Sie sind auf Seite 1von 3

What is an ethical dilemma? The word wishes.

While the former scenario is


‘ethical dilemma’ is self–explanatory. It contrary to a patient’s personal
indicates confusion related to the
autonomy and questions a doctor’s
ethics of a person. Ethical dilemma is a
complex situation which often rights in a patient’s life, the latter
originates from conflict between the contradicts the oath of non-
moral imperatives of two persons. In maleficence that is a basis of
some cases, this confusion may arise medical practice. Both the above are
within a single person when his/her moral ethical violations and the pressure of
principles cannot determine the right
which violation to select can give
course of action. It may also occur
between people and often occurs due rise to ethical dilemma for the
to conflicts in ideologies. An ethical medical staff.
dilemma can happen anywhere and  A conflict between a person’s
anytime but, it’s most oft repeated moral values and perceived role may
occurrence is seen in workplaces. This
also lead to ethical dilemma. For
is because of the diversity of the people
there. People in a workplace come from instance, if a physician, who is
various cultural and moral back grounds absolutely against the idea of
and so, the chances of conflict are higher. abortion, comes across a patient for
Workplaces usually have definite patterns whom pregnancy can pave way to
of action which may contrast with the sure death, an ethical dilemma for
ideologies of an employee or vice versa.
the medical practitioner is inevitable.
This may result in an internal conflict in
the employee resulting in confusion on  Ethical dilemma may, at times,
what should be done and what shouldn’t. arise due to unavoidable alternatives
This article illustrates ethical dilemma and also. For example, if an employee is
also deals with the ways to resolve it. asked to manipulate reports for the
Browse down to read more! benefit of the company then he has
 
two options – either follow the way
Moral dilemma Examples
shown by the company officials and
go ahead with the manipulation or
 Ethical dilemma may arise due to
act as a whistleblower to bring the
a conflict between the professional
malpractice to common notice. The
and personal values of a person. For
choice again would depend upon the
instance, if a physician attending an
financial well-doing of an employee
important family function is called to
and if the employee agrees to the
attend an emergency, there arises a
manipulation due to lack of any
dilemma. If the physician leaves for
other alternative, ethical dilemma is
the hospital, his duty to the family is
a certainty.
breached but if he doesn’t then his
duty as a doctor is jeopardized. 
 
 The conflict between two How To Resolve Ethical Dilemma
professional values may also give  
rise to an ethical dilemma. For Think About The Consequences
instance, a patient showing When faced with an ethical dilemma
reluctance towards treatment can be where you just can't be sure of what is
right and what is wrong, slow down and
dealt with in two ways. He can either
analyze the consequences of all the
be coerced to accept the treatment possible decisions that you can take and
against his/her or left to his/her
find out answer for the below questions    Hence, to advance our lecture, I will
for both the long and short run. present to you the 3 levels of moral
dilemmas, and these are:
 Who all will be benefitted?
1. Personal Dilemma: a common
 Who all will be hurt? dilemma experienced by an
 What all are the benefits? individual. In this level, the moral
 What all are the harms? problem is unique and distinctive to
the moral agent who is confronted by
After listing the answers to the above the moral situation, such that, it
questions, give due weightage to both the entails a private and peculiar solution
negatives and the positives. from the individual. 
 
2. Organizational Dilemma:This
Consider The Course Of Action
dilemma exists within an
After considering the consequences, try to
organization or a particular
consider the most beneficial or practical
sector.  It refers to the colliding
course of action. Find out which principles
interests of an individual and that of
are you ready to breach and which are the
the organization.
ones you’d never let go off and why. Plan
your actions in accordance to that. 3. Systemic Dilemma: It is a problem
  due to issues inherent in the
Make A Decision overall system such that, a change
In the end, do it. No matter how much to the structure, organization or
time you spend evading a problem, you policies in that system could alleviate
cannot stay away from taking a decision. the systemic problem.
With the previous steps guiding you
towards a sane decision, your chances of Thus, it remains at the personal level if
faltering are significantly reduced. the dilemma refers to attending a
Consider the above mentioned things and basketball try out or obeying your father.
make a decision with minimum harm to
your moral principles. But, the moral problem may be
  organizational in level if attending or not
Ethical dilemma or moral dilemma is an attending the basketball game would
unpleasant situation which almost all of us affect the team's performance and likely
experience at different times in life. Above to loose a good standing in the overall
article seeks to help you overcome the ranking. Likewise, disobedience in the
helplessness and mental pressure that family is a gross moral violation that may
comes with such a situation. severely affect the relationships of the
members in the family...in such, the act
of disobedience may lead to disputes and
   In real life, we need to understand that dissents of opinions among family
not all moral problems could be solved members.
within the personal level. Though
The systemic dilemma is a "bloated"
obviously, most moral dilemmas are "felt"
moral problem which did not happen
and resolved in such level.
overnight. Remember that it aims
   However, there are some moral to change a system, hence, the moral
dilemmas which solutions needed a dilemma is obviously a problem that
consensus of the members of an relates to practices and traditions that had
organization or at least, some kind of prevailed over a period of time. Example
"bargaining" or "lobbying" that would of this level are: corruption, lack of
change an existing complex structure.  political will, obsolete policies, and others.
So the next time you encounter a moral number of complications when attempting
problem, it is necessary that you establish to make a decision.
the level of the dilemma before you find
yourself severely affected when the 4. World-imposed moral dilemmas
supposed solution is never within your
capacity as an individual moral agent. A world-imposed dilemma is a situation
where events that we can’t control have
6 TYPES OF MORAL DILEMMAS
created an unavoidable moral conflict.
There are several categories of moral
An individual must resolve a moral
dilemmas within philosophical thought.
dilemma, even though the cause of it is
They can seem complex, but learning the
beyond his/her control. For example, this
basics of them can help identify them and
could be in times of war or a financial
mould a solution for them:
crash.
1. Epistemic moral dilemmas
5. Obligation moral dilemmas
‘Epistemic’ means to do with the
Obligation dilemmas are situations where
knowledge of something. This is what this
we feel we are obliged to opt for more
dilemma is about.
than one choice. We feel we are obliged to
The situation involves two moral choices carry out an action from a moral or legal
that conflict, but the individual has no standpoint.
idea which choice is the most morally
If there were just one option that is
acceptable. They don’t know which is the
obligatory, then the choice would be easy.
most ethically viable. They need more
However, if an individual feels obliged to
information and knowledge surrounding
opt for several of the choices in front of
the two options before making
them but can only choose one, which one
an informed decision.
should they choose?
2. Ontological moral dilemmas
6. Prohibition moral dilemmas
‘Ontological’ means the nature of
Prohibition dilemmas are the opposite of
something or the relation between things.
obligation dilemmas. The choices that are
The options in this dilemma are equal in
offered to us are all, on some
their moral consequences.
level, morally reprehensible.
This means that neither of
They can all be considered as wrong, but
them supersedes the other. They are
we must choose one. They could be
fundamentally on the same ethical level.
illegal, or just plain immoral. An individual
Therefore, the individual cannot choose
must choose between what would
between the two.
normally be considered as prohibited.
3. Self-imposed moral dilemmas

A self-imposed dilemma is a situation that


has been caused by the individual’s
mistakes or misconduct. The moral
dilemma is self-inflicted. This can cause a

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen