Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
REFERENCES
Linked references are available on JSTOR for this article:
http://www.jstor.com/stable/20627616?seq=1&cid=pdf-
reference#references_tab_contents
You may need to log in to JSTOR to access the linked references.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
Balkans and Greece Gumelnitsa Ryndina et al. 1999; Gale et al. 2003
Sitagroi McGeehan-Liritzis and Gale 1988
Anza Gale 1991
Fourth millennium B.C.E. Iranian plateau Tepe Yahya Heskel and Lamberg-Karlovsky 1980
Seistan Kennoyer and Miller 1999, 116, 121-22
Baluchistan Allchin and Hammond 1978, 89-90
Mehrgarh Jarrige 1984
Thailand Non Nok Tha Bayard 1980; White and Pigott 1996
Khao Phu Kha Bennett 1989
Second millennium B.C.E. South America Andes Donnan 1973; Hosier 1988;
Shimada and Merkel 1991
be related to another outstanding feature of Thai pre crushed matte has also been found mixed with
historic metallurgy: the use of chimneys that induce air crushed ore.31 This suggests that the prehistoric
convection and limit heat loss from the crucible area.25 Thai smelters intentionally used the matte as a
This anomaly suggests that the temperature within the reducing agent for the cosmelting process.
reactor is the limiting factor for the increase in size 4. Copper produced by crucible smelting frequently
of the crucible.26 This limitation is relevant only if the included arsenic, an element generally present in
crucible is heated from outside. It points to a funda sulfide but not in oxide ores.32
mental difference between the crucible and furnace It has been suggested on the basis of this informa
smelting, namely that a furnace is filled with a mixture tion that sulfide ore may have been used as an exclu
of charcoal and ore (inside heating), while a crucible sive source of copper in crucible smelting. But this is
is not (outside heating) .27 not likely. To become the exclusive source of copper,
This singularity of crucible smelting may be dis the sulfide ore should be oxidized first, as follows: the
missed because charcoal is not only the source of sulfide ore is mixed with charcoal and iron/manga
heat for the smelting process. Burning charcoal, when nese additives. This mixture is heated at a tempera
mixed with copper ore, is also the source of carbon ture that increases slowly but does not exceed 800?C,
monoxide, the reducing agent for copper smelting. initially to dehydrate the ore, then to ignite the sulfurs
But charcoal is not the single potential source of re and remove them prior to the oxidation of the cop
ducing agents for smelting. Copper sulfide may be per salts. It is only after this process that the roasted
used too. Under high temperatures (ca. 1200?C), the ore may be smelted. But the required addition of
sulfur-rich atmosphere generated by the supply of silicates and other additives, in order to retain iron
about 20% of sulfide ore is able to extract the smelt of and manganese in the slags, prevents smelting it in a
copper from oxide ore, a process called cosmelting.28 crucible. Furthermore, the roasting process clearly ap
Some observations suggest that sulfide ore served as proximates furnace metallurgy both by the mixing of
a reducing agent in crucible smelting: ore and charcoal and by the use of iron/manganese
1. When used as a reducing agent, charcoal should additives. This is why we may assume that the traces
be mixed with oxide ore. In this case, except for of sulfide ore in copper and refractories indicate a
copper ore of very high grade, the small volume cosmelting process in the crucible.
of a crucible does not allow the smelting of more These general considerations about crucible smelt
than a few grams of copper. It is difficult to believe ing explain why crucible metallurgy always remained
that the prehistoric smelters invested so great an a very limited activity, generally coexisting with the
effort for such a small quantity. The cosmelting use of native copper. Beyond the limited yield, the re
process, in contrast, enables one to fill most of duced volume of the crucible prevented the addition
the crucible with copper oxide, thereby improv of fluxes, so that successful smelting always depended
ing the yield. on the supply of high-grade oxide ore. In these condi
2. In the Balkans, copper artifacts produced by cruci tions, crucible metallurgy would cease to exist as soon
ble smelting show high sulfide content and inclu as the grade of the ore diminished.
sions of sulfide ore partially smelted (matte).29 Identification of crucible smelting as a cosmelting
3. In Thailand, matte is also identified in refracto process clearly separates it from furnace smelting (fig.
ries from crucible metallurgy.30 But in this case, 1). In no way should furnace smelting (mixed ore and
Furnace Smelting
Crucible
Characteristics Pit Bowl Continuous
Smelting Furnace Furnace Furnace
Tuyere/blowpipe no yes
connected to the reactor
charcoal) be considered a spontaneous extension of the purification of native copper from its gangue by
crucible smelting, a process developed in a context of being melted in a crucible. To address this peculiarity,
the purification of native copper. It is therefore im it should be noted that copper smelting was not con
portant to elucidate the circumstances surrounding sidered a local development in the southern Levant. It
the emergence of furnace metallurgy. was supposedly introduced by northern seminomadic
people (Caucasians and/or Anatolians) who brought
THE EARLIEST FURNACE SMELTING
about transformations in the way of life, habitat, and
The smelting of copper is attested in the southern burial practices for the indigenous population.33 But
Levant (Negev, Aravah, and Sinai) from the fifth mil this hypothesis contradicts the archaeological data
lennium B.C.E., but curiously, this metallurgy arises in because a continuous evolution in ceramic shape and
a region totally devoid of native copper. For this rea technology is evident between the Late Neolithic and
son, the emergence of metallurgy cannot derive from Chalcolithic phases in southern Canaan.34 Further
33 This theory was first suggested by Ferembach 1959; de 34Gilead 1990; Merkel and Rothenberg 1999.
Vaux 1966; Mellaart 1966.
more, there is no evidence of the emergence of a new indicates that it maintains its high viscosity throughout
population in this area during the Early Chalcolithic the smelting process. This explains why the smelted
period.35 Accordingly, the development of copper copper remained trapped in slags. At this first stage,
metallurgy should be considered indigenous to the slags were crushed and the largest copper prills were
southern Levant. manually extracted.
