Sie sind auf Seite 1von 24

Video Shorts New V2 Simulations Cases, Articles, Chapters, New Online Course:

p. 2 Coming Soon & eLearning IT for Management


p. 2 p. 4 back cover

TEACHING MATERIALS
NEWSLETTER

SPRING 2012

Partner Case Collections


Case Collection Grows with The Harvard Business Publishing

Addition of New Partners case catalog has added hundreds of


cases from partner case collections.
Collections include:
HARVARD BUSINESS PUBLISHING has long been a major distributor of cases from
eminent case-writing institutions. Over the last few years, Harvard Business Babson College
More than 100 cases with a strong emphasis on
Publising has added hundreds of cases from content partners, including our newest
Entrepreneurship, General Management, Organiza-
partner collection, NACRA—the North American Case Research Association. tional Behavior, and Strategy. The collection covers
smaller businesses well, and many cases reflect a
NACRA is a nonprofit organization of approximately 500 researchers, case multidisciplinary approach.
writers, and teachers, primarily in business disciplines. It provides a forum for
Business Enterprise Trust
members’ ideas on case teaching and their latest case projects, including the
A small group of cases on social responsibility topics.
quarterly Case Research Journal.
Darden School of Business, University of Virginia
For several reasons, NACRA cases are highly valued by case method instructors.
More than 1,000 cases from a leading case-producing
Nearly all cases are based on field research, not public material. All cases undergo institution. The Darden collection spans all major
a double-blind peer review process involving at least two academics. Most cases disciplines but is notable for the large number of
have been class-tested by their authors. Finally, every NACRA case comes with a recent cases in Finance and current Industry and
Background Notes.
Teaching Note—also subjected to a double-blind peer review.
Design Management Institute
Harvard Business Publishing has recently added to its catalog more than 50
A small set of cases focused mainly on topics
NACRA titles in a range of disciplines, including Entrepreneurship, Finance, related to industrial design.
Strategy, Accounting, Marketing, and Social Enterprise. A number of the cases
focus on ethical issues. Nearly all have been published since 2005. Global Health Delivery/Harvard Medical School
A set of cases, each under 20 pages, focused on
New partners will be added to the case collection in coming months. Check the real issues in global health situations. Available at no
cost to registered Premium Educators on our web
Educators’ web site for updates: hbsp.harvard.edu.
site, these cases are designed to increase access to
training in global health delivery.

Harvard Kennedy School of Government


Approximately 400 titles that emphasize political
and governmental contexts. Many cases are appli-
cable to standard business disciplines, including
International Business, General Management, and
Strategy, as well as Social Enterprise.

See more collections on p. 3.

Î S IGN UP FOR ONLINE DELIVERY OF THIS NEWSLETTER: hbsp.harvard.edu


COMING
SOON
Video Shorts
FREE VIDEOS TO SHOW IN CLASS
V2 Simulations
VIDEO SHORTS are free videos, all under 10 minutes long, that illustrate a case’s central ENHANCED TEACHABILITY
learning objective. Intended solely for displaying inside the classroom, the streaming
video is available at no cost to registered Premium Educators at hbsp.harvard.edu.
Harvard Business Publishing
is improving some of its most
popular simulations.

NEW DESIGN: The user experience is updated


so that students can analyze information and
make decisions quickly and easily.

Popular cases with Video Shorts include: NEW TEACHING MATERIALS: Updated Teach-
ing Notes reduce the time required to learn
ENTREPRENEURSHIP Dove: Evolution of a Brand each simulation and prepare for class.
MAC Development Corp. #508047
#802140 NEW DYNAMIC DEBRIEF SLIDES: Instructors
Harrah’s Entertainment, Inc. can download presentation-ready debrief
#502011 slides populated with class results.
FINANCE
Millegan Creek Apartments Starbucks: Delivering Customer Service
#395118 #504016
COMING THIS SPRING:
Real Property Negotiation Game:
OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
Lender Case, Porus Bank Strategic Innovation Simulation:
Big Bazaar
#209031 Back Bay Battery V2
#606099
Students must balance financial goals with
GENERAL MANAGEMENT the need to innovate while guarding against
ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR
HCL Technologies (A) disruptive technologies. #7015
#408004
Anne Mulcahy: Leading Xerox
Through the Perfect Storm (A)
McKinsey & Co.: Managing #405050 Supply Chain Management
Knowledge and Learning Simulation: Root Beer Game V2
#396357
King Arthur Flour
#407012 Students play four roles in a root beer supply
chain and experience the “bullwhip” effect in
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY this version of the classic Beer Game. #6619
STRATEGY
Buckman Laboratories (A)
#800160
Academia Barilla
#507001 Marketing Simulation: Managing
CareGroup Segments and Customers V2
#303097
Tanishq: Positioning to Capture
Students develop a business-to-business
the Indian Woman’s Heart
#507025 marketing strategy by targeting specific
MARKETING customer segments. #7018
Aqualisa Quartz: Simply a Better See a full list of cases with Video Shorts:
Shower
#502030 hbsp.harvard.edu/list/videoshorts

Î NOT A PREMIUM EDUCATOR? APPLY ONLINE: educatoraccess.hbsp.harvard.edu

2 | SPRING 2012 Teaching Materials Newsletter


Partner Case Collections
...continued from p. 1

HEC Montréal Kellogg School of Management, “


A small set of cases in MIS/Information Northwestern University IN THIS ISSUE
Technology. More than 300 titles covering all major
disciplines, with a strong concentration in 01 CASE COLLECTION GROWS
IESE Business School, University of Navarra Marketing and many titles in Finance,
Approximately 80 titles, most focused on Operations, and Strategy.
01 PARTNER CASE COLLECTIONS
European firms, with strong emphasis in
General Management, Marketing, Strategy, NACRA Case Research Journal
and Organizational Behavior. Most are More than 50 titles in disciplines including 02 NEW V2 SIMULATIONS
accompanied by a Teaching Note. Entrepreneurship, Finance, Strategy,
Accounting, Marketing, and Social Enterprise.
02 VIDEO SHORTS
IMD (International Institute for A number focus on ethical issues. Nearly all
Management Development) have been published since 2005 and all have
More than 200 titles, most focused on Euro- Teaching Notes. 04 NEW CASES, ARTICLES & BOOKS
pean companies, with special emphasis on
Social Enterprise Knowledge 04 Accounting
General Management, Organizational Behavior,
and Strategy. Many cases are relatively brief Network (SEKN) 05 Business Ethics
and most have a Teaching Note. These cases in Social Enterprise were
06 Business & Government Relations
developed by member schools in the Latin
Indian Institute of Management— American Case Consortium. Most cases 07 Economics
Bangalore are available in both English and either
A small collection of cases on India and sur- Spanish or Portuguese and nearly all have 08 Entrepreneurship
rounding countries. IIMB cases are especially Teaching Notes.
09 Finance
notable for presenting the perspectives
of companies and protagonists based in Stanford Graduate School of Business 10 General Management
the India region, as opposed to the more Nearly 1,000 titles with special emphasis on
11 Human Resource Management
common view of Western firms attempting modern technology firms, with many cases
to build businesses abroad. All come with a in Strategy, Marketing, Entrepreneurship, and 11 Information Technology
Teaching Note. Supply Chain Management. The Stanford
collection also contains many Background 12 International Business
INSEAD and Industry Notes.
13 Marketing
A small collection of cases, many focused on
European businesses, emphasizing General Thunderbird School of Global Management 15 Negotiation
Management, Organizational Behavior, and More than 100 cases, the vast majority 16 Operations Management
Strategy. Several cases explicitly facilitate complemented by Teaching Notes. The
analysis via the perspective explained in the collection emphasizes International Business 17 Organizational Behavior
best-selling Harvard Business Review Press and most are under 20 pages.
book Blue Ocean Strategy.
18 Sales
Tsinghua University 19 Service Management
Ivey School of Business, A small, developing collection of materials
University of Western Ontario 19 Social Enterprise
from a premier business school in China,
More than 1,500 titles, nearly two-thirds focused on Chinese companies. 20 Strategy
complemented by Teaching Notes, covering
the full range of academic disciplines. Many University of Hong Kong
are focused on Canadian firms but a growing 23 CONTACT INFORMATION
More than 400 titles spanning all major
proportion of titles cover Asia. Many are disciplines. Most cases examine Asian
appropriate for undergraduates. businesses and many are notable for BC IT FOR MANAGEMENT ONLINE
coverage of business-government relations COURSE
and international and cross-cultural issues.
Roughly 80 percent of the cases have
Teaching Notes.

See a full list of partner case


collections:
hbsp.harvard.edu/list/partners

hbsp.harvard.edu 1-800-545-7685 | 3
NEWLY
ÎC ASES
ÎA RTICLES

RELEASED
ÎC HAPTERS
Îe LEARNING

ACCOUNTING Kanebo Ltd. (A) Risk Management at Wellfleet Bank:


David F. Hawkins, Suraj Srinivasan, All That Glitters Is Not Gold
Alfred Brooks Menswear Limited Akiko Kanno, Lizzie Gomez Anette Mikes
James E. Hatch, Steven Cox Harvard Business School Case Harvard Business School Case
TN Product #111037 (16 pages) TN Product #110011 (16 pages)
Richard Ivey School of Business
Foundation Case The case speculates how Japanese companies Inspired by one of the few banks that suc-
TN Product #989B55 (18 pages)N cessfully weathered the 2007–2009 credit
might implement IFRS, with particular
emphasis on consolidation accounting. crisis, the case illustrates risk management in
The treasurer of a Toronto menswear manu-
the world of corporate lending. Chief execu-
facturer attempts to negotiate bank financing
tive Alastair Dawes has to decide if the risk
for his company. The task is made more com- Leadership in Corporate Reporting
governance process is adequate to uncover
plex by the need to purchase material from Policy at Tata Steel mega-risks, based on reflections on the risk
Hong Kong and by sales made to the United
Karthik Ramanna, Rachna Tahilyani assessment and sanctioning of a $1 billion
States and Italy.
Harvard Business School Case credit proposal. Students are invited to assess
TN Product # 111028 (22 pages) and review the risks in the proposal, prepared
The IASB at a Crossroads: The by the bank’s sales organization on behalf of
Future of International Financial The case describes the challenges faced by a large gold-mining company, and to arrive at
Reporting Standards Tata Steel, India’s largest private-sector steel a decision (whether Wellfleet should accept it
company, as it transitions from Indian GAAP or not). At the same time, students will learn
Karthik Ramanna, Karol Misztal,
Daniela Beyersdorfer to IFRS. It first describes those challenges in that gray-area risk decisions and, in particular,
the context of the institutional voids that make risk-adjusted performance measurement
Harvard Business School Case
IFRS adoption difficult in India. The case can rarely be automated. Risk governance
TN Product #111084 (32 pages)
then focuses on how companies in emerging requires executives to strike a balance
What are the major challenges to the contin- markets might represent their interests at the between risk modeling and qualitative
ued growth of IFRS worldwide? Should coun- IASB, the standard-setting body for IFRS. business judgment—a holistic (rather than
tries be encouraged to pursue “full adoption” silo-based) view of risks.
of IFRS, or should each country determine its
Mike Mayo Takes on Citigroup (A)
own IFRS “convergence” strategy? Given the Supply Chain Partners: Virginia
limitations of governance and information- Suraj Srinivasan, Amy Kaser
Mason and Owens & Minor (A)
intermediation institutions worldwide, should Harvard Business School Case
V.G. Narayanan, Lisa Brem
IFRS limit the use of fair value accounting? TN Product #112025 (23 pages)
Harvard Business School Case
How should the IASB respond to the growing The case details the conflict between Mike TN Product #110063 (17 pages)
power of emerging markets such as China in Mayo, an influential banking analyst, and
international standard setting? What lessons Owens & Minor (O&M) performed lean
Citigroup about what Mayo considers aggres- inventory services for Virginia Mason (VM)
can be learned from the growth and develop- sive accounting policies. Mike Mayo questions as its alpha vendor, but the outdated industry
ment of IFRS for international harmoniza- Citigroup’s lack of a valuation allowance pricing model created perverse incentives
tion of corporate governance standards more
against its deferred tax assets despite Citi’s and could not capture O&M’s costs. Together,
broadly? This case first describes the IASB’s
recent losses. The case discusses the economics O&M and VM created an activity-based pric-
major accomplishments over the 2001–2010
of and accounting for deferred tax assets. It ing model called the total supply chain costs
period and then outlines the major challenges
also focuses on management-analyst relations (TSCC), which incented both companies to be
to the continued growth of IFRS as it enters
and challenges faced by analysts in providing more efficient and to streamline their distribu-
its second decade. tion activities. After beta testing the TSCC for
a negative opinion on companies. The inclu-
sion of deferred tax assets in Tier 1 capital one year, VM’s Daniel Borunda and O&M’s
and implications for regulatory capital are Michael Stefanic believed that TSCC was a
also discussed. better and more cost-effective pricing model,

