Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
The effect of cement paste volume and w/c ratio on shrinkage strain,
water absorption and compressive strength of high performance
concrete
Wojciech Piasta ⇑, Bartlomiej Zarzycki
Faculty of Civil Engineering and Architecture, Kielce University of Technology, Tysiaclecia PP 7, 25-314 Kielce, Poland
h i g h l i g h t s
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Shrinkage strain, compressive strength and water absorption of high performance concrete (HPC) are
Received 26 October 2016 estimated to high accuracy with linear equations using the w/c ratio and paste volume as variables. A
Received in revised form 8 February 2017 paste volume reduction, thus an increase in coarse aggregate fraction, improves the HPC properties.
Accepted 9 February 2017
These changes most likely result from: 1) adsorption of water on a greater surface of aggregate, leading
Available online 6 March 2017
to bulk paste desiccation and densifying and reduction in actual w/c ratio and width of aggregate-cement
paste interfacial transition zone; 2) beneficial influence of larger volume of coarse aggregates produced
Keywords:
from rocks of high strength and low water absorption.
High-performance concrete
Cement paste volume
Ó 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
w/c ratio
Water absorption
Compressive strength
Shrinkage strain
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2017.02.033
0950-0618/Ó 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
396 W. Piasta, B. Zarzycki / Construction and Building Materials 140 (2017) 395–402
Yet the scope of the related research was either limited or mostly practice. Paste volumes of 220, 320 and 420 dm3/m3 were used
concerned with ordinary concretes [4,5]. Some authors [6,7] so that HPCs intended for mass structures, standard HPCs and
observed that an increase in the cement paste volume may reduce self-compacting HPCs could be included. Constant amounts of sand
the compressive strength of concrete and increase its water and coarse aggregate were applied to mixes with a given paste vol-
absorption. However, these authors did not perform any analysis ume. The coarse and fine aggregate mix composition was designed
or indicate the causes of the changes. This issue has been hardly to maintain approximately the same volume of sand in each mix,
ever addressed with respect to high performance concrete [8]. regardless of the w/c ratio. This procedure allowed using only
Other researchers [9] claimed that compressive strength of two variables: paste volume and coarse aggregate content.
100 MPa could be attained only with the high volume of paste
and the use of silica fume. 2.2. Materials
In the context of concrete strength variations due to varied
paste volume, the issue of aggregate-cement paste bond seems All mixes were produced from the same materials. The results
interesting. A decrease in the paste volume is accompanied by an obtained from the author’s previous research [12,13] were used
increase in the volume and surface area of aggregate particles in to establish that blast furnace slag (BFS) cement and basalt aggre-
contact with the paste. The surface area interfacial transition zone gate would be an optimal option for the HPCs. The cement con-
(ITZ) is simultaneously increased. The ITZ is developed as a result tained 55% of granulated ground blast furnace slag. The
of the formation of a thin water film adjacent to aggregate particles properties and chemical composition of the cement are detailed
in the fresh paste. Adhesion of the paste to aggregates takes place in Table 1. Chemical composition of the cement clinker and slag
through this narrow (20–50 lm) layer of weaker paste around and the phase composition of the clinker are presented in
aggregate grains, with different microstructure and porosity. This Tables 2 and 3. Suitable workability and consistency of the mixes
region is important enough to consider the concrete microstruc- were provided by the new generation polycarboxylate ether super-
ture as a composite made of three constituents: cement paste, plasticizer. High quality basalt coarse aggregate used in the con-
ITZ and aggregate [10]. crete was derived from the deposits in the Lower Silesia, Poland.
The cement paste volume should be considered as a factor in Basalt as the volcanic extrusive rock containing no quartz or only
HPC shrinkage and durability [11]. Although shrinkage strains in minor quantities of quartz is recommended as alkali-nonreactive
HPC are similar to those of ordinary concretes, the process is differ- aggregate. Its properties are summarized in Table 4. Pre-washed
ent, in particular at low w/c ratios and high cement contents. natural quartz sand was used as fine aggregate. Fine and coarse
Unlike in ordinary concretes, in HPCs, autogenous shrinkage is pre- aggregate sieve analysis results are provided in Table 5, along with
dominant, especially at the start of hardening. HPCs are subject to aggregate mix compositions designed for concretes containing
this shrinkage type due to internal desiccation. Heat generation, three different volumes of cement paste. Prior to the production
particularly violent at the beginning of hydration, accelerates paste of the mixes, the aggregate was thoroughly dried.