Also noteworthy in southern Levantine metallurgy
is the occurrence of furnaces from its earliest stages Phase 2: Low-Viscosity Smelting
(Timna, fifth millennium B.C.E.).36 Many scholars Slags produced later in the same sites are more ho
have taken exception to this point and have argued mogeneous. Their mineral structure reveals a transi
that furnace technology was a process much too ad tion toward a low-viscosity stage during the smelting
vanced for this period.37 Though this tenet fits the clas process. Their low copper content indicates that most
sical opinion that assumes a gradual evolution from of the reduced metal was released.41 The amount of
crucible to furnace smelting, it is challenged by the copper oxide was also reduced in comparison with
following observations: slags belonging to the high-viscosity smelting process.
1. The earliest furnace unearthed at Timna (site These changes indicate that the smelting process
F2) is extremely archaic in its size and shape. was improved, probably through the use of furnaces
Similar furnaces are not encountered after the reaching a higher temperature and maintaining a
Chalcolithic period. more reducing atmosphere. At this stage of develop
2. Slags from this earliest furnace are characterized ment, a copper ingot was generated at the bottom
by a high content of copper, pointing to an in of the furnace, while small copper prills remained
complete smelting process. This confirms their trapped in slags.
ancient origin.
3. Chalcolithic furnaces also have been identified at Phase 3: True-Smelting Process
Beer Sheba (Abu Matar, ca. 4200 B.C.E.) ,38 Analy A new type of slag containing a very low level of
sis of their slags reveals a control of the smelt copper (<1%) characterizes smelting in the Late
ing process more advanced than in Timna. This Chalcolithic period. This suggests the occurrence of
suggests that the earliest furnace from Timna is a fluid-phase transition of the mineral matrix during
even older than 4200 B.C.E. the smelting process, accompanied by manganese-,
A comparative analysis of chemical composition magnesium-, and calcium-enrichment of slags. This
and structure of slags from southern Araba (Timna change argues for the use of new fluxes.42
and Yotvata)39 enables the identification of three suc This sequence reveals a progressive improvement of
cessive development phases in southern Levantine the furnace smelting process toward the total liquefac
furnace metallurgy. tion of the mineral matrix and the complete separa
tion of metal copper and the slags. Other innovations
Phase 1: High-Viscosity Smelting are attested during the course of the Chalcolithic pe
The most ancient slags discovered both at Timna riod in the southern Levant. At Beer Sheba, copper
and Yotvata are extremely heterogeneous, includ oxide ore was mixed with a small fraction of sulfide ore
ing many copper prills, veinlets, and dendrites. They of local origin.43 This sulfide ore intentionally intro
are characterized by a dark red shade due to various duced in the furnace acted as another kind of reduc
iron oxides that were used as fluxing agents and the ing agent. Arsenic-copper alloy was also intentionally
presence of about 10% unsmelted cuprite (Cu20).40 produced through the addition of arsenical sulfide ore
Analysis of the mineral structure of the silicate matrix imported from mining areas far from Canaan.44
35Tangri et al. 1993; Agelarakis et al. 1998. 38 Shugar 2000. The analysis of slags from the inner part
36 See Rothenberg and Glass 1992; Rothenberg and Merkel of the bowl furnace from Abu Matar has indeed revealed the
1995; Rothenberg 1999. This dating is based on typical Chal presence of charcoal ash (Hauptmann 2007,224).
colithic flint axes and the radiocarbon dating (4460-4240 39 Rothenberg and Merkel 1995, 1998; Rothenberg et al.
B.C.E.) of an ash sample from a habitation near the furnace 2004.
(Rothenberg and Merkel 1998). 40Rothenberg et al. 2004; Hauptmann 2007,159.
37Craddock 2001. The earliest furnaces discovered at Tira 41 Golden et al. 2001; Rothenberg et al. 2004.
na have been, therefore, related to the Bronze Age. The main 42Rothenbergetal. 2004; Hauptmann 2007,160.
arguments for and against the Chalcolithic dating of the 43 Shugar 2000,194-95.
Timna furnace are summarized by Rothenberg (2002) and 44 Shugar 2000,197-228.
Hauptmann (2007,148), respectively.
45 Crucibles were also identified in many other sites of early 49?zbaletal. 2000.
metallurgy in the southern Levant (Adams 2002; Levy et al. 50Yener2000,39-42.
2002; Hautpmann 2007,240). It is the presence of slags in the 51 Shugar 2000, 223-28. Hauptmann (2007, 299) also
crucibles (normally occurring during the process of purifica points to the compatibility of the finding of arsenical copper
tion of the smelted copper) that led to the conclusion about a from the southern Levant with ores from the northern Eu
crucible smelting process in Canaan. phrates. The addition of sulfide ores in the furnace, found at
46 Levy et al. 2002. In this area, it is suggested that up to Beer Sheba but not at Timna (B. Rothenberg, pers. comm.
5,000 tons of slag was produced during the Early Bronze Age. 2009), is consistent with the contact, at this time, between the
47 ?zbal et al. 2000; Yener 2000, 34-6. southern Canaanite homeland and the northern Euphrates
48Yener 2000,42. At Degirmentepe, archaeological traces of area, where crucible cosmelting was practiced.
smelting installations are not so important with regard to the 52Yener2000,43-4.
quantitative importance of metallurgical findings. This sug 53Yener2000, 34.
gests that Degirmentepe was a center specializing in the refin 54Mallowan 1963.
ing of the copper smelted in the surrounding mining areas.
