Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Swedbank Analyses the Swedish and Baltic Economies January 13, 2011
September). However, the quarterly to inflationary pressures but these expect the budget deficit to come down
rate of expansion will slow after last will dampen gradually. In the longer to 3% of GDP in 2012, thus satisfying
year’s bounceback. The main drivers term, foreign support for investments the Maastricht criteria. Hence, inflation
of growth in 2011 are the higher in Estonia is likely to increase due is expected to be the most difficult goal
household consumption, supported by to a perceived higher stability and to fulfil.
a better labour market performance; predictability of the economy. Fiscal
Lithuania’s recession has also ended,
the stronger confidence; and a further policy is disciplined, and the budget
and GDP in 2010 is expected to have
recovery of investments. Net exports situation will be better than the
shown marginal growth of 0.5%. The
will be marginally higher. In 2012, government plans throughout the
outlook is improving as GDP will grow
GDP growth is set to slow somewhat forecast period. The main fiscal risks
by 3% in 2011 and 4.5% in 2012.
more than the September forecast, are geared towards social spending
Exports explain last year’s better
to 2.5% (2.9%). The most important and developments in labour markets
performance, as well as inventory
reason for this is the slower growth and municipal budgets. Increasingly,
restocking, which added extensively
of exports due to higher unit labour higher inflation is likely to be a major
to growth. For 2011, investments are
costs and a slightly stronger krona. challenge for policy makers, with
set to grow somewhat faster, while
The Riksbank will raise the policy rate possible negative consequences for
general government consumption
marginally faster during the spring of growth and competitiveness.
will decrease more than previously
2011, reaching 2,25% at end- 2011
Latvia already experienced a recovery envisaged. We have revised upwards
and 3% at end- 2012. Fiscal policy will
last year, despite the negative GDP the inflation rate for 2011 and 2012
become tighter, and there is still room
growth, which was due to a carryover as commodity prices have increased
for targeted reforms improving the
effect from 2009. During the first more than expected, and excise duties
functioning of the labour market.
nine months of 2010, the economy on tobacco and diesel fuel will add
Estonia’s GDP growth has also been grew by 3%, mainly due to stronger to inflationary pressures. Like Latvia,
revised upwards for 2010, from 2.2% exports and inventory restocking. The Lithuania has the goal of becoming a
in the September Outlook to 2.8%. A labour market has also improved in member of the EMU in 2014, which
stronger export performance explains line with the stronger growth climate, means that all Maastricht criteria must
most of the difference. For 2011 and and unemployment is falling from the be fulfilled in 2012. While we foresee
2012, we are keeping the overall peak of above 20% at the beginning that the government can manage
GDP growth basically unchanged, but of 2010. Going forward, GDP will to reduce the budget deficit to 3%
exports are now forecast to speed grow by 4% and 4.2% in 2011 and of GDP in 2012 , the inflation rate
up in line with a stronger global 2012, respectively. Growth in 2011 could become a greater hindrance.
demand, while domestic demand is stronger than the September Labour productivity will increase, but
will increase more slowly than in the forecast (3%) as a result of a better not as fast as during 2010, and more
September forecast. A more subdued global demand situation, as well as measures are needed to improve
investment growth and the effects stronger investments. Household competitiveness.
on households of higher inflationary consumption, although remaining
Many challenges for sustainable
pressures explain the downward subdued, will slowly pick up in line with
growth remain, and all four
revision of domestic demand. GDP lower unemployment and stronger
countries should continue to
will grow by approximately 4.5% in confidence. Inflation is also increasing,
focus on reforms that will add to
both years. Estonia has now become but the government will focus on
longer-term competitiveness by
the 17th member of the Economic holding price pressures down as Latvia
supporting education and research
and Monetary Union (EMU). In the is still aiming to join the EMU in 2014.
and development, improving the
short term, price increases will add Fiscal improvements continue, and we
functioning of labour markets,
Quarterly real GDP levels( quarterly peak =100) 1/ increasing competition on domestic
105
product markets, and strengthening
100 the business climate. The times when
loan-driven economies could generate
95
success stories are over. Only by
90 creating an environment for companies
that are dynamic and environmentally
85
and economically sound may the
80 standard of living grow in a sustainable
way.
