FACTS

The real Patrick Caronan is the younger brother of Richard Caronan The real Patrick
Caronan was a degree holder of Business Administration from the University of Makati
(UM) while his brother Richard studied at the Pamantasan ng Lungsod ng Maynila
(PLM) and was later transferred to the Philippine Military Academy (PMA). Richard
Caronan was discharged from PMA after a year to help in their car rental business. He
never went back to school and moved to Nueva Vizcaya with his wife and three children
in 1997 Richard Caronan informed his brother two years after that he was enrolled at a
law school in Nueva Vizcaya. In 2004, Patrick was informed by his mother that his
brother passed the Bar examination. He was further informed that Patrick used his
name and college records to enroll at St. Mary’s University College of Law.
When the National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) asked Patrick’s office for his
participation in an investigation against 'Atty. Patrick A. Caronan' for committing
qualified theft and estafa, Patrick was forced to resign which drove him to file a
complaint against his own brother.
The fake lawyer richard caronan was also arrested for gun-running activities, illegal
possessions of explosives, and violation of the Bouncing Checks Law.
In 2013, the Commission on Bar Discipline of the IBP received a complaint from Patrick
Caronan against his brother after he resigned from his work because of the
consequences of his brother’s doing.

All allegations were denied by Richard who strongly argued that an earlier
administrative case, AC No. 10074, resolved and closed the issue on his identity.
However, Patrick was able to clearly establish before the high court that he is the real
'Patrick A. Caronan.'
It was further pointed out by the IBP that Richard does not have a pre-law degree
because of his non-completion of his undergraduate bachelor’s degree.

RULING

“Good moral character is essential in those who would be lawyers. This is imperative in
the nature of the office of a lawyer, the trust relation which exists between him and his
client, as well as between him and the court,” emphasized the court.
Richard’s actions and behavior were held by the high court as dishonest and a display
of moral unfitness to be a member of the Bar.
- Richard Caronan, who was admitted to the Bar as 'Atty. Patrick A. Caronan', was
disbarred by the Supreme Court for stealing his brother’s name and identity
- richard caronan, after committing fraud, further violated the law for his
involvement in gun-running activities, illegal possession of explosives, and
violation of the Bouncing Checks Law
- The Supreme Court pointed out that Richard exhibited dishonesty and moral
unfitness to be a member of the Bar by assuming his brother’s name and for
bringing adversities to his brother’s life
The Supreme Court ordered that the name 'Patrick A. Caronon with Roll of Attorneys
No. 49069' be removed in the Roll of Attorneys, through a per curiam decision in
Administrative Case No. 11316 which was promulgated last July 12, 2016, after Richard
A. Caronan stole the identity of his sibling to practice the law.
The high court further barred Richard A. Caronan, who has been admitted as a member
of the Bar as 'Atty. Patrick A. Caronan'. Further, all identification cards and certificates
issued by the Integrated Bar of the Philippines (IBP) and the Mandatory Continuing
Legal Education (MCLE) to Richard Caronan under the name 'Atty. Patrick A. Caronan'
are nullified by the high court.
Moreover, the Office of the Court Administrator was ordered to publicize Richard
Caronan’s photograph to warn all the courts in the Philippines of his fake identity as
'Atty. Patrick A. Caronan'.