Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Generations
Education in Maternal and Child Public Health
Winter 2009-2010
Early Childhood
Mental Health
Winter 2009-2010
IN This Issue
A Public Health Approach to Early Family Home Visiting: A Public Health Center for Excellence in Children’s Mental
Childhood Mental Health: Balancing Mental Program to Promote Healthy Social- Health: Linking University and Community
Health Promotion and Treatment for Mental Emotional Development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 Experts and Resources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32
Health Problems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Sharon Hesseltine, BSW Cari Michaels, MPH
Joän M. Patterson, PhD, LP Jill E. Simon, MSW, LICSW, IMH-E® (IV)
Culturally Sensitive, Relationship-
Early Experience and the Science of Brain Follow Along Program: An Early Childhood based Practice Promoting Infant Mental
Development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Intervention System at the Minnesota Health: Competency-Based Training and
Megan R. Gunnar, PhD, and the National Department of Health . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 Endorsement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33
Scientific Council on the Developing Child Andrea Mayfield Candace Kragthorpe, MSW, IMH-E® (IV)
Social-Emotional Developmental Part C IDEA, Early Intervention Services: Bringing Order to the Complexity of Early
Screening of Young Children . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Serving Children Under 3 Years with Mental Experience: The Role of Training in Infant
Troy Hanson, MD, and Joän Patterson, Health Concerns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21 Mental Health . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34
PhD, LP Karen Adamson, RN, MPH Elizabeth A. Carlson, PhD, LP
Diagnosing Young Children with Mental Minnesota Head Start: Addressing Mental
Health Concerns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 Health Needs Early . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22
Catherine Wright, MS Gayle L. Kelly, MS
Early Childhood Mental Health Systems Promoting Infant Mental Health through
Development in Minnesota . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 Relationship-Based Interventions . . . . . . . 24
Catherine Wright, MS Martha Farrell Erickson, PhD
Early Childhood Family Education (ECFE): Supporting the Mental Health Needs of
A Mental Health Promotion Program for Traumatized Young Children . . . . . . . . . . 28
Young Children and Families . . . . . . . . . . . 15 Abigail Gewirtz, PhD, LP
Lois Engstrom
Minnesota Early Childhood Comprehensive
Clinical and Public Health Perspectives on System (MECCS): Building the Infrastructure
Mental Health Disparities in Early to Meet Developmental Needs of Young
Childhood . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 Children . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30
Andrea Aga Kelly Monson MAEd, CFLE
The Center for Leadership Education in Maternal and Child Healthy Generations is produced with support from the Maternal and Child Health Bureau,
Health Resources and Services Administration, U.S. Department of Health and Human
Public Health is committed to improving the health of children, women Services (grant numberT76-MC00005-55)
and families. Center faculty and staff offer a Master’s degree in Public Health The University of Minnesota is committed to the policy that all persons shall have equal
(including an online degree program), continuing professional education, and access to its programs, facilities, and employment without regard to race, color, creed,
consultation and technical assistance to community- based organizations and religion, national origin, sex, age, marital status, disability, public assistance status, veteran
status, or sexual orientation.
agencies. Center faculty are involved in intervention and etiologic research in
Contact: mch@umn.edu or (612) 626-8644
child health, adolescent health, family health, health disparities, reproductive
© 2009 by University of Minnesota Board of Regents. All rights reserved.
health, and women’s health. See our web site at www.epi.umn.edu/mch.
Graphic design/art direction: Carr Creatives
(www.carrcreatives.com)
Letter from the Editors
In this issue of Healthy Generations, we focus on the mental health of young children, ages birth to five.
We are aware that this domain of early childhood has too often been overlooked—only recently drawing
considerable professional attention. Why this lack of attention? Perhaps too many have believed that young
children, especially infants, cannot experience mental health problems. Infants who cry inconsolably or
preschoolers who show excessive biting have often been viewed as “going through a stage” that they will
outgrow. This dismissive attitude fits the societal stereotype about mental health problems in general; that
is, the tendency to ignore such challenges because a parent or caregiver does not know what to do, or worse,
fears being blamed for their young child’s behavior. Dramatic advances in our understanding of early brain
development, the critical importance of social environments that stimulate and nurture, and the untoward
consequences when relationships to provide this care are absent or unpredictable have taught us that the
developmental trajectory towards positive mental health begins early. We now know what can and MUST be
done to ensure that ALL infants and young children receive what they need from their caregiving environments
to develop into happy, healthy children with positive mental well-being who grow into productive, contributing
members of our society.
We want to thank the many professionals who contributed to this volume and shared their expertise
about early childhood mental health. We are excited to see that public health thinking is being brought to
bear in assuring the mental health of our young children. To present a balanced perspective—promoting
positive mental health with attention to mental health problems—we invited articles that provide examples of
interventions that promote mental health, prevent problems in high-risk groups, as well as interventions that
treat diagnosed mental health disturbances—in all cases, emphasizing evidence-based practice. Other articles
in this volume highlight cutting edge issues related to early childhood mental health—screening and diagnostic
assessment, collaborative efforts to develop early childhood and mental health systems of care, and workforce
training initiatives in Minnesota.
We are keenly aware of the need for policies that provide public support for the programs and interventions
described in this issue, as well as policies that assure the social conditions that enable families and communities
to create nurturing, supportive contexts where children’s mental health can flourish.
We are pleased to showcase the wealth of information and strength of resources presented by our
professional colleagues in Minnesota. We are also very proud to share with our readers several articles written
by graduates of our Maternal and Child Health Program at the University of Minnesota, who are leaders in
this field. As we finalized this volume, we read, with sadness, that Norman Garmezy died on November 21,
2009. Dr. Garmezy, a Professor Emeritus of Psychology at the University of Minnesota, was considered the
“grandfather of resilience theory.” Among the many findings of Dr. Garmezy and his colleagues was that good
relationships with adults exert an effect that is as powerful—or even more powerful—than the mitigating
effects of adversity on child mental health. His work furthered our understanding of how children can flourish
in adverse environments and continues to stimulate researchers at the University of Minnesota and across the
globe.
As always, we welcome your feedback about this issue as well as topics for subsequent issues.
—Joän Patterson, PhD, LP, Julia Johnsen, MPH, and Wendy Hellerstdt, MPH, PhD
Winter 2009-2010 1
A Public Health Approach to
Early Childhood Mental Health
Balancing Mental Health Promotion and Treatment for Mental Health Problems Joän M. Patterson, PhD, LP
"Parents and other regular Defining Early Childhood which is related to several challenges in
Mental Health conceptualizing and measuring mental
caregivers in children’s lives impairment in this age group:
In young children, mental health is often
are 'active ingredients' of equated with healthy social and emotional ■ First, given the rapid pace of
environmental influence during development, which is defined as “the development in the early years, there
is wide variation in what constitutes
the early childhood period. developing capacity of the young child to
normal social and emotional
experience, regulate, and express emotions;
Children grow and thrive in the form close and secure interpersonal development, making it difficult to
assign boundaries between normative
context of close and dependable relationships; and explore the environment
development and at risk, problematic,
and learn, in the context of a caregiving
relationships that provide environment that includes family, or clinically significant impairment;
love and nurturance, security, community, and cultural expectations ■ Second, a young child’s mental health
responsive interaction, and for young children.”1 Noteworthy in this can best be understood in terms of
definition is the emphasis on positive mental his/her primary relationships with
encouragement for exploration. health, which contrasts with the tendency caregiver(s) in the context of family,
Without at least one such to focus on mental health problems in older culture, and community; these
children, adolescents, and adults. contextual factors are not considered
relationship, development is in diagnostic schemes that are used for
disrupted and the consequences Assessing Prevalence of older children and adults; and
can be severe and long lasting.” Mental Health Problems ■ Third, there is not yet consensus on
— National Research Council and There are limited data for estimating the the diagnostic criteria for classifying
Institute of Medicine, page 7..4 number of young children who experience psychiatric impairment in young
serious mental health disturbances, children.2
2 Healthy Generations
However, awareness of social, emotional, young children at risk for mental health on optimizing positive mental health draws
and behavioral problems in young children problems include violence in the home or from recent psychological literature that
is increasing, as reflected in the growing neighborhood, intense marital discord, describes persons who are “flourishing” in
number of young children who are expelled parental substance abuse, and child abuse contrast to “languishing,”9 and from a recent
from preschool.3 A limited number of and neglect. The effects of these exposures Institute of Medicine report emphasizing
studies of psychiatric disorders (e.g., anxiety in infants and young children may “developmental competencies” in children.10
disorders, disruptive behavior disorder, manifest in behaviors such as excessive Emphasis on positive mental health is also
attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder, and and inconsolable crying; a heightened congruent with public health’s focus on
depression) have reported prevalence rates sensitivity to touch and cuddling; excessive health promotion (and disease prevention),
in preschool children ranging from 14% biting, kicking and hitting; inability to and infant/toddler mental health
to 26%, which are similar to rates reported focus on activities; flat affect (no emotive professionals emphasis on the promotion
for school-age children.2 Newer diagnostic expressions); and/or depression. of social and emotional competencies in
schemes, developed specifically for birth Poverty. Many of the aforementioned young children.
