Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Introduction
These clinical guidelines describe the application of Considerations of treatment quality in cardiac
physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation. They were rehabilitation are discussed below in the review of the
developed by the Royal Dutch Society for Physical evidence.
Therapy (KNGF) and follow up the Cardiac
Rehabilitation Guidelines 1995/1996 produced by the Cardiac rehabilitation phases:
Dutch Cardiology Association and the Dutch Heart Phase I: during hospital admission;
Foundation. In essence, the guidelines provide a Phase II: in the polyclinic rehabilitation setting
summary of the information contained in the second (both clinical and polyclinic patients);
section of this document, entitled “Review of the Phase III: post-rehabilitation and aftercare phases.
evidence”, in which the choices made in deriving
guideline recommendations are presented separately. These clinical guidelines describe the goals of
The guidelines and the review of the evidence can be treatment and the end criteria in phase I and the
read individually. An explanation of the abbreviations diagnostic and therapeutic processes in phase II.
used and the definitions of some important terms and Aftercare, which comprises phase III, is not covered
concepts are given in an appended list of by the guidelines.
abbreviations and definitions and a glossary. These
KNGF guidelines on physical therapy in cardiac Defining cardiac rehabilitation
rehabilitation are for the use of physical therapists These KNGF clinical guidelines have been devised for
who work with cardiac patients in rehabilitation the implementation of physical therapy in patients
phases I and II. who have had an (acute) myocardial infarction, or
who have undergone a coronary artery bypass
The (Dutch) physical therapists involved will have operation, percutaneous transluminal coronary
also knowledge of the multidisciplinary Cardiac angioplasty, a heart valve operation, or operative
Rehabilitation Guidelines 1995/1996 and of a correction of a congenital heart disorder.
supplementary publication entitled “Physical therapy
in cardiac rehabilitation”.
I Lisette Vogels, MSc, physical therapist / social scientist, Department of Research and Development, Dutch Institute of Allied Health
Professions, Amersfoort, The Netherlands
II Rob Bertram, physical therapist, rehabilitation center Beatrixoord, Haren, The Netherlands
III Jean Graus, physical therapist, rehabilitation center Hoensbroek, The Netherlands
IV Erik Hendriks, PhD, physical therapist / clinical epidemiologist and guidelines coordinator, Department of Research and Development,
Dutch Institute of Allied Health Professions, Amersfoort, The Netherlands
V Rob van Hulst, physical therapist, Deventer Hospital, Deventer, The Netherlands
VI Erik Hulzebos, MSc, physical therapist / human movement scientist, University Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands
VII Hessel Koers, physical therapist / manual therapist, Groene Hart Hospital, Gouda, The Netherlands
VIII Tinus Jongert, MSc, exercise physiologist, TNO-PG, Leiden, The Netherlands
IX Frank Nusman, physical therapist, Isala Klinieken, Zwolle, The Netherlands
X Roelof Peters, physical therapist, Sint Antonius Hospital, Nieuwegein, The Netherlands
XI Bart Smit, physical therapist, Sint Lucas Andreas Hospital, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
XII Simon van der Voort, physical therapist, Zonnestraal, Hilversum, The Netherlands
V-08/2003/US 1
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Table 1. Goals of therapy, end criteria and methods of evaluation applicable during the acute and mobilization
phases of rehabilitation phase I.
Acute phase
Physical therapy goals End criteria Evaluation method
Surgical treatment: Physical therapy: Monitoring mucus clearance
• Provide preoperative • No objectively observed and ventilation
pulmonary guidance; pulmonary problems.
• Monitor mucus clearance,
ventilation and treatment Medical:
(if necessary). Post-operative treatment:
• No excess mucus retention
Non-surgical treatment: and no atelectasis;
• Monitor mucus clearance, • Patient is hemodynamically
ventilation and treatment stable;
(if necessary). • No severe rhythm disorders
or conduction abnormalities.
Non-surgical treatment:
• Patient is hemodynamically
stable;
• Enzyme levels decreasing;
• No severe rhythm disorders
or conduction abnormalities.
Mobilization phase
Physical therapy goals End criteria Evaluation method
Surgical treatment and Physical therapy: History-taking2;
non-surgical treatment: • Patient can function at the Risk factor checklist;
• Ensure patient can function intended level of activities of Objective determination of the
at the intended level of daily living; patient’s level of activities
activities of daily living; • Patient has moderate aerobic of daily living by evaluating
• Ensure patient has sufficient capacity (≥ 3 MET’s1); activities.
information to start • Patient has knowledge about
phase II or to proceed heart disease and surgery and
independently, which means can cope adequately with
that the patient: the information;
- can cope sensibly with • Patient has knowledge
the heart disease; of risk factors;
- has knowledge about • Patient can cope adequately
the disease’s nature, with symptoms.
surgery and risk factors;
and
- can react adequately to
any symptoms that might
occur.
1 1 Metabolic Task Equivalent (MET’s) = 3.5 ml of oxygen per kg per minute. Supplement 3 to the review of the evidence gives the metabolic
equivalence (i.e., MET’s values) of different activities.
2 Preferably using a structured questionnaire.
2 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Risk factors and prognostic factors applicable methods of evaluation in these two
Coronary heart disease risk factors can be split into subphases are presented in Table 1.
two groups: influenceable and non- influenceable risk
factors. Influenceable factors include smoking, lipid Rehabilitation phase II
imbalance (e.g., hypercholesterolemia and Before beginning rehabilitation in the polyclinic (i.e.,
hyperlipidemia), hypertension, obesity, physical rehabilitation phase II), all patients are screened by
inactivity and diabetes mellitus. Non-influenceable the rehabilitation team after physician referral. The
factors include hereditary tendencies, age and sex. referral documentation must include, as a minimum,
Prognostic factors that influence recovery after acute the information listed in Table 2. The rehabilitation
myocardial infarction include the residual function of team consists, at a minimum, of a physician, a
the left ventricle and the size and location of the physical therapist, a social worker and a nurse. The
infarct. The patient’s psychological condition, physician in the team, who is usually a cardiologist,
including factors such as exhaustion, fear and has the final responsibility for treatment.
depression, and the presence of any co-morbid
conditions, such as physical limitations or a The exercise capacity of the patient are estimated by a
cerebrovascular accident, can have a negative cardiologist and are classified as either low, medium
influence on recovery. or high.
Table 2. Minimum referral information given by the physician to the rehabilitation team.
• Medical diagnosis;
• Relevant cardiac information, as decided by the physician, including details of:
- hemodynamic stability;
- the location and extent of the infarction and the extent of any left ventricular dysfunction;
- exercise testing results including ECG findings (e.g., the presence of ischemia); and
- heart rhythm disorders or conduction abnormalities.
• Co-morbid conditions;
• Risk factors;
• Medicine use; and
• The cardiologist’s estimate of exercise capacity (i.e., low, medium or high1) and prognosis.
V-08/2003/US 3
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Table 3. Questions in the five areas of enquiry used in rehabilitation screening, taken from the Cardiac
Rehabilitation Guidelines 1995/1996:
I. Has physical aerobic capacity been reduced objectively, in terms of the patient’s ability to work and carry
out domestic and leisure activities? Are there any motor limitations that restrict the patient’s functional
abilities?
II. Has physical aerobic capacity been reduced subjectively because of anxiety about aerobic capacity
(including sexual capabilities) or because the patient feels very handicapped?
III. Is there a problem with emotional balance? Does the patient deal with the sickness in a dysfunctional
manner? In other words: What is the difference between the patient’s present and optimal psychological
functioning?
IV. Is there a problem with social functioning? What is the prognosis for the patient’s return to a normal
social role in relation to work, leisure and family relationships? What is the quality and extent of the
patient’s social network?
V. Are there any influenceable risky behaviors, involving, for example, smoking, diet (e.g., leading to
obesity or lipid disorders), physical inactivity, or non-compliance with therapy?
provide answers to the questions posed in area I In history-taking, information is obtained partly by
above. Physical, psychological and social functioning, the rehabilitation team, and includes referral data
covered in areas II, III and IV, can be determined from the cardiologist, and partly from the patient
objectively using screening questionnaires, which are himself or herself. History-taking involves:
currently being developed. Some of these • recording the patient’s concerns and goals,
questionnaires can be used for rehabilitation including his or her desired level of activity;
screening as well as for evaluating treatment. A risk • assessing the patient’s level of activity before the
factor checklist can be used to determine risk factors present health situation developed;
objectively and to relate them to the patient’s • assessing the overall health situation, including
lifestyle, to help answer questions in area V. taking details of:
- the nature and severity of any impairments,
disabilities and problems with social
Diagnosis participation;
The objectives of the physical therapy diagnostic - the start and course of the condition;
process are to investigate the severity and nature of - any factors that led to the condition (e.g., poor
the health problem in relation to functional circulation);
movement and to identify any influenceable - prognostic and risk factors;
prognostic factors. Of central importance are the • recording the present situation, including noting
patient’s concerns and goals. The physical therapist details of:
will assess the patient’s health status and identify the - any current impairments, disabilities and
most important disorders, the desired health problems with social participation associated
condition, any existing influenceable and non- with the heart disease;
influenceable risk factors, and the patient’s need for - present general health status, including
information. The diagnostic process makes use of the information on functioning, and levels of
referral, history-taking, assessment, analysis and the activity and participation;
formulation of a treatment plan. The recommended - present treatment, including medications used
measuring instruments are described and explained and medical treatment received;
in Supplement 2 to the review of the evidence. - personal factors;
- the patient’s motivation; and
History-taking - the patient’s need for information.
4 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
The patient’s most important complaints, including influence on exercise capacity? For example:
any activity problems, can be determined using a - fear, depression, mental handicap or sleep
specially designed questionnaire, called the patient- problems;
specific complaint questionnaire, and a visual - stress or exhaustion;
analogue scale for assessing activity level. The risk - lifestyle, involving, for example, smoking,
factor checklist should be used to identify risk factors. physical inactivity or eating problems;
- medication use; or
Assessment - social problems.
Functional human movement can be expressed in 4. How does the patient envisage his or her future
terms of physical load and aerobic capacity but is also performance of daily activities, leisure activities,
affected by the presence of any functional work and hobbies (i.e., the patient’s goals and
impairments. Assessment involves observation, expectations)?
functional evaluation and, if necessary, palpation. 5. Is the desired level of performance attainable,
Basically, assessment centers on determining the according to the information obtained in
levels of functional impairment, activity limitation answering questions 2 and 3?
and problems with participation, all of which - can any negative factors be influenced?
influence the choice of exercises used in the - if so, negative factors should be reduced or
rehabilitation program. Activities may be limited in eliminated and exercise capacity increased;
terms of their nature, duration or quality. In dealing - if not, the situation should be optimized and
with psychosocial functioning, the physical therapist the patient should learn to accept it.
adopts a signaling function. During activity 6. Can physical therapy help ameliorate the health
evaluation, the physical therapist should pay problem? In terms of:
attention to how the patient deals with the health - reducing impairments;
problem. For example, does the patient have a fear of - reducing disabilities;
movement? The following measuring instruments or - reducing participation problems; or
techniques can be used during assessment: the Borg - improving functions, activities and the level of
scale, an ergometer, MET’s units, the specific activity participation.
scale, the six-minute walking test, and the fear,
angina pectoris and/or dyspnea scale. If indicated by In addition to the above-mentioned problem areas,
the physician, heart rate and blood pressure can also patients may experience other health problems that
be monitored. may or may not be related to heart disease. On
occasion, additional physical therapy may be
Analysis indicated. These problems are not covered by these
Analysis is based on assessment and evaluation. The guidelines.
physical therapist must obtain answers the following
questions: Treatment plan
1. What is the patient’s health status in terms of The rehabilitation team will decide if there are
impairments, disabilities and participation discrepancies between the patient’s present condition
problems? How much can the patient currently and the desired level of functioning and determine
handle, physically, mentally and socially? whether there is an indication for further
2. Are there physical problems that limit increases in rehabilitation (see the flow chart in Figure 3 in the
the patient’s physical, mental and social review of the evidence). The rehabilitation team,
performance? These may be: together with the patient, will formulate therapeutic
- related to a cardiac disorder (e.g., myocardial goals with help from the answers given to questions
infarction or chronic heart failure); or in the five areas of enquiry used in rehabilitation
- related to other sicknesses or disorders, screening, which were taken from the Cardiac
including other physical complaints. Rehabilitation Guidelines 1995/1996. These goals are
3. Are there any other factors that have a negative translated into an individual rehabilitation plan that
V-08/2003/US 5
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Table 4. Data held by the rehabilitation team that is relevant for physical therapy:
• The physician’s diagnostic and prognostic referral data and information about the patient’s exercise
capacity (See Table 2 above);
• Individual aerobic capacity goals and reasons for any aerobic capacity limitations, such as fear or a
dysfunctional way of coping with heart disease;
• Physical therapist’s diagnosis.
