Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
The NPSA (2007) report that 71% of fatal and serious harm from medication Reason (1990) devised the Swiss chees
incidents are due to: ■ Unclear prescriptions model, which likens the occurrence of
■ The wrong dose being written drug errors to a stack of Swiss cheese
■ The wrong frequency being prescribed ■ The drug being omitted slices. The holes in the slices of Swiss
cheese represent a minor error. The holes
■ The medicine being delayed.
may allow a problem to pass through to
Over half of all drug errors relate to dosage, strength, frequency or a failure to
the next layer, but it can be stopped as the
administer; therefore, ‘omission or failure to administer a drug, which could
holes in the next layer of
compromise patient safety, unless appropriate’ should be added to the above quote.
Other drug errors include the wrong quantity being prescribed, the drug being
intended for another patient, poor labelling and storage, and out-of-date drugs.
cheese are in different places. Therefore,
the more minor errors there are, the
Table 1. The five ‘R’s of safe drug administration
greater the likelihood of a major error
getting through. Each layer, therefore, is a Number R Information
defence against an error becoming
1 Right patient Ensure medications are administered to the
realised and affecting the outcome. In
correct patient by checking the wristband
relation to the journey from prescribing to
administration, this model explains how 2 Right drug The prescription of a drug should be clear and
errors occur if each stage is allowed to legible. The generic name, and not the trade
progress without appropriate defences name, should be used (unless appropriate).
being put in place. Highlight any antiobiotics allergies on the
Most medication errors go unreported wristband as well as on the drug chart
(Nursing and Midwifery Council 3 Right dosage Check the name of the drug against the dosage
(NMC), 2007). According to NPSA of the medication to be administered
(2007), the most serious medication
incidents reported are caused by errors in 4 Right time A drug needs to be administered at the
administration (41%) and to a lesser appropriate time(s) for effective outcomes
extent, prescribing (32%). Fortunately, the (antibiotics, for example)
majority of medication incidents reported 5 Right route Some drugs cannot be administered by the oral
have clinical outcomes of no or low harm.
route (GTN or insulin, for example). Others have
Two groups of patients are particularly
to be administered IV for 100% bioavailability
vulnerable to medication errors (Barber,
2013): children, who are three times more GTN: glyceryl trinitrate; IV: intravenous
likely than the average adult to be subject
Choo et al (2010) argues that these rights a visual reminder such as a ‘do not
to a medication error (owing mainly to the
fail to reflect human, system and disturb’ message (Pape et al, 2005),
complex calculations required), and
environmental factors—the key causes of whereby patients and staff are discouraged
patients with known allergies.
drug errors. from disturbing a nurse who is
administering medications. However, the
Causes of drug errors
Environment The literature suggests that effectiveness of this intervention in
The five ‘Rs’ (Table 1) were put into
many medication errors are related to reducing human factor errors has not
place in an attempt to reduce drug errors
human error and environmental factors, been thoroughly researched.
(Barber, 2013). Other rights include the
since drug administration often takes The quality of team communication has
right reason and documentation (Elliott
place in noisy environments with poor been linked to improvements in patient
and Liu, 2010). Elliott and Liu (2010)
lighting (Jones, 2009) (Table 2). Fry and outcomes (Institute of Healthcare
argue that the quality of drug
Dacey (2007) suggest that to reduce Communication, 2011). Therefore,
administration or occurrence of a
human and environmental error, such as conceivably, any links to a reduction in
medication error are not solely a matter of
distractions, protected time during medication errors, owing the use of a
adhering to the five ‘R’s. Jones (2009)
medication administration could be tabard or reminders, is more likely to
states that the use of checklists such as the
introduced. This includes the use of a occur because of an improvement in team
five ‘R’s does not fully address the issues
bright tabard (Hitchen, 2008) or the use of communication, as all team members are
related to the causes of medication errors.
© 2015 MA Healthcare Ltd
aware a drug round is being performed, Healthcare Research and Quality (2014), of being accused of or causing a drug
thus reducing distractions. the consequences for nurses who report error.