to three years (see page 10), emphasize risks are confounded by living in a Categories of interventions. In the
relationship disorders and stress-related family experiencing persistent poverty. Georgetown model, interventions are not
disorders resulting from exposure to Children from low-income families show restricted to preventing and treating mental
environmental stressors, but prevalence higher rates of emotional and behavior health problems, but include interventions
rates have not yet been reported. problems.6 Because children of color are to promote positive mental health as
disproportionately represented among well. Interventions are grouped into four
Determinants of Mental low-income families, they are reported domains:
Health in Young Children to experience poorer social-emotional ■ Promoting and optimizing positive
Determinants of mental health for the birth development. Poor, minority children also mental health in ALL children by
to 5-year-old population include biological, are more likely to be in the child welfare assuring that the determinants of
geographical, social, and economic factors system—another setting where higher rates positive mental health are present (e.g.,
associated with both positive mental health of social, emotional, and behavior problems Early Child and Family Education
and mental health problems. in young children are found.7 programs to support parents in how
The quality of early relationships is the However, when any of these determinants to engage in nurturing, consistent
most fundamental determinant of healthy are identified early, at-risk children and relationships with their babies—see
social-emotional development in infants their caregivers can receive interventions page 15);
and toddlers. A secure attachment to a and support that can buffer mental health ■ Preventing mental health problems in
primary caregiver has an enduring influence problems and lead to positive emotional young children, especially those known
on the mental health of young children. and social developmental outcomes. to be at risk due to exposure to any of the
Relationships with parents (and other determinants of mental health problems
caregivers) need to be nurturing, protective, A Framework to Guide (e.g., home visiting—see page 19);
consistent, and characterized by high Mental Health Interventions
sensitivity to infant cues. ■ Treating diagnosed mental health
Georgetown University, with support from problems as early as possible to
Biological factors within the infant, such as the Substance Abuse and Mental Health diminish or end the effects of the
a difficult temperament or premature birth Services Administration (SAMHSA), identified problem (e.g., the Incredible
and low birth weight, may pose a challenge recently released a monograph that draws Years program for young children with
to some parents’ abilities to respond on public health values, principles, and conduct disorders—see page 26); and
sensitively to infant cues and develop a functions to advance an intervention model
nurturing relationship. for children’s mental health.8 ■ Re/Claiming health for those children
who have been or continue to be
The mental health of parents and caregivers Differentiating positive mental health treated for mental health disorders
is another major determinant of infant from mental health problems. Unlike the so they can develop and experience
mental health because it influences the historical emphasis on preventing and mental well-being even in the context
caregivers’ capacity to be nurturing and treating mental health problems in children of managing their mental health
responsive to their infants and provide and adolescents, this new intervention problem.
adequate stimulation for learning. model proposes a balanced focus between
Untreated postpartum depression in positive mental health and mental health Nearly all of the interventions include a
mothers is a recognized risk factor affecting problems. Positive mental health is viewed focus on the quality of the young child’s
infants’ social-emotional development.4 along a continuum that is independent of early relationships with parents/caregivers.
Among child care workers, higher rates of the continuum of mental health problems.8 Viewing a child alone as the source of
depression have been reported compared to The absence of a mental health problem the problem, without considering his/
adults in the general population.5 does NOT indicate positive mental health, her relationships, can lead to ineffective
nor does having a diagnosable mental intervention practices. Although examples
Social environment. Other factors in the for each category of intervention are
social environment that can undermine illness prevent a child from experiencing
social-emotional well-being. The emphasis described throughout this issue, many fit
high quality early relationships and put Continued on page 4
Winter 2009-2010 3
Intervening Model for Children’s Mental Health6
Early Childhood Mental Health from page 3
health as one of several domains that member of society, or it can lay the Study of Child Care Employment, U of CA at Berkeley,
2004.
intersect to ensure healthy development in foundation for intergenerational cycles of
abuse, neglect, violence, dysfunction, and 6. Duncan GJ, Brooks-Gunn J. Family poverty, welfare
young children. reform and child development. Child Dev 2000; 71:188-
mental illness. The burgeoning science 196.
Role of Public Policies of early brain development points to the 7. Burns B, Phillips S, Wagner H, et al. Mental health need
wisdom of investing resources “early” in a and access to mental health services by youths involved
in Assuring Early Childhood child’s developmental trajectory, beginning with child welfare. A national survey. J Am Acad Child
Mental Health in utero to eliminate toxic exposures that Adolesc Psychiatry 2004; 43:960-970.
Brains Are Built Over Time Interactive Influences as expected, which can lead to disparities in
from the Bottom Up of Genes and Experience learning and behavior.
The construction of the brain’s architecture Shape the Developing Brain The Brain’s Capacity for
begins before birth and continues to be It is not just one’s genetic makeup, but Change Decreases with Age
refined into early adulthood. Brain systems how those genes get used, that determines
that perceive sensation (e.g., hearing, brain development. Once the child is born, The brain is most flexible, or “plastic,” early
touch) and simple actions develop first, experiences influence how genes are turned in life. As the maturing brain becomes
followed by systems that are involved in on and off and thus how they are used. more specialized to assume more complex
emotions, more complex actions, and One important example of this process is functions, it is less capable of reorganizing
early language. Later-developing systems the “serve and return” nature of children’s and adapting to new or unexpected
support increasingly complex thinking, relationships with adults. Young children challenges. For example, by the first year,
reasoning, planning, and self-control. As naturally reach out for interaction through the parts of the brain that differentiate
each brain system develops, it is built on top babbling, facial expressions, and gestures. sound are becoming specialized to the
of earlier-developing systems and can be Adults respond with the same kind of language the baby has been exposed to. At
only as good as the architecture on which vocalizing and gesturing back at them. In the same time, the brain is already starting
it is built. Early experiences affect whether the absence of such responses—or if the to lose the ability to recognize different
a child’s brain architecture will provide a responses are unreliable or inappropriate— sounds found in other languages. Although
sturdy or fragile foundation for all of the the child’s brain architecture does not form the “windows” for language learning and
learning and development that will follow. other skills remain open, these brain
Continued on page 6
Winter 2009-2010 5
Early Experience and the Science of Brain Development from page 5
8 Healthy Generations
Social and Emotional
Developmental Milestones
Winter 2009-2010 9
Diagnosing Young Children
with Mental Health Concerns
Catherine Wright, MS
10 Healthy Generations
Early Childhood Mental Health Systems
Development in Minnesota
Catherine Wright, MS
Continuum of Care Child and Teen Check-Ups* conducted in new eligibility criteria allow children birth
medical clinics. The screening tools assist to 2 years with mental health conditions to
The Minnesota statewide early childhood
caregivers and medical professionals in receive the full early intervention services
mental health system includes four specific
identifying social-emotional concerns in offered through Part C.2
domains in the continuum of care:
young children. The Maternal and Child The CMHD also is working closely with
■ Prevention—services available to all Health Assurance Unit was also recently the Minnesota Head Start Association to
children; awarded the ABCD III grant from the promote the use of the Incredible Years3
■ Early intervention—services for Commonwealth Fund and the National curriculum, an evidence-based early
children who demonstrate undiagnosed Academy for State Health Policy (NASHP). intervention for children with potential
mental health concerns; This grant will assist medical clinics in behavioral concerns.
connecting with local early intervention
■ Intervention—services for children with services for children with identified mental Intervention. For the past six years, the
diagnosable mental health conditions; health and developmental concerns. CMHD, in partnership with the Minnesota
and Department of Health’s Minnesota Children
Early intervention. In 2006, the Minnesota with Special Health Needs (MCSHN)
■ Intensive intervention—intensive Department of Education, with support from
services for children with significant section, has been working with the national
state and local agency partners, changed organization, Zero to Three, to train and
diagnosable mental health conditions. the eligibility criteria for Part C of the mentor mental health professionals in the
Prevention. Through a Commonwealth Individuals with Disabilities Education Act use of the DC:0-3R, a developmentally
Grant, Assuring Better Child Development (IDEA) to include 13 early childhood mental appropriate mental health diagnostic tool
(ABCDII), the CMHD partnered with the health diagnoses listed in the DC:0-3R
DHS Maternal and Child Health Assurance (Diagnostic Classification of Mental Health *Child and Teen Checkups is Minnesota's name for Early
Unit to promote the use of standardized and Developmental Disorders of Infancy Periodic Screening, Diagnosis and Treatment (EPSDT),
mental health screening tools during and Early Childhood: Revised Edition).1 The which is required by Medicaid.
