Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Philosophy in Education
Raneem Awad
31130734 EDUC 520 – A
Hanan Faour
Instructor: Dr. Lutfi Hamedeh
31630394
Fall 2019 - 2020
SUFISM
My religion is love.
Ibin Arabi
2
SUFISM
ABSTRACT
This paper aims to showcase the assimilation of religions and/or doctrines in terms of spirituality
and mysticism across different cultures and societies through highlighting modern literary works that
revolve around these themes. The objective of this project is to develop the philosophy of Sufi education
from the work of Shams Bin Tabriz, a Persian Sufi, who was credited for transforming Mawlana Rumi’s
life after arriving in Konya in the 13th century. Based on Shams’ works, the final purpose of the Sufi
education is annihilation and survival by God. The paper also aims to show how a form of spirituality
can originate out of organized religion, yet pertain a unique identity through practices that transcend
doctrine teachings i.e. showcasing spiritual practices to be a product of internal and innate need. This
paper also aims to construct these notions from the point of view of the west by recommending that
future studies revolving around mental don’t shun the effects of spirituality on the subjects.
3
SUFISM
“Rumi Phenomenon”
“Since 1994 the American literary market has been taken by storm by what may be called the
‘Rumi phenomenon’: the posthumous literary success of the thirteenth-century Sufi poet and mystic,
Muhammad Jalal ad-Din Balkhi, known to the Anglophone world as Rumi.” (Furlanetto, 2013). Rumi
was a hype for mystic infatuated audience and poetry amities. “Forty Rules of Love” By Shafak (2010)
contributed to the “Rumi phenomenon” and succumbed to simplify and decipher contextualization of the
works of Rumi in which merging post modernization with social and cultural conventions. The novel
talked about a spiritual journey of Rumi and his friendship with the dervish Shams Tabrizi who
transformed his perception on spirituality. Thus, “Understanding Shams and his message can become an
The Encounter
In Konya, Shams Tabrizi met Jaluldine Muhammad Rumi, Tabrizi jumped over and asked Rumi
on who he found greater, Prophet Muhammad or the Sufi Bistami. Rumi was bewildered by his question
and absurdly criticized the point of comparison for Prophet Mohammad, may peace be upon him, was the
last line of the prophets and it would be paradox to compare him to an infamous Sufi. Tabrizi replied that
Prophet Mohammad said: “Forgive me, God, I couldn’t know Thee as I should have”. While Bistami
claimed that “Glory be to me, I carry God inside my cloak”. Then who will be greater? The man who saw
himself so small in his relation with God, or the one who claimed that he carry God inside of him? Rumi
“You see, God’s love is an endless ocean, and human beings strive to get as
much water as they can out of it. But at the end of the day, how much water we
4
SUFISM
each get depends on the size of our cups. Some people have barrels, some buckets,
while some others have only got bowls. Bistami’s container was relatively small,
and his thirst was quenched after a mouthful. He was happy in the stage he was at.
It was wonderful he recognized the divine in himself, but even there still remains
the distinction between God and Self. Unity is not achieved. As for the Prophet, he
was the Elect of God and had a much bigger cup to fill. This is why God asked him
in the Qur’an, Have we not opened up your heart? His heart thus widened, his cup
immense, it was thirst upon thirst for him No wonder he said ‘We do not know You
156 -157).
The two interchangeable terms “Tasawwuf” and “Sufism” were a part of the Islamic notion of
Islamic teaching. Islamic religiosity and its moral and piety were the focus of Sufism. Tasawwuf, on the
other hand, accentuated the philosophical of Islam in terms of intellectuality and ethics. It was a merging
notion of sensual perception of the physical world with the intellectual thought through a transcendental
mind. The intellectual philosophy of Tasawuf was far beyond the practice of trivial practical relation to
God, it was the mental transcendent to interpret an unswerving relation with God, life, and nature
spiritually. It was a quest for finding the orientation of oneself in the universe. “A Tasawwuf-influenced
education (ʿIrfān-Education) invites wisdom, insight and piety into the acquisition of knowledge,
whereby such piety does not end at the border of a particular sort of confessional theology, but rather
stands for universality and inclusivity.” (Polat, 2017). When knowledge was attained and understood by
5
SUFISM
the senses and depicted with the transcendental, a new dimension of thought was unveiled; Awareness in
the interconnected topics of knowledge (Al ‘Ilm) and information (Al Maaloumat) and perception (Al
i’rfan) along with profound comprension (al Hikma). This new dimension was a generic boundary
between information produced transcendentally (Ilham) and sensual or cognitive information. “The
Muslim Sufis perceive an indivisible connection between belief, knowledge and reason.” (Ibin Sina) as
quoted by Pulat (2007). All of which were of utmost importance in the prerequisites of determining one’s
In Forty Rules of Love, Shafak (2010) illustrated Tasawwuf as a universal spiritual path devoid of
constraints on religion and society. A Sufi by heart was he who owns a pure heart and yearned for God
and humanity through love (Anjum & Ramzan, 2014). In the novel, Desert Rose, the prostitute, and
Hassan, the beggar, even Francis, the Christian….all could be Sufis if they dispensed their ego and rather
existed in search for God. Females and males could be dervishes. “When a true lover of God goes into a
tavern, the tavern becomes his chamber of prayer, but when a wine bibber goes into the same chamber it
becomes his tavern; in everything we do, it is our heart that make the difference, not our outer
appearances.” (Shafak, 2010, p.141). According to Lings (2005), ideologies of theocratic civilizations
differed from each other, in part they were all unique and particular yet intact with religious boundaries.
