Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Abstract
A new exploration method has been developed by Saunders et al. (Geophysics 58(10) (1993) 1417) using surface and
aerial gamma-ray spectral measurements in prospecting for petroleum in stratigraphic and structural traps. Wadi Araba
area, North-eastern Desert, Egypt, was selected to apply this method on its recorded aerial gamma-ray spectrometric
survey data, due to its distinct stratigraphic and structural setting as well as its situation in close connection with the
Gulf of Suez, which represents one of the important sites of oil production in Egypt.
The three variables (eU, eTh, and K) registered for the whole study area, in the form of three contour maps, were
digitized along the flight paths every 1.0 km. The DRAD arithmetic means plus three standard deviations for the data
set were computed. Any single profile value greater than this quantity should have a probability of 99.87% that it
represents a valid anomaly and is not caused by random variations in the background values.
The use of these criteria has identified one flight line which has a valid anomaly that is not caused by random
variations in the background values. This might indicate a prospective possibility for petroleum accumulation in the
Wadi Araba area, North-eastern Desert, Egypt. r 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
0969-8043/02/$ - see front matter r 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 9 6 9 - 8 0 4 3 ( 0 2 ) 0 0 0 8 2 - 9
122 M.A. El-Sadek / Applied Radiation and Isotopes 57 (2002) 121–130
Fig. 2. Compiled geological map of Wadi Araba Area, North-eastern desert, Egypt (after El-Aassy, 1981; Conoco Coral, 1987).
Table 1
Mean natural radioelement content of sedimentary rocks (Galbraith and Saunders, 1983)
sence of uranium is also shown to be genetically related amounts of organic matter accumulated unusually high
to the content of organic matter in uranium-rich shales, concentrations of uranium from percolating ground-
and uranium enrichment is enhanced by a low rate of waters (Jaworowski and Pensko, 1967). The high
sedimentation which allows more organic material to uranium concentrations in peat is not derived from
accumulate (Alekseev and Gottikh, 1966; Serikov, plants growing in uranium-bearing soils; instead, the
1964). humus tends to absorb uranium by direct contact with
Hydrocarbon deposits, especially those which are water (Lopatkina et al., 1970).
highly oxidizing in nature, tend to accumulate heavy As hydrocarbons rise towards the surface, they may
metals (Ball et al., 1960; Dunning, 1957; Erickson et al., react chemically with sulfates in groundwaters to
1954; Lisitsin, 1960). Fossil bones that contained large produce hydrogen sulphide (H2S), carbon dioxide
124 M.A. El-Sadek / Applied Radiation and Isotopes 57 (2002) 121–130
(CO2) and secondary carbonate mineralization (CaCO3) heavy insoluble minerals and observations generally
(Kartsev et al., 1959). For example, confirm this (Saunders et al., 1993).
Cn Hm þ3CaSO4 3CaCO3 þH2 O þ 3H2 S þ CO2 : There is some evidence that low-potassium anomalies
may ‘‘fade’’ after fields are depleted. The loss of pressure
Sulphate-reducing bacteria in groundwaters can also is thought to cause microseepage to cease along with its
accomplish this (Krauskopf, 1967; Sassen, 1980). They alteration (Horvitz, 1969). This might allow potassium
obtain oxygen from sulphate ions and hydrogen to build up again through groundwater influx. Thus, the
sulphide byproducts: potassium concentration at any given time could be the
2Hþ þSO2 result of a dynamic equilibrium between rates of influx
4 þCH4 ¼ CO2 þH2 S þ 2H2 O:
and removal. The situation with respect to uranium is
High carbon dioxide concentrations in groundwater more complex than that for potassium (Saunders et al.,
form carbonic acid that can react with minerals (calcium 1993).
silicates, for example) to create secondary pore-filling Microbially produced, hydrogen-sulphide-related,
calcium carbonate mineralization and silicification chemically reducing environments can result in a
(SiO2) (Kartsev et al., 1959; Donovan et al., 1974; build-up of uranium concentrations with time (Adler,
Donovan and Palziel, 1977). For example, 1974). Uranium has two valence states. The oxidized
CaAl2 Si6 O16 þCO2 ¼ CaCO3 þ6SiO2 þAl2 O3 : form, the uranyl ion (UO2+ 2 ) is soluble in groundwaters.