Continued on page 12
Winter 2009-2010 11
Early Childhood Mental Health Systems Development in Minnesota from page 11
Evaluation
The CMHD recently required all mental
health professionals who receive public 2. Minnesota Department of Health. Early childhood
intervention Part C. Available from: http://www.health. Minnesota Association of
reimbursement for services to birth Children’s Mental Health:
state.mn.us/divs/fh/mcshn/ecippkt.htm
to 5-year-olds to use two evaluation
3. More information about the Incredible Years programs is From a parent support group to a
instruments: the Strengths and Difficulties available from: http://www.incredibleyears.com/ statewide advocacy organization
Questionnaire6 (an assessment tool for
4. Eyberg SM, Boggs SR, Algina J. Parent-child interaction
children ages 3 to 5) and the Early Childhood therapy: a psychosocial model for the treatment of
The Minnesota Association for Children’s Mental
Services Intensity Instrument7 (a functional young children with conduct problem behavior and their
families. Psychopharmacol Bull. 1995;31(1):83-91. Health (MACMH) was established in 1989 by a small
assessment tool for children ages birth to group of parents who shared the experience of
5). The State chose to evaluate state-funded 5. Minnesota Department of Human Services. Bulletin.
raising children with mental health disorders. Today
DHS requires standardized outcome measures and level
mental health services so that families and of care determinations for children’s mental health. April MACMH is a statewide education and advocacy
consumers would have information to 2009. Available from: http://www.dhs.state.mn.us/main/ organization. Its mission is “to promote the positive
better choose from the array of services and groups/publications/documents/pub/dhs16_144775.pdf mental health of all infants, children, adolescents, and
providers for their children.5 6. Goodman R. The Strengths and Difficulties their families” and is carried out through education,
Questionnaire: a research note. J Child Psychol advocacy, and an annual conference. MACMH has
Psychiatry 1997; 38:581-586. published curricula for parents, educators, and
Infrastructure Building
7. American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, other practitioners and offers numerous trainings
Through the Governor’s Mental Work Group on Community-based Systems of Care. in Minnesota. Among MACMH’s resources are its
Health Initiative of 2007, the CMHD Early Childhood Service Intensity Instrument (ECSII). Guide to Early Childhood Mental Health, mental
2005. Available from: http://www.aacap.org/galleries/
has released 3 million dollars in direct PracticeInformation/Information_sheet_ECSII.pdf health factsheets (in English and Spanish), and a
service/infrastructure building grants for newsletter. Its Open-Up magazine is one component
early childhood mental health systems of a new arts-based community outreach initiative
Catherine Wright, MS, is an Early Childhood Mental that showcases the work of young people through
development across the state. In April 2009,
Health Program Coordinator for the Children’s Mental essays, poems, and visual arts to impart powerful
10 communities were awarded these grants Health Division at the Minnesota Department of messages about mental health.
to develop comprehensive services for Human Services.
children, birth to 5 years, employing the four According to MACMH, its annual conference is the
For more information about early childhood systems largest of its kind in the nation, offering parents,
categories of the continuum of care using the
development efforts in Minnesota, please contact caregivers, and professionals access to more than
state-required evaluation tools. 75 workshops of varying technical levels and
Catherine Wright at catherine.wright@state.mn.us.
REFERENCES nationally renowned keynote speakers. The 2010
1. Zero to Three. Diagnostic classification of mental health conference will take place April 25-27 at the Duluth
and developmental disorders of infancy and early Entertainment Convention Center.
childhood: Revised edition. Washington, DC: Zero to
Three Press, 2005.
For more information about MACMH go
to: http://www.macmh.org/index.php
12 Healthy Generations
Evidence-based Practices
in Early Childhood Mental Health
Glenace E. Edwall, PsyD, PhD, LP, MPP
What Is the Meaning of EBP? challenging questions are often raised about a rating based on the quality of research
EBPs. underlying a specific practice, as well as
The American Psychological Association
■ What “evidence” is required to establish notes the demographic and diagnostic
(APA) has provided leadership in defining
an EBP? Early EBPs emphasized what application of the practice, to the
and promulgating EBPs for children’s
is now referred to as a “gold standard” extent that this information is specified
mental health. In a 2008 task force report,
of evidence, including double-blind, in the practice’s research reports.
APA noted that the term EBP has come to
randomized trials with control groups, Evidence that is still needed in the
connote:
using competing interventions, early childhood domain is that from
■ A broader focus than evidence-based longitudinal interventions.
manualized practices, studies by more
treatment, which is limited to
than one group of researchers, and ■ Do EBPs privilege some values over
prevention or intervention programs
statistically and clinically significant others? EBPs are unapologetically
for which there is a strong scientific
differences in outcomes favoring the rooted in the tradition of scientific
base;
practice in question..2 If we relied solely evidence derived from experimental
■ The quality, robustness, and/or on this standard, there would be very research. As the field has evolved,
scientific evidence about prevention, little “evidence” for effective practice. there has been increasing attention
treatment, access, engagement, and More recent approaches to EBPs have to contextual factors related to
retention of targeted client populations; included somewhat broader research evidence, including the importance
■ Incorporation of client characteristics criteria. For example, the National of individualized care, strengths- and
as well as clinical expertise; and Registry of Evidence-based Practices family-based care, and cultural
and Programs assigns ratings from competency.
■ A coherent body of scientific 1 to 4 on specific criteria: reliability
knowledge relevant to a range of ■ Do EBPs reinforce the “medical model”
and validity of measures, intervention of mental health? EBPs are certainly
service and clinician practices, which fidelity, missing data and attrition,
allows for prediction of the impact of rooted in health care, and particularly
potential confounding variables, and in evidence-based medicine. Compared
interventions.1 appropriateness of analysis.3 The with EBPs for adult care, EBPs for
database that Minnesota is using to children generally have a more
EBPs: Questions and Issues train providers, developed from the developmental and preventive focus.
Particularly as applied to early childhood work of Dr. Bruce Chorpita (University
mental health services, a number of of California–Los Angeles), also assigns
Continued on page 14
Winter 2009-2010 13
Evidence-Based Practices in Early Childhood Mental Health from page 13
14 Healthy Generations
Early Childhood Family Education (ECFE):
A Mental Health Promotion Program for Young Children and Families
Lois Engstrom
16 Healthy Generations
Clinical and Public Health Perspectives on
Mental Health Disparities in Early Childhood
Andrea Aga
18 Healthy Generations
Family Home Visiting
A Public Health Program to Promote Healthy Social-Emotional Development
Sharon Hesseltine, BSW
Jill E. Simon, MSW, LICSW, IMH-E® (IV)
Building a Supportive is presented through a series of home “stepping back” to consider the meaning of
Relationship visiting case scenarios. This method allows one’s professional and personal responses to
participants the opportunity to learn relationship interactions. The home visitor
Essential to the effectiveness of ongoing concepts by applying them to a home
home visits is having the family experience steps back to ponder her own reactions,
visiting situation and gain insight through wonder about the parent’s perspective,
a supportive and continuing relationship discussion with peers and trainers. In each
with a visitor. This relationship promotes and reflect on how she might best help the
scenario, participants are encouraged to parent discover her or his own solutions.
the parent’s capacity to care for the focus on how to use the visitor-parent
child in a manner that fosters healthy Likewise, the home visitor helps the parent
relationship as the primary vehicle to effect think about his or her thoughts and feelings,
attachment. Research shows that supportive change. Future training development will
relationships in the parent’s life have a consider the child’s experience, and identify
continue to promote the fundamental solutions that encompass both perspectives.
significant and long-term positive influence skills and theoretical underpinnings of
on the parent-child relationship. It is Essentially there is a parallel process; that
evidence-based home visiting practice and is, the home visitor relates to the parent in
well-documented that an infant’s healthy its relationship to infant mental health.
attachment is a major contributing factor a healthy respectful manner, which builds
in optimal social, emotional, and cognitive One of the tools that home visitors use is the parent’s capacity to develop a healthy
development of the child.2 the Parent-Child Interaction (PCI) Feeding relationship with his or her child. The goal
and Teaching Scales,3 which assess the of reflective practice is to gain a better
To enhance the capacity of family home quality of parent-child interaction and understanding of relationships—between
visitors in the work of relationship-building, communication behaviors. Results of this the parent and child, as well as between
the Minnesota Department of Health assessment can be used by home visitors the home visitor and parent—so that all
(MDH) provides training, technical to support parents’ learning about how to relationships support the healthy emotional
assistance, and consultation. respond to their infants’ cues, which is a development of the child.
critical component of sensitive caregiving. MDH offers a reflective practice consultant
Training Home visitors also receive training in to local public health departments to
A new family home visiting training motivational interviewing,4 which is a support and strengthen home visitors’
curriculum, “Promoting Relationships with collaborative, person-centered discussion to skills in using a reflective approach with
Relationships,” is available to public health elicit and strengthen parents’ motivation for families. The consultant facilitates reflective
home visitors in Minnesota. This training making healthy changes. practice case conferences and provides
addresses infant mental health, parent-child mentoring and reflective practice groups
attachment, and culturally responsive Reflective Practice for supervisors. Reflective supervision
practice. To emphasize the ongoing An essential component of most contributes to an understanding of home
development of relationship-building evidence-based home visiting models is the visitor boundaries and roles and clarifies
skills and knowledge, the course material use of reflective practice, which involves goals and areas of intervention.