If necessary:
• information about work rehabilitation and prognosis;
• information on the patient’s family.
consists of a number of different modules. If her physical disabilities and to help him or her
necessary, these modules can be implemented with learn how to deal with different physical
individual guidance. The rehabilitation team decides situations and types of movement. Acceptance
when the rehabilitation program will start and which is essential. It is important to encourage the
module the patient should use first. The Cardiac patient’s active involvement in discovering his
Rehabilitation Guidelines 1995/1996 describe four or her level of physical capability.
modules: short and long exercise modules (FIT), an 3. Finding the optimum aerobic capacity level [3].
information module (INFO), and a psychoeducational • The goal is to enable the patient to reach a
preparation module (PEP). The KNGF guideline working desired level of physical capability. Capabilities
group advises the addition of a fifth module, on are improved up to a level at which the patient
relaxation instruction (RELAX). The information given can function better in performing normal daily
in these guidelines is divided into exercise programs. activities, work, sports and hobbies.
Table 4 provides an overview of the data held by the 4. Diagnosis: evaluating aerobic capacity level and
rehabilitation team that is relevant to physical correlating symptoms with objective disorders [4].
therapists. • The goal is to assess the patient’s exercise
capacity on a number of occasions. It is
Patients who have to employ physical training to important to find correlations between
achieve their most important goal must undergo a symptoms and objective disorders, and to
symptom-limited aerobic capacity test using an determine which disabilities the patient has
ergometer to provide relevant information for problems with in daily life. The results of the
therapy. diagnostic process provide an insight into the
patient’s exercise capacity and identify
The following are the six specific goals for physical opportunities for increasing these capabilities.
therapy (the numbers in square brackets refer to the 5. Reducing fear of movement [5].
goals listed in the Cardiac Rehabilitation Guidelines • The goal is to enable the patient to experience
1995/1996): movement, with the hope that, through
1. Learning to find one’s own physical limits [1]. experience, fear for movement will decrease.
• The goal is to enable the patient to go about 6. Developing and attaining a physically active
daily life and to manage at a physical level. By lifestyle [14].
coming up against objective boundaries, the • The goal is to help the patient enjoy
patient learns what his or her personal exercise exercising. Providing guidance that enables the
capacity is and where his or her physical limits patient to be active at home will reduce the
lie. risk factors associated with an inactive lifestyle.
2. Learning to deal with physical limitations [2]. The patient will learn to integrate exercises
• The goal is to confront the patient with his or into his or her lifestyle. The idea is that the
6 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
patient will make exercise a normal daily individual rehabilitation schemas, which are drawn
activity and will, therefore, progress to up by the rehabilitation team. If rehabilitation
rehabilitation phase III. screening occurs shortly before hospital discharge,
the patient can immediately enter rehabilitation
The physical therapist can also have an influence on phase II in the same hospital where screening was
the achievement of other goals, such as achieving carried out. If rehabilitation screening is carried out
secondary prevention [12–16], acquiring emotional and indications for therapy are determined at the end
balance [6], and learning how to deal with heart of rehabilitation phase I but the patient does not
disease in a functional manner [7]. Each patient immediately progress to phase II (for example,
usually has a combination of goals. If improving because rehabilitation only starts four weeks after
aerobic capacity is not indicated, then goal 1 or 2, or hospital discharge) or the patient is referred from
both, are recommended. If improving aerobic another hospital, the physical therapist will repeat
capacity is indicated, then goal 1 or 3, or both, are the diagnostic process before therapy starts. During
recommended. If there is a subjective decrease in the therapeutic process, the physical therapist will
aerobic capacity, treatment should focus on goal 1 or evaluate individual goals systematically (see
5, or both. The problem areas covered by goals 1 and description of evaluation given below). The
5 are usually the initial focus of treatment. For therapeutic process is divided into the following areas
example, the patient must first reduce the level of for descriptive purposes: informing and advising,
fear or learn what his or her personal limits are before patient-orientated exercise program, and relaxation
being ready for training. If there is no clear objective instruction.
reduction in aerobic capacity, then goal number 4 is
recommended. In cardiac rehabilitation, the patient’s physical
functioning is of central concern, not his or her
It is important that patients are divided into groups sporting abilities.
with high, medium or low exercise capacity, as
estimated by the cardiologist and rehabilitation team, Informing and advising
before deciding on an exercise program. It is also Providing information and advice, and supporting
important that the patient’s motor capabilities and the patient are both part of physical therapy and fall
degree of motivation for carrying out activities are under the general category of providing guidance.
also taken into consideration. Patients who have little The patient’s need for information, advice and
motivation need an exercise program in which the coaching, which becomes apparent during diagnosis,
main exercises can be incorporated into normal daily forms the basis for the patient information plan.
activities. This is more enjoyable and ensures better Consultation with practitioners of other disciplines is
functioning during exercise. important.
An exercise program may consist of exercises that The provision of patient education is divided into
focus on improving health or exercises that focus on four tasks: informing, instructing, educating and
improving performance, or both. guiding. In practice, these four tasks overlap. Each
task involves a different approach, which depends on
Exercises aimed at improving health involve the time and educational aids available, and on the
practicing skills and activities, and training is less therapist’s experience. The physical therapist coaches
intensive. Exercises aimed at improving performance the patient and helps him or her to make the desired
involve physical training. Attention must always be behavioral adjustments by providing education, by
paid to helping patients enjoy the exercises. giving positive feedback, and by enabling the patient
to have positive movement experiences.
V-08/2003/US 7
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
subsequent rehabilitation – the physical therapist daily living, a reduction in risk factors, and
informs the patient about the nature and course improved postoperative mobility.
of heart disease, surgery, rehabilitation (including 2. Aerobic exercise (goals 1, 2 and 3). Result:
its goals, therapeutic content and estimated increased general aerobic capacity, reduced blood
duration), risk factors and prognosis; pressure and heart rate through submaximal
• To improve compliance and increase trust in exercise, decreased myo-cardial oxygen uptake,
therapy – the learning process involves extending and a reduction in risk factors.
and incorporating the activities and behaviors 3. Strength and aerobic exercise (goals 1, 2 and 3).
learned during treatment into the patient’s daily Result: increased strength and aerobic capacity,
life. The patient has to learn to ‘feel’ how to deal and a higher level of daily activity in housework,
with heart disease; occupational work, sports and hobbies.
• To encourage an adequate way of coping with the 4. Learning how to enjoy exercise by practicing
condition – the patient should learn what specific functions and activities (goals 5 and 6).
symptoms mean and how to control them. The Result: patient enjoys exercising and integrates
learning process may be based, for example, on exercises into his or her normal lifestyle.
reducing fear of movement. The physical therapist 5. Training to reduce risk factors, such as
ensures that the patient does not receive any hypertension, hyperlipidemia, diabetes mellitus,
unclear or conflicting information. For example, obesity, inactivity and emotional factors. Result:
reassuring information can counteract a negative increased energy, weight loss, blood pressure
view of the cardiac condition and can, therefore, control, controlled insulin responses, and an
help prevent unnecessary invalidity. If the active lifestyle.
patient’s partner is worried, it is important that
the partner as well as the patient is provided with The treatment used in cardiac rehabilitation is not all
information. given at the same level. The therapeutic approach can
vary from professional sports training to learning the
Patient-oriented exercise programs most efficient way to tie shoelaces.
In developing a patient-oriented exercise program, it
is important to take into consideration the patient’s (b) Types of exercise
goals and desires, the patient’s exercise capacity, and Cardiac rehabilitation involves a wide range of
the individual goals and choices made regarding (a) activities, such as practicing basic skills and daily life
the priorities of the exercise program, (b) the types of activities, and sports training. Therapy can take the
exercise to be used, and (c) training variables and form of fitness or aerobics exercises, swimming, or
loading. If the exercise program is directed at exercises in water. The therapeutic approach chosen
improving objective aerobic capacity, the choices must provide the most appropriate and specific way
made in selecting training variables should be based of increasing the patient’s daily activities. If therapy is
on physiological training concepts, such as focused on physical training, use of an ergometer and
specificity, overloading, supercompensation, reduced sports training are involved. ECG and blood pressure
output, and reversibility. monitoring are carried out if indicated by the
rehabilitation team.
(a) Exercise program priorities
The different exercise program priorities are described Ergometers are mostly used during training in high-
below along with the general goals to be achieved risk patients whose ECG recording, blood pressure
and with individual goals listed in parentheses: and heart rate are being monitored.
1. Practicing specific skills, with the goal of
increasing general aerobic capacity and strength (c) Training variables and loading
during motor activities (goals 1, 2, 3, 5 and 6). Examples of training variables are the intensity,
Result: improved performance of the skills and frequency and duration of training, and the length of
activities practiced, a higher level of activities of the rest intervals. However, training structure is also
8 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Table 5. Determining exercise intensity, and hence aerobic capacity level, in a training session lasting 20–60
HR-max* VO2-max * or
HR-reserve*
< 35% < 30% < 10 very light
35–59% 30–49% 10–11 light
60–79% 50–74% 12–13 medium
80–89% 75–84% 14–16 heavy
> 90% > 85% > 16 very heavy
* HR-max = maximum heart rate; VO2-max = maximum oxygen uptake; HR-reserve = HR-max - resting
heart rate.
This table has been reproduced with permission from WB Saunders Company. Source: Pollock ML, Wilmore JH. Exercise in health and disease:
evaluation and prescription for prevention and rehabilitation. Second edition. Philadelphia: WB Saunders; 1990. © 2000
important. General indications of training variable results of tests of maximum symptom-limited aerobic
values according to exercise program priorities, as capacity. Table 5 shows the relationship between
noted above, are: exercise intensity, percentage maximum heart rate
1 and 4. (HR-max), heart rate reserve (HR-reserve) or
Practicing specific functions, skills and activities maximum oxygen uptake (VO2-max), and Borg scale
while encouraging the patient to enjoy exercise: score. The reserve heart rate, which is defined as the
training frequency should be 2–3 times a week. maximum heart rate minus the heart rate in a resting
2. Aerobic exercise: training intensity should be at state, is used during training when VO2-max is
40–85% of maximum oxygen uptake and at 11–16 unknown. The Karvonen formula is used to derive
on the Borg scale; training should consist of a the heart rate during training, as follows:
warm-up period, aerobic training, and a cooling- heart rate during training = heart rate in the resting
down period, and should last 20–60 minutes; state + (X/100 x HR-reserve),
training frequency should be 3–7 days a week. where X = target percentage VO2-max.
