LANKA
GUARDIAN
Vol. 18 No.2 June 1, 1995 Price Rs.10.00 Registered at GPO, Si Lanka QD/SYNEWSIS4
EELAM WAR III
DEATH OF A MONK
—Mervyn de Silva
THE ILL-PREPARED PRESIDENT
— Nirupama Subramanian
BROKEN PROMISES, LOST FAITH
— V. Prabhakaran
RUSSIAN SAMS
DELHI’S OFFER
FLASHBACK
1985: BATTLES BEFORE PEACE ACCORD
—K.M. De Silva
PEACE ZONE AND SRI LANKAN POLICY
— Humayun Kabir
AUSTRALIA AND THE INDIAN OCEAN
— Gareth Evans
FARMERS UNDER I.M.F ATTACK
— Kalinga Seneviratne
IS DEVOLUTION A SOLUTION?
— Dayalal AbeysekeraWITH THE BEST COMPLIMENTS
OF
ELEPHANT HOUSE SUPERMARKET
QUALITY AT AFFORDABLE PRICES
NO. 1 JUSTICE AKBAR MAWATHA
COLOMBO 2.TRENDS
LTTE infiltrates city
Police suspect that the LTTE has
Inilrated numbers of informants
and acilvists, including suicide bo-
‘bers, into Colombo, One suspe-
ted female soy was aresied on
May 18 at Sri Saranankara Road,
‘on the southem outskirts of the cy.
She was found to be a rative of
Mancathiva, in Jatioa
Don't sell arms, EU told
The European Parimament in a
recent respiuiion urged member
states of ha European Union not fo
sell arms lo the LTTE. The Euro-
pean Perfament also called on
SAARC counties and other nations
of the Indian oceen region to bring
pressure on the LTTE to return to
the negoiiation table.
SUBSCRIPTION RATES
Air Mail
Canadla/U.S.A.
USS 65/ ‘or 1 year
US$ 45/ for 6 months
U.K., Germany, New Zealand,
Australia, Netherlands, France,
Japan, Holland, Phillippines,
Austria, Norway, Sweden,
China, Ireland, Switzerland,
Nigeria, Belgium, Denmark,
Paris, Landon,
US$ 55/ for 1 year
USS 39/ for 6 months
Hong Kong, Saudi Arabia,
Dubai, Baharin, Arabian Gull,
Syria, Singapore.
USS 45/ for 1 year
USS 25/ for 6 months
India, Pakistan.
US$ 40/ for 1 year
USS 22/ for 6 months
Local
Rs. 250/-for 1 year
Rs. 150/-for 6 months
The Union was urged to support
the peace efforts of the Sr Lanka
govemment. The resclition deplo-
‘ed the LTTE’S unlaterel breach of
the ceasefire.
Awer Council?
Moves to set up a war council
which woul inclide Qppastion
Leader Franil Wickremesinghe,
instead of tne extsting Naticnal So-
curity Councl, is being resisted by
powerful persons in the gove-
‘mort, according ioastoryin"The
Island”. The war council idea Is
being pushed bya former AlrForce
thie, according to this newspaper
which has recently had differences
with the goverment jn war news
repating.
Editor in court
“Sunday Times" editor Sinha Ra-
tnatunga has bean chaiged by the
Atlonay General with crminaldela:
‘mation of President Chandiika Ba-
ndaranaike Kumaratunga, The edt
tor has boen noticed to appoar in
court on June 13.
First on the hit list
President Chandiha Bandara
rnaiko Kumaratinga told India To-
day during her recent bref visit to
Delhi inat site was 01 the (op of the
LTTE’ hit list. Tho president also
sadthat LTTE leader VelupillaiPra-
bhakaranhadeatierdecidedincold
bleod to kil former indian Prime
Minister Ray Gena,
The Indian press took note that
this was the irsttime ihe Sa Lanka
government had _catogerically
blamed the LTTE for Rajiv Gandhi's
murder.
Meanwhile, India Today in an
‘ecftorial said that there should be no
hrestation (by Incia) in. providing
‘material and other help to Si Lanka
tocombatthe LTTE. Feferring ote
recen! missile atack on the Sh La-
‘nkan aircraft the edtional saict
“These missiles in tho hand of tho
Tami Tigers is not only a threat to
Sa Lankan miltary air operatiors
butmayalsoendengercivilairiraffic
in Si Lanka and even in Tarnil
Nadu”,
Subsidies only for the
needy
Donor rations at the Aid Group
‘meeting in Paris told Sri Lanka that
subsides should be targetted oniy
lotheneedy. Specificreference wes
made to the whoet flour subsidy;
bread is avilable in Sri Lanka forthe,
richand the pooralikeat te subsic
sad rate of Rs. 3.50 per loaf
Following the Aid Group advice
the government isto re-think subsi-
‘gy schemes to nelp only the poor.
GUARDIAN
Vol.18 No.2 June, 1995
Frice Rs. 10.00
Published fortnightly by
Lanka Guardian Publishing Co. Ltd,
No. 248, Union Place:
Gdarbo -2,
Edo: Mervyn de Silva
Telephone: 447504
Printed by Ananda Press
82/5 Sir Fainajothi Saravanamutty
Mawatha, Colombo 13.
