Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
No.59/31-SMU/2018
09 March 2020
Notification
1
1.2 It was realized that there was an urgent requirement to fully appreciate
the changing Governance and Technology landscape and its pace, both
within Government of India and State Governments. Significant internal
practices and structures in our peer organisations across the world were
also looked at in the process.
1.3 It was agreed that our existing strengths were needed to be reinforced
and sectoral focus and specialisation in both audit planning and reporting
had to be built and integrated into our processes more strongly. The
existing structures and processes were inherently less amenable to
specialisation and to integrated and outcome oriented audits. Also,
domain specific skill gaps and deployment of human resources were
required to be assessed and addressed, as required.
1.5 It was acknowledged widely that structures and processes that enabled
the following were amongst the elements essential to underpin the change
process
2
‘Technology Led’ and not just a ‘Technology Enabled’ focus to
work processes and audits, going forward.
3
(ii) Horizontally, Ministries/Departments have been grouped
together to form clusters that have inter-connected
outcomes or inter-relationships under an HoD.
2.2 The final structures achieved are not intended to undermine the fact
that going forward, audits of complex subjects/issues identified by Senior
Management and certain technical subjects will have to be addressed by
specialized teams at Headquarters and in the field and such audits will
involve multi-sectoral and multi-skilled teams drawn across offices. A high
level of co-operation, co-ordination, and leveraging domain expertise
outside will continue to be the mainstay of audit work.
4
(d) Clusters will be divided amongst audit offices as per Annex-1 and 2.
Annex-1 will be applicable for all States including where both audit offices
are located in one Station. States where audit offices are located in two
stations have the option of applying option 2. Under both options,
Clusters at level 1 will be in an office to be henceforth called Accountant
General (Audit I). Clusters at level 2 will be in an office to be henceforth
called office of the Accountant General (Audit II). The nomenclature is
without prejudice to seniority of the HoDs. Clusters at level 3 can be
distributed to any office. Departments within clusters cannot be
distributed without the approval of SMU. Certain small exceptions,
necessitated by how departments are organized in the State, have
already been approved and will be communicated to the concerned
State. Any further exceptions desired have to be sent to SMU with
detailed justification for approval.
(g) In States with two audit offices, HoDs are required to ensure that
distribution of staff between offices meets the functional requirements
of the IAAD in the best possible manner. Civil and Commercial audit skill
sets are now required across both offices. Revenue and works audit skill
sets are also required to be built across offices. As an illustration, public
5
works traditionally used to be executed by only public works departments
such as PWD, PHED and Irrigation Departments. However, they are being
executed increasingly by other agencies and parastatal bodies, such as
Municipal Corporations, Zila Parishads, Panchayat Samitis, Rural Works
Department, Road and Bridges corporations, Development Authorities,
Industrial Corporations, Autonomous bodies, Housing Boards,
Agricultural Marketing Committees, Police Housing Corporations, etc.
(h) Towards this, till requisite skills sets are developed, where two offices
are situated in the same station, staff engaged in commercial audit and
specialized streams like revenue, works, etc., will be required to move
across offices as necessitated by the new work distribution. In such
stations, Group officers presently looking after specialized work such as
revenue, etc., will move to the other office with their entire strength of
cadres below. No internal transfers of staff between branches/Group
officers’ charges will be made between the date of issue of these orders
and date of implementation on ground, 1 April 2020. This will help in
minimising disruption to the 2020-21 audit cycle.
(i) In States, where the two audit offices are located in different cities,
branch offices may be formed and staff movement across stations is not
envisaged. Specific proposals for constitution of branch offices, as may be
necessary, may be sent by these offices to SMU after approval of ADAI by
20 March 2020.
6
(k) Integrated audit plans for each State will be achieved from the year
2021-22. Despite work distribution as ordered, it is reiterated that audit
of certain subject matter will continue to require collaboration and
synergy between clusters and between two offices, where they exist, as
necessitated by State level comprehensive risk assessment. The latter will
be achieved, in States with two offices, by the joint audit planning group
comprising both HoDs and their ADAI.
(a) Central audit offices comprise the field offices of DGA/PDA (CE), SD,
ESM, P&T1 and Commercial.
