Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless
you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you
may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use.
Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at .
http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=caa. .
Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed
page of such transmission.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
College Art Association is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Art Journal.
http://www.jstor.org
In 2004, photographs of prisoner torture in
Abu Ghraib prison became street murals
inTehran. Photograph: Behrouz Merhri/
Getty Images.
In the on the moral of Abu Ghraib, several com
topical commentary disgrace
mentators have noted a resemblance between the torture
photos from Iraq and
'
American These similarities have remained
lynching photos. largely unexplored,
however, including perhaps the most significant effects of the two sets of
photos,
which is that both came to function as sites of resistance the very acts
against
they represent. Between deeds that are very different in nature and motivation,
and which took place at very different times and places, what
DoraApel might we learn from the similarities? What indeed constitutes
these similarities?2 In this essay, I examine the usefulness of par
89 art journal
men, who would often be humiliated, tortured, and castrated. In addition to the
threatening to shame them in front of their families and community if they did
not become for the United States. One consultant said, "I was
spies government
told that the purpose of the photographs was to create an army of informants,
4. See my Imagery of Lynching: Black Men, White could insert back into
people you the population." Seymour Hersh revealed the
Women, and theMob (New Brunswick, NJ:
facts in the New Yorker, an unnamed CIA official and both current and for
Rutgers University Press, 2004). quoting
5. Quoted inAdam Liptak, "Legal Scholars mer intelligence officials. They trace the problem to a special program set up in
Criticize Torture Memos," New York Times, June
with commandos authorized to use terror and at secret
25, 2004, A14. Afghanistan degradation
6. Hersh, "The Gray Zone."
90 SUMMER 2005
CIA tanks, which was then to
holding exported Iraq.6
This would Rumsfeld's first reaction to the was not
explain why photos
shock, horror, or but that had out.7 He
surprise, anger they gotten immediately
banned soldiers' cameras at prisons. Like those from Abu
lynching photos,
Ghraib were meant to stay within a like-minded
community. Spectacle lynchings
were recorded amateurs
by hundreds of with Kodaks, and professional photog
turned out thousands of postcards. But Southern town leaders were as
raphers
distressed as Rumsfield when lynching photos found their way into the hands of
Northern and liberal activists, who used them for opposing
left-wing ideological
purposes, although itwould have been difficult to ban the taking of such photos
Lynndie England and prisoner on a leash, and systematic American phenomena like lynchings, which followed a history of
Abu Ghraib prison, Baghdad, October 25, a
On the other hand, the rhetoric of "oriental
slavery. longstanding demonizing
2003.
ism," the old and unresolved Israeli/Palestinian conflict, and the effects of the
first Gulf War in 1991 have many Americans to view many Arabs and
encouraged
Muslims with growing suspicion and distrust, which burst into open and wan
figure both by her gaze and by the physical line of connection, we might believe
that the youthful England is trapped in a descending spiral of victimization
the pressure to conform to the demands of prison culture exerted
produced by
by her largely male peers and superiors. By impelling her to comply with an
act of humiliation and her these actions
appalling deep documenting complicity,
Abdou Hussain Saad Faleh, prisoner at the way for future and collusion in further acts of torture
paved acquiescence
Abu Ghraib, November 4, 2003. and abuse. For the Arab world, the picture of a naked Arab man held
however, by
the throat as the of a short-haired American woman in can
"pet" military garb
only confirm the worst suspicions of the most perverse anti-Arab contempt
harbored by Americans,
The second first in the New Yorker, represents the most
photo, published
7. On the role of the father of Ivan Frederick, one
emblematic of the torture scandal: the hooded man on a box
of the accused soldiers, ingetting the pictures to image standing
SixtyMinutes II,which broadcast them on April with wires attached to his hands, who was told by Specialist Sabrina Harmon
28, 2004, see "Here's How the Abu Ghraib
that he would be electrocuted if he fell off the box. According to the testimony
Photos Got Out," available online at http://talk
left.com/ new_archives/006410.html#006410, of the victim, Abdou Hussain Saad Faleh, the wires were not attached to
only
May 8, 2004. Specialist Joseph M. Darby also his but also his toes and Known as the the res
fingers penis.8 "Vietnam," image
turned over CDs with photographs of the tor
ture. See "In a Soldier's Words, an Account of onates with allusions to the crucifixion, robed monks, the Statue of the
Liberty,
Concerns," New York Times, May 22, 2004, avail the executioner, the mask of death.