4 | SPRING 2012 Teaching Materials Newsletter


ACCOU N TIN G — B U SIN ESS ET HICS

but could they convince their companies to that whether one holds up estimation error, used to be kept under lock and key but are
continue to invest in TSCC? holding gains and losses, earnings volatility, now largely out of our hands. Given how radi-
stewardship, or diligence, fair value proves cally virtual networks have transformed the
Tough Choices for the Illinois its worth. In many cases, the old favorite of nature of our social interactions—including
Pension System historical cost-based measures leaves much to those that connect firms with their stakehold-
be desired. Until the International Accounting ers—experts have started to stress the need
Robert C. Pozen, Brij Khurana
Standards Board (IASB) and the United States for an ethical framework that is uniquely
Harvard Business School Case
Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) conceived to tackle the complexity of the
TN Product #311139 (19 pages)
finalize their joint conceptual framework phenomena at play under this new scenario.
This case describes the precarious fiscal situ- project, this article helps clarify some of the This article addresses “network ethics”—an
ation of the Illinois public pension system contentious issues that continue to dog the integrated vision of ethical problems as
in the spring of 2009 and the accounting profession. Rather than battling against it, associated with the management of Internet-
of pension plans by nonfederal municipali- accounting experts would be better off devoting driven networks—and highlights the need
ties more generally. In February 2009, in their energies to making sure that fair value is for carefully analyzing not only financial and
the midst of a recession, recently appointed used in the most effective way possible. relational drivers but also ethical ones. Sound,
Governor Quinn had to lay out his budget for conscious, careful ethical judgment becomes a
the coming fiscal year and tackle the state’s fundamental tool for managers to understand
underfunded public pension, its largest the appropriateness of stakeholders’ ethical
BUSINESS ETHICS claims and then build fruitful relationships
liability. Immediately, the governor needed
to raise funds to make the state’s annual with those stakeholders based on trust.
contribution to the pension plan, and at the Disability Accommodations and
same time he needed to come up with a plan Promotions at Bunco
A Global Leader’s Guide to
for pension reform to prevent the future Katherine E. Breward Managing Business Conduct
insolvency of the state. Governor Quinn had a North American Case Research Association
Lynn S. Paine, Rohit Deshpande,
number of levers he could employ, including TN Product #NA0074 (7 pages)
Joshua D. Margolis
changing the asset allocation of the pension
This case highlights the dilemma of Nicholas, Harvard Business Review Article
funds; directly tackling entitlements through
an accounting executive, who must decide Product #W1109A (7 pages)
a defined benefit or defined contribution
whether to promote a disabled employee,
plan; or implementing a package of pension An extensive global survey by three Harvard
Paul, to a management role. Paul is a strong
bonds, taxes, and employee contributions. Business School professors finds that employ-
performer; however, he is frequently required
Through this case, students should more fully ees agree on core standards of corporate
to work at home on a laptop in order to
understand pension accounting and the hard behavior. But meeting those standards will
manage the symptoms of Crohn’s disease.
choices that many states will face because of require new approaches to managing business
Nicholas needs to decide whether this
their outstanding pension liabilities. conduct. The compliance and ethics programs
presents a barrier to Paul’s ability to take on
of most companies today fall short of address-
greater degrees of responsibility. He struggles
Why It’s Not Fair to Blame ing multinationals’ basic responsibilities,
with the legal and ethical implications of his
Fair Value let alone such vexing issues as how to stay
decision. The impact of his decision on the
competitive in markets where rivals follow
Mary E. Barth rest of his team is also considered.
different rules. Companies must bring to the
IESE-Insight Magazine Article management of business conduct the same
Product #IIR041 (7 pages) Ethics Hold the Key to Network performance tools and concepts that they use
The debate surrounding the financial report- Contradictions to manage quality, innovation, and financial
ing measurement approach known as fair Antonino Vaccaro results.
value was already in full swing by the time IESE-Insight Magazine Article
the recent economic crisis hit. That event only Product #IIR052 (7 pages) Kitchen Best: Ethics When Doing
served to add fuel to the fire, as some critics Cross-Boundary Business in
Today’s Internet-based world has certainly
charged that fair value measures of heav- Southern China
made it easier for companies to acquire,
ily discounted assets during an exceptional
store, and transmit detailed information like Say Goo, Grace Loo
period of distress sales actually made the situ-
never before. But with these gains in speed University of Hong Kong Case
ation worse. The author questions this analy-
and efficiency have come more complex TN Product #HKU948 (15 pages)
sis. Far from being the culprit, she argues,
and sometimes-contradictory expectations
fair value is a rather robust measurement Kitchen Best is a Hong Kong–based electrical-
about how companies should collect, retain,
approach that embodies several core princi- appliance company. The company has a
and disclose that information. Consumers,
ples underpinning the accounting framework. manufacturing facility in China and sells its
employees, and other stakeholders are access-
As well as highlighting the relative merits of wares to customers around the world.
ing and exchanging all manner of information
fair value, the author responds to the chief Henry Chan, the newly appointed CEO, has
related to individual habits, personal prefer-
concerns put forward by the critics, showing ambitious plans for the business. However,
ences, and privately held beliefs, all of which

TN TEACHING NOTE AVAILABLE hbsp.harvard.edu 1-800-545-7685 | 5


BU S IN E SS & G OV E R NM ENT RELATI O NS

a series of instances of misconduct and BP’s payments, the case depicts the payments lectual property rules and agricultural subsi-
unethical behavior makes him realize that the made by Exxon after the Exxon Valdez spill. dies and tariffs, or to instead pursue regional
business is suffering from a lack of internal The U.S. regulatory regime is then briefly trade agreements in South and Central
control. What type of internal control mecha- compared with regimes in other countries. America. Rousseff also pledged active govern-
nisms should he put in place to ensure the After a brief description of the way the fund ment involvement in the economy, described
future success of the company? set up by BP sought to distribute funds and of in the case as “Brazilian capitalism,” but it was
the temporary moratorium that followed the unclear whether fiscal expansion coupled with
spill, the case ends with discussion of possible conservative monetary policies would reduce
regulatory responses. bottlenecks to growth and further temper
BUSINESS &
Brazil’s high inequality.
GOVERNMENT Brazil: Leading the BRICs?
RELATIONS China “Unbalanced”
Arthur A. Daemmrich, Aldo Musacchio
Harvard Business School Case Diego Comin, Richard H.K. Vietor
Barack Obama and the Bush TN Product #711024 (24 pages) Harvard Business School Case
Tax Cuts (A) TN Product #711010 (27 pages)
Brazil’s new president, Dilma Rousseff, had
Matthew C. Weinzierl, Eric Werker
announced plans to sustain GDP growth In 2010, Wen Jiabao looked back at the
Harvard Business School Case
above 5 percent annually and continue the financial crisis with some satisfaction. Using
TN Product #709037 (28 pages)
country’s leadership role among emerging aggressive fiscal and monetary policy, China
As his inauguration approached, President-elect economies. Between 2003 and 2010, Brazil had weathered the crisis successfully, growing
Obama faced a financial sector meltdown, a benefited from strong economic growth and 8.7 percent annually in 2010. Most of the
costly bailout, and massive government defi- stable policies under the Lula administra- unemployed workers had returned to work,
cits. With the economy in recession, interest tion. Brazil also increasingly led the BRICs often demonstrating for higher wages or
rates near zero, and joblessness on the rise, (the fast-growing countries of Brazil, Russia, better working conditions. Wen, however, was
Obama needed to decide whether, and how India, and China) in multilateral negotiations, really focused on his new development strat-
much, to use fiscal stimulus to resuscitate notably in the World Trade Organization’s egy—shifting away from export-led growth
the economy. To help students understand Doha Round. Yet Brazil’s actions to enforce a to ease domestic and international pressures.
Obama’s options, the case reviews both the compulsory license of a patented therapy for But many institutional challenges seemed
recent tax cuts under President George W. HIV/AIDS and its victory in a long-standing to hamper domestic demand, and Wen
Bush, including the supply-side and demand- WTO dispute with the United States over was particularly concerned with pressures
management justification given for them, cotton subsidies had created tensions with from America on China’s policies for trade,
and the broad history of fiscal policy in the major trading partners. Entering office in exchange rates, energy, and investment.
United States. January 2011, Rousseff had the opportunity to
outline a new agenda for international trade.
BP’s Macondo: Spill and Response Specifically, she had to decide whether to seek
completion of the Doha Round, which was in
Julio J. Rotemberg
a stalemate due to disputes over global intel-
Harvard Business School Case
TN Product #711021 (21 pages)

This case starts by reporting various factors


that may have contributed to the massive ECONOMICS
Macondo oil spill, noting that BP, its partners,
and the government all made decisions that
helped cause the accident. It then discusses
Managerial Economics
the response to this spill by BP and the Concepts and Principles
government. This helps provide some context By Donald N. Stengel, California State University,
for the decision by the Obama administra- Fresno
tion to request $20 billion for a fund from
This eight-chapter book addresses the application
BP and for BP’s willingness to go along with
of microeconomics to business decisions. Chapters AVAILABLE ONLY IN CHAPTERS
this request. The case also depicts BP’s safety cover key relationships among price, quantity, cost, Business Expert Press
record before this spill, which may also have revenue, and profit for an individual firm, as well as Product #BEP069–BEP076
contributed to the creation of this fund. After the economics of consumer demand and production.
this, the case describes the various ways in The economics of organization, market price,
which the U.S. government is involved in quantity equilibrium, competitive behavior, and the
offshore oil, including the leasing of tracts, the role of market structure in market equilibrium and
regulation of drilling, and the assessment of competition are also addressed.
fines and damages. To provide contrast with

6 | SPRING 2012 Teaching Materials Newsletter


B U SIN ESS & GOVER N MEN T R ELATION S — ECON OMICS

Global Capitalism at Risk: What Are higher-tech exports could recapture U.S. a board director to Morgan Stanley, a company
You Doing About It? market share and make headway in Europe in which CIC had directly invested close to $6
and Latin America. billion and held 9.9 percent ownership. Addi-
Joseph L. Bower, Herman B. Leonard,
Lynn S. Paine tionally, the case discussed SWFs generally and
Securities Lending After the their rights and responsibilities to the global
Harvard Business Review Article
Financial Crisis community.
Product #R1109H (9 pages)

Market capitalism, a system that has proven to Robert C. Pozen, Gayle Hameister
be a remarkable engine of wealth creation, is Harvard Business School Case
poised for a breakdown. That sounds dire, and TN Product #311130 (24 pages) ECONOMICS
it is. Increasing income inequality, migration, In April 2009, Wendy Jefferson had just
weaknesses in the global financial system, returned to her office following a whirlwind
Give Your Workers Something
environmental degradation, and inadequate day of meetings with her newest client, to Smile About
government and international institutions are Star Advisor. Jefferson, a financial services Bruno S. Frey
just a few of the forces that threaten to disrupt consultant, was eager to dig into the informa- IESE-Insight Magazine Article
global market capitalism in the decades ahead. tion provided to her and her team about the Product #IIR024 (7 pages)
In conversations with business leaders around Star mutual funds and the income the funds
the world, the authors found that virtually Economics is undergoing a remarkable
earned from securities lending. Securities
all of them shared a deep concern for the new development that may even be called
lending involved temporarily transferring
sustainability of the market system, but their revolutionary. This development is likely to
securities from mutual funds managed by
beliefs about how to respond varied widely. change economics substantially in the future.
Star Advisor to short sellers and other inves-
Some said that changing their behavior would New insights from happiness research are
tors. Income from these loans had been a
be unnecessary or even inappropriate. Others slowly being accepted in standard economics,
small but secure component of Star mutual
were unsure how to deal with issues seldom a field that is traditionally conservative. If the
fund returns for decades.
thought to be the responsibility of individual goal of most human beings is to be happy,
firms. The authors call for business to be then a fuller understanding of the factors that
Two Key Decisions for China’s contribute to well-being is critical, especially if
both innovator and activist in protecting and
Sovereign Fund recent findings on what determines happiness
strengthening market capitalism. Instead of
seeing themselves as narrowly self-interested Robert C. Pozen, Xiaoyu Gu are at variance with standard economic
players in a system that is overseen by others, Harvard Business School Case theories. Happiness research is even more
business leaders must spearhead entrepre- TN Product #311137 (27 pages) important in helping to determine which
neurial activity on a massive scale—devising institutional forms best enable individuals to
The China Investment Corporation (CIC)
strategies that provide employment for the increase their life satisfaction.
was China’s sovereign wealth fund (SWF),
billions now outside the system, inventing established with $200 billion of registered
business models that make better use of capital in September 2007 to diversify China’s
How to Win Investors Over
scarce resources, and creating institutional foreign exchange holdings and increase risk- Baruch Lev
arrangements for coordinating and governing adjusted returns on those assets. CIC was Harvard Business Review Article
neglected and dysfunctional aspects of market unusual in that it had a strictly commercial Product #R1111B (10 pages)
capitalism. orientation and market-driven investment
Providing earnings guidance—publicly
mandate to invest in foreign assets but also
releasing managerial forecasts of a company’s
Mexico: Crisis and Competitiveness served as the parent company of a 100 percent-
profits—has become a highly controversial
Aldo Musacchio, Richard H.K. Vietor, owned subsidiary, Huijin, that invested solely
practice, with critics ranging from Warren
Regina Garcia-Cuellar in key state-owned financial institutions in
Buffett to a McKinsey team to the U.S. Cham-
Harvard Business School Case China. Moreover, the fact that CIC was an
ber of Commerce. Yet more than a thousand
TN Product # 710058 (28 pages) SWF presented broader political challenges
U.S. corporations issue such forecasts each
for it, its shareholder the Chinese govern-
In 2010, the bicentennial anniversary of year. Are they making a mistake? On the
ment, its direct investments and their govern-
Mexico’s revolution against Spain, Mexican contrary, argues Lev, an accounting professor
ments, and the world economy generally.
President Felipe Calderon hoped he could at NYU Stern: investors want more informa-
This case involved two decisions CIC faced in
orchestrate several crucial reforms that Mexico tion, and they will reward companies that
early 2011: the first was how to best and most
needed. Mexico had not grown much over make it available. Conventional wisdom
accurately articulate the relationship among
the course of the last decade, losing competi- notwithstanding, Lev maintains that investors
CIC, Huijin, and Industrial and Commercial
tiveness to China and other Asian countries. care a lot about what drives a company’s long-
Bank of China (ICBC) to the Federal Reserve
Several of its institutions, including labor, term growth; however, they often need help
Board (the Fed) so that ICBC could expand its
education, healthcare, energy, and antitrust, understanding what the drivers are. Guidance,
business in the United States while exempt-
seemed uncompetitive. But with a weaker non-GAAP pro forma earnings statements,
ing CIC and Huijin from certain types of Fed
peso and greater governmental attention to and executive conference calls with inves-
oversight. The second was whether to appoint
infrastructure, Calderon hoped that Mexico’s tors and analysts after the release of earnings

