Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
RECRUITMENT
towards a career in psychiatry
before and after viewing a
promotional DVD
Tasha Robertson, Garry Walter, Nerissa Soh, Glenn Hunt,
Michelle Cleary and Gin Malhi
doi: 10.1080/10398560902874298
# 2009 The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists 311
psychiatry trainees reflects diminishing interest themes that emerged were the ‘‘limitations of treat-
among medical students and junior doctors.1,2 This ment, lack of funding and the ‘unscientific’ nature of
has also been evident overseas; for example, an psychiatry’’ (p. 731).8 Wigney and Parker’s 2008 study
American study by Feifel and colleagues3 reported ‘‘a suggested that the positive factors influencing medical
distinct decline over the past two decades in the students to become psychiatrists included financial
attraction of freshman medical students to careers in and lifestyle advantages, the challenging nature of the
psychiatry’’ (p. 1400), with most entering medical work, and stimulating research opportunities.2
school with a negative attitude toward psychiatry In light of the current shortage of psychiatrists and
compared with other medical careers. trainees, and the image problem contributing to the
The Australian Medical Workforce Advisory Commit- lack of interest among medical students, in 2008 the
tee (AMWAC)4 in 1999 published a review of psychia- Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychia-
try training and recommended that the number of first trists (RANZCP) and the Australian Government’s
year trainees increase to 131. However, over the past Department of Health and Ageing released a promo-
few years the number of first-year psychiatry trainees tional DVD designed to attract potential trainees to a
has not reached the AMWAC target. career in psychiatry.9 The DVD, titled Psychiatry: A
Better Understanding, aims to address the misconcep-
The ongoing difficulty recruiting into psychiatry has
tions of the current student population by helping to
led to several studies to identify reasons for the lack of
dispel the stigma surrounding mental disorders, and to
interest in the profession as a career choice among
provide better information about the benefits of a
medical students. Malhi et al.1 and Feifel et al.3
career in psychiatry by reinforcing its positive attri-
identified two important factors that influence pro-
butes. This could be of significant benefit to the
gression from medical school to psychiatry trainee.
profession considering that Malhi et al. found nearly
The first is the stigma surrounding psychiatry among
one in six first-year Australian medical students were
medical students, and the second entails views such as
‘‘open to the possibility of pursuing a career in psy-
the perceived absence of a scientific foundation and
chiatry’’ (p. 420).1
the limitations of psychiatric treatment. Malhi et al.
looked at medical student attitudes before clinical Recruitment strategies like this DVD are supported by
exposure and reported that students attracted to a recent study by Thomas, which examined psychiatry
psychiatry considered the specialty an interesting and trainees’ reasons for choosing psychiatry and their
intellectually challenging field, with high job satisfac- satisfaction with opportunities within the field.10 The
tion and ‘‘an enjoyable job’’.1 study reported that once trainees became involved in
the training program, over 80% were satisfied with
A few reportse.g.5,6 have suggested that the stigma and their choice of career and positive about career
misconceptions surrounding psychiatry can be chan- opportunities within the specialty. More than two-
ged by illustrating the positive attributes of the speci- thirds of trainees identified a general interest in the
alty to medical students and junior medical officers, area, enjoyable clinical experience, good work-life
especially through their clinical experience. The posi- balance and patient contact as positive aspects.
tive features of a career in psychiatry that have been
identified by these studies, and that need to be The aim of our study is, first, to determine current
reinforced, include lifestyle factors, flexible hours, attitudes towards psychiatry as a career among medical
patient interaction, psychiatry’s intellectually challen- students enrolled at the University of Sydney, and,
ging nature, the holistic approach to assessment and second, to establish the immediate impact of the DVD,
treatment, and its scientific basis. Research by Psychiatry: A Better Understanding, on medical students’
Manassis et al.7 also emphasizes the importance of attitudes towards a career in psychiatry.
nurturing and encouraging students interested in
. August 2009
Two recent Australian studies by Wigney and Parker2,8 complete an online questionnaire regarding their
questioned senior medical students after their psychia- views and attitudes towards psychiatry. The question-
try rotation about why a career in psychiatry may or naire was voluntary and anonymous. Several of the
items were adapted from similar studies by Feifel et al.3
Australasian Psychiatry .
312
encourage participation. Approximately 30 minutes Overall, being an internal medicine specialist (physi-
was required to complete the survey; this included cian) was rated the most likely career, with 85 (69.1%)
15 minutes viewing the DVD. students indicating this as a chosen/quite possible
career and only three as definitely not. This was
The questionnaire sought background information
followed by general practitioner (69 students), paedia-
about the students (e.g. age, gender, year of medical
trician (47), surgeon (44), obstetrician/gynaecologist
degree, undergraduate degrees, marital status). The
(30) and public health specialist (24). The full results
next section ascertained attitudes towards different
are shown in Table 2.
specialties (e.g. psychiatry, general practice, internal
medicine, surgery, paediatrics, obstetrics/gynaecology, A x2 test was performed to assess for any relationship
and public health) as career options; students were between gender and psychiatry choice, but no associa-
asked the current likelihood of a career in certain tion was found (x2 1.68, df 1, p 0.2).
specialties and the attractiveness of these specialties in
terms of various factors (e.g. interesting subject, job Attractiveness of the various specialties
satisfaction, lifestyle, prestige, financial reward,
research opportunities, etc). Students were then asked Ratings of attractiveness for the various specialties,
to estimate the degree to which they, their families, according to 11 features listed on the questionnaire,
other medical students and medical practitioners are shown in Table 3. It was noteworthy that psychia-
respect the doctors in each specialty. try did not rate as the most attractive career option for
any of the features, and returned the lowest attractive-
Next, students were asked to rate their understanding ness rating for the degree to which patients are helped
of the benefits of a career in psychiatry, both before effectively and for having a reliable scientific founda-
and immediately after viewing the DVD, and to then tion. Psychiatry did rate higher than general practice
indicate the effect of the DVD on their understanding and obstetrics/gynaecology in terms of being intellec-
of and interest in psychiatry. Finally, open-ended tually challenging, a rapidly advancing field of medi-
questions provided an opportunity for the students cine and research opportunities; psychiatry also rated
to express their views concerning the DVD, as well as
the study and their attitudes towards psychiatry in
general.
Quantitative analysis was performed using SPSS (ver- Table 1: Characteristics of participating medical
sion 15) for frequency data and x2 tests were used to students (n 123)
evaluate associations between some of the results.
Paired t-tests were used for the assessment of the n %
effectiveness of the DVD. Written comments were
collated to identify common themes. Year in medical First 22 17.9
degree Second 20 16.3
Third 49 39.8
RESULTS Fourth 32 26.0
Across the four years of medicine, a total of 123
students responded to the survey out of a possible Age (years) 2025 56 45.5
1103 students (11.2% response rate). Sixteen of the 2630 53 43.1
respondents (13%) did not complete all survey ques- 30 14 11.4
tions.
Gender Female 77 62.6
Participant characteristics Male 46 37.4
The majority of participants were female, third year Australasian Psychiatry . Vol 17, No 4 . August 2009
Undergraduate Biology/Sciences 88 66.7
students, had a background in biology/science and
were single or had a partner but were not married. degreea Humanities/Arts/Law 16 12.1
Participant characteristics are shown in Table 1. Maths/IT/Computers 10 7.6
Other 18 13.6
Choice of career
Marital status Single 56 45.5
When asked to assign a rating for the degree to which Partner, not married 54 43.9
they considered careers in various specialties, only one Married 12 9.8
student out of the 123, a female, identified psychiatry Separated/divorced 1 0.8
as their chosen career. Out of the 37 considering
psychiatry ‘quite possible’, 26 were female and a
The total is larger than the number of participants because several
11 male. Thirty-one students (25%) had already students had more than one degree.
deemed psychiatry ‘definitely not’ a career choice.