(b) Across central audit offices except DG/PD (Central), Ministries are
grouped as given in Annex-3 in accordance with the principles of
horizontal coherence and vertical alignment outlined above.
1
CE- Central Expenditure, SD- Scientific Department, ESM-Economic and Service Ministries, P&T-Post and
Telecommunication
7
(g) HoDs are required to ensure that distribution of staff between offices
meets the functional requirements of the IAAD in the best possible
manner. Civil and Commercial audit skill sets are now required across all
offices in Delhi. Towards this, staff will be required to move across offices
as necessitated by the new work distribution. This will help in minimising
disruption to the 2020-21 audit cycle. With the approval of DAI (RC), DAI
(C,C&IS) and DAI (C), offices in their respective jurisdictions are required
to agree and propose distribution of staff between offices, distribution of
work within groups and associated staff deployment to SMU, by 20 March
2020.
5. Specialization at Headquarters
8
DAIs/ADAIs seeking specialized inputs. Ownership of audit would be of the
respective functional audit wing.
5.3 The following specialized teams/structures (paragraph 5.5 onwards)
are set up by utilising existing resources, expertise and structures and
envisaging new ones. All previous orders regarding creation of knowledge
centres, except those issued by Training wing in respect of RTIs, are
withdrawn with immediate effect. Training wing may review the
requirement keeping in view these orders.
5.4 The specialized audit offices and teams achieved as a result of this
restructuring will function as lead offices on curating, assimilating and
disseminating knowledge resources as necessary and will make them
available on Knowledge Management System (KMS) presently, and later on
the One-IAAD-One System (OIOS) KMS. A detailed Standard Operating
Procedure (SOP) on these issues will be issued in due course.
(a) An SOP has been issued for imparting required stewardship to IS audits
and requisite support to IT audits. As per the SOP, iCISA/CTO has been
vested with key roles in various stages of audit processes pertaining to
audits in this area. iCISA is under the jurisdiction of DAI (C,C&IS).
(b) An SOP has also been issued for imparting required stewardship to
audits in Environment related areas. As per the SOP, iCED and
O/o DGASD have been vested with key roles in various stages of audit
processes pertaining to audits in this area. iCED is placed under the
jurisdiction of DAI (RC).
(c) The arrangements above are a part of the design to help both the
Institutes, iCISA and iCED to truly develop as think tanks to the
Department and outside entities. However, recognizing their role in
overall training and capacity building and recognizing that both
Institutes are Global Training Facilities for the entire INTOSAI
community, Training Wing will issue an SOP for oversight on activities
relating to INTOSAI, International Training Programmes (ITPs),
National Training Programmes (NTPs), Training Calendar, liaison with
IR wing, MEA and DoPT, participation in Central Training Advisory
9
Committee (CTAC) and other aspects as necessary for both Institutes
to continue to fulfill the requirements of the overall Training and
Capacity building framework of the Department.
CRA Wing will continue to advise on all technical aspects related to GST and
its audit, for both Central and State audit offices and all tax policy and
implementation issues that may arise from time to time.
The Local Bodies Wing will continue to provide technical support and advise
on issues relating to Technical Guidance and Support (TGS) and audit of
local bodies. It will also co-ordinate with State audit offices and the
concerned central audit offices and functional wings, handling Ministry of
10
Panchayati Raj and Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs, on certain audits
that may need to be carried out across Centre and States. All issues
affecting mandate of audit of local bodies, TGS and financial reporting
issues arising from the implementation of the National Municipal Accounts
Manual for ULBs and the Model Accounting System for PRIs, will be
continued to be referred to the LB wing for a concerted response at an
organizational level, as required.
(b) In respect of each sectoral team, the list of activities would include,
at the minimum, building a professional team (Gr B, Young
professionals, interns and networking with outside experts), mapping
the entire sector, keeping abreast of national and international
developments on the sector and in other SAIs, holding consultations
and at least an annual stakeholders workshop, keeping a view on
international best practices, methods, disseminating key learnings,
identifying strategic areas of focus for audits, reviewing audit reports
on like issues across States and fundamentally liaising with Central
and State Audit offices undertaking audits in the sector by being
institutionally involved therein. These teams will maintain close
liaison with PPG for issue of any guidelines/guidance in their areas of
expertise.