Attempts to reduce medication errors medication errors (such as suspension However, combining the 5 ‘Rs’ with an
owing to faulty system factors have from work, disciplinary action, or being understanding of the causes of drug errors
included the introduction of information reported to the NMC for misconduct) can (owing to factors in the environment,
technologies, such as computerized be an issue. culture and performance) enables the five
physician order entry, bar-coding of ‘Rs’ to be implemented correctly. In
drugs, and automated dispensing devices Performance Nurses can further reduce addition, by ensuring all multi-disciplinary
(Bates, 2000). Fowler et al (2009) human factors in medication errors teams involved in medication
suggest that technology can improve (leading to morbidity and mortality in management are aware of combining the
patient safety, but further study is hospitalized patients) by keeping their five ‘Rs’ with the knowledge of the causes
required to determine the impact of these skills up to date (Sneck et al, 2015). of drug errors can further enhance the
technologies on the reduction of Regular or annual updates for nurses effectiveness of using the five ‘R’s
Table 2. Causes of medication errors
Human errors Faulty system errors Environmental errors
Poor calculation or competence, Unclear error reporting processes, Distractions from other nurses
or lack of confidence which provide no clear definitions of or patients (which can be hard
medication errors and near-miss to ignore)
events
Poor adherence to prescription/ Limited or no easily accessible Lack of awareness of when and where
administration protocols resources, such as electronic an error can occur
databases, to research
unfamiliar drugs
Poor knowledge of medications Lack of staff, poor management Poor lighting on night shifts
or leadership, or lack of funds
Complacency, misconceptions Ambiguous protocols, policies and Busy ward
or incorrect interpretations procedure guidelines for prescribing
and drug administration
Misinterpretation of packaging Drug companies’ packaging not clearly Noisy environments
information (‘not for oral use,’ marked or labelled
for example)
Fatigue, inexperience Lack of training and no regular updates Time pressures
or poor communication or courses provided
Medical professionals’ poor Poor teamwork Increase in nurses’ workload
handwriting or unclear prescriptions
medication errors (Durham, 2015). approach in error prevention.
verify that they are competent in This article introduces five new ‘R’s to
Culture medication administration and have consider, which incorporate an integrated
Information regarding the prevention and theoretical knowledge and drug multi-disciplinary approach, supported by
reduction of medicine errors is widely calculation skills. The implementation of evidence.
available (Bates, 2007). There is a need to these updates allow policies and
immediately report all nearmisses and procedures to represent nurses as
medication errors, regardless of whether a autonomous knowledgeable
patient has been harmed, to ensure a practitioners, who are able to use their
learning experience (Armitage, 2008). own clinical judgement without the fear
However, according to the Agency for
© 2015 MA Healthcare Ltd
Multi-disciplinary, team, prescribing journey, from drug companies, There is a need for a multi-disciplinary
packaging designers, doctors, pharmacists, approach as advocated by the NPC’s
and evidence- based nurses, paramedics, the patient, and policy (2012) prescribing competencies for
approach and procedure makers (Table 3). clinicians. This requires an inclusive
In today’s complex health-care system, in The competence framework (NPC, process that can be utilized by all health
which patients can access a number of 2012) considers nine areas of competence, professionals involved in the process of
health professionals, there is a need for a including participation in the review, the drug administration, providing
streamlined approach. This idea has been development of prescribing to optimize opportunity for reasoning and autonomy.
Table 3. A medication error can occur from preparation to outcome
Stage in the drug’s journey Responsibility Relationship to the five ‘R’s
Chemical preparation Drug companies Drug
and drug naming
Packaging Packaging companies and drug Drug, route
label designers
Prescribing and transcribing Doctor, nurse prescriber or the nurse Drug, patient, time, route, dosage
checking drugs
Preparing (in the ward Formulation prepared by pharmacist— Drug, dosage, route, patient
and community) liquid form, tablet form or IV
Dispensing Pharmacist from pharmacy to ward Drug, dosage, route, patient
or community setting
Omission, failure to administer, Refusal to administer drug by health Drug, dosage, route, patient
or increase or decrease in period professional, or refusal to take the drug
of time between drugs by the patient
Administration Nurse, doctor or non-medical Drug, patient, route, dosage
professional
Providing medication advice Nurse, doctor or non-medical Not applicable
professional
Monitoring, outcome and response Nurse, doctor, pharmacist Not applicable
or paramedic
IV: intravenous
recognized by the National Prescribing patient outcomes, reporting prescribing In addition to the five ‘R’s’, which nurses
Centre (NPC, 2012), which has developed errors and near-misses, and acting upon at the bedside and other health
a single competency framework for all colleagues’ inappropriate prescribing professionals can use to safely manage a
prescribers—its ethos is that all health using appropriate mechanisms. Yet, drug(s) episode, five additional ‘Rs’ are
professionals are involved in drug Durham (2015) highlights that nurses may proposed. The ten ‘R’s approach embraces
administration. not be aware of a near-miss event or what a broader, holistic, integrative multi-
The NPC framework makes it clear that constitutes a medication error, implying disciplinary view and encompasses the
the administration of drugs and the that Sneck et al’s (2015) proposal of NPC’s guidelines.
occurrence of medication errors is not the regular medication updates may be
sole responsibility of nurses at the attractive.