3. Strength and aerobic exercise: training intensity
should be at 40–50% of maximum strength; each Relaxation instruction
training session should comprise 1–3 sequences of Progressive relaxation, autogenic training and deep-
10–15 repetitions with pauses lasting 1–2 minutes; breathing therapy are the approaches to relaxation
resistance should increase with time, both used during instruction. The important elements of
relatively and absolutely; training frequency these methods were used to develop the relaxation
should be 2–3 times a week. Circuit training instruction approach used in the Cardiac
should last for 20–30 minutes and should consist Rehabilitation Guidelines 1995/1996. The specific
of a warm-up period, strength training, and a type of instruction given is formulated to meet the
cooling-down period. patient’s needs and to suit the patient’s current
4. Reduction of risk factors: exercises that have a situation. Relaxation instruction takes place during
longer duration, lower intensity and higher exercise, as active relaxation, and during rest periods,
frequency are recommended for patients with as passive relaxation, or it could form part of warm-
obesity, hypertension, diabetes mellitus (type-II), up or cooling-down activities. Relaxation instruction
and lipid disorders. can also be provided by itself in a separate treatment
session. The need for relaxation instruction
Individual exercise programs are devised using the determines therapy frequency. Two or three sessions
V-08/2003/US 9
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
10 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Table 7. Physical therapy goals and means of evaluating the achievement of these goals.
4. Make a diagnosis There is insight into the • all methods used in Continuous monitoring
patient’s capabilities evaluating goal 3 during rehabilitation
• scoring before, during
and after movement
activities, Borg scale
score (see goals 1 and 2)
8. Learning to relax Patient has knowledge • questionnaire During and at the end
about relaxation and can • flow chart
use this information
to relax
V-08/2003/US 11
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
12 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
• What is the normal course of development in organizations, or both, so that a general consensus
patients eligible for cardiac rehabilitation? with other professional groups or organizations and
• Which parts of the physical therapy approach to with any other existing monodisciplinary or
treatment and prevention are valid in this group multidisciplinary guidelines could be achieved.
of patients and what are the effects of different
forms of treatment, such as movement programs The members of the working group individually
(e.g., exercises), relaxation instruction, selected and graded the documentation collected on
psychoeducational interventions, and the the basis of the quality of the scientific evidence.
provision of advice and information? Even though the scientific evidence was collected by
• Which diagnostic and evaluative measuring individuals or smaller subgroups, the results of the
instruments are useful? process were presented to and discussed by the whole
working group. Thereafter, a final summary of the
Formation of the monodisciplinary working group scientific evidence, which included details of the
In May 1998, a monodisciplinary working group of amount of evidence available, was made. In addition
professionals was formed to find answers to these to scientific evidence, other important considerations
clinical questions. In forming the working group, an were taken into account in formulating
attempt was made to achieve a balance between recommendations, such as: the achievement of a
professionals with experience in the area of concern general consensus, cost-effectiveness, the availability
and those with an academic background. Patients’ of resources, the availability of the necessary expertise
desires and preferences were expressed via the Dutch and educational facilities, organizational matters, and
Heart Foundation. All members of the working group the desire for consistency with other
stated that they had no conflicts of interest in monodisciplinary and multidisciplinary guidelines.
participating in the development of these guidelines.
Guideline development took place from May 1998 Validation by intended users
until June 2000. Before they were published and distributed, the
guidelines were systematically reviewed, for the
Monodisciplinary working group procedure purpose of validation, by the target group that would
The guidelines were developed in accordance with use the guidelines in the future. The draft KNGF
concepts outlined in a document entitled “A method guidelines on cardiac rehabilitation were tested in
for the development and implementation of clinical daily practice by members of the working group who
guidelines”.3–6 This document includes practical were working in different environments in order to
recommendations on the strategies that should be provide an overall appraisal of the guidelines. The
used for collecting scientific literature. Below, in this working group included nine physical therapists who
review of the evidence for these guidelines, details are tested the guidelines in their own working
given of the specific terms used in literature searches, environments, with their own teams, or with other
the sources searched, the publication period of the professionals working in their field. The comments
searched literature, and the criteria used to select and criticisms made by the physical therapists were
relevant literature. The recommendations made on recorded and discussed by the working group. If
therapy are almost entirely based on scientific possible or desirable, they were taken into account in
evidence. If no scientific evidence was available, the final version of the guidelines. The final
guideline recommendations were based on the recommendations on practice, then, are derived from
consensus reached within the working group or the available evidence and take into account the
between professionals working in the field. External other above-mentioned factors and the results of the
experts commented on guideline recommendations. guideline evaluation carried out by intended users
(i.e., physical therapists).
Once the draft guidelines were completed, they were
sent to a secondary working group comprising During the period 2001–2003, a prospective cohort
external professionals or members of professional study was conducted that involved cardiac
V-08/2003/US 13
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
rehabilitation patients who were treated according to coronary angioplasty (PTCA), heart valve operation,
the guidelines. Before the start of the study, and operative correction of congenital heart
documentation and reporting forms were developed disorders, together with the additional terms: exercise
for distribution at the end of the study. Patients’ therapy, movement therapy, physical therapy,
opinions were sought during the study and an postoperative care, cardiac rehabilitation, clinical
attempt was made to identify organizational aspects trial, randomized clinical trial, protocol, meta-
of treatment that could be improved, for example, by analysis, and reviews (in both Dutch and English).
obtaining information about the cost implications of Literature was also provided by working group
applying guideline recommendations. Another goal members.
was to identify criteria for ascertaining whether
guidelines are being followed (i.e., process indicators), Rehabilitation phases I, II and III
for determining the results of therapy (i.e., outcome Cardiac rehabilitation involves actions that take place
indicators), and for determining the extent of care in the following phases: during hospital admission
(i.e., benchmarks). The results of this prospective (phase I), during rehabilitation in the polyclinic
cohort study will be included in the first revision of (phase II), and after rehabilitation and during
the guidelines. aftercare (phase III).1,13 KNGF guidelines focus on
phase II, as do the multidisciplinary guidelines. The
Composition and implementation of the details of rehabilitation in phase I are given in
guidelines summary form because the period of hospital
The guidelines comprise three parts: the practice admission has been increasingly shortened and
guidelines themselves, a schematic summary of the rehabilitation treatment in this phase consequently
most important points of the guidelines, and a review reduced. Rehabilitation in phase III does not take
of the evidence. Each part can be read individually. place in the institutional healthcare sector and is not,
Immediately after publication of the guidelines and therefore, covered by these guidelines. Phase III
their distribution among members of the Dutch focuses on individual sporting and recreational
Physical Therapy Association for Cardiac and Vascular activities. In the Netherlands, physical therapists in
Diseases (NVFH), a prospective cohort study was primary healthcare sectors are involved in treatment
started, which involved implementation of the related to sport and recreation, which may include
guidelines in eleven hospitals and rehabilitation Heart-in-Movement and Heart Care Federation clubs,
centers. In addition, the guidelines were the Corefit heart rehabilitation program, and physical
implemented in accordance with the standard therapy sports centers.
method of implementation, which has been
described elsewhere.3–7 Defining cardiac rehabilitation
“Cardiac rehabilitation involves the rehabilitation of
normal activities after a cardiac incident.
Introduction to these guidelines Rehabilitation focuses on optimizing physical,
This section describes the choices made in arriving at psychological and social activities, so that the patient
the recommendations given in the KNGF guidelines on can regain a normal place in society, and on
physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation. The influencing risk factors.”14 The KNGF guidelines are
guidelines are based on Dutch Cardiac Rehabilitation based on this definition with the addition of the
guidelines,1,2 United States guidelines9–12 and recent following: “Cardiac rehabilitation involves strategic
scientific literature on cardiac rehabilitation, since training and education to promote adequate coping
1994. Literature was collected using the Cochrane behavior and optimal functioning in normal daily
Library 1999 Issue 2, MEDLINE (November 1994 to life, such that the patient’s quality of life is improved,
1999) and CINAHL (September 1994 to 1999). The and individual limitations and participation problems
following terms were used in literature searches: heart are reduced”.15
disorder, (acute) myocardial infarction (AMI), coronary
artery bypass graft (CABG), percutaneous transluminal
14 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
V-08/2003/US 15
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
specialized than in 1993. In 1998, institutions The most important prognostic factors determining
generally provided more than two exercise programs, the chance of survival and quality of life after the
in which patients were categorized as having a acute phase of a myocardial infarction are left
physically good condition or a physically poor ventricular function and the amount of vascular
condition. Around 85% of all institutions offered damage in the coronary system.25 Other prognostic
relaxation instruction, usually as part of the exercise factors that are important for recovery are the
program (81%), but sometimes individually (48%).20 patient’s psychological state, which may be affected
by exhaustion, fear or depression, and co-morbid
Risk factors and prognostic factors conditions, such as physical limitations or a
The cause of almost all coronary heart disease is cerebrovascular accident. Taking part in a
arteriosclerosis. Arteriosclerotic processes and damage rehabilitation program after a myocardial infarction
to coronary arteries depend on existing risk factors. increases the patient’s quality of life. This is especially
Influenceable risk factors include smoking, lipid the case for those whose quality of life is low or
disorders (e.g., hypercholesterolemia and whose level of cardiovascular risk is low.26
hyperlipidemia), hypertension, obesity, depression,
diabetes mellitus, stress and physical inactivity.2 Non- Secondary and tertiary prevention
influenceable risk factors include hereditary The prevention of coronary heart disease involves
tendencies, age and sex. adopting measures that focus on behavioral change,1
stopping smoking, and increasing regular physical
Definitions
Lipid imbalance: There are different forms of imbalance such as hyperlipidemia (i.e., high blood levels of
triglycerides and cholesterol) and hypercholesterolemia (i.e., a high blood cholesterol level).15 A cholesterol
level between 5 and 6.5 mmol/l is slightly high, between 6.5 and 8 mmol/l high, and greater than 8 mmol/l
very high. (Source: Dutch cholesterol consensus document).16
Hypertension: Hypertension is defined as a systolic blood pressure (SBP) of 140 mmHg or more or a diastolic
blood pressure (DBP) of 90 mmHg or more, or both, in persons not taking medications for high blood
pressure.17 For adults over 18 years of age, the following hypertension categories are used:17
• grade 1 (mild hypertension): SBP of 140–159 mmHg or DPB of 90–99 mmHg;
• grade 2 (medium hypertension): SBP of 160–179 mmHg or DBP of 100–109 mmHg;
• grade 3 (severe hypertension): SBP > 180 mmHg or DBP > 110 mmHg.
Obesity: The most commonly used method for assessing body weight is the Quetelet index (QI), which is
also referred to the body mass index (BMI). To obtain the QI, body weight in kilograms is divided by body
height in meters squared. The World Health Organization proposed the following weight classification for
adults on the basis of the QI:18
• normal weight: QI = 18.5–24.9 kg/m2;
• overweight (level I): QI = 25.0–29.9 kg/m2;
• obesity (level II): QI = 30.0–39.9 kg/m2;
• morbid obesity (level III): QI > 40 kg/m2.