Mysticism was universal, and in a way, every religion had his own share and perspective of versions of
mysticisms, each were different yet all universal in the search for truth. The core of all mysticisms was
similar yet the cortex differed. Shams told Kera that Mother Mary signified piety and compassion and
love for her is by far divulged by Muslims just like Christians. “...All religions are only one religion,
because all praises are directed towards God light, these various forms and figures are borrowed from it.”
(Rumi & Nicholson, 2015). Rumi regarded himself as far from being belonging to any religion or cultural
system, that be Christianity, Buddhism, Sufism, Zenism, Islam, Judaism…He was not of the west nor the
6
SUFISM
east…”My place is placeless, a trace of the traceless.” (Shafak, 2010, p. 183). Love was the ulterior
It was said that Moses encountered a shepherd on the way. This shepherd was praying to his God,
asking him what he could do to show his love to him, shall he comb his hair? Shall he wash his robe? Kill
his lice? Moses was startled by his prayer and uttered that it was sheer blasphemy. He then taught him the
correct way to pray before embarking on his journey. That same night, God appeared to Moses and asked
him for what he have done; that shepherd was so dear to God for his prayer was a prayer of love and
devotion. The next day Moses ran to that shepherd and saw him praying in the way he was taught, yet his
focus on his devotion and sincerity of the heart was now shifted to the act of prayer itself. Moses
approached the shepherd and asked for his forgiveness for his prayer was precious in the eyes of God.
Yet the shepherd didn’t want to pray the same way he used to, nor he was able to fully conduct the new
prayer he was preached. He found a new prayer that allowed him to communicate to God (Rumi,1973).
Shams Tabrizi was trained by the greatest Sufi masters at that time and associated himself with
Sufis and theologians (Tasbihi, 2005). Tabrizi supported “Objective Knowledge” over dogma. He
believed that the context meaning of intellectuality and philosophical debates was what weakened their
search for the elixir of divine love (Tasbihi, 2005). Tabrizi was very keen to theology. His focus of
attention was on the anthropological approach in the importance of human creation and attaining
annihilation through truthfulness and love (Jadid & Mohabbati, 2018). Spiritual, philosophical and
religious commitment to the convention were of subordinate to training the mind and taming the ego.
Tabrizi was a dervish, constantly wandering in his passion of spiritual knowledge in the search for God.
7
SUFISM
In “Forty Rules of Love”, after had been wandering for quite some time, Tabrizi entered a lodge where he
met a prestigious Judge. Shams introduced himself courteously and said he was travelling in the search of
god. The judge was infatuated and asked if his search was of any result. Tabrizi said contentedly that God
was with him all along. The judge sarcastically interjected that dervishes made life so complicated, why
would they bother to rummage all around and they knew that God was with them in the first place.