TN TEACHING NOTE AVAILABLE hbsp.harvard.edu 1-800-545-7685 | 7


E CO N O M I C S — E N T R E P RENE URS H I P

statements are potent tools. Done right, they rial economics, which is the application of political organizers looking to disseminate
can bring higher stock prices, lower volatility, microeconomics to business decisions. Key information to their followers and businesses
and reduced cost of capital, and they may also relationships among price, quantity, cost, looking to reach out in real time to potential
temper shareholder litigation and its con- revenue, and profit for an individual firm are customers, and it serves social networking
sequences. Some guidance for guiders is in discussed, as are elements from the econom- purposes. The company charges consumers
order: offer guidance only if your predictions ics of consumer demand and production. nothing for its service. By 2009, competitors
are consistently better than analysts’ consen- The economics of organization, market price, have emerged—some of whom have deep
sus forecasts. Don’t stand out as a “guidance quantity equilibrium, competitive behavior, pockets. Yet it remains unclear—at least to
refusenik” in a sector where guidance is and the role of market structure in market observers—whether the company will ever
prevalent. Maintain credibility and don’t duck equilibrium and competition are addressed. make money from its service.
the truth—manipulating expectations so that Finally, the text considers market regulation in
reported earnings will comfortably exceed terms of generic problems that create the need FreshTec: Revolutionizing Fresh
them breeds mistrust. Resist legal advice to be for regulation, as well as possible remedies for Produce
cryptic or bland, and don’t overlook the value those problems. Chapter 1 introduces the con-
Jose B. Alvarez, Ryan Johnson
of “soft” information; executives’ narrative cept of managerial economics at a broad level.
Harvard Business School Case
and tone color many investors’ decisions and The vital relationship between economics and
TN Product #511059 (24 pages)
account for most stock price changes in the business management is addressed.
wake of financial reports. These are not easy An entrepreneurial produce packaging firm
times to be an executive dealing with financial that has developed a disruptive technology
markets. But running away from disillusioned that keeps fresh produce and flowers fresh
investors only makes things worse. Far better
ENTREPRENEURSHIP for significantly longer faces strategic growth
is to figure out what they value and to shape decisions. CEO Bob Wright must decide how
your financial reporting and communications Entrepreneurs at Twitter: Building best to bring his company’s unique packaging
strategies accordingly. a Brand, a Social Tool, or a Tech product to market. The technology holds
Powerhouse? promise after a long development phase, but
Managerial Economics: Concepts Ken Mark the packaging is expensive and Wright and his
and Principles 1: Introduction to Richard Ivey School of Business team must convince the industry stakeholders
Managerial Economics Foundation Case of the packaging’s value.
TN Product #910M28 (10 pages)
Donald N. Stengel
Twitter has become an incredibly popular Humble Abode Music and The
Business Expert Press
Product #BEP069 (5 pages) micro-blogging service since its launch in Mammals: Not Your Grandpa’s
2006. Its founders have ambitious plans for String Band
Managerial Economics: Concepts and Principles, the service and are backed by $155 million of Michael J. Merenda, William Naumes,
written by Donald N. Stengel of California venture capital funding that valued the com- Margaret J. Naumes
State University, Fresno, is an eight-chapter pany at $1 billion in 2009. Twitter seems to North American Case Research Association
book published by Business Expert Press. attract a diverse audience of users, including TN Product #NA0021 (17 pages)
The text addresses the core of manage-
The three founding members of The Mam-
mals—Tao Rodriguez-Seeger, Ruth Ungar,
and Mike Merenda—were facing a major deci-
ENTREPRENEURSHIP
sion. In the year just ending, the string band
specializing in folk rock music had played
over 160 concerts, earning approximately
The Other Side of Innovation
$100,000 in gross revenues but leaving little
Solving the Execution Challenge
time to write or prepare new music. Signa-
By V.G. Govindarajan and Chris Trimble ture Sounds Records had offered the group
a recording contract. They needed to decide
“The Other Side of Innovation shows—using
practical examples and ideas and clear writing—
whether to accept the record deal and leverage
how to marry the company’s core business Signature Sounds’ financial and marketing
TEACHING RESOURCE
with new activities. With its emphasis on the AVAILABLE ONLINE: resources or to remain independent. Would
importance of implementation, the book provides hbsp.harvard.edu/list/syllabi the record label want them to tone down their
a wonderful complement to the emphasis on sometimes-controversial songs and com-
creativity and discovery so common in the AVAILABLE IN CHAPTERS
promise their artistic values? They also had
Harvard Business Review Press
innovation literature.” questions as to the role of their two backup
Product #13219
–Jeffrey Pfeffer, Professor, Stanford Graduate ISBN 978-1-4221-6696-3 musicians, Mike’s brother and a childhood
School of Business . +2!.ƫđƫĂąĀƫ,#!/ƫđƫĸĂĊċĊĆ
friend. Should they join The Mammals on a
permanent basis? The case presents informa-

8 | SPRING 2012 Teaching Materials Newsletter


EN TR EPR EN EU R SHIP — F IN A N CE

tion on the music industry in general and the RevenueWire.com: Growing in a present value (PV) are discussed and exempli-
folk segment in particular. Competitive Affiliate Industry fied for both lump sum and recurring cash
flow situations. In this vein, the derivation
Rebecca A. Grant
PremiumSoft: Managing Creative and use of four useful time-value-of-money
Richard Ivey School of Business
People Foundation Case
reference tables are presented to highlight the
TN Product #W11054 (16 pages)
underlying logic, connections, and mechan-
Neale O’Connor, April Yu, Melissa Moi
ics of determining FVs and PVs. Second,
University of Hong Kong Case After three years of rapid growth in a this case provides students with several
TN Product #HKU937 (10 pages) relatively young industry, the affiliate and simple vignettes in which they can apply the
PremiumSoft had been a competitive player payment processing company RevenueWire. foregoing time-value-of-money insights and
in the SQL software market for 10 years. Like com found itself operating in a very different techniques. The case can be effectively used
many software companies, PremiumSoft’s environment. Sales growth in the com- in degree and nondegree programs, and it
business model required that it continuously pany’s affiliate network service had leveled requires no additional reading materials. It is
evolve its current successful product lines off, and orders for Q1 2010 looked just like well suited for one 90-minute class period,
through research and development. At the those for Q1 2009. New competitors, low and all or selected subsets of the vignettes
core of the business were its creative people: entry barriers, and a plateau in the affiliate contained in it may be assigned. A Teaching
they were the company’s largest asset. Premi- market meant few opportunities for growth Note is available to registered faculty.
umSoft had created a team-centric, informal across the industry. Despite those conditions,
work environment that promoted creativity the company’s owners had set aggressive
INTELFRA Ltd.: Pricing Telecom
and innovation and attracted the best candi- revenue targets for 2010 to 2012. The general
Infrastructure in a Monopolistic
dates. As a small company, PremiumSoft had manager must evaluate options for growth,
Market
a mix of formal and informal controls when including new markets and new products, to
determine how to meet her targets. Because Ashok Banerjee, Indranil Bose,
dealing with recruiting, retention, roles, and
RevenueWire.com’s competitors are privately Debashis Saha, Minyi Huang
responsibilities. It had achieved success with
held, there is little public data on the state of University of Hong Kong Case
hiring, retaining, and managing its current
their finances or the size of various markets. TN Product #HKU929 (18 pages)
employees and wanted to ensure that it could
maintain this success with future growth. In The general manager has learned how to use Indian Telecom Infrastructure Ltd. (INTEL-
2010, PremiumSoft’s owners were looking to surrogate data to gauge the market and make FRA) is about to develop a proprietary basic
grow the business through the development strategic decisions, and the students must do telecom infrastructure and deliver that infra-
of new software. This growth required an the same to develop an effective three-year structure on demand to the customers in Lake
expansion of its staff by 25 percent and the plan that will meet or exceed the owners’ East, India. Using the telecom infrastructure
addition of a new product line. expectations. The case exposes students to (TI) services provided by INTELFRA, custom-
decision making in a global industry domi- ers will no longer need to incur the high fixed
nated by privately held companies. It also costs of building the required infrastructure
Primedic—Providing Primary Care
exposes students to the affiliate marketing on their own or commit to long-term fixed-
in Mexico
industry from the viewpoint of an entrepre- price outsourcing contracts. Though the
Richard G. Hamermesh, Regina Garcia neurial company that serves as an interme- business is promising, TI services required
Cuellar, Lauren Margulies diary between merchants and affiliates. It significant ex ante development and start-up
Harvard Business School Case describes many of the challenges facing an costs, and the demand was uncertain because
TN Product #811040 (27 pages) intermediary in an industry that includes Lake East is an upcoming township compris-
Primedic is a Mexican start-up that aims to not only legitimate merchants but also a vast ing both residential and commercial spaces.
deliver affordable primary and preventative array of scam artists and phony products. Pricing became a difficult yet crucial business
healthcare to those at the base of the economic decision for INTELFRA. High prices could
pyramid. The company is about to exhaust its drive customers away, but low prices would
first round of venture capital funding, and the FINANCE not be profitable, possibly even insufficient
business model has yet to gain traction. How to cover the high investment costs. This case
should the business model be changed, and addresses the critical pricing issues facing
Developing Financial Insights: Using
should the venture capitalists continue to fund telecom infrastructure services providers.
a Future Value (FV) and a Present
the company?
Value (PV) Approach
Joseph Vigneault and the Capital
Mark E. Haskins
Pool Company Program
University of Virginia Darden School Case
TN Product #UV5137 (12 pages)
Colette Southam, Jeff McDonald
Richard Ivey School of Business
This case has two aspects. First, it provides Foundation Case
a tutorial on the basic concepts associated TN Product #W10015 (8 pages)
with straightforward time-value-of-money
Joseph Vigneault and his entrepreneurial
scenarios. The topics of future value (FV) and

TN TEACHING NOTE AVAILABLE hbsp.harvard.edu 1-800-545-7685 | 9


F I N A N C E — G E N E R A L M ANAGE M ENT

FINANCE
GENERAL MANAGEMENT

A Bomb in Your Pocket? Crisis


Winning Investors Over Leadership at Nokia India (A)
Surprising Truths About Honesty, Earnings Charles Dhanaraj, Monidipa Mukherjee,
Guidance, and Other Ways to Boost Your Hima Bindu
Stock Price Richard Ivey School of Business
Foundation Case
By Baruch Lev
TN Product #910M64 (11 pages)
Harvard Business Review Press
“Winning Investors Over offers solutions for
.+ 10ƫņāĆĀĂƫ This case addresses the theme of crisis
managers who face difficult questions from ƫĊĈĉġāġąĂĂāġāĆĀĂġĂƫ
investors about financial performance. Based on
leadership in a multinational enterprise in a
. +2!.ƫđƫąĀĀƫ,#!/ƫđƫĸĂĊċĊĆ
scholarly research in accounting, finance, and powerful way to help students internalize the
economics, Baruch Lev’s advice is both practical critical challenges of a multinational company
and practicable.” in an emerging market. In August 2007, a
–Katherine Schipper, Professor, Fuqua School routine product feedback and defect analysis
of Business, Duke University process identified a defective batch of batteries
supplied by a Japanese vendor, Matsushita.
India happened to be the recipient of the larg-
est proportion of the defective batch. Nokia’s
partners wanted to raise $500,000 through Water Funds: Financing Nature’s corporate communications team, based in
the purchase of a currently existing com- Ability to Protect Water Supplies Finland, in cooperation with the Indian team,
pany in the $4 million to $5 million price responded with a customary global product
Erica Plambeck, Gretchen Daily,
range in order to pursue a new venture. A advisory. Instructions were made available on
David W. Hoyt
boutique investment bank introduced them the Internet for customers to diagnose a defec-
Stanford University Case
to the features of the Capital Pool Company tive battery and get a free replacement. Nokia
TN Product #OIT104 (13 pages)
(CPC) program. Vigneault must decide if a was shocked to see the antagonistic response
CPC is an option he and his partners should Nature plays an important role in maintaining from the Indian press to the product advisory
consider. He must consider the effect on their the flow and purity of water. Human activities and the ensuing mayhem that spread quickly
ownership stake in the company and calculate often degrade the quality and/or quantity of through the country. The head of Nokia India
the return on their investment. The case is water flowing to downstream users, but the and his team had to act swiftly to preserve the
focused on the quantitative and qualitative maintenance of natural ecosystems and the company’s hard-earned reputation and market
decision factors that go into deciding how to sound conservation management by those share. Case A is set at a midnight strategy ses-
finance a new business venture and exposes living upstream in watersheds can help sion at Nokia’s Indian headquarters to chart
students to the unique CPC program offered provide a clean, reliable supply of water for the way forward. Case B is a short version of
by the TSX Venture Exchange. downstream water users. Water funds are a what actually happened: how Nokia and the
way for downstream water users to preserve team successfully steered the organization
Valuing Wal-Mart 2010 their water supply, by paying to restore and through the crisis and not only survived but
conserve natural ecosystems. They also enable also used the situation to create new organiza-
James E. Hatch, Cyrus Zahedi
upstream and downstream communities to tional capabilities.
Richard Ivey School of Business work together for mutual benefit, preserving
Foundation Case
or restoring nature’s ability to improve water From Score to System: How the Net
TN Product #W11058 (14 pages)
quality and reliable flow while providing Promoter Score (NPS) Grew from a
An equity analyst uses a variety of methods to economic opportunities for upstream com-
Metric to a Management System
value Wal-Mart shares, with a view to making munities. This case introduces the concept
a buy/sell or hold recommendation for the stock. of ecosystem services (the role that natural Fred Reichheld, Rob Markey
ecosystems play in sustaining and fulfilling Harvard Business Review Press Chapters
human life) and payment for ecosystem Product #8573BC (20 pages)