People with obesity are at a higher risk of physical inactivity, hypertension and hypercholesterolemia
because they are overweight.1
Diabetes mellitus: In diabetes, there is absolute (type-I diabetes) or relative (type-II diabetes) insulin
deficiency, which leads to hyperglycemia. People with diabetes area t a higher risk of developing
retinopathy, nephropathy, vascular diseases and neuropathy.15
16 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
activity. Healthy eating habits have a positive patient information, group training techniques, and
influence on such risk factors as being overweight, guiding exercise. Patients can work towards several
hypercholesterolemia, and hypertension. Additional goals using one or more exercises and the physical
instruction is necessary for patients who find it therapist must adjust activities, as appropriate.2
difficult to take medications or to develop trust in Dutch physical therapists who provide instruction on
therapy.2 relaxation therapy in groups must follow a basic
course entitled “Relaxation instruction”, which is
Physical therapist’s role provided by the Dutch Heart Foundation. Providing
The physical therapist’s specific role in the individual therapy involving deep-breathing and
rehabilitation team concerns the patient’s functional relaxation techniques necessitates specialized
movement. On the basis of history-taking and education in subjects such as haptic therapy, the
functional assessment, the physical therapist analyses Feldenkrais method, deep-breathing therapy and
the patient’s movement capabilities and limitations, psychosomatic therapy.
identifies influenceable risk factors, and develops a
treatment plan. The main goal of physical therapy is
to influence the patient’s movement capabilities Rehabilitation phase I
positively so that his or her participation in society is Once a diagnosis has been made and surgery carried
optimized. The patient’s interests are central in out, therapy in this phase involves the provision of
devising the treatment plan, and the patient and appropriate medical treatment, early mobilization,
physical therapist must work well together as a and giving information on heart disease, on any
team.27 associated surgery and on risk factors and prevention.
Referral data should include the diagnosis, the dates
Physical therapy qualifications of the infarct and operation, details of any
Physical therapists working with patients in cardiac complications, and the reasons for referral.
rehabilitation have knowledge and experience that Additional referral information detailing the patient’s
they acquired while obtaining their physical therapy current level of mobility and the cardiologist’s advice
qualifications. In the Netherlands, they will know may be necessary. Table 8 provides an overview of
about publications such as the “Cardiac information the cardiologist may provide.
Rehabilitation Guidelines 1995/1996” and “Physical
therapy in cardiac rehabilitation”. They must have Diagnosis
adequate knowledge and experience of behavior- History-taking provides the physical therapist with
orientated principles, the methodical provision of information about: the patient’s concerns; the
V-08/2003/US 17
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Table 8. Cardiac information that may be provided by a cardiologist. Reproduced, in an adapted form, from a
report on a 1994 symposium on cardiac rehabilitation. 29 NYHA = New York Heart Association classification.
Non-surgical Surgical
• medical condition on admission • type of operation:
• thrombosis: yes/no - number of bypasses
• reperfusion: yes/no - arterial or venous grafts
• size of myocardial infarction: • valve:
- creatine kinase and creatine kinase vtype of valve operation
(MB fraction)
- levels • left ventricular function
- echographic wall-motion score
- left ventricular resting function • cardiac complications (e.g., rhythm disorders,
• myocardial infarction location pericardial fluid, pleural fluid or decompensation)
• complications: • non-cardiac complications (e.g., atelectasis,
- rhythm disorders infiltration, wound problems or cerebrovascular
- cardiac decompensation accident) and co-morbid conditions
- post-infarct angina pectoris • cardiac history
- NYHA grading • test results:
- cardiac aneurysm - thorax X-ray
• cardiac history - echography
• test results: - ergometric tests*
- thorax X-ray - lung function
- ejection fraction
- coronary angiography
- ergometric tests*
- thallium scintigraphy
- lung function • medication
• relevant laboratory results: hemoglobin and • diagnosis
cholesterol levels • reasons for referral
• medication • psychological information
• diagnosis • work rehabilitation information and prognosis
• reasons for referral • family information
• psychological information
• work rehabilitation information and prognosis
• family information
18 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
This table has been reproduced with permission from the American College of Sports Medicine ( ACSM). Source: American College of Sports
Medicine. ACSM guidelines for exercise testing and prescription. Philadelphia and Baltimore: Lippincott William & Wilkins; 2000. © 2000.
the size of infarct and any complications that arise disease, coping with symptoms, medical treatment,
within five to ten days, on average. During the acute risk factors and the level of activity desirable during
phase, the patient will be in hospital for cardiac care rehabilitation at home. The optimum levels of
and will stay there for a few days. For patients with physical activity and stress to be applied during
pulmonary problems, such as chronic obstructive treatment depend on the patient’s current exercise
pulmonary disease, physical therapy focuses on capacity. The end criteria for physical therapy are: the
monitoring mucus clearance and ventilation. The end patient can function at the desired level of activities
criterion for physical therapy is that there are no of daily living; the patient’s aerobic capacity level has
longer any objective signs of pulmonary difficulty. improved, both subjectively and objectively, to
The acute phase ends when the patient meets the greater than 3 MET’s; the patient has knowledge
following criteria: there is hemodynamic stability, the about heart disease and can deal responsibly with the
relevant enzyme levels have been reduced, there are condition; the patient has knowledge about risk
no serious rhythm disturbances or conduction factors; and the patient understands how he or she
disorders, and all pulmonary complications have can deal appropriately with symptoms. To achieve
been eliminated. these, the physical therapist must, therefore,
determine the patient’s normal level of activities of
After the acute phase, the patient is moved to another daily living and identify any risk factors.
hospital ward where mobilization can begin. During
this mobilization phase, the physical therapist helps During rehabilitation, the physical therapist should
the patient achieve the desired level of daily activity be alert to signs of patient distress and overloading
(see Table 9). It is also the physical therapist’s (see Table 10). Vascular problems are indicated when
responsibility to inform the patient about heart angina pectoris, dyspnea or exhaustion occurs during
V-08/2003/US 19
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
• angina pectoris;
• left ventricular systolic disfunctions;
- shortness of breath;
- excessive exhaustion for the level of physical activity;
• rhythm disorders;
- faster than expected heart rate for the level of physical activity;
- irregular heart rate, alterations in normal rhythm;
• abnormally high or low blood pressure;
• fainting;
• dizziness;
• orthosympathetic responses (e.g., sweating or pallor).
low-level exercise. Dyspnea is an important symptom methods of mucus clearance, and advising
of serious stenosis of the left coronary artery or the patients.30,31 The postoperative phase is split into two
frontal descending coronary artery. Abnormally high phases: the first immediately follows the operation
blood pressure is a systolic pressure above 250 mmHg when the patient is in the intensive care unit and
and a diastolic pressure above 120 mmHg. A diastolic lasts, on average, one or two days; the second, the
pressure that is more than 25 mmHg higher than in mobilization phase, lasts 4–10 days in the recovery
the resting state can indicate coronary heart disease. ward. The goals of physical therapy in intensive care
The occurrence of hypotension or low blood pressure are to identify problems with mucus clearance and
at higher levels of exertion can indicate left ventilation and, if necessary, to teach techniques for
ventricular difficulty. This is usually seen in patients coughing, blowing and breathing (see Figure 1). In
with serious ischemic heart disease or chronic heart the mobilization phase, the treatment goals are
failure. Supraventricular rhythm disorders can occur identical to those following myocardial infarction,
in heart disease, or may be secondary to endocrine or with additional information being given about the
metabolic factors, or may result from the use of operation. The physical therapist should provide the
certain medicines. Ventricular rhythm disorders may patient with information about the pain occurring in
be associated with mitral valve prolapse, with the operated areas and about wound care. Guidelines
hypertrophic and idiopathic cardiomyopathies (i.e., developed by Dutch clinical physical therapy
heart muscle disorders), and with heart valve rehabilitation teams in university hospitals, and
disorders.10 entitled “Guidelines for peri-operative physical
therapy of the lung with abdominal and heart
(b) Rehabilitation after surgical treatment surgery”,30 advise the following: provide appropriate
Rehabilitation phase 1 includes preoperative and breathing exercises that concentrate on maximizing
postoperative phases. In the preoperative phase, the inspiration and that involve holding deep breaths for
patient is prepared for the operation. The treatment a few seconds. Teaching effective coughing, blowing
goal in this phase is to inform the patient about and forced expiration techniques is useful for helping
previous lung disorders and other potential problems mucus clearance. Particular attention should be paid
(e.g., paralysis, muscle disease or Bechterew’s disease) to encouraging the patient to become self-reliant
that could have a negative effect on postoperative during mobilization as early as possible.
recovery. Preexisting lung disorders are treated if
indicated by a physician or pulmonologist.
Preoperative pulmonary therapy consists of: Rehabilitation phase II
explaining the goals of physical therapy, teaching The need for rehabilitation in the polyclinic is
techniques for improving ventilation, teaching about indicated in the physician’s referral documentation.
20 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Operation
Analysis
Combination of preoperative and postoperative:
higher risk
Treatment plan
higher risk
1. Improve ventilation: 3. Advice:
- maximum inspiration Patient:
- chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, - maximum inspiration
pressed-lip breathing five time per hour
Physician:
2. Improve mucus removal: - painkillers
of the lung with abdominal and heart surgery. University of Amsterdam, the Netherlands: 1997. © 2000.
Evaluation
Low • normal left ventricular function (i.e., ejection fraction > 50%);
• absence of complex arrhythmias while resting and during aerobic capacity exercises;
• no complications during the clinical phase (i.e., absence of chronic heart failure and
symptoms of ischemia);
• hemodynamic stability while resting and during aerobic capacity exercises;
• no symptoms (e.g., absence of angina pectoris during aerobic capacity exercises);
• functional capacity greater than 7 MET’s1;
• absence of depression.
For a patient to be classified as low-risk, it is assumed that all the characteristics in this category are present.
Medium • moderate limitation of left ventricular function (i.e., ejection fraction = 35–49%);
• symptoms, including angina pectoris, occur during or after exercising at a medium
aerobic capacity level (i.e., 5–6.9 MET’s).
All patients who do not fit into the low-risk or high-risk categories are classified as medium risk.
High • poor left ventricular function (i.e., ejection fraction < 35%);
• status after successful resuscitation;
• complex ventricular arrhythmias while resting and during aerobic capacity exercises;
• myocardial infarction or heart operation with complications such as cardiac shock,
congestive heart failure or symptoms of repeated or persistent ischemia;
• hemodynamic instability during aerobic capacity exercises, especially systolic blood
pressure reduction or chronotropic incompetence with increasing exercise;
• symptoms, including angina pectoris, occur during or after light aerobic capacity
exercises
(< 5 MET’s);
• functional capacity less than 5 MET’s2;
• clinically significant depression.
For a patient to be classified as high-risk, it is assumed that at least one of the characteristics listed in this
category is present.
This table has been reproduced with permission from the American Association of Cardiovascular and Pulmonary Rehabilitation. Guidelines for
cardiac and secondary prevention programs, 3rd edition. Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics; 1999.(51)
Additional screening is carried out by the heart rhythm or conduction disorders, details of any
rehabilitation team to ascertain indications for risk factors, and details of medicine usage. The
therapy.2 Referral information should, at a minimum, cardiologist will appraise the patient’s exercise capacity
include the physician’s diagnosis, relevant and estimate the level of risk using all diagnostic
cardiological diagnostic information, details of any information available (see Table 11). A low risk level is
22 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Table 12. Questions in the five areas of enquiry used in rehabilitation screening, taken from the Cardiac
Rehabilitation Guidelines 1995/1996:(1,2)
I. Has aerobic capacity been reduced objectively, in terms of the patient’s ability to work and carry out
domestic and leisure activities? Are there any motor limitations that restrict the patient’s functional
abilities?
II. Has aerobic capacity been reduced subjectively because of a fear of physical activity (including sexual
activity) or because the patient is highly aware of being disabled?
III. Has the patient’s emotional balance been threatened? Does the patient cope with the condition
inadequately? In other words: Is there a relationship between present and optimal psychological
functioning?
IV. Is social functioning threatened? What is the prognosis for the patient’s return to a normal social role in
relation to work, leisure and family relationships? What is the quality and extent of the patient’s social
network?