313
Table 2: Student ratings of the likelihood of pursuing various careers
Chosen career Quite possible Unlikely Definitely not Unsure
n % n % n % n % n %
higher than internal medicine, surgery, paediatrics and Respect for specialties
obstetrics/gynaecology for good lifestyle. Public health
When asked to estimate the degree to which each
medicine rated lowest for seven of the 11 features.
specialty is respected by themselves, their family, other
Comparing those students interested in psychiatry medical students and medical practitioners, students
(who considered a career in psychiatry ‘chosen’ or ‘quite rated internal medicine most respected by themselves
possible’) with the remainder, students interested in and medical practitioners (Table 4). The students
psychiatry rated all the career features higher (more considered surgeons would be the most respected by
attractive) and this difference was significant for all their families and other medical students. Public
except two of these features (rapidly advancing field of health medicine was rated least respected by all four
medicine (p 0.09) and career opportunities (p 0.08)). groups and psychiatry second least respected.
Table 3: Mean attractiveness ratings for each of the medical specialties across nominated career features
General Internal Obstetrics/
Career feature practice medicine Surgery Paediatrics Gynaecology Psychiatry Public health
patients are
helped effectively
Rapidly advancing 5.15 2.42 2.52 3.88 4.25 4.18 5.04
field of medicine
Vol 17, No 4
foundation
Research 5.81 2.18 3.57 3.72 4.37 3.90 3.48
opportunities
314
Table 4: Mean rankings of respect for the various specialties
General Internal Obstetrics/
practice medicine Surgery Paediatrics Gynaecology Psychiatry Public health
When asked their opinion on how much medical Two open questions concerned the DVD’s effect on
students respect psychiatry, two students (1.6%) in- understanding and interest in psychiatry. When asked
dicated ‘respect greatly’, 57 (46%) said ‘respect some- how the DVD changed their understanding, most
what’, 26 (21%) were ‘neutral’, 35 (28%) indicated comments related to the following ideas: the diversity
‘disrespect somewhat’ and three (2.4%) suggested of roles available within psychiatry, lifestyle factors
‘disrespect greatly’. When asked how much qualified especially relating to the flexibility of work hours (e.g.
medical practitioners respect psychiatry, one student potential for part-time work) and training, the extent of
reported ‘respect greatly’, 53 (43%) said ‘respect some- the training involved, and the importance of mental
what’, 35 (28%) were ‘neutral’, 30 (24%) indicated health in the management of all types of illnesses.
When asked to explain how the DVD changed their
‘disrespect somewhat’ and three (2.4%) suggested
interest in psychiatry, the major themes were similar to
‘disrespect greatly’.
those just mentioned and were concentrated on good
lifestyle aspects (e.g. flexibility of training and work),
Effect of DVD how they now think more highly of psychiatry as a
specialty, and the diversity of subspecialties on offer.
Students were asked to rate the benefits of a career in
psychiatry (strongly agree, agree, neutral, disagree,
Why psychiatry is not regarded as an attractive
strongly disagree) in terms of the features listed in
career
Table 5 before and after viewing the DVD. There was a
significant improvement in all areas except ‘intellec- Student opinions on why psychiatry may not be
tually challenging’. The largest changes in opinion regarded as an attractive career option included psy-
were in relation to believing the specialty is enjoyable, chiatry involving difficult/unstable patients with
psychiatry offering effective treatment and having a chronic diseases and treatment being ineffective;
scientific foundation. soft/non-scientific/not ‘real’ medicine; lacking the
use of procedural skills; emotionally draining interac-
Students were also asked to rate how viewing the DVD tions and demanding area; and being an often un-
has affected their understanding of the role of a appreciated field to work in. The effect that daily work
315
Table 5: Effectiveness of DVD (mean of the difference between pre and post DVD viewing)
Mean difference SD 95% CI df p value
psychiatric treatments have or have not helped them. medical students and current medical practitioners’
Table 6: Agreement between the effect of the DVD on understanding and interest in psychiatry
Vol 17, No 4
n % n % n %
316
respect psychiatry. These results support the finding by ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Wigney and Parker8 that psychiatry is seen as less We thank the medical students who participated in the study and the Royal Australian and
prestigious and less respected than some other special- New Zealand College of Psychiatrists for providing copies of the DVD.
ties by current (and future) medical professionals.