55 Beyond the finding of copperless slags (indicating a fur od (Wenke 1991; Harrison 1993; Gophna 1995; Adams 2002).
nace true-smelting process), the presence of slags with cop This included the trade of copper artifacts and ingots (Haupt
per prill inclusions and a high level of oxidation suggests that mann 2007, 303).
a process of metal purification (and eventually metal alloy 58Kavtaradze 1999, 74.
ing) was performed in crucibles at Hacinebi (Ozbal et al. 2000 59 Levy 1995; Issar and Zohar 2007.
[with references]). 60Kavtaradze 1999. Many of these settlements are fortified
56 Later, these southern and northern Levantine poles of (Kohl 1988), suggesting that they were inhabited by a foreign
metallurgy were the source of two distinct metallurgical tra population.
ditions coexisting in Canaan (Levy 1995; Muhly 1995,1504). 61 Concerning the presence of antimony in some of the Na
The northern tradition is characterized by the use of larger hal Mishmar artifacts, see Tadmor et al. 1995; Golden et al.
furnaces and crucibles than are used in the southern tradi 2001. No significant sources of antimony exist in the Euphra
tion, by the use of hand instead of foot bellows, and by the tes basin and the region of Susa, but polymetallic ores rich in
preferential use of bivalve molds for casting. Davey (1988) antimony (up to 40%) have been identified in the Ghebi area
justifies the difference in traditions by the relative scarcity of (see fig. 3 herein), where traces of very ancient mining have
charcoal in the semiarid climate of the southern Levant. also been observed (Kavtaradze 1999, 87).
57 A southern Canaanite metallurgical activity is attested in 62Lyonnet (cited by Kohl 2007, 70-1).
Sinai (Beit Arieh 1980; Rothenberg and Glass 1992), and the 63 Kohl 2007, 74-8. This linkage is also stressed by the Le
Beer Sheba culture extended its influence upon Predynastic vantine influence observed on Transcaucasian culture (Gam
Egypt (esp. in the Nile Delta) from the Late Chalcolithic peri krelidze and Ivanov 1985).
3500 B.C.E.). At the same time, crucible smelting was Western Anatolia, the Balkans, and the Aegean World.
suddenly replaced by furnace metallurgy.64 But the The presence of furnace metallurgy has been acknowl
development of furnace technology was not a gradual edged in southeastern Europe from the end of the
process at Susa, suggesting, again, an exogenous ori fourth millennium. Its sudden occurrence at a mature
gin. The Levantine influence is suggested both by the stage follows a long period of cultural regression, the
sudden emergence of a mature stage of the lost-wax so-called Balkan Dark Age characterized by the decline
technique of casting and by the style of the earliest of copper production (crucible smelting) and the
artifacts produced in Elam by this technique.65 Simi abandonment of many settlements.67 In Greece and
larity of the seals found in the Levant and at Elam at in the Aegean, furnace metallurgy suddenly appears
this time confirms the idea of Levantine ascendancy at a mature stage of development at Kythnos, Naxos,
on the Elamite furnace metallurgy.66 Manika (Euboia), and in the mining area of Laurion.68
64 Pigott 1999a, 79. B.C.E.) was stimulated, at least partly, by an attempt to con
65Davey 1988; Moorey 1999, 256-57; Avilova 2008. trol copper production and trade from the Tigris-Euphrates
66 Beck 1976; Lapp 1995. This intimate relationship be basin. It generated a pathway of communication between the
tween areas so far apart was possible via the Urukian network northern Euphrates area and the Iranian plateau, where cop
of exchange already linking Canaan to Sumer (Algaze 1993; per was already being produced by crucible smelting.
Butterlin 2003; Philip 2003). Evidence of copper metallurgy (i7McGeehan-Liritzis 1983; Kohl 2007, 34.
is scarce at the earliest stages of development of Sumer (5000 68 At Kythnos, one of the main sites of Aegean copper pro
3500 B.C.E.), as this area depended on the exogenous produc duction during the Early Bronze Age, the remains of furnaces
tion of copper (Moorey 1999). In this context, it is likely that and of large amounts of slag have been identified from 3100
the Uruk expansion toward the northern Euphrates (ca. 3700 B.C.E. (Stos-Gale 1989; Davis 1992, 704, 717, 728).
69Even Renfrew (1967,14) assumed that "[t]he notion [of portance of the transformations undergone in the Sintashta
exogenous origin of Aegean metallurgy] conforms, however, (metallurgical) culture during the Indo-European expan
to the belief that metallurgy came to the Aegean from the sion, from the beginning of the second millennium B.C.E.
east. Whether its origins were in Mesopotamia or southern (Sarianidi 1999; Jones-Bley 2000).
Anatolia, metal working was practiced in both areas well be 76Heskel and Lamberg-Karlovsky 1980.
fore its relatively sudden arrival in the Aegean." 77Thornton etal. 2002.
70 Gale etal. 2003,127. 78Kennoyer and Miller 1999, 116-17. From isolation of
71 E.g., Yener and Vandiver (1993) have described the rap metalworking areas from the Indus Valley settlements, Ken
id development of K?ltepe (Taurus Mountains), an Early noyer and Miller (1999, 117) suggested: "It is possible that
Bronze Age site of tin smelting. Its rapid integration in the the Indus people themselves were not involved in the mining
Anatolian trade network linking the Taurus region of tin pro and smelting."
duction with the Aegean, the Balkans, and the Amuq Valley is 79Hauptmann etal. 1988; Blackman etal. 1989.
discussed by Sahoglu 2005. 80 Potts 1993.
