Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Keywords: Sexual assaults and rapes are such violent crimes that not only leave the victims physically assaulted but also
POCSO act emotionally traumatized or even dead. In 2002, WHO (World Health Organization) estimated that 150 million girls
CSA (child sexual assault) and 73 million boys under the age of 18 years had experienced sexual assault which is one of the most common but
Medico legal examination
unreported crime. Children below the age of 18 suffer all forms of sexual activities that include vaginal-fingering,
DNA profiling
anal-fingering, vaginal and/or anal penetration, looking at sexual parts with psychiatric sense, voyeurism, or
pornography. In spite of all the laws, education and awareness, Child Sexual Assault (CSA) cases were recorded to
have been tremendously increasing especially in the metropolitan cities. Studies prove that the incidence is far
bigger than what is reported to authorities and the frequency of CSA cases is therefore difficult to determine as they
are often not reported. Sexual assault and rape victims seek out official provision amenities in the acute period that
may even be stretched to days, weeks, months or years following the sexual assault. This delayed disclosure may be
challenging for the purpose of eliciting the tell-tales from the evidence that could be the only way to establish the link
between the accused and the crime.
The objective of our study is to evaluate the overall crime rate of Delhi NCR in the year 2017–2018 and to study the
reasons associated with delayed reporting. Rising out of the analysis, the secondary objective of the study is to find
the possible effects of delayed medico legal examination on forensic DNA evidence. The emphasis is given on the
cases reported U/S 376 IPC (this section stipulates punishments that are awarded if a person is convicted to rape),
U/S 377 (this section describes punishment for whoever voluntarily commits unnatural intercourse with any human
being or animal) and POCSO Act (Child Sexual Assault). The victims in this study are in the age range of 2 months to
17 years; unmarried, predominantly adolescents, having very low social and educational status. Involvement of
Juvenile offenders in committing rape is quite high. In most of the cases the offenders are either neighbor and/or
known to the victim. The objective of our study is to evaluate the statistical percentage of child sexual abuse cases.
Introduction [4]. In the recent Kathua rape case the victim was just 8 years old who was
tortured and raped inside a temple [5] and whereas, Manipur victim who
Crime against children has been a cause of great distress of India’s was raped and later burnt was 11 years old [6]. In India, a special
development efforts. Childhood is reflected as a developmental age with legislation, POCSO Act (Protection of Children from Sexual Offences) was
high susceptibility to psychological and physical risks. Child sexual abuse approved in May 2012 by the Indian Parliament which describes all forms
is when a child is involved in sexual activity that he/she cannot of sexual abuse for both male and female of age group 0–18 years. This
understand because of being unaware of right and wrong [1]. Sexual legislation depicts the type of punishment of each sexual assault for the
activities include all forms of genital, or anal contact, or child abuse like culprit and also laid down certain guidelines for police officials and legal
exhibitionism, voyeurism, and pornography [2]. authorities to deal with the sufferers [7]. Reporting of such offence cases
According to RAINN’s website (Rape, Abuse And Incest National becomes a challenge due to either threat by the offender or due to the
Network), one-third of abusers, mostly men, are juveniles that include thought that it would bring shame to the family. Also due to one more
family friends, relatives, neighbors or babysitters [3]. Also, one in 9 girls important fact that the offender is a known, a family member, a relative, a
and 1 in 53 boys under the age of 18 have faced sexual abuse or assault by person trusted with care and safekeeping of the child or a neighbor [8].
an adult of which 82% are female victims [3]. In India, ‘Asian Center for Sexual assault and child abuse cases are identified as a major crime in
Human Rights’ reported 48,338 cases of the CSA between 2001 and 2011 the capital city, Delhi. Thus there is a need to understand the factors
Abbreviations: CSA, Child Sexual Assault; MLC, Medico-Legal Cases; U/S, Under Section; IPC, Indian Penal Code; POCSO, Protection Of Children from Sexual Offences;
UPT, Urine Pregnancy Test.
* Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: ksuminder@gmail.com (S. Kaur), simarkhurana13@gmail.com (S. Kaur), akkajal21@gmail.com (K. Varshney).
http://doi.org/10.1016/j.fsir.2019.100047
Received 9 August 2019; Received in revised form 14 October 2019; Accepted 15 October 2019
Available online 18 October 2019
2665-9107/© 2019 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-
S. Kaur et al. FSIR 1 (2019) 100047
associated with the occurrence of such cases. On an average eight women assault cases are:
get molested every day and most of them go without reporting it to the Vaginal/cervical swab/smear, Oral/Buccal Swab, Anal and rectal
police [New Delhi Television Limited 2019]. Hence, the prevalence of swab/smear, Nail Scrapings and Clippings, Semen and seminal stains,
molestation and DV still remains difficult to determine as the occurrence Penile swabs/smears, Blood, as a control specimen, Fetal tissue from
of such abuses/assaults is higher than what is actually reported. This aborted fetus.
study thus focuses on the nature and incidences of CSA and gives an
overview of the DNA examinations. Result
Before the introduction of DNA technology, the success of a
prosecution was mainly dependent upon the testimony of the victim Out of 2000 reviewed cases between January 2017 and December
against the perpetrator. Since 1985, DNA has proved to be a great tool 2018, 34.52% cases of U/S 376/377 IPC (Vaginal, Oral and anal
in criminal investigation as well as paternity cases worldwide. DNA can penetration) were reported at the Forensic Science Laboratory (FSL).
be extracted from different biological sources including blood, semen, [Fig. 1 showed the maximum cases reported were of U/S 376 IPC followed
saliva, hair, skin, teeth, bone and fetal tissue. In cases in which sexual by cases under the POCSO Act (CSA), U/S 377 IPC (Anal penetration),
assaults lead to pregnancy, it becomes vital to determine the paternity Intoxication and assault, molestation and Domestic Violence (DV) others
which is attained by using fetal tissue from the aborted fetus as a DNA [‘others’ include murder, attempt to murder, unidentified bodies,
source [9]. In cases of sexual assault, after reporting the offence the paternity, theft and robbery and abduction cases]. The total child sexual
victim is sent to a nearby Hospital for medical examination by a assault cases i.e. 59.22 which were due to Vaginal penetration, anal
gynecologist. This hesitation or taboo associated with the crime results penetration, molestation, DV, Intoxication and assault in the age range of
in the delay of the medico legal examination and sample collection, the 5 months to 17 years (registered under the POCSO Act) were further
only way to establish the link between the accused and the offence. considered for analysis.
Family members of the victim avoid disclosure and maintain the To determine the prevalence of Child Sexual Assault cases, 100 cases
confidentiality especially in cases that result in pregnancy [10]. Child from January 2017 to December 2018 were randomly selected and
sexual assault victims and their families experience the long tardy studied for the various factors [Table 1]. The factors include age of the
panorama of court proceedings that usually takes a time period of victim, gap between the occurrence of crime and medico-legal
several years. Additionally, the effecting of laws and initiatives in India examination and type of crime (Vaginal, Vaginal fingering, Anal, Oral,
is a problem. Thus the families intend to abstain from reporting the Molestation and Sodomy) in each case.
assault [11]. Lack of trust in judicial system and medical services are According to Fig. 2 statistics, out of 100 reviewed POCSO cases
among the major barriers in reporting and successfully suing majority of cases fall under the age group 14years to 17years which is 51,
the offenders [12]. There have been few cases, and still are, in which followed by age group 11years to 14years where the number is 23, 13
the police protect the offender and discourages the victim to report the victims fall under the age group of 5years to 8years, 7 victims under the
assault, resulting in low charge filing and conviction rate too. Doctors age group 8years to 11years, 4 under the age group 2years to 5years and
also sometimes neglect to collect vital evidence when they deal with surprisingly 2 below the age of 2 years out of which 1 girl child is aged 5
medico-legal examinations resulting in alleged perpetrators being months old.
released by the courts. Poor preservation of the evidence also accounts The present findings in Table 2 indicated that out of 18 cases reported
for negative results or insufficient DNA incapable of generating a on same day, the DNA STR analysis was positive among 09 cases and 01
profile [13]. cases showed UPT+(pregnancy positive). Twenty cases [20] cases
Due to inadvertent delay in the reporting of the offence, the reported on the next day for Medico legal Examination gave positive DNA
essential evidences are destroyed especially in the case of anal and oral analysis in 16 cases and 04 DNA negative cases. Another 36 cases reported
penetration [13]. Many a times, child sexual assaults don’t involve within one week depicts 13 positive DNA cases and 02 UPT + cases. 15
penetrated sex. In such cases, it becomes quite difficult to prove the cases reported between 8th day to 2 months revealed 01 DNA positive case
commitment of assault. While in cases that involve victim of very young and 03 UPT + cases. The 11 cases reported after 2 months could not
age it becomes a challenge to elicit the statements of the assault as well reveal any DNA positive case whereas 10 UPT + cases were indicated.