It was pleasing that the DVD appeared to improve the
understanding of the role of a psychiatrist in about REFERENCES
50% of the participants and increased the interest in
1. Malhi GS, Parker GB, Parker K et al. Shrinking away from psychiatry? A survey of
psychiatry in about 30% of participants, with almost Australian medical students’ interest in psychiatry. Australian and New Zealand
one-quarter (23.5%) indicating improvement in both Journal of Psychiatry 2002; 36: 416423.
areas. At the same time, it was disappointing to find 2. Wigney T, Parker G. Factors encouraging medical students to a career in psychiatry: a
that a large percentage of students felt the DVD had no qualitative analysis. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 2008; 42:
effect on their understanding of or interest in this 520525.
profession. 3. Feifel D, Moutier CY, Swerdlow NR. Attitudes toward psychiatry as a prospective
Students identified explanations about the diversity of career among students entering medical school. American Journal of Psychiatry 1999;
156: 13971402.
roles available within psychiatry, flexible lifestyle
factors, and the extent of training as areas the DVD 4. Australian Medical Workforce Advisory Committee 1999. The Specialist Psychiatry
covered that helped improve their understanding and Workforce in Australia: Supply, Requirements and Projections 19992010. Cited
March 2008. Available from URL: http://www.health.nsw.gov.au/amwac/amwac/pdf/
interest in psychiatry. It may thus be valuable to
psychiatrya201999.7.pdf.
develop these areas further in future promotional
material, as well as address the various concerns raised 5. McParland M, Noble LM, Livingston G, McManus C. The effect of a psychiatric
attachment on students’ attitudes to and intention to pursue psychiatry as a career.
by students about why psychiatry is not seen as an
Medical Education 2003; 37: 447454.
attractive profession.
6. Sierles FS, Dinwiddie SH, Patroi D, Atre-Vaidya N, Schrift MJ, Woodard JL. Factors
The major shortcoming of the study was the low affecting medical student career choice of psychiatry from 19992001. Academic
response rate, despite several reminder emails, which Psychiatry 2003; 27: 260268.
may be partly attributable to the survey length (30 7. Manassis K, Katz M, Lofchy J, Wiesenthal S. Choosing a career in psychiatry:
minutes) and lack of financial or other incentives influential factors within a medical school program. Academic Psychiatry 2006; 30:
being offered to students. The response rate and 325329.
inclusion of only a single medical school limits the 8. Wigney T, Parker G. Medical student observations on a career in psychiatry. Australian
extent to which the results can be generalized. and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 2007; 41: 726731.
Nevertheless, our findings support those of McPar-
9. Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists 2008. The Royal Australian
land et al.5 and Sierles et al.6 that demonstrated that and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists. Cited March 2008. Available from URL:
negative views about psychiatry can be changed by http://www.ranzcp.org/publicarea/dvd.asp.
highlighting the positive aspects of the field to
10. Thomas T. Factors affecting career choice in psychiatry: a survey of RANZCP trainees.
medical students and junior doctors. Our preliminary Australasian Psychiatry 2008; 16: 179182.
study shows the potential value of simple promo-
11. Malhi GS, Parker GB, Parker K et al. Attitudes toward psychiatry among students
tional tools, such as a DVD, in improving attitudes
entering medical school. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 2003; 107: 424429.
towards and interest in psychiatry, at least in the
short term.
317