V. Are there any influenceable risky behaviors, involving, for example, smoking, diet, physical inactivity, or
non-compliance with therapy?
associated with a high degree of physical capability, and Psychological Questionnaire for Heart Patients
and vice versa. (MPVH)”,36 the “Maastricht Questionnaire on
Exhaustion and Depression (MV)” and the “Cardio Fear
The rehabilitation team screens patients by means of Test (HAT)” together give an assessment of the patient’s
questions on five areas of enquiry relating to the level of life satisfaction. A checklist of risk factors is
patient’s physical and social functioning and to the used to assess risky lifestyles objectively (question V in
presence of risky behavior (see Table 12). Evaluation Table 12). It can also be useful to look at specific
criteria provide a guide to the patient’s present and characteristics of the patient, such as the patient’s
future functional status. Screening is carried out by personality and whether the patient’s partner is being
means of a clinical assessment, a maximum symptom- overprotective.37,38 The physical therapist’s diagnosis
limited aerobic capacity test, and a psychological forms part of the screening process carried out by the
assessment. If these objective measures coupled to rehabilitation team.
clinical judgement fail to provide sufficient
information to answer screening questions, it is Diagnosis
necessary to use a questionnaire to obtain additional In diagnosis, the goals of physical therapy are to
information about the patient’s physical, psychological determine the severity and cause of any health
and social functioning, about risk factors and about problems affecting the patient’s mobility and whether
the lifestyle choices made by the patient. In this it is possible to influence them. The starting point is
situation, screening is distinct from evaluation. The the patient’s concerns and needs. The physical
decision on which questionnaire to use can be made therapist will investigate the patient’s health
with the aid of the “Leiden Screening Questionnaire problems and symptoms, the health state the patient
for Heart Patients (LSVH)”33 and the “Maastricht wishes to attain, the existence of any factors that
Screening Questionnaire for Heart Patients (MSVH)”.34 hinder or promote recovery, and the patient’s
These screening questionnaires both include elements information needs. The diagnostic process involves
that are used in rehabilitation evaluation. For example, history-taking, assessment and analysis.
the “Quality of Life after Myocardial Infarction
Instrument (QLMI)’35 forms part of the “Leiden History-taking
Screening Questionnaire for Heart Patients”. Moreover, In history-taking, information is obtained partly by
the questionnaires cover physical, psychological and the rehabilitation team, and includes referral data
social factors as well as quality of life. The “Medical from the cardiologist, and partly from the patient
V-08/2003/US 23
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
himself or herself. See Table 13 for details. The physical therapist should determine the patient’s
aerobic capacity level using the maximum symptom-
The clinical guidelines advise using a standard limited exercise test and estimate of the skill level
questionnaire during history-taking, especially for needed by the patient to carry out the motor
those carrying out history-taking for the first time. In functions involved in his or her normal daily
addition to the assessment techniques described activities. The physical therapist must taken into
above in the introduction to rehabilitation phase II, account coordination, movement efficiency, muscle
use can also be made of the “Patient-specific strength, flexibility and the patient’s psychological
complaints” questionnaire, of specific visual analogue state. The patient’s psychological state indicates to
scales, and of “numerical rating scales” for the physical therapist which course of treatment
quantifying the nature, duration and extent of should be followed. The working group advises that
activity problems. For details, see Supplement 2 on measuring instruments should be used during
measuring instruments. assessment, for example: the MET’s method, which
Assessment quantifies the activities the patient finds most
Investigating the patient’s level of activity before the present health problem, and the course of the
health problem and its prognosis:
• Which impairments, limitations and problems with social participation does the patient experience as a
result of heart disease?
• Which physical disorders were caused by the heart disease?
• Which emotional disorders were caused by the heart disease?
• Briefly describe how the patient’s symptoms relate to the onset and progression of the condition.
• Which underlying factors contributed to the disorder?
- disease course (e.g., poor circulation)
- prognostic and risk factors:
- local: e.g., left ventricular function or coronary artery condition (one, two or three vascular
disorders?)
- general: risky behavior such as an inactive lifestyle, smoking, stress (e.g., sleep problems), fear or
depression.
- treatment and the effects of treatment.
24 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
V-08/2003/US 25
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
• the patient’s current exercise capacity, expressed in terms of VO2, MET’s units or watts, as derived from
symptom-limited tests;
• the protocol in use;
• the cardiologist’s estimate of aerobic capacity level based on cardiograms made before, during and after
physical exertion (there are criteria for cardiac ischemia and rhythm disorders and the practical
consequences of these conditions);
• resting heart rate, maximum achievable heart rate, and heart rate after recovery;
• blood pressure while resting, during exertion and during recovery;
• reasons for not completing the tests;
• medication use before and during testing;
• the patient’s subjective symptoms during testing (e.g. angina pectoris or dyspnea).
prognostic information using the symptom-limited are recommended. If improving aerobic capacity is
exercise test (i.e., using an ergometer). Therapeutic indicated, then goals 1 and 3 are recommended. If
goals then depend on cardiac capacity, the maximum there is a subjective decrease in aerobic capacity,
symptom-limited heart rate, maximum aerobic treatment should focus on goals 1 and 5. The
capacity, and maximum acceptable exercise problem areas covered by goals 1 and 5 are usually
duration.2 The maximum symptom-limited exercise the initial focus of treatment. For example, the
test for cardiac patients indicates maximum oxygen patient must first reduce the level of fear or learn
consumption (peak VO2) and, thereby, maximum what his or her personal limits are before being ready
aerobic capacity.2 Table 14 outlines the information for training. If there is no clear objective reduction in
that can be obtained from ergometric tests. aerobic capacity, then goal number 4 is
recommended.1
There are six specific goals of physical therapy, which
correspond to goals specified by multidisciplinary Goals must be clearly formulated at the beginning of
guidelines (the numbers in square brackets refer to treatment. For example, it is preferable to formulate
the goals listed in the Cardiac Rehabilitation goals such as “the patient should able to cycle” or
Guidelines 1995/1996):1,2 “the patient should able to continue with sexual
1. Learning to find one’s own physical limits [1]. activities” rather than “the patient has overcome fear
2. Learning to deal with physical limitations [2]. of movement”. A goal such as “improving lifestyle
3. Finding the optimum aerobic capacity level [3]. activities” is better formulated as “the patient should
4. Diagnosis: evaluating the aerobic capacity level able to walk twice a day for 30 minutes”.2
and correlating symptoms with objective disorders
[4]. On the basis of information obtained during
5. Reducing fear of movement [5]. diagnosis, the patient can be allocated to an exercise
6. Developing and attaining a physically active group in which rehabilitation exercises match the
lifestyle [14]. patient’s exercise capacity. Corstjens et al.39
developed three exercise groups:
The physical therapist can also have an influence on 1. an exercise group for, usually young, patients with
the achievement of other goals, such as achieving high exercise capacity;
secondary prevention [12–16], acquiring emotional 2. a less-intensive exercise group for less physically
balance [6], and learning how to deal with heart capable patients; and
disease in a functional manner [7]. Each patient 3. a functional exercise group for, usually elderly,
usually has a combination of goals. If improving patients with poor exercise capacity.
aerobic capacity is not indicated, then goals 1 and 2 It is important when allocating patients to exercise
26 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
groups to bear in mind that high-frequency programs Cardiac rehabilitation programs that focus on
are more effective in counteracting psychological physical training, developing a healthy lifestyle, and
complaints40 and low-frequency programs are more relaxation techniques help patients to recover and
effective in encouraging self-sufficiency and self- increase aerobic capacity, slow down atherosclerotic
confidence.37 processes, and reduce the risk of further cardiac
events.1,2,28,41–43
V-08/2003/US 27
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Table 15. Effects of aerobic training on the cardiorespiratory system. Source: Jongert et al.(52)
follow-up period of five years, improvements were programs to screen for cardiovascular complications
observed in cardiorespiratory status, psychological and for specific medical conditions. They give the
well-being and quality of life. There was also a following exclusion criteria for intensive muscle
reduction in the risk of early death and strength training: abnormal hemodynamics or
improvements in work and occupational ischemia noted on ECG recordings during aerobic
performances. Stahle et al.’s51 randomized trial activities, poor left ventricular function (i.e., an
compared the physiological effects of aerobic training ejection fraction of less than 30%), unstable angina
and giving exercise advice in a group of elderly pectoris, acute heart failure, malignant hypertension,
patients (> 65 years old) with those of a program uncontrolled rhythm disorders, and serious aortic
providing only exercise advice. Significant stenosis or aneurysm. Verrill et al. recommend
improvements in aerobic capacity and well-being strength and resistance exercises for patients with
were found in the group of patients who took part in functional capacities of 6 MET’s or more. Low-risk or
the aerobic training program. Table 15 outlines the medium-risk patients (see Table 11 above) who have
effects of aerobic training on the cardiorespiratory functional capacities of less then 6 MET’s should use
system. low-resistance exercises.
28 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Table 16. Effects of strength training on skeletal muscle. Source : Jongert et al.(52)
• functional hypertrophy;
• increased mitochondrial numbers (mitochondrial hypertrophy);
• increased capillary circulation;
• increase in muscle enzymes;
• increased energy-rich phosphate level.
more easily. Table 16 outlines the effects of strength which included educational components, reacted
training on skeletal muscle. better to hyperlipidemia treatment than patients
who did not undergo cardiac rehabilitation. The
Other effects of exercise educational component of the program promotes
• Less angina pectoris in patients with coronary secondary prevention by providing knowledge
heart disease, and fewer symptoms of chronic about low-lipid diets and by increasing trust in
heart failure in patients with left ventricular therapeutic recommendations concerning diet
systolic dysfunction (scientific evidence: level B). and medication use.
The symptoms of angina pectoris are also reduced • Cardiac rehabilitation in patients who have had a
by psychological and education interventions, myocardial infarction or who have received a
counseling, and behavioral change (components coronary artery bypass graft leads to increased
of multifactorial rehabilitation).9 participation in exercise after rehabilitation
• In the past, exercise programs, with or without (scientific evidence: level B). The effect is short
psychological and educational preventative lived, however, and it is, therefore, advisable to
measures and stress management, have been provide further cardiac rehabilitation on a long-
shown to have positive effects on psychological term basis to encourage both exercise and the
functioning.41,46,56 However, these findings have adoption of an active lifestyle. It is important to
not been supported by more recent encourage patients to find a form of exercise that
research.49,57,58 These inconsistencies have had they enjoy and that they find easy to continue.9
the result that additional screening is now carried
out in heart patients in order to ensure good Pathophysiological effects 9
healthcare, to ensure that personal goals are met, • Exercise programs administered in combination
and to assess the relationships between different with extensive dietary control and any necessary
components of exercise programs and the results hyperlipidemia medications slow the progression
achieved.49 of coronary arteriosclerosis, as observed
• Positive effects on social functioning (scientific angiographically, and are, therefore,
evidence: level B). Exercise programs improve recommended. Rehabilitation that involves only
social functioning.9 an exercise program has been shown to be less
• Exercise programs combined with educational and effective (scientific evidence: level A/B).
