Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Identification of Engineering
Work (IDoEW)
The Council for the Built Environment (CBE) has recently issued a draft policy
document on the application of the reservation of work for registered engineering
categories. Commentary and suggested amendments have been requested from
ECSA (Engineering Council of SA) and the Voluntary Associations (VAs).
T
he essence of the policy lies in disciplines to all registered persons, the other,
the Acts issued by Parliament in favoured by ECSA, is to follow a process which
2000 governing the six profes- provides for a series of generic questions that need
Chris Reay sions that are considered to be to be asked about defined job functions. If these
Chairman of the Working
Committee: Communications
responsible for the activities that create conclude that the activities would have the need
(SA Institution of Mechanical and manage the built environment. One to comply with engineering competencies that
Engineering) of these is the Engineering Professions relate to public safety, then that role is reserved
Act which would apply to the various for registered persons.
categories of engineering activities. The selection of who is competent to carry out this
The implementation of registration is mandated to role is then done by normal evaluation of potential
ECSA which essentially provides an administration candidates by the responsible employer body. The
role and relies heavily on the input and support of ECSA model ensures compliance with the Act,
all the VAs, as well as from academia and industry. while that of the CBE introduces terms and roles
The bulk of the technical work is carried out by not contained in the Act, and which would lead to
the latter bodies in various committees hosted by enormous lists of competencies and disciplines that
ECSA. Overall it works well when one considers the would need massive administrative and technical
evolutionary challenges of setting and maintaining support bodies. It would require changes to the
standards for a profession. Act and the current registration process.
One hopes a constructive, collective solution to this
Could have literally reduced the profession to a low challenging process will result but one thing is for
standard free-for-all certain. It will have an enormous impact and per-
haps currently unknown effect on the employment
The key component of the process is the peer review of engineering resources. The VAs should evaluate
role played by the largely voluntary persons who how they can be relevant in this new order and
are appointed to the committees. provide employers of engineering resources with
Readers may recall the collective objections to the assistance.
recent SACBE Bill that got as far as the National Understanding the issues
Council of Provinces in Parliament before being It would be advisable for all mechanical engineering
withdrawn and effectively terminated. That fun- based companies to consider joining the SAIMechE
damental component of independent peer review as Affiliate Members as well as to encourage their
of applications for registration was to be removed qualifying resources to register with ECSA, and
and replaced by a ministerial appointment. It become members of the SAIMechE as well. It
would have lead to a disaster which could have costs the same to do both as it is to register with
literally reduced the profession to a low standard one only.
free-for-all. So much for the Act that focuses on
It will also benefit employers to form associations
the maintenance of public safety.
with those recruiting consultants who understand
Two views the implications of engineering qualifications and
However, we are now progressing to the stage where competence criteria. Too many job specifications
IDoEW may become a reality, and this depends on are issued by those who patently fail to understand
the CBE, ECSA and the VAs finding common ground these issues.
in the structuring of the policy and its practical
implementation. Currently there are two views on
how it should work.
One, favoured by the CBE, is to ascribe competency
Produced by:
Official Publication of
PROMECH PUBLISHING, THE SA INSTITUTION OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
P O Box 373, Pinegowrie, 2123 and endorsed by:
Republic of South Africa
Tel: (011) 781-1401, Fax: (011) 781-1403 CORROSION INSTITUTE OF SA
Email: editorial@promech.co.za SA PUMP MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION
Website: www.promech.co.za SA VALVE AND ACTUATORS MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION
Managing Editor Susan Custers THE SA INSTITUTE OF TRIBOLOGY
Editor Kowie Hamman NUCLEAR INSTITUTE
Advertising Pauline Bouwer SA INSTITUTE FOR NON-DESTRUCTIVE TESTING
Circulation Catherine Macdiva
NATIONAL SOCIETY OF BLACK ENGINEERS
DTP Zinobia Docrat/Sanette Lehanie
INSTITUTE FOR CERTIFICATED MECHANICAL AND
Disclaimer ELECTRICAL ENGINEERS
PROMECH Publishing and The South African Institution of Mechanical
SOUTH AFRICAN ASSOCIATION OF CONSULTING ENGINEERS
Engineering as well as any other body do not take responsibility for
the opinions expressed by individuals. ASSOCIATION OF SOCIETIES FOR OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY
Printed by: Typo Colour Printing, Tel: (011) 402-3468/9 AND HEALTH
2010 Challenge
2009 was another exciting and vibrant year
Council 2009/2010 for the Technology Olympiad. Not only is the
Office Bearers programme reaching more learners but it’s
President .................................................. G Barbic (George) also working closely with the educators and
President Elect ............................................. D Findeis (Dirk) the Department of Education to increase its
National Treasurer ................................. K Nyangoni (Kudzai)
footprint across South Africa.
Branch Chairpersons
S
Central ...................................................... M Cramer (Mike) AIMechE’s Technology Olympiad is fast
Eastern Cape ............................. Prof Dr DG Hattingh (Danie) becoming the only Technology awareness
KwaZulu/Natal ........................................... AG Fileczki (Alex) programme that schools can offer to learn-
Western Cape ......................... Prof B Collier-Reed (Brandon)
ers wishing to take technology subjects that
Portfolios: are free of charge to all participants.
Communications .............................................. CD Reay (Chris) Learners participating stand to gain a greater under-
Education - Universities................... Prof JL van Niekerk (Wikus) standing of the important underpinning principles
Education: Universities of Technology............... E Zawilska (Ewa) of mechanical engineering. At the same time,
Membership .................................................... E Zawilska (Ewa)
participants learn to co-operate as part of a team
Seminars and Workshops.................................. D Findeis (Dirk)
while they find a feasible solution to the challenge
Technology Programme ................................. SZ Hrabar (Steve)
set each year.