There is general agreement for
Modifying practice:
bedside; it is a team effort, in which all
members work together to ensure safe strategies to be put in place to reduce enhancing safety,
practice. Reduction in medication errors is medication errors, and these are generally reducing drug errors
the responsibility of all those involved in specific to each professional group The occurence of a drug error may not
the preparation of medicines the involved in medication management. relate solely to human, system or
© 2015 MA Healthcare Ltd
environmental error, but a combination a prescribed drug, as nurses should not per minute. These issues question the
of them all. To ensure a thoughtlessly obey ‘orders’. policies and procedures, which may fail to
multiprofessional, evidence-based and If the prescription has been incorrectly represent the nurses as autonomous and
streamlined approach to reducing errors, written, the prescription is ambiguous, or knowledgeable practitioners, who are able
five more rights (‘R’s) are put forward: the nurse doubts the legitimacy of the to use their own clinical judgement in
■ The right to refuse (patient and nurse, prescription, the nurse has a right not to such situations without the fear of being
including autonomy) give or administer the drug to the patient. accused of a drug error. With the increase
■ Knowledge and understanding However, problems can arise here—if a in independent prescribing by disciplines
nurse omits or fails to administer a drug or other than in the medical profession,
■ Right questions (including reason)
does not give it at the correct time, these nurses may find themselves administering
■ Right response (including drugs prescribed by non-medical
incidences can constitute a medication
documentation) ■ Right error, and the nurse is placed in a difficult prescribers (pharmacists, physiotherapists
advice. position. If nurses refuse to administer a and other nurses, for example), which
drug on the grounds that the prescription may add to the complex nature of patient
6. The right to refuse (patient
is inappropriately written, or if an management and the right to refuse.
and administrator)
inappropriate preparation is to be given,
The current five ‘R’s fail to consider the
this may also constitute a drug error. 7. Right knowledge and
intricacies associated with administering
According to the NMC (2015), understanding
medications in more complex settings; for
medicine administration should be The seventh ‘R’ regards in-depth
example, when a patient refuses to take a
evidence-based, so nurses can refuse or knowledge and understanding of (Table
prescribed medication. The patient may
omit a drug, referring to sound 4): ■ The naming of a drug
have a difficulty in taking the medicine
evidencebased practice, yet can still be ■ How the body affects the drug
(such as trouble with swallowing) or they
accused of a drug error. For example, the (pharmacokinetics)
may not perceive the need for the
refusal of potassium supplements on the ■ How the drug affects the body
medication. A sixth right is implied: the
grounds that the patient’s potassium level
right of the patient to refuse a drug. (pharmacodynamics)
is too high (by checking daily blood
The right to refuse can also incorporate
results) or the refusal of digoxin, as the ■ Side-effects of drugs
the right of a nurse to refuse to administer
apex and redial pulses were below 60
beats
patient. For example, has the correct considering the frequency of dosing and swallowing, as crushing of drugs should
prescription, with clear unambiguous specific timings of drug administration. not be the norm. Is the drug being used
instructions, been written up? Dosing For example, a slowrelease preparation appropriately or is it to treat a side-effect
schedules, formulation and the exact may be given less frequently and may of a medication the patient is already
nature of the condition being treated (‘is also cause fewer side-effects. Is the taking that could be dealt with by
the drug being given for the right formulation the most appropriate for the considering another group of drugs?
reason(s)?’) should also be considered. patient? The very young and elderly may
Concordance can be improved by require liquid preparations for ease of
for example). Importantly, this ‘R’ is also for all health professionals to employ a restrict the professional’s ability to make
concerned with the safety of using the broader, holistic understanding of autonomous decisions. The inclusion of
drug in the individual patient. Has any medication management, as no single discretion in medication administration,
harm come to the patient (allergy, adverse health professional group is responsible as in the 10 ‘R’s approach, values the
effect, drug interaction, or side-effects, for for all drug errors. complex thought processes required,
example)? A drug error can occur at any stage of which can be beneficial to prescribing
The right response, again, is the the drug’s journey from preparation and and non-prescribing professionals and
responsibility of all health professionals prescription to outcome (Table 3). Elliott patients, to ensure safe practice is
involved with medicines management. and Liu (2010) suggest that only a small maintained.
