LEGAL ARENA ASSESSMENT SHEET

Prescribed Word limit: 1200-2500 Words

Total Words in the document: 3076

Name of the Doc: LA_ENTRY3_DG

Title of the Manuscript: USE OF SCENT IN FORENSIC SCIENCE

Analysis/Comments of the Associate Editor:

Name: Marks/Remarks:

Topic: Relevancy [Marks out of 5]: 4

USE DIGITS

Novelty [Marks out of 5]: 4

USE DIGITS

Content: % of Plagiarism 0

USE DIGITS

No. Of hyperlinks/Citations 12
used:

USE DIGITS

Language: Contours touched: Abstract, introduction, research methodology,

central discussion, admissibility, analysis and
results

Laws mentioned: Federal Rules of Evidence (US), Forensic US case

laws

Recommendation for
the Senior Editor (if
any):

Total Marks Allotted (Out of 20): 16.5

 Analysis/Comments of the Senior Editor 1:

Name: Remarks:

Topic: Relevancy:

Novelty:

Content: Research:

Utilisation of cited
resources:

Language: Argument making/nature of

arguments:

Distribution of sub
heads/paragraphs/flow of the
article:

Recommendation
for the Reviewer (if
any):

Total Marks Allotted (Out of 30):

 Analysis/Comments of the Senior Editor 2:

Name: Remarks:

Topic: Relevancy:

Novelty:

Content: Research:

Utilisation of cited
resources:

Language: Argument making/nature of

arguments:

Distribution of sub
heads/paragraphs/flow of the
article:

Recommendation
for the Reviewer (if
any):

Total Marks Allotted (Out of 30):

Total Marks Allotted (Out of 60):

 Analysis/Comments of the Reviewer 1:

Name: Remarks:

Topic: Relevancy:

Novelty:

Content: Research:

Utilisation of cited
resources:

Language: Argument making/nature of

arguments:

Distribution of sub
heads/paragraphs/flow of the
article:

Recommendation for
the Managing Editor
(if any):

Total Marks Allotted (Out of 30):

 Analysis/Comments of the Reviewer 2:

Name: Remarks:

Topic: Relevancy:

Novelty:

Content: Research:

Utilisation of cited
resources:

Language: Argument making/nature of

arguments:

Distribution of sub
heads/paragraphs/flow of the
article:

Recommendation for
the Managing Editor
(if any):

Total Marks Allotted (Out of 30):

Total Marks Allotted (Out of 60):

ALLOTMENT OF MARKS
Reviewed by: Associate Editors Senior Editors Reviewers

(Name)

Marks (out of 20) [T]:

Marks (out of 60) [C]:

Marks (out of 60) [L]:

Total Marks
[TM=T+L+C]:

Total Marks (Out of 140):