Tabrizi replied “Because although it is a fact that He cannot be found by seeking, only those who seek
Sufism is an inner journey of love and the quest of love lead to submission to the idea that when
one knew oneself, he knew his God. Tabrizi noted that “How we see God is a direct reflection of how we
see ourselves. If God brings to mind mostly fear and blame, it means there is too much fear and blame
welled inside us. If we see God as full of love and compassion, so are we.” (Shafak, 2010. p.30). Tabrizi
inspired, through his forty rules of love, relating God’s traits to oneself. He did not assertively preached
on those traits to be idolized, he only gave a glimpse of a foundation on change in order to broaden one’s
flow of ideas and let him attribute to his own development. Tasawwuf according to Tabrizi allowed
understanding that the self was nothing but a reflection of God or Spirit, then human nature would be
realized (Helminski, 2017). As the self becomes detached from identification in social and materialistic
norm of programming and conditioning, the self will the capacity of loving unconditionally, and manifest
a conscious choice and fundamental creativity. The soul yet must be cleansed by love. On Tabrizi, “It is
easy to love a perfect god, unblemished and infallible that He is; what is far more difficult is to love
fellow human beings with all their imperfections and defects.” (Shafak, 2010, p.110). Love was not
limited to the submission to God, but in the love one withholds to God’s creations with all their
imperfections and flaws. Rather God wanted his creatures to be the same, he would have created them
8
SUFISM
that way, yet he created unique and different souls for every heart beats to its own rhythm. Pantheism
adhered to the presence of God in the whole world among all his creations, “All-is-one” (Anjum &
Ramzan, 2014). Monism, all-is-now, the past, present and the future were nothing but a mere illusion.” If
you want to experience eternal illumination, put the past and future out of your mind and remain within
the present moment” (Shafak, 2010, p.135). The aim of the journey was to change the seeker; when one
started looking for love, he is changing from without and within where each present moment creates life.
When a moment is filled with love, it ascends the seeker to heaven, yet when a moment is filled with
envy and hatred, it descends the seeker straight into hell. Shams regarded life as temporarily and
illustrates a simulation of reality. Children would be infatuated with a toy assuming that it is the real
thing and by far get disrespectful handling it by breaking and scorning it and eventually throw it away.
Extremities destroy inner balance. A Sufi is always moderate and mild. Yet when it came to love, an
intellect is always cautious on experiencing too much ecstasy and won't easily subside and break down.
Rather, a Sufi would relentlessly take the plunge when it comes to love. But the thing about love is that it
can effortlessly elude itself to rubble. According to Tabrizi “treasures are hidden among ruins and broken
heart hides treasure” (Shafak, 2010). Love cleanses the soul, just as hatred, pride, bigotry poisons the
soul. Sufism purges the filth dwelled inside the soul and shuns out the devil. Yet self-examination was
naively escaped through attributing human’s mischiefs to the devil ( Anjum & Ramzan, 2014).
In Forty Rules of Love, Desert Rose, the harlot, was seen as pure and delicate in the eyes of a Sufi
as Tabrizi. Yet for Baybar, a relative of renowned religious zealot, Desert Rose’s body tormented him yet
he regarded his submission as a symbol of cowardice. To Baybar, enemies of Islam and infidels should
be treated with hatred for War is the core of existence and to that he renowned the name “Baybars the
Warrior”. Baybar represents people who regard the Sharia as the ultimate post for humanity in the
modern world. “They hate seeing women as prostitutes but make life of repentance hard for them as
9
SUFISM
well.” (Anjum & Ramzan, 2014). People like Baybar searched the mosques for love and prayers for God.
Sufism perspective on God and God’s relationship with his lovers is rather deeper than conventional and
customs in which nothing should stand between a man and his God. Tabrizi’s thirty second rule of love
was:” Nothing should stand between yourself and God, Not imams, priests, rabbis, or any other
custodians of moral or religious leadership; No spiritual Masters, not even your faith.” (Shafak, 2010, p.
246).
To confine the notion of spirituality with the binding limits of one single religion or culture, is
doing the concept a disservice. Kneller (2019) defined spirituality from a philosophical standpoint stating
that it is the inherent and natural awareness and curiosity that humans experience regarding their
existence in the world on the greater scheme of things. Spirituality and seeking meaning in life is
considered to be a natural human reaction and it often emerged early on in the lives as young children as
Miller (2015) stressed upon the importance of providing innate natural inclination to inquire on spiritual
matter with a positive and assuring atmosphere. She stated that in order for kids to explore this
(Miller, 2015).
She encouraged parents and guardians to be involved in their child’s spiritual journey by
providing three different methods to help navigate this new territory of knowledge successfully both
10
SUFISM
parties. Throughout the 3 methods Miller (2015) proposes, there is a common theme to guide children in
their spiritual journey. This theme is Love. Love is the driving force which paved the path to spirituality
and the starting point of the journey as well as representing the child’s safety net and source of inner
peace. Love is the guiding force which enables children to feel a constant sense of security no matter
what life throws at them. Even without the presence of a parent/guardian, children living out their lives
out of love, will face life’s hardships with an open mind and a calm heart (Miller, 2015).