Klan,
able online at http://www.nytimes.com/2004/
05/22/politics/22WTEX.html?ex=l 113969600& But most of all, like themortified Christ, the image signals abjection and
en=c6dc9c55e8f06b78&ei=5070&fta=y. surrender. The echoes of innocence, sacrifice, and that lend it a tragic
suffering
8. See translation of statement provided by
Abdou Hussain Saad Faleh, January 16, 2004, in air aremade all themore chilling by the hooding and wires?a decidedly
Danner, Torture and Truth, 230. modern emblem of martyrdom, dubbed Sarah Boxer "the icon of the abuse"
by
91 art journal
it shows "no no dead, no leash, no face, no nakedness, no
although dogs, pileup,
no Rather, it "unites of torture and sacredness or
thumbs-up."9 figures divinity,"
asW J. T. Mitchell observes. "This is not the crucified or resurrected Christ," he
grueling ordeal of the victim, allowing the viewer to identify with both and
the experience unbearable. Chen conveys the visual
making virtually ambiguity
between ecstasy and stupefaction in the lolling head and rolling eyes of the vic
tim, which echoes the reading of such photos by Bataille, who saw on the
Chinese victim's face an that confirmed his about the
expression assumptions
close connection between and Bataille to endow the execu
pleasure pain. sought
9. Sarah Boxer, "Torture Incarnate, and Propped
on a Pedestal," New York Times, June 13, 2004. tions of lingchiwith an ambiguously sacred or sacrificial quality; but, as Giorgio
W. J.T. Mitchell, "Echoes of a Christian
10. the of sacrifice and eroticism is not ade
Agamben argues, conceptual apparatus
Symbol," Chicago Tribune, June 27, 2004, Section
quate to grasp the profane and banal violence of modern life.I2 The
2, I, available online at http://humanities. political
uchicago.edu/faculty/mitchell/interviews.htm. delirium of the victim combined with the shame of the witnesses in Chen's fic
I I. For the most authoritative information on
tional video is piercingly traumatic; this helps to explain the psychological need
lingchi, see the work of the research group
Turandot, which held a conference on "The for the hood in Iraq,which not only disorients the victim, but also effaces their
Representation of Pain," April 22-23, 2005, at
humanity for the perpetrator and more turns the into an
easily subject object.
University College Cork inCork, Ireland. The
Turandot Web site on Chinese torture is When were transformed into souvenir
lynching photos postcards, they
http://turandot.ish-lyon.cnrs.fr/. Also see An-yi were sent to friends and with the senders'
family proud boasts of having been
Pan, "Contemporary Taiwanese Art in the Era
of Contention," inContemporary Taiwanese Art in in the mob, blackness an exotic and the "look" of
making spectacle privileging
the Era of Contention, exh. cat. (Ithaca: Johnson over blacks. Spectacle lynchings
Museum of Art, Cornell University; Taipei: Taipei
whites similarly relied on the look of the crowd
to reaffirm notions of white "manliness" over the of the
Fine Arts Museum, 2004), 158, 160-61. superior stereotype
12.Giorgio Agamben, Homo Sacer: Sovereign sexual black male, even as many white men in the mob acted on
hyper repressed
Power and Bare Life, trans. Daniel Heller-Roazen
homoerotic desires and many white women found vicarious in the
(Stanford: Stanford University Press, pleasure
1998),
112-15. mob's exposure and penetrations of the black body. At Abu Ghraib, compact
92 SUMMER 2005
discs, videos, and computer files of digital images performed the role of the
and were meant to circulate
only within the community of American
postcards,
military personnel, their families, and friends. The pictures established the right
of the soldiers to "look" at the nude and brutalized bodies of their victims, even
to pose with corpses, while effacing the look of the prisoners through hooding
and other forms of degradation.