Continued on page 27
Winter 2009-2010 19
Follow Along Program: An Early Childhood
Intervention System at the Minnesota Department of Health
Andrea Mayfield
20 Healthy Generations
Part C IDEA, Early Intervention Services:
Serving Children Under 3 Years with Mental Health Concerns
Karen Adamson, RN, MPH
W hile all states provide early childhood intervention services for children
under 3 years of age who are experiencing developmental delays,
screening and services for social-emotional delays have lagged behind services
for other developmental delays in many states.1 In Hennepin County, Minnesota,
staff provide developmental and social-emotional screening for referred children
under age 3. These children are referred from families, pediatric providers,
hospitals, and other community sources when a delay is suspected. Screening
is done in the home using standardized tools by public health nurses and child
development specialists.
In 2008, Hennepin County early childhood “at risk” of developmental delay.1 intervention, but have very significant
staff administered nearly 500 mental needs as evidenced by their interactions
health screens using the Ages and Stages Interagency Coordination and behavior. It is for these children that
Questionnaire: Social Emotional (ASQ:SE).2 Part C legislation requires coordination Hennepin County social workers try to
In this sample of children with suspected among education, health, and social provide additional in-home services or
delays, 17% of the infants under 1 year service agencies in a state, with one agency referrals to early childhood mental health
scored in the “concerns” area and 40% of 1 designated as the lead. In Minnesota, professionals for therapeutic intervention.
to 3-year olds, had scores in the “concerns” education is the lead, and Interagency These services are provided through county
range.3 In Minneapolis, all children under Early Intervention Committees (IEIC) funds or third-party billing.
age 3 with scores indicating mental health have been formed throughout the state to
concerns are referred to IDEA Part C, enact this coordination function. School Services for Abused and
Part C of the Individuals with Disabilities districts are required to provide early Neglected Children
Education Act (IDEA) Early Intervention intervention services for eligible children The Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment
Services through the Minneapolis School in their districts. Because the needs of very Act (CAPTA)5 mandates social-emotional
District. young children are frequently complex and screening and, when warranted, referral
not directly observable in a public K–12 to Part C Early Intervention services.
What is IDEA and Part C? system, public health and social services are In 2008, child welfare staff in Hennepin
IDEA Part C is a federal program that important partners with education in finding County administered mental health screens
assists states in providing statewide early young children experiencing developmental to all children under age 5 who had been
intervention services for children, birth to delays. Screening is just the beginning. Part in foster care for at least 30 days. Many
3 years, with disabilities.4 Established in C Early Intervention Services require a full of these children have significant mental
1987 and reauthorized in 2004, all states evaluation for all children whose screens health conditions and require therapeutic
participate in the program, although there is indicate developmental delays, and services intervention in addition to services through
considerable variation in how developmental are provided at no cost to families through the local school district. Nationally,
delay is defined and how many children the school district. one-third of children ages 2 to 5 in child
are served. Services must be provided for welfare need mental health services and
those who are experiencing developmental Early Intervention Services related interventions.6
delays and for those who have a diagnosed for Social-Emotional Delays As we improve our ability to screen more
mental or physical condition that has a high
Determination of service need is based on young children in Hennepin County,
probability of resulting in a developmental
an education model. As we screen young Minnesota and other states, we realize that
delay. States may choose to serve children
children for mental health concerns, we find we need multiple resources to meet the
“at risk” of experiencing a substantial
that there are some children who do not mental health needs of very young children.
developmental delay, but currently, only
meet the eligibility criteria for educational In addition, there is a need to assist agencies
seven states and one territory include those
Continued on page 23
Winter 2009-2010 21
Minnesota Head Start:
Addressing Mental Health Needs Early
Gayle L. Kelly, MS
Head Start Goals with mental health professionals to offer Addressing Parent Education
consultation services for enrolled children Needs
Echoing the Zero to Three definition of
with social or emotional problems. Mental
infant mental health, Head Start’s goals are Parents look to Head Start to understand
health consultants can provide a range of
to ensure that all young children can form their children’s social and emotional
services including classroom observations,
strong attachments with their caregivers, development, and parent education is a
in-depth assessments of children, direct
regulate their emotions, and reach out and critical component of Head Start’s family
therapeutic services, training and/or support
explore their environment to learn.1 These development services. The Ages and Stages
for staff, and meetings with parents.
goals underlie all Head Start efforts to Questionnaire: Social-Emotional (ASQ:SE)3
provide early learning experiences for young The 2008 federal Program Information has been adopted by every Head Start
children. Report demonstrated that Minnesota Head program in Minnesota to screen children
Start staff sought consultation with mental and help initiate a dialogue with parents
Federal Requirements for health professionals related to the mental about their child’s development. ASQ:SE
Meeting Social-Emotional health problems of more than 2,100 enrolled is completed by parents within the first 45
children (or 13% of Minnesota’s Head Start days of their children entering Head Start,
Needs
enrollment).2 In-house professionals served and the results are reviewed with every
The federal Head Start Performance many additional children and families. parent. Parents whose children have a
Standards require programs to develop The number of children in Head Start positive screening result can request further
systems for screening, identifying, and with mental health concerns has grown assessment, and all parents have a variety
treating children with emotional difficulties. dramatically in the past 10 years. of options for further discussion with staff
They also require Head Start to contract
specialists or mental health professionals.
22 Healthy Generations
continued from page 21
Part C IDEA, Early Intervention Services
New parent education offerings like the programs indicate they now serve many that work with young children on a daily
Incredible Years Parenting Program (see children with mental health problems who basis, such as preschools and child care
page 26) are being offered in partnerships are waiting for evaluation by their local Part centers, to employ qualified professionals
between Head Start and community mental C or ECSE team or have not qualified for who are skilled in early childhood services.
health organizations throughout Minnesota. those education services. References
Changing role of mental health consultation. 1. Cooper J, Vick J. Promoting social-emotional wellbeing in
Mental Health Consultation Increasingly, Head Start programs are early intervention services. A fifty-state view. New York:
National Center for Children in Poverty, 2009. Available
In 2004, Minnesota Head Start programs partnering with community mental health from: http://www.nccp.org/publications/pdf/text_885.pdf
faced considerable challenges in finding organizations with expertise in early 2. Squires J, Bricker D, Twombly MS, Heo K. Identification
qualified mental health consultants with childhood, thereby bringing assessment and of social- emotional problems in young children using a
early childhood expertise. A partnership treatment services into Head Start settings. parent completed tool. Early Child Res Q 2001;16(4):405-
between the Minnesota Head Start 419.
Today, integrated service approaches are
Association and the Minnesota Department occurring with dramatic positive results 3. Hennepin County Human Services and Public Health.
2008 Annual Report: Early Childhood Public Health.
of Human Services (DHS), Division of for children and families. Examples of the Internal publication, available upon request.