72 Kohl 2007,59. 81 Carter 2006.
73Chernykhl980. 82Branigan 1968; Pryce et al. 2007. During the Prepalatial
74Jettmar 1980; Mei 2000,58-60; Mei and Yanxiang 2003. period in Crete, most of the copper originated from the Cy
75Grigoriev (2000) mentions the affinities already observed clades and Laurion, though some was imported from Arabah
between the Sintashta and Near East furnace metallurgy. This and even Elam (Kristiansen and Larsson 2005,124).
point is especially interesting when one remembers the im 83LoSchiavo 1988; Ambert 1999.
through a pattern that parallels the spread of the Bell was specialized in a way that invokes the protoindus
Beaker culture. Also on continental Europe, furnace trial complex previously seen in the southern Levant.
metallurgy was diffusing concurrently with the spread Nothing is known about the identity of these metal
of the Bell Beaker culture.84 Beyond their patterns of lurgists, but their sudden emergence, their habitat in
migration, the discovery of tools for metalworking and fortified settlements, their limited influence on the
furnaces in Bell Beaker settlements confirms their in local culture, and their sudden disappearance at the
volvement in the diffusion of furnace metallurgy.85 end of the third millennium B.C.E. suggest that, also
In the early third millennium B.C.E., furnace met in this case, furnace metallurgy had no local origin.
allurgy made a sudden appearance at a very advanced
stage in the southern Iberian peninsula (Rio Tinto). Second Millennium B. C.E.
Settlements highly specialized in copper production During the second millennium B.C.E., furnace met
are identified, and the quantity of slag points to exten allurgy spread toward the limits of the ancient world:
sive mining and smelting activity.86 The process of cop it reached the British Isles,87 and two distinct paths
per production (smelting, purification, and casting) (the Baltic Sea and rivers from central Europe) led to
84Harrison 1974; Price etal. 1998; Craddock 1999; Vander near the sites of furnace metallurgy already existing from the
Linden 2007. According to Zoffmann (2000), the Bell Beaker beginning of the third millennium B.C.E. Their continental
people were aliens who did not mix with the indigenous Car diffusion via the Danube ties them to the furnace metallurgy
pathian population. from the Balkans.
85Gomori 1988; Brodie 1997; Price etal. 1998; Krause 2002; 86Nocete2006.
Sarauw 2007; Vander Linden 2007. Concerning the Mediter 87Tylecote 1986; Needham et al. 1989; Budd et al. 1992;
ranean diffusion, the Bell Beaker people probably resided Northover 1999.
i~~n?7-y^s-1?rrr^-1 t/ /i (OC)
a y?-/ Tin mining area
$y y^Kr-^^ \) ) T Copper o
or bronze
opment of furnace metallurgy, this region ingots from smelters belo
was already
metallurgical
of central importance in the network network."
of the trade and But these
distribution of obsidian.98 fusion are not systematically linked
The two processes of expansion Caucasus, for instance,
of furnace metal the emerge
lurgy are certainly interrelated.gical province
An isolated results
colony of from its geo
metallurgists (centripetal expansion) may
from the stimulate
Levantine core, and its e
toward province
the emergence of a new metallurgical Central Asia
(cen(centrifugal p
without
trifugal expansion). Reciprocally, theliving
smiths interaction
in a with smelter
metallurgical domain must have purchased
centripetal copper
process.100
copper and tin (Muhly 1995). to the Near East. But this claim is now bar
100 This
98 Bressy et al. 2005. Similarly, the pathway phenomenon
of diffusion ofis shown in the C
furnace metallurgy in the north of the ern Caucasian
Iranian (Kura-Araxes)
plateau follows culture
small
the lapis lazuli route linking the Indus settlements
Valley to the Nearfortified
East or perched
during the Late Neolithic period (Crawford 1974).
places, with no social differentiation (K
99 The existence of itinerant metallurgists supplying
the transfer met metallurgy to the
of furnace
al ingots to local metalworkers of Caucasus
central Europe has been
is followed by deep transformat
noted for a long time (Schaeffer 1949; Hanfmann
hierarchy 1952)
appears andMaikop culture
in the
confirmed by recent studies (Tylecote 1986,
casus, 10-24; Kristian
characterized by royal tombs (kur
sen and Larsson 2005, 108-16). The Levantine
and ascendancy
gold artifacts (Kohl 2007, 58-78). It is
den
of these itinerant smelters is stressed byconcentration
the analogy ofof power resulted fr
arti
northern
facts (and esp. specific neck-ring bronze ingots)Caucasus community
unearthed at of metall
Ugarit and in central and western Europe
vantine (early
network.second
Thismil
phenomenon is of
lennium B.C.E.). Later, Schaeffer-Forrer
tance (1978) attempted to
when considering the role of the M
invert the direction of influence byemergence and the
assuming that development
devel of the Indo
opment of bronze metallurgy spread gradually from Europe
101 Potts 1993; Prange et al. 1999. tance of the long-range network of trade and exchange in the
102Nocete 2006. Bronze Age world: "It is a point we wish to make that Bronze
103Rovira 2002. Nevertheless, it may be that the expansion Age research is thereby missing an essential aspect of this
of the Bell Beaker culture from the Iberian peninsula, from epoch?the importance ofjourneys, of trade and interactions.
the middle of the third millennium B.C.E., is concurrent with This led to a widespread transmission and transformation of
the massive presence of these alien smelters. social institutions with a Near Eastern/Mediterranean back
104Astour 1967; Kestemont 1983,1984; Castro 2006. ground in large parts of Bronze Age Europe?it is perhaps
105 Documents from Ebla, Man, Alalakh, and Ugarit reveal the most characteristic element of that epoch."
the importance of tin and cassiterite from countries as widely 108 Sherratt 1983.
separated as the Indus Valley and the Iberian peninsula and of 109 Levy and Shalev 1989; Joffe and Dessel 1995; Levy 1995.
their trade all over the ancient Near East (Linder 1981; Muhly 110 The scarcity of copper artifacts unearthed from Chal
1985; Stieglitz 1987; Pettinato 1995; Kristiansen and Larsson colithic and Early Bronze Age sites was justified by the con
2005,114-20). tinuous recycling of copper. The bias toward prestige artifacts
106The coexistence of local {dactyls, couretes) and foreign in regard to utilitarian tools was similarly justified (by their
(cyclopes, telkhine) metallurgists is stressed in Greek mythology. symbolic value, prestige artifacts are less easily recycled than
The latter, mainly involved in smelting and the supply of met utilitarian tools). However, through an analysis of cut marks
al ingots, are also considered daimonesof Near Eastern origin on butchered animal bones, Greenfield (1999) concluded
(Blakely-Westover 2002). that, in prehistoric southern Europe, metallic cutting tools
107 For a synthesis concerning the cultural homogeneity of were not commonly in use until the middle of the third mil
distant Bronze Age civilizations, see Kristansen and Larsson lennium B.C.E.