Likewise, the voices of the tortured, like the voices of victims, were
lynching
meant to be silenced outside the circumstances of their ordeal. But testimonies
have been taken. One prisoner tells of being covered with phosphoric liquid
from a chemical light and raped with a stick: "Then they broke the glowing fin
ger and spread it on me until Iwas glowing and they were laughing. They took
me to the room and me to on the floor. And one of the police
they signaled get
he put a part of his stick that he always carries inside my ass and I felt it going
inside me about 2 centimeters, And I started and he
approximately. screaming,
93 art journal
humiliated as any of us would be in the same situation.ls
occupiers. It is no surprise that this is the perception of much of the Arab world,
Cultural theorist Zizek suggests that the issue of abuse is more perva
Slavoj
sive and fundamental to American culture. "Far too often," he writes, "we are
94 SUMMER 2005
(such as the John Reed Club and International Labor Defense, both affiliated
with the Communist Party, and the NAACP), the torture photos of Abu Ghraib
also have become the basis for antiwar images and artworks.22 The of the
photos
man on a leash and the hooded man are now side side as murals on
painted by
a wall in Tehran, once that the meaning of
demonstrating again images depends
on the arena inwhich they circulate. Like their distribution in the world media,
this public transforms them from private souvenirs of American
visibility
laughing while taking photographs. Here, as Lynndie England mocks the genitals
of one in a row of naked prisoners, her jauntiness and the casualness of her dan
gling cigarette differ markedly from the stiffness of her pose with the prisoner
on a leash. is The man to whom she points, who
England's cooptation complete.
mmmv*wt. ^mxr-vr' m.im.biiihm?bu. m has since been released, has come forward to identify himself as Saddam Saleh.
Lynndie England and prisoners at Abu He says he only knows that he is the third from the right because American sol
Ghraib. to his cell and pointed him out, in an obvious
diers brought the photograph
effort to humiliate him further. He was tortured for another before
eighteen days
the interrogations began.24
Other also have testified about their sexual humiliation: "The two
prisoners
American girls that were there when they
were me, they
were me
beating hitting
with a ball made of sponge on my dick. And when Iwas tied up inmy room,
one of the girls, with blonde hair, she iswhite, she was playing with my dick."
22. See my Imagery of Lynching.
23. Boxer, "Torture Incarnate, and Propped on a This was also urinated on a and made to bark
prisoner by military policeman
Pedestal."
like a dog, hit on the side of the head so forcefully that he lost consciousness,
24. Buncombe, Huggler, and Doyle, "Abu
Ghraib." forced to wear women's red underwear on his head, and tied to a window in his
25. See translations of statements: [name blacked
cell with his hands behind his back until he again lost consciousness. Another
out], January 21, 2004; Shalan Said Al-Sharoni,
saw a beaten with Others remembered how soldiers
January 17, 2004; Nori Samir Gunbar Al-Yasseri, prisoner's genitals gloves.
January 17, 2004; Hussein Mohssein Mata Al ordered them to masturbate, sometimes in front of female soldiers, and to simu
Zayiadi, January 4, 2004; Hiadar Sabar Abed
late homosexual acts.25 Jonathan Raban characterizes the infantilization
Miktub Al-Aboodi, January 20, 2004; all in effectively
Danner, Torture and Truth, 247-48, 234, 236-37, and feminization of Arabs the Americans: "Here is Arabia nude, faceless under
by
240, 245.
a hood, or feminised in women's forced into infantile mas
26. Jonathan Raban, "Emasculating Arabia," The ridiculously panties,
Guardian (London), May 13, 2004, Features, 6.
95 art journal
sex and
turbatory sodomy."26
A photograph of a human pyramid pictures a grinning Sabrina Harman and
Charles Graner posing with their handiwork, Graner offering a thumbs-up. The
word "RAPEIST" [sic], written on the leg of one of the prisoners, echoes the
charges against black lynching victims and becomes a bitter parody of blaming
the victim for the crime of the perpetrator. "We thought it looked funny, so pic
tures were taken," told She confessed that piling
England investigators.27 prison
ers naked or forcing them tomasturbate had nothing to do with interrogations;
but it has everything to do with the arrogance that seeks global domination and
is insensitive to the of "others," as a to
subjugation functioning corollary
American nationalist pride.