This includes the documentation of proportion (between 26 and 38%) of Visual reminders have been used as a
medicines prescribed and administered, a errors are nursing-related. means to guide medication
review of the patient and their response to Therefore, a majority (between 62 and administration (Pape et al, 2005).
the medicine. All should form an integral 74%) of medication errors are due to other Hospitals, community health care, GPs,
part of the written record to provide factors. ambulance services, and pharmacies can
continuity of care across the team caring All doctors, and prescribing and non- display the ten ‘R’s as a benchmark to
for the patient. In addition, the right prescribing professionals including nurses, good practice of safe drug
response is about recording and notifying must aim to provide safe medication administration’ (Table 5) as a prompt, to
relevant parties about adverse drug administration, which is based on encourage compliance with the ‘R’s and
reactions or interactions, so that evidence of the purpose of the prescribed improve the safety of medication
documentation can be updated in relation drug(s), what the body does to the drug administration.
to allergy status if appropriate. and the action of the drug on the body.
In relation to public health, it is also The NMC (2015) advises on nurses Conclusion
necessary to inform the Medicines and should only prescribe, advise about or Part of the nurse’s role is the
Healthcare products Regulatory Agency provide treatment or medicines if they administering of drugs, which should be
(MHRA) of significant adverse affects to have enough knowledge about the carried out in compliance with the five
drugs through the Yellow Card system person’s health and are sure that the ‘R’s. It is increasingly common for
(Joint Formulary Committee, 2015). treatment or medicine serves the person’s experienced, suitably qualified nurses and
Finally, the right response is concerned health needs. In addition, a nurse must allied health professionals to prescribe
with ‘safety netting’—nurses, doctors and make sure that the advice given takes into drugs too, but the journey from chemical
other prescribing and non-prescribing account other care the person is receiving; preparation to prescribing, to
professionals should explain to a patient thus, drug administration is a holistic administering, to determining outcome is
what they should do if progress is not as episode of care. complex, fraught with dangers, and a drug
expected with their medicines and what This paper takes a multi-professional error could be due to more than just the
action they should take. This information approach to drug administration and the wrong drug being prescribed or the wrong
should also be recorded in the patient’s prevention of drug errors, and dose being calculated.
notes. recommends the 10 ‘Rs’ as a benchmark Understanding of nomenclature,
to multi-professional safe drug pharmaceutics, pharmacokinetics,
Discussion administration (Table 5). It includes pharmacodynamics, therapeutics are
The standardized five ‘R’s, advocated by considerations to follow before the drug essential for all involved. Thus, no
the NMC (2006; 2007), are adequate for round, during preparation, immediately health professional should administer a
nurses to incorporate into their care at the before administration and afterwards. drug if they do not know what it is for,
bedside to facilitate safe administration of These considerations are flexible and are not able to explain it to the patient,
medication. However, the NPC encompass the need to include do not understand the outcome of its
framework (2012) makes it clear that the professionals’ thinking during administration or are unable to notice the
responsibility for managing the medication administration. side-effects. Drug administration is not a
environment in which drug administration Lawton and Parker (1999), and simple task; it demands clinical
takes place, and reducing the possibility Eisenhauer et al (2007), recognized that judgement before and during
of drug errors, is a multi-disciplinary administering drugs extends beyond preparation, immediately before
concern. Therefore, there is a requirement protocols, policies or checklists, which administration and afterwards.
are considered not to be useful, as they
© 2015 MA Healthcare Ltd
This paper puts forward a proposal to Fowler SB, Sohler P, Zarillo DF (2009) Bar-code
technology for medication administration:
merge the five ‘R’s with the knowledge of
Medication errors and nurse satisfaction.