Telephone: 495075
CONTENTS
News Becky ourd 2
Prathakarars Irtevew 4
Keshmie 6
Inala-SriLarka
From Medion o
Intervariion (2) 7
‘Avstraia ane tha
Indian Gcean Region "
Farmers Vs Sivetural
‘Adjustnent 13
Peoole, Powerand Poliics (3) 17
Tho India Factor
Siilania’s Forogn Poicy 6) 19NEWS BACKGROUND
THE LTTE’S TOTAL WAR
Mervyn de Silva
lthough she launched an atlack
(on some newspaper groups, was an
Unusually subdued and serious President
Chandrika who addrassad the lerge ca:
thering at the inaugural meeting of the
National Media Centre. The kiling of the
much respected Dimbulagala monk, had
sunned the nation. For all his sezmingly
eccentric Ways, the venerable monk was
a symbol. He was more than a colourful
character. He was "he trontier monk in
an undecared war. The boundary be-
twoon tho separate “EELAM" that the
beralicn Tige’s'foughttocarve out fram
Sri Lankan tertitory, ard the land over
which Colombo's witran, wasthe central
issue. ina way, the question had become
frontpage news because Dr. Jayelath Ja-
‘yawerdena IMP had raisedit inthe House,
Explaining the matter, he IGP Frenkde
Silva sald that thespecal securilyhadirot
been withdravin,*itwae replaced in acco.
‘dance with a Defence Minisiry policy
directive. This drective related to the pro:
Vision of security to individvalsand institu
tions hitherto supplied by the Sri Lanka
army The security duties were to be
undertaken by the Police in order that
ammypersonnelbe released forthirosse-
nilal combat cities
While the explanation seems quite rea
sonable, itledto a bill dispute between
the P.A. government and tho UNP-led
‘opposition — a strking sign of how the
vwar in the north-and-sast has resulted in
‘another kind of civil warn the South, the
traditional UNP-SLEP battle. This bate
iso longer confined to Parliament.
It is everywhere and anywhere — in
village of municipal councl, on all types
of publ platform, and on noarly avery
public queston,
‘That many-sided war in the South has
become mote incessant and much bioa-
der alter tho last parliamentary elections.
Most of the time, the UNP had a strong
president and 2 socurs, it rot ovorwhs-
2
[ming majority in the house. And it gove-
ted the country for 17 years. it was only
with the advent of the Wijetunca Preside-
‘ney haithingsstartedlochangs. Thetime.
had come for change, anew adrinisira-
tion, It wes made possible once alliercely
divided SLFP, afamily-basedparty where
the bitter family infighting nao caused
serious rifts, discovered a new leader,
albeit enoter member of the family but
‘a nowfaco", a person wih a clean slate,
known to be a dynamicleader Thus, tha
‘Chandrika revolution".
‘The parious ccndition of “the estabi-
shment” parly was dramaticed by the
decision of Prasident Wietunga to retire
from poliics. This gave way to an open
fight for leadership between the acting
leader, Mr. Ranil Wickrermasinghe, and
the new challenger, Mr. Gamini Diseana-
yke — who had joined Mr. Laith Athula-
thmudaliin forming the O.U.NF, en anti
Premadasa front. Despita the usual ru-
mours, there was litle doubt thal the
former National Security Ministar who pe-
rsonally led the Vadamaarachl operation,
Was assassinated by the movernent that
held him guity.
If there were any lingering coubls, the
assassination of Mr. Gamini Dissanaya-
ke, Mr. Rajiv Gandhi's trustediiend,clsa-
ted these doubls several weeks before
tho November residential polls, The now
UNP leader was kiled in precsely the
mannerin which Mr. Ganchi wesassassi
ated — a woman suicds-bomber at an
election meeting,
vis. Gamini Dissanayke was hardly a
serious rival to Mre. Kumaratunga, the
widow of superstar Vijay Kumaratunga
‘whose courageous stance on the “Natio
nial Question’ hadwonthousands of Tarril
‘acimirers andangeredtheultra nationalist
Sinhala movements.
Itisinsuchabackground thatthedaring
assassination of Mr. Vilay Kumaratunga,
a presicential candidate, has tobe placed
bystuden's ofsouthern ornational plites
in tho past hioon yeare, yearain which
the LTTE’ cramatic inteneentons have
been a majorsheping force of SriLanka's
contamperary history And in ths, the
orinant personally es baen Veluotiel
Prathakaran — cacond in importance
oniyto PresicentJ, R. Javawardene. And
yotitwas Prashekaran who made our the
van. 1st 1960 cover. The LLG. had to
choose between President JR. and sue
premo Pradhakaran. The “past” volod
strongly for JR, the past and the future
uggostad tho LTTE leader. Hecortinues
tomake history,
Miltary missions have visited Russ:
Ukreine, China, Czechoslovakia ete. The
defence vate, poor Pref. Pieris edits, wil
soar, He had already reduced it trom 27
billion to 24.7 bilion rupees. He nove fears
itwillexceed 30 tilion rupees (600milion
dollers) two hundred end fity milion less
than what the donor consortium pledged
in Paris for 1888. He prorises nct io print
money orgo to the Central Bank. So what
wil he do? No Sarta Claus is likely to
knock on his door New taxes, sub-
sidy cuts, a viage freeze or sell off State
corporations i foreigninvesiorsurider tie
PERC scheme,
Inthe meantime, anti-lroratt guns have
been installed in vital areas of the cly,
says the ST. in its frontpage lead story,
‘The patiiamentary complex, the Presi
ents offical residence, Sapugaskanda
and Kolonnava cil refineries, The HINDU
reported that the LTTE had been sho:
Pping for microight aircraft, and had
ought six in France. The buyer was a
‘spars fim. The shor take-off andlanding
could provelethalforsvicicebambing, the
report said,
Meanwhile the PA. — UNP. “war
‘once a low-intonsity corflict shows all
signs of @ “no holds barred” battle that
is likely to increase in intensity in the
coming months. And that of course, suits
the LTTE strategists perfectly,Back to the Battlefield
{As Sri Lankan jets pound Jaffna peninsula, the wheel has turned full eicte in relations between the Government
and the LTTE, with Colombo seeking Intemational help to fight the Tigers
Nirupama Subramanian
“or Chandika Kumaratunga, the
‘transtion from a dedicate peacerra-
kerte a determined fightorhas boon swift
and decisive, but certainly not painiess
For a leader who got elected on ¢ one.
point agenda to bring peace back to
Sifftorn S1i Lanke, this must have been
a terrible disappointment. Tougher sills
the prospect of doing battle witha foe that
‘saemsto aut-gunand autsthink her armad
forces by a considerable margin, balling
up a fith of her armed forces in isolated
‘carrisons and much emboldened afier
Killing atleast 200 0! them n usta fortnight
cf onesided fightin,
The Srl Lankan Presidentfound herself
li-propared to wage war as tho LTTE
unleashed tne deadly surface-te-airmissi
Is on Aprii29, In a desperate image-boo-
sting effort, she authorised her ai force's
tiny jet force on May 10 to tomb Jafina
peninsuia despite the risk ol civilian casu-
ss, Even Sii Lenkens, long used to the
falure of peace negotalions, were taken
aback by the quickness with which the
process cisintegraied this time round.
Despite the Government's persistence
over a regoliated seltiement iothe ethnic
crisis, twas clear that without the parc
pation of the intiansigent Tigess, such a
‘settlement waulé bein vain, LTTE supre-
mo V, Prabhakeran, on his par, clans
thathostillias were renewed because the:
Goverment falled to live up to ils prom
ses to the Tamis, prmavil the liting of
the economic embargo imposed by the
previous goverment (c@0 interview).
“This Government has beon trapped by
the public promises it made. But itis now
time fora clear rethink on howto provent
the country from being diviced,” says
Kingsley De Silve, biographer of former
president J.R. Jayewardene. As the Go-
‘vernmen! prepares for war withthe Tigers,
Kumratunga is baing asked to separaie
the LTTE ffom the espitalions of the
Tamils in oder to eave Sri Lanka'sterita-
fal integrity.
For the Government to make any hea-
way politically, t must dealwith tha LITE
rmlirly, and combine it with the annou-
neemant of its poltical package,” says.
Sunil Eastan, pollical enalyst with the
Colombo-based Institute of Ethnic Stu-
digs. According to him, a package which
devolves substantial poworsto the othnic
‘minovitias may even bring the LTTE back
to the negotiation table. That such a pa-
‘ckage is in the offing was hinted at when
the Government annouced it was having
talks with ether Tamil groups and parties.
But divisions within the Government
‘over the poliical peckege have to be
sorted out irst. The point of disagreement:
the proposed meigerof tie northern with
the eastem province, both Tami majorty
‘areas with pockets of Musfims ang Sinh
ese. In fact, the DUNF. one of the cons
tuents of the People's Alliance Gove-
rmmont, has openly citicised such @
‘move, arguing iat it would mean giving
‘up contrl of one-third of Sri Lanka’s land
area an two-thirds of is coastline. inthis
ease, Sinhalese iro may wallbe aroused.
And it fe clear that the LTTE wouldn't
be complaining, “What the Tigers would
like rght naw ie a Sinhalese backlachthat
‘would once again corvince ail Tami that
the LTTE is thair only lifeline," says
EPRLF spokesmen. Ketheeswaran. At
the end of the dey, even i Kumaratungo
does manage to carry Sinhalese opinicn,
there are more serious obstacles to such
‘g process.
irs, it will be near on impossible to
Implernentitin the nor, where a majority
cf the Tamils live. At prasent, the region
Is vitally a quas-state under the LTTE's
control. Second, the LTTE could easily
Jeopardse the process in otter parts of
the country 100, especally in the east
Prabhakaran’s outfit nas demonstrated
time and agains ruthless ability o dispo-
se of leaders who have ried to sideline
it — former president Premadasa, Rajiv
Gandhi and K Padmenabha of he
EPRLF, forinslance.
‘The only hope thet any peace process
sans the LTTE has of success is it the
SriLankan security forcesareable tobeat
the Tigersin theirown territory. Rightnow,
that looks like « very tall order.
Ifthe attack on the gunboats in Trineo-
male harbour on Aptil 19 demonstrated
the efficiency of te Black Sea Tigers, he
rmiscile atlack on the Avro plane carying
men and supptesto the northern base of
Paleli demolished the myth that the
‘countty’s ar force was invulnerable. Inits
belated rush to overcome a shortage of
men and material, the Government has
embarked on @ major driva to fil the
shrinking ranks of the 100,000-sirong
army and fo ecquire miltery equipmant
overseas. What the miltary might stl be
short on, however, ere inspiting loado-
‘ship, siralegy and motivation.
Unfortunately, the present set-up has
‘evoked only dread and despeir. Amy
Commander Gerry Siva is on record sa-
ying € miitary solution to the elhnic crisis
is “not possible”. Though the sialement
islargely rue, coming from the army chief
ithas had a demoralsng effect. "If that
Is indged the cese, the man on the front
wants fo know what he is doing there,”
remarked a brigadier.
In te coming days, morale will play en
‘important role for the army. Holed up in
the Pooneryn camp in Jafina are ever
4,500 soldiers, dependent for their su-
plies on air force vanspot planes. In
Palali there ere anolhor 16,000 man in
a similar predicament. With the air force
viruelly neulralisedatterthe missile attack
andthenavyapprehensiveaboutenteing
thearea, the woopsare completely bottled
Up, After squeezing the amyss supplies,
the LITE may wel launch an offensive
the camps. LTTE has lo weigh long-term
Implications | such @ move sinceit would
invite opprebrium from the international
‘community.
One thing that Is clear ts while the
Governments peace agenda promptod
the armed forces to goon a vitual hiatus,
the LTTE used the timo to build itestrength. is successful sirkes in the east
bear testimony to this — the LTTE hac
been more or less flushed outof the area
iy 1999 but it Used tie three months of
Ceasefire to make inrcads into the area
onceagein. After ie renewalof hostililes,
al its ambushes have ocurred in this
province.
However, itis the LTTE’s possession
of missiles — said to be Russian-made
‘SA‘7 missiles cbiained from Ukraine —
that has really got the Government iwo-
ried and strengthened the boief that the
ctisis cart be resolved by Sil Lanka elon,
The recent meeting between Kumaratu-
ge end Prime Minister P.V. Narasimha
Rao in New Dolhi during the SAARC
summit fuelled speculation on India's po-
ssibla invovoment.Itis befeved thet Ku-
maratunge raised the Issue of “commen
threat" to both countries from the LTTE.
Indeed, there Is 2 growing feeling that
India could offer valuable assistance 10
the Govemment, “india cand alottohelp
‘ur couniry, without stepping into Si La-
‘kan terntory. Forinstance, patraling the
waters to ensure that the LTTE does not
get its supply of weapons," says Air Vice
Marshal Hairy Gooneilleke, former air
forea chief. Even die-hard India-bashors,
lke Dinesh Gunawardene, president of
tha Sinhala nationalist Mahajana Ekeath
Petuming, feel Si Lanka needs inda's
help. “It 6 no longer just a Sri Lankan
{ssue. The problem concernsihe bounda-
ties of India as wal,” he cays.
Butitis unikely that Incia will be drawn
into the confit — considering the IPF
‘exoerience, and with the upcoming gene-
ral elections and assembly elections in
‘Temil Nadu — even though renewed
fignting may step up LITE actviy in he
slate. External Afairs Minister Prana
Mukherjee, in fact, has categorically
deniad that Si Lanka asked India for
military help and termed it an “internal
ispute.” The Indian Government, howe~
Ver, may be forced fo change its mind if
Sri Lanka wore offered essislance by a
thd country, say, Pakistan,
But with nointernational help immeciae
{ely forthcoming, the pressure is on the
Government to get its act together and
formulate a consensual package for poa-
e.Faiingwhich, he alernaiivelsancther
org dravin out battle in which the LTTE
bas been fist off the biocks,
4
“We have lost faith’
‘Anandhi Surya Prakasen of the BBC wes
in Jaffna within 48 hours of the LTTE's
‘renewal of hostities. LTTE supremo Va-
Wupilal Prabhekaran, who rarely granis
inleviews to the press, agreed 10 meet
ineratone ofhis camps. In miltary fatigue
witha black cord holding acyanice capsu-
Je around nls neck, and surounded by
‘bodyguards, he remained uniazedby pe~
ssisient questioning on why the LTTE
decided to unilaterally withdraw froma the
peace process. The exclusive interview,
in Tarnil, wes recoided cn tape. Excerpts:
Q. Why did you decide to withdraw
‘trom the peace negotiations at a time
when there was hope that peace wil
be rastorad in the north?
‘A. We mace this painful decision at a
time when our peoele had lest all hope.
Inthe beginning, we enterainad the hope
that the Tamil national question viould be
resolved through poltical negotiations,
The Tami people have been subjectad
to enormous suffering as a corisequence
of the economic embargo, fishing bans
and the blockade on traffcimposedby tie
previous gevernmont. We requested no:
thing other than theremmovalofinesebans,
Instead of viewing thes issues as pro-
blems of the Tamil people, the Gove-
rament took them as spectfic demands of
the LTTE, Furthermore, wo were told that
any attempt to resolve them wouldspark
ff miliary reporoussions. Wopointed out
thatthe continuation oftheneace negotia-
tions vould serve no purpose if the pio-
blers of our people were not resolved
‘The Governmentassured us thatit would
remove the bans, Wo extended our dea:
dineby tnre weeks, Butthe Government
delayed the implementation of is deci-
ions. It is because of this that we and
‘our people have lost fait in Crandrika’s
Government
@. Why did youcecide todiscontinue
the peace negotiations even though
President Kumaratunge lifted the eeo-
nomic embargo and offered several
concessions?
A. Giving pledges and implementing
those pledges are two different things. it
is true thal President Chandrika gave ue
— V. Prabhakaran
Pledges. But she hasnottaken constnueti
‘ve measuies to implement them,
@. Shouldn't you have been « bit pa:
tient since the delay could have been
caused by administrative hurdles?
A. We reached the brink of tolerance.
‘The Government dragoedits feet iormore
than sx months. If there was a genuine
will, the Government would have lited the
bansand proceeded with theimplementa-
tion within 24 hours.
@. What do you feel about the dec
sion to relmpose these bans?
‘A. it nes made one thing very clear: as
faras the Tanillissue is concerned, here
is nofundamenialdifierencokotween the
present Government end the UNP regi-
mo.
@. Several forsign governments
haye condemned you for terminating
the peace negotiations,
A. Weare fully aware that the intematio-
nal community is geruinely concemed
abou the Tamilissueand vianisapoliical
setlement, Some foreign counties have
chasento condemntheLTTE onthobacie
of the onesided story provided by the
Government before studying the issue in
depth.
@ Chandrika has made It clear that
sho is determined to pursue the peace
process wlth or without the coopera-
n of the LTTE,
A. Itt’ practicable to achieve peace
without the cooperation of the LTTE, lot
hercontinue her effort,
@__Theinternational Secretariat ofthe
LTTE in London issued 2 statoment
recently that the Tigers have not
closed the doorsforpeaco. What eteps
do youexpectthe Governmentto take?
A. Ourdcorsforpeace are stil open, We
are dissatisfied and dsilusioned with the
Government approach but we haventtlost
hops. If the Goveinment makes favoura-
ble decisions on the issues wo raicod, wo
will be prepared locease allhostiities and
reium to tho peace process.On the prow!
1@ President of Sri Lanka,
Chandrika Kumaratunga, wes lected
in November wih a larga majority parly
by promisingto bring poaccto tho country.
Shes now blterly contemplating theruins
otherquest, Notonly havatharebel Tamil
Tigers rejected her peace feelers, butthe
miltary advantage has swung in the Tr
gore’ favour.
‘The government was rattled by the
sinking of Mo naval gunboats which
marked the resumption of the civil war on
‘pill 19in; but is teacticn ten days later
totheshocting down of tworrlitary arcraft
‘over Jatina, where the Tigers are strong,
vas moro tke panic. Regular fichistothe
aimy's isoiled bases in Tige:-controlled
‘areas have not been resumed. Now that
thea force heslostits confidence, aTiger
Onslaught on the base of Poonareen,
close to Jaffna, may be imminent.
Since the 190,000trong secur
forces appear to be incapable of inficting
decisive defeat on a rebel farce aterth
of their size, the goverment has tumec
‘abroad for help. The defance altaches of
ffiendly counties in the region have been
Invited to Colorribo for talks andthe gove-
foment has reversed its ban on erms
purchases. Itis planning to buy warships,
airerait and armoured vehicles irom a
‘number of countries, amiong them Israel,
China and Russia.
But even with new equipment, the go-
‘vernmentis ot confidentthatitcandefeat
the Tigers clone, Iipaniculaly wenisindia
to hep cut tha Tig2rs' lfe-ine to Tamil
Nad, India's couthorn stato, Supplias of
weepons. fuelandoheressentasarestil
smuggled across the Palk Strat to Jatina
Wourdled Tigers ere locked after in privax
‘ehospitals in Tamil Nadu. Tigerunifomms
‘aro mado in tho state. In addtion to cu-
pressing such services, Si Lanka would
ike Inela to share intelligerca witht, and
foagree toa joint naval petrolot the strat.
What India is prepared to offer, howe-
yer, is rather different, Both counties
folse to disclose the substance o} ciscu-
seions held during wo visits to Dethi by
Mrs Kumaretunga: one Just before the
peace effort collapsed, the otharalterthe
Tigers fredtheirant:-circraft missiles. But,
according to unconfirmed reports, the
Indian prime mister, Narssirha Rao,
faised the possistily of a joint raid by Sri
Larkanand lidiancommandostocaature
the Tiger leader, Velupilai Prabhakaran.
Jn an election year, arresting the man
suspected of arranging the murder of
Rajiv Gandhi, Mr Rac's predecessor,
would help Mrfiao. SnatshingMr Prabha:
karan tromhisiuraehidecut vouldalaca
te Raji loyalists in Congrose and unde
(cut MrReo'srrain val, Aqjun Singh, wiio
locks to Rajiv's widow, Sonia, for support
But beyond serding a snatch squad,
the signs ara that India willnat hap. Once
‘chlytoo eagerto getinvelvedin SriLanks,
itis now wary of getting sucked back into
the mess. Athough a stike against Mr
Prabhakeranirselfrmightprove popular,
coordinated action against the Tigors
would be deeply resented in Tamil Nadu,
Where the main Tanil paries sympathise
= either openty or covertly — with the
Tigers. And memores are stil fresh of
1987-90, when a 100,000-streng Indian
peacekeeping force cccuped the north
‘and east of the island, but alled to tame
the Tigers and sutlered many casualties.
Now, wih the Tigers posing a more se
flous tweat than ever, the government in
Colombo Icoks Ikely to be lelt to is own
devices,
—Feanomiet
LTTE missiles may be of Russian origin
Dinesh Kumar
indian defence and security agencies
fare trying to trace the type, source and
Gfigin of the surlace-b-air missiles
(GAMs) used by LITE miltants in Si
Lanka recenty since this could have a
direct bearing on the Indian securlly sce~
‘The LTTE ied brought down two Avro
aircrafi belonging 'o the S1i Lankan Air
force in the Jaffna peninsula with hea
{seeking SAMs on two conseculve days
last weekend, The issue was also discu-
sed by leaders of SAARC, excepting the
SriLankan Prime Minister who had retu-
‘med eaflsr on. Although no consensus
bad emetgedrom the discussions, Prime
Minister P. V. Narasimha Rao had while
‘Geseribing the veaponsystemes “fighto-
fing” observed that it was an Issue of
*Serious concern”,
lnformed sources sey that this incident
hasacdadanewdimensontothesecurity
‘scera‘io since this is the frst ime that
heat-seeking missles nave been usedby
2 militant of guerila grcup against fying
aircraft in the sub-continent. inthis region
only Afghan mujahideens have so far
Used such missfes. But then, the hi-
ahly-capable heai-seeking Stinger missi-
Tes had coon cuppliae by US govarrmant
agencies 19 the mujahideens fo fight the
farmed forces of the former Soviel Union
in Afghanistan,
Presentindizationsarethat the missiles
the LTTE used are of Russian origin and
have provably been procured from
‘Afghan mujahideen groups. There has
alsobeen sometalko!theLTTE procuring
these missilesthrough urofficialchannels
from Usraine. inital reports, for examole,
hhad eaid that Sri Lankahad been warmed
by te Ukrainian government some
months ago that an llagal arms shipment
was heading towards the island nation.
Interestingly, folowing thistip off SriLanka
had alerted indian sccurity agencies thi-
‘nking that ihe consignmenk was intended
foruse-againis India ratherthan Si Lanka
liself which was then engaged in peace
talks with the LTTE,
ut wnat would aso be of relevance to
Indian securty agencies is the typo of
middlemen (eny) sourcing offunds, and
the routs iaxen by ine rTE Incaring nis
lothalricelo eystom to Sx ank insu.
gent grouesin ihe nonieeast,notebl ihe
National Socialist Counell cf Nageland
(NSCN), is known to have established in
Fiematonal arms bazers SOue) East
Asia as had even Purjab milians. There
fave been unconfimed reports of the
LTE establshing coniacis wih Puna
iltante Canada ae aleowith tho Poo.
ples War Group (PW)
Although ro militant crinsurgent group
in India has til now used surface-io-alr
mssilas, an Amy patrol had recovered a
ussian made SA-7 (Siralla) dose to tho
Line of Contiol in Kashimirs Kupwara
order district in Apil 1994. The SA-7
compares similarly in capablliyand peto-
mance to the type ol SAM used by the
LTTE. "Any such weapon eystam should
be a cause of concern.
= Times of Incia
5CONFLICT
Kashmir once more
dn the age of identity, armed conflicts have a spill-over effect. Identity does nob respect borders. Tt was
the flow of rofugeos to Tamilnadu that gave Delhi the right to be ‘concerned and then involved, The state
of Tamilnadu itself was earved out after a re-drawing of borders because Pandit Nehra, confronted by
tthe force of linguistic nationalism and the threat of suicide by Pottu Sri Ramclu, tho respected friend
of Mahatma Gandhi, was forced to intervene to prevent a national tragedy. In Sri Lanka, language was
tthe root cause of conflict.
Religion rather than language is the souree of the region’s generic conilict — Kashmir, British India
became two states under the supervision of the departing cclonial power. Here isa comment on the current
conflict from the LONDON TIME:
Kashmir Flames
‘No solution in sight as Delhi drifts and Pakistan meddles
Chrar--Sratit, a sleepy village in Ka-
shmir wes the scence of fierce fichting
between Indian troops ardarmedisarric
mmiliants. What is striking is not that there
should be fres and bloocisheld in an
obscure hamlet, Kashmir and its civitans
have suflered more than thelr falr share
of both in the course of an intense civil
war now in its sixth year, The arresting
feature of the baitla was thatit was fought
inside Irdan-administered temtory,
against Indan solders by Pakistani
gunmen,
‘As our Scuth Asia correspondent re-
ports rom Kashmir, morethan 60 Mujahi-
din are entrenched in a Musim shrine in
the vilage. The shrine was occupied by
them — and immediaiely encicied by
Indian treops — some months ago yet
only now has it emerged boyand dispute
that the majoriy of the occupiers ara nat
local Kashrilis but heavily armedinilra-
{orsfromPakisian. This withave the effect
‘ef boosting tho consistont indian claim that
separatist violence in tha disputed prov.
nog is “sponsored by iis neighbour, and
cof weakening the consistent Pakistani
protesietion that is involvement in Ke
shmir comes orly in the form of moral
supporto thearea's beleaguered people.
6
The unmasking of Pakistani fighters at
Char--Starifwill surely make Incia/sinte-
mationel diplomatic offensive on the Ka-
shri issue less ciffcult to conduct than
ithas boon forsoretime. Delhiwould err,
however, ifit were to attbuteallviclonco,
and al calls for Kashmir self-daterm ins
tion, to the machinations of te boneymen,
in Pakistan. Thereiscompeling evlence
that many Kashmise are now unprepared
to accept ther present polifical status as
citizens of the indian republic. insofar as
‘many ale unprepared also to accept the
accession of thir dspured province to
Pakistan, tho only lasting way to end the
conflict would be to search for solutions
that would accomadale the Kashmid
quest lor self-goverrment
The batle of Chrai-i-Sharif could resutt
in yet another postpenament of provincial
élections in Kashrir by the Indian Gove-
rmment. But these elections are likely. if
ever held, to be tie source of even more
confic! vidually every Kashi politcal
‘erganisation hac refused to participate
arguing instead for 2 referendum on the
nature of Kashmirs poltical association
(erather wise) with Inc.
But the foree of Indian public opinion,
as it now stands, makes it inconceivable
that the Prime Minister, Narasimha Rao,
Would even begin to addrase tho qusstion
of Kashmiri selfletermination: to do so
‘would be tartamount pottical suicide and
would play diecty into the hands of the
Hindu nationalist opposition Bharatiya Ja-
nata Party. Equally, the fragilly of the
Government in islamabadhas meantihal
Benazir Bhutto has had to be more shell
on Kashmir than is haloful for the people
Who live under Indian administration
‘There is mounting evidence also, that
Miss Bhullo has litle control over those
Pakistani egencies— such asthesrister
Inter-Services Intelgence — which aid,
abet and supply radical anred Islamic
groups in Kashmir,
As events at Chari-Shari now demo-
Nstrate, such support is not confined to
money end material. The Indian Gove-
rementis entitled todeliverashaiprebuke
to Miss Bhutto and to call on Pakisian to
stanch the flow of infitrators into Indian-a-
ministered Kashrir. Vet Dolhi must not
regard the crisis in Kashmir as a smpio
‘Case of infitration rom across the border,
the roots of Kashmrin disaifeciion sil le
finniy in Indian sot,PART2
War Amidst Peace Talks
K. M. de Silva
he increase in the number of
‘spokesmen for the Tami minorty had
some preciGanle consequences, beginning
‘raturalyencugh with astriggieamong ham
{for dominence, anda quest forthe positon
f sole spokesmen. The TULF, the most
‘moderato of the Tamil groups, found itself
‘edged out of any posiion of influence.
Instead the lead wert at various stages to
cer groups, with a bowiklerng range of
‘acronyms, People'sLiberation Army cf Tami
Edam (PLOTS); the Tami Eelam Liberation
Organization (TELO), the Liberation Tigers
of Tamil Eelam (LTTE), and Eeam Peope's
Rovolutionary Liberation Front (EPRLE) all
ofwhonwereassisduously culivatedbythe
Research and Analysis Wing of the Indian
Prime Miriter offs. Botter known by i
acronym RAV Itwas the Indian equivalent
of the CIA. RAW provided Tami groups
Iocated in India with arms and training with
the knowledge, not under the aegis, ofthe
Indian governmant, Tae TELO group was
spedal favorite of the RAW. The LTTE eve-
niuallypushedzhead oa postion o!domina-
noo latgoly because of i's strong and expa-
‘nding base in Jalfra, The three leacers of
the strongest ofthese groups, Prabhakaran,
Uma Maheawaren, and Sr Sabarainar,
ere soon engaged In a biter and increas
‘gly violant rivalry ferthe pestiono’ princpal
spokesmen ofthe’ Tamilcause. Prabhakaren
eventually wen the day. But that is another
sory.
‘Two sels oltalks between representatives
ofthe Si Lanka governmant andthe various
Tamil. gioups, claiming to speak on behalf
of ther ethnic group took place in July and
‘August 1985 al Thimpu, tho capital of Bhu-
tan, These talks dd not yield any postive
results, but Bhardaf ised the opportunity
they provided lo continue negotiations wih
the Sx Lankan delegation in New Delhi,
Those taks ware more fruit The new
‘agenda for etic recondliation which eme-
‘ged from them yielded a framework for a
realise devolution of power in Sri Lanka
intended to meetsomeo' the princpal Tani
demands
Che of ihe most significant feetures ofthis
matculously crafied agreement wasthal the
tit of devolution was to be a province, no
longer a district. Secondy, the powers to be
devolved on these provincial unis were
Thewiters Prfes
Unversty,
sortlicteryatibe Peredeniye
‘much wider than those offered eatlier by the
Sri Lanka goverament in decuscions with
Indian mecietors and Tamil representatives.
The complex new structures agreed upon
‘consttuted a major conceasion on tho part
(of the Sit Lankan government to the Ge
‘mands of the Tamils of the novth end sas
‘of he island, The draft accord which came
to be known in official circles as the Dan
‘Accord of August 1985 was basod on the
consersusreached onthial occasion and the
TULF's views were part of that consensus
Inialed on 30 August his draft accerdbaca
ime the basis ol all ulure negotations be
tween the two governments on Sri Lanka's
‘elhnis problems concerning the Tamil mio
fy.
‘The actual sianing of the accord which
Bhandari hoped would crown his mediatory
elforts confronted @ mejor obstecle in the
reluctance if not relusal of the other Tami
{@rcups who ware reprasontad af Thimpulto
{ve thelr consent cit. The longer hey held
Gui the more ciffcultitbecame fo: he TULF
to publidy commit iol to an agreomentin
the formulation of which they had been co-
resulted and to which they had given their
‘concurencain Delhi.
In December 1805 the TULF withckew its,
ssuppatt or the Deh Accord under pressure
fiom thoirmors aggrossive vals, in paricu-
Jar, the LUTTE. By the tine Bharidalet office
Jn early 1986 only the two governments
femnainied committed fo the agreement rox.
‘che and inalled in Delhi
Meanwhile spcradic outbursts of ethnic
\islence, especaily in the north and oasi of
the Island, and dashes between the security
forces end Tamil guerrilas and terorsts
‘grouse disturbed the peace ct tha isan.
Greatly inpioved relallons between the wo
counties did notextandicany sercuselfors
fon the part of the Indian goverment to
prevent indian teritory being used by Tarr
fliaras and terrvie's for ataake on 2 fie
fy neighbor, much lessto close down the
training facities ard camps. Raiv Gandri,
‘20 much loss depandent on tha southam
Indian poitical base than his mother, and
intent on taking a more even-handed
Approach than cho ict tne problems posed
by Sii_Lanke's ethnic conflicts, found his
options more lirited than he would have
hed them fo be. The constant lay in tho
elinic politics of Tami Nadu, The Tamil
uerritas and torrosis groups costinued to
have training facillles end bases there.
“The Tamil separatist groups in Sri Lanka
all ad their supporters among the pdlitcal
partios of Tamil Nadu, the govomnmart and
‘Opposition panies alike, each of wliom was
determined to. demonstrate that its commi-
‘mont to tho Sri Larkan Tamil cause wes
slioiges then the other's. In locking Lierise~
ives into the police of Sri Lankan Tamil
separatist agiction, thoy were also drawn
into the flece factonalism thet was part of
the Si Lankan Tamil paiifeal scene. Nora
ifthe Tamil Nadu pottical patios couldkeep
the peace among the rval Si Lenkan Tami
{graups whose Intamecine warfare atten ook
‘more Tamil ives than theirfrequent clashes
wih the Si Lenkantotces. Temil Naduconti-
ued to serve thiee purposes: as a s2-
rictuary, as @ base for Fairing and supely
of sims; and as a souroa of funds. Thenks
to the euppot they hed in and from Tamil
Nadu the Tarilseparatist groups, and espo-
cial the LTTE and isally the EHOS group,
hhad become a formidablo guerilla Torco,
much stronger Man thelr indian mentors
thought they would ever be.