Chief Executive Officer: Vaughan Rimbault Encouraged to take up a career in one of
National Office Manager: Anisa Nanabhay the many disciplines of engineering
PO Box 511, Bruma, 2026
Tel: (011) 615-5660, Fax: (011) 388-5356 Advice to educators
Email: info@saimeche.org.za The Technology Olympiad provides workshops
Website: www.saimeche.org.za through appointed facilitators, at no charge.
Membership: Central, Eastern Cape & KZN: Guidance and advice to schools is also offered to
membership@saimeche.org.za educators. Through these workshops, the learn-
Membership: Western Cape: saimeche.wc@vodamail.co.za ers are instructed in presentation, report writing
Company Affiliates
Alstom Power Service SA
Babcock Africa Limited 2010 Challenge
Bateman Engineered Technologies Design and build a self-powered ball-shooter
Fluor SA that can travel from the start area to the shoot-
GEA Air-cooled Systems ing area and shoot a tennis ball at the goals
Hansen Transmissions SA without human intervention. The power source
Hatch Africa of the ball-shooter may be mechanical, gravity,
Howden Power pneumatic, hydraulic or any combination of
Industrial Water Cooling these.
KHD Humboldt Wedag SA
Megchem Eng & Drafting Services Invitations to par-
Osborn Engineered Products SA ticipate in the
Rotek Engineering 2010 chal-
RSD a division of DCD-Dorbyl lenge were
S.A.M.E Water mailed in
Sasol Technologies Januar y to
SEW Eurodrive approximate-
Siemens Ltd ly 8 000 high
SNC-Lavalin SA
schools offer-
Spicer Axle SA
Spirax Sarco SA ing Mathemat-
Thyssenkrupp Engineering ics, Science and
Transvaal Pressed Nuts & Bolts Technology at a grade
Ultra-Flow Engineering Services 10-12 level. We look forward to working closely
Vital Engineering with the donors, sponsors, schools, DST and
Weir Warman Africa Department of Education this year.
Winder Controls
A
lthough many Korea
of these mov- During the Korean War, for
ies play off instance, the North Kore-
during WWII ans failed to adequately
when U-boats were a defend against the Inchon
relatively new thing, Invasion in mid-September
the concept of min- 1950, but they were not to
ing rivers, harbours be caught out twice. Their
and bays to prevent Soviet supporters provided
access by the enemy thousands of sea mines,
dates back to the 17th plus technical advisors,
century, and is still very and very soon, several
USA and South Korean
Allowed countries without much Navy ships struck mines
of a navy to protect themselves off their east coast.
against invasion via their The threat of mines proved
waterways to be a serious problem for
the US Navy throughout
much general practice
the conflict. In mid-Oc-
today. The simplicity of
tober 1950, with winter
naval mine technology
fast approaching, they
has allowed countries
urgently needed supplies
without much of a
for their men and equip-
navy in terms of frig-
ment. Roads were in dis-
ates and submarines
What the first repair from heavy bombing
to protect themselves Naval mines against the retreating North
against invasion via looked like Korean Army, and rail links
their waterways.
were virtually unusable. Supply by sea through the under water. The water tamped the explosive, so
port city of Chinnampo was the only possibility. that the greatest force of the explosion was directed
The port’s approaches, however, were known to be against the boat.
heavily mined and opening the port became one
How it works
of the top military priorities. History has it that an
Sea mines are known to the general public as con-
US Navy admiral wired Washington: “We have lost
tact mines, those spiky balls moored just under the
control of the seas to a nation without a Navy, using
pre-World War I weapons, laid by vessels that were
Nobody can really account for exactly where all those
utilised at the time of the birth of Christ..”
mines are
Still a threat
Today, naval mines, whether they’re
built with sophisticated electronics or
simple ‘home-made’ technology, are still
one of the best ways of protecting shore
areas from invasion via the open sea.
To understand more about the domain
of underwater security, “SA Mechanical
Engineer” visits a division of Armscor
Business, the Institute for Maritime
Technology (IMT), in Simonstown to talk
to their development manager Mackenzie
Johnson.
“To build a missile and use it you need
expensive sophisticated technology and
equipment, but a naval anti-ship mine
can easily be built by anyone with ac-
cess to explosives and some electronics
knowledge” he says.
“The sea mine is still far and away one
of the most real threats across the world
today especially because of the large
numbers around,” Mackenzie says. “When
the Iron Curtain fell it was estimated that A fish-eye view of a mine field
Russia’s arsenal alone had between 250
000 and 425 000 naval mines. Today
nobody can really account for exactly
where all those mines are.“
History
Mine warfare as we know it today began
in 1776 when David Bushnell invented
the ‘Bushnell’s Keg’. This primitive mine
was composed of a watertight keg filled
with black powder and a flintlock detona-
tor which was suspended from a float.
These kegs were placed in the Delaware
River so that, it was hoped, they would
float into British ships downriver. These
early mines were called torpedoes as self-
propelled torpedoes as we know them
today had not yet been invented.
In 1829, a 14-year-old Yankee inventor
named Sam Colt demonstrated how an
underwater powder charge could be
set off by electricity. The demonstration
did not increase young Colt’s popularity
because onlookers were showered with
muddy water. However, Colt showed how
devastating a small explosive charge
could be when exploded against a boat A popular anti-ship mine
Not Just
Commodities
Newly-appointed President of Cesa (Consult-
ing Engineers SA), Zulch Lötter, says that the
presidency of Cesa is the most important office
he has held outside of UWP Consulting and he
regards it as a great honour to be able to plough
back into an industry in which he has been ac-
tive for close to 40 years.
I
n this role he aims
to focus on improv-
ing the business
environment for
consulting engineers.
It is important to him
that both Cesa mem-
bers as well as their
clients conduct busi-
ness with integrity
and in a professional
manner. He strongly
believes that consult-
ing engineers should
not be perceived by
clients and the public
as commodities, but
Zulch Lötter as their trusted advi-
sors.
To this end, Cesa and its members must engage with
politicians and decision makers to guide, advise and
assist them in creating a sustainable South Africa where
all our inhabitants work towards the common goal of
creating a future for our children.
Zulch was involved with the planning, design, rehabilita-
tion and construction of roads and runways, as well as
traffic engineering. Since 1984 Zulch has been a partner
and later a Director of UWP Consulting. In April 1999
he was appointed Managing Director of the company,
responsible for approximately 300 staff members situated
in 16 offices across South Africa, as well as subsidiary
offices in Zambia, Tanzania and Botswana. Zulch has
served on the CESA Council and EXCO since 2003.
He has been Chairman of CESA’s National Liaison, Finance
and Staff as well as Disciplinary committees. He is also
a Director of two of the Section 21 companies created
by CESA including the Project Development Facilitation
Alliance (PDFA) as well as the Built Environment Profes-
sionals Export Council (BEPEC).
Graham Pirie, Consulting Engineers South Africa (CESA), Tel:
(011) 463-2022, Email: gspirie@cesa.co.za
Focus on
Cutting,
Welding, and
Fabrication
F
rom 16 - 18 March 2010, the 4th Subsahara Oil &
Gas and Petrochem exhibition and conference – Oil
& Gas Africa – will be co-located with the 13th Fish
& Marine Africa expo for the first time.
As both the offshore oil industry and the marine industry
are high users of welding, cutting, and fabrication technol-
ogy, these combined events are showcasing a pavilion of
relevant products and services called: “Focusing on cutting,
welding and fabrication”.
Co-Generation
In a sugar processing plant there are hundreds of electric motors for fans, conveyors, compactors and pumps,
all using electricity. But sugarcane processing produces a high percentage of fibre waste called bagasse
which, in countries like Brazil, is widely used to generate the electricity used by these motors.
B
agasse fuel is renewable and the gases Using waste
it produces (essentially CO2) are more As a supplier of a large percentage of drives to the
than used up by the new cane growing sugarcane processing industry, Zest saw the Brazil-
in the fields. ian technology as an opportunity to offer the South
African sugar industry a similar solution.
Very flexible and can be adapted to
operate with other fuels as well
“SA Mechanical Engineer” speaks to Coenraad
Vrey, managing director of Zest Energy to learn
more. “Zest has traditionally supplied every-
thing from electric motors through to variable
speed drives, transformers, cabling and
electrical installation work, but we
did not have anything to offer on
the power generation side,” he
says. “We therefore established
Zest Energy and entered into an
agreement with a Brazilian com-
pany, TGM, to bring their technol-
ogy of co-generation, specifically
developed for the sugar industry
in Brazil over the past ten years,
to South Africa.
Total solution
“As a result, we can now sup-
ply everything from the drives
through to the complete power
generation plant to make a sugar
processing plant self-sufficient
and much more efficient from an
environmental point of view,” adds
Coenraad. “TGM manufactures a
complete power generation system
including the steam turbines and
planetary gearboxes which they
manufacture in-house. This means
that we will be able to ‘customise’
every installation to the exact
speed reduction and turbine
pressures for each individual
application, whether it is a sugar
processing plant, a steel mill or
a paper processing plant.
Coenraad elaborates, “One of
Zest’s technology suppliers, WEG,
has been supplying 90% of
TGM’s requirements in terms
of the alternator and electrical
reticulation equipment to support
the operation of the steam turbine
unit that they manufacture. graded to the higher pressure needed for turbine
This now gives Zest Energy power generation.”
access to this technology
Feeding the grid
and many years of expertise,
Essentially, the process involves the burning of
thereby allowing us to bring
bagasse to generate steam, which in turn generates
proven technology to South
electricity for all the plant equipment.
Africa.”
TGM’s steam power generation system is very
Electric motors flexible and can be adapted to operate with other
The steam turbine units TGM fuels as well. “Many sugar processing plants also
manufacture can generate produce ethanol which can be used as a fuel,”
up to 150 MW and for more says Coenraad. “Normally sugarcane estates only
power, units can easily be have accessible bagasse for about eight months of
combined to increase the the year. To deliver constant power, we can now
output. “In Brazil, the sugar install dual boilers that can also run on coal for
industry alone generates those short periods when no bagasse is available.
about 80% of the energy In Brazil this translates to 97% power generation
required by the industry,” availability throughout the year, which is what we
Coenraad Vrey, managing director of Zest
says Coenraad, “which is are now offering the local market.”
Energy why we are focussing on
the African sugar industry Other applications
Zest is not limited to providing equipment and
You cannot simply adjust a furnace to use less energy solutions for the sugar industry only. They are also
targeting industries that simply cannot scale down
as a start. In Brazil all the steam-driven mills and on the consumption of electricity. “You cannot sim-
centrifuges on the sugar processing plants have ply adjust a furnace to use less energy. For these
been converted to more effective electrical drives, industries, it will become more difficult to afford
while the steam generation plants have been up- electricity as the tariffs increase and high penalties
start being introduced in the future,” says Coenraad.