When it is reduced, it converts to UO2, uraninite, which
This can result in rendering the near-surface materials is relatively insoluble and precipitates. Thus, uranium
more dense and resistant to erosion. The effects may be will tend to migrate from an oxidizing environment to a
(1) increased seismic velocity over the petroleum reducing one, where its concentration will build up over
accumulation, time. If conditions are right, a sedimentary uranium
(2) erosional topographic highs and consequent geo- deposit may be formed. Thus, lesser build-ups of
morphic anomalies, or uranium in surface sediments may be useful clues to
(3) dilution of the normal radioactive element concen- petroleum at depth (Saunders et al., 1993).
trations with resultant low-thorium gamma-ray According to Saunders et al. (1993), the hydrocarbon
activities over production. microseepage involves vertical ascent of ultra-small
(colloidal size) gas bubbles of light hydrocarbon
The destruction of clay minerals by carbonic and (methane through the butanes) through a network of
organic acids can release potassium and uranium for interconnected, groundwater-filled joints and bedding
removal by groundwater leaching (Price, 1986). planes as suggested by MacElvain (1969) and Saunders
Potassium in sediments is contained primarily in the et al. (1991). When the bubbles reach the surface of the
clay mineral, illite, and occupies spaces between layers in water table, first they enter the interstitial soil gases,
the clay structure (Rankama and Sahama, 1950). When where they may be sampled and detected by sensitive gas
exposed to concentrations of other cations, possibly chromatography, and then they escape into the atmo-
Ca2+, Mg2+ or H+, the potassium ions in illite may be sphere where they may be detected by airborne
replaced by them (Grim, 1953). Goldschmidt (1954) microwave spectrometry.
states: ‘‘In soil and hydrolysate sediments (clays), a most Normalizing to thorium will also suppress these
important process in equilibria of adsorption and cation effects. This similarity in behaviour allows use of
exchange is the competition between potassium ions and thorium values to roughly predict uranium and potas-
what are commonly called hydrogen ions.’’ In water sium by determining their general relationships. Sig-
solution, the hydrogen ion H+ combines with a water nificant differences between predicted (or ‘‘ideal’’)
molecule to form H3O+, hydronium ion, which has an uranium and potassium amounts, and actual (measured)
ionic radius, 1.54 A,( close to that of the potassium ion, values must be due to factors other than lithology, soil
(
1.33 A. Mutual exchange in an acidic solution seems moisture, vegetation, shielding, or counting geometry.
quite feasible. The microbial oxidation of microseeping By measuring these secondary effects, one can define
hydrocarbons produces hydronium ions possible petroleum prospects (Saunders et al., 1993).
The three variables (eU, eTh, and K) for the whole
CH4 þ2O2 ¼ H2 CO3 þH2 O; study area are in the form of three contour maps, scale
1:50,000. These variables were digitized along the flight
H2 CO3 þH2 O ¼ H3 Oþ þHCO
3: paths, every 1.0 km.
These are believed to replace potassium ions in illite and Equivalent uranium and potassium data for aerial
release them to be removed in groundwater solution. gamma-ray spectral profiles were normalized to equiva-
Observations to date are, in general, in agreement with lent thorium data, using the procedure of Saunders et al.
this model as it pertains to potassium. Thorium should (1993). Plots were made for the field-measured Ks versus
remain relatively fixed in its original distribution in the eThs and eUs versus eThs values for all stations
M.A. El-Sadek / Applied Radiation and Isotopes 57 (2002) 121–130 125
(readings). Various linear, logarithmic, and second- where Ks and eUs are the measured (real) values at the
order curve fitting procedures were tried, and the station, and KD% and eUD% are the relative devia-
simplest effective Eqs. (1) and (2) relating these variables tions expressed as a fraction of the station values.
were determined to be linear and pass through the Experience has shown that KD% yields small (negative)
origin. The slopes of the lines were determined by the values and eUD% yields smaller (negative) or some-
ratios of mean Ks to mean eThs ; or mean eUs to mean times positive values over petroleum accumulations
eThs : The equations are (Saunders et al., 1993): (Saunders et al., 1993).
KD% and eUD% variations can be combined as a
Ki ¼ ðmean Ks =mean eThs ÞeThs ; ð1Þ
single positive number, DRAD, which is the difference
between both of them (Saunders et al., 1993):
eUi ¼ ðmean eUs =mean eThs ÞeThs ; ð2Þ
DRAD ¼ eUD% KD%;
where Ki is the ideal (calculated) equivalent thorium-
defined potassium value for the station with a real where positive DRAD values are favourable indications
equivalent thorium value of eThs, and eUi is the ideal of petroleum accumulation.