hardening and self-desiccation-related autogenous shrinkage All the mixes were produced from the materials named above.
developing in proportion to hydration levels. High cement contents Concrete mix compositions are included in Table 6.
in HPC can be avoided, although not without difficulty, but it is The total external surface of the coarse aggregate was deter-
impossible to avoid using very low w/c ratios. Therefore, the influ- mined from the formula proposed by Jamrozy [14] for specific sur-
ence of paste volume on HPC properties is a very topical issue. face area of aggregate fraction:
5; 6 2
2. Materials and methods S¼ ½m =kg ð1Þ
d
2.1. Aim and scope of the experiment
d1 þ d2
d¼ ½mm ð2Þ
The aim of this study was to evaluate the influence of cement 2
paste volume and w/c ratio on long-term shrinkage strains, mass S – specific surface area of aggregate fraction [m2/kg]
absorption and compressive strength of HPCs at 28 days of curing. d1 – upper sieve opening size [mm],
An attempt was made to explain the causes and the mechanism of d2 – lower sieve opening size [mm].
the changes induced by varied volumes of cement paste.
To be able to perform a comprehensive assessment of the vari- The formula above is for the aggregate with a density of 2.65 kg/
ation in the properties, a clear plan of experiment was designed dm3 – in the case of basalt aggregate with a density of 3.0 kg/dm3,
and the results were subjected to statistical analysis. The w/c ratio the values calculated for the specific surface area had to be multi-
ranged from 0.25 to 0.35 to cover the entire w/c range applied in plied by quotient 2.65/3.00.
Table 1
Properties of cement.
Specific surface Initial setting Final setting 2-Days 28-Days Specific Water Content of Content of Content of
area [cm2/g] time [min] time [min] compressive compressive density demand sulphates SO2 chlorides Cl alkali [%]
strength [MPa] strength [MPa] [g/cm3] [%] [%] [%]
4650 230 300 14.2 50.3 2.98 30.9 2.56 0.026 0.83
Table 2
Chemical composition of cement clinker and slag [as % by weight].
Insoluble particles SiO2 Al2O3 Fe2O3 CaO MgO SO3 Na2O K2O Cl-
Clinker 0.15 21.8 5.1 2.9 65.9 1.4 0.5 0.1 0.8 0.02
Slag 0.1 38.1 7.7 1.5 43.7 6.2 0.06 0.5 0.6 0.08
W. Piasta, B. Zarzycki / Construction and Building Materials 140 (2017) 395–402 397
Table 4
Properties of basalt rock.
Compressive Tensile strength Modulus of Bulk density Specific density Total Water absorption by Water absorption by
strength [MPa] [MPa] elasticity [GPa] [g/cm3] [g/cm3] porosity [%] weight [%] volume [%]
215.8 12.5 100.8 3.0 3.06 1.96 0.5 1.5
Table 5
Sieve analysis of fine and coarse aggregates and aggregate mix compositions.
Sieve Sand Basalt coarse Fine and coarse aggregate for Vp = 220 Fine and coarse aggregate for Vp = 320 Fine and coarse aggregate for Vp = 420
[mm] aggregate dm3/m3 dm3/m3 dm3/m3
31.5 100 100 100 100 100
16 100 98 99 99 99
8 100 50 64 67 70
4 100 13 37 43 48
2 98 0 27 33 39
1 78 0 22 27 31
0.5 46 0 13 16 18
0.25 12 0 3 4 5
0.125 2 0 1 1 1
Table 6
Compositions of concrete mixes.
w/c Cement paste volume [dm3/m3] Water [kg/m3] Cement [kg/m3] Sand [kg/m3] Coarse aggregate [kg/m3] Superplasticizer [kg/m3]
0.25 220 93.93 375.70 662.24 1590.29 6.32
0.25 320 136.62 546.48 663.79 1288.54 7.11
0.25 420 179.31 717.25 661.08 991.61 7.58
0.30 220 103.84 346.15 662.24 1590.29 3.54
0.30 320 151.05 503.48 663.79 1288.54 5.60
0.30 420 198.25 660.82 661.08 991.61 5.90
0.35 220 112.32 320.90 662.24 1590.29 2.96
0.35 320 163.37 466.76 663.79 1288.54 4.27
0.35 420 214.42 612.63 661.08 991.61 5.51
Table 7
Coarse aggregate fraction specific surface area. Table 8
Sieve Content of given fractions Specific surface Fraction surface Coarse aggregate total surface area.