as the associated evidence. Insufficient evidence collected also prove to Under CSA cases, vaginal penetration and anal penetration are the
be drawback during DNA profiling [14]. Currently the punishment in most common form of sexual assault reported [Fig.3]. The vaginal
India for aggravated penetrative sexual assault is imprisonment penetration with 76% occurrence topped the pie graph followed by anal
between 10 years to life and a fine. The bill has now increased the penetration (9%), vaginal fingering and oral penetration both show 6%
minimum punishment from 10 years to 20 years and the maximum each and lastly molestation which showed 3% occurrence as it is least
punishment to death penalty [15]. reported crime.
2
S. Kaur et al. FSIR 1 (2019) 100047
Table 1
Age-wise distribution of CSA, Medico-legal analysis and prevalence of various forms of sexual abuse of 100 CSA cases.
S.NO. Age Gap between the date of Type of Crime Report
occurrence and date of (DNA Result)
Medico-legal certificate
3
S. Kaur et al. FSIR 1 (2019) 100047
Table 1 (continued)
S.NO. Age Gap between the date of Type of Crime Report
occurrence and date of (DNA Result)
Medico-legal certificate
Discussion
4
S. Kaur et al. FSIR 1 (2019) 100047
5
S. Kaur et al. FSIR 1 (2019) 100047
[14] A.M. Hagras, S.M. Moustafa, H.N. Barakat, A.H. El-Elemi, Medico-Legal evaluation of [18] T. Magalhães, R.J. Dinis-Oliveira, B. Silva, F. Corte-Real, D. Nuno Vieira, Biological
child sexual abuse over a six-year period from 2004 to 2009 in the Suez Canal area, evidence management for DNA analysis in cases of sexual assault, (Sci World J. 2015
Egypt, (Egypt. J. Forensic Sci. 1 (1) (2011) 58–66, doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j. (2015) , doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2015/365674.
ejfs.2011.04.009. [19] T.F. Vrolijk-Bosschaart, S.N. Brilleslijper-Kater, M.A. Benninga, R.J.L. Lindauer, A.H.
[15] The Criminal Law (Amendment) Bill, 2018. URL:- http://www.prsindia.org/ Teeuw, Clinical practice: recognizing child sexual abuse—what makes it so difficult?
billtrack/criminal-law-amendment-bill-2018 (Date of publish-) (Date of access- Aug (Eur. J. Pediatr. 177 (9) (2018) 1343–1350, doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00431-
5, 2019). 018-3193-z.
[16] Suminder Kaur, Monica Lamba, Ritika Gupta, Y chromosome STR typing: a [20] Lotus McDougal, Samuel Krumholz, Nandita Bhan, Prashant Bharadwaj, Anita Raj,
distinguishing tool for exclusion in a casework of sexual assault, (J. Forensic Res. 08 Releasing the tide: how has a shock to the acceptability of gender-based sexual
(05) (2017) , doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.4172/2157-7145.1000391 391. 18. violence affected rape reporting to police in India? (J. Interpers. Violence (2018) 1–23.
[17] Yemeni man publicly executed for raping and murdering four-year-old girl as crowd [21] S. Mansell, D. Sobsey, R. Moskal, Clinical findings among sexually abused children
film on smartphones. URL:- https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle- with and without developmental disabilities, (Ment. Retard. 36 (1998) 12–22.
east/yemen-public-execution-rape-murder-four-year-old-girl-crowd-film- [22] Louise Morgan, Sophie Khadr, Susan Bewley, Child sexual assault reported to an acute
spmartphones-videos-sanaa-tahrir-a7892836.html (Date of publish-Aug 14, 2017) sexual assault referral centre in London, (Arch. Dis. Child. 102 (2017) 165–169, doi:
(Date of access- Aug 5, 2019). http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/archdischild-2016-311121.