(calculated) equivalent thorium-defined equivalent ur-
anium value for that station.
Using this approach, the equations were calculated 4. Results and interpretation
directly from the data, and quick field evaluations may
be made without preparing the plots and resorting to Comparative profiles of Ks ; eUs ; eThs ; KD%; eUD%;
curve fitting. Deviations of the real values from the and DRAD were plotted for 22 flight lines, to illustrate
calculated ideal values for each station were obtained typical crossover. The following discussion is devoted
using equations of the form (Saunders et al., 1993) only to three flight lines out of the 22, as examples.
Plots of the unprocessed and processed airborne
KD% ¼ ðKs Ki Þ=Ks ; ð3Þ
radiospectrometric survey data over the flight line (No.
10130, Fig. 3) are presented in Fig. 4A and B. This flight
eUD% ¼ ðeUs eUi Þ=eUs ; ð4Þ
line is located in the extreme eastern part of the area
Fig. 3. Flight lines map, Wadi Araba area, North-eastern Desert, Egypt.
126 M.A. El-Sadek / Applied Radiation and Isotopes 57 (2002) 121–130
Fig. 6. Flight line (No. 10230) profiles: the unprocessed Ks ; eUs Fig. 7. Flight line (No. 10161) profiles: the unprocessed Ks, eUs
and eThs data (A), and the processed KD%; eUD% and DRAD and eThs data (A), and the processed KD%; eUD% and DRAD
data (B), Wadi Araba area, North-eastern Desert, Egypt. data (B), Wadi Araba area, North-eastern Desert, Egypt.
Table 2
Statistical parameters computed for ‘‘DRAD’’ for the studied flight lines, Wadi Araba area, North-eastern Desert, Egypt
Flight line no. (Fig. 3) Min. value Max. value Arithmetic mean (X ) Standard deviation (SD) X þ 3SD
Fig. 8. DRAD anomaly map, Wadi Araba area, North-eastern Desert, Egypt.
5. Statistical evaluation of the profile data 1993). The application of these criteria has led to the
identification of one station along one flight line over the
The characteristics and fluctuations of DRAD in study area that is statistically valid (Flight line No.
areas not situated over identified oil or gas-producing 10161) and which shows a valid anomaly that might
fields may be estimated by examining the profiles in indicate a prospective petroleum accumulation in the
those areas. Table 2 lists profile ‘‘background’’ stations study area.
located over areas not known to produce oil or gas,
arithmetic means and standard deviations for each flight Flight line No. (10161)
line are treated as representing one population. A
conservative estimate of background statistical para- Plots of the aeroradiospectrometric survey data over
meters is based on the population. The DRAD flight line No. 10161 (Fig. 3) located in the eastern part
arithmetic mean plus three standard deviations reach of the study area are presented in Fig. 7. The field-
1.117 for this data set (Table 2). Any single profile value measured data for potassium (Ks ), equivalent uranium
greater than this quantity has a probability of 99.87% (eUs ) and equivalent thorium (eThs ) are all shown in
that it represents a valid anomaly that is not caused by Fig. 7A. After thorium normalization, to suppress the
random variations in the background values (Elkins, lithologic effect, KD% shows negative values between
1940; Saunders, 1989). It is improbable for adjacent 15 and 25 km. The corresponding eUD% values are
points on a profile to be simultaneously anomalous shown with a consequent positive DRAD anomaly
because of radon fluctuations. The presence of a reaching more than 1.117, where a crossover occurs at a
statistically valid DRAD anomaly can enhance the distance oscillating from 15 to 25 km (indicated by
probability of wildcat success, but it does not eliminate hatched pattern). This might indicate a prospective
the possibility of a dry hole. Experience has demon- petroleum accumulation in the study area.
strated that DRAD anomalies may be found only over The examination of the DRAD anomaly map (Fig. 8)
portions of fields, and cannot be used to determine shows that some of the delineated high DRAD
production boundaries accurately (Saunders et al., anomalies are circular in shape and others are elongated
M.A. El-Sadek / Applied Radiation and Isotopes 57 (2002) 121–130 129
either in the N–S or in the NE–SW direction. The Alekperov, R.A., Efendiev, G.Kh., 1959. On the uranium
highest levels are located in the central part of the Wadi content in petroleum. Geokhimiya 6, 621–627 (translated in
Araba and are associated with Quaternary Sediments Geochemistry 6, 621–627).