“In the case of a furnace, for
example, we can take the gas
from that furnace, clean it
and then use it as a fuel in
a co-generation configura-
tion. The gas from a 20MW
furnace could comfortably
generate between 5 to 7 MW
of electrical energy.”
Small steam power gen-
eration and co-generation
technology is not new to
South Africa, but it has
not been readily available
until now. “The advantage
of dealing with Zest is
that we now offer a total
in-house solution, where
we not only supply the mo-
tors, but all the mechanical
and electrical equipment
as well,” says Coenraad
in conclusion. “All these
systems are configurable to
specific industries and their
individual requirements and
are backed up by the expe-
rience and expertise of our
Brazilian counterparts.”
Coenraad Vrey, Zest Energy,
Tel: (011) 723-6000, Email:
coenraadv@zestenergy.co.za
Controlling
Drives
Lower cost variable speed units can be economically used to
replace mechanical damping units, manage air and fluid flows
with integrated PID, so reducing energy costs. It is however
necessary to look at the complete system in order to achieve
the required results.
S
A Mechanical Engineer” speaks to Marcus
Gericke, Gauteng branch manager at SA Marcus Gericke of SA Power
Power, a company that offers a full range of
mechanical and electrical products as well
we have Lenze gearboxes that cater for the smaller
as the design capability to optimise drive solutions
industry up to 45Kw. With Vogel we can cater for
for various applications. “On the mechanical side
medium sized applications ranging from bevel
gearboxes of 0.5 Nm to large planetary gearboxes
rated for 400kW,” he says.
Savings
The company is busy with a multi-stage project
where IP65 inverters are installed on motors at
a plant in KZN to improve the energy consump-
tion of the plant. This is being achieved by
replacing throttling valves used to regulate flow
by reducing motor speeds, This has resulted in
reduced mechanical wear on the pumps and less
strain on the motors caused by lower current
requirements. “Taking all of these actions into
account, the actual saving by the customer is
A complete drive installed not only in electricity but also in maintenance
costs as well,” adds Marcus.
area,” says Marcus.
“Energy saving is not as easy as just installing
“For many industries, we can design, engineer VSD’s. You need to take into account many factors
and supply all the drive systems they may need that change from company to company, application
including gearboxes, motors and control systems to application. Thinking about it, we have, in fact,
needed to improve efficiencies. We can integrate been doing energy saving for many years now by
with many control systems that are in the field designing our systems correctly, by using the best
today and work with customers to ensure energy suited products for the job, be it synchronous motors
efficient systems”. to soft starters. Each project has its unique design
features that must be taken into account and an
Obstacles can be overcome and these drives can be “energy saving drive solution” needs to be made.
replaced with VSD’s
Gearbox
VSD The overall energy efficiency of a drive train is,
In the past, variable speed drives were big and however, not only dependent on the motor efficiency
bulky, but with ever improving technology the and its control. The choice of gearbox used in the
components used have become smaller and in turn system is as important. Explains Marcus, “Usually
have resulted in smaller AC drives. people first ask after the price when it comes to
“We assist customers by doing a site analyses to the gearbox, but if you compare a low-cost worm
determine the exact power requirements for each gearbox with an efficiency of 50 to 60% to that of
application. We use Lenze software called “drive a moderately priced helical-bevel gearbox at 97%
solution designer” that incorporates and takes into efficiency, the cheaper gearbox wastes a lot of energy
due to the losses within.” Further improvements
in efficiency are achieved if a smaller motor and
gearbox can be used thanks to the improved
efficiency of the gearbox. In the end it all boils
down to designing the drive train optimally for
each specific application. For instance hydraulic
drives are well known for their comparatively
low efficiencies and hydraulic oil is hazardous
to the environment. Advances in electric drive
technology have meant that in many cases these
obstacles can be overcome and these drives can
be replaced with VSD’s.
“The crux of the matter is; design your drive
system correctly and incorporate energy saving
drive solutions from the start and your footprint
will be greener,” Marcus says in conclusion.
Marcus Gericke, SA Power, Tel: (011) 908-7060, Email:
marcus@sapower.co.za
Drive control
C
ompared with the rapid evolution of auto-
mated handling systems and robots, AGVs
seem to have lagged behind a bit in some
countries, but this does not mean the de-
velopment of technology has stagnated altogether.
While conveyors and lift trucks are the most com- Willem Prinsloo of Varic
mon handling solutions in warehousing as well as
in manufacturing plants, automatic guided vehicles The vehicle communicates with the main controlling
are increasingly becoming a viable alternative in PLC system on a continuous basis while continu-
both of these situations. ously reporting back to the system on, for example,
its battery condition.
Ultimate solution because it eliminates human presence
from high security areas Artificial intelligence
“In plain language, an AGV will, for instance, get to
In South Africa there have been a couple of AGV a station and tell the system: I am AGV 3, I have
installations in both the manufacturing and ware- completed my delivery to dispatch, my battery
housing environments. To learn more about these is still fine, standing by. The AGV will then wait
and the latest technology available, “SA Mechanical there until the system tasks it for the next job,”
Engineer” meets with Willem Prinsloo of Varic. explains Willem.
“Apart from our original installation at SA Mint’s “At the point when it reports that its battery is low,
plant, we also installed AGVs at an engine as- the system will instruct the AGV to go to the battery
sembly plant and some for the handling of large bay for either a recharge or a freshly-charged bat-
rolls of paper,” he says. “The installation at the SA tery replacement. Today we even have technology
Mint, in terms of security, is the ultimate solution which allows the battery to be recharged without
because it eliminates human presence from high attaching any cables. The AGV will simply park
security areas. on a spot where high induction coils are embed-
O
TH
R
AN
S
ES
IM
AL R
S I N DIS T
SO
CI ETY
FO
SHOW THEM YOU CARE BY MAKING A MONTHLY DONATION! SO
CI ETY F
O
E
E
TH
R
R
TH
As little as R50 a month, or whatever you can comfortably afford, can make a BIG difference in an animal’s life.