Children’s Mental Health, has contributed evolving role of mental health consultants in 4. U.S. Department of Education. Individuals with
to significant progress in improving mental Head Start include: Disabilities Education Act. Available from: http://idea.
health supports for young children. ed.gov/
■ In the Duluth Head Start programs,
Building capacity through training. 5. Cutler C, Ward H, Yoon SY, et al. Children at risk in the
mental health consultants conduct child child welfare system: collaborations to promote school
In 2004, Head Start adopted a “grow observations, work closely with parents, readiness. University of Southern Maine: Muskie School
your own” approach by partnering with and work closely with classroom staff to of Public Service, April 2009. Available from: http://
mental health professionals. The Head muskie.usm.maine.edu/schoolreadiness/
develop individualized strategies for all
Start program identified community children showing challenging behaviors. 6. Cooper J. Social and emotional development in early
childhood: what every policymaker should know. New
mental health professionals who lacked Reflective consultation is used to help York: National Center for Children in Poverty, 2009.
training and experience serving young staff recognize the difficulty in caring for Available from: http://www.nccp.org/publications/
children, but were motivated and willing children with social-emotional issues.
to acquire additional competencies. The
■ Through the work of its consulting Karen Adamson, RN, MPH, is Program Manager for
DHS Division of Children’s Mental Health Children, Youth and Families at Hennepin County
psychologist, Parents in Community
began offering regional training grounded Human Services and Public Health (Minnesota) and
Action (PICA), Inc., the Head Start
in neurobehavioral scientific research and she is the current Chair of the Minnesota Department
provider in Hennepin County, has of Health MCH Advisory Task Force. Karen received
designed to develop trainee competencies in
developed a collaborative partnership her MPH in Maternal and Child Health from the
using state-of-the-art methods for screening,
with Family and Children’s Services University of Minnesota.
assessment, and intervention with children
to provide on-site play therapy
under the age of 5. Head Start programs
for identified children. PICA’s
in many communities provided financial
referral-to-follow up ratio is nearly
support to help their mental health partners
100%. Visit the Center for Leadership
participate in this training. They also made
their classrooms available as laboratories The Minnesota Head Start community Education in Maternal and
to help ground these professionals in the is redefining the roles of mental health Child Public Health ONLINE
language of early childhood development. consultants as an invaluable resource for the
well-being of children and families, as well
Referral for diagnostic assessment. Prior Join us in the blogosphere:
as staff. The first priority in comprehensive
to 2004, Minnesota Head Start programs www.healthygenerations.wordpress.com
school readiness must be early learning
referred children with mental health Engage with MCH professionals discussing a broad
policies and funding streams that ensure
concerns almost exclusively to their local range of cutting-edge topics, including innovative
services to promote the social and emotional
educational agency for evaluation by Early MCH projects, emerging research, and important
well-being of children and their caregivers. policy efforts.
Childhood Special Education (ECSE) (or
for a child under 3 years, Part C Early References Tour our website: www.epi.umn.edu/mch
Intervention). Very few children were given 1. Task Force on Infant Mental Health. Definition of infant Learn more about our academic training
a diagnosis related to their social-emotional mental health. Arlington, VA: Zero to Three, 2002. programs and continuing education workshops
Available from: www.zerotothree.org.
delay or disability and hence, were not and events, or check out the new videos and
eligible for ECSE or Part C services. Today, 2. Kuklinski W. Data from the 2008 Federal Head Start podcasts we have posted. The content is changing
Program Information Report for Minnesota. St. Paul,
more programs have access to mental health everyday—so be sure to bookmark us and check
MN: Minnesota Department of Education.
professionals who have been trained in back often!
3. Squires J, Bricker D, Twombly E. Ages and stages
developmentally appropriate mental health questionnaires: social-emotional (ASQ:SE): a parent- If you would like to be added to our mailing list
assessment techniques such as DC:0-3R completed, child-monitoring system for social-emotional to receive future volumes of Healthy Generations
behaviors. Baltimore: Brookes Publishing, 2009. please contact Jan Pearson at pears014@umn.edu.
and referrals are often made concurrently
to community mental health providers and
their local ECSE or Part C team. Head Start Gayle L. Kelly, MS, is Executive Director of the
Minnesota Head Start Association, Inc.
Winter 2009-2010 23
Promoting Infant Mental Health through
Relationship-based Interventions
Martha Farrell Erickson, PhD
http://www.regonline.com/strongfoundations2010
The Center for Leadership Education in Maternal and Child Public Health is a co-sponsor of this event.
Winter 2009-2010 25
Promoting Early Childhood Mental Health
through Evidence-based Practice
Implementation of the Incredible Years in Ramsey County, Minnesota Gael Thompson, MSW, LICSW
26 Healthy Generations
in small group sessions for 20–22 weeks.
In addition to the weekly therapeutic
sessions for children, the BASIC Parent
Program is offered to parents so they
learn ways to foster healthy interactions
at home similar to what their children
are learning in the group.
■ Preschool BASIC parent program is
designed for parents of 3 to 6 year-olds.
It focuses on strengthening children’s
social skills, emotional regulation, and
school readiness skills. Parents are
taught how to encourage cooperative
behavior and how to use positive
discipline by establishing rules, routines,
and effective limit setting.
■ Parents and babies program is designed
for parents of infants (ages 0–12
months). The program focuses on
helping parents learn to observe and
read their babies’ cues and learn ways
to provide nurturing and responsive
care, including physical, tactile, and
visual stimulation as well as verbal
communication.
■ Parents and toddlers program is
designed for parents of 1 to 3 year-olds.
Parents learn how child-directed play National Award Recipient continued from page 19 Family Home Visiting
promotes positive relationships, how to On September 25, 2009, the Substance
References
use emotion coaching to build children’s Abuse and Mental Health Services
emotional vocabulary and encourage Administration announced that Wilder’s Visit www.health.state.mn.us/divs/fh/mch/
their expression of feelings, how to build Incredible Years Program was selected as one fhv/index.html for information about the
children’s self-esteem through praise of 27 nation-wide recipients of their 2009 family home visiting program and www.
and encouragement, and how to teach Science and Service Awards. These awards health.state.mn.us/divs/fh/mch/fhv/
age-appropriate self-care skills. recognize exemplary implementation of newsletter/documents/summer2009.pdf for
evidence-based interventions that have been information about reflective practice.
Program Outcomes shown to prevent and/or treat mental illness References
In 2009, Wilder Research completed an and substance abuse. 1. Powers S, Fenichel E. Home visiting: reaching babies
and families “where they live.” A report of the best
outcome report of data collected since For more information about the early available information from 20 years of research and
implementing the Incredible Years programs childhood programs offered at the practice on home visiting. Washington DC: Zero to
(2005–2009). Children showed statistically Wilder Foundation, go to www.wilder. Three, 1999.
significant improvements in all five org/432.0.html. For more information about 2. Zeanah CH, Zeanah PD. Towards a definition of infant
behavioral domains: emotional symptoms, the Incredible Years programs, please go to mental health. Zero to Three, 2001; 22(1):13-20.
conduct problems, hyperactivity-inattention, www.incredibleyears.com. 3. Nursing Child Assessment Satellite Training (NCAST)
AVENUW. Available from: http://www.ncast.org/
peer problems, and pro-social behavior.
Parents and teachers reported that fewer 4. Miller W, Rollnick S. Motivational interviewing.
Gael Thompson, MSW, LICSW, is the Early Childhood preparing people for change, 2nd edition. New York:
children had difficulties with emotions, Intervention Program Coordinator at the Amherst H. Guilford, 2002..
concentration, behavior, or getting along Wilder Foundation Child Guidance Clinic, St. Paul,
with others at discharge compared to intake. MN.
Sharon Hesseltine, BSW, is a Child Development/
Parents who participated in the Preschool
Infant Mental Health Specialist in the Family and
BASIC Parent Program demonstrated Community Health Division of the Minnesota
significant improvement from intake to Department of Health
discharge in six of seven parenting skills
areas: appropriate discipline, harsh and Jill E. Simon, MSW, LICSW, IMH-E® (IV), is a
inconsistent discipline, positive verbal Reflective Practice Consultant in the Family and
Community Health Division at the Minnesota
discipline, praise and incentives, physical Department of Health.
discipline, and clear expectations.
Winter 2009-2010 27
Supporting the Mental Health Needs of
Traumatized Young Children
Abigail Gewirtz, PhD, LP
Risks Associated with Trauma who are homeless—are most likely to be to live in communities (or on bases) with
single-mother families with several young better social supports and more resources.
Several subgroups of very young children
children. Children living in homeless
are at particularly high risk for exposure to
families are significantly more likely to Treatment for Traumatized
traumatic events. These are young children
have health and social-emotional problems Young Children
with backgrounds indicating high adversity
compared to poor children who have
or exposure to multiple stressful events, and What can be done to support young, highly
housing.3
often the caregivers of these children also stressed families dealing with traumatic
have been exposed to significant trauma. Military families. Recent studies have shown experiences? Over the past several decades,
These childhood experiences include increased risk of maltreatment among effective programs have been developed
homelessness, having refugee parents who children in military families where a parent to both prevent and treat trauma-related
have fled war in their native countries, and has been deployed to Iraq or Afghanistan.4 problems in adults and children. SAMHSA’s
having mothers fleeing domestic violence. Parents remaining at home are challenged National Child Traumatic Stress Network
An additional group emerging as high-risk by the stressors associated with being a sole (NCTSN) is a nationwide network
includes children whose parent(s) have caregiver and having a deployed partner of Centers dedicated to developing,
been deployed to combat duty in Iraq or in an unsafe environment. Reunions can disseminating, and implementing best
Afghanistan. These "high-risk" families are also be stressful for all members of the practices in child trauma.5 The NCTSN’s
less likely to access mental health or related family. Some returning soldiers may have
services that might buffer poor parenting,2 posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), * Traumatic events include any event in which an
increasing both parenting and couple individual experiences actual or threatened death,
enhance social support, and increase child serious injury, the threat to physical integrity, or the life
and family functioning. challenges. In the military, supports for or integrity of a close associate. Examples include abuse,
active-duty service families are stronger than domestic violence, community violence, wars, natural
Homeless and poor families. Families
for families with caregivers serving in the disasters such as tornados or flooding, terrorism, or motor
living in poverty—particularly those vehicle or other accidents.