75
Latvia Lithuania Sweden Estonia
70
Q1-07 Q2-07 Q3-07 Q4-07 Q1-08 Q2-08 Q3-08 Q4-08 Q1-09 Q2-09 Q3-09 Q4-09 Q1-10 Q2-10 Q3-10 Cecilia Hermansson
Sources: National statistics authorities and Swedbank.
1/ Each quarter of the year is compared to the highest level of that quarter’s GDP.
Japan -5.2 3.2 1.5 1.3 3.2 1.4 1.5 Last, but not least, commodity prices
China 8.9 10.1 8.5 8.1 9.8 8.5 8.1 have risen faster than expected,
India 5.7 8.8 8.2 7.5 8.0 7.5 7.8 partly due to policy measures leading
Brazil -0.2 7.5 4.8 4.5 7.2 5.0 5.0 to higher liquidity like in the US,
Russia -7.9 4.0 4.3 4.5 4.3 4.5 5.0 partly due to a faster global recovery.
Global GDP in PPP -0.7 4.6 3.9 3.8 4.4 3.6 3.8 There is a risk that higher energy and
Global GDP in US$ -2.0 3.7 3.1 3.0 3.5 2.8 3.1 commodity prices will dampen profit
margins, raise consumer prices, and
Sources: National statistics authorities and Swedbank.
reduce growth in many parts of the
1/ Countries representing around 70 % of the global economy. The World Bank weights from 2009
(purchasing power parity, PPP) have been used.
world. The effects of higher commodity Commodity prices , 2002 - 2012 (indices)
500
prices will be more severe in countries Food Metals Oil
where food and energy make up a 450
industry worsens due to a stronger Real GDP levels and growth, 1980 - 2012
3500 6
krona and rising unit labour costs. Growth (% real; rhs) Level (real)
3300
We expect export growth in that year 4
3100
of 5.5%, implying losses of market
2900
shares for Swedish companies. The 8 quarters
2
2700
growth contribution from foreign trade
2500 0
will be limited by the strong growth in
2300
imports. Following an expansion in -2
2100
2010 of 12.5%, import growth in 2011
1900
and 2012 is expected to decelerate to 18 quarters
-4
1700
7.3% and 6.4%, respectively. 1500 -6
Broad recovery in fixed 1980 1982 1984 1986 1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012
Sources: SCB and Swedbank projections.
investment
The recovery in investments has during 2011, followed by a deceleration falling back in 2012.
strengthened in line with increasing in 2012 when the industrial capacity is
production and a higher utilisation rate. Inventory restocking is expected to
larger.
Housing shows the largest pickup, have contributed 2.3 percentage
together with the services sector, while The rebound in real estate investment points to GDP growth in 2010,
industry investments are lagging. in 2010 was more pronounced than significantly more than expected.
Large public investment projects in we had anticipated. This will also have Companies’ needs for growing stocks
infrastructure also contributed more to spillover effects in 2011. Because of of intermediate and finished goods
the investment rebound in 2010 than this rebound, as well as an improving in industry explain to a large extent
we expected. labour market and tax reductions this boost from inventories. This is
for renovations, we foresee double- a sharp reversal from 2009, when
With private sector output continuing digit investment growth in real estate the destocking process started and
upwards, there will be a growing need during 2011. For 2012, we anticipate industrial production fell significantly.