S
S
AN
AN
ES
ES
M
R
IM
AL AL
I
R
S I N DIS T S I N DIS
NAME : ______________________________________________________________________________________________
Transforming
There are still many commodities that South
Africa has to import which makes us
vulnerable when there are shortfalls. A few
years ago, violent storms in the USA directly
affected the production of the base oils that
the Market
are used to make transformer oil, rapidly
leading to a serious shortage in South Africa at
a time when demand was particularly high in
the power distribution industry.
A
midst this shortage, Engen decided to
do something about it by investigating
the possibility of entering the market by
producing this precious commodity using
imported ingredients combined with the flexibility
of local blending to produce various grades.
Oil plant
“SA Mechanical Engineer” speaks to Anton Allner,
industrial lubricants strategy manager at Engen. “At
the time there were only two suppliers of transformer
oil in South Africa and when it became scarce, it was
really difficult for us to fulfil the demand from our
customers while at the same time competing with
these suppliers on the local market,” he explains.
One of our two lube oil blend plants in Durban had Anton Allner, industrial lubricants strategy manager
capacity to produce transformer oil on a small scale, at Engen
but lacked the technology and capacity to produce
higher volumes. “We partnered with Apar Industries The oil
in India and began the process two years ago to Transformer oil, or insulating oil, is a highly-refined
start producing enough transformer oil to at least mineral oil that is stable at high temperatures and
keep our existing customers wet”. has excellent electrical insulating properties. It is
used in oil-filled transformers, some types
of high voltage capacitors, fluorescent lamp
ballasts, and some types of high voltage
switches and circuit breakers.
It functions to insulate, suppress corona
and arcing. The oil also helps to cool the
transformer. Because it also provides
part of the electrical insulation between
internal live parts, transformer oil must
remain stable at high temperatures for
an extended period.
To improve cooling of large power trans-
formers, the oil-filled tank may have
external radiators through which the oil
circulates by natural convection. Very
large or high-power transformers may
also have cooling fans, oil pumps, and
even oil-to-water heat exchangers.
Growth
“When the expansion in the power gen-
eration industry started we decided to
address lubricant needs in this industry
The transformer oil plant sector specifically by establishing FluidLink
Tackling Tribology
Greening Challenges
Tribology is an ancient science but was only recently defined
are aware of. Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs)
in the mid-sixties by Dr H Peter Jost. It’s the study of fric-
are a class of organic compounds with 1 to 10
tion and wear that goes well beyond lubrication to include chlorine atoms attached to biphenyl, which is a
the properties and nature of the surfaces that are rubbing to- molecule composed of two benzene rings. The
gether. We require friction – either increased or minimised– in chemical formula for PCBs is C12H10-xClx, where
every aspect of our lives, such as vehicle braking systems or x = 1-10. PCBs were widely used for many
the rolling resistance that a tyre pattern creates. Tribological applications, especially as dielectric fluids in
output is wear, heat and waste by-products. And a sound prin- transformers and capacitors and coolants. Due
ciple of well-applied tribology is that less is more. One litre of to PCB’s toxicity and classification as persistent
used oil has the potential to contaminate one million litres of organic pollutants, PCB production was banned
water. by the United States Congress in 1976 and by
W
the Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic
ith the environment at the top of the Pollutants in 2001.
agenda, SAIT recently held a one-day It’s no wonder then that Eskom imposed a
seminar at Science Park entitled ‘Lubes trade ban on PCBs in 1977 and has a special-
& The Environment’. Expert subject ist program dealing with this poison. Note that
presenters dealt with topics ranging from managing PCBs are governed by SANS 0290 – a National
used oil in South Africa to micro-dosing lubricants, Standard on the management of polychlorinated
correct lubricant storage and handling, identify- biphenyls, mineral insulating oils. Recently
ing and management of Polychlorinated Biphenyl published in 2007, SANS 0290 provides a na-
(PCB) in insulating oils, low friction bearings and tional best practice guide on the management
energy-savings in hydraulic systems – to name a and phase-out of PCBs in dielectric fluids. This
few of the key issues. indicates the stuff is still out there and waiting
to contaminate unsuspecting handlers.
Only recover an estimated 70% of the 120 million litres
of used oil
MQL – it’s a ‘no-brainer’
ROSE foundation And if you like to believe that less can be more,
The Rose Foundation is Africa’s only used oil recov- then look no further than lubricant micro-dosing.
ery programme ‘ROSE’, which stands for Recycling This subject flies in the face of an African com-
Oil Saves the Environment, is a Section 21 (Non monplace practice of over-lubricating to prevent
profit) company established in 1994 consisting of excessive wear and failure. Micro-dosing is the
19 members from the lubricants Industry. In spite technique whereby minute quantities of lubricant
of their structured efforts at used lubricant recovery, are applied in an industrial operation, leaving an
the Foundation provides a sobering perspective for almost dry product and production environment.
Raj Lochen Micro-dosing is also referred to as “near dry” or
CEO of the ROSE used oil pollution in South Africa.