National Guard or Reserves; the former tend
28 Healthy Generations
goal is to increase access to high-quality care
for traumatized children and their families.
Parenting through change. Ambit Network Earn an Online MPH
is the NCTSN Center in Minnesota. A
community-University partnership based In Maternal and Child Health
at the University of Minnesota, Ambit
includes multiple child-serving systems
and agencies. Over the past four years,
Ambit (formerly known as the MN Child
Response Center) has trained hundreds of
practitioners in Minnesota to increase their
capacity to identify and provide services
for traumatized children and families. The
Center has focused on the implementation
of two types of interventions—treatment
for individual children and prevention to
support parenting in traumatized families.
A flexible program for working professionals who are
The latter, Parenting through Change concerned about vulnerable populations and want to
(PTC),6 is a 14-week group that enhances
critical elements of parenting that may acquire leadership skills for addressing the health needs
be adversely affected when families have of families, women, infants, children, and adolescents.
experienced traumatic events. PTC has been
implemented successfully in a shelter, at
several supportive housing agencies, and
at schools, in collaboration with several
non-profit agencies (the Family Housing
Fund and the Minneapolis Public Schools).
In partnership with the Center for Victims
of Torture and the East African Women’s
Center, a PTC group will begin with Somali
mothers in Minneapolis in late 2009. Also in
late 2009, a PTC group for returning military T o learn more: visit our Web site
parents will be led by Ambit Network staff in www.epi.umn.edu/mch/index.php/Page/View/Distance-Learning
partnership with the Minneapolis Veterans or email gradstudies@epi.umn.edu
Administration Medical Center.
or call (612) 626-8802
Trauma-focused cognitive behavioral
therapy. For traumatized children ages
three and older, trauma-focused cognitive
behavioral therapy (TF-CBT)7 is a treatment through Ambit Network, contact Ashley 6. Forgatch MS, Patterson GR, DeGarmo DS, Beldavs ZG.
shown to be effective in multiple settings. Wahl at 612-624-7722. Testing the Oregon delinquency model with 9-year
follow-up of the Oregon divorce sudy. Dev Psychopathol
Over the past three years, Ambit Network, in 2009; 21:637-660.
partnership with the Minnesota Department REFERENCES
7. Cohen J, Mannarino A, Deblinger E. Treating trauma and
of Human Service, Division of Children’s 1. Finkelhor D, Turner H, Ormrod R, Hamby S, Kracke traumatic grief in children and adolescents. New York:
K. Children’s exposure to violence: a comprehensive
Mental Health, has trained and provided Guildford Press, 2006,
national survey. Juvenile Justice Bulletin, Washington
technical assistance to almost 100 mental DC: Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs,
health professionals across Minnesota to OJJDP Bulletin, 2009. Available from: http://www.ncjrs.
Abigail Gewirtz, PhD, LP, is an Assistant Professor
gov/pdffiles1/ojjdp/227744.pdf
deliver TF-CBT. in the Department of Family Social Science and the
2. Gewirtz AH, Forgatch M, Wieling L. Parenting practices Institute of Child Development at the University of
Over the next three years, Ambit, in as potential mechanisms for child adjustment following
Minnesota, and Director of Ambit Network.
collaboration with Minnesota’s Department mass trauma. J Marital Fam Ther 2008; 34(2):177–192.
of Human Services, will expand its efforts to 3. Gewirtz AH, DeGarmo DS, Plowman E, August GJ.
develop a trauma-informed mental health Parenting, parental mental health, and child functioning
in families residing in supportive housing. Am J
system in Minnesota, to ensure that all Orthopsychiatry, in press.
children and families who have experienced
4. Gibbs DA, Martin SL, Kupper LL, Johnson RE. Child
traumatic events have access to the best maltreatment in enlisted soldiers’ families during
services available. combat-related deployments. JAMA 2007; 298:528-535.
5. National Child Traumatic Stress Network. Description,
For more information about the programs
resources and products. Available from: www.nctsn.org
for traumatized children and families offered
Winter 2009-2010 29
Minnesota Early Childhood Comprehensive System (MECCS):
Building the Infrastructure to Meet Developmental Needs of Young Children
Kelly Monson MAEd, CFLE
Moving from a Fragmented ■ Mental health and social-emotional adopt a model developed by the National
development; Childhood Systems Working Group1,3 that
to a Comprehensive System integrates the key systems necessary for early
■ Early child care and education;
In most states, policies and programs that childhood development: (1) health, mental
address the developmental needs of young ■ Parenting education; and health and nutrition; (2) early learning; (3)
children and their families are spread across ■ Family support. family support; and (4) special needs/early
government agencies, funded through intervention.1,3
The Minnesota Department of Health
different sources, and delivered through The five essential elements of ECCS
(MDH) has been an ECCS grantee since
multiple public and private providers in are represented by one or more of the
July 2003. The Minnesota Early Childhood
communities.1 This fragmentation is costly, four ovals in this systems model. While
Comprehensive System (MECCS) focuses
inefficient, and most importantly, results in individual programs within any of the ovals
on infrastructure and capacity building
many needs of young children going unmet. may demonstrate some positive impact
services and involves representatives of key
In an effort to encourage comprehensive upon children’s healthy development and
units within the state departments of health,
systems for young children 0–5 years and school readiness, they will not realize
education, and human services whose
their families, the Health Resources and their full potential without support from
work is directly related to the five critical
Services Administration initiated the State the programs in the other ovals.1 By
components.
Early Childhood Comprehensive Systems adopting a systems model, mental health
(ECCS) grants in 2003. The purpose of
Adopting a Model was incorporated into early childhood
ECCS grants is to integrate early childhood systems-building in Minnesota. Ensuring
policies and programs, including funding for Systems Development
positive mental health requires that children
streams. The systems to be integrated include With this multi-sector partnership, have good self-esteem, adaptive skills, and
key public, private, state, and local agencies Minnesota adopted the goal of “families positive social behaviors with peers and
that address five critical components of early supported and children thriving, healthy, adults—and that any developmental delays
childhood: and ready for school in the context of of children are recognized and treated.1
■ Access to health insurance and medical culture and community.” In 2007, MECCS
homes; collaborated with Ready 4K, the state
recipient of a national Build grant,3 to
30 Healthy Generations
Key Indicators to Monitor identified and referred at early REFERENCES
an Early Childhood System childhood screening; 1. Bruner C. Connecting child health and school
readiness. Build Initiative and Child and Family Policy
In collaboration with the Wilder Foundation, ■ Number/percent of children being Center, February 2009. Available from: http://www.
Minnesota Build and MECCS identified 22 served through publicly funded mental buildinitiative.org/files/IssueBrief_Bruner_Feb09_Final.
pdf
indicators of child and family well-being health services compared to estimated
need; 2. Shonkoff J, Phillips D. (Eds.). National Research
and systems quality that represent each Council and Institute of Medicine. From neurons
of the four ovals in the systems model.4 ■ Number of children ages 0–2 and 3–4 to neighborhoods: the science of early childhood
development. Washington, DC: National Academy Press,
Identification and ongoing measurement enrolled in quality early childhood 2000.
of indicators are critical because such data programs;
3. Build initiative: A project of the Early Childhood
allow the state partners to: ■ Participation rates in ECFE and other Funders’ Collaborative supporting state efforts to prepare
our youngest children for success. Available from: http://
■ Track trends in young child and family parent education and support models; www.buildinitiative.org/
well-being over time; and
4. Moore C, Chase R, Waltz M, et al. Early childhood
■ Measure progress toward improving ■ Number/percent of children birth to 3 Minnesota Indicators and strategies for Minnesota’s early
childhood system, a joint report of Minnesota Build and
child outcomes; years who are served through Part C Minnesota Early Childhood Comprehensive Systems. St.