to expand capacity. Together with a gradual slowdown in real estate We foresee a further rebuilding of
strengthening confidence, favourable investments when the interest rates stocks during the forecast period due
financing terms and rising profits will be higher. Supply constraints, such to the low current levels, growing
will trigger an increase in business as a lack of qualified labour, are also industrial production, and higher
investments. Total investment is expected to limit growth in real estate investment growth. The momentum
expected to grow by 8.2% in 2011 investment. is, however, expected to slow, and
and 8% in 2012, which means that the contribution to GDP growth from
investments will exceed the pre-crisis Ongoing and investments brought
inventories will be zero during 2011
2008 level by the end of the forecast forward in infrastructure and new
and slightly negative in 2012.
period. We expect an uptick in the projects by local governments will
momentum of industrial investment boost public investment in 2011 before Sustained, but slow, labour
market improvements
The labour market continues to
Swedbank’s GDP Forecast – Sweden
recover, but at a slower rate than
Changes in volume, % 2009 2010e1/ 2011f1/ 2012f economic growth. By November of last
Households' consumption expenditure -0.4 3.6 (3.0) 2.9 (2.6) 2.0 (1.8) year, the Swedish economy had added
Government consumption expenditure 1.7 2.0 (1.7) 0.9 (1.0) 0.4 (0.4) more than 90,000 jobs compared
Gross fixed capital formation -16.4 4.7 (4.3) 8.2 (5.5) 8.0 (6.7) with the same month in 2009, and
private, excl. housing -19.1 1.4 (4.3) 9.4 (6.7) 10.9 (8.3)
the unemployment rate had fallen to
public 4.2 3.5 (-3.6) 0.5 (-1.3) -0.5 (-0.4)
7.8% (seasonally adjusted). However,
housing -23.3 19.7 (13.5) 11.7 (7.7) 5.5 (6.9)
Change in inventories 2/ -1.7 2.3 (1.8) 0.0 (0.0) -0.3 (0.0) compared with the rapid expansion
Exports, goods and services -13.4 11.1 (11.2) 6.8 (5.6) 5.5 (6.4) of GDP, employment is lagging.
Imports, goods and services -13.6 12.5 (13.5) 7.3 (6.7) 6.4 (6.4) Instead, the number of working hours
GDP -5.6 5.6 (4.3) 3.3 (2.4) 2.1 (2.6) is increasing. This suggests that slack
GDP, calendar adjusted -5.2 5.3 (4.0) 3.3 (2.4) 2.5 (2.9) that had accumulated is now being
Domestic demand 2/ -3.1 3.1 (2.7) 3.1 (2.5) 2.5 (2.2) used up. Also, productivity levels have
Net exports 2/ -0.8 0.1 (-0.2) 0.2 (-0.1) -0.1 (0.4) been rising quickly, and, in tandem
Sources: Statistics Sweden and Swedbank. with low wage increases, unit labour
1/ The figures from our forecast in September 2010 are given in brackets. costs have fallen. As many companies
2/ Contribution to GDP growth.
now are faced with making new hirings
instead of rehiring previously laid-off Productivity and unit labour cost, 2001 - 2012
personnel or increasing hours, we 7 5
suggested for 2012, and transfers precautionary savings can be expected by 2.5% at the end of the year. In
from the government will decline in to fall off as household confidence light of this, we expect the Riksbank
line with falling unemployment and improves, supporting increasing to raise policy rates at a faster pace,
the tightening of health benefits. The consumption levels. and to effectuate two additional hikes
minority government has strongly of 25 basis points during the first half
Put together, we expect the household
committed itself to fiscal policy of 2011. The output and employment
saving ratio to continue to decline in
restraint and does not seem to have gaps are closing faster than expected,
2011 and 2012, but will remain at a
parliamentary support for any major which shortens the way toward a
relatively high level. It soared during
demand enhancing policies. Also, the normalisation of monetary policy, which
the crisis as precautionary savings
normalisation of monetary policy will strengthen the krona and dampen
surged. A combination of increasing
make a dent in household finances. inflationary pressures. The consumer
consumption, limited growth of
As the share of mortgages at flexible price index with fixed interest rates
disposable income, and improving
rates was 59% in September 2010, (CPIF) is expected to reach 1.7% at
confidence will lead households to
compared with 43% in October 2008, the end of 2012. There have also been
draw down on savings. However, as
increasing interest rates will reverse concerns that the exceptionally low
interest rates increase, we expect
the beneficial impact that low rates interest rates are fuelling asset prices,
amortisation to pick up, supporting
have had on consumers’ budgets. including those in real estate. For
a relatively high saving ratio and
Even though consumer behaviour has 2012, the pace of rate hikes will slow,
dampening consumption growth.