services (PES), in which stakeholders pay In 2003, when loyalty economics expert Fred
in order to preserve or restore the ability of Reichheld created the Net Promoter Score
nature to provide these services. It describes (NPS) as a new way of measuring how well
water funds and other PES arrangements, an organization generates customer loyalty,
as well as some of the challenges that water no one could have predicted how swiftly
funds face. Several examples are provided of this easy-to-understand, open-source metric
water funds and other PES programs. would catch on. Thousands of innovative
companies—Apple, American Express,

10 | SPRING 2012 Teaching Materials Newsletter


GE NE RAL M ANAGEMEN T — HU MA N R ESOU R CE MA N AGEMEN T — IN FOR MATION T ECHN OLOGY

Zappos, Intuit, eBay, Southwest Airlines, working definition of “market capitalism” and Managing Transitions Chapter 1: It
and Facebook, to name just a few—adopted its key features as well as a brief overview of Isn’t the Changes That Do You In
the Net Promoter Score as a way to track the how capitalism varies across global markets.
William Bridges
loyalty, engagement, and enthusiasm of their They then describe a series of forums they
Perseus Press
customers. Then, over time, these same com- organized in order to ask business leaders
Product #PER067 (8 pages)
panies discovered new methods to expand the in Europe, East Asia, Latin America, and the
impact of NPS—using it to build employee United States what they believed to be the Managing Transitions is a book of nine chap-
engagement and customer loyalty—and it threats to the capitalistic system in the future. ters written by William Bridges and published
became something much bigger: a manage- This chapter describes those forums and dis- by Perseus Books Group. The business world
ment system capable of transforming entire cussions as a basis for a broader examination is continuously transforming as layoffs, bank-
organizations. In this powerful introductory of the current and future state of the market ruptcies, mergers, and restructurings occur
chapter, Reichheld and his Bain colleague Rob system as a whole. This chapter was originally every day. These situational shifts present
Markey share the back story of NPS. You’ll published as chapter 1 of Capitalism at Risk: psychological challenges to both individuals
learn how the “S” in NPS came to stand not Rethinking the Role of Business. and organizations, and many of us respond in
only for a score but also for a system and a unhealthy ways. The author describes healthy
spirit of leadership—a distinctive philosophy responses to these challenges, providing prac-
that inspires organizations to enrich the lives tical, step-by-step strategies for minimizing
of those they touch. You’ll also be introduced
HUMAN RESOURCE the disruptions caused by workplace change.
to The Ultimate Question—“On a zero-to-ten MANAGEMENT Chapter 1 describes the difference between
scale, how likely is it that you would recom- change, which is situational, and transition,
mend us to a friend or colleague?”—and to Combating the Effects of Turnover: which involves psychological response to
the three categories of customers who respond Military Lessons Learned from change. The author argues that transition is a
to it: promoters, passives, and detractors. The Project Teams Rebuilding Iraq process comprising three stages: the ending,
impact of this chapter is best summed up in Charles Y. Murnieks, Scot T. Allen, the neutral zone, and the new beginning. He
Reichheld’s own words: “The Net Promoter Claudia J. Ferrante describes the life cycle of properly managed
system will help you run a better business, do transitions and shows how mismanaged tran-
Business Horizons/Indiana University Case
more satisfying work, and build relationships Product #BH451 (11 pages) sitions can go wrong.
that yield a more fulfilling life.” This chapter
was originally published as the introduction The literature concerning turnover has
to The Ultimate Question 2.0 (Revised and traditionally been composed of studies and
analyses that assume that turnover rates are INFORMATION
Expanded Edition): How Net Promoter Compa-
nies Thrive in a Customer-Driven World. malleable and can be reduced. The authors TECHNOLOGY
take the opposite position and contend that
turnover rates for certain organizations are Binnj on the Apple iPad
Introduction: The Role of Business
not variable but rather remain fixed. Is it pos- Derrick Neufeld, Ken Mark
in the Future of Market Capitalism
sible, then, to reduce the deleterious effects of
Joseph L. Bower, Herman B. Leonard, Richard Ivey School of Business
turnover without reducing the actual churn of Foundation Case
Lynn S. Paine individuals? To answer this question, we draw TN Product #910E24 (24 pages)
Harvard Business Review Press Chapters from experiences of the U.S. military during
Product #8615BC (19 pages) Operation Iraqi Freedom in order to learn In this dialogue-styled situation, Binnj’s CEO
from that operation’s methods of dealing with has assembled a team of people for a 100-day
The spread of capitalism worldwide has
high personnel turnover during the manage- “science experiment” to determine whether
made people wealthier than ever before. But
ment of projects. Specifically, the authors offer a new high-tech business venture is worth
especially in the wake of the 2008 financial
four best practices that reduce the negative pursuing. He is focused on an untapped
meltdown, capitalism’s future is far from
effects of turnover while allowing the rate market—a new kind of restaurant menu
assured. As Europe’s economies teeter, as
itself to remain constant. These best practices service built on the Apple iPad platform.
income inequality incenses those struggling
aim toward sharing the knowledge and mental Members of the team are excited and have
to make ends meet, and as mass migrations
models critical for sustained operations in been furiously working on the project while
alter world demographics, a question arises:
order to insulate the organization against the retaining their full-time jobs. They have
can capitalism be sustained? In this intro-
departure of key personnel. Herein, the case developed a prototype of the technology and
ductory chapter, Harvard Business School
demonstrates how efficient operations can be business offering, pitched the idea to several
professors Joseph Bower, Herman Leonard,
maintained amid high churn rates. clients, and generated significant interest.
and Lynn Paine set forth a radical proposi-
The case is set at the end of the first 100 days,
tion: that business must begin taking a more
when the CEO must decide on the next steps.
active role in assuring capitalism’s health and
This case introduces students to information
sustainability and that government cannot
technology entrepreneurship, technology
be capitalism’s savior. The authors provide a
development approaches, service pricing
issues, virtual project management techniques

TN TEACHING NOTE AVAILABLE hbsp.harvard.edu 1-800-545-7685 | 11


I N FOR M AT I O N T E C H N O LO GY — I NTE RNATI O NAL BUSIN ESS

INTERNATIONAL
APPLY ONLINE FOR EDUCATOR ACCESS AND RECEIVE:
BUSINESS
 10+.ƫ+,%!/ƫđƫ!$%*#ƫ+0!/ƫđƫ+1./!ƫ(**%*#ƫ++(/
01 !*0ƫ.%%*#ƫđƫ.!2%!3ƫ!//ƫ0+ƫ*(%*!ƫ+1./!/ƫĒƫ%)1(0%+*/
The CEO of Heinz on Powering
Growth in Emerging Markets
Î educatoraccess.hbsp.harvard.edu
Bill Johnson
Harvard Business Review Article
Product #R1110A (5 pages)
and tools, brainstorming revenue generation ogy ventures, many of which ran into trouble
The developing economies are now a primary
opportunities, and the challenges of prioritiz- during the great recession. Green technology
focus for consumer-oriented businesses,
ing decisions. companies need to develop staying power. In
says Johnson, who put together Heinz’s first
addition to understanding the opportunities,
long-term strategy for those markets soon
Brand Equity they need to get ahead—and stay ahead—of
after becoming CEO in 1998. The strategy
competitors.
Chris A. Higgins, Jodie Whelan emphasizes four As: applicability (the product
Richard Ivey School of Business must suit the local culture), availability (sales
Foundation Case What Every CEO Needs to Know channels must be relevant to the local popula-
TN Product #910E23 (3 pages) About the Cloud tion), affordability (very small packages of a
A marketing company has collected a large Andrew McAfee product may be crucial for these customers),
dataset on brand equity for the fast-food and Harvard Business Review Article and affinity (local customers and employees
travel sectors. They have come up with their Product #R1111J (10 pages) must feel close to your brand). Sometimes
way of measuring brand equity. Various statis- Heinz takes its brands into a market and
Cloud computing is a sea change in the way
tical techniques are used to assess the concept tries to grow them organically; more often it
companies use technology; it’s as inevitable
of brand equity. These include descriptive looks to acquire solid brands with good local
and significant as the shift from steam power
statistics, crosstabs, ANOVA, and MANOVA. management that will get it into the right
to electricity on the factory floor. Because criti-
channels. That means a second layer of due
cisms of the cloud have gotten a lot of hype,
diligence regarding how the company goes to
Innovating in Uncertain Markets: however, many companies are hesitant to
market, the tax system, the regulatory envi-
10 Lessons for Green Technologies explore it. In this article, McAfee, a principal
ronment, currency trends, and the political
Paul J.H. Schoemaker, George S. Day research scientist at MIT’s Center for Digital
climate in comparison with what exists in the
Business, debunks commonly cited concerns
MIT Sloan Management Review United States.
Product #SMR389 (9 pages) about the cloud. When it comes to cost, reli-
ability, and security, he says, the cloud prom-
Talking about green technology gets people ises to equal or better on-premise computing.
Coca-Cola and Huiyuan (A):
excited. It’s thrilling to think that a new wave Moreover, as the experiences of companies Antitrust Barriers to Buying Top
of inventions and discoveries will revolution- like 3M, the global contractor Balfour Beatty, Chinese Brands
ize the way we live, halt the degradation of and the consulting firm CSC show, cloud Ping Lin, Wen Zhou, Penelope Chan
our planet, and conserve resources for future computing offers sizable benefits, such as University of Hong Kong Case
generations. And it’s more than just talk: improved productivity, easier collaboration, TN Product #HKU946 (38 pages)
investors are committing real dollars. As the the ability to mine data for insights, and
level of activity increases, however, discus- The Coca-Cola Company (Coca-Cola)
higher capacity without major capital invest-
sions about green technology raise as many announced a plan in September 2008 to
ment. Here, McAfee walks readers through
questions as they answer. Addressing the key acquire China’s biggest domestic juice manu-
the three basic categories of cloud computing:
questions is complicated by the fundamen- facturer, China Huiyuan Juice Group Limited
infrastructure-as-a-service (the leasing of raw
tal uncertainties that are at the heart of the (Huiyuan). This acquisition will boost the
computing capacity), platform-as-a-service
green technology market. The evolution of market share of Coca-Cola from 12.7 percent
(the leasing of computers ready for software
this market space depends on forces that are to 20.2 percent in the country’s juice market
development), and software-as-a-service (the
beyond the control of any individual entrepre- that year. Because Huiyuan-brand fruit juice is
hosting of applications for users). Arguing
neur or investor: government policies; avail- one of China’s prominent homegrown brands,
that CEOs and senior managers need to take
ability of capital; and wild cards such as oil this news has triggered a public outcry rooted
the lead on the shift to the cloud, McAfee then
price volatility, geopolitical conflicts, the rate of in patriotic nationalism against Coca-Cola’s
outlines how companies can get started.
economic growth, and public attitudes toward acquisition. Local juice manufacturers have
warnings of global climate change. History also protested, claiming that Coca-Cola’s
shows that the road to technological innova- enhanced market position would drive them
tion is a long and winding one. Between 2005 out of business. China’s antitrust officials plan
and 2007, runaway enthusiasm led to the pro- to conduct a public hearing in late December
liferation of hundreds of new green technol- 2008. Coca-Cola’s senior executives are mull-
ing over the best strategies to convince the