■ Improve programs for children and Early Intervention. Paul: Wilder Research, 2008. Available from: http://www.
wilder.org/download.0.html?report=2173
families; Given the frequently voiced concern by both
■ Inform state and local planning and parents and professionals about the unmet
social-emotional needs of young children, Kelly Monson MA Ed, CFLE, is a State Early
policymaking; Childhood Systems Coordinator at the Minnesota
the infrastructure being developed through
■ Monitor the impact of investments and Department of Health, Community and Family
MECCS is an important step in the direction
policy choices; Health Division.
of filling this gap and improving the mental
■ Improve data quality and availability of health of all young children in Minnesota.
current and emerging indicators; and For more information about MECCS, visit
■ Expose and eliminate disparities by their website at: www.health.state.mn.us/
income and race/ethnicity...4 divs/cfh/meccs/. For more information about
the BUILD initiative, visit their website at:
Some of the indicators selected that relate
www.buildinitiative.org/
specifically to young children’s mental health
include:
■ Number/percent of children with
possible social-emotional problems
Winter 2009-2010 31
Center for Excellence in
Children’s Mental Health
Linking University and Community Experts and Resources Cari Michaels, MPH
Head Start Goals specific area and a collection of responses SPEAKERS' SERIES Center for Excellence
from providers and policymakers regarding
Since its inception, CECMH has displayed in Children’s Mental Health LESSONS
the practical application of that research. The
a strong commitment to strengthening from the FIELD 2009-2010:
first issue, “Attachment Relationships and
children’s mental health by promoting the Race, Culture and Children’s Mental Health
Adoption Outcomes,” and all subsequent
use of evidence in mental health practice
eReview issues are published on the CECMH
and policymaking. CECMH also works December 4, 2009, 9:00 a.m. – 12:30 p.m.
website (www.cmh.umn.edu).
with faculty members to promote publicly Historical Trauma, Microaggressions, and Identity: A
engaged research that is pertinent to the One of the most critical areas of CECMH Framework for Culturally Based Practice
needs of community members. work is to promote publically engaged Dr. Karina Walters
research by building partnerships between February 17, 2010, 9:00 a.m. – 12:30 p.m.
In order to engage a wide range of
research faculty and community members. Intersection of Culture and Children’s Mental Health
providers, parents and researchers in in Working with Immigrant & Refugee Families
CECMH staff bring University research
training events, CECMH sponsors an
expertise to bear on problems of significance March 18th, 2010, 9:00a.m. – 12:30 p.m.
annual Lessons from the Field seminar
to the community—facilitating the Promoting Child Well-being and Early Intervention
series that features local and national within a Cultural Context
community’s voice in guiding academic
speakers. Seminars are video-streamed Brenda Jones Harden, University of Maryland
research. One example of this work is the
live to over 30 sites in Minnesota where
CECMH’s active participation in a Cultural May 12, 2010, 1:30p.m. – 3:30 p.m.
participants view and listen to the speakers Title TBD
Providers Network of local clinicians
and participate in discussions. Each Lessons Alicia Lieberman, University of California – SF
that serves children of color. This diverse
from the Field series is organized around a
group of dedicated providers incorporates All sessions will be at the Coffman Theater, University
community-identified theme. Because of of Minnesota and broadcast to sites in Greater
research-based evidence into their work
CECMH’s strong interest in early childhood, Minnesota.
and develops new, culturally appropriate
the 2006–2008 seminars explored issues
interventions. Sponsors: Center for Excellence in Children’s
of attachment and its relationship to Mental Health in partnership with Center for
mental health, intervention, treatment CECMH is housed in the interdisciplinary Advanced Studies in Child Welfare (UMN) and Harris
methods, and intergenerational issues. The Children, Youth, and Family Consortium Programs (UMN).
2009–2010 series will focus on race, culture, (CYFC) at the University of Minnesota. For
Co-sponsors: Center for Leadership Education
and children’s mental health.This series is more information about CECMH and its in Maternal and Child Public Health (UMN), MN
co-sponsored by several partners, including projects, visit www.cmh.umn.edu or call ADOPT, Office for Equity and Diversity (UMN),
the Center for Leadership Education in (612) 625-7849. Minnesota Community Foundation-Baby Project, and
Maternal and Child Public Health. Sheltering Arms Foundation.
CECMH also disseminates current, Cari Michaels, MPH, is the Associate Director of the
applicable, and accessible research to Center for Excellence in Children’s Mental Health at
the University of Minnesota.
providers and policymakers. CECMH
For more information, visit: http://www.cmh.
eReview is an online publication that features
umn.edu/culture/workshop1.html.
a summary of published research in a
32 Healthy Generations
Culturally Sensitive, Relationship-based Practice
Promoting Infant Mental Health
Competency-based Training and Endorsement Candace Kragthorpe, MSW, IMH-E® (IV)
Training in Best Practices Professional competencies. MAIECMH outcomes, improved quality of services, and
works to advance standards in practice support for ethical practice and cultural
Infant and family professionals require among a range of professional disciplines competence.1
specialized professional development and working with infants, young children, and
consultation from infant mental health Endorsement. Professional competencies
their families. These standards are grounded are the framework for a professional
specialists to ensure service quality and in comprehensive professional competencies
effectiveness in addressing the diverse and endorsement program offered in Minnesota
based on infant mental health principles, as by MAIECMH, called Culturally Sensitive,
often complex needs of infants, young identified by the Michigan Association for
children, and families. Relationship-based Practice Promoting
Infant Mental Health (MI-AIMH). These Infant Mental Health. A number of states
The Minnesota Association for Infant principles include mutuality of caregiving across the country offer the endorsement
and Early Childhood Mental Health relationships and understanding and using program, developed and copyrighted by
(MAIECMH) is a statewide membership the rich histories, feelings, and behaviors MI-AIMH. Working with MI-AIMH,
organization whose mission is to promote that the child, parent/caregiver, and partner states, Minnesota organizations,
social and emotional development and provider/educator bring to these working and association members, MAIECMH is
mental health of children, from birth to 5 relationships. promoting and evaluating the application
years. Founded in 2007 and affiliated with Reflective practice. These principles of these competencies among a range of
the World Association for Infant Mental require that professionals actively engage practitioners, providers, and educators.
Health, MAIECMH operates as the infant in a reflective stance via supervision and
and early childhood division of MACMH The set of professional competencies can be
consultation. This reflective practice is used to:
(Minnesota Association for Children’s an integral component of interventions
Mental Health). The goals of MAIECMH provided along a continuum of care, from ■ Guide and encourage continuous
include education and advocacy to enhance promotion and prevention to intensive professional development and career
culturally sensitive interdisciplinary capacity treatment. Reflective supervision, provided planning;
to serve infants, young children, and their regularly, leads to improved family ■ Guide the development of pre-service
families. Continued on page 35
Winter 2009-2010 33
Bringing Order to the Complexity of Early
Experience The Role of Training in Infant Mental Health
Elizabeth A. Carlson, PhD, LP
E arly childhood is unique in the human life cycle for the rapidity and
complexity of developmental change and transformation.1 Typically, the
infant progresses from complete dependence upon the caregiver to a mobile,
cognitively sophisticated, self-regulating child who is capable of understanding
and participating actively in the social world.1,2 However, development in the early
years is paradoxical; it is both highly robust and highly vulnerable, with cascading
effects for later development.3
34 Healthy Generations
continued from page 33
Promoting Infant Mental Health
As one of a number of training programs and Early Childhood Mental Health 3. systems expertise
in the U.S., the University of Minnesota’s certificate program, contact Sara Zettervall 4. direct service, reflection and leadership
2-year post-baccalaureate Infant and (612-625-2252) or visit their website: skills and
Early Childhood Mental Health certificate www.cehd.umn.edu/ceed/profdev/
certificateprograms/IECMH/default.html 5. research and evaluation.
program provides a professional
development opportunity for early REFERENCES For more information
interventionists and an illustration or model
of a process-oriented approach to training.
1. Sroufe LA. (1996). Emotional development: the about endorsement:
organization of emotional life in the early years. New
The program is designed for front-line York: Cambridge University Press, 1996. Contact MAIECMH staff at 651-644-7333
service providers (e.g., public health nurses, 2. Zeanah CH (Ed.). Handbook of infant mental health, 3rd or 1-800-528-4511
edition. New York: Guilford Press, 2009.
early childhood and family educators, Continuing requirements for endorsement
child welfare workers, home visitors) and 3. Shonkoff J P, Phillips DA. From neurons to
include MAIECMH membership and 15
neighborhoods: the science of early childhood
credentialed mental health professionals development. Washington, D.C.: National Academy hours annually of related training approved
who wish to build their knowledge and skills Press, 2000. by MAIECMH. A central registry of
in early childhood mental health, dyadic or 4. Erickson MF, Kurz-Riemer K. Infants, toddlers, and endorsees and consultants is maintained at
triadic treatment, and reflective consultation. families: a framework for support and intervention. New
the MACMH office, 165 Western Avenue
York: Guilford Press, 1999.