“Minimum Quantity Lubrication or MQL” or “mist
Foundation “Annually around 300 million litres of new lubri- lubrication”.
cants is sold into the South African market. This in
turn results in approximately 120 million litres of MQL requires special micro-pumps that can deliver
used oil becoming available. The Rose Foundation between 3 and 30 micro-litres per pulse – 30 mi-
through their partners NORA-SA only recover an cro-litres is an average volume of a drop. By adding
estimated 70% of the 120 million litres of used pumps, changing the pulse rate, dosing parameters
oil. 36 million litres of used oil remains to pollute can be established to meet the specific needs of
our waterways and underground water. This is the operation, ie, metalworking, lubrication of
a cumulative problem that will only grow and it bearings, chains, dies etc. Dosing is accompanied
concerns everyone.” by carefully-controlled air to disperse lubricant at
the exact point of lubrication, to blow away chips
PCB what? (metalworking) and to provide cooling of the tool.
On the green front, Polychlorinated Biphenyls
(PCBs) are a whole subject on their own that few Hydraulics – an unexplored frontier
Patrick Swan, CEO of Aswan Consulting, points out
In most cases these energy savings are combined low-friction bearings, effective storage of lubricants
with other performance benefits such as oxidation and becoming 14001 compliant – it’s for serious
stability, wear protection, corrosion resistance and minders of the planet.
improved air release. Case studies have proved that
SAIT has rubbed a vast knowledge surface that
modern, widely cross-graded hydraulic fluids are no
needs cascading into every aspect of life. How to
longer commodity items, but if used correctly, have
get these strong messages into the market – that’s
the capacity to contribute significantly to overall
the challenge!
energy efficiency.
Dave Scott, SAIT Member
Cascading Gill Fuller, Tel: (011) 802-5145, Fax: (011) 804-4972,
And then there are many other savings from using Email: secretary@sait.org.za, www.sait.org.za
No
More
Hassles
Sales engineer Joe Pinheiro (left) and Philip Craig
Considering the cost of capital equipment and the demand for cleaner fuel, fuel suppliers are under pressure
to guarantee quality especially for remote locations where delivery trucks travel hundreds of miles on dirt
roads to the end user. The supply of clean fuel/oil is a problem of the past for many fuel/oil companies, as
they’re using a bulk fuel filtration system developed and built by Operational Marketing in Johannesburg.
S
A Mechanical Engineer” speaks to sales making contaminated diesel a huge problem that
engineers Philip Craig and Joe Pinheiro often affects plant availability,” they say.
about the comprehensive filtration solutions “End-users such as mining companies are increas-
they’re now offering into the fuel/oil industry. ingly demanding a cleaner supply of fuel/oils which
“Today’s engines are much more sophisticated presents a great opportunity for fuel/oil companies
Once water ingress occurs, bacterial growth within the to gain the edge by guaranteeing the delivery of
diesel forms clean product on site.
Dirt
“There are many ways that fuel/oil incurs contamina-
tion, particularly when it’s taken to remote mining
sites by road on rough roads, agitation loosens rust
inside the tank, while dust from the sand roads or
water condensation entering into the tanker is at
times unavoidable.
“For these reasons, we filter the
product on site before it goes
into the storage tanks and,
in some cases, we even filter
it again before it is delivered to
mining equipment or another source of
demand. Another option is to continuously
filter the product in storage through a kidney
circulation / multi-passing system to ensure
acceptable cleanliness levels.”
Know-how
“Each site, environment and system is different
requiring each filtration system to be adapted or
modified accordingly,” both Philip and Joe concur.
“As the sole agents in Africa for the Mahle range
of filters made in Germany, we use their complete
scope of supply on offer to us to provide best cost
The four-way filtration system effective filtration systems. In addition to these
The system
Filtration for diesel starts with a simple manifold design,
incorporating very fine particulate filters followed by
a coalescer and separator filter for water in diesel. A
pre-filter was then included into the system and has
been developed further to a full-on self-containerised
filtration system that is tested and commissioned in
house before being supplied to the client. “This fil-
tration system incorporates a pre-filter that removes
all the coarse particles, followed by a filter manifold
or housing to remove the finer ingress of particles,”
explains Philip.
Enhancements
To ensure the system is more flexible, each filter
manifold is purposely designed to ensure that the inlet
and outlet pipes are symmetrical and can be rotated
180 degrees to accommodate the piping installation
on site. Isolating valves, which are critical, are fitted
to the manifold so the delivery line can be isolated in
order to change filters without stopping the operation
altogether.
A further enhancement is an in-line particle counter
which shows the level of contamination in fuel or oil.
There’s also an in-line filter with a magnetic cartridge
and aluminium housing available for thick oils which
cannot pass through a normal filter cartridge. The
magnetic filter cartridge is re-useable ensuring zero
cost on replacement of spares.
Understanding filters
“In our experience, most systems incorporating filtra-
tion are neglected with regards to maintenance. Filtra-
tion is merely the “kidney” or “liver” in the system,
without this, failure will eventually occur” says Philip
in conclusion.
Philip Craig, Tel: (011) 793-5562, Email: philipc@omsa.
co.za
H
energy consumption.”
owever, it’s not just a matter of choosing a
high efficiency filter. In fact, the pressure Study
drop of a higher efficiency filter is higher He elaborates, “We did a lifecycle cost (LCC) cal-
than a lower efficiency filter which means culation for an air filter and found that between
more energy is used to move the air against the 70 to 80% of the LCC of the filter is actually the
higher resistance of a high efficiency filter. Until now, energy it consumes when the fan has to overcome
there has only been an efficiency classification for its pressure drop. Only 20 to 30% of the cost is
filters, where the higher number indicates more par- related to purchase price, change-out, labour and
ticles being waste management. So, obviously, we tackled
taken out of the matter of filters. As mentioned, there is an
the air, but not efficiency classification for filters according to the
much about various European and American rating standards
optimising which we’ve cross-referenced with the performance
energy con- ratings,” explains Daniel.