12 | SPRING 2012 Teaching Materials Newsletter


IN TER N ATION A L B U SIN ESS — MA RK ET IN G

authorities that this acquisition benefits the believed that the dominant logic behind the involves several trade-offs. The CIO’s decision
consumers and the society at large. Factors chain’s growth in the U.S.—a limited menu, on each will have a major effect on the rev-
of considerations may include the rationale small stores, and an emphasis on takeout— enues, margins, and competitive positioning
of regulatory control of M&A; synergies of wouldn’t produce the kind of success they of MBI in the Indian automotive industry.
the merging companies; and the potential were looking for in China. KFC China offers
effects of merging on competition, consumer important lessons for global executives
interests, and industry development. (Note: seeking guidance in determining how much
Case B covers the ruling by China’s antitrust
MARKETING
of their existing business model to keep in
authorities on Coca-Cola’s case and its impli- emerging markets—and how much to
cations for foreign companies trying to expand throw away. Adding Social Media to the
business in the country through acquisition of Marketing Mix
top domestic brands.) Mercedes-Benz India Guillermo Armelini, Julian Villanueva
IESE Insight Magazine Article
Nicole R.D. Haggerty, Shankar
KFC’s Radical Approach to China Product #IIR051 (8 pages)
Venkatagiri, Ramasastry
David E. Bell, Mary L. Shelman Chandrasekhar Social media have rapidly gained share and
Harvard Business Review Article Richard Ivey School of Business attention among all kinds of consumers and
Product #R1111K (6 pages) Foundation Case companies, often at the expense of traditional
TN Product #W11084 (13 pages)
media. Companies have started to redefine key
Global companies face a crucial question
In December 2007, the management of aspects of their marketing mix. With advertis-
when they enter emerging markets: how far
Mercedes-Benz India (MBI), a fully owned ing and online word of mouth competing for
should they go to localize their offerings?
subsidiary of Daimler AG, the 12th-largest shrinking marketing budgets, many compa-
Typically they try to sell core products or
automobile manufacturer in the world, nies regard having an active presence in social
services pretty much as they’ve been sold in
decided to relocate to a new facility near media as a viable alternative to traditional
Europe or the United States, with headquar-
Pune in western India. In overseeing the advertising. Yet the authors believe this would
ters calling all the shots—and usually with
installation of information technology (IT) be a mistake, because the two strategies are
disappointing results. The authors, both of
infrastructure at the new premises, the com- complementary rather than substitutive.
Harvard Business School, examined why KFC
pany’s CIO is dealing with some managerial A comparison of advertising and word of
China has been able to find fertile ground in
choices pertaining to IT architecture, IT tools, mouth shows that social media obey very dif-
a market that is notoriously challenging for
and IT skill sets of the company. Each choice ferent rules than does traditional advertising.
Western fast-food chains. KFC’s executives

Ratings and Product Reviews: Marketing Simulation – Managing Segments and Customers

Managing Segments and Customers:

Reviews Teachable:
B2B Simulation
July 18, 2011

This was an exciting, challenging, and highly relevant simula-


Relevant: tion for students that engaged their interest and skills levels.
Share Your Expertise The teaching materials were very useful and well laid out.
Student Friendly:
with Our Community The best feature is the ability to customize the weightings each
teaching period to reflect the
he current market place.
of Educators Marion
from Australia
Product Reviews: Marketing Simulation – Managing Segments and Customers
Discipline: Marketing
Years Teaching: 5 to 9 yrs 0 0 Report
orrt inappropriate
inappropriate content
Ratings and reviews are now Post Comment Simulation for Graduate Students
August 5, 2011
available for educators on
Teachable: I used this simulation for a graduate Channels and Distribution
our web site. You can let Strategy class and used it as an individual assessment. We
Relevant: started with a practice round and then had four competing
others know if a certain case To get started, simply log rounds, each getting more and more difficult. Segmentation
strategy, cumulative profit and customer service were weighted
Student Friendly:
more than total revenue. Created a very competitive class
is right for undergraduates, in to the site as a Premium environment.
Chipman5
how it worked to teach an Educator and search for an from Baltimore
Discipline: Marketing
online simulation for the first item you have used in class. Years Teaching: 10 to 19 yrs 0 0 Report inappropriate content

Post Comment
time, or the myriad other
ways you might teach with NOT A PREMIUM EDUCATOR? APPLY ONLINE:

specific course materials. educatoraccess.hbsp.harvard.edu

TN TEACHING NOTE AVAILABLE hbsp.harvard.edu 1-800-545-7685 | 13


M A RK E T I N G

Social media can start conversations or build Herborist: A Chinese Personal Care to help students understand the decisions
brand recognition, but the results are much Brand Goes Abroad that helped propel Lady Gaga into one of the
more difficult to predict or measure. With entertainment world’s biggest names. Written
Kevin Zhou, Grace Loo
that in mind, the authors recommend how to from the perspective of her manager, the case
University of Hong Kong
define a social media plan, citing examples provides rich insights into the artist’s touring,
TN Product # HKU927 (24 pages)
of companies that got it right—and offering recorded-music, and social media activities, as
cautionary tales of those that got it wrong. Herborist, a high-end Chinese personal care well as supporting economic data.
brand, had been steadily expanding its share
Dacia Duster SUV in global markets since 2008. The brand The Pepsi Refresh Project: A Thirst
distinguished itself by integrating traditional for Change
Marina Apaydin, Hantuile Oana
Chinese medicine with modern biotechnol-
Nicoleta Michael I. Norton, Jill Avery
ogy and emphasizing its green and organic
Richard Ivey School of Business Harvard Business School Case
ingredients. Whereas the Chinese were
Foundation Case Product #512018 (24 pages)
TN Product #910A31 (14 pages)
familiar with the concept, how would Herbor-
ist sell it to consumers outside mainland In 2010, for the first time in 23 years, PepsiCo
Driven by the 2009 global economic crisis, China who were used to using established did not invest in Super Bowl advertising for its
Dacia Romania designed and built the Dacia Japanese brands, such as Shiseido and SK-II, iconic brand. Instead, the company diverted
Duster sport utility vehicle (SUV) to be the or Western brands, such as Estée Lauder and $20 million to the social media–fueled Pepsi
ideal SUV at an affordable price. After the Sisley? In 2001, Herborist chose to enter the Refresh Project: PepsiCo’s innovative cause-
successful introductions of the cheapest Hong Kong market and test its product in this marketing program in which consumers
modern sedan on the international market very competitive market that was dominated submitted ideas for grants for health, envi-
in 2004 and among the cheapest modern by the major Japanese and Western cosmetics ronmental, social, educational, and cultural
seven-seaters in 2006, Dacia planned to brands. The company opened two Herborist- causes. Consumers voted for their favorite
introduce what it hoped would become the branded stores in major shopping centers but ideas, and PepsiCo funded the winners with
cheapest modern SUV on the international was forced to close them down two years later grants ranging from $5,000 to $250,000.
market. The main challenges Dacia was facing due to bad results. The company tried again The case highlights the benefits and risks
in 2009 were how to sell the car to existing in 2007, this time distributing its products of traditional branding and social media
customers and how to conduct an extensive through the Hong Kong personal health and branding, including a discussion of how the
public communication campaign in order to beauty chain Mannings. In 2008, Herborist Pepsi Refresh Project fits with Pepsi’s previ-
convince other drivers to change their cars for entered the Paris market with the help of the ous brand positioning. The case discussion
the cheaper, more efficient Dacia SUV that cosmetics chain store Sephora. Results were focuses on how the brand team should evalu-
was going to be available in spring 2010. mixed; although some of its products became ate the initiative’s return on investment (from
top sellers, the overall sales figures were not sales to social media engagement), whether
Forecasting Denosumab very promising. By 2011, Herborist was ready they should continue the initiative in 2011,
Aggarwal Nayna, Tim Calkins for the next step in its international expansion and whether Pepsi is the right brand for this
plan. Which markets should it target and what kind of initiative.
Kellogg School of Management,
Northwestern Case strategy should it adopt?
Product #KEL531 (15 pages) Procter & Gamble: Marketing
This case looks at an important business task:
Lady Gaga (A) Capabilities
forecasting a new product. The case can be Anita Elberse, Michael Christensen Rebecca Henderson, Ryan Johnson
used to teach finance, marketing (new product Harvard Business School Case Harvard Business School Case
introduction), and healthcare strategy. The Product #512016 (28 pages) Product #311117 (17 pages)
product is one of Amgen’s most important
In September 2009, Troy Carter, manager P&G had become known and recognized
new products: denosumab. On the surface,
of up-and-coming pop star Lady Gaga, has to as a marketing machine. It was the largest
the case is fairly easy: students simply have to
decide on a new course of action now that his advertiser in the world, with 2010 spending
do some simple mathematical calculations.
artist’s planned co-headlining arena tour with of $8.68 billion. From the company’s early
However, the challenges of forecasting quickly
hip-hop superstar Kanye West has been can- exploitation of broadcast media (radio and
become apparent: every forecast depends on
celed. Carter knows that continuing the tour television) for its soap products to more recent
some critical assumptions, and the answer
solo comes with huge risks, but scaling it back experiments in digital media for its men’s
can vary dramatically.
to smaller theaters or postponing the tour hygiene brand Old Spice, P&G was a seasoned
altogether has disadvantages as well. Making marketer with strong consumer research, a
matters more complicated, Carter also has to powerful innovation network, and the world’s
consider the implications for Gaga’s partners, largest financial commitment to advertising.
including the concert promoter Live Nation
and the William Morris Endeavor agency.
What is the best strategy? The case is designed

14 | SPRING 2012 Teaching Materials Newsletter


MA R KETIN G — N EGOTIATION — OPER ATION S M A N AGEMEN T

Revitalize Your Business: A Brand


SEE TEACHING NOTES AND EDUCATOR COPIES
Reinvention Framework
Alonzo Canada, Joyce Chen
Rotman School of Management Case Faculty registered as Premium Educators on our web site receive:
Product #ROT150 (4 pages) ƒ Educator copies of cases, articles, books, and chapters
In the past decade, Procter & Gamble has ƒ Free trials of online courses and simulations
transformed Oil of Olay from “oil of old lady” ƒ Teaching Notes that provide an instructor’s guide to teaching with a case
into Olay Total Effects—one of its strongest ƒ Course planning tools
brands. Is one of your brands a diamond in ƒ Student pricing up to 60 percent off
the rough? The authors outline five key ques-
tions that can help you assess whether or not These benefits are available to teaching faculty at academic institutions.
to invest in brand reinvention. If a brand can APPLY NOW educatoraccess.hbsp.harvard.edu
answer all of them in the affirmative, chances
are good that it has the potential to be trans-
formed from a laggard into a star. The authors
present the five components of their Brand
NEGOTIATION Negotiation in China: How
Reinvention Framework: proposition, target,
offerings, production, and channel, describing Universal?
in detail how to approach each element. Bidding for Hertz: Leveraged Tao Zhigang, Shangjin Wei,
Buyout Penelope Chan
The U.S. Military Academy University of Hong Kong Case
Susan Chaplinsky, Felicia C. Marston
TN Product #HKU956 (20 pages)
at West Point University of Virginia Darden School Case
Anat Keinan TN Product #UV1056 (21 pages) This is a fictitious case in which Universal
Harvard Business School Studios, a major U.S. theme parks and resorts
In August 2005, The Carlyle Group and its
Product # 512012 (26 pages) company, has to negotiate with China’s central
partners must finalize the terms of a bid to
government to build its first theme park in
The case examines an iconic institution’s purchase the Hertz Corporation. The Ford
the country. Students are divided into groups,
decision on whether or not to undertake a Motor Company had put Hertz, a wholly
and each student is assigned a role as one of
branding initiative. Founded in 1802, West owned subsidiary, up for sale in April 2005,
the negotiators or as an observer. The topics
Point has played a key role in America’s history. and in June 2005 Hertz entered a dual-track
covered in the negotiation include the new
It is one of the nation’s oldest institutions of process that would result in its sale or an
theme park’s location, ownership structure,
higher learning and is well known for produc- initial public offering (IPO). The case provides
size, nature of theme zones, local employ-
ing prominent military, political, and business detailed pro forma projections for the transac-
ment, and hospitality training programs.
leaders. In the increasingly competitive envi- tion that allow students to examine the syner-
The case allows students to experience the
ronment of higher education, the Director of gies of the deal and estimate a value and bid
difficulties of conducting negotiations in a
Strategic Communications at the U.S. Military for Hertz. Students must consider whether
cross-cultural setting.
Academy is faced with a decision on whether their bid provides an adequate return to the
or not to invest resources in a rebranding sponsors, can produce a higher value for
Hertz than can an IPO, and can best the bid Palestinian Negotiating Partners:
effort. Over the course of the school’s history,
of a rival bidding group. The case is appropri- 2010 Strategic Reassessment
several distinct logos have come into existence
and little uniformity or guidance for use ate for use in courses on corporate finance, James K. Sebenius, Shula Gilad
exists. Data from a recent consumer survey private equity, or deal valuation. Because of Harvard Business School Case
offers some insight for the decision maker the rich range of issues that can be considered, Product #911025 (34 pages)
to contemplate, as does the school’s recent the case also works well as a capstone case or
A network of influential Israelis and Palestin-
appearance on the cover of Forbes magazine in a case competition. For instructors wishing
ians, jointly trained in negotiation at Harvard
as the number one undergraduate institution to provide students an overview of the role
since 2002, faces organizational, strategic, and
in the nation. Numerous stakeholders, and practices of private equity, we recommend
funding challenges in 2010. Unlike “people to
tradition, the competitive environment, combining the Hertz LBO case with its
people” or “Track II” initiatives, the Israeli-Pal-
and resource constraints all factor into the companion case, Investing in Sponsor-Backed
estinian Negotiating Partners (IPNP) consists
decision-making process. IPOs: The Case of Hertz (UV1409). The Hertz
of relatively senior people on both sides of
IPO was announced in July 2006, just seven
the conflict who have undergone advanced
months after the LBO was completed. The two
negotiation training together and now consti-
cases cover a wide range of issues that arise
tute a unique network in the region. IPNP’s
over the course of entry and exit of private
academic sponsor, the Harvard Negotiation
equity investments.
Project, is helping to assess this unique nego-
tiation initiative and assisting the organization

