and
conflicts. It is also a test for marketers because therefore no alcohol. But we don’t want to
Sharia may well have unfavourable associations make it sound like an absolute rule; it is just
for outsiders, with connotations of severe part of the culture. We don’t want it to sound
punishments and regimes that are repressive negative’. He also acknowledged the commer-
and violate the rights of women (BBC, 2002). cial necessity of hosting guests from parts of
In reply to the dilemma, analysts and hoteliers the world with cultural norms and patterns of
contend that Sharia-compliance does not behaviour different to those of Islam (Hotelier
exclude non-Muslims and may indeed be Middle East, 2008d).
attractive to them. Alcohol bans, in combina- There will be no compromise on Sharia-
tion with no-smoking policies, can be turned compliance by the Landmark Hotel Group,
into a selling point conducive to good health although the company insists that their hotels
and exposure to Islam in a hotel setting will appeal to non-Muslims and especially
presented as a unique experience of a sort families who will ‘thoroughly enjoy the quieter
not found in a Westernised milieu (Business and cleaner ambience’ (Hotelier Middle
Emirates, 2009; Rosenberg and Choufany, East, 2008c). The Serai Group also aims to
2009). target both regional and Western guests in its
Such a stance is conveyed in announcements properties that will be ‘designed to embrace
by Almulla Hospitality, a company that does local and Islamic influences in order to deliver
not intend to limit its market to Muslims an authentic traditional and cultural experi-
(Almulla Hospitality, 2007). The corporate ence’. The stated objective is to develop and
website refers to ‘conscious lifestyle travellers’ manage an ‘international chain of Middle
who appreciate the ‘health and clean living Eastern themed Sharia-compliant hotels’ in
aspects’ of Sharia-compliant hotels. These tour- response to mounting demand for ‘culturally
ists are also a ‘very culturally open and sensitive Middle East hotels’ (AME.info.com,
discerning group of travellers’ who will be 2006).
drawn to the special qualities of such hotels. Jawhara Hotels and Apartments has a mission
The company maintains that ‘compliance with to provide ‘authentic Emirate Sharia-compliant
the Sharia follows a number of clear principles’, hospitality’ in its hotels. The core theme of
but enforcement will ‘range from being ‘unique Emirates’ or ‘Islamic hospitality’ incor-
extremely strict (rules being enforced over each porates many of the points in Figure 1 ( Jawhara
guest) to lenient (general policy of hotel, each Hotels, 2009), but is extended to all faiths
© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1467-3584 Tourism and Hospitality Research Vol. 10, 3, 246–254 251
whereas ‘respect for the culture and beliefs of are doubtful. At the same time, a case can be
its guests’ is the espoused Rotana philosophy made for a limited number of such properties
(Islam Online, 2009). Adherence to ‘Islamic in busy international tourist hubs that record
principles’ is also acknowledged by Tamani substantial volumes of Muslim visitors. Many
Hotels and Resorts, yet the ‘Tamani Vision’ of these may be seeking a familiar setting, free
encompasses the creation of a ‘unique product from anxieties about religious obligations, and
based on Arabic heritage and local values to this predilection accounts for speculation about
cater to the world at large without restriction openings in selected European centres that are
on race, creed or religion’ (Tamani Hotels and popular with Arab tourists.
Resorts, 2009). In other properties and places, hotels might
Such pronouncement yields insights into be advised to demonstrate awareness of the
possible responses to the difficulties for Sharia- religious-related needs of all guests. Muslims
compliant hotels in reconciling amenities and should have access to certain items from the
modes of operation designed to satisfy Muslim Sharia-compliance list such as a Quran, prayer
guests with the expectations of non-Muslims. mats and arrows indicating the direction of
A common approach is to depict hotel envi- Mecca in every room as well as information
ronments shaped by the Islamic belief system about local mosques. Halal menus can be
as expressions of culture and authenticity. offered in restaurants and special arrangements
Certain core attributes are cast in a favourable made for Ramadan. Although a restricted
light and any prohibitions are downplayed, package will not please the most orthodox of
carefully chosen terminology being used to this followers of Islam, it would suggest knowledge
effect. Whether these messages can be effec- of and respect for religious sensitivities and
tively communicated is debatable and the sensibilities, which will be appreciated by
successful performance of many of the new some. Catering to Muslims within the
ventures remains to be seen. constraints imposed by destination and commer-
cial realities also makes business sense and
CONCLUSION allows companies to tap into new markets of
Hotels with aspirations to be Sharia-compliant more modern and less conservative Islamic
thus possess unique characteristics that have tourists.
