Haas VF3 vs.

Doosan DNM 5700

APT Machine Tools

(321)280-2482 | www.aptmtools.com | 4180 St. Johns Parkway, Sanford, FL 32771
 UNDER THE HOOD
VF casting
14,330 lbs
12,474 lbs

2
BASIC CONSTRUCTION
HAAS VF platform Doosan DNM platform

Still
using a
counter
balance
for Z
axis.

3
HAAS COUNTERBALANCE

4
HAAS SPINDLE
Every spindle
drawing I was
able to get
was slightly
different.
When I read
chat online,
the common
complaint was
the tools
wearing at the
large end of
the taper.

5
SPINDLE CONSTRUCTION
Haas Spindle
DNM Spindle
 Two Double angle
contact bearings  Four
at the spindle double
nose and two Ball angle
bearings at the top contact
end of the spindle. bearings.
 This means there  Two
is only one bearings
bearing to handle to handle
the end load / the end
thrust from drilling load /
thrust
from
drilling.

6
 ROLLER –VS- BALL TYPE LM GUIDE

Haas:
Ball Type LM Guide

DNM:
Roller Type
LM Guide
7
 2-1 High RIGIDITY and More DURABLE

DNM
Guide Ways Wider Guide LM Ways and Ball Screws for GREATER RIGIDITY.

Haas Mori Seiki Mazak DOOSAN

VF Series Dura Vertical VC Smart DNM

Guide Way Ball+Roller Roller Roller Roller

Type

LM Guide X: 1.26” (32mm) X: 1.34” (34mm) X: 1.34” (34mm) X: 1.37” (34mm)

Width Y: 1.26” (32mm) Y: 1.34” (34mm) Y: 1.34” (34mm) Y: 1.77” (45mm)
Z: 1.26” (32mm) Z: 1.77” (45mm) Z: 1.34” (34mm) Z: 1.77” (45mm)

Ball Screw X: 1.26” (32mm) X: 1.42” (36mm) X: 1.42” (36mm) X: 1.57” (40mm)
Dia. X/Y/Z Y: 1.26” (32mm) Y: 1.42” (36mm) Y: 1.42” (36mm) Y: 1.57” (40mm)
Z: 1.26” (32mm) Z: 1.77” (45mm) Z: 1.42” (36mm) Z: 1.57” (40mm)
9
 Doosan
Z AXIS BALL SCREW
Haas

Double anchored

Pre-tensioned
NOT pre-tensioned

10
 X & Y BALL SCREWS
Doosan DNM

Haas Axis configuration:

All 3 axis are only Double Anchored
not pre-tensioned.

Pre-tensioned
11
ADJUSTING THE HAAS ATC

12
THERMAL COMPENSATION
Haas Thermal Comp

Doosan DNM Thermal Comp

The Pre-Tensioned ball screws are “stretched” to the warm state so Thermal
comp can be eliminated. The DNM Series use a Sensorless type
compensation which is established at the factory and creating a Matrix for each
model based on testing over a long period of time in the “Reliability bay” shown
on the next page. No Operator intervention is required.

13
 TEMPERATURE CONTROLLED
TESTING ROOM
This room is used to test
and map the thermal growth
and straightness deviation
from extreme temperature
swings from an ambient
temperature of 70 degrees.

 There are 5 Thermal

Compensation types
used by Doosan
1) Active Cooling via oil
cooler / heat exchanger
2) Sensor type
3) Sensor less type
4) Straightness
compensation

14
 BALL BAR EXPECTATIONS
Haas VF Ball Bar from new machine

Reading news groups, the largest complaint among

Haas users concerning accuracy is Squareness. This
one is at 41% of the top 5 issues.
Circularity is .0010”

DNM650II actual
measured
results.
15
STANDARD USA SPEC
DNM5700 Standard USA Spec
 Big Plus spindle
 8k,12k or 15k Spindle
 30 or 40 Side Mount Atc
 230 psi Coolant through Spindle
 Probe ready system (minus probe)
 Cabinet cooler
 Chip augers
 Dynamic work offsets & TCP
 G30 & G30P3, P4
 AICC 20 block look ahead
 Remote MPG
 Work light and 3 color tower signal light
 Cyclonic coolant filter
 Oil Skimmer
 2 year warranty (Haas option for 2nd year)
 Tool Load Monitoring
 Adaptive Control
 EZ Guide i Programming & Operation

16
BASIC SPECS

17
CONTROL PANELS

 Mylar cover, wears from use then leaks

coolant onto pcb underneath.
 No Override knobs, step up/down by
pressing the button many times.
Operators hate this.  Standard QWERTY keyboard
 No QWERTY keyboard  Hard buttons
 Feedrate Override knobs
 Hot Keys
18
HAAS CONTROL - PROGRAMMING

19
 3-1 USER FRIENDLY and More Convenient Features

DNM
Control New Control offers several User Friendly Features as Standard.
(Overview)

USB & PCMCIA Card Ports

10.4” Color LCD

Easy Operation Pkg. Software

QWERTY keyboard

HOT Keys
SCREEN SHOTS

21
SCREEN SHOTS

Position & Program Check

22
SCREEN SHOTS

Offset & Tool Life management

23
SCREEN SHOTS
Big Tool / Tool condition
&
Adaptive machining control

24
SCREEN SHOTS

Probing Bore & Slot

25
SCREEN SHOTS

Probing Surface

26
SCREEN SHOTS
Probing for B axis alignment
&
Web or 2 point centering

27
SCREEN SHOTS
Status & ATC Maintenance mode
for recovery

28
1-1. Doosan Adaptive Feedrate Control (DAFC)

DNM (8,000rpm) Standard Control Feature

DNM II (8,000rpm) is equipped with exceptional control feature that

significantly improves efficiency (standard feature)

Adaptive Feedrate Control:

• Monitors the amount of spindle load to adjust feedrate adaptively
• When cutting conditions favorable, NC increases feedrate to reduce cycle
time
• Results an Improved Cycle Time & Cutting Process Protection due to
Optimized Machining Conditions
2-1. Big Plus Standard

DNM 8,000rpm

Standard Big Plus on all DNM Series provides better machining

performance

Big Plus: Dual (Taper & Face)

Contact offers up to 40%
additional Radial Rigidity
• Better finishes
• Greater Stock Removal Rates
• More Accurate Boring
• Less Blending

Big Plus w/o Big Plus

CONCLUSION APT Machine Tools
 Pre-tensioned ball screws
 Big Plus two face contact spindle
 Probe ready
 Oil skimmer
 Adaptive feed control
 Tool load monitoring with “no Load”
 Tighter ball bar spec
 EZ Guide
 EZ OP Operator assistance
 Built to stand the test of time

(321)280-2482 | www.aptmtools.com | 4180 St. Johns Parkway, Sanford, FL 32771

31