of coarse aggregate [%] area [m2/kg] area [m2/kg] Cement paste Specific Coarse Total coarse
16/31.5 2 0.206 0.0041 volume Vp surface area aggregate aggregate surface
8/16 48 0.412 0.1979 [dm3/m3] [m2/kg] content [kg] area [m2]
4/8 37 0.824 0.3050 220 0.7214 1590.20 1147
2/4 13 1.649 0.2144 320 0.7214 1288.54 930
R = 100% Surface area: 0.7214 420 0.7214 991.61 715
398 W. Piasta, B. Zarzycki / Construction and Building Materials 140 (2017) 395–402
500
300
200
100
Vp=220 dm3/m3 Vp=320 dm3/m3 Vp=420 dm3/m3
0
1 8 15 22 29 36 43 50 57 64 71 78 85 92 99 106 113 120
time [days]
Fig. 1. Shrinkage strains up to 120 days for concretes with 0.25 w/c ratio.
500
shrinkage strain [*10-6]
400
300
200
100
Vp=220 dm3/m3 Vp=320 dm3/m3 Vp=420 dm3/m3
0
1 8 15 22 29 36 43 50 57 64 71 78 85 92 99 106 113 120
time [days]
Fig. 2. Shrinkage strains up to 120 days for concretes with 0.30 w/c ratio.
500
shrinkage strain [*10-6]
400
300
200
100
Vp=220 dm3/m3 Vp=320 dm3/m3 Vp=420 dm3/m3
0
1 8 15 22 29 36 43 50 57 64 71 78 85 92 99 106 113 120
time [days]
Fig. 3. Shrinkage strains up to 120 days for concretes with 0.35 w/c ratio.
compressive strength [MPa]
130
the concretes with the same w/c ratio, the strains varied with the
120 cement paste volume. Lower shrinkage for each w/c ratio was
R² = 0.9931 observed with lower paste content. The shrinkage strain was from
110 228 * 106 for the paste volume of 220 dm3/m3 and w/c = 0.25 to
R² = 0.9956 533 * 106 for the paste volume of 420 dm3/m3 and w/c = 0.35.
100
Fig. 4 illustrates the test results for HPC compressive strength,
90 R² = 0.9998 depending on the cement paste volume and three different w/c
w/c=0.25 w/c=0.30 w/c=0.35 ratios. The highest value of compressive strength, 124.7 MPa, was
80 attained by the concrete with w/c = 0.25 and paste volume of
200 250 300 350 400 450
220 dm3/m3. The lowest compressive strength, 84.3 MPa, was
cement paste volume [dm3/m3]
recorded for the concrete with the paste volume of 420 dm3/m3
Fig. 4. Dependence of compressive strength on the cement paste volume and w/c and w/c = 0.35.
ratio. Fig. 5 shows the relationship between water absorption and
paste volume. The water absorption parameter, dependent on both
Results were presented as average values of compressive strength the w/c ratio and the paste volume, was from 1.95% (w/c = 0.25
for each concrete. and Vp = 220 dm3/m3) to 4.98% by weight (for w/c = 0.35 and
Vp = 420 dm3/m3).
3. Test results Table 9 shows the HPC results from the shrinkage strain test at
7 and 60 days and compressive strength and absorption tests at
Figs. 1–3 show HPC shrinkage strains measured up to 120 days 28 days of curing. These results were subjected to statistical
of curing for w/c ratios of 0.25, 0.30 and 0.35, respectively. Among analysis.
W. Piasta, B. Zarzycki / Construction and Building Materials 140 (2017) 395–402 399
5.2
R² = 0.9977
3.2
2.7
2.2
w/c=0.25 w/c=0.30 w/c=0.35
1.7
200 250 300 350 400 450
cement paste volume [dm3/m3]
Table 9
Test results for shrinkage strain at 7 and 60 days, compressive strength and water absorption at 28 days of curing.
w/c Cement paste volume [dm3/m3] Compressive strength [MPa] Water absorption by weight [%] Shrinkage strain [*106]
at 7 days at 60 days
0.25 220 124.7 1.95 125 219
0.25 320 116.4 2.98 164 308
0.25 420 110.2 3.79 210 406
0.30 220 113.3 2.30 140 263
0.30 320 103.6 3.46 182 370
0.30 420 95.9 4.42 240 473
0.35 220 98.4 2.60 167 332
0.35 320 91.5 3.89 212 418
0.35 420 84.3 4.98 260 515
4. Analysis and discussion of test results in mortars all with the same w/c ratio decreases the porosity of
cement mortar.