2005. The authors stress from the first page the central impor
per production was ignored (Egypt, the Caucasus, nace metallurgy is associated with the smelting of ore
northern Europe, Central Asia, Vietnam, China)111 or rather than with metalworking.117 It seems, therefore,
processed in crucibles (northern Euphrates, Anatolia, that the civilizing impetus accompanying the spread
Balkans, Greece, Elam).112 Accordingly, the transfor of metallurgy is more related to the production of the
mations stimulated by furnace smelting do not appear metal itself than the artifacts. Yet this elevated status
directly related to the circulation of copper artifacts. of the metallurgist is not observed in South America,
A look at traditional societies may help explain how where copper was produced by crucible smelting. This
furnace metallurgy may have provoked so many chang suggests that the civilizing dimension of metallurgy is
es. In Africa, smelters and smiths are not only known as intimately connected to the smelting of copper ore
craftsmen; they also regulate the political power (from in a furnace.
the instruction/coronation of the future leader to his Crucible smelting emerges in the context of pu
resignation), and they ensure the exercise of justice rification of native copper from its mineral gangue.
and the arbitration of conflict. They also possess the For this reason, the smelting of copper remains an
secret knowledge of divination, sorcery, rain making, extension of the purification of an already existing
medicine, poetry, and rites of passage (birth, puberty, matter, native copper. At best, the smelter "acceler
death) ,113 This crucial role is reflected in many African ates" in his crucible a natural process of copper pro
mythologies, where the first metallurgist (generally duction. But furnace smelting emerged in a context
coming from outside) is the civilizing hero par excel devoid of native copper. For this reason, the produc
lence.114 The major importance of the metallurgist is tion of copper in a furnace cannot be interpreted as
similarly expressed by many ancient mythologies. In an improvement/acceleration of any natural process
Greece, for instance, the civilizing hero (Prometheus, of maturation. Rather, the first production of copper
Phoroneus, Cadmos) is a metallurgist providing "divine in a furnace was probably interpreted as a process of
knowledge" to humankind. Similarly, the smith god creation of a matter previously unknown, since the
(Hephaistos) is a demiurge (creation of a woman and oxide ore from the southern Levant is totally devoid
of automats) forging "magic tools" for the other gods of native copper. In such a context, it is not surpris
(thus becoming the source of their divine power), and ing that the smelters became invested with demiurgic
building the apparatuses of the divine city (the robots (magical) powers, encouraging them to transcend the
on Olympus described in Horn. IIA). The importance boundaries of "existing matter," the universe given by
of legendary metallurgists and smith gods is extant the gods. As many ancient mythologies bear witness,
in many other ancient world traditions.115 Together, this "Promethean attitude" is probably the source of
they suggest that the ancient metallurgists enjoyed a the civilizing impetus accompanying, from its origin,
prestigious status similar to that recently encountered the spread of furnace metallurgy.
in Africa.116
CONCLUSION
Both in antiquity and in traditional cultures, smelt
ers enjoyed a more prestigious status than smiths. For The lack of a clear distinction between the furnace
instance, the magic/divine dimension related to fur and crucible smelting processes was the singular de
inChernykh 1980; Jettmar 1980; Zhimin 2000; Adams 46-63. For comparison of the myths and rituals from Africa
2002; Kristiansen and Larsson 2005; Nguyen Giang Hai 2005; and ancient Greece, see Blakely 2006. The similarity between
Kohl 2007. Mesopotamian and Greek myths relative to metallurgy is dis
112Caskey 1971; Ruiz 1993; Yener and Vandiver 1993; cussed by Penglase 1994,197-229.
Nakou 1995; White and Pigott 1996; Rothman 2004. 116 The civilizing heroes from antiquity are rooted in the
113Levi-Makarius 1974,108-44; Seignobos 1991. Bonze Age, while metallurgy is attested in central Africa from
114Tegnaeus 1950; Eliade 1977. the Early Iron Age. But the cultic importance of copper in Af
115 In the book of Genesis (4), the first engendered man is rican cultures (de Barros 2000,161) suggests that they are also
named Cain, a term designating the metallurgist. This first rooted in Bronze Age traditions.
smelter is also the founder of the first city. From his descen 117 The magical powers in ancient Greece were related to
dents, Tubal-Cain is the "father of the smiths" and Jubal the the semimythical smelters living apart in wild areas (cy dopes,
"father of poets and musicians." A similar link between met telkhines), rather than the smiths (couretes, dactyls), living in
allurgy and poetry is encountered in Greece (Athena), in the city (Blakely-Westover 2002). In many African cultures,
India (Saraswati), in the Celtic world (Brigit/Eithne), and in the upper stages of initiation (and, by consequence, the high
Finland (the brothers Ilmarinen/Vainamoinen). The civiliz est powers) are strictly reserved for the smelters, while the
ing aspect of metallurgists is stressed in Egypt by Aha/Menes, smelting itself is regarded as a secret activity (see, e.g., Njoku
the first king devoted to Ptah, the god of Nop (Memphis) pa 1991; Reid and MacLean 1995). For the magical element of
tronizing unification of the Upper and Lower Egypt. Also in metallurgy, see Budd and Taylor 1995; Martin 2005; Amzal
Persia, Housheng is both the first king and the first smelter. lag2008.
