0 Bewertungen0% fanden dieses Dokument nützlich (0 Abstimmungen)
44 Ansichten3 Seiten
The document discusses arguments for and against recognizing Dr. Jose Rizal as the Philippine National Hero. It summarizes views from historians Renato Constantino and Teodoro Agoncillo.
Constantino argues that Rizal should not be the hero because he did not come from the masses and was privileged, making him unable to fully understand the struggles of Filipinos under Spanish rule. Agoncillo resolved the debate by recognizing Rizal's ideals of independence and democracy while still acknowledging other heroes' roles in the revolution.
The document discusses arguments for and against recognizing Dr. Jose Rizal as the Philippine National Hero. It summarizes views from historians Renato Constantino and Teodoro Agoncillo.
Constantino argues that Rizal should not be the hero because he did not come from the masses and was privileged, making him unable to fully understand the struggles of Filipinos under Spanish rule. Agoncillo resolved the debate by recognizing Rizal's ideals of independence and democracy while still acknowledging other heroes' roles in the revolution.
The document discusses arguments for and against recognizing Dr. Jose Rizal as the Philippine National Hero. It summarizes views from historians Renato Constantino and Teodoro Agoncillo.
Constantino argues that Rizal should not be the hero because he did not come from the masses and was privileged, making him unable to fully understand the struggles of Filipinos under Spanish rule. Agoncillo resolved the debate by recognizing Rizal's ideals of independence and democracy while still acknowledging other heroes' roles in the revolution.
Pag-isipan at sagutin ang mga sumusunod na katanungan:
1. Ilarawan ang mahigpit na ugnayan ng "nasyonalismo" at "kabayanihan".
Ano ang kahulugan ng nasyonalismo? Ano ang kahulugan ng salitang bayani/kabayanihan? Basahin: https://www.manilatimes.net/2018/01/20/opinion/analysis/defining- surveying-heroism/375390/
2. Magbanggit ng hindi bababa sa tatlong (3) argumentong inilatag ni
Renato Constantino sa kanyang artikulo na nagbibigay dahilan kung bakit "hindi dapat" itanghal na pambansang bayani ng Pilipinas si Dr. Jose Rizal. Ibigay ang iyong sariling reaksyon sa bawat argumentong mababanggit.
The article written by Renato Constantino entitled “Veneration
without Understanding” aims to help Filipinos awoke from the “blinded” thinking that Dr. Jose Rizal, among other Filipino heroes, ultimately deserves to be the National hero of the Philippines. Constantino supports this claim by mentioning some important points that provide enlightenment in relation with historical events and facts. Constantino mentioned in his article that Rizal cannot and should not be recognized as the Philippine National hero simply because he did not come from the masses himself. Rizal grew up during the Spanish colonization with more opportunities and privileges that other Filipinos. In fact, he can afford to have good quality education in private universities such as Ateneo Municipal de Manila and University of Santo Tomas and travel easily to other countries whenever he wants. This privileges, according to Constantino, made him distant and uncomprehending to the cries and struggle of his fellow country men under the Spanish rulers at that time. This is also the reason why he publicly repudiated the Revolution and condemned the mass movement along with its leaders through one of his letters. Constantino stated that Rizal did not fully understand what the Filipinos are really experiencing at that time and was unable to perceive that the Philippines really needed was freedom from the hands of the Spanish invaders. In my opinion, I agree with Constantino that Rizal’s upbringing truly had an impact in the way that he sympathize with the Filipino people during that time. Because of his social status, he wasn’t able to see the whole picture which led him to believe that it is enough for the Filipinos to have self recognition as a race, unity and respect from the Spaniards even if it is under the Spanish rulers which of course is definitely not true. Furthermore, Rizal having privileges in his life is not his fault, that’s why he must not be criticized for it. He simply did not have the opportunity to get to know his country well enough and share with its struggles and oppression. I also understand the hesitation of Rizal to support the Revolution simply because he doesn’t think that the nation is ready and in full capability to defend herself against the ruthless foreigners. I, myself, don’t fully support violence before either because I don’t want to be remembered as the one who led people towards their death. But now that I was able to clearly see what truly happens to our fellow countrymen especially under the hands of abusive and selfish rulers, I don’t think that I can just standby and not take risks towards the possibility of change. Sometimes, all we really need is to take a leap of faith in our self and in others as well. Constantino also stated that the preeminence of Rizal among the other national heroes is because he is an American-sponsored hero. This relates to him being a part of the Illustrado class, which is composed of Filipinos who had the opportunity to study abroad. Constantino believes that the Americans supported the recognition of Rizal to be the National hero with hidden motives. One of these motives is that when the Filipinos see that the Americans are not as bad as the Spaniards and is willing to help in establishing the monument and legacy of Rizal, maybe they will accept and welcome the American colonization better than they had with Spain. In addition, Rizal, to the Americans’ benefit, will also become a symbol of rejection to any resistance that may arise again which will discourage many if not all of the aspiring revolutionaries at that time. 3. Magbanggit ng hindi bababa sa tatlong (3) argumentong inilatag ni Armando Malay sa kanyang artikulo na nagbibigay dahilan kung bakit "karapat-dapat" itanghal na pambansang bayani ng Pilipinas si Dr. Jose Rizal. Ibigay ang iyong sariling reaksyon sa bawat argumentong mababanggit.
4. Paano niresolba ng historyador na si Teodoro Agoncillo ang mahigpit na
"suliranin ng pambansang bayani"? Ibuod ang kanyang naging paliwanag tungkol dito.