In terms of spirituality in the East and specifically in Sufism, the concept of Love transcended the
earthly definitions and focused on the unwavering deep affection and passion towards God. It is an
inward drive to find a greater sense of enlightenment free from worldly concerns and earthly possessions
(Specia, 2018). This movement was considered quite mainstream during the Golden Ages of the Arab
World circa the 12th century, however lately those who practiced Tasawwuf have been targeted in
Moreover, while Sufism had emerged out of Islam, its’ teachings and practices weren’t so unlike
other spiritual movements. When it boiled down to the components of Sufism, it was essentially a
combination of the teachings of Islam as well as cultural elements that have been integrated into the
movement over the years of its expansion beyond the borders of the Arab World. An article released by
The New Times, aimed to inform readers on Sufism, states that the movement has adapted itself to suit
the culture of the community or society in which it was being practiced- be it in China, West Africa or
even in the US (Specia, 2017). Regarding the practicing sects of the Sufism movement , an interview
with Alexander D. Knysh, a professor of Islamic studies at the University of Michigan and expert in
modern Sufism, describes the movement as a “’Very wide, amorphous movement’ practiced within both
the Sunni and Shiite traditions.” (2017). We can infer that Sufism adheres to the general definition of
spiritual movements, where it is viewed as “Spiritual philosophy and secular religion meet in the middle;
11
SUFISM
depending on how people approach the spiritual and the secular ,there is overlap.” (Kneller, 2019).
Therefore, a draw out of the similarities between all spiritual movements and Sufism in terms of this
constant search for a meaning in life and seeking a higher power and inner peace, highlights the idea that
the spiritual needs of humans are universal and collectively aimed at bettering one’s self, regardless of
Which begs the question: what are the consequences when this spirituality is stifled or not pursued; be it
Spirituality for the Adult: “Eat Pray Love” and the Assimilation of Religions
Prior to the release of “Forty Rules of Love”, the world was infatuated with one woman’s journey
in “Eat Pray Love” to seek enlightenment in 3 distinct chapters that encompass her perception of what
life revolves around: Leisure, Spirituality and Love. One an easily noticed a common theme between
both titles.
Gilbert (2006) brought about her story as a successful but mentally and emotionally depleted
journalist who’s been struggling with her failed marriage, money trouble and mental illness. She decided
to pull herself out of this sump by pitching to her publishers the idea of a memoir which will document
Gilbert (2006) used her memoir to give a peep into the journey of a very privileged westerner
thrust into new cultures hoping to find herself, God and the Love within. Throughout the book, she
detailed her life back as a country girl raised on Christian ideals, as well as her life in the hustle and
bustle of New York City as a career woman trying to have it. However, between her desires to acquire
12
SUFISM
fame, fortune, and seeking out her desires she found that she has lost herself and comes to the realization
that this was not the life for her. Only after losing everything in terms of money, possessions and stability
While her methods were unorthodox, they provided a clear view of the modern perception of
seeking spiritual enlightenment beyond one’s culture and societal norms. The second part (Pray) and
third part (Love) of her journey will be our main focus as we draw the almost unified nuances of
Gilbert (2006) realized that after losing the shackles of the complex and materialist life, she was
able to start enjoying her new daily routine in the simple Buddhist retreat she chose to spend the second
portion of her trip. By participating in extremely disciplined meditation sessions, prayer circles or even
during her daily chores, was her mind and soul free to contemplate and reconnect with herself and the
universe beyond.
Such experiences weren’t limited to Buddhism, as they also made up for a huge portion of the
teachings of Sufism as well. Many scholars also suggested due to geographical proximity of the Arab
World and the South East, there was a good chance that both cultures experienced mutual influence from
Further similarities were found within both movements, be it in terms of the practices, messages,
concepts and ideas that were expressed in their teachings. Perhaps the biggest similarity was in the
thinking process of both practices and the pursuit of the highest level of internal spiritual awareness
which in turn was the reason for the never ending journey to reach enlightenment. Beyond the beliefs,
some practices were also very similar such as meditation as a method to connect with God and
13
SUFISM
understand one’s presence in the world and his destiny; In addition to the repetition of mantras, songs or
poems that often revolved around one’s undying Love for God.
While Buddhism and Sufism did have differences in terms of religious teachings, their
similarities, however, indicated that in the grand scheme of things, our pursuit of a spiritual life is
consistent over all cultures. They were an indication of the importance of one seeking the answers to their
spiritual questions.