(c) Other sectoral teams, as found necessary, will be constituted in the
future.
11
6. Audit Planning and Reporting
(a) Integrated audit plans for each area of activity (Industry, Agriculture,
Irrigation and Food, Energy, Infrastructure, Health and Family Welfare,
Environment, amongst others) by both Central and State audit offices
so designated and clusters so organised, in collaboration with their
joint auditors/co-auditors, as applicable, will be achieved from the
year 2021-22. (However, by delineating strategic areas of focus in
audit, some steps have already been taken towards this objective for
audits planned in 2020-21).
Encl.: As above.
All DAIs/ADAIs
All Heads of Offices in IA&AD
All Directors General/Principal Directors in Headquarters
Principal Director & Secretary to CAG
12
Annex-1
2. Education, Skill
5. Agriculture, Food & Allied
1. Health and Welfare Development and 3. Finance 4. Rural Development 6. Water Resources
Industries
Employment
Irrigation, Water
Finance
Primary Education, Higher Agriculture, Plantations, Fertilizers, Resources, Soil and Water
Women & Child Development, Lotteries, Treasuries and
Education, Secondary Education, Agriculture Marketing, Agriculture conservation, CAD,
Social Justice & Empowerment, Accounts,
Level 1
Technical Education, Sanskrit Research & Education, Agriculture Ground Water, Dam Safety
Rehabilitation, Tribal Affairs, SC, Pension & Pensioner
Education, Bhasha & Pustakalay Financial Institutions, Animal
ST & OBC Development, Welfare, State Insurance and
(Library), Translation, Husbandry, Dairy, Gopalan,
Minorities, Disability Welfare, PF, Economics & Statistics, Rural Development, Panchayati Raj
Youth & Sports Affairs, Horticulture, Sericulture, Cane
Sainik Kalyan, Hill/Spl. Area Planning, Local Audit
Labour, Employees State Development, Jute Development,
Councils, Medical Health, Family department, Revenue (State
Insurance, Employment, Skill Food Processing, Fisheries, Food,
Welfare, Ayush, Medical Excise, GST, Stamp &
Development, ITI, Public Service Civil Supplies and Consumer
Education Registration and excluding
Commission Affairs, Cooperatives
Land Revenue), Endowment
13. IT and Communication 14. Law and Order 15. Culture and Tourism 16. General Administration
General Administration
(Collectorates including land
Level 3
Finance
Lotteries, Treasuries and
Accounts,
Level 2
Transport,
Mining & Geology, Steel, Pension & Pensioner
Waterways, Metro, Public Works,
Industries, MSME, Village Forest, Environment, Wildlife, Welfare, State Insurance
Energy (Thermal, Hydro, State Motor Roads & Bridges,
Industries, Trade, Commerce, Science & Technology, and PF, Economics &
Renewable), Petroleum (Gas) Garage, Civil Public Heath
Factories and Boilers, Textile, Meteorology Statistics, Planning, LAD,
Aviation, Ports, Engineering,
Handicraft, Handloom Revenue (State Excise,
MVT
GST, Stamp & Registration
and excluding Land
Revenue), Endowment
General Administration
(Collectorates including land
Level 3
1
3 Principal Director of Audit Earth Sciences
(Environment and Scientific Environment, Forest and Climate Change
Departments) Science and Technology
Department of Space
(DGSD, Delhi) Atomic Energy
New & Renewable Energy (MNRE)
B. The following office is formed at Delhi under the charge of DAI (Coord, Commn. & IS)
C. The following offices are formed/modified under the charge of DAI (Commercial)
Ministries were audited from the O/o PD ESM at Delhi. MABs handled audit of all CPSEs. In line
with the principle of vertical alignment, Ministries are shifted from the ESM office to MABs and
all such offices have been given a sectoral identity. As a consequence, ESM also gains a sectoral
identity and related CPSEs from other MABs in Delhi stand transferred to it. CPSEs will move
according to the principle of vertical integration across Delhi.
CPSEs will remain geographically distributed in offices outside Delhi with the only change being
that audit of Ministries of Coal, Steel, Shipping and Mines are being shifted from Delhi to
respective MABs outside Delhi, as below. A detailed clarification, as required, will be issued by
Commercial wing.
Civil and Commercial Staff will have to be accordingly relocated between these offices in Delhi
jointly by respective cadre control offices in consultation with constituent offices and approval of
DAI (C). The final staff distribution and Group Officer Charges achieved should be intimated to
SMU by 20 March 2020. Additional strength of Group officers, overall amongst these offices taken
together, is not envisaged.
2
The offices at Delhi will be responsible for sectoral annual audit plans and inputs for strategic plan.
As indicated in column 3, Joint Auditors will contribute in arriving at sectoral perspectives and
finalising strategic and annual areas of focus for audit planning. Any modifications in joint
auditors, sub-auditors will however be clarified by the functional wing.
Offices
SN Ministries allotted Joint Auditors
(renamed as below)
INDUSTRY CLUSTER
1 Principal Director of Audit Finance (DFS and DIPAM), (DFS) - PDA (Shipping),
(Industry and Corporate Corporate Affairs offices at Hyderabad and
Affairs) Chennai
Ministry of Heavy Industries
(Currently ESM office, Delhi) Commerce & Industry
Micro, Small & Medium Industry - PDA (Steel), PDA
Enterprises (MSME) (Mines), Hyderabad and
Textile Ranchi, Chennai
Department of Chemicals &
Petrochemicals
Tourism
2 Principal Director of Audit Steel Hyderabad
(Steel)
Ranchi
Presently MAB Ranchi
INFRASTRUCTURE CLUSTER
5 Principal Director of Audit Housing and Urban Affairs Office handling Ministry of
(Infrastructure) Road Transport and Highways Shipping and office at Chennai
Delhi Civil Aviation & Hyderabad
(Presently MAB I Delhi)
6 Principal Director of Audit Shipping Chennai
(Shipping)
Mumbai
(Presently MAB I Mumbai)
3
7 Principal Director of No change
Commercial Audit Chennai
(Presently MAB Chennai)
ENERGY CLUSTER
8 Principal Director of Audit Power Office handling Ministry of
(Energy) Petroleum and Natural Gas Coal
Delhi (Ministry and downstream oil Offices at Ranchi, Chennai
(Presently MAB II and MAB CPSEs) Office handling audit of
III Delhi, which are combined BHEL upstream oil CPSEs
into one office)
9 Principal Director of Audit Coal
(Coal)
Kolkata
(Presently MAB II Kolkata)
Sd/-
Principal Director (SMU)
4
Annex-4
i. The work related to audit of central expenditure is separated from the Office of the
Principal Director of Audit (Central) and constituted as separate offices, under the
jurisdiction of RC wing. The existing offices of DG/PD (Central) would henceforth
audit only central revenue and continue to report to DAI (CRA).
ii. The following branch offices currently dealing with the audit of Central Expenditure
exclusively are brought under the jurisdiction of RC wing
a. Gwalior branch office of DGACR, Delhi
b. Allahabad branch office of PDAC, Lucknow
c. Andaman & Nicobar Islands branch office of DGAC, Kolkata
iii. The post of one Group Officer and the cadres below (posting to be effected once
existing vacancies are satisfactorily addressed) in the following DG (Central)/PD
(Central) Audit Offices, which are currently earmarked for conducting audit of
Central Expenditure, is transferred under the jurisdiction of the RC wing.
a. Chandigarh
b. Bengaluru
c. Mumbai
d. Kolkata
iv. In Mumbai and Kolkata, offices headed by PDs/DGs are envisaged.
v. In other stations (Ahmedabad, Chennai, and Hyderabad) proposals detailing
reporting structure, workload, staff requirement and need for Group Officer, are
required to be sent to SMU.
vi. Any units which fall under the jurisdiction of DAI (Commercial) but located under
the geographical jurisdiction of these newly constituted (Central Expenditure)
offices would also be audited by these new offices dealing with audit of Central
Expenditure.
vii. There is no change in the existing cadre controlling arrangements. The cadre
controlling authorities concerned will continue to provide staff to these branch
offices, even after they are shifted under the administrative control of the new
offices/central audit offices in Delhi.
viii. A detailed order on the jurisdiction of all such newly created offices may be
proposed by RC wing to SMU for approval and constitution of the new offices.
Sd/-
Principal Director (SMU)