‘The LTTE was algo holped by a decision
taken by the Sri Lanke governimentin July,
1985, es part of an understanding reached
with India, that its focos in tho Jatiaa poni-
‘sula would be Kept within tielrbasracks or
‘camps. Originally this erangement was to
Taatfor wo months, butitwas lateroxtended,
In response to Indian pressure, for three
months. The LTTE took advantage of this
temineal the roads leadng out of he camps
‘and proceeded thereatter iobaricade them,
These makeshit barricades wereconverted
into concrete bunkers, The result was that
the LTTE established ellectve control over
tho town of Jafina not tre Jafiraperineula
Iisa, since the Si Lenkearmysmmovernents
weieseriousyhampered thereaiterdy these
barricades. Tho units of tho Sri Lark army
stationed in the fort of uatfra could only be
supped by ait
“The LTTE wos embcldened by this shit
{in te miltary Delence to emtark on a vigo-
rovs campaignagainsitheSi Lankan forces,
and allacks on softer targels as well as a
ruthless program ct eliminating is Tami
rivals. They eoldom directed their attacks
‘against the secuily forcesinopencontronia~
tions, Whey they id so thelr attacks were
generally easily repuises. But one o} the
‘Consequences of such confrontations was
that quite offen civiians were kiled, cithor
‘caugilin the crosssire or — on occasion —
by Solciers on the rampage seekng to ave-
fnge the ‘ose of thelr comrades in land-mine
blasts. The LTTE, for its part, Legen to
7choose easter and softer targets suchas an
atzck on the city of Anurachapara in May
1985 in which 150 civilians were killed, or
‘more frequently thereater on Sinhalesepea-
Sanis in the remoter areas of the norh-oa-
‘ral and caster regions, Thess attacks
became a mglor pollical embarrassment to
the govamment
‘Tho intamecins warlere between the so-
paalist orcups reacted its peak belwsen
September 1925and April 1036,0n 1Septo-
mer 1695 the LTTE assassinated WoTULF
stalvarts — two former WP's — who had,
tnlike the bulk ofthe colleagues, contrued
‘olive in Jaffna, K wes a move designed '0
Compal the TULF in Macras and elsewhere
to too the line, thati to aay, to rerain from
sighing the Dalnl Accord,
‘The SriLarka govermmentbecan iodiven
an increasingproperton of ts annvalbucgot
tothe expansion and equipping of iis aimed
foices. Along with itthere was an escalation
ofrriliary action egainet te Tantl separatist
ups in the noah end east of the Island
The Sri Lankan armed forces ware now
betterequirpedand better tained tianbelo-
e.Much ctinetranng wesdon nPaksian,
while small groupe of leraelis and Brieh
mervenaries horied the skills of special
ccunter-lerrs|untsintheamyandipolce,
‘As clashes hetwoon the securty forces
ard the Tami separats! aclists beceine
more frequent and casualies increased
number India’s modiatory 1010 gave way to
@ return to the: Indira Gandhi policy cf a
diplomaic cfersive against Si Lanka: thus
@ prosagands campaign was launched
tough is embassies and High Commi-
sions abroad, accusing the gavemment of
human rights violetions. Si) Larkan ard
Indian gpiomats clasied at the UN in New
York and Geneva, all gait of ai policy of
*moral” sarctions aimed at persuading S11
Lanka to retimto the bargaining table. The
Indian Embassy in Washingtonandthe igh
Conimissions in Otiawva and Lordon, the
meantime, continued tobe cantorsof support
forTamilsepatatst groups operating those
count
Had the Indian goverment been mare
onsiive to the Sii Lankan government's
dificulies, and made seme tnambiguous
and noticeable effortto sloptheuseo! nian
teritory by the LITE and ctheis for thelr
military ecivties, here mayhavebem grea
ter gollical eupport witiin Sri Lanka for a
resumption of negotiations wih the Tani
groups, or greater reatiiness fo ion military
aciien agains! tho LTTE The Sri Lankan
‘govetrmient had treated the Delhi Accord
inialled on 20 April 1685 as an important
step forwerd in reaching a setlement with
the Tamil minoity, and descrined it as “a
bla basis for negotiation and setle-
‘Neither the TULF orthe other Tamil groups
hhac responded postive to the proposals in
the Delhi Accord, It tock sevaral ments of
negotiations with tiem by indian officals
before teindian goverment could send an
offial delegation to Sri Lanka for further
discussions on possible adjustments and
mocifications ofthe Delhi Accord, By thetima
the delogation arved in SriLanka Bhandari
had let office. The deleqaton was led by &
Ministarof Stalenatinthe Cabinet, P. Chide-
‘mbaramn a young [40 yeas atthe te) Tamil
\WwhoaspredioaCongress-basedleaderstip
of Tami) Nac, ard Natwar Singh, Rajiv
Gendhi’s Winister of State for Extemel
Aais. The delegaticn arrived in Colombo
‘0n@0 April 1986andhold veryintensivetalis:
overthenex five days. Thelrartivaloinced
wih the LTTE's massacre of the TELO les
ersand the killing of Si Sabaranam in the
course ct this clash,
For the fist time since Indian mediation
boganin lato 1983 tho principal negotiators
forthe Indian goverment were poliletans
‘and not bureaucrats or diplomats. On tha
departure of the Chidambaram del
‘on 4 May it was announced that “
Lanka govemment had agrood to male fu-
‘ther concessions beyond the tems of the
‘Delh Accord" The decisions raachedon his
‘cceaion were publishod on 4 May 1906,
Bhanda's successors Foreign Secreta
1 AP. Yenicleswaran had much less
port wity Rlajv Ganchi than had Bhardan,
and greater sympattyforihe SriLarka Tami
case.
He placedhis rustia the TULF andvitua
lly pushed them inio taking the laadin nago-
tiatons wit the Sri Lanka government, The
TULF lacdare living in oxla in Macrae, were
‘pol unviling to play the role that Venkato-
‘swaran had devse¢ for them bit they were
terrified at the prospect of eniaganizing te
Moe aggiessive Tamil groups. Venkate-
swvaran Called representatives! thesa later
fgrcups to Delhi and persuaded them to let
the TULF take the lead in the discussion with
the Sri Larkan government ec
heldin Colombe later in te yeer
Veniateswarenhit upon the idea of giving
the Dathi Accord great accaptabiliy fo tho
Tamils by using the Indian state sysiem as
‘a model (or Sti Lania’s devolutionary sche.
‘mos. He bolioyod that this subte but none
theless signlicant transtonmalicn o! te de-
volition packaga nagolisted by Bhandar
‘would appeel io the TULF because i used
the indian ‘ederal system as 2 model, while
itwould be accoptable to Presidant Jayewa.
ene nd his advisers because tie cena
‘goveinment inna was much more powe:
‘Mul than in most federations, Besides there
‘als sulficient ambiguty in the refinemento!
the Dehi Accord mace by Verkateswaran
to allow for bargaining and dive and take,
and for more compromise.
Bythe time the TULF arrived in Colombo
for-negotations with the Sri Lanka gove-
‘mmentin June 1996, President Jayewarde-
‘ne had embarked on 2 new initative, the
Poltical Parties Conference (PPC) at which
theDelhiAccordandthechangesinitagrend
toby the two goverment Apmi 1985, would
badiscussed. Once again heprincipal oppo:
sttion pert, the SLFP refused 1 jain the
‘conference, but seven other pares, Incu-