Assignment No.
01
Scenario:
Here is an educational software system where a student can register for different courses. Like student will be able
to enroll to undergraduate courses or post-graduate courses.
Following requirements are gathered at initial stage. Identify Good or Bad requirements and you will only
write most appropriate characteristic of a good requirement.
Requirements
Students will be able to enroll
to undergraduate and post
graduate courses
A student will log into the
system by providing his
username and other relevant
information
 Students will be able to
enroll to undergraduate
courses
 Students will be able to
enroll to post-graduate
courses
A student will log into the
system by providing his
username and password
A student will have either
undergraduate courses or post-
graduate courses but not both.
Some courses will be open to
both under-graduate and post-
graduate
Each page of the system will
load in an acceptable time-
frame
A student will have either
under-graduate or post
graduates but not both
Register student and enroll
courses pages of the system
will load within 5 seconds
Maintain student information-
mapped to BRD (Business
Requirement Document) req.
ID?
Maintain student information-
Mapped to BRD req. ID 4.1
(BC180200506)
Good/Bad Characteristic of a good
requirement
Bad Because category maintains
students record in an efficient
way.
Good Because user must login before
submitting any record so it is
also a good option
Good Every person must enroll
according to her needs and as
per qualification
Good So only registered user can get
course material.
Bad For students must having a
unique category either
undergraduate courses or post
graduate courses.
Bad Page will be load as soon as
possible. MAX time of loading
is 5 sec.
Good After graduation it can be
enroll in post graduate.
Good 5 sec is like a university
standard loading time.
Good Maintains student information
mapped to BRD (Business
Requirement Document) Req.
id 4.1
Good As we discussed above