Hussein Mohssein Mata Al-Zayiadi was among the Iraqis in the pyramid
who later sworn in which he described his ordeal and its after
gave testimony
math: "After that they brought my friends, Haidar, Ahmed, Nouri, Ahzem,
:t
Hashiem, Mustafa, and I and they put us 2 on the bottom, 2 on top of them, and
Sabrina Harman and Charles Graner
2 on those and one on took of us and we were naked.
behind human pyramid of hooded Iraqi top of top. They pictures
prisoners at Abu Ghraib, November 7 or 8, After the end of the beating, they took us to our separate cells and they opened
2003.
the water in the cell and told us to lay face down in the water and we stayed like
that until the morning, in the water, naked, without clothes." When asked how
he felt about this treatment, he replied, "Iwas trying to kill myself but I didn't
have any way of doing it."28
they represent. Here Sallat makes clear his that the mere act of
understanding
more familiar to Iraqis. The words painted on the wall indicate themockery of
"freedom" that the war on Iraq has produced, doubling the hooded man with
the preeminent of America. The Statue of once the icon of wel
symbol Liberty,
come to stands above all for American But the rhetoric of
27. "U.S. Rules on Prisoners Seen as a Back and refugees, democracy.
Forth of Mixed Messages to G.I.'s," New York is exposed for its extreme The images that illustrate the
democracy hypocrisy.
Times, June 22, 2004, A7. words "That Freedom for Bush" what this rhetoric has set in motion
represent
28. Translation of statement provided by Hussein
and come to mean; since the rationale for war was the export of freedom and
Mohssein Mata Al-Zayiadi, January 18, 2004, in
Danner, Torture and Truth, 240.
democracy, it is Liberty and no other symbol, such as Uncle Sam, which best
29. Virginie Locussol, "U.S. Prison Abuse Painted
America. But her torch now becomes a lethal electric current. Effec
onWall," June 2, 2004, available online at represents
Novinite.com/view_news.php?id=35348. tively conflating Liberty and the executioner into a single image, the figures
96 SUMMER 2005
become doppelgangers; the mask of degradation becomes the face of America,
the hooded man its innocent victim. Commenting on the power of the hooded
man and the leashed man Mark Danner calls such the
images, representations
replaces Liberty with race hatred, intolerance, and greed while Liberty runs for
her life.
Another protest image, produced by the L.A. graphic design group Forkscrew
was in the and streets of New York and Los
Graphics, placed subways City Angeles
97 art journal
Richard Serra. Stop Bush, 2004. Offset
printing on paper. Installation view.
Courtesy of Gagosian Gallery, New York.
Photograph ? 2004 Robert Polidori.
98 SUMMER 2005
Postmade decisions not to publish many of themore disturbing photographs,
Klaus Theweleit, author of Male Fantasies, in an interview with the S?ddeutsche Zeitung,
such restraint: "I have these kinds of scenes in my head, from
argued against
concentration camps, from splatter, snuff, and porn films. We could repress these
99 art journal
An Iraqi family in downtown Baghdad
reacts to images of tortured prisoners
broadcast on the Arabic channel AI
Jazeera. Photograph: Sungsu Cho/Polaris.
authority by shirking responsibility and blaming a few "bad apples." And they
succeeded, at least in the United States, another election. How, then,
by winning
do of torture their own When is the power of an
photographs produce undoing?
turned itself, it into a that opposes the very
image against transforming picture
thing the photograph means to uphold? We can affirm that different meanings
are to the arenas in which those circulate, and that
produced according images
the association of photographs and artworks with the status of the real is critical
Dora Apel is associate professor andW. Hawkins Ferry Chair inModern and Contemporary Art at
43. Christopher Hitchens, "AMoral Chernobyl: State University, Detroit. Her books include Memory Effects: The Holocaust and the Art of Secondary
Wayne
Prepare for theWorst of Abu Ghraib," Slate, June Witnessing and Imagery of Lynching: Black Men, White Women, and theMob.
14, 2004, available online at slate.msn.com/id/
2102373.