TN TEACHING NOTE AVAILABLE hbsp.harvard.edu 1-800-545-7685 | 15


O PE R AT I O N S M A N AGE M ENT

in its efforts to conduct a basic reassessment products, established a sourcing office in FIJI Water: Carbon Negative?
in the face of changes in regional politics, the Shanghai. The Shanghai office was respon- Francesca Gino, Michael W. Toffel,
conflict, and the funding environment. sible for sourcing vendors not only in China Stephanie van Sice
but also in southern Asia. It played a major
Harvard Business School Case
role in quadrupling China Sourcing Group’s TN Product #611049 (22 pages)
revenues over the next four years. Despite its
OPERATIONS contribution to the group, the Shanghai office Seeking to go beyond global best practices in
MANAGEMENT faced a major issue of frequent late deliveries, reducing environmental impacts, FIJI Water,
especially of new products that were devel- a premium artesian bottled water company in
The Art of Piloting New Initiatives oped from scratch. In 2009, as the Shanghai the United States, launched a carbon-negative
Bettina Büchel, Rhoda Davidson management team reviewed the performance campaign that would offset more greenhouse
of the sourcing office, it decided that some- gas emissions than were released by the
MIT Sloan Management Review
thing had to be done to improve the punctual- company’s operations and products. The case
Product # SMR402 (8 pages)
ity of that office’s deliveries. What should the examines the controversies surrounding this
Successful multinationals get that way by Shanghai office do to improve the situation? program as well as the program’s impacts
finding progressively better ways to lever- on the environment and FIJI Water’s brand
age good operational improvements across image. The company also faced decisions
Don’t Let Your Supply Chain Control
the entire company. But developing such regarding how to best manage its relationship
Your Business
superior processes is not easy. As few as one with the Fijian government, which recently
in three new process initiatives succeeds. Thomas Y. Choi, Tom Linton dramatically raised imposed export taxes
Each failure can cost the company as much Harvard Business Review Article and could limit FIJI Water’s access to water,
as $10 million in development costs, not to Product #R1112H (7 pages) its primary raw material. The case enables
mention forgoing the hundreds of millions In the past 25 years, major original equipment students to better understand the challenges
of dollars that a successful initiative might manufacturers have delegated the manage- of implementing an environmental strategy
have generated. New operational ideas fail for ment of their supply chains to a handful of and of negotiating with parties that control
many reasons. However, the experience and first-tier suppliers. Although this approach raw materials, and it invites discussion of
research of these authors suggests that one of frees OEMs from the tasks of building and the effectiveness of various approaches and
the most common reasons is not that the idea supervising supply subsystems, speeds up the general lessons for the management of
was bad but that the developers set up a pilot product introductions, and helps manufac- companies seeking to operate in an environ-
that failed to persuade managers in the units turers secure larger volume discounts, it has mentally responsible manner.
that the process was an improvement. If the gone too far. In this article, Choi, of Arizona
pilot covers business units, customer types, or State University, and Linton, a former chief SeaMicro
products and services that the managers who procurement officer of LG Electronics, point Mark Leslie, Sara Rosenthal
are expected to roll out the innovation don’t out the dangers of relinquishing so much
see as analogous to their own unit’s situa- Stanford University Case
power to first-tier suppliers: it weakens an Product #E409 (17 pages)
tion, the working template may be viewed OEM’s ability to control costs, stay on top of
as insufficient to be considered a reliable critical technology developments and shifts in Launched in 2007, SeaMicro developed one
experiment. Many of these failures can be demand, and ensure that suppliers are operat- of the most innovative server products to hit
avoided. Specifically, the authors find that suc- ing in a socially and environmentally sustain- the market in over a decade. The SM10000
cessful pilots share three qualities: credibility, able fashion. The solution is for an OEM to consumed one-quarter the power and space of
replicability, and feasibility. The pilot location selectively establish direct relationships with conventional server products, thereby address-
must seem credible in that the situations and key lower-tier suppliers. Specifically, an OEM ing a significant and growing pain point, par-
challenges seem familiar to the managers who should form close ties with vendors that have ticularly among Web 2.0 companies. As these
are expected to eventually adopt it into their a significant impact on the OEM’s cost of companies increased their compute power
own units. It needs to be replicable as well, goods sold, have strong innovation potential, through the addition of tens of thousands of
and capable of being turned into a template pose sustainability risks, and can provide servers, their data centers expanded as well,
that can be rapidly introduced in a variety of insights into important trends. Implementing creating major issues around the availability
locations. Finally, its results must meet the this approach isn’t simple—it may require and costs associated with electricity, cooling,
expectations of multiple stakeholders. reshaping the entire purchasing function. But and physical space. Though SeaMicro’s
it’s essential for manufacturers that want to founders were confident that their product
China Sourcing Group: Delivering stay ahead of competitors. would address this significant market need,
on Time they faced initial resistance from the invest-
ment community, based largely on the recent
Neale O’Connor
failures of a handful of newly emergent server
University of Hong Kong Case
companies, combined with the oligopoly
TN Product #HKU931 (9 pages)
structure of the server market dominated by
In 2004, U.S.-based China Sourcing Group, HP, Dell, and IBM. The case profiles SeaMicro’s
which specializes in premium and gift voyage navigating these obstacles and high-

16 | SPRING 2012 Teaching Materials Newsletter


OPER ATION S MA N AGEMEN T — OR GA N IZATION A L B EHAV IOR

lights the challenges that lie ahead after its Sunset Grill at Blue Mountain using transnational structures that exploit
initial product commercialization. John S. Haywood-Farmer, Dina location-specific advantages—just doesn’t cut
Ribbink, Jason Melhuish it anymore. So argue Kumar and Puranam, of
Seven Myths to Beat Before London Business School. The authors show
Richard Ivey School of Business
They Beat You Foundation Case how the growth of China and India as lead
TN Product #910D15 (13 pages) markets and as talent pools, coupled with
David Simchi-Levi PhD.
advances in technology, enables companies to
IESE-Insight Magazine Article A partner and owner of the Sunset Grill at
optimize their organizations by segmenting
Product #IIR048 (8 pages) Blue Mountain in the village at Blue Moun-
R&D both vertically and horizontally, thereby
tain, Ontario, had very mixed emotions. The
Many traditional operations strategies—such creating T-shaped structures. The greatest
restaurant had just finished its first year of
as just-in-time, lean manufacturing, and challenge of the T-shaped structure is manag-
operation and had broken even, and had been
offshoring—may not suffice in today’s trickier ing integration across countries. The solution
named Business of the Year in the counties
global economy, which is marked by rising is to allow your corporation’s center of gravity
of Simcoe and Grey. On the other hand, the
labor costs in developing countries and huge to shift eastward. That means globalizing the
owner knew that operations were still far from
volatility in oil and other commodity prices. top management team, moving headquarters
perfect. This case was written for courses
Sticking to received wisdom risks doing more outside the home country, and genuinely valu-
on operations, particularly in the section on
harm than good by imperiling a firm’s control ing the cultural shifts that those two changes
managing capacity and demand. It could also
over its supply chain. In this article based on require. Companies such as GE, Intel, and
be used in a service management or service
his book Operations Rules: Delivering Customer AstraZeneca have had some success in these
operation course.
Value Through Flexible Operations, the author endeavors, and all multinationals have the
tackles seven myths that companies often potential to secure the advantages of deploy-
struggle with in their operations. Recognizing ing a T-shaped structure.
these myths, he says, can help an organization ORGANIZATIONAL
avoid potential problems. Unfortunately, some BEHAVIOR HSN’s CEO on Fixing the Shopping
of these pitfalls are disguised as quite-reason- Network’s Culture
able strategic goals. But when these pitfalls are
Have You Restructured for Mindy Grossman
followed, an organization is almost guaran-
Global Success? Harvard Business Review Article
teed to fail or miss opportunities. Considering
Nirmalya Kumar, Phanish Puranam Product #R1112A (5 pages)
issues such as cost cutting, product character-
istics, and information technology, the author Harvard Business Review Article When Mindy Grossman was approached to
stresses that flexibility is the key for compa- Product # R1110J (7 pages) head the parent company of Home Shopping
nies to innovate their operations and supply The organizational structures of many Network, she had no television experience,
chain strategies and to compete successfully multinational corporations are inadequate no direct-to-consumer experience, and no
in turbulent times. to the task of capitalizing on opportunities experience in most of the product categories
in emerging markets. Locating customer- HSN sold. She’d never even watched a home
facing processes in each country—and even shopping channel. But after a crash course
consisting of channel surfing, she had an
“aha” moment: she realized that HSN needed
to become more of a lifestyle network that
TEACHING AND THE CASE METHOD would inspire people through products. That
pitch won her the job. Then she visited head-
quarters—where the staff appeared downtrod-
Case Study Handbook den and the organization seemed frozen in
How to Read, Discuss, and Write time. Grossman saw that she would need to
Persuasively About Cases dramatically alter the company culture, under-
stand and reposition the brand, and devise a
By William Ellet
new product strategy. She began with white
Ideal for students new to the case method, paint and new office chairs.
The Case Study Handbook presents a powerful A BEST-SELLING BOOK
approach for analyzing, discussing, and writing FOR STUDENTS Is Sony Turning Around?
about cases. Individual chapters are ideal for
including in a course pack. Best-selling chapters AVAILABLE IN CHAPTERS Marcus Schuetz, Atsushi Sumi,
include:
Harvard Business Review Press Claudia H.L. Woo
.+ 10ƫņƫāĆĉąƫ
University of Hong Kong Case
čƫĊĈĉġāġąĂĂāġĀāĆĉġĂƫ
Q Analyzing a Case #2449BC ,!.'ƫđƫĂĈăƫ,#!/ƫđƫĸĂąċĊĆ Product #HKU954 (30 pages)
Q How to Discuss a Case #2450BC

Q How to Write a Case-Based Essay #2451BC Instead of adopting more commonly used
standards that appeal to a consumers’ taste,

TN TEACHING NOTE AVAILABLE hbsp.harvard.edu 1-800-545-7685 | 17


O RG A N I Z AT I O N A L B EH AVI O R — SALES

Sony’s traditional focus on its own technolo- measurable progress by honing and practicing of this project and the trade-offs inherent in
gies has trapped the company in the state of basic techniques. But developing a strength mixing social and business goals. Further-
“Galapagos-ization” (garapagosu-ka) that seg- is a different matter, because simply doing more, as background, the case provides detail
regates the company from global competition. more of what you’re good at will yield only on Salesforce’s 1-1-1 business model whereby
Since the mid-1990s, the company has been incremental improvements. If you are strong the company contributes 1 percent of product,
struggling with unstable profit and sales in its technically, becoming even more of a technical 1 percent of equity, and 1 percent of employee
core electronics business while it aggressively expert won’t make you a dramatically better hours back to the communities it serves.
expands into the entertainment content sector. leader. If, however, you use what the authors
A number of restructuring strategies had been call “nonlinear development”—similar to an
implemented, but the effect was not sustained athlete’s cross-training—you can achieve expo-
due to various internal conflicts within the nential results. Your technical expertise will
SALES
company. In mid-2005, a non-Japanese, Sir become more powerful if, for instance, you
Howard Stringer, was appointed as the first build on your communication skills, enabling Entrepreneurial Sales Strategies:
Western CEO and chairman of Sony. Stringer you to explain technical problems both more Namaste Laboratories Pursues New
pushed forward a series of operational broadly and more effectively. The authors, all Markets for Hair Care Products
restructurings and placed a greater focus on from the leadership-development consultancy Cheryl Mayberry-McKissack,
software and content development than on Zenger Folkman, present a step-by-step pro- Tracey Robinson-English
Sony’s tradition business, hardware technol- cess by which developing leaders can identify Kellogg School of Management,
ogy. Even though Stringer’s change efforts had their strengths (through either a formal or Northwestern Case
brought a blink of hope for Sony’s comeback, an informal 360-degree evaluation), select TN Product #KEL529 (10 pages)

