From the Origin of Life to Evolutionary School of Thought
ACTIVITY: Complete the table below to summarize the history of the theory of evolution from pre-1800s to present. The timeline is already provided; write only one key concept involved on each box. You may utilize other reference for this activity.
Pre-1800s Evolutionary thought of:
Andreas Vesalius on comparative anatomy Andreas Vesalius (1514-1564) was a physician and anatomist who lived during the 16th century AD, a time when the standard authority on anatomy was the work of Galen, an ancient Greek physician. Vesalius was known for correcting numerous fallacies on Galen’s anatomical knowledge through repeated and comparative dissections of the human body. For instance, he found that the lower jaw of humans was only one piece of bone, not two; that there were no holes in the septum of the heart; that the human breastbone has three segments, not seven, all as opposed to Galen’s claims. The mistakes, as Vesalius noticed, was because many of Galen's observations were not even based on actual humans as he had never dissected one before, and instead were based on animals such as apes, monkeys, and oxen. Vesalius' discovery of the important differences between species marked the start of a new phase in the study of human anatomy and had helped pilot the science of comparative anatomy, in which researchers studied animals to find their similarities and differences. Nicholas Steno on Paleontology The birth of paleontology was considered to be on the day in 1666 when Nicholas Steno (1638-1686) noticed a strong resemblance between shark teeth and triangular stony objects found within rock formations called “tongue stones”. He concluded that tongue stones were once shark teeth in the mouth of sharks that were buried in mud or sand which later became dry land, which led him to the question of how solid objects could come to be found inside another solid object. He proposed that all rocks and minerals were originally fluid that had been formed by successive deposition of horizontal layers, with new layers forming on top of older ones. Steno also realized that as the rocks formed, they could trap animal remains, converting them into fossils and preserving them deep within their layers. This is now referred to as Steno’s Law of Superposition, his most famous contribution to geology. Therefore, closely examining the earth’s strata and fossils could provide a chronological history of geological events. Carolus Linnaeus on nomenclature and classification After making botanical expeditions, Carolus Linnaeus (1707-1778) became convinced that he could organize all of life into a single artificial system, one that would be his first step towards comprehending God’s design in nature, and he started grouping species into a hierarchy of increasingly general categories. Linnaeus was the first to frame principles for defining natural genera and species of organisms and develop a uniform system for classifying and naming them, known as binomial nomenclature. It consists of the two Latin names given to an organism, the first being the name of the genus to which the organism belongs, that is further divided into species which makes up the second name. Period: 1800s-1900 Thomas Maltus on human population 1798, Thomas Malthus (1776-1834) wrote the book “An Essay on the Principle of Population”, which explained his Theory of Human Population Growth. His calculations and theories state that the human population would increase geometrically by factors of four, eight, or sixteen, while the food supply and natural resources would only increase arithmetically, which means that food production will not be able to keep up with growth in the human population. This would result in disease, famine, war, and calamity if the population size was not kept under control. Georges Cuvier on Extinction Georges Cuvier (1769-1832) was the first person to propose extinction as fact. In his Essay on the Theory of the Earth in 1813, Cuvier proposed that now-extinct species had been wiped out by periodic catastrophic flooding events. He arrived at this conclusion after studying different fossils from elephants and other mammals and finding out that they did not belong to any species alive today. The fossil evidence led him to propose that periodically, the Earth went through sudden changes, each of which could wipe out a number of species. Jean Baptiste Lamarck on evolution Jean-Baptiste Lamarck (1774 – 1829) is often credited with making the first large advance toward modern evolutionary theory for being the first to propose a mechanism by which the gradual change of species might take place. His theory of evolution had two important points: the Use and Disuse, stating that parts of the body often used to cope with the environment become larger and stronger, while unused ones deteriorate; and the Inheritance of Acquired Characteristics, in which Lamarck believed that traits changed or acquired over an individual's lifetime could be passed down to its offspring. Karl Ernst von Baer Known as the founding father of embryology, Karl Ernst von