(reaching 1.14 along flight line No. 10161 at station 16). Alekseev, F.A., Gottikh, R.P., 1966. concerning the mechanism
The lowest values are located in the extreme north- of formation of radiometric anomalies above petroleum
deposits. K voprosy o mekhanizm obrazovaniya radio-
eastern corner of the study area, and associated with the
metricheskikh anomaliy nad neftyanymi mestorozhdeniya-
Rod El-Hamal formation (the minimum value reach- mi. Sov. Geol. 12, December 1965, 100-120 (translated in
ing—4.0 along flight line No.10270 at station 5). Internat. Geol. Rev. 8(10), 1157–1171).
Armstrong, F.E., Heemstra, R.J., 1973. Radiation haloes and
hydrocarbon reservoirs: a review. US Bureau of Mines
6. Summary and conclusions Information Circular 8579.
Ball, J.S., Wenger, W.J., Hyden, H.J., Horr, C.A., Myers, A.T.,
The three variables (eU; eTh; and K) for the Wadi 1960. Metal content of twenty-four petroleums. J. Chem.
Eng. Data 5 (4), 553–557.
Araba area North-eastern Desert, Egypt were digitized
Bogoyavlenskiy, L.N., 1929. Radioactivity of ashes of some
along the flight paths, every 1.0 km. Comparative rock oils. Izv. Inst. Prik. Geofiz. 4, 311–314 (translated in
profiles of Ks ; eUs ; eThs ; KD%; eUD% and DRAD BuMines Inf. Circ. 6224, p. 22).
were plotted for 22 flight lines to illustrate typical Conoco, C., 1987. Geological map of Egypt, scale 1:500,000—
‘‘crossover’’ anomalies over the areas or zones which NH36SW—Beni Suef, Egypt. The Egyptian General Petro-
may indicate petroleum accumulations. leum Corporation, Cairo, Egypt.
The characteristics and fluctuations of DRAD in Donovan, T.J., Friedman, J., Gleason, J.D., 1974. Recognition
areas not situated over identified oil- or gas-producing of petroleum-bearing traps by unusual isotopic composi-
fields may be estimated by examining the profiles in the tions of carbonate-cemented rocks. Geology 2, 351–354.
area. The DRAD arithmetic mean plus three standard Donovan, T.J., Dalziel, M.C., 1977. Late diagenetic indicators
of buried oil and gas. US Geol. Surv. Open File Report
deviations reached 1.117 for this data set. Any single
77-817.
profile value greater than this quantity has a probability Dunning, H.N., 1957. The protective action of crude petroleum
of 99.87% that it is a valid anomaly and is not caused by for metal-prophyrin complexes exposed to gamma irradia-
random variations in the background values. The tion. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 79, 5320–5321.
application of these criteria has led to identify one El-Aassy, I.E.E., 1981. Structural and radiometric studies of
location along one flight line over the study area (flight Wadi Araba area, Eastern Desert, Egypt. Ph.D. Thesis
line No. 10161) which has valid anomalies, and might (unpublished), Faculty of Science, Mansoura University,
indicate a prospective petroleum accumulation in the Egypt, 297 p.
study area. Elkins, T.A., 1940. The reliability of geophysical anomalies on
the basis of probability considerations. Geophysics 5,
321–336.
El-Shazly, E.M., Meshref, W.M., Fouad, K.M., Ammar, A.A.,
Acknowledgements Meleik, M.L., 1969. Aerial radiometry of El-Alamein
oil field, Egypt, U.A.R. Geophys Prospect XVII (3),
The author wishes to express his thanks to the 336–343.
Egyptian Geological Survey and Mining Authority Erickson, R.L., Myers, A.T., Horr, C.A., 1954. Association of
(EGSMA) and the Egyptian General Petroleum Cor- uranium and other metals with crude oil, Asphalt and
poration (EGPC) for providing the airborne gamma-ray Petroliferous rock. Bull. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geol. 38 (10),
spectrometric maps and profiles used in the present 2200–2218.