stabilized economic activity during the and we forecast a policy rate of 3% by
recent turbulent years, vulnerabilities
Monetary policy – a balancing the end of the year, i.e., unchanged
are building up. We forecast household
act from our September forecast.
debt levels to reach close to 180% of The Riksbank has continued on The Riksbank will need to perform
disposable income and debt service its path towards a normalisation of several balancing acts over the next
to rise quickly with policy rate hikes. monetary policy. In October, the policy couple of years. Primarily, as economic
Increasing utility prices, in particular rate was raised to 1.0%, but the policy activity is again picking up, there is
of electricity during another cold spell rate path was revised downwards at a risk that a too rapid normalisation
this winter, and rising inflation due the same time amidst concerns over of monetary policy will prematurely
to food and commodity prices will the international economic recovery. strain economic growth. The Swedish
limit household budgets and curb In December, another increase of 25 economy is likely to have become
consumption spending. basis points took place, but with no more interest rate sensitive as the debt
change in the policy rate path. While burden has increased, in particular
Although consumer spending is
referring to the strong economic amongst households. Higher interest
expected to grow more slowly during
growth and improvement in the labour rates will affect consumption behaviour
the next two years, it will remain
market, the Riksbank noted that the more now than before the crisis.
an important source of growth. A
underlying inflation rate was still low, Regarding whether the Riksbank
significant share of the increase in
despite higher utility and commodity should be more proactive in preventing
consumption during 2010 was due to
prices. asset price bubbles, we believe that
pent-up demand for durables such as
cars. As households are returning to there is a role for monetary policy to
Against the background of a stronger-
their desired levels of consumption “lean against the wind” to prevent,
than-expected economic recovery and
of capital goods, we expect real e.g., housing prices from becoming too
rising food and energy prices, inflation
spending to increase at a slower rate excessive. In that sense, the on-going
began accelerating in 2010 and
in 2011 and 2012. At the same time, normalization of the monetary policy
consumer prices (CPI) had increased
is welcome. In general, balance-sheet
concerns should also be addressed
Household income , consumption and saving, 1998 - 2012
through financial supervision measures
14
Real disposable income
and appropriate fiscal policy measures.
12 Private consumption This way, policy interventions will be
Saving ratio
10 Saving ratio (excl. occupational and premium pensions)
more targeted, through, e.g., loan-to-
8
value ratios or mandatory amortisation
of highly leveraged house purchases,
6
or through a phase-in of a reduction of
4
the mortgage interest tax deduction.
2
0
Fiscal policy – towards
-2
surpluses
-4 The rapid economic recovery has
1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 improved fiscal balances. A better-
Sources: SCB and Swedbank projections.
130
2.0
125
1.0
120
0.0 115
110
-1.0
105
-2.0 100
Jan-08 Jun-08 Nov-08 Apr-09 Sep-09 Feb-10 Jul-10 Dec-10 May-11 Oct-11 Mar-12 Aug-12
Sources: Riksbanken, SCB and Swedbank projections.
10% 2
First consequences of high
0% 0
unemployment to be felt
-10% -2
We have lowered our unemployment -20% -4
rate forecast for 2010 and 2011
-30% -6
as its decline in the third quarter
-40% -8
was stronger than expected. There 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
were two factors behind: besides Source: EP, Swedbank calculations
-10%
Unemployment rate Employment, yoy 2 The main indication is different growth/de-
Gross wage, real yoy GDP per working hour, yoy
cline rates in consumption: while spending
-15% on necessities declines, spending on other
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 items is growing.
