c
 

c
c 
c 





Dear Editor,p

c refer to the letter by R Karim entitled ³m
 
 


 


  Ô (SN Jan 18 2011), and would appreciate the opportunity to
respond! p

Karim perpetuates the stream of disinformation from an increasingly desperate group of propagandists on behalf of the Arabs in Palestine. His
contentions can be rebutted on several clear grounds, and one senses an increasing reluctance in the blogosphere to defend the indefensible! Not many
persons chose to comment online, and those that did not agree with Karim¶s views had to « wait!p

Firstly, and significantly, clan Pappe and Edwin Montagu will go down in history as the two most confused Jews ever claiming the nationality. While
Montagu's utter tomfoolery has long been documented, Pappe¶s is a work in progress!p

Secondly, Karim offers no references, no authority outside of Pappe's delusion, to support his contentions « or any that illustrate that thousands of other
csraeli scholars reject Pappe¶s account of the factual record. On the other hand, we have consistently offered the online article "-
 



 


 


 " (http://www.mythsandfacts.com/conflict/mandate_for_palestine/mandate_for_palestine.htm ) as a starting point
for any discussion. The astonishing thing is that that article addresses ALMOST ALL of his issues. p

Karim refuses to rebut same! Why?p

A rebuttal in the absence of Karim's unwillingness to address "-
 


: ..." devolves to the simple task of providing an even wider net of
evidence that rejects the idea of Arab "innocence" in their departure from csrael. Readers will be astonished to know that Arabs were enraged when the
UN offered to partition csrael in 1947, and scuttled the deal after ³only being offeredÔ 50% of csrael¶s land (don't forget, csrael had already given away
77% to enable the formation of Jordan). Their ³rageÔ was immediately manifest in several brutal ways. The following extract is instructive: « p

"... à
  


 à
 
 
      à
 

    

 


 
 
   
 
  
  









  
 
 




p

   






 




 !   
"#"$%& 
"'#(
 



   

  à

 
  

 
     ))
           


 

 
 
    
 
p

à
 


)



)


  )

 

 )

!
)


 



  )   
      *

+  


 
  
 
)   

  



 à  
,
-,,



-./ p




   p

à  





 ,

-  


 0


12"$%3."( "$%&1#



 ) 
 
4 5 6 .7
''%%




 ) 

-8
9
:
 7
'$'1




 
 

) 

 
, 6
 
p

à  






)
      
 "1  "'3


 
  ;
5 6   "#
"$%&

12
 



)
5 6 9 p

*  
 
 "22


 
) )




 
) 



 


p

9  
 
    6 

 +

    ) 4  9


 ,   

 9  :  ;
 :
6   
0


*7
 
 
8 <
6 :
 ,
à =
5 5, 6)
 6

,)- p

*    

   
       ,   %22  
 
 )

 *       ;
 0  




9
 p

  
   
à

 
   7
 * 

 )

 
9 
) ,
 5))
 


  
p

 

 - 


 

 




>
 
?  

 

   > ?


  
*
 ))







"$%&p

9    p

à

 "'#(





  5





 )


 
$'%
 



p

*
  
 

  )  




 

  

)

 «.Ô p

Source: http://smoothstone.wordpress.com/category/what-happened-in-1948/ p
Next, we look at the book "V 


 
 
m
 Ô ... a brutal expose¶ of Pappe¶s misadventure into revisionism! cnitial
excerpts are found at http://www.amazon.com/Fabricating-csraeli-History-Historians-Politics/product-reviews/071468063X .p

The mayhem that has followed EVERY YEAR thereafter has been well documented. Surely the government of Guyana, and Karim, should have
considered the implications of current csraeli responses after reading the online article "  


 
 !


" by WM Johnston (
http://www.johnstonsarchive.net/terrorism/terrisrael.html ). cf Karim were a connoisseur of wine, and the analogy were acceptable, there is no doubt that
he would say to Johnston that ³2006 was a good yearÔ!

The Arab view on Jewish lives is that cynical and crude « and they expect us all to agree with them!p

'