Baer (1792-1876) studied the embryonic development of animals and formulated what became known as Baer's Laws of Embryology. Von Baer proposed four rules to explain the observed pattern of embryonic development in different species, which are: 1) general characteristics of the group to which an embryo belongs develop before special characteristics; 2) general structural relations are likewise formed before the most specific appear; 3) the form of any given embryo does not converge upon other definite forms, but separates itself from them; and 4) the embryo of a higher animal form never resembles the adult of another animal form, such as one less evolved, but only its embryo. Charles Lyell on uniformitarianism Uniformitarianism is a theory based on the work of James Hutton and made popular by Charles Lyell (1797-1875) in the 19th century. This theory states that the forces and processes observable at earth’s surface acted in the same manner and with essentially the same intensity in the past as they do in the present and that such uniformity is sufficient to account for all geologic change. Charles Lyell influenced Darwin so deeply that Darwin envisioned evolution as a sort of biological uniformitarianism. In which he argued that evolution took place from one generation to the next before our very eyes but it worked too slowly for us to perceive. Uniformitarianism is also the first theory to predict deep time in western science, which is the idea that Earth history is so deep that a person can’t possibly conceive the amount of time that has passed on planet earth. This further proved that the earth could not be a few thousand years old, as believed by theologian scientists. Gregor Mendel on Genetics Johann Gregor Mendel (1822–1884), often called the “father of genetics,” discovered the fundamental laws of inheritance through his work on pea plants, forming the very basis for the field of genetics. He discovered that genes come in pairs and that traits were inherited as distinct units. Mendel also tracked the segregation of parental genes and their appearance in the offspring as dominant or recessive traits. Charles Darwin on Natural selection The mechanism that Charles Darwin (1809-1882) proposed for evolution is natural selection, the process by which organisms change over time as a result of changes in heritable physical or behavioral traits. Changes that allow an organism to better adapt to its environment will help it survive and reproduce, therefore becoming more common in a population over time. Charles Darwin’s works was influenced heavily by many people and pre-existing concepts from past theorists, such as Jean Baptiste Lamarck’s theory on evolution, Thomas Malthus’ Principle of Population, Georges Cuvier’s theory on extinction, and Charles Lyell’s uniformitarianism. Ernst Haeckel on Embryology Ernst Haeckel (1834-1919) was a strong proponent of Darwinism and applied evolutionary theories to embryology as he proposed the biogenetic law after reading Charles Darwin's theories in The Origin of Species. The law theorizes that the stages an animal embryo undergoes during development are a chronological replay of that species' past evolutionary forms, or simply that each embryo's developmental stage represents an adult form of an evolutionary ancestor. This evidence from embryology supported the theory that all of species on Earth share a common ancestor, and that by studying the stages of embryological development, one is, in effect, studying the history and diversification of life on Earth. However, although Haeckel cited Darwin as he proposed the biogenetic law, the two disagreed about embryology and evolution: Haeckel interpreted the process of evolution as progressive, following a specified path from lower to higher animals, contrary to Darwin’s belief that evolution wasn't progressive. Haeckel also endorsed Jean Baptiste Lamarck's theory of acquired characters that competed with Darwin's natural selection as the mechanism for evolution; in the end, Haeckel incorporated both theories into the biogenetic law. Wallace and Wegener on Biogeography Alfred Russel Wallace (1823-1913) had already accepted evolution when he began his travels in 1848 through the Amazon and Southeast Asia, and he sought to demonstrate that it took place by showing how geography affected the ranges of species. On his journeys, he was struck by discoveries like how rivers and mountain ranges marked the boundaries of many species' ranges. Wallace came to much the same conclusion as Darwin, that biogeography was simply a record of inheritance: as species colonized new habitats and their old ranges were divided by mountain ranges or other barriers, they took on the distributions they have today. Moving on to the 20th century, scientists have recognized that biogeography has been far more dynamic over the course of life's history. In 1912, Alfred Wegener (1880- 1930) was struck by the fact that identical fossil plants and animals had been discovered on opposite sides of the Atlantic. Since the ocean was too far for them to have traversed on their own, Wegener proposed that