Galbraith, J.H., Saunders, D.F., 1983. Rock classification by
study.
characteristics of aerial gamma-ray measurements. J.
Geochem. Expl. 18, 47–73.
Goldschmidt, V.M., 1954. Geochemistry. Oxford University
References Press, Oxford 157 p.
Grim, R.E., 1953. Clay mineralogy. McGraw-Hill, New York.
Adler, H.H., 1974. Concepts of uranium ore formation in Horvitz, L., 1969. Hydrocarbon geochemical prospecting after
reducing environments in sandstones and other sediments. thirty years. In: Heroy, W.B. (Ed.), Unconventional me-
Proceedings on the Formation of Uranium Ore Deposits. thods in exploration for petroleum and natural gas, South-
Internat. Atomic Energy Agency, pp. 141–168. ern Methodist University Press, Dallas, TX, pp. 205–218.
Aero-Service, 1984. Final operational report of airborne Jaworowski, Z., Pensko, J., 1967. Unusually radioactive fossil
magnetic/radiation survey in the Eastern Desert, Egypt. bones from mongolia. Nature 214 (5084), 161–163.
Conducted for the Egyptian General Petroleum Corpora- Kartsev, A.A., Tabasaranskii, Z.A., Subbota, M.I., Mogilevs-
tion (EGPC), and the Egyptian geological Survey and kii, G.A., 1959. In: Geochemical methods of prospecting
Mining Authority (EGSMA), Aero-Service Division, Wes- and exploration for petroleum and natural gas. Unversity of
tern Geophysical Company, TX, USA (six volumes). California Press, Berkeley, CA, pp. 294–295.
130 M.A. El-Sadek / Applied Radiation and Isotopes 57 (2002) 121–130
Krauskopf, K.B., 1967. Introduction of Geochemistry. Saunders, D.F., 1989. Simplified evaluation of soil magnetic
McGraw-Hill, New York. susceptibility and soil gas hydrocarbon anomalies. Bull.
Lisitsin, A.K., 1960. Uranium content of oxidizing petroleums. Assoc. Pet. Geochem. Explor. 5, 30–48.
Geokhimiya, 7, 761–768 (translated in Geochemistry 7, Saunders, D.F., Terry, S.A., Thompson, C.K., 1987. Test of
761–768). national uranium resource evaluation gamm-ray spectral
Lopatkina, A.P., Komarov, V.S., Sergeyer, A.N., Andreyev, data in petroleum reconnaissance. Geophysics 52,
A.G., 1970. On concentration of uranium by living and 1547–1556.
dead peat-forming plants. Geokhimiya 3, 372–377 (trans- Saunders, D.F., Burson, K.R., Thompson, C.K., 1991.
lated in Geochem. Internat. 7(2), 277–282). Relationship of soil magnetic susceptibility and soil gas
MacElvain, R., 1969. Mechanics of gaseous ascension through hydrocarbon measurements to subsurface petroleum accu-
a sedimentary column. In: Heroy, W. B. (Ed.), Unconven- mulations. Bull. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. 75, 389–408.
tional Methods in Exploration for Petroleum and Natural Saunders, D.F., Burson, K.R., Branch, J.F., Thompson, C.K.,
Gas. Southern Methodist University Press, Dallas, TX, 1993. Relation of thorium-normalized surface and aerial
pp. 15–28. radiometric data to subsurface petroleum accumulations.
Price, L.C., 1986. A critical overview and proposed working Geophysics 58 (10), 1417–1427.
model of surface geochemical exploration. In: Davidson, M. Serikov, Yu.I., 1964. The source of the uranium in the Khadum
J. (Ed.), Unconventional Methods in Exploration for Shales. Geokhimiya 3, 253–257 (translated in Geochem.
Petroleum and Natural Gas IV. Southern Methodist Internat. 1, 229–232).
University Press, Dallas, TX, pp. 245–304. Ward, S.H., 1981. Gamma-ray spectrometry in geologic
Rankama, K., Sahama, Th.G., 1950. Geochemistry. University mapping and uranium exploration. In: Skinner, B. J.
of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp. 204–205. (Ed.), Econom. Geol. 75th Anniversary Volume—1905–1980.
Sassen, R., 1980. Biodegradation of crude oil in a shallow gulf Econom. Geol. Publ. Co., pp. 840–849.
coast salt dome. Org. Geochem. 2, 153–166.