consequences for their development, manage- However, further research is necessary into
ment and marketing. When discussing viability, how Islam impacts on attitudes and behaviour
it is necessary to distinguish between properties in order to improve understanding of Muslim
in Muslim countries and elsewhere. Success is tourists and assist in decision making. Opinions
clearly more probable in societies and econo- among non-Muslims about staying in hotels
mies in which there is a close affinity with the of assorted degrees of Sharia-compliance and
concept and high demand from Muslims, epit- reactions to such experiences are another
omised by Middle East states. Nevertheless, the avenue for enquiry. In addition, execution of
hospitality business is inclusive and levels of the original plans and strategies of companies
international tourism mean that non-Muslims new to the market merit monitoring to assess
may constitute a valuable market worthy of if ambitious goals are realised and the desired
cultivation, even in predominantly Muslim mix of Muslim and non-Muslim customers is
cultures. In such situations, hotel companies attained. Interesting sociocultural questions of
have to consider how best to accommodate the the desirability of isolating Muslims and non-
needs of both Muslims and non-Muslims in Muslims and the extent to which travellers
mutually satisfactory ways. Where Islam is a should be willing to adapt to local circum-
minority religion or little known, the advan- stances also arise, which have wider sociocul-
tages of stricter versions of Sharia-compliance tural and political reverberations. Discussion of
252 © 2010 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1467-3584 Tourism and Hospitality Research Vol. 10, 3, 246–254
Sharia-compliance cannot be divorced from Henderson, J.C. (2007) Tourism in Dubai: Over-
developments in the wider world, and the coming barriers to destination development.
situation illustrates the manner in which International Journal of Tourism Research 8:
tourism and hospitality are exposed to external 87–99.
forces and the problems and opportunities this Henderson, J.C. (2009) Islamic tourism reviewed.
Tourism Recreation Research 32(2): 207–212.
creates for practitioners.
Heyer, H. (2008) Sharia-compliant hotels: The next
big thing in Arabia. ETN, 7 March, http://
www.eturbonews.com, accessed 12 October
REFERENCES 2009.
Al-Hamarneh, A. (2008) Islamic tourism: A long Hotelier Middle East. (2008a) Shariah by any other
term strategy of tourist industries in the Arab name. 5 July, http://www.hoteliermiddleeast
world after 9/11. Centre for Research on the .com, accessed 13 October 2009.
Arab World, http://www.ceraw.uni-mainz Hotelier Middle East. (2008b) Shaza sets record
.de, accessed 31 October 2008. straight. 5 July, http://www.hoteliermiddleeast
Almulla Hospitality. (2007) Almulla launches .com, accessed 13 October 2009.
world’s first Sharia compliant hotel brand
Hotelier Middle East. (2008c) Landmark hotel
portfolio. Press Release, 24 October.
group launches Shariah brand across UAE and
Almulla Hospitality. (2009) Corporate culture, http://
KSA. 5 August, http://www.hoteliermiddleeast
www.almullahotels.com/site/corporateculture
.com, accessed 13 October 2009.
.php, accessed 13 October 2009.
Hotelier Middle East. (2008d) Shaza’s pre-launch
AMEinfo.com. (2006) Abraaj Capital and Ithmaar
preview. 22 December, http://www.hotelier
Bank create JV fund for landmark hospitality
middleeast.com, accessed 13 October 2009.
project. AME.info, 5 July, http://www
Islamic Finance.com. (2009) Research, http://www
.ameinfo.com, accessed 14 October 2009.
.islamic-finance.com, accessed 15 October
Armanios, F. (2004) Islam: Sunnis and Shiites. CRS
2009.