For further examples, see Eliade 1977,72-81; Amzallag 2008,
Ha'emeq." Tel Aviv 3:120-26. Proceedings of the International Conference "The Beginnings
Beit Arieh, I. 1980. "A Chalcolithic Site Near Ser?bit el of Metallurgy, Bochum, 1995, "edited by A. Hauptmann,
Kh?dim." Tel Aviv 7:45-64. E. Pernicka, T. Rehren, and U. Yalcin, 175-91. Der An
Bennett, A.T.N. 1989. "Crucible Smelting in Prehistoric schnitt 9. Bochum: Deutsches Bergbau-Museum.
Thailand." Institute of Archaeo-Metallurgical Studies News -. 2001. "From Earth to Furnace: Evidences for the
letter 14:5-6.
Earliest Metal Smelting Technologies in the Eastern
Blackman, M.J., S. Mery, and R.P. Wright. 1989. "Produc Mediterranean." Paleorient 26:151-65.
tion and Exchange of Ceramics on the Oman Peninsula Crawford, H.E.W. 1974. "The Problem of Tin in Mesopo
from the Perspective of Hili/'^FA 16:61-77. tamian Bronzes." WorldArch 6:242-47.
Blakely, S. 2006. Myth, Ritual, andMetallurgy in Ancient Greece Davey, C.J. 1988. "Tell edh-Dhiba'i and the Southern Near
and Recent Africa. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge Eastern Metalworking Tradition." In The Beginning of the
University Press. Use ofMetals and Alloys: Papers from the Second International
Blakely-Westover, S. 2002. "Smelting and Sacrifice: Com Conference on the Beginning of the Use of Metals and Alloys,
parative Analysis of Greek and Near Eastern Cult Sites Zhengzhou, China, 21-26 October 1986, edited by R. Mad
from the Late Bronze Through the Classical Period." din, 63-8. Cambridge, Mass.: The MIT Press.
In Metals in Antiquity, edited by S.M.M. Young, A.M. Davis, J.L. 1992. "Review of Aegean Prehistory I: The Is
Pollard, P. Budd, and R.A. Ixer, 86-90. BAR-IS 792. Ox lands of the Aegean." AJA 96(4) :699-756.
ford: Archaeopress. de Barros, P. 2000. "Iron Metallurgy: Sociocultural Con
Branigan, K. 1968. Copper and Bronze Working in Early Bronze text." In Ancient African Metallurgy, edited by M.S. Bisson
Age Crete. SIMA 19. Lund: Paul Astr?ms F?rlag. andJ.O. Vogel, 147-98. Walnut Creek, Calif.: AltaMira
Bressy, C, G. Poupeau, and K.A. Yener. 2005. "Cultural In Press.
teractions During the Ubaid and Halaf Periods: Tell Kur de Vaux, R. 1966. Palestine During the Neolithic and Chalco
du (Amuq Valley, Turkey) Obsidian Sourcing." JAS32: lithic Periods. CAH47. Rev. ed. Cambridge: Cambridge
1560-65. University Press.
Brodie, N. 1997. "New Perspectives on the Bell-Beaker Cul Donnan, C.B. 1973. "A Pre-Columbian Smelter from North
ture." OJA 16:297-314. ern Peru." Archaeology 26:289-97.
Budd, P., and T. Taylor. 1995. "The Faerie Smith Meets Eliade, M. 1977. Forgerons et Alchimistes. Rev. ed. Paris:
the Bronze Industry: Magic Versus Science in the Inter Flammarion.
pretation of Prehistoric Metal-Making." WorldArch 27: Ferembach, D. 1959. "Le peuplementduProche-Orientau
133-43. Chalcolithique et au Bronze Ancien." ZE/9:221-28.
Budd, P., D. Gale, A.M. Pollard, R.G. Thomas, and P.A. Fletcher, R. 2008. "Some Spatial Analyses of Chalcolithic
Williams. 1992. "The Early Development of Metallurgy Settlements in Southern Israel" JAS 35:2048-58.
in the British Isles." Antiquity 66:677-86. Gale, N.H. 1991. "Metals and Metallurgy in the Chalco
Butterlin, P. 2003. Les temps proto-urbains de Mesopotamia lithic Period." BASOR 282-283:37-61.
Contacts et acculturation ? Tepoque d'Uruk au Moyen-Orient. Gale, N.H., Z. Stos-Gale, A. Raduncheva, I. Panayotov, I.
Paris: CNRS Editions. Ivanov, P. Lilov, and T. Todorov. 2003. "Early Metallur
Caldwell, J.R. 1968. "Tal-i-Iblis and the Beginning of Cop gy in Bulgaria." In Mining and Metal Production Through
per Metallurgy at the Fifth Millennium." Archaeologia the Ages, edited by P.T. Craddock andj. Lang, 122-73.
Viva 1:145-50. London: The British Museum Press.
Carter, R. 2006. "Boat Remains and Maritime Trade in the Gamkrelidze, T.V., and V.V. Ivanov. 1985. "The Migrations
Persian Gulf During the Sixth and Fifth Millennia BC." of Tribes Speaking the Indo-European Dialects from
Antiquity 80:52-63. Their Original Homeland in the Near East to Their His
Caskey J.L. 1971. "Greece, Crete, and the Aegean Islands in torical Habitations in Eurasia."yZES 13:49-91.
the Early Bronze Age." In Early History of the Middle East, Gates, M.H. 1992. "Nomadic Pastoralists and the Chalco
edited by I.E.S. Edwards, CJ. Gadd, and N.G.L. Ham lithic Hoard from Nahal Mishmar." Levant 24:131-39.
mond, 771-807. CAH 1(2). 3rd ed. Cambridge: Cam Giblin,J.I. 2009. "Strontium Isotope Analysis of Neolithic
bridge University Press. and Copper Age Populations on the Great Hungarian
Castro, J.L.L. 2006. "Colonials, Merchants and Alabaster Plain^/AS 36:491-97.