the situation turned sour in early 2009 when appropriate complementary skills (the article The Namaste case is a story of how Kellogg
the company announced its first operating identifies 6–10 for each core strength), and alumni couple Gary and Denise Gardner
loss in 14 years. While different voices about develop those skills to dramatically improve grow their Namaste-branded hair care line
the problems of Sony arose and the leadership their strengths, making themselves uniquely from production at the family’s kitchen table
of Stringer was questioned, another round of valuable to their companies. into a formidable $80 million empire within
restructuring attempts was pushed forward a 14-year period. The Gardners come from
by Stringer. How could Stringer overcome the One Acre Fund: Outgrowing a longtime hair care business lineage, the
deep-rooted internal resistance that his prede- the Board Soft Sheen dynasty, started by Gary’s father
cessor had failed to overcome? What had gone decades earlier. Soft Sheen was ultimately
Elliot Sherman, Anne Cohn Donnelly
wrong with the iconic electronics giant? Were sold to hair care giant L’Oreal for over $100
Kellogg School of Management,
all those restructuring and change efforts nec- million. Gardner claims Namaste’s growth
Northwestern Case
essary and useful to Sony’s turnaround? TN Product #KEL542 (13 pages) occurred through listening to the needs and
desires of customers for healing hair care
Liberté, Egalité, Sororité: How Should A young international nonprofit social
products that reminded them of nourish-
enterprise governed by friends of the founder
France Achieve Boardroom Parité? ing household remedies. The hair care line
grows rapidly and faces increasing demands
Boris Groysberg, Hilary Fischer-Groban became a leader in its industry but faced the
for resources and key connections to major
Harvard Business School Case dilemma of how to expand sales in new mar-
potential donors, expertise in going to scale,
Product #412061 (25 pages) kets, especially international markets such as
and managing expansion. The case presents
South Africa and Nigeria.
The French government is considering man- this issue commonly faced by new nonprofits
dating a gender quota for corporate boards. and details how the organization, led by the
board chair, seeks to resolve it through rede- The Future of Shopping
Other countries have approached the question
of gender equity in corporate governance in sign of the board and major changes in board Darrell Rigby
various ways. Which model might best work membership. Harvard Business Review Article
for France? Product #R1112C (12 pages)
Social Innovation at salesforce.com When the dot-com bubble burst 10 years ago,
Making Yourself Indispensable Christopher Marquis, Marley C. the ensuing collapse wiped out half of all
John H. Zenger, Joseph Folkman, Kornreich, Bobbi Thomason online retailers. Today, e-commerce is well
Scott K. Edinger Harvard Business School Case established and much digital retailing is now
Harvard Business Review Article Product # 412049 (19 pages) highly profitable. As it evolves, digital retailing
Product #R1110E (9 pages) is quickly morphing into something so differ-
Salesforce.com recently implemented an
ent that it requires a new name: omnichannel
Peter Drucker and other leadership thinkers innovative social enterprise business model
retailing. The name reflects the fact that retail-
have long argued that leaders should focus on whereby the Salesforce.com Foundation funds
ers will be able to interact with customers
strengthening their strengths. How should its operations and grant budget by selling
through countless channels—web sites, physi-
they do that? Improving on a weakness is discounted Salesforce.com software licenses
cal stores, kiosks, direct mail and catalogs,
pretty easy and straightforward: you can make to nonprofits and education clients. The case
call centers, social media, mobile devices,
recounts the development and initial stages

18 | SPRING 2012 Teaching Materials Newsletter


SA LES — SERVICE MA N AGEMEN T — SOCIA L EN T ERPRISE

gaming consoles, televisions, networked appli- intra-agency leadership processes, manag- the high end of Zappos’ estimated market
ances, home services, and more. If traditional ing creative processes, and managing client value. Hsieh and Lin, Zappos’ CEO and COO,
retailers hope to survive, they must embrace relationships. respectively, knew that much of Zappos’
omnichannel retailing and also transform growth, and hence its value, had been due to
the one big feature Internet retailers lack— the company’s strong culture and obsessive
stores—from a liability into an asset. They emphasis on customer service. In 2009, they
must turn shopping into an entertaining,
SERVICE MANAGEMENT
were focusing on the three C’s—clothing,
exciting, and emotionally engaging experi- customer service, and company culture—the
ence by skillfully blending the physical with Zappos.com 2009: Clothing, keys to the company’s continued growth.
the digital. They must also hire new kinds of Customer Service, and Company Hsieh and Lin had only a few days to consider
talent, move away from outdated measures of Culture whether to recommend the merger to Zappos’
success, and become adept at rapid test-and- Frances X. Frei, Robin J. Ely, board at their July 21 meeting.
learn methodologies. A successful omnichan- Laura Winig
nel strategy should not only guarantee a Harvard Business School Case
retailer’s survival—no small matter in today’s Product #610015 (27 pages)
environment—but also deliver a revolution in
SOCIAL ENTERPRISE
On July 17, 2009, Zappos.com, a privately
customers’ expectations and experiences.
held online retailer of shoes, clothing, and B Lab: Building a New Sector of
other soft-line retail categories, learned that the Economy
What Would Don Draper Do? Rules Amazon.com, a $19 billion multinational
for Restoring the Contemporary Christopher Marquis, Andrew Klaber,
online retailer, had won its Board of Directors’
Agency Mojo Bobbi Thomason
approval to offer to merge the two companies.
Harvard Business School Case
David Strutton, David G. Taylor Amazon had been courting Zappos since
TN Product #411047 (32 pages)
Business Horizons Article 2005, hoping a merger would enable Amazon
Product #BH450 (13 pages) to expand and strengthen its market share in The founders of B Lab are on a mission to
soft-line retail categories. While Amazon’s create a new sector of the economy and are
What are the timeless truths of advertising?
interest intrigued Zappos’ senior executives, specifically focused on a three objectives: 1)
How can agency leaders manage their teams,
they had not felt the time was right—until building a community of Certified B Corpo-
creative talent, and clients? To answer these
now. Amazon’s offer—10 million shares of rations (B=Benefit) that legally expand their
and other questions, the mythology of the
stock (valued at $807 million), $40 million corporate responsibilities to include consid-
“Golden Age of Advertising” is examined and
in cash, restricted stock units for Zappos’ eration of diverse stakeholder interests, 2)
analyzed herein. Specifically, using adman
employees, and a promise that Zappos could advancing the public policies necessary to
Don Draper—protagonist of the fictional
operate as an independent subsidiary—was on create a new corporate form called a Benefit
but already culturally iconic television series
the table. Zappos’ financial advisor, Morgan Corporation, and 3) creating an investment
Mad Men—as a mythic archetype, lessons
Stanley, estimated the future equity value of rating system to help drive institutional invest-
are extracted for contemporary advertising
an IPO to be between $650 million and $905 ment to the emerging asset class of “impact
practitioners. Ten timeless rules are proposed
million; this estimate skewed the Amazon investments.” The case considers the chal-
and explicated in the areas of managing
offer—at least in financial terms—toward lenges associated with achieving each one of

STRATEGY

Passion and Purpose


Stories from the Best and Brightest Young Business Leaders
By John Coleman, Daniel Gulati, and W.O. Segovia

This inspiring new book draws on personal stories from recent Harvard Business School
MBAs, as well as a survey of students from top U.S. business schools, for insights about
assuming leadership after graduation. AVAILABLE IN CHAPTERS
Harvard Business Review Press
“With America—and the world—at a major inflection point, strong and principled Product #10343
leadership is as crucial as it’s ever been. As this book shows, the younger generation ISBN 978-1-4221-6266-8
is stepping up more and more each day to provide that leadership—in ways all of us . +2!.ƫđƫĂĉĉƫ,#!/ƫƫĸĂĆċĊĆ

should be paying attention to.”


—David Gergen, Director, Center for Public Leadership at the Harvard Kennedy School;
senior political analyst, CNN; and former presidential advisor

TN TEACHING NOTE AVAILABLE hbsp.harvard.edu 1-800-545-7685 | 19


S OC I A L E N T E R P R I S E — STRATEGY

these objectives, let alone all three at the same mentally, CPDC was afflicted with what might Game Time Decision for AppDirect
time. Is B Lab’s tripartite strategy its secret be called organizational schizophrenia, with Andrei Hagiu, Laura Arjona,
sauce or its albatross? two different lines of business, each with its Emily Zhang
own organizational structure, funding mecha-
Harvard Business School Case
Cause-Related Marketing: 3M as a nism, and supporters on the board of direc- TN Product #712410 (15 pages)
Corporate Sponsor of the Canadian tors. The case presents the question of what
strategies and, ultimately, business model the AppDirect is a start-up that offers small busi-
Breast Cancer Foundation
incoming CEO should adopt to keep the orga- nesses software-as-a-service solutions through
Allison Johnson, Laurie Dudo a business app marketplace and portal. Daniel
nization viable and fulfill its mission.
Richard Ivey School of Business Saks, cofounder and co-CEO, is faced with the
Foundation Case key question of deciding distribution strategy:
TN Product #W11047 (18 pages)
should AppDirect find channel partners or
3M Canada (3M) has been a corporate sponsor
STRATEGY create a self-branded platform? The case
of the Canadian Breast Cancer Foundation describes the evolving business app market by
(CBCF, or the Foundation) since 2005. In sup- Adaptability: The New Competitive analyzing the strategies and business models
port of the CBCF, 3M has produced and sold Advantage of competitors for both the marketplace and
“pink products” (products that bear the pink Martin Reeves, Mike Deimler portal products. The marketplace offers small
ribbon, such as Post-it Notes and flag pens, Harvard Business Review Article businesses search, trial, and purchase of
Nexcare bandages, and Scotch-Brite sponges), Product #R1107M (9 pages) software-as-a-service apps for a wide range of
with a contribution of each sale benefiting business needs, from customer management
Traditional approaches to strategy assume to human resources, while the portal service
the CBCF. This case examines the corporate
that the world is relatively stable and predict- gives businesses the ability to manage all their
sponsorship relationship, specifically how
able. But globalization, new technologies, apps in one place, from user management to
3M’s brand manager for Post-it–brand office
and greater transparency have combined to single sign-on. The case encourages discus-
products can further activate the relationship
upend the business environment. In this sion on the evolution and future direction of
with CBCF. The brand manager’s marketing
period of risk and uncertainty, more and more this nascent market.
campaign for 2009 was successful; however,
managers are finding competitive advantage
she now needs to determine the best approach
in organizational capabilities that foster rapid
for her 2010 campaign. ICICI Bank’s Credit Card: Journey
adaptation. Instead of being really good at
to Asian Leadership
doing some particular thing, companies must
The Test of Transition: The Case of be really good at learning how to do new Arunaditya Sahay, Shilpi Jain,
the Community Preservation and things. Those that thrive are quick to read Vineet Kapoor
Development Corporation and act on weak signals of change. They have University of Hong Kong Case
Alexander Von Hoffman worked out how to experiment rapidly and TN Product # HKU935 (28 pages)

Harvard Kennedy School Case frequently not only with products and services When ICICI, an Indian private bank, entered
TN Product #HKS123 (27 pages) but also with business models, processes, and the retail banking market in the 1990s with
strategies. They have acquired the skills to little technology infrastructure, capital, and
The Community Preservation and Devel-
manage complex multi-stakeholder systems retail expertise, few expected it to succeed.
opment Corporation (CPDC), one of the
in an increasingly interconnected world. And Public-sector banks, holding 75 percent of
best-known nonprofit housing development
perhaps most important, they have learned to deposits, were dominating the retail banking
companies in the United States, is at a time
unlock their greatest resource: the people who market, and foreign giants had cornered the
of fundamental transition, due largely to a
work for them. The authors, senior partners market for high-net-worth individuals living in
new chief executive officer. The first CEO
at the Boston Consulting Group, review these the major cities across India. With a strategy
had made a specialty of using a variety of
four types of organizational capabilities, show- to offer credit cards to the middle class, abol-
complicated financial arrangements to revive
ing what companies at the leading edge are ish annual fees, and enter into partnerships
assisted low-income housing projects that had
doing to create them. They also discuss the with major retailers, ICICI quickly proved the
become or were at risk of becoming dilapi-
particular implications of this fundamental skeptics wrong. Revenues per employee grew
dated, crime-ridden disasters. The organiza-
strategic shift for large corporations, many of to over $9 million compared to about $3 mil-
tion had become famous for blazing new
which have built their operations around scale lion for the Bank of India and slightly below
trails in providing services for the low-income
and efficiency—sources of advantage predi- $160,000 for Standard Chartered. The lofty
residents of its housing projects, particularly
cated on an essentially stable environment. number one position was achieved by Vaidya-
related to technology. But CPDC was a house
divided. Concerned about CPDC’s difficulties nathan, ICICI’s head of retail, and his team.
in accounting and reporting its revenues and Their progressive initiatives were focused
expenditures, members of the board of direc- on developing new products and improving
tors became more involved in running the consumer service experiences. As the 2008–
organization and contributed to the departure 2009 financial crisis tripled the percentage of
of the organization’s founding CEO. Funda- nonperforming assets in the Indian banking