4.1. Mechanism of the effect of paste volume changes on the properties In addition, the adsorption of water on the surface of a large
of concrete quantity of aggregate in the HPC mix, reduces the actual (effective)
w/c ratio during desiccation thus decreasing the degree of cement
While explaining significant changes in concrete paste volume- hydration. Progressing cement hydration is the major factor in
dependent properties, it is vital to include the issues concerning autogenous shrinkage of cement paste [11].
the water movement in the fresh concrete mix. Also the phe- In summary, the change in the properties of HPCs induced by
nomenon of water being adsorbed to the surface of aggregates the changes in paste volume is within the ‘‘hidden meaning” of
and their influence on the actual w/c ratio should be considered. actual (effective) w/c ratio, first indicated by Aitcin and Bentz [3]
The paste volume reduction in a concrete mix results in the lower with reference to the spacing between cement particles in the
total water content, increased aggregate volume and a propor- paste.
tional increase in external surface area of the aggregate adjacent
to the paste (Figs. 6, 7). Consequently, the surface area of the water 4.2. Shrinkage strain
film separated from the fresh paste and adsorbed onto the aggre-
gate increases. The total surface area of the aggregate-cement Regression analysis was used to evaluate the relationship
paste interfacial transition zone (ITZ) tends to become larger in between shrinkage, paste volume and w/c for concretes cured for
the hardened concrete. For example, for w/c = 0.25 and paste vol- 7 and 60 days. Figs. 8 and 9 include equations that can be used
ume Vp = 420 dm3/m3, the total water content is 179.3 kg and to estimate the dependence of shrinkage in high performance con-
the total surface area of aggregate is 715 m2 (Figs. 6a and 7a), cretes cured for 7 and 60 days on two variables – the paste volume
whereas for the paste volume of 220 dm3/m3, the content of water and the w/c ratio – and planes that visualize estimated dependen-
is 93.9 kg, and the total surface area of the coarse aggregate is 1 cies. Coefficients of determination, R2 = 0.993 and R2 = 0.997,
147 m2 (Figs. 6b and 7b). respectively, indicate that the regression model fits the data very
The formation of a water film over large surface area of aggre- well.
gate will substantially decrease the water content in the bulk paste Shrinkage strain of concrete is a sum of autogenous and drying
and as a result decrease its actual (effective) w/c ratio. Also, the shrinkage as concrete shrinkage is a result of desiccation of the
porosity of the bulk paste and transition zone paste is reduced paste due to cement hydration and drying in air, respectively.
thereby leading to improved tightness. This suggests denser bulk Due to cement hydration, self-desiccation follows and autogenous
and ITZ paste and narrower ITZ. Water reduction in the bulk paste shrinkage occurs and continues until hydration ceases [19]. This
through adsorption will probably also reduce the width of the ITZ, shrinkage type is particularly important at low w/c ratios and high
may affect the adhesion of the paste to aggregate particles and can cement contents, thus first of all in HPCs. The process of self-
be partly responsible for the improvement of concrete perfor- desiccation indicates that free autogenous shrinkage is propor-
mance. Scrivener et al. [18] noted that the increase in sand content tional to the degree of cement hydration [20,21]. This fact together
400 W. Piasta, B. Zarzycki / Construction and Building Materials 140 (2017) 395–402
Fig. 6. Concept sketch of the cross-sections of concrete mixes (w/c = 0.25) containing different volumes of cement paste: a) 220 dm3/m3; b) 420 dm3/m3 (dimensions of the
objects in the figure are not real). In mix (a) with 93.9 kg of water, the thin water film (light blue) adsorbed from a small volume of paste (grey) covers a large external surface
of well packed grains of aggregate (light brown) and sand (black dots) (very thin films on sand particles are not marked; amount of sand in both mixes (and the number of
dots in both figures) is the same, about 662 kg/m3 (item 2.1)). In mix (b) with 179.3 kg of water, the water film adsorbed from a large volume of paste covers a small surface
area of well dispersed grains of aggregate and sand. (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of this article.)
Fig. 7. Cross-sections of concrete specimens with different cement paste volumes: a) 220 dm3/m3, b) 420 dm3/m3.
Fig. 8. Relationship between shrinkage strain, cement paste volume and w/c ratio Fig. 9. Relationship between shrinkage strain, cement paste volume and w/c ratio
at 7 days of curing. at 60 days of curing.