Vases: The Western Phoenician Aristocracy." Antiquity Gilead, 1.1990. "The Neolithic-Chalcolithic Transition and
80:74-88. the Qatifian of the Northern Negev and Sinai." Levant
Chernykh, E.N. 1980. "Metallurgical Provinces of the 5th 22:47-64.
2nd Millennia in Eastern Europe in Relation to the Pro -. 1994. "The History of Chalcolithic Settlement in
cess of Indo-Europeanization." ?ES 8:317-36. the Nahal Beer Sheva Area: The Radiocarbon Aspect."
Coleman, J.E. 1977. Kephala: A Late Neolithic Settlement and BASOR 296:1-13.
Cemetery. Keos 1. Princeton: American School of Clas Glumac, P.D., andJ.A. Todd. 1991. "Eneolithic Copper
sical Studies.
Smelting Slags from the Middle Danube." In Archaeometry,
Cooper, H.K., MJ.M. Duke, A. Simonetti, and G.C. Chen. edited by E. Pernicka and G.A. Wagner, 155-64. Basel:
2008. "Trace Element and Pb Isotope Provenance Anal Birkh?user Verlag.
yses of Native Copper in Northwestern North America: Golden, J., T.E. Levy, and A. Hauptmann. 2001. "Recent
Results of a Recent Pilot Study Using INAA, ICP-MS, Discoveries Concerning Chalcolithic Metallurgy at
and LA-MC-ICP-MS.'7AS 35:1732-47. Shiqmim, Israel."^ 28:951-63.
Craddock, P.T. 1995. Early Metal Mining and Production. Gomori, J. 1988. "The Earliest Use of Metals in Hungary."
Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. In The Beginnings of the Use of Metals and Alloys: Papersfrom
-. 1999. "Paradigms of Metallurgical Innovation in the Second International Conference on the Beginning of the
Prehistoric Europe." In The Beginnings of Metallurgy: Use of Metals and Alloys, Zhengzhou, China, 21-26 October
Levy, T.E., and S. Shalev. 1989. "Prehistoric Metalworking Needham, S.P., M.N. Leese, D.R. Hook, andJ.M. Hughes.
in the Southern Levant: Archaeometallurgical and So 1989. "Developments in the Early Bronze Age Metallurgy
cial Perspectives." WorldArch 20:352-72. of Southern Britain." WorldArch 20:383-402.
Levy, T.E., R.B. Adams, A. Hauptmann, M. Prange, S. Nguyen Giang Hai. 2005. "Ancient Metallurgy in Vietnam:
Schmitt-Strecker, andM. Najjar. 2002. "Early Bronze Age An Ethno-Archaeological Investigation." Indo-Pacific Pre
Metallurgy: A Newly Discovered Copper Manufactory in history Association Bulletin 25:121-23.
Southern Jordan." Antiquity 76:425-37. Nilhamn, B. 2003. Revealing Domesticity: White Ware as an
. Linder, E. 1981. "Ugarit: A Canaanite Thalassocracy." In Indicator of Change in Near Eastern Archaeology. Uppsala:
Ugarit in Retrospect, edited by G.D. Young, 31-42. Wino Uppsala University Press.
na, Ind.: Eisenbrauns. Njoku, O.N. 1991. "Magic, Religion and Iron Technology
LoSchiavo, F. 1988. "Early Metallurgy in Sardinia." In The in Precolonial North-Western Igholand." Journal of Reli
Beginnings of the Use of Metals and Alloys: Papers from the gions in Africa 21:194-215.
Second International Conference on the Beginning of the Use Nocete, F. 2006. "The First Specialised Copper Industry in
of Metals and Alloys, Zhengzhou, China, 21-26 October 1986, the Iberian Peninsula: Cabezojure (2900-2200 BC)."
edited by R. Maddin, 92-103. Cambridge, Mass.: The MIT Antiquity 80:646-57.
Press. NorthoverJ.P. 1999. "The Earliest Metalworking in South
Majidzadeh, Y. 1979. "An Early Prehistoric Coppersmith ern Britain." In The Beginnings of Metallurgy'.Proceedings of
Workshop at Tepe Ghabristan." AMIran 6:82-92. the International Conference "The Beginnings of Metallurgy,"
Mallowan, M.E.L. 1963. "The Amuq Plain." Antiquity 37: Bochum, 1995, edited by A. Hauptmann, E. Pernicka, T.
185-92. Rehren, and U. Yalcin, 211-25. Der Anschnitt 9. Bochum:
Martin, M. 2005. Magie et magiciens dans lemondegreco-romain. Deutsches Bergbau-Museum.
Paris: Editions Errance. ?zbal, H., A Adriaens, and B. Earl. 2000. "Hacinebi Metal
McGeehan-Liritzis, V. 1983. "The Relationship Between Production and Exchange." Paleorient 25:57-65.
Metalwork, Copper Sources and the Evidence for Set Park J.S., and R.B. Gordon. 2007. "Traditions and Transitions
tlement in the Greek Late Neolithic and Early Bronze in Korean Bronze Technology."/AS34:1991-2002.
Age." OJA 2:147-80. Patterson, C.C. 1971. "Native Copper, Silver, and Gold Ac
McGeehan-Liritzis, V., andN.H. Gale. 1988. "Chemiealand cessible to Early Metallurgists." AmerAnt 36:286-321.
Lead Isotope Analyses of Greek Late Neolithic and Early Penglase, C. 1994. Greek Myths and Mesopotamia. London:
Bronze Age Metals." Archaeometry 30:199-255. Routledge.