20 | SPRING 2012 Teaching Materials Newsletter


ST RAT EGY

case describes Haier’s rise over three decades,


STRATEGY from a defunct refrigerator factory in China’s
Shandong province to an international player
with $5.5 billion in overseas sales. Haier had
Understanding Michael Porter
followed a nontraditional expansion strategy
The Essential Guide to Competition
of entering the developed markets of Europe
and Strategy
and the United States as a niche player before
By Joan Magretta venturing into Middle Eastern and neighbor-
ing Asian markets. Looking ahead to the next
Michael Porter’s groundbreaking ideas on
decade, Haier CEO Zhang Ruimin saw oppor-
competition and strategy are required reading AVAILABLE IN CHAPTERS
for MBA students—but they often misunderstand Harvard Business Review Press
tunities for Haier to grow through product
his concepts. Written by Porter’s former editor Product # 13023 diversification and additional market penetra-
at Harvard Business Review, this book provides ƫĊĈĉġāġąĂĂāġćĀĆĊġćƫ tion in both developed and emerging markets.
. +2!.ƫđƫĂĀĉƫ,#!/ƫđƫĸĂąċĊĆ
an engaging and highly readable summary of He and his colleagues would depend on their
Porter’s ideas and includes an original Q&A with experience of acquiring numerous companies,
Porter, including answers to FAQs. entering and retaining new markets, restructur-
ing the organization, and managing hundreds
of subsidiaries around the world. They would
need to determine which of the lessons learned
from Haier’s international operations should
industry, Vaidyanathan had to plan how ICICI current procedures, including fine-tuning the be implemented in China and which skills
would adapt to the new environment and philanthropic giving strategy that is the main learned at home could best be applied abroad.
maintain industry leadership. component of its social mission.
How Great Companies Think
Good Capital and Better World Grolsch: Growing Globally Differently
Books (A): A Better World for Pankaj Ghemawat, Steven A. Altman Rosabeth Moss Kanter
Investing Harvard Business School Case Harvard Business Review Article
Jamie Jones, Jennifer Yee, Wes Selke TN Product #PG0001 (31 pages) Product #R1111C (11 pages)
Kellogg School of Management Case Grolsch reassesses its international strategy in Corporate leaders have long subscribed to
TN Product #KEL526 (14 pages)
light of the company’s recent acquisition by the belief that the sole purpose of business
The purpose of this case is to introduce the SABMiller, the world’s second-largest brewer. is to make money. That narrow view, deeply
topic of socially responsible investing from Grolsch was the 21st-largest global beer brand, embedded in the American capitalist system,
both the investor and investee perspectives. sold 51.5 percent of its volume in interna- molds the actions of most corporations,
The students will walk away with an under- tional markets, and exported to 70 countries. constraining them to focus on maximizing
standing of 1) how to evaluate a portfolio However, its poor profitability in international short-term profits and returns to shareholders
company on a social/environmental mission markets—four countries alone accounting for at the expense of worker safety and health,
and on traditional financial criteria, and 2) two-thirds of foreign sales—and churn of the environment, and society in general. In
what considerations should be top of mind markets and distribution partners raised this article, HBS professor Kanter argues that
for a social venture considering accepting an concerns about the company’s international a very different logic informs the practices of
equity investment. Wes Selke is a portfolio strategy and execution. Grolsch’s 60 years most high-performing and sustainable compa-
manager at Good Capital, an investment fund of history in foreign markets provide a rich nies: an institutional logic. These companies
created to increase the flow of capital to inno- backdrop to introduce a range of interna- believe that they are more than moneymaking
vative nonprofit and for-profit social ventures tional strategy topics, including performance machines; they are also a vehicle for advanc-
that are using market-based solutions to solve assessment, rationale for expansion, market ing societal goals. They deliver more than just
problems of poverty, illiteracy, and inequality. selection, and choice of entry mode. financial returns; they also build enduring
In 2007, Good Capital is ready to make its institutions. At great companies, institutional
first growth equity investment in a for-profit Haier: Taking a Chinese Company logic takes its place alongside economic logic
social enterprise and Selke is considering Global in 2011 in research, analysis, and managerial decision
Better World Books as the firm’s primary making. Six facets of institutional logic—a
Tarun Khanna, Krishna G. Palepu,
target. Selke must evaluate whether or not the Phillip Andrews common purpose, a long-term focus, emo-
firm is a financially sound investment and if tional engagement, partnering with the public,
Harvard Business School Case
its social and environmental missions can be innovation, and self-organization—radically
Product #712408 (23 pages)
preserved upon a liquidation event. If Good alter leadership and corporate behavior and
Capital proceeds with the investment, Selke In 2011, Haier, China’s leading appliance form the building blocks of a more sustain-
must also rework some of Better World Books’ manufacturer, had over $20 billion in world- able competitive advantage.
wide sales and had just been named the lead-
ing refrigerator manufacturer worldwide. The

TN TEACHING NOTE AVAILABLE hbsp.harvard.edu 1-800-545-7685 | 21


STRAT E GY

Know What Your Customers Want Mittal Steel in 2006: Changing ness to readers and advertisers that responded
Before They Do the Steel Game to why they “hired” the paper in the first place.
To implement his new strategy he terminated
Thomas H. Davenport, Pankaj Ghemawat, Ravi Madhavan
Leandro Dalle Mule, John Lucker senior managers and others who he did not
Harvard Business School Case
feel could contribute to the new paper, and
Harvard Business Review Article TN Product #PG0002 (31 pages)
made significant changes in key dimen-
Product #R1112E (8 pages)
Mittal Steel’s remarkable rise to the top of the sions of implementation: culture, structure,
Shoppers once relied on familiar salespeople steel industry spearheaded a wave of cross- information and decision support systems,
to help them find exactly what they wanted— border consolidation that aimed to fundamen- incentives, and human resources. Through-
and sometimes to suggest additional items tally change the industry’s competitive and out he used a mix of both authoritative and
they hadn’t even thought of. But today’s geographic structure. This case provides the participative change management—a mix that
distracted consumers, bombarded with infor- opportunity to examine how Lakshmi Mittal may provoke an interesting class discussion.
mation and options, often struggle to find built his company’s position via international
products or services that meet their needs. acquisitions, to assess the logic of global
Advances in information technology, data integration in the steel industry, and to think Responding to the Wii?
gathering, and analytics are making it possible through how Mittal can continue adding
Andrei Hagiu, Hanna Halaburda
to deliver something like the personal advice value to its acquired operations on an ongoing
of yesterday’s sales staffs. Using increasingly HBS Premier Case Collection
basis (i.e., post-turnaround) as a global steel
TN Product #709448 (19 pages)
granular customer data, businesses are start- company.
ing to create highly customized offers that After years of gaming console industry
steer shoppers to the “right” merchandise— Northlands Ledger (A): leadership, how should Sony respond to the
at the right moment, at the right price, and in Management Style, Strategy, overwhelming success of competitor Nin-
the right channel. But few companies can do tendo’s user-friendly Wii over Sony’s high-tech
and Performance
this well. The authors demonstrate how retail- PlayStation 3? It was August 2008, and Kazuo
ers can hone their “next best offer” (NBO) Robert Dewar
Hirai, chief executive of Sony Computer
capability by breaking the problem down into Kellogg School of Management,
Entertainment Inc. (SCEI), was contemplat-
Northwestern Case
four steps: defining objectives, gathering data ing questions from reporters about how Sony
TN Product # KEL536 (9 pages)
(about your customers, your products, and the planned to respond to Nintendo’s Wii console,
purchase context), analyzing and executing, Case (A) describes the situation at the North- which was dramatically leading Sony’s Play-
and learning and evolving. Citing success- lands Ledger, a newspaper on its way out of Station 3 and Microsoft’s Xbox 360 consoles
ful strategies in companies such as Tesco, business due in large part to its publisher’s in sales. The Wii’s supremacy was especially
Zappos, Microsoft, and Walmart, they provide and editors’ focus on what they do and want to disconcerting to Hirai, given that Sony had
a framework for nailing the NBO. keep doing rather than on what their custom- dominated the video game industry and
ers (readers and advertisers) want. The value largely defined its course since 1995. But the
Making a Blue Ocean Strategic proposition to the reader is that they deliver tables had turned dramatically in the current
Move That Discourages Imitation the paper reliably and provide the latest generation. Though the Wii was technologi-
national and international news. The value cally much less advanced than were PS3 and
W. Chan Kim, Renee Mauborgne,
proposition to the advertisers is that they print Xbox 360, the Wii’s ease of use, innovative
Katrina Ling
ads accurately and runs them on time. Both motion-sensitive controller, and simple but
INSEAD Case
value propositions are outdated, and, even if fun games had made the console a hit with
TN Product #BOS020 (12 pages)
they were what the customers wanted, which all demographics: nine to 65 years old, male
This case is excellent for teaching both MBAs they were not, neither was being executed and female. As a result, Nintendo had stolen a
and executives how to create a blue ocean well. The paper’s key performance indica- march on its two larger rivals by appealing to
strategy that is hard to imitate and sustainable. tors—circulation, classified ads, and commer- people who were traditionally not avid video
It focuses on Wikipedia versus Britannica.com cial advertising—are all in decline despite the game users. Microsoft’s and Sony’s more pow-
in the online encyclopedia industry. The case fact that the community it serves is growing. erful machines remained targeted at the tradi-
teaches participants the importance of align- The senior management of the Paulus chain tional “core gamer” audience: 18-to-65-year-old
ing the three strategy propositions of value, that owns this paper has forced the pub- males. Hirai was determined to restore that
profit, and people around both differentiation lisher, Allison, to retire and brought another supremacy in the current generation or the
and low cost to break the value-cost trade-off publisher, Potter, in from one of its other next. He knew that whether or not he publicly
and create a blue ocean that is hard to imitate. papers, The Sun Belt City Star, where Potter defined SCEI’s strategy as a response to Wii,
was highly successful. However, he cannot he had to find a way for his company to deal
simply transfer his success formula from the with the new order of the video game industry
Star to the Ledger. Case (B) details his efforts that Nintendo had created. In seeking to do
and may be used as a classic example of good so, Hirai might find guidance in the history of
change management and leadership practices. the industry, which had been marked by rapid
Potter established a clear-cut set of objectives and frequent changes of fortune.
and formulated a new strategy of responsive-

22 | SPRING 2012 Teaching Materials Newsletter


ST RAT EGY

Social Strategies That Work Which Strategy When?


Mikolaj Jan Piskorski Christopher B. Bingham, Kathleen M. CONTACT US
Harvard Business Review Article Eisenhardt, Nathan R. Furr
Product #R1111H (8 pages) MIT Sloan Management Review Article
Product #SMR401 (7 pages) CUSTOMER SERVICE
Although most companies have collected lots
is available Monday–Friday
of friends and followers on social platforms Markets are changing, competition is shifting,
8 am–6 pm, ET
such as Facebook, few have succeeded in and businesses may be suffering or perhaps
generating profits there. That’s because they thriving. Whatever the immediate circum-
merely port their digital strategies into social stances, corporate managers ask the same PHONE 800-545-7685
environments by broadcasting their commer- questions: where do we go from here, and +1 617-783-7600
cial messages or seeking customer feedback. which strategy will get us there? To under- (outside the U.S. and Canada)
To succeed on social platforms, says the stand how to choose the right strategy at the
author, businesses need to devise social strate- right time, the authors analyzed the logic
gies that are consistent with users’ expecta- of the leading strategic frameworks used in
tions and behavior in these venues—namely, business and engineering schools around the TECH SUPPORT
people want to connect with other people, not world. They matched those frameworks with is available Monday–Friday
with companies. The author defines suc- the key strategic choices faced by dozens of 8 am–8 pm, ET
cessful social strategies as those that reduce industry leaders at different times, during
costs or increase customers’ willingness to periods of stability and of change. Two
PHONE 800-810-8858
pay by helping people establish or strengthen insights emerged from their analysis. First,
the frameworks divided into three archetypes: +1 617-783-7700
relationships through doing free work on a
(outside the U.S. and Canada)
company’s behalf. Citing successes at Zynga, strategies of position, strategies of leverage,
eBay, American Express, and Yelp, Piskorski and strategies of opportunity. What’s right
shows that social strategies can generate for a company depends on its circumstances,
profits by helping people connect in exchange its available resources, and how manage-
EMAIL
for tasks that benefit the company, such as ment combines those resources. Second,
custserv@hbsp.harvard.edu
customer acquisition, marketing, and content many of the assumptions about competitive
creation. He lays out a systematic way to build advantage didn’t hold. For example, although WEB
hbsp.harvard.edu
a social strategy and shows how a major credit strategy gurus talk about strategically valuable
card company he advised used the method to resources, sometimes competitive advantage
roll out its own strategy. came from very ordinary resources assembled
well. To figure out when it makes sense to
Wal-Mart Update, 2011 pursue strategies of position, leverage, or
opportunity, the authors advise managers
David B. Yoffie, Renee Kim
to understand their company’s immediate
Harvard Business School Case
circumstances, take stock of their current
TN Product #711546 (10 pages)
resources, and determine the relationships
In 2011, Wal-Mart was the world’s largest among the various resources. Understanding
company, with $420 billion in sales and these factors, they argue, will help managers
operations in 14 countries. Yet it found itself select the right strategic framework.
searching for the right growth strategy moving
forward. U.S. same-store sales had declined
for eight consecutive quarters, and Wal-Mart
was increasingly becoming dependent on
international sales. Meanwhile, intense com-
petition came from various players, ranging
from general discounters to dollar stores to
online retailers. What should Wal-Mart do as
its traditional markets and core competencies
no longer ensure the kind of growth that it
had enjoyed for decades in the past?

EDUCATORS

Get updates from us at


Twitter@HarvardBizEdu

TN TEACHING NOTE AVAILABLE hbsp.harvard.edu 1-800-545-7685 | 23


60 HARVARD WAY | BOSTON, MA 02163

IT for Management
NEW
NEW ONLINE COURSE

This new online course covers infrastructure, data, applications, Free Trials offer complete
and IT organization. Students follow staff at a fictional fitness access to the entire course
company that is expanding its technology infrastructure and and are available to Premium
building applications to automate business processes. Educators registered at

hbsp.harvard.edu
The course takes 10–12 hours to complete and includes a final
assessment. It is also available in shorter sections.

Product #4330

Product #M11227 171790212


+DUYDUG%XVLQHVV3XEOLVKLQJLVDQDI¿OLDWHRI+DUYDUG%XVLQHVV6FKRRO ‹+DUYDUG%XVLQHVV6FKRRO3XEOLVKLQJ Printed on Recycled Paper

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen