Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Abstract: This study presents an experimental evaluation for the performance properties of polymer modified asphalt
(PMA) binders containing warm mix asphalt (WMA) additives. The PMA binders with the additives were produced using
two of the available warm asphalt processes (i.e., Aspha-min and Sasobit) and three PMA binders graded as performance
grade (PG) 76-22. The warm PMA binders were artificially short-term and then long-term aged using the rolling thin film
oven (RTFO) and pressure aging vessel (PAV) procedures. Superpave binder tests were carried out on the binders through
the rotational viscometer (RV), the dynamic shear rheometer (DSR), and the bending beam rheometer (BBR). In general,
the results of this research indicated that (1) the addition of the WMA additives into the PMA binders showed positive ef-
fects on increasing rutting resistance at high temperature (based on the high failure temperature values from the DSR test);
(2) the PMA binders containing the additives were observed to be less resistant to fatigue cracking at intermediate temper-
atures compared to the control PMA binders (based on the G*sin d values at 25 8C from the DSR test); and (3) the addi-
tion of wax additive represented a possible lower resistance on low temperature cracking (based on the stiffness and the
m-value at –12 8C from the BBR test).
Key words: PMA, WMA additives, rutting, fatigue cracking, low temperature cracking.
Résumé : La présente étude traite de l’évaluation expérimentale des propriétés de comportement des liants bitumineux modi-
fiés par polymères (« PMA ») contenant des adjuvants de mélanges bitumineux chauds (« WMA »). Les liants PMA avec les
adjuvants ont été produits par deux procédés bitumineux chauds disponibles (« Alpha-min » et « Sasobit ») et trois liants PMA
classé comme ayant une classe de rendement (« PG ») 76-22. Les liants PMA chauds ont été âgés artificiellement à court et à
long terme en utilisant les procédures de film mince roulant au four (« RTFO ») et d’essai de vieillissement PAV. Les essais
sur les liants Superpave ont été réalisés en utilisant un viscosimètre rotatif (« RV »), le rhéomètre dynamique de cisaillement
(« DSR ») et le rhéomètre à flexion de poutre (« BBR »). Règle générale, les résultats de cette recherche indiquent que
(1) l’ajout d’adjuvants WMA dans les liants PMA a engendré des effets positifs d’augmentation de la résistance à la création
d’ornières à température élevée (selon les valeurs de défaillance à température élevée de l’essai DSR), (2) les liants PMA
contenant des adjuvants ont été moins résistants aux fissures de fatigue à des températures moyennes que les liants PMA de
référence (selon les valeurs G*sin d à 25 8C de l’essai DSR) et (3) l’ajout d’un adjuvant de cire présentait une résistance possi-
blement plus faible à la fissuration à basse température (selon la rigidité et la valeur m à –12 8C selon l’essai BBR).
Mots-clés : « PMA », adjuvants WMA, création d’ornières, fissuration de fatigue, fissuration à basse température.
[Traduit par la Rédaction]
Can. J. Civ. Eng. 37: 17–24 (2010) doi:10.1139/L09-118 Published by NRC Research Press
18 Can. J. Civ. Eng. Vol. 37, 2010
Fig. 1. Flow chart of experimental design procedures. Note: PMA, polymer modified asphalt; PG, performance grade; RTFO, rolling thin
film oven; PAV, pressure aging vessel; DSR, dynamic shear rheometer; BBR, bending beam rheometer.
Binder sources
Aging states Test properties A B C
Unaged binder Rotational viscosity at 135 8C (Pas) 2.139 1.537 1.428
G*/sin d at 76 8C (kPa) 1.702 1.382 1.163
RTFO residual G*/sin d at 76 8C (kPa) 4.498 2.579 2.558
RTFO + PAV residue G*sin d at 25 8C (kPa) 2880 4167 1775
Stiffness at –12 8C (MPa) 133 175 126
m-value at –12 8C 0.336 0.301 0.333
Note: G*/sin d, rutting resistance factor; G*sin d, fatigue cracking factor; m-value, rate at which binder stiffness changes
with time at low temperatures.
(i.e., excessive carbon dioxide emission or odor problems) using rolling thin film oven (RTFO) and pressure aging ves-
(Zubeck et al. 2003). If the technologies of WMA are incorpo- sel (PAV) procedures. The high temperature viscosity prop-
rated into the PMA mixes, optimum mixing and compaction erties for the binders in the original state, the rutting
temperatues of the polymer modified mixes are expected to resistance properties in the original state and after RTFO
decrease and be comparable to those of conventional mixes. aging, the fatigue cracking properties at intermediate tem-
Prior to investigating the properties of polymer modified perature after RTFO+PAV aging methods, and the low tem-
mixes containing WMA additives, the PMA binders with the perature cracking properties after RTFO+PAV procedures
additives need to be studied. were evaluated. Figure 1 shows a flow chart of the experi-
mental design used in this study.
Research objective and scope
The objective of this research was to investigate the per- Materials and test program
formance properties of PMA binders containing WMA addi-
tives through Superpave binder tests. The warm PMA Materials
binders were manufactured with two different warm asphalt Three PG 76-22 asphalt binders designated as A, B, and C
additives, Aspha-min1 and Sasobit1, and artificially aged from different crude sources were used in this study. Binder
Table 2. Statistical analysis results of the viscosity at 135 8C of PMA binders as a function of WMA
additive and binder source (a = 0.05): N: non-significant difference, S: significant difference.
A was from a Venezuelan crude source, binder B was from (Eurovia Services 2008). Sasobit1 is a product of Sasol
a Middle Eastern source, and binder C was a mixture of sev- Wax. It is a long chain aliphatic hydrocarbon obtained from
eral sources that could not be identified by the supplier. coal gasification using the Fischer-Tropsch process which is
Each binder was graded in accordance with AASHTO a catalyzed chemical process to convert gas to liquid hydro-
M320 to verify the performance grade. Table 1 shows the carbons of various forms including gasoline, diesel, wax,
properties of the three PMA binders included in this study. and so on. After crystallization, it forms a lattice structure
The binder A was found to have the highest values for the in the binder that is the basis of the structural stability of
viscosity and rutting resistance factors while binder C had the binder containing Sasobit1. The manufacturer reports a
the lowest values for those. However, these two binders reduction in mixing and handling temperature of 50 to 908F
have the similar low temperature values (i.e., stiffness and (Sasol Wax 2009). More detailed information regarding the
m-value). two additives can be found in other reports (Hurley and Pro-
This study presented an evaluation of two additives, As- well 2005a, 2005b).
pha-min1 and Sasobit1 among a number of WMA additives
introduced (Gandhi and Amirkhanian 2007). Aspha-min1 is Production of warm PMA binders
sodium-aluminum-silicate, which is hydro thermally crystal- Two of the available commercial WMA additives were
lized as a very fine powder. It contains approximately 21% selected in making the warm PMA binders. Process 1 in-
crystalline water by weight. By adding it to an asphalt mix, cluded addition of Aspha-min1, a chemical powder at speci-
the fine water is gradually released over time, which results fied concentration (0.3% by weight of mixture — a binder
in volume expansion in the binder, therefore increasing the content of 6% was assumed, and the entire additive was
workability and compactability of the mix at lower temper- added to the binder) followed by mixing with a stirrer to
atures. According to the manufacturer, it is possible to re- disperse the powder throughout the PMA binder at 150 8C
duce the mixing and compaction temperature by 40 to 508F for 5 min. Process 2 included addition of Sasobit1, pellets
Fig. 3. High failure temperature of PMA binders with WMA additives: No aging.
Fig. 4. High failure temperature of PMA binders with WMA additives: RTFO residual.
at a specified concentration (1.5% by weight of binder) fol- (AASHTO T 313), and the dynamic shear rheometer (DSR)
lowed by mixing for 5 min (at 150 8C) in a shear mixer to test (AASHTO T 315). Three duplicate samples were tested
achieve consistent mixing (Gandhi and Amirkhanian 2007). and the results were reported as the average of these tests.
The warm PMA binders were then artificially short-term A 10.5 g binder sample of various binders was tested with
and long-term aged through the RTFO aging process for a number 27 spindle in the rotational viscometer at 135 8C.
85 min at 163 8C and the PAV method for 20 h at 100 8C In the DSR test, the binders (Original, RTFO residual, and
(Asphalt Institute 2003). RTFO+PAV residual) were tested at a frequency of 10 radi-
ans per second, which is equal to approximately 1.59 Hz.
Superpave binder tests The BBR test was conducted using each asphalt beam
The Superpave binder tests are used to quantify the as- (125 mm 6.35 mm 12.7 mm) at –12 8C, and creep
phalt’s performance at three states of its life: in its original stiffness (S) and creep rate (m) of the binders were measured
state, after mixing and construction, and after in-service at a loading time of 60 s.
aging (Asphalt Institute 2003). In this study, the properties
of warm PMA binders were evaluated using selected Super- Analysis method
pave binder test procedures including the viscosity test Statistical analysis was performed using the Statistical
(AASHTO T 316), the bending beam rheometer (BBR) test Analysis System (SAS) program to conduct analysis of var-
Table 3. Statistical analysis results of the high failure temperature of PMA binders (no aging) as a function
of WMA additive and binder source (a = 0.05): N: non-significant difference, S: significant difference.
Table 4. Statistical analysis results of the G*sin d at 25 8C of PMA binders as a function of WMA
additive and binder source (a = 0.05): N: non-significant difference, S: significant difference.
iance (ANOVA) and Fisher’s Least Significant Difference ses of this study, the level of significance was 0.05. Upon
(LSD) comparison with an a = 0.05. The primary variables determining that there were differences among sample
included the WMA additives (Control, Aspha-min1, and means using the ANOVA, the LSD was calculated. The
Sasobit1) and the PMA binder sources (A, B, and C). LSD is defined as the observed differences between two
ANOVA was performed first to determine whether signif- sample means necessary to declare the corresponding popu-
icant differences among sample means existed. In the analy- lation means difference. Once the LSD was calculated, all
Fig. 6. Stiffness at –12 8C of PMA binders with WMA additives: RTFO+PAV residual.
Fig. 7. m-value at –12 8C of PMA binders with WMA additives: RTFO+PAV residual.
pairs of sample means were compared. If the difference be- PMA binders. A general trend was observed from the results
tween two sample means was greater than or equal to the that the addition of Sasobit1 into PMA binder decreased the
LSD, the population means were declared to be statistically PMA binder’s viscosity, compared to the control PMA
different (Ott and Longnecker 2001). binder, and this finding was consistent for all binder sources
(A: 12.7%, B: 15.7%, C: 7.6%). However, the addition of
Results and discussion Aspha-min1 resulted in increasing the viscosity (A: 6.3%,
B: 0.3%, C: 11.2%), and this result is considered to be
Viscosity (high temperature) caused by the addition of fine powder to the binder, which
In general, the viscosity of asphalt binder at high temper- acts as a filler (Akisetty et al. 2009). Aspha-min1 utilizes
ature is thought to be an important property because it re- short-term foaming action that is active during mixing and
flects the binder’s ability to be pumped through an asphalt compaction process only. Once all the foaming action has
plant, thoroughly coat the aggregate in a hot mix asphalt been completed, Aspha-min1 is more or less an extra
(HMA) mixture, and be placed and compacted to form a amount of filler. After the foaming action, Aspha-min1 par-
new pavement surface (Asphalt Institute 2003). Figure 2 ticles remain undissolved in the PMA binder, therefore in-
shows the variation in viscosity at 135 8C for the warm creasing the viscosity. In addition, all the warm PMA
Table 5. Statistical analysis results of the stiffness at –12 8C of PMA binders as a function of WMA
additive and binder source (a = 0.05): N, non-significant difference; S, significant difference.
binders satisfied the maximum limit for viscosity of asphalt Generally, the lower values of G*sin d are considered desir-
binders at 135 8C set forth by Superpave (i.e., 3.0 Pas). able attributes from the standpoint of resistance to fatigue
The statistical significance of the change in the viscosity cracking (Asphalt Institute 2003). The G*sin d values of the
as a function of WMA additive and binder source was ex- warm PMA binders (RTFO+PAV residual) were measured
amined and the results are shown in Table 2. In general, the using the DSR at 25 8C and the results are illustrated in
data indicated that the binder source has a significant effect Fig. 5. The G*sin d values were found to be 2880, 3105,
on the viscosity of the warm PMA binders. In most cases and 3055 kPa for PMA binders with control, Aspha-min1,
(except for binder source B: Control vs. Aspha-min1), the and Sasobit1 (from binder source A), respectively. This
results showed that, within each binder source, the binders trend, the lowest at the control PMA binder (i.e., without
have a significant difference in the viscosity depending on WMA additive) was consistent with the binders from the
the WMA additive. other binder sources of B and C, indicating that the PMA
binders containing the inorganic additive Aspha-min1 or
Rutting property (high temperature) the aliphatic hydrocarbon Sasobit1 have possible lower re-
Generally, higher failure temperature values indicate that sistance on fatigue cracking than the PMA binder without
the binders are less susceptible to rutting at high pavement the additives.
temperature (Asphalt Institute 2003). The high failure tem- The statistical significance of the change in the G*sin d
perature of warm PMA binders in original state (i.e., without values was examined using one-way analysis of variance
aging) and after RTFO aging was measured using the DSR and the results are shown in Table 4. It was observed from
and the results are shown in Figs. 3 and 4. In general, the the results that the binder source has a significant effect on
PMA binders containing the additives resulted in the higher the fatigue cracking factor of the warm PMA binders, as ex-
failure temperature than the control PMA binders regardless pected. Also, the PMA binders with Aspha-min1 and Saso-
of the aging state, suggesting that the addition of Aspha- bit1 were found to be insignificantly different at the 5%
min1 or Sasobit1 has a positive effect on rutting resistance level in the G*sin d value (for two binder sources of A and
of PMA binders. When Aspha-min1 is added into PMA B), when compared within each binder source.
binders, the zeolite particles are thought to act as fillers in
the PMA binders, thereby increasing the stiffness of the Cracking property (low temperature)
binders. The increase in the rutting resistance of the PMA Superpave binder specification includes a maximum value
binders containing Sasobit1 is considered to be attributed to of 300 MPa for creep stiffness and a minimum m-value (i.e.,
the presence of wax crystals in the binders, which causes an the rate at which binder stiffness changes with time at low
increase in the complex modulus of the binders (Edwards temperatures) of 0.300. The decrease in stiffness leads to
and Redelius 2003; Edwards et al. 2006). smaller tensile stresses in the asphalt binder and less chance
The statistical results of the change in the high failure for low temperature cracking (Asphalt Institute 2003). From
temperature are shown in Table 3. For binder sources A and the BBR tests at –12 8C, the stiffness and the m-value of the
B, the differences between the control PMA binder and the warm PMA binders (RTFO+PAV residual) were calculated,
PMA binder containing Sasobit1 are statistically insignifi- and the results are shown in Figs. 6 and 7. The stiffness of
cant within each binder source. Also, the WMA additives all warm PMA binders was much less than 300 MPa, the
are found to have a different effect on the high failure tem- maximum value for Superpave binder (Fig. 6). Similar to
perature of the PMA binders depending on the binder the G*sin d values at 25 8C, the stiffness values of control
source. PMA binders were found to be lowest for all the binder
sources. With respect to m-value, the PMA binders contain-
Fatigue cracking property (intermediate temperature) ing Sasobit1 resulted in the lowest m-value properties irre-
The product of the complex shear modulus, G*, and the spective of the binder source, indicating that the addition of
sine of the phase angle, d, is used in Superpave binder spec- Sasobit1 to the PMA binder may make the binder less re-
ification to help control the fatigue of asphalt pavements. sistant to low temperature cracking. This finding is thought