sumption. You can select a filter according to
Filtration particle removal efficiency together with
Freudenberg its energy efficiency ratings
Filtration
recognised “Now you can select a filter according to particle
this dilemma removal efficiency together with its energy efficiency
and has come ratings. By selecting a specific energy efficiency
up with a rated filter and combining that with the energy
new system savings of a variable speed controlled fan instead
whereby fil- of the constant speed fans that are still being used
ters are not widely in South Africa, you can comfortably save
only classed between 15 to 20% in energy consumption. This
in pressure has been proven in various ventilation system
drop rang- installations in Europe.”
es, but also Mining
Dr Daniel Schmitt, managing director of Freudenberg Filtra- grouped into Daniel and his team of engineers are taking the
tion in South Africa energy effi- energy efficiency filtration
concept further in terms
of specific industrial ap-
plications in South Africa.
“We’re working closely with
end-users and compressor
OEMs to look at the air in-
take compressors on mines
which is a huge energy
item for them,” he says.
“Up here on the Highveld,
the air is thin to start with
which affects compressor
Energy efficiency for Viledon air filters of Filter Classes G3 to F9 in the first or second filter stage performance. If you also
The particularly energy-efficient Viledon Compact pocket filters and MaxiPleat cassette filters
have an air intake that has a high pressure drop can’t produce a standard reference grid like we did
because the filters are not properly selected, you’re for ventilation applications because each mine is
dramatically reducing the performance of the system different from the next one, so we’re analysing each
in terms of energy consumption. one individually. It depends what they have in place
“The mines, from the cost as well as availability as far as compressors, fans and filtration systems
point of view, are keen to reduce energy consump- are concerned. In these studies we consider all pos-
tion and have been very open to the discussions sibilities that will help to reduce the pressure drop
we’ve had so far,” says Daniel. “In this instance we such as simply making the intakes a little bigger at
the cost of a little bit of sheetmetal work.”
Not as common in South Africa yet as in Europe
New equipment
The very latest they’re working on at Freudenberg’s
workshop in Edenvale is actually building complete
energy-efficient pressurisation units designed for
local conditions. “Basically they are fan-filter units
equipped with variable speed fans, something
not as common in South Africa yet as in Europe,”
explains Daniel.
“We’re in the process of building the first one and
are working closely with a number of fan and electric
motor manufacturers to bring a ‘green’ pressurisation
unit to the market. The unit will come complete
with variable speed fans, the control unit built in
and already equipped with the best filters accord-
ing to the energy classification. It is a concept we
designed locally and each unit will be customised
for each individual application. The first one will
be completed for tests early in 2010.”
Although energy consumption is the hype right
now and shortages appear to have been resolved,
chances are there may very well be shortages again
when the economy picks up again. Daniel says in
conclusion. “Now is the time to familiarise yourself
with the technologies that are already available
to help you. Don’t wait until the crisis hits before
you react.”
Dr Daniel Schmitt, Feudenberg Filtration Technologies,
Tel: (011) 929-4500, Email: daniel.schmitt@freudenberg.
co.za
Travelling-wave Reactor
In Enrico Fermi’s New Piles Committee in the USA at the end by implication, available in quantity.
of WW2, Farrington Daniels, head of metallurgy in the Man- As far as I can gather, there are so far just two
hattan Project, advocated a power reactor system based on 50 MW plants in operation, both rather recently
spherical fuel elements cooled by helium. He later left nuclear commissioned in Spain. Others are on the way.
technology and became a prominent advocate of solar energy. The system is therefore still in the developmental
It’s therefore somehow neat to find Dieter Matzner, formerly stage.
chief engineer with PBMR, now extolling solar energy on be- For South Africa, without external back-up but with
half of Hatch. abundant sunshine and relatively abundant uranium
I
and thorium, solar (with storage) plus nuclear ap-
n Nov/Dec 09 issue, Matzner pear to be the obvious paths to pursue.
presented his vision of our electri-
cal future. Base-load (60%) is to January is a good month for crystal ball gazing and
be shared between coal, nuclear in respect of nuclear also, it seems to me that we
and imported hydro. Mid-merit (30%) are looking at a step change in the technology. As
is to be solar (with energy storage) a result of TMI and Chernobyl, nuclear plateaued
and closed-cycle gas turbines. Daily for some twenty years at around 16% of world
peaks are to be shared by pumped generation. We are now starting to move forward
storage fed possibly by wind genera- again – but there are issues. The safety record
tors, and by the present open cycle is excellent – apart from Chernobyl. But another
gas turbines. One may want to argue, Chernobyl must become inconceivable. Waste is
and the vision will certainly evolve an issue, at least in the public mind, as is the risk
as technologies mature and their of weapons proliferation. All can now be addressed
relative merits – and costs – become by advanced reactor and fuel cycle design. Uranium
apparent, but this surely is the type reserves are limited but, together with thorium, they
John Walmsley can be used vastly more efficiently in advanced
of picture that anyone interested in
energy should have in mind. It’s something tangible designs to the extent that the resource will become
to argue about. virtually infinite.
This schematic diagram shows the positioning of the various elements of one of the turbine hall ventila-
tion systems on any one of Medupi power station’s six generation units
Ventilation contracts
MikroPul of Johannesburg, a member of Actom, was re-
cently awarded its biggest ever HVAC (heating, ventilation
Fast first aid
The Quick Fix Clamp, available from Multotec Wear Linings,
& airconditioning) project by way of two contracts together
provides an appropriate and convenient solution for leaking
worth over R100m.
pipes which demand immediate attention. This innovative
The contracts, for the manufacture and supply of fans and product straps easily around the pipe with the minimum effort
auxiliary equipment for ventilation of all the turbine halls of sealing the leak for later long-term planned repair.
both of Eskom’s new six-
pack 4800 MW coal-fired
power stations, Medupi
and Kusile, were awarded
to MikroPul at the end of
July by Alstom Power, the
manufacturer and supplier
of the turbines for both
plants.