psychological interventions also influence: • There is no evidence showing that exercise
smoking (scientific evidence: level B), programs influence the development of a
hyperlipidemia (scientific evidence: level B), collateral coronary circulation or cause consistent
obesity (scientific evidence: level C) and changes in cardiac hemodynamic measurements
hypertension (scientific evidence: level B). Cardiac made during cardiac catheterization. Exercise
rehabilitation involving only exercise programs programs for patients who have chronic heart
has a smaller effect on these risk factors.9 In a failure and, therefore, also reduced ventricular
randomized clinical trial, Vergès et al.59 showed ejection fractions, result in positive changes in the
that patients with chronic heart disease who peripheral musculature and are, therefore,
completed intensive rehabilitation programs, recommended for improving muscle function
V-08/2003/US 29
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
(scientific evidence: level B). At present, more then twenty studies demonstrate
• Exercise programs reduce myocardial ischemia that relaxation therapy is effective in patients with
(scientific evidence: level B). coronary heart disease. Most of these studies are
• Exercise programs have small positive effects on randomized clinical trials. About half of the research
the ventricular ejection fraction and on is on the beneficial effects of supplementing
abnormalities in ventricular wall motion. rehabilitation that involves exercise modules in
However, they are not recommended for polyclinics.60,61 Research covers a large variety of
improving ventricular systolic function. Exercise methods and there is a large variation in results. Table
programs have different effects on left ventricular 17 outlines the results of these studies. The use of
function in patients who are recovering from relaxation therapy after exertion has received the
frontal infarctions, who exhibit Q waves in their most research interest – resting cardiac oxygen
ECGs and who have left ventricular dysfunction consumption is reduced by relaxation. This is
(scientific evidence: level B). confirmation that relaxation increases physiological
• Exercise programs have no consistent effects on aerobic capacity. For this reason, it is important that
ventricular rhythm disorders (scientific evidence: all patients have the opportunity to learn relaxation
level B). methods. It is possible that relaxation helps
physiological adaptations consolidate the effects of
Effects of relaxation instruction training. In other words, relaxation therapy can lead
Table 17. Overview of the effects of relaxation therapy. The second and third columns give the number of studies
in which the improvement in the group receiving relaxation therapy was greater than or equal to, respectively,
that in the control group.(60,61)
30 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
to an increase training intensity. A few studies have information about the disorder and rehabilitation, to
investigated myocardial ischemia, by looking at ST influence compliance, and to help the patient adopt
depression and by using thallium scintigraphy, and an adequate way of coping with the condition, which
rhythm disorders. In these studies, positive effects may involve dealing with fear. For more information,
were also found. see Supplement 1 on patient education.
V-08/2003/US 31
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
32 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Table 18. Summary of training variable values recommended for patients with cardiovascular problems by
guidelines developed by different organizations.
Strength training:
Method minimum one set, 10–15 one set, 10–15 repetitions, one set, 12–15 repetitions,
repetitions, large muscle 8–10 exercises, large 8–10 exercises, large
groups, start with low muscle groups muscle groups before
resistance small muscle groups
College of Sports Medicine gives a range of values. • Diabetes: training intensity of 50–90% of HR-max
The Cardiac Rehabilitation Guidelines 1995/19962 or 50–85% of VO2-max (a lower intensity may be
recommend that patients should train at 50–60% of necessitated by complications or chronic
their reserve heart rate in the first half of movement diabetes); training duration of 20–60 minutes;
training modules and at 60–80% in the second half. training frequency of 4–7 days a week.
Static strength exercises are effective when training is • Obesity: training intensity of 50–70% of peak
carried out at 30–40% of maximum voluntary muscle VO2; training duration of 40–60 minutes (or two
strength. Optimal effects are achieved at 50–60% of 20–30 minute sessions a day); training frequency
maximum. Above 70% of maximum, effectiveness of 5 days a week; more important to build up
begins to level off.2 duration than intensity.
• Hyperlipidemia: 40–70% of peak VO2 or 11–16*
The training variable values recommended for on the Borg scale; training duration of 40
reducing the effects of specific risk factors are:24 minutes; training frequency of 1–2 sessions, 5–7
• Hypertension: training intensity of 50–85% of HR- days a week; more important to build up duration
max or 40–70% of VO2-max or 11–13 on the Borg than intensity.
scale; training duration of 30–60 minutes; training
frequency of 3–7 days a week; strength training is
given with many repetitions and low resistance.
V-08/2003/US 33
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Calculating the intensity of aerobic capacity specified training load for a relatively long period of
exercises time without stopping. There are two levels of
The intensity of individual exercises can be calculated intensity: extensive continuous training, which is
using information from a maximum or symptom- characterized by a relatively long duration and
limited aerobic capacity test. The reserve heart rate relatively low intensity, and intensive continuous
(HR-reserve), which equals maximum heart rate training, which is characterized by a relatively short
minus resting heart rate, is used during training when duration and relatively high intensity. The minimum
VO2-max is unknown. The Karvonen formula is used training duration required for training to have a
to derive the heart rate target during training, as central effect on maximum aerobic capacity is 20–30
follows:2,69 minutes. Therefore, to achieve an effect, it is
heart rate during training = heart rate in the resting necessary, first, to build up to the minimum training
state + (X/100 x HR-reserve), duration and, then, to increase training intensity. As
where X = target percentage VO2-max. the patient’s physical condition improves, the focus
of the exercise program changes from extensive
Calculating the intensity of strength exercises continuous training to intensive continuous training.
Using the pyramid diagram shown in Figure 2, an If the patient is severely overweight, or suffers from
estimate of maximum muscle strength can be made extreme hypertension, diabetes mellitus or
without having to determine directly the maximum hypercholesterolemia, the total training duration can
weight a patient can pick up only once. The patient be increased while the intensity is kept at a low level.
should choose a weight that he or she can lift about In this way, the main focus of training is on
10 times and it should then be determined how metabolizing fat.52
many times he or she can repeatedly lift the weight
in practice. The total number of repetitions the In intermittent training, periods of intensive training
patient can make is related to a percentage on Figure are alternated with periods of rest or less intensive
2. The weight, in kg, is multiplied by the percentage training. By choosing the right duration and intensity
to obtain an estimate of maximum muscle strength. of intermittent training, it is possible to influence
different metabolic systems, such as alactic anaerobic,
Figure 2. Pyramid diagram relating the number of lactic anaerobic or aerobic metabolism.2 Intermittent
times a patient can repeatedly lift a specified weight to training enables patients to prepare themselves for
the desired training intensity and duration.
Intermittent training is particularly recommended for
patients with peripheral arterial disease and
intermittent claudication.24
34 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
medication significantly reduces the maximum heart and an explanation of stress and relaxation, and how
rate. The magnitude of the reduction in maximum to incorporated relaxation into an exercise program.
heart rate depends on the dose and type of beta- If instructing the patient in a group does not have the
blocker. The nature of beta-blocker administration required effect, the patient can be given individual
determines the relationship between exercise load relaxation instruction. Individual sessions are
and heart rate. Therefore, the dose, intake time and recommended for patients who are likely to be
type of beta-blocker must be the same for all tests receptive to relaxation therapy and who are willing to
carried out during the rehabilitation program. A accept change, and for those who did not receive
change in one of these three parameters can lead to a enough information during relaxation instruction to
change in heart rate during exercise. In order to enable it to be effective. For all these patients, it is
provide effective maximum aerobic training for important that attention is paid to the existence of
patients taking beta-blockers, the heart rate must be any underlying psychological factors. If any are
relatively high during training, in terms of percentage present, patients should be referred for guided
maximum heart rate. It is advisable to keep training conversation therapy.72 For more information on
intensity at a level at which the heart rate is 70–90% relaxation instruction, Dutch readers should refer to
of the maximum measured while the patient is taking the Cardiac Rehabilitation Guidelines 1995/19962
the beta-blocker. The results of training are usually and the published conclusions of a workshop entitled
good in patients using beta-blockers. However, those “Relaxation instruction in cardiac rehabilitation”.72
who take beta-blockers because of hypertension have
poorer results.24 The results of training in patients Evaluation
taking other forms of medication, such as ACE In addition to carrying out continuous evaluation
inhibitors, calcium antagonists and diuretics, are also during treatment, thorough evaluations should take
good.71 place every four weeks during treatment and at the
end of therapy. The choice of evaluation instrument
Relaxation instruction made by the physical therapist depends on the
It is recommended that every cardiac patient learns specific goals of therapy. Table 19 describes the
about or experiences relaxation exercises.2 The aims desired end result for each goal along with the
of these exercises are: to enable patients to learn recommended means of reliably evaluating the
about their physical limits, to improve aerobic achievement of these goals. In the final evaluation, it
capacity, to help patients regain an emotional is determined whether: (a) the patient has achieved
balance, and to help them find a practical way of the specified goals; (b) the patient has partially
dealing with heart disease. There are many ways in achieved the specified goals and it is expected that he
which relaxation instruction can contribute to or she will achieve the treatment subgoals by
cardiac rehabilitation. Being able to relax has a independently continuing treatment activities at
positive effect on recovery and can enable patients to home; or (c) the patient has not achieved the
exercise without stress. Becoming aware of stress and specified goals but is thought to have reached his or
learning to sense the position of one’s body in space her maximum capacity. In the last case, the patient is
enables patients to understand their physical sent back to the rehabilitation team. A description of
limitations. The sense of inner peace that comes the measuring instruments used is given in
about during relaxation can reduce feelings of fear Supplement 2. The first evaluation should be carried
and depression. Moreover, learning to deal with stress out after four to six group relaxation sessions. The
in daily life improves social functioning. Together flow chart in Figure 3 provides an explanation of the
these factors influence psychological balance and processes involved in evaluating relaxation therapy.
help patients find a practical way of dealing with
heart disease. There are even positive effects over the
long term.
V-08/2003/US 35
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Table 19. Physical therapy goals and measuring instruments used for evaluating the achievement of these goals.
1. Learn about physical Patient knows own • the top five problem Beginning and end
limits physical limits and areas are identified
activity levels achievable and scored using a
questionnaire (visual
2. Learn to cope with Patient can cope with analogue scales could
physical limitations physical limitations also be used)
• activity problems are
identified and scored
using the fear,
dyspnea and/or
angina pectoris scale
• Borg scale scores on
exhaustion, chest
pain and shortness of
breath are obtained
• if necessary, heart rate
and blood pressure
are monitored
3. Optimize aerobic Aerobic capacity is • questionnaire (as in Beginning and every four
capacity level optimum for the patient goals 1 and 2) weeks
• ergometer
• MET’s units, specific
activity scale, six-
minute walking test
4. Make a diagnosis There is insight into the • all instruments used Continuous monitoring
patient’s capabilities in evaluating goal 3 during rehabilitation
• scoring before, during
and after movement
activities, Borg scale
score (see goals 1 and 2)
7. Attaining knowledge Patient has knowledge • risk factor checklist Beginning and end
about secondary about secondary
prevention prevention
8. Learning to relax Patient has knowledge a- • questionnaire During and at the end
bout relaxation and can use • flow chart
this information to relax
36 V-08/2003/US
GROEPSMODULE (4-6 KEER)
V-08/2003/US
most a few all
yes
* DEFINING THE PROBLEM
is another course of
satisfactory none or not enough* referral
sufficient action necessary?
yes
how well-motivated is
the patient?