The Institute of Child Development, the North, Suite 2, St. Paul, MN 55102
academic home of the program, offers 5. Korfmacher J, Hilado A. Creating a workforce in early
childhood mental health: defining the competent
graduate credits applicable to advanced specialist. Research Report from the Herr Research
REFERENCES
degrees; alternatively, participants may Center for Children and Social Policy at Erikson 1. Lamb-Parker F, LeBuffe P. A strength-based, systemic
complete the program for professional Institute, 2008. Available from: http://www.erikson.edu/ mental health approach to support childen’s social and
hrc emotional development. Infants & Young Children
continuing education units. 2008;21(1):45-55.
6. Weatherston DJ, Dowler Moss B, Harris D. Building
capacity in the infant and family field through 2. MAIECMH Endorsement for Culturally Sensitive,
competency-based endorsement: three states’ Relationship-based Practice Promoting Infant Mental
experiences. Zero to Three 2006; 26(3):4-13. Health. Available from: http://www.macmh.org/
…the professional development of skilled maiecmhweb/2PageEndorsemntFlyer.pdf
workers, teachers, and interventionists in 7. Fraiberg S. Clinical studies in infant mental health. New
York: Basic Books, 1980.
early childhood requires a transformation
Candace Kragthorpe, MSW, IMH-E® (IV), is Director
or shift in understanding of the nature of the Minnesota Association for Infant and Early
Elizabeth A. Carlson, PhD, LP, is Director of the
of early experience and its role in later Harris Programs and is a Research Associate at
Childhood Mental Health (MAIECMH), a Division of
functioning. MACMH.
the Institute of Child Development, University of
Minnesota.
Winter 2009-2010 35
Interested in Making a Difference?
Consider a Master’s in Public Health (MPH) degree in Maternal and Child Health (MCH)
F or Lauren Gilchrist, a typical day at work always has “an exciting element of
the unexpected.” Gilchrist is a health policy advisor for Minnesota Senator Al
Franken. As the nation is engaged in a debate about health care reform, it is not
surprising that Capitol Hill would provide a stimulating professional venue for
this recent MCH Master's of Public Health graduate.
“The hands-on experience and historical And I use that as a way to evaluate policy
perspective on policy as a strategy for public opportunities, and to frame ideas that we
health” that Gilchrist received through are thinking of putting forth or supporting
Jean Forster’s legislative advocacy classes ideas that other folks have put forth.”
gave her a way to pull all of her skills Gilchrist’s work with Senator Franken is
together. During her MCH training, she a good fit because the health of women
spent a semester working with the state and children throughout the life course
legislature at the Children’s Defense Fund are among his policy priorities. According
A native of Rochester, Minnesota, home of Minnesota. Through that experience she
of the world-renowned Mayo Clinic, to Gilchrist, “maternal and child health
realized that public policy work was a good issues are critically important when we are
Gilchrist grew up believing that people fit for her skills and personality.
“deserve a high standard of health care designing public health programs…and
and health status.” After graduating from After receiving her MPH in 2007, Gilchrist policy. Also, when we are looking at health
Wesleyan University, Gilchrist pursued this worked as the Outreach Director for the care reform, we want to make sure…that
view, working for several years in direct Deborah E. Powell Center for Women’s everything we do is in the best interest of
services with underserved communities. Health at the University of Minnesota, maternal and child health because we know
That experience gave Gilchrist perspective where she planned programs to promote that those investments have the greatest
about the day-to-day challenges confronting the health of women and girls. In 2008, pay-off in the long run.”
disenfranchised people. To Gilchrist, Gilchrist received a one-year Health Policy Gilchrist’s future goals in her position
“direct services were rarely getting to the Fellowship from the Association of Schools are “to pass national health care reform
root of problems…I felt like I was putting of Public Health. Her placement with the and make sure it is implemented in
band-aids on things instead of helping late Senator Ted Kennedy on the U.S. Senate a way that will be most beneficial to
problems be resolved or improved in a Committee for Health, Labor, Education, Minnesotans.” Additionally, Gilchrist
larger sense.” and Pensions helped her transition from hopes to “continue to make our country
designing public health programs and a more prevention-focused place,” so that
Gilchrist pursued a degree in public health working on state policy to working on
because she wanted to use research and discussions about health care reform are a
policy at the federal level. jumping-off point for a movement towards
policy as tools to make systemic changes to
improve people’s lives. Through the MCH After her Fellowship Gilchrist began work health promotion, health maintenance, and
Program at the University of Minnesota, with Minnesota Senator Al Franken. Her addressing barriers to optimal health at the
Gilchrist was able to take classes about position offers “a great opportunity… to be community level.
the health of children and families and tied to what is going on…in [Washington] Learn more about getting an MPH in
develop strong analytic and quantitative D.C…and at the same time…work on Maternal and Child Health, visit:
skills through the program’s epidemiology Minnesota issues.” Gilchrist spends her
time meeting with Minnesota constituents, www.sph.umn.edu/education/mch/home.
emphasis curriculum.
collaborating with other Senate offices, and html
Particularly influential in her current work drafting and evaluating original legislation email: Kathryn Schwartz,
as a policy advisor are the skills Gilchrist to develop and support policies that will schwa139@umn.edu
gained in epidemiology and program “enhance the health of Minnesotans.”
evaluation as a student in the MCH Gilchrist’s experiences as a Minnesotan, a
program. Her training in epidemiology gave public health professional, and a specialist
Gilchrist the “ability to look critically at in maternal and child health give her a
research” and assess its quality. The skills she unique perspective on health policy: “I look
developed in program evaluation help her at everything through a Minnesota lens,
to determine if a policy has accountability. a public health lens, and…an MCH lens.
36 Healthy Generations
Website Resources for Early Childhood Mental Health
In addition to the websites identified in this issue’s articles, the following list provides additional select web resources related to early childhood
mental health and social-emotional development.
American Academy of Pediatrics advocates at the federal and state National Center for Children in Poverty at Columbia University’s
level for children’s mental health as well as provides informational resources Mailman School of Public Health, conducts research on states’ efforts to
to parents and professionals about the behavioral and mental health of infants maximize polices to provide services that effectively promote social and
and young children. www.aap.org emotional development in early childhood, particularly for at-risk children.
www.nccp.org
Bright Futures is a national initiative that seeks to strengthen the
connection between state and local programs, health and service providers, National Early Childhood Technical Assistance Center (NECTAC)
and families through cross-agency training and distance-learning curricula is supported by the U.S. Department of Education’s Office of Special
related to children’s mental health. www.brightfutures.org Education Programs to strengthen service systems to ensure that children with
disabilities (birth through 5 years) and their families receive and benefit from
Center for Early Education and Development (CEED) and the Irving high quality, culturally appropriate, and family-centered supports and services.
B. Harris Training Center for Infant and Toddler Development at the University www.nectac.org
of Minnesota support the social-emotional development of young children
throughout Minnesota through applied research on infant mental health, Social and Emotional Development in Children and Adolescents–
trainings to help educators address challenging behaviors, and outreach to MCH Knowledge Path offers a selection of recent scientific research
promote quality early child care. www.cehd.umn.edu/ceed about the promotion of healthy social and emotional development in young
children as well as tools for keeping up-to-date with new research. http://www.
Center on Social and Emotional Foundations of Early Learning mchlibrary.info/knowledgepaths/kp_mental_healthy.html
(CSEFEL) is a national resource center that provides training materials,
videos, and print resources to help early child care, health, and education Technical Assistance Center on Social Emotional Interventions
providers implement the Pyramid Model for Supporting Social Emotional (TACSEI) translates research on effective practices for improving the social
Competence in Infants and Young Children. www.vanderbilt.edu/csefel and emotional health outcomes for young children into free products and
resources to help caregivers and service providers apply best practices in their
Georgetown University Center for Child and Human everyday work. www.challengingbehavior.org
Development provides national technical assistance, trainings, and policy
resources, and conducts research and evaluation to address mental health Zero to Three provides resources for parents and professionals on
needs of young children. www.gucchd.georgetown.edu social-emotional development and mental health of young children as well as
information for policymakers and advocates on relevant public policy initiatives
Minnesota Association for Family and Early Education (MNAFEE) and advocacy opportunities. www.zerotothree.org
is a membership organization that offers professional development meetings,
conferences, and networking opportunities to providers and coordinators of
early childhood education throughout Minnesota. www.mnafee.org