In bidding for these prized
contracts MikroPul faced
competition from a host of
other reputable companies,
including several interna-
tional contenders. However
Alstom Power found it to
have the requisite expertise
and track record for project
managing contracts of
similar magnitude.
“Although these are the
largest HVAC contracts The Quick Fix Clamp, available from Multotec Wear Linings, provides an appropriate and convenient
we have won to date, we solution for leaking pipes which demand immediate attention
c l ive t s
c y el u c
ry
are resistant to ag- energy savings of 35%. The
C er d r o d
gressive chemicals entire range has been equipped
VA t p
e
H wa f
e g ro
and guarantees that with new saver cycles on both fan
t h gin b e
o f na u m
the production process and dryer, increasing the average
ts a n
energy savings even further.
en m a
respects the natural en-
m in e d
vironment. l e ole o p More Flexibility
l e r el
a l ey v
h a k de
folio of pumps for HVAC include GA 5-11/GA 5-15 VSD Premium-range. The GA
r o la h
th t p ra
the FC Series pumps used mostly in Workplace Concept is reinforced with noise levels
th o w a
commercial HVAC applications which starting from 60 dB(A)*. This GA-range is the most
L
a
incorporate the Hydrovar. silent in the complete Atlas Copco GA-portfolio, allowing
Lowara can provide a wide range of pumps for installation close to the point of use. Installation cost
that create an end-to-end water solution not only for HVAC is further minimized by extending the standard operating
building services, but all applications including water sup- range to up to 46° Celcius, making a dedicated compressor
ply, wastewater pumps, borehole or submersible pumps, room unnecessary.
and fire-fighting systems. More VSD models, including a tank-mounted GA 15 VSD
The Hydrovar variable speed controller is a great example
of realising energy efficiency. By varying pump speed
with demand, savings in pump power usage combine
with longer pump reliability for a lower life cost across
commercial and domestic HVAC applications.
Lanelle Wheeler, ITT Water & Wastewater, Tel: (011) 966-
9300, www.flygt.co.za
Hands-free
SKF’s laser-based and wireless shaft alignment tool,
Fixturlaser Upad, is the first tool of its kind that is
truly portable.
“The wireless display unit is worn on the arm; the
user therefore has his hands free and can work in
complete freedom,” explains David Ramnath, SKF
South Africa’s Business Development Manger, Reli-
ability Systems.
David continues, “It may be small in size, but it can
handle everything that its big brother, the award-
winning shaft alignment tool Fixturlaser XA, can do,
ranging from advanced shaft alignment applications
to geometric measurements. The user interface guides
the user during the entire measurement and align-
ment process by using color-coded measurement
values, icons, and arrows. These units also have a
touch screen, which makes it easier for the user to
navigate through functions.”
“The consumer market for electronics has long been
driven by making products smaller and portable. Elos
Fixturlaser, with 25 years of experience in developing
laser-based system for alignment of rotating machinery,
considers it is high time that the maintenance sector
benefits from this development, and SKF South Africa
BMG’s comprehensive range of Tsubaki chain products includes low noise is in full agreement,” elaborates David.
drive chain that combats noise pollution, ensuring an improvement in the work Elos Fixturlaser are also proud to be the only manu-
environment. SN roller chain can be used in applications where the strength
of a roller chain is required, without the accompanying noise. The low noise
facturer of laser based shaft alignment tools with
SN series is fully interchangeable with standard roller chain a measurement method for Fixturlaser UPAD that
Ndumiso Kubeka and George Iliev from Munitech interpret a filed correlation as part of Munitech’s
leak detection programme, which is designed to improve water loss management throughout South-
ern Africa
Subscription
Please fax us if you wish to subscribe to “SA Mechanical En-
gineer” at R375,00 (incl postage and VAT) per year; R875,00
per year for Africa/Overseas. We will post you an invoice on
receipt of your fax.
Gavin Phillips Jacky Wilson Sabelo Shabalala
PROMECH PUBLISHING Fax No: (011) 781-1403
Bosch Projects (Pty)
Ltd, part of the B & From:......................................................................................
A Group, has made
(insert your name)
the following ap-
pointments: Andy Title: ......................................................................................
Church is business
manager, agricul- Company: ..............................................................................
Christo van Rooyen Gert van den Berg ture; Deric Dignon
is process engineer; Address: ...............................................................................
and Mzingaye Mthethwa is senior mechanical engineer.
...............................................................................................
Gavin Phillips has joined Metric Automotive Engineering
as the company’s IPD parts specialist. IPD products are ...................................................................Code: ..................
Caterpillar replacement parts which are manufactured in a
quality controlled environment. Telephone: ( ) ....................................................................
The Omsa Group of companies has appointed Jacky Wilson Fax: ( ) ................................................................................
as their internal sales representative specifically to handle
the valve sector of the group. Email:.....................................................................................
The following new staff have joined SEW Eurodrive: Sabelo
Shabalala as internal sales engineer (Pinetown branch),
Christo van Rooyen as sales engineer for the Pietersburg Index to Advertisers
area as well as Gert van den Berg as sales engineer for the
Northern Cape region. Association of Arbitrators 19
AST Inside Front Cover