Figure 3. Flow chart explaining the process of evaluating relaxation instruction throughout therapy.
sufficiently insufficiently
37
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Ending therapy and reporting therapy in this group of patients may have an impact
The rehabilitation team is informed about the on the knowledge contained in these guidelines. The
treatment process and about treatment results during prescribed method for developing and implementing
and at the end of treatment. In addition, advice is guidelines in general proposes that all guidelines
given on aftercare. It is decided in consultation with should be revised a maximum of three to five years
the rehabilitation team whether rehabilitation should after the original publication.4,5 This means that the
continue or end. For more information on reporting, KNGF, together with the working group, will decide
the Dutch reader is referred to KNGF guidelines on whether these guidelines are still accurate by 2006 at
reporting.73 the latest. If necessary, a new working group will be
set up to revise the guidelines. These guidelines will
Aftercare no longer be valid if there are new developments that
During rehabilitation, the patient must receive necessitate a revision.
information that encourages the continuation of
rehabilitation activities after discharge. For example, Before any revision is carried out, the recommended
information can be given on walking, cycling, or method of guideline development and
joining a gym. It is important that patients choose implementation should also be updated on the basis
exercises that they enjoy and can continue for a long of any new knowledge and to take into account any
time. Patients and their partners can be referred to cooperative agreements made between the different
local heart patient clubs (e.g. Heart-in-Movement and groups of guideline developers working in the
Heart Care Federation clubs in the Netherlands) and Netherlands. The details of any consensus reached by
to heart rehabilitation programs such as Corefit. Evidence-Based Guidelines Meetings (i.e., the EBRO
Corefit is a fitness program in the Netherlands in platform), which are organized under the auspices of
which patients can work on their physical condition. the (Dutch) Collaborating Center for Quality
CORE stands for Cardiopulmonary, Osteoporosis, Assurance in Healthcare (CBO), will also be taken into
Recreation and Education.74 account in any updated version of the method of
guideline development and implementation. For
example, the stipulation that uniform and
Legal significance of the guidelines transparent methods are necessary for determining
These guidelines are not statutory regulations. They the amount of evidence needed and for deriving
provide knowledge and make recommendations practice recommendations would constitute an
based on the results of scientific research, which important improvement.
healthcare workers must take fully into account if
high-quality care is to be provided. Since the
recommendations mainly refer to the average patient, External financing
healthcare workers must use their professional The production of these guidelines was subsidized by
judgement to decide when to deviate from the the (Dutch) Ministry of Public Healthcare, Welfare
guidelines if that is required in a particular patient’s and Sport (VWS) within the framework of a program
situation. Whenever there is a deviation from entitled “A quality support policy for allied health
guideline recommendations, it must be justified and professions (OKPZ)”. The interests of the subsidizing
documented.4,5 Responsibility, therefore, resides with body have not influenced the content of the
the individual physical therapist.8 guidelines nor the resulting recommendations.
Guideline revisions
These KNGF guidelines are the first such clinical Acknowledgments
guidelines to be developed for diagnosis, treatment For their help in producing these KNGF guidelines,
and prevention in patients requiring cardiac special words of gratitude are in order to members of
rehabilitation. Subsequent developments that could the secondary working group: ELD Angenot PhD
lead to improvements in the application of physical (rehabilitation physician, Amsterdam Rehabilitation
38 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
V-08/2003/US 39
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
40 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Table 20. The six steps in patient education, as suggested by van der Burgt en Verhulst.(76)
1. Being open
The physical therapist adapts the methods used to suit the perceptions, expectations, questions and
concerns of the patient. Important questions are: What are the patient’s main concerns? Which concerns
limit the patient’s ability to be open to new information and to behavioral change?
2. Understanding
Information must be presented in such a way that the patient will understand it and remember it. It is
important: not to provide too much information at one time; to decide which information is needed first
and what can be saved for later; to repeat the message (in another form, if necessary); and to use educational
aids, such as leaflets and videos. The physical therapist should monitor whether or not the patient has
understood the information provided.
3. Wanting
The physical therapist should determine what motivates the patient to act. Here it is important: to
determine how significant performing the exercises is to the patient; to find out whether individuals in the
patient’s environment encourage or discourage the patient; and to determine whether the patient feels that
he or she can influence the situation. The physical therapist offers support and provides information about
different options and alternatives. Achievable goals are set.
4. Being able
The patient must be able to perform the desired behavior. Functional skills must be practiced. It is important
that the physical therapist determines which practical problems the patient expects and decides how they
will be overcome.
5. Doing
This step covers the actual performance of the new behavior. The physical therapist makes a clear, concrete
and realistic agreement with the patient and sets concrete goals. If possible, positive feedback is given.
6. Keeping on doing
The patient must to continue to perform the learned behavior after treatment has ended. During therapy,
the physical therapist will discuss with the patient whether continuation is possible. It is important to know
what the possibilities are, what encourages the patient, and whether there are any short-term or long-term
gains. The physical therapist should determine what helps the patient get back on track after a ‘dip’ in
motivation.
V-08/2003/US 41
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
42 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Table 21. Example of the visual analogue scale as used for assessing activity level.
Patient code :
Physical Therapist :
Date :
The aim of this scale is to obtain knowledge about how the patient performs various activities. After each
question, the patient must draw a vertical line on the horizontal line. If the vertical line is placed to the far
left, the patient has no difficulty in performing the activity. If placed to the far right, the patient has a lot of
difficulty. All questions must be answered.(86)
V-08/2003/US 43
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Level Description
Reproduced with permission from the American College of Sports Medicine. Source: American College of Sports Medicine guidelines for exercise
testing and prescription. Philadelphia, Baltimore: Lippincott William & Wilkins; ©2000.
VI. Borg scale heart failure. The research shows that this test is safe
The Borg scale is a subjective index that is used to and applicable in these patients.88 Heijblom et al.89
assess the patient’s degree of exhaustion or reaction concluded from their research that the six-minute
to participating in activities. Use of the Borg scale walking test provides reliable results in patients with
helps patients learn how to match their daily chronic heart failure and that the results correlate
activities to their current exercise capacity.85 In with cardiac information.
practice, the patient indicates the level of exhaustion
and the extent of any dyspnea or chest pain VIII. The MET Method
experienced during activity on a scale from 6 to 20. The MET’s method can be used to estimate aerobic
Patients quickly learn how to apply the Borg scale to capacity levels and makes it possible to evaluate the
their daily activities. For example, the patient can metabolic demands of motor activities without
learn how to exert himself or herself up to a certain having to take into account the individual’s body
level during the performance of normal daily size. One MET’S unit is equal to the basic metabolic
activities or while participating in a sport.2 The Borg level of the particular individual while resting. The
scale score can be used in combination with heart number of MET’s units needed to perform a specific
rate measurements made while resting, at maximum motor activity depends on the ratio of the amount of
exertion, and during recovery to provide feedback to energy used during the activity and that used in
the patient on normal and abnormal symptoms. resting state. The numbers of MET’s units needed to
perform a large range of activities have been
VII. Six-minute walking test determined.90 For more details, see Supplement 3.
Scientific research has been carried out on the use of The energy used by the patient in resting state
the six-minute walking test in patients with chronic corresponds to an oxygen uptake, or VO2, of 3.5 ml
Level Description
Reproduced with permission from the American College of Sports Medicine. Source: American College of Sports Medicine guidelines for exercise
testing and prescription. Philadelphia, Baltimore: Lippincott William & Wilkins; ©2000.
44 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Table 24. Borg scale for estimating aerobic capacity on the basis of subjective observation. Sources: Borg (85,86)
and Pollock and Wilmore.(87)
6 no feeling of exertion
7 extremely light extremely light
8
9 very light very light
10
11 fairly light light
12
13 fairly heavy fairly heavy
14
15 heavy heavy
16
17 very heavy very heavy
18
19 extremely heavy extremely heavy
20 maximum exertion
per kg per minute. By using the MET’s method, the IX. The specific-activity scale91
physical therapist can correct differences between the X. Evaluating relaxation instruction2
patient’s actual and desired performance by using an It is of the utmost importance not only that the
appropriate rehabilitation program. patient receives relaxation instruction but also that
• It must be remembered that the patient’s ability to the effects of relaxation instruction on daily life are
perform an activity not only depends on his or evaluated. To date, no reliable measurement
her aerobic capacity level, but also on his or her instruments are available. Measurement methods 1
fears, movement efficiency, and motor behavior, and 2a shown below are highly recommended. The
which are all equally important. third measurement method requires more time but
• The number of MET’s units quoted for each results in more detailed information.
activity is an average. It is important to take
different levels of skill into consideration. For Three measuring instruments for evaluating
more information, see the Cardiac Rehabilitation relaxation instruction:
Guidelines 1995/1996.2
In this method, the patient is asked to score the result
Does the therapist have the impression that the patient has learned how to relax?
1 = yes, clearly: The patient can demonstrate the ability to carry out the instructions and, after doing so,
feels a positive benefit.
2 = not clearly: The patient can scarcely, or not at all, demonstrate the ability to carry out the instructions
and no change is experienced.
3 = no: The patient does not carry out the instructions and either no change or an unpleasant
change is experienced.
V-08/2003/US 45
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
1. Can you walk down a single flight of stairs (i.e. more than eight steps) without stopping?
YES NO
YES NO
YES NO YES
Figure reproduced with permission from Circulation.(91) Source: Goldman L et al. Comparative reproducibility and validity of systems assessing
cardiovascular functional class: advantages of a new specific-activity scale. Circulation 1981;64(6):1227-34. Copyright 2000.
46 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
1a. Have you found an exercise method that you can use yourself at home and is it one you practice
repeatedly?
2 = yes (completely adequate)
1 = yes (somewhat adequate)
0 = no
A total score of 5 or 6 points indicates that relaxation exercises have had a positive influence; a total score of
0 or 1 indicates that there has been no effect.
Additional questions:
of following each relaxation instruction on a matrix.91 The matrix can be filled in before the exercise is
completed, as suggested in the Cardiac Rehabilitation Guidelines 1995/1996.2 Each instruction can be repeated
four times, after each of which the patient scores the result on the following dimensions: (C) completion, (F)
feeling, and (A) appreciation, as explained below. The higher the percentage of instructions that receive three
pluses, the better the patient’s ability to relax.
V-08/2003/US 47
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Instruction C F A C F A C F A C F A
48 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Table 25. Metabolic equivalence of a range of professional, leisure and sporting activities.
20 2 driving a car, light office work playing music (e.g., light cycling,
cooking, brushing (e.g., typing), piano or guitar), walking at 2.5 km/h
hair, moping the handicraft light wood work,
floor, dusting fishing, playing
billiards
V-08/2003/US 49
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
80-90 5 grocery shopping heavy office work, dancing, fishing in cycling at 12 km/h,
with a heavy bag, wall-papering, using fast-flowing water, walking at 5.5 km/h,
sexual activities (new a wheelbarrow, hunting, playing golf horseback riding
partner), digging in making footpaths, (carrying own bag) (trotting), playing
the garden, mowing mixed labor tennis doubles,
the lawn (non- involving digging, la- playing badminton,
electrical mower) ying stones or land- rowing
scaping, feeding
animals
140 7 shoveling powdery sawing wood, fast dancing (e.g., cycling at 15 km/h,
snow, chopping railroad work, swing) walking at 7.5 km/h,
wood, walking in transporting a load walking up gentle
gentle hills while of 30–38 kg hills, fencing, skiing
carrying less than 5 at 4–9 km/h
kg
160-170 8 shoveling wet snow, sawing by hand, high-impact aerobics cycling at 19 km/h,
cutting down trees, heavy digging using jogging at 8 km/h,
scrubbing floors, a pick-axe, moving cross-country skiing
hillwalking with a 40-kg weights, on the level, swim-
10-kg weight cleaning out stables ming (front crawl) at
35 m/min,
horseback riding
(racing), playing
hockey
50 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Table reproduced with permission from Bohn Stafleu Van Loghum. Source: Vanhees L. Cardiac rehabilitation. In: Physical Therapy/Kinesiology
Therapy Year book 1999. Den Dekker J, Aufdemkampe G, van Ham I, Smits-Engelsman BCM, Vaes P (editors). Houten, the Netherlands: Bohn
Stafleu Van Loghum; 1999:66-95. © 2000.