Report for Congress, Congressional Research
Service. The Library of Congress, RS21745, Islam Online. (2009) Rotana opens the Al Marwa
23 February. Rayhaan by Rotana, Makkah. 16 September,
BBC. (2002) Sharia: Introduction. BBC Religion http://www.islamonline.com, accessed 13
and Ethics, 2 October, http://www.bbc.co October 2009.
.uk/religion/religions/islam/beliefs/sharia , Javed, N. (2007) Islamic hotel branding and Islamic
accessed 22 October 2009. hospitality, http://www.salesvantage.com,
BBC. (2009) Is Islamic finance the answer? 11 May, accessed 13 October 2009.
http://newsvote.bbc.co.uk, accessed 15 October Jawhara Hotels. (2009) About us, http://www
2009. .jawhara.ea, accessed 13 October 2009.
Business Emirates. (2009) Demand for Sharia hotels Mansfeld, Y., Ron, A. and Gev, D. (2000) Muslim
rising. Business Emirates 8 March, http://www Tourism to Israel: Characterisation, Trends and
.business24-7.ae, accessed 14 October 2009. Potential. Haifa, Israel: University of Haifa
EIU. (2008) Country Report Saudi Arabia. London: Center for Tourism, Pilgrimage and Recrea-
Economist Intelligence Unit. tion Research (in Hebrew).
Euromonitor. (2008) Halal tourism. Euromonitor OIC. (2008) Framework for development and
archive, http://www.euromonitor.com/Halal_ cooperation in the domain of tourism between
Tourism, accessed 31 October 2008. OIC member states 2008–2018, http://www
Euromonitor. (2009) Travel accommodation: .oic-oic.org/oicnew/page, accessed 27 October
United Arab Emirates. 3 September, http:// 2008.
www.portal.euromonitor.com, accessed 13 Pew Forum. (2009) Mapping the global Muslim
October 2009. population: A report on the size and distribu-
Henderson, J.C. (2003) Managing tourism and tion of the world’s Muslim population, http://
Islam in Peninsular Malaysia. Tourism Manage- pewforum.org/docs/?DocID=45, accessed 13
ment 24: 447–456. October 2009.
© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1467-3584 Tourism and Hospitality Research Vol. 10, 3, 246–254 253
Rosenberg, P. and Choufany, H.M. (2009) Spir- The National. (2009) Sharia principles cushion
itual lodging: The Shariah-compliant hotel hotel from downturn. 24 September, http://
concept. 4 Hoteliers, 2 May, http://www www.thenational.ae, accessed 12 October
.4hoteliers.com, accessed 13 October 2009. 2009.
Rotana Hotels. (2009) Al Marwa Rayhaan by Timothy, D.J. and Iverson, T. (2006) Tourism and
Rotana Makkah, http://www.rotana.com, Islam: Consideration of culture and duty. In:
accessed 17 October 2009. D.J. Timothy and D.H. Olsen (eds.) Tourism,
Saeed, M., Ahmed, Z.U. and Mukhtar, S.M. (2001) Religion and Spiritual Journeys. Oxford: Routledge
International marketing ethics from an Islamic Taylor Francis Group, pp. 186–205.
perspective: A value-maximisation approach. UNWTO. (2009) Tourism 2020 vision, http://
Journal of Business Ethics 3(2): 127–143. www.unwto.org, accessed 16 October 2009.
Syed, O.A. (2001) Catering to the needs of Muslim Weidenfeld, A. (2006) Religious needs in the
travellers, tourism: Challenges and opportuni- hospitality industry. Tourism and Hospitality
ties. Paper presented at the Second Confer- Research 6(2): 143–160.
ence of Ministers from Muslim Countries, Yunis, H. (ed.) (2009) Islamic Finance. Oxford:
Tourism: Challenges and Opportunities; Oxford University Press.
10–13 October, Kuala Lumpur. Zamani-Farahani, H. and Henderson, J.C. (2009)
Tamani Hotels and Resorts. (2009) About us, Islamic tourism and managing tourism devel-
http://www.tamanihotels.ae/aboutus.aspx, opment in Islamic societies. International Journal
accessed 13 October 2009. of Tourism Research 11: 79–89.
254 © 2010 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1467-3584 Tourism and Hospitality Research Vol. 10, 3, 246–254