the causes of drug errors, to broaden Medsurg Nurs 18(2): 103–9
perspectives to the idea of medication Fry MM, Dacey C (2007) Factors contributing to
management as a muli-professional, incidents in medicine administration: Part 2. Br
evidence-based endeavour. This involves J Nurs 16(11): 676–81
merging the understanding of the causes Hitchen L (2008) Frequent interruptions linked to
of errors, and the strategies to reduce them drug errors. BMJ 336(7654): 1155. doi: 10.1136/
bmj.39584.477951.DB
accumulated so far, with the original five
Institute for Healthcare Communication (2011)
‘R’s, with consideration to a further five Impact of communication in healthcare. http://
‘R’s, to give a ten ‘R’s approach. The ten healthcarecomm.org/about-us/impact-
‘R’s can serve all disciplines involved in ofcommunication-in-healthcare (accessed
medication episodes and provide a 14 July 2015)
benchmark for good practice that is based Jones SW (2009) Reducing medication
administration errors in nursing practice. Nurs
on sound knowledge and evidence. Stand 23(50): 40–6
Lawton R, Parker D (1999) Procedures and the
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (2014) professional: The case of the British NHS.
Hospital survey on patient safety culture: 2014 Soc Sci Med 48(3): 353–61
user comparative database report. www.
National Patients Safety Agency (2007) Safety in
ahrq.gov/professionals/quality-patient-safety/
doses: Medication safety incidents in the NHS.
patientsafetyculture/hospital/2014/ (accessed
www.nrls.npsa.nhs.uk/EasySiteWeb/getresource.
14 July 2015)
axd?AssetID=61392 (accessed 14 July 2015)
Armitage G (2008) How do we reduce drug errors? National Prescribing Centre (2012) A single
Nursing Times www.nursingtimes.net/how-dowe- competency framework for all prescribers. http://
reduce-drug-errors/524579.article (accessed tinyurl.com/o3a2ta8 (accessed 14 July 2015)
14 July 2015)
Nursing and Midwifery Council (2006) Standards of
Barber P, ed (2013) Medicine Management for proficiency for nurse and midwife prescribers.
Nurses: Case Book. McGraw-Hill Education, http://bit.ly/1PAs49y (accessed 14 July 2015)
Maidenhead
Nursing and Midwifery Council (2007) Standards for
Bates D (2007) Preventing medication errors: medicines management. www.nmc.org.uk/
A summary. Am J Health Syst Pharm 64(14 globalassets/siteDocuments/NMC-Publications/
Suppl 9): S3–9 NMC-Standards-for-medicines-management.pdf
Bates DW (2000) Using information technology to (accessed 14 July 2015)
reduce rates of medication errors in hospitals. Nursing and Midwifery Council (2015) The Code:
BMJ 320(7237): 788–91 Professional standards of practice and behaviour
Berry D, Courtenay M, Bersellini E (2006) Attitudes for nurses and midwives. www.
towards, and information needs in relation to nmc.org.uk/globalassets/sitedocuments/ nmc-
supplementary nurse prescribing in the UK: J publications/revised-new-nmc-code.pdf
Clin Nurs 15(1): 22–8 (accessed 14 July 2015)
Joint Formulary Committee (2015) British National Pape TM, Guerra DM, Muzquiz M (2005) Innovative
Formulary (online). London: BMJ Group and approaches to reducing nurses’ distractions
Pharmacuetical Press. http://tinyurl.com/ ou27t5p during medication administration. J Contin Educ
(accessed 14 July 2015) Nurs 36(3): 108–16
Choo J, Hutchinson A, Bucknall T (2010) Nurses’ Reason J (1990) Human error. Cambridge University
role in medication safety. J Nurs Manage 18(7): Press, Cambridge
853-861. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2834.2010.01164.x Sneck S, Isola A, Saarnio R (2015) Nurses’
Crouch S, Chapplehow C (2008) Medicines perception of verification of medication
Management: A Nursing Perspective. Pearson competence. Journal of Nursing Education
Education, Harlow and Practice 5(6): 114–22. doi: 10.5430/jnep.
Eisenhauer LA, Hurley AC, Dolan N (2007) Nurses’ v5n6p114
reported thinking during medication
administration. J Nurs Scholarsh 39(1): 82–7.
doi: 10.1111/j.1547-5069.2007.00148.x
Elliott M, Liu Y (2010) The nine rights of
medication administration: An overview. Br J
Nurs 19(5): 300–5
Durham B (2015) The nurse’s role in medication
safety. Nursing 45(4): 1–4
© 2015 MA Healthcare Ltd