V-08/2003/US 51
Supplement 4: Effects of medications on heart rate,
blood pressure, ECG responses and exercise capacity
Medications Heart Rate Blood Pressure ECG Exercise Capacity
}
Felodipine ↓ ischemia (E) ↑ in patients with angina’
Isradipine ↔ in patients without angina
Necardipine ↑ or ↔ (R and E)
Nifedipine
Nimodipine
Nisoldipine ↓ (R and E)
↓ HR (R and E)
Bepridil
Diltiazem
Verapamil } ↓ (R and E) ↓ ischemia (E)
IV. Digitalis ↓ in patients with ↔ (R and E) May produce nonspe- Improved only in patients with
atrial fibrillation cific ST-T wave atrial fibrillation or in
and possibly CHF change (R) patients with CHF
Not significantly altered May produce ST seg-
in patients with sinus ment depression (E)
rhythm
VII. Antiarrhythmic agents All antiarrhythmic agents may cause new or worsened arrhtyhmias (proarrhythmic effect)
Class I
Quinidine ↑ or ↔ (R and E) ? or ↔ (R) ↑ or ↔ HR (R) may ↔
Disopyramide ↔ (E) May prolong QRS and
QT intervals (R)
Quinidine may result in
“false negative” test
results (E)
Procainamide ↔ (R and E) ↔ (R and E) May prolong QRS and ↔
QT intervals (R)
May result in “false
positive” test results
(E)
}
Phenytoin
Tocainide ↔ (R and E) ↔ (R and E) ↔ (R and E) ↔
Mexiletine
Flecainide
Moricizine ↔ (R and E) ↔ (R and E) May prolong QRS and ↔
QT intervals (R)
↔ (E)
Propafenone ↓ (R) ↔ (R and E) ↓ HR (R) ↔
↓ or ↔ (E) ↓ or ↔ HR (E)
Class II
ß-Blockers (see I.)
Class III
Amiodarone ↓ (R and E) ↔ (R and E) ↓ HR (R) ↔
↔ (E)
Class IV
Calcium Channel
Blockers (see III.)
52 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
IX. Hyperlipidemic agents Clofibrate may provoke arrhythmias, angina in patients with prior myo-
cardial infarction
Nicotinic agents may ↓ BP
All other hyperlipidemic agents have no effect on HR, BP, and ECG
X. Psychotropic medications
Minor tranquilizers May ↓ HR and BP by controlling anxiety: no other effects
Antidepressants ↑ or ↔ (R and E) ↓ or ↔ (R and E) Variable (R)
May result in ‘false positive’
test results (E)
Major tranquilizers ↑ or ↔ (R and E) ↓ or ↔ (R and E) Variable (R)
May result in ‘false positive’ or
‘false negative’ test results (E)
Lithium ↔ (R and E) ↔ (R and E) May result in T wave changes
and arrhythmias (R and E)
XIII. Cold medications with Effects similar to those described in sympathomimetic agents, ↔
Sympathomimetic agents although magnitude of effects is usually smaller
Key: ↑ = increase; ↔ = no effect; ↓ = decrease; R = rest; E = exercise; HR = heart rate; PVC’s = premature ventricular contractions
V-08/2003/US 53
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
Glossary
Activity Execution of a task or action by an individual
Borg scale Subjective scale that patients can use to indicate how they experience difference loads
Ergometer Standardized instrument for measuring work capacity
Functions Physiological functions of body systems (including psychological functions)
Impairment Problem with body function or structure, such as a significant deviation or loss
Limitation Difficulty in performing an activity; activities may be limited in nature, duration or
quality
Load The physical, mental or social demands on an individual
Load capacity The load an individual can handle
Muscular function Muscle strength, speed of movement, flexibility and coordination
Optimal functioning The level of functioning at which the patient can return to full participation in society
Participation Involvement in a life situation
Prevention The sum of all the measures taken to bring about behavioral change aimed at
preventing heart disease progression; in 1995, the (Dutch) Rehabilitation Commission
used the term secondary prevention, whereas epidemiologists refer to it as tertiary
prevention
Training Providing a physical exercise plan to force the body to adapt to a higher level of
functioning
Training capacity The individual’s scope for adapting his or her body to a higher level of functioning
54 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
References
1 Revalidatie Commissie (NHS/NVVVC). Richtlijnen hartrevalidatie: Hartstichting; 1999.
Deel I. ’s-Gravenhage, the Netherlands: Nederlandse 18 Statistiek Jaarboek 2000. Voorburg, the Netherlands: Centraal
Hartstichting; 1995. Bureau voor de Statistiek; 2000.
2 Revalidatie Commissie (NHS/NVVVC). Richtlijnen hartrevalidatie: 19 Senten MCM. Hartrevalidatie. Deel 2: Cardiologische nazorg in
Deel II. ’s-Gravenhage, the Netherlands: Nederlandse Nederland: een overzicht in cijfers. Cardiologie 1995;2:330-4.
Hartstichting; 1997. 20 Strijbis AM. Hartrevalidatie in Nederland anno 1998. ’s-
3 Hendriks HJM, Reitsma E, van Ettekoven H. Centrale richtlijnen Gravenhage, the Netherlands: Nederlandse Hartstichting; 1999.
in de fysiotherapie. Ned Tijdschr Fysiother 1996;106:2-11. 21 American College of Sports Medicine. ACSM exercise
4 Hendriks HJM, van Ettekoven H, Reitsma E, Verhoeven ALJ, van management for persons with chronic diseases and disabilities.
der Wees PJ. Methode voor centrale richtlijnontwikkeling en Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics; 1997.
implementatie in de fysiotherapie. Amersfoort, the Netherlands: 22 Herziening consensus cholesterol. Utrecht, the Netherlands: CBO;
KNGF/NPi/CBO; 1998. and ’s-Gravenhage, the Netherlands: Nederlandse Hartstichting;
5 Hendriks HJM, Bekkering GE, van Ettekoven H, Brandsma JW, 1991.
van der Wees PJ, de Bie RA. Development and implementation 23 1999 World Health Organization-International Society of
of national practice guidelines: A prospect for continuous quality Hypertension guidelines for the management of hypertension.
improvement in physiotherapy. Introduction to the method of Guidelines subcommittee. J Hypertens 1999;17(2):151-83.
guideline development. Physiotherapy 2000;86:535-47. 24 WHO expert committee. Physical status: the use and
6 Hendriks HJM, van Ettekoven H, van der Wees PJ. Eindverslag interpretation of anthropometry. Geneva, Switzerland: World
van het project Centrale richtlijnen in de fysiotherapie (Deel 1). Health Organization; 1995.
Achtergronden en evaluatie van het project. Amersfoort, the 25 Moons KGM, Schouten JSAG, Grobbee DE. Acuut hartinfarct. In:
Netherlands: KNGF/NPi/CBO; 1998. Van der Meer J, Schouten JSAG, editors. Volksgezondheid
7 Hendriks HJM, van Ettekoven H, Bekkering T, Verhoeven A. Toekomst Verkenning 1997. Deel 5. Maarssen, the Netherlands:
Implementatie van KNGF-richtlijnen. Fysiopraxis 2000;9:9-13. Elsevier; 1997.
8 Heerkens YF, Lakerveld-Heyl K, Verhoeven ALJ, Hendriks HJM. 26 Oldridge N, Gottlieb M, Guyatt G, Jones N, Streiner D, Feeny D.
KNGF-richtlijn fysiotherapeutische verslaglegging, O-01/2003. Predictors of health-related quality of life with cardiac
Amersfoort, the Netherlands: KNGF; 2003. rehabilitation after acute myocardial infarction. J Cardiopulm
9 Agency for Health Care Policy and Research. Cardiac Rehabil 1998;18(2):95-103.
rehabilitation. Clinical practice guidelines, 1995, number 17. 27 Van der Wees P. Beroepsprofiel fysiotherapeut. Amersfoort, the
DHHS publication AHCPR 96-0672. Rockville, MD: Agency for Netherlands: KNGF; 1998.
Health Care Policy and Research, Public Health Service, US 28 Revalidatie Commissie (NHS). Kwaliteitseisen Hartrevalidatie. ’s-
Department of Health and Human Services, National Heart, Gravenhage, the Netherlands: Nederlandse Hartstichting; 1998.
Lung, and Blood Institute; 1995. 29 Symposium on “Hartrevalidatie passen en meten”. June 9, 1994.
10 American College of Sports Medicine. ACSM guidelines for 30 Van Duijn H, van Rijnsoever M, van der Schaaf M, Sommers J, de
exercise testing and prescription. Sixth edition. Philadelphia, PA: Vries R. Richtlijn peri-operatieve longfysiotherapie bij buik- en
Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2000. hartchirurgie. FysioPraxis 2000;7:13-7.
11 American Association for Cardiovascular and Pulmonary 31 Webber BA, Pryor JA. Physiotherapy for respiratory and cardiac
Rehabilitation. Guidelines for cardiac rehabilitation and problems. New York, NY: Churchill Livingstone; 1993.
secondary prevention programs. Champaign, IL: Human 32 Richtlijn: peri-operatieve longfysiotherapie bij buik- en
Kinetics; 1999. hartchirurgie. Amsterdam, the Netherlands: Universiteit van
12 Fletcher GF, Balady G, Froelicher VF, Hartley LH, Haskell WL, Amsterdam, Afdeling Revalidatie Academisch Medisch Centrum;
Pollock MK. Exercise standards. A statement for healthcare 1997.
professionals from the American Heart Association. Circulation 33 Van Elderen T, Chatrou M, Weeda H, Maes S. Leidse Screenings
1995;91(2):580-615. Vragenlijst voor hartpatiënten. Leiden, the Netherlands: 2000.
13 Soons PHGM. Hartrevalidatie in Nederland geregistreerd en 34 Lindeman E, Falger P, Bär FW, Korstjens H. Maastrichtse
geëvalueerd. Een inventariserend onderzoek naar hartrevalidatie Screenings Vragenlijst voor hartpatiënten. 2000.
in Nederland. Maastricht, the Netherlands: Rijksuniversiteit 35 Hillers TK, Guyatt GH, Oldridge N, Crowe J, Willan A, Griffith L
Limburg; 1995. et al. Quality of life after myocardial infarction. J Clin Epidemiol
14 Revalidatie Commissie (NHS). Hartrevalidatie ... meer dan nodig. 1994;47(11):1287-96.
’s-Gravenhage, the Netherlands: Nederlandse Hartstichting; 36 Erdman RAM. Een medisch psychologische vragenlijst ter
1998. bepaling van het welbevinden bij hartpatiënten. Hart Bulletin
15 Werkgroep Longrevalidatie Astmacentrum. Longrevalidatie. 1982;13:143-7.
Produktbeschrijving van de behandeling van volwassenen in het 37 Berkhuysen M, Nieuwland W, Buunk B, Sanderman R, Viersma
astmacentrum. Groningen, the Netherlands: Grafisch Huis; JW, Rispens P. Change in self-efficacy during cardiac
1996. rehabilitation and the role of perceived overprotectiveness.
16 Internationale classificatie van het menselijk functioneren. ICIDH- Patient Educ Couns 1999;38:21-32.
2 beta-2 voorstel. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health 38 Berkhuysen M, Nieuwland W, Ranchor AV, Buunk B, Sanderman
Organization; and Bilthoven, the Netherlands: RIVM; 1999. R. The moderating role of neuroticism on reducing psychological
17 Konings-Dalstra JAA, Reitsma JB. Hart- en vaatziekten in distress during rehabilitation in patients with coronary artery
Nederland. ’s-Gravenhage, the Netherlands: Nederlandse disease. In: Berkhuysen M. Toward tailor-made cardiac
V-08/2003/US 55
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
56 V-08/2003/US
KNGF-guidelines for physical therapy in cardiac rehabilitation
V-08/2003/US 57