Gilbert (2016) and Shafak (2010) were only two western writers; albeit two prominent ones, that
had taken on this literary path in relating spirituality to everyday modern life. Furthermore, it is important
to shed light on the average Westerners who have taken on the pursuit of a spiritually guided life. The
New York Times ran a story about a group of Sufis living in New York who had let go of their past
notions of religion and what they were taught as children in order to embrace a more holistic, love
centered concept in order to approach God and lead their lives from a spiritual point of view. The story
written by Suliman (2016) was a testimony on the ever spreading influence of spiritual teachings in the
west and maybe let us think whether these communities were lacking in this domain despite the need for
such teachings.
Conclusion:
In a nutshell, it is safe to say that the path to find spiritual closure began from one’s self and ended there
as well. Both women in “Eat, Pray, Love” and “Forty Rule of Love” have found resolution through going
on their spiritual journeys after living lives of hardship and resentment. On a scientific Level, some
studies have indicated that one’s spirituality, played a prominent role in the psychological and mental
wellbeing.
14
SUFISM
“The Impact of Spirituality on Mental Health” explored the correlation between spirituality and
psychological wellbeing .The study suggested that the west’s inclination to separate science and
methodological research from spirituality lead to little findings in this domain until recent years (Cornah,
2006, p. 7). However, the study did point out to a number of limitations regarding the method of research
and the people conducting it as well as the subjects of the experiments/questionnaires. But, the study
indicated that morals associated with spirituality, such as empathy, had helped some patients dealing with
Perhaps western based studies should start by taking Sufism as an example of a concept that is
derived from religion but is in another league of teaching and practices. This could prove to be beneficial
in bringing the conflicting east and west together. Future studies can make use of the semi-independent
concept of mysticism and its’ effect on people who have decided to uphold it as their path and the main
15
SUFISM
Bibliography
Anjum, F., & Ramzan, M. (2014).” The Sufi Phenomenon" The case of Elif shafak's the Forty Rules of
Love. Global Journal of Human-Social Science: G Linguistics and Education, 14(7). doi: ISSN:
2249-460x
Berzin, A. (2007). The Relation between Buddhism and Sufism. SCM Press, 256–261.
Cornah, D. (2006). Impact of spirituality on mental health a review of the literature—The British Library.
health-a-review-of-the-literature
COSMOPOLITANISM The Case of Elif Shafak’s The Forty Rules of Love, European Journal of
Helminski, K. E. (2017). Living Presence (Revised): The Sufi Path to Mindfulness and the Essential Self.
Penguin.
SHAMS TABRIZI. National Academy of Managerial Staff of Culture and Arts Herald, 0(1).
https://doi.org/10.32461/2226-3209.1.2018.177665
https://theexplanation.com/spiritual-philosophy-wisdom-spirituality/
Lings, Martin. (2005) What is Sufism? Produced and distributed by Suhail Academy, Chowk Urdu Bazar,
Lahore.
16
SUFISM
Miller, L. (2016). How to raise a spiritual child: 3 exercises from Dr. Lisa Miller. Today NBC Universal.
https://www.today.com/parents/how-raise-spiritual-child-3-exercises-dr-lisa-miller-t11736
Polat, M. (2017). Tasawwuf-oriented Educational Philosophy and its Relevance to the Formation of
doi: 10.13189/ujer.2017.050514
Rūmī Jalāl al-Dīn, & Nicholson, R. A. (2015). Selected poems from Divan-e Shams-e Tabrizi. Bethesda:
Ibex Publishers.
Rumi, J. M. (1973). Moses and the Shepherd (part one). Masnavi II. Dar Al Masnavi. Retrieved January
Shafak, Elif (2010). The Forty Rules of Love. New York: Penguin
Specia, M. (2017). Who Are Sufi Muslims and Why Do Some Extremists Hate Them? The New York
Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/24/world/middleeast/sufi-muslim-explainer.html
Suliman, A. (2016). Sufi Sect of Islam Draws ‘Spiritual Vagabonds’ in New York. The New York Times.
https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/25/nyregion/sufi-islam-new-york-converts.html
Tasbihi, E. (2005). Me and Rumi: The Autobiography of Shams-i Tabrizi, translated, introduced and
annotated by William C. Chittick. Louisville: Fons Vitae, 2004. 347 pages. ISBN 1-887752-52-8.
Vaziri, M. (2015). Rumi and Shams’ Silent Rebellion: Parallels with Vedanta, Buddhism, and Shaivism.
Springer.
17