the continents had once been connected. He introduced the Theory of Continental Drift, though it was not widely accepted until the 1960s. The theory explained how continents were formerly joined together in one large landmass, Pangea, and slowly drifted apart due to the movement of the plates below Earth's surface. This revolutionized the way that everyone thought about species and their distribution around the globe. Thomas Morgan on modern genetics Thomas Hunt Morgan (1866-1945) played a key role in initiating the field of experimental genetics. He began to breed and conduct experiments with the common fruit fly, Drosophila melanogaster, by which he established the chromosome theory of heredity. Morgan confirmed Mendelian laws of inheritance by showing that genes are responsible for identifiable, hereditary traits, and demonstrated the hypothesis that genes are linked in a series and are located on chromosomes. 1920-1940 population genetics and modern evolutionary The modern synthesis was the early 20th-century synthesis synthesis that describes the fusion of Charles Darwin's theory of evolution and Gregor Mendel's ideas on heredity in a joint mathematical framework. The 19th century ideas of natural selection and Mendelian genetics were put together with population genetics, early in the twentieth century. Population genetics is a field of biology that studies the genetic composition of biological populations, and the changes in genetic composition that result from the operation of various factors namely natural selection, mutation, random genetic drift, and migration into or out of the population. Ernst Mayr on Speciation Ernst Mayr (1904-2005) helped define the modern synthesis of evolutionary theory, proposing the "Biological Species Concept." In particular, his work on species and speciation helped scientists understand the progress and mechanisms of evolution from one species to another, and the importance of the species unit as "the keystone of evolution." Ironically, one great unsolved problem in Darwin's master work, On the Origin of Species, was just the question on how and why species originate. Mayr proposed that when a population of organisms becomes separated from the main group by time or geography, they eventually evolve different traits and can no longer interbreed. According to him, it's this isolation or separation that creates new species, and the development of many new species is what leads to evolutionary progress. Francis Crick and James Watson on DNA structure In 1953, Francis Crick (1916-2004) and James Watson (1928-) announced that they have discovered the chemical structure of the DNA, the molecule containing human genes. The structure of DNA, as represented in Watson and Crick's model, is a double-stranded, antiparallel, right-handed helix. The sugar-phosphate backbones of the DNA strands make up the outside of the helix, while the nitrogenous bases are found on the inside and form hydrogen-bonded pairs that hold the DNA strands together. They also found that the DNA replicated itself by separating into individual strands, each of which became the template for a new double helix. This marked a milestone in the history of science and gave rise to modern molecular biology, which is largely concerned with understanding how genes control the chemical processes within cells. 1970-2000: Evolutionary paths, horizontal gene transfer, One important development in the study of microbial endosymbiosis, and developmental biology evolution came with the discovery in Japan in 1959 of horizontal gene transfer, which is the introduction of genetic material from one species to another species by mechanisms other than the vertical transmission from parent/s to offspring. The endosymbiotic theory for the origin of organelles sees a form of horizontal gene transfer as a critical step in the evolution of eukaryotes such as fungi, plants, and animals; it states that organelles within the cells of eukaryotes such as mitochondria and chloroplasts, had descended from independent bacteria that came to live symbiotically within other cells. 21st Century: Macro-, micro-evolution and Epigenetic Epigenetics is the study of heritable changes in gene inheritance expression or cellular phenotype caused by mechanisms other than changes in the underlying DNA sequence. By the first decade of the 21st century, it had become accepted that epigenetic mechanisms were a necessary part of the evolutionary origin of cellular differentiation, and that epigenetic variations can affect the production of genetic changes, leading to both micro- and macro- evolutionary changes. Microevolution happens on a small scale and is the change in allele frequencies that occurs over time within a single population, while macroevolution happens on a scale that transcends the boundaries of a single species. Within the modern synthesis of the early 20th century, macroevolution is thought of as the compounded effects of microevolution; thus, the distinction between micro- and macroevolution is not a fundamental one, and the only difference between them is of time and scale.