Mei, J. 2000. Copper and Bronze Metallurgy in Late Prehistoric Pettinato, G. 1995. "Testi cuneiformi del 3. millennio in paleo
Xinjiang BAR-IS 865. Oxford: Archaeopress. cananeo rinvenuti nella campagna 1974 a Tell Mardikh
Mei, J., and L. Yanxiang. 2003. "Early Copper Technology Ebla." Orientalia 44:361-74.
in Xinjiang China: The Evidence So Far." In Mining and Philip, G. 2003. "The Early Bronze Age of the Southern
Metal Production Through the Ages, edited by P.T. Craddock Levant: A Landscape Approach." JMA 16:103-32.
andj. Lang, 111-21. London: British Museum Press. Pigott, V.C. 1996. "Near Eastern Archaeometallurgy: Mod
Mellaart, J. 1966. The Chalcolithic and Early Bronze Age in the ern Research and Future Directions." In The Study of the
Near East and Anatolia. Beirut: Khayrats Publishing. Ancient Near East in the Twenty-First Century, edited byJ.S.
Merkel, J., and B. Rothenberg. 1999. "The Earliest Steps to Cooper and G.M. Schwartz, 139-76. Winona Lake, Ind.:
Copper Metallurgy in the Western Arabah." In The Begin Eisenbrauns.
nings of Metallurgy: Proceedings of the International Confer -. 1999a. "The Development of Metallurgy on the
ence ''The Beginnings of Metallurgy, "Bochum, 1995, edited Iranian Plateau: An Archaeological Perspective." In The
by A. Hauptmann, E. Pernicka, T. Rehren, and U. Yalcin, Archaeometallurgy of the Asian Old World, edited by V.C.
149-65. Der Anschnitt 9. Bochum: Deutsches Bergbau Pigott, 73-106. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania
Museum. Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology.
Miller, D.E., and J. van der Merwe. 1994. "Early Metal -. 1999b. "Reconstructing the Copper Production
Working in Sub-Saharian Africa: A Review of Recent Process as Practised Among Prehistoric Mining/Metal
Research. "Journal of African History 35:1-36. lurgical Communities in the Khao Wong Prachan Val
Moesta, H. 1986. "Bronze Age Copper Smelting." Interdis ley of Central Thailand." In Metals in Antiquity, edited
ciplinary Science Review 11:73-87. by S.M.M. Young, AM. Pollard, P. Budd, and R.A. Ixer,
Moorey, P.R.S. 1999. Ancient Mesopotamian Materials and In 10-21. BAR-IS792. Oxford: Archaeopress.
dustries: The Archaeological Evidence. Winona Lake, Ind.: Potts, D.T. 1993. "Rethinking Some Aspects of Trade in
Eisenbrauns. the Arabian Gulf." WorldArch 24:423-40.
Muhly, J.D. 1985. "Sources of Tin and the Beginning of Prange, M.K, HJ. G?tze, A. Hauptmann, and G. Weisberg
Bronze Metallurgy." AJA 89(2):275-91. er. 1999. "Is Oman the Ancient Magan? Analytical Stud
-. 1989. "Cayon? Tepesi and the Beginnings of Met ies of Copper from Oman." In Metals in Antiquity, edited
allurgy in the Ancient World." In Old World Archaeometal by S.M.M. Young, AM. Pollard, P. Budd, and R.A. Ixer,
lurgy: Proceedings of the International Symposium "Old World 187-92. BAR-IS 792. Oxford: Archaeopress.
Archaeometallurgy, "Heidelberg, 1987, edited by A. Hautp Price, T.D., G. Grupe, and P. Schr?ter. 1998. "Migration
mann, E. Pernicka, and G.A. Wagner, 1-11. Der Anschnitt in the Bell Beaker Period of Central Europe." Antiquity
7. Bochum: Deutsches Bergbau-Museum. 72:405-11.
-. 1995. "Mining and Metalwork in Ancient Western Price, T.D., C. Knipper, G. Grupe, and V. Smrcka. 2004.
Asia." In Civilizations ofthe Ancient NearEast.Vol. 3, edited "Strontium Isotopes and Prehistoric Human Migra
byJ.M. Sasson, 1501-21. New York: MacMillan. tions: The Bell Beaker Period in Central Europe." EJA 7:
Nakou, G. 1995. "The Cutting Edge: A New Look at Early 9-40.
Aegean Metallurgy." JMA 8:1-32. Pryce, T.O., Y. Bassiakos, M. Catapotis, and R.C. Doonan.
Wertime, T.A. 1973. "The Beginnings of Metallurgy: A New Yener, K.A., and P.B. Vandiver. 1993. "Tin Processing at
Look." Science 182:875-87. G?ltepe, an Early Bronze Age Site in Anatolia." AJA 97 (2):
White J.C., and V.C. Pigott. 1996. "From Community Craft 207-38.
to Regional Specialization: Intensification of Copper Zhimin, A 2000. "Some Problems Concerning Early Chi
Production in Pre-State Thailand." In Craft Specializa nese Copper and Bronze Artifacts." In The Beginnings of
tion and Social Evolution, edited by B. Wailes, 151-75. Metallurgy in China, edited by K.M. Linduff, H. Rubin,
University Museum Monograph 93. Philadelphia: Uni and S. Shuyun, 63-81. Chinese Studies 11. Lewiston,
versity of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and N.Y.: Edwin Meiler Press.
Anthropology. Zoffmann, Z.K. 2000. "Anthropological Sketch of the Pre
Yener, K.A. 2000. The Domestication of Metals: The Rise of Com historic Population of the Carpathian Basin." Acta Bio
plex Metal Industries in Anatolia. Leiden: Brill. logica Szegediensis 44:75-9.