W. Piasta, B. Zarzycki / Construction and Building Materials 140 (2017) 395–402 401
with increasing capillary porosity resulting from increased w/c capillary porosity of the hardened paste and affects the width
ratio explains the observed proportional gain in shrinkage strains and microstructure of the aggregate-paste ITZ [22,23]. The lower
during drying, as the water loss from the surface of concrete is the w/c, the less water separates from the fresh paste forming a
responsible for the change in concrete volume. thinner film on the aggregate grains, thereby increasing the inter-
The replacement of coarse aggregate, which is not subject to facial paste strength and, consequently, improving the properties
shrinkage, with cement paste suggests a proportional increase in of the concrete.
shrinkage across the entire concrete specimen. In addition, lower
w/c and hydration degree due to water adsorption (the cement 4.4. Water absorption
content is not increased) make cement particles lie very close to
each other. This proximity of the particles [3] may result in more The graph in Fig. 11 is a visualised estimation of the dependence
rigid paste and lower total shrinkage. The influence of paste vol- of concrete water absorption on the cement paste volume and w/c.
ume is strong enough to produce higher shrinkage in concrete with A high value of the coefficient of determination, R2 = 0.988, allows
the lowest w/c ratio and the highest paste volume (w/c = 0.25; predicting absorption levels to high accuracy with the estimated
Vp = 420 dm3/m3) than in the concrete with the highest w/c but regression equation.
the lowest paste volume (w/c = 0.35; Vp = 220 dm3/m3). Thus, the Differences in the values of absorption, from 1.95% to 4.98% by
lowering of w/c ratio at the increase in paste volume may not lead weight, depending on the cement paste volume and w/c ratio
to shrinkage reduction. imply an evident influence of both variables. The principal factors
in these significant and proportional changes in absorption values
include the percent content ratio of the volume of basalt aggregate
4.3. Compressive strength
with relatively low absorption (0.4% by weight) to hardened paste
with high absorption [6] and capillary pore volumes and diame-
The results were used in the linear regression model to estimate
ters, which increase with increasing w/c ratio.
the dependence of compressive strength on the paste volume and
Induced by increasing paste volume, the absorption gain
w/c ratio. The coefficient of determination is R2 = 0.997, which
increases with the w/c ratio. This contributes to higher inclination
indicates that the plane fits the data very well (Fig. 10). Compres-
angle of the lines (see Fig. 5) relative to the paste volume axis.
sive strength of HPC is significantly related not only to the w/c ratio
At w/c = 0.25, absorption gain is 0.9 percentage point per
but also to the paste volume.
100 dm3/m3 paste volume, whereas at w/c = 0.35, the gain
The tests results indicate that the strengths of concretes with
increases up to 1.2 percentage points. It can be suggested that
w/c from 0.25 to 0.35 increase with decreasing paste volume
the increased absorption gain takes place not only because of
(Figs. 4, 10). Separation of the water film from the fresh paste as
increasing potential relative pore volume to be filled with water
a result of its adsorption on the aggregate surface (item 4.1.
but also because of increasing depth to which external water pen-
Fig. 6) is supposed to dry the paste, lowering its actual w/c ratio
etrates the concrete. Note that at decreasing w/c ratios, the move-
and probably narrowing the ITZ. Consequently, the strength of
ment of water becomes limited owing to reduced diameter of
the bulk paste and the paste around the aggregate grains may
continuous capillary pores and increased resistance to this move-
increase, thus increasing the strength of the cement paste-
ment. High performance concretes having low w/c ratios usually
aggregate bond and the concrete. With good aggregate-paste adhe-
show low absorption ability not only because they are less porous,
sion assumed for w/c 0.35 [19], higher strength of the concretes
but also because their capillary and pore networks are somewhat
may result from replacing the weaker paste by coarse aggregate
disconnected, which restrains the water penetration depth. In
derived from higher strength rocks. This would partly explain the
addition, decreasing paste volume leads to increased content of
linear dependence of concrete strength on the varied paste volume.
water adsorbed on the larger surface area of aggregate, which
A decrease in w/c from 0.35 to 0.25 increases the strength by
results in the reduction in the actual w/c ratio and, thereby, in
nearly 26 MPa for all paste volumes despite the reduction in the
absorption values.
degree of cement hydration. The lower w/c ratio decreases
Fig. 10. Relationship between compressive strength, cement paste volume and w/c Fig. 11. Relationship between water absorption, cement paste volume and w/c
ratio. ratio.
402 W. Piasta, B. Zarzycki / Construction and Building Materials 140 (2017) 395–402