Source: SE
of the latter group caused us to cut levels in 2011 as well. Still, in 2012 (e.g. for resumption of the second
growth prospects for 2011 and 2012. we foresee a slowdown in inflation as pension pillar), but again close to
The low-income families are seriously global supply-side effects weaken. zero in 2012. This improved outlook
affected also by price growth: this is However, as mentioned above, is based on a better-than-expected
forcing them to squeeze down their stronger-than-expected inflation is performance of the economy, as well
spending as prices are rising-- most of among our main risk factors, for two as strict controls on spending.
all in the category of necessities. reasons. First, it would undermine
The main risks are related to higher-
domestic consumption, especially as it
The high saving rate is another factor than-projected social spending needs
affects the main items of consumption.
behind our cutting the spending in 2011 and 2012. The problems of
Second, it would increase wage
forecast for 2011 and 2012. According unemployment, poverty, and health
demands, which would undermine
to the survey,3 36% of families in all care financing may turn out to be
the competitiveness of Estonian
income groups are trying to save more severe than currently assumed,
companies and, hence, affect exports.
money, and there are no signs that requiring additional spending. The
If wage demands are not translated
this approach has changed. On the weakest areas in the public sector
into companies’ selling prices, then
contrary, the deleveraging process and are municipalities, many of which
profits of companies will be weaker,
the resumption of the second pension may face financial failure due to low
thereby affecting their investment
pillar payments indicate that savings incomes (employment) and high social
ability.
will actually increase from the 2010 spending needs. This may force the
level. Budgetary situation improving government to step in. If the number
of failing municipalities is significant,
The euro changeover will have a short- Estonia’s budgetary position will be
the costs for the budget will be large
term impact on consumption: while, better than forecast in the autumn. The
enough to cause the deficit to grow.
at end-2010, some people probably budget deficit was 0.5% of GDP in nine
Still, we are of the opinion that, if
increased their spending in fear of a months of 2010; hence it is possible
the economy develops according
rise in prices when Estonia joins the that the budget balance will be much
to our main scenario, a significant
euro zone. closer to zero for the full year than
deterioration of the budget situation is
the government expects.4 We foresee
Inflation has short-term negative unlikely.
budget deficit to be somewhat bigger
effect on consumption
in 2011 due to increased spending
We have increased our inflation
Maris Lauri
expectations for 2011 because price 4 In 2010 Estonia, sold Kyoto emission
growth in 2010 was stronger than quotas for EUR 230m. In December two
assumed. The main reason behind contracts were concluded. There are
discussions going on with Eurostat about
this strong growth was the global reporting how the sale income and the
price surge, which will affect price use of those revenues will be included into
budgetary statistics. Hence the effect of the
3 A survey conducted by the Estonian Insti-
quota sales on the budget outcome may be
tute of Economic Research at the request
different than currently assumed.
of Swedbank’s Institute of Private Finances.
9%
6%
3%
0%
-3%
CPI Base inflation Manufacturing prices
-6%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Source: SE, Swedbank calculations
-80 -10
Although many exporting companies
-100 -20
are already reaching capacity 1Q 05 1Q 06 1Q 07 1Q 08 1Q 09 1Q 10
constraints to further increase GDP GDP s.a. qoq (rs) Households
production volumes, there is still Government Gross fixed capital form. Exports
Imports Source: CSBL.
potential for value-added increases.
Manufacturers are continuing to
diversify their product and country mostly driven by intermediate and Investments will be supported by
mix, and to invest in improving the capital goods (which constitute about European Union (EU) funds – the
effectiveness of their production to two thirds of total goods imports). It government plans to acquire them up-
increase their turnovers; growing is expected that, with the recovery of front – about 8% of GDP in 2011 and
global commodity prices are making household consumption strengthening about 5% in 2012, most of them for
this somewhat easier. Exports in value in 2011 (albeit slower than previously infrastructure/transport and agriculture.
terms reached historically highest anticipated), import growth of In view of capacity constraints,
levels in autumn 2010. consumption goods will somewhat exporting sectors will seek to invest
accelerate. Meanwhile, the inventory in capacity and/or new product
Growth prospects of services exports
cycle will run out of steam in 2011, development. Although construction
are less optimistic – in 2010 they
thus undermining imports. activity started to rebound in the third
were nearly flat. Although the number
quarter of 2010, its growth is expected
of both business and personal Investments have started to
to be slow due to weak demand and
travellers continues to rise, freight recover
either still excessive supply or lack of
carriage volumes are likely to grow
The rebound in investments, although funding.
very slowly in 2011. The largest part
anticipated in the second half of 2010,
of international freight is by railway Foreign investors’ activity has
was stronger than expected, and gross
(including that through the ports), and started to increase slowly. Together
fixed capital formation is anticipated to
the forecasts by the largest railway with inflows of new equity capital,
have fallen by about 20% for the year
carrier suggest that freight volumes will reinvested earnings from foreign direct
overall. We are raising our forecast
be flat in 2011. investment (FDI) were positive in the
for gross fixed capital formation to
third quarter of 2010 for the first time
We now estimate import volumes about 15% for 2011, mainly due to
in two years. Standard & Poors has
to have grown by 8% in 2010 and larger positive carryovers, and are
revised Latvia’s sovereign country
we have raised our forecast to 9% keeping the 14% forecast for 2012.
rating one notch upwards – although
in 2011 on account of stronger The quarterly growth for 2011-2012
this is still below investment grade,
investments and exports. Imports remains similar to our previous
the revision shows the improvement
are also expected to grow similarly forecast.
of confidence. Further upgrades of the
in 2012. Import growth in 2010 was
ratings are expected in the first half of
2011, which will promote investments.
Swedbank’s GDP Forecast – Latvia Labour market improves on the
Changes in volume, % 2009 2010e1/ 2011f1/ 2012f1/ surface
GDP -18.0 -0.5 (-1.5) 4.0 (3.0) 4.2 (4.2) The labour market rebound in 2010
Household consumption -24.1 -1.0 (-2.0) 2.5 (2.0) 4.5 (4.5) was stronger than expected – in the
General government consumption -9.2 -8.0 (-4.3) -1.8 (-1.1) 0.1 (0.2) second and third quarters, employment
Gross fixed capital formation -37.3 -20.0 (-27.0) 15.0 (7.0) 14.0 (14.0) increased by 37 thousand (net of
Exports of goods and services -14.1 9.5 (9.0) 10.0 (6.0) 6.0 (6.0) active labour market programmes);
Imports of goods and services -33.5 8.0 (7.5) 9.0 (5.0) 9.0 (9.0) in the first nine months of 2010,
Inventories contribution to GDP, pp -1.5 5.9 (6.7) -0.7 (-0.5) 0.0 (0.2) seasonally adjusted nominal gross
Net export contribution to GDP, pp 14.2 0.5 (0.5) 0.3 (0.4) -1.8 (-1.7) wages had grown by 4%. The job-
Sources: CSBL and Swedbank. seekers’ rate decreased from its peak
1/ The figures from our forecast in September are given in brackets. of 20.4% in the first quarter of 2010 to
18% in the third quarter. imbalances (e.g., a skills mismatch) competition seems to have weakened
that effectively reduce unemployment’s during the crisis4, the skills mismatch
We are of the opinion, however,
ability to hold down wage rise. Wage in the labour market might yield faster
that the pace of improvement
developments will differ among wage growth, 2011 tax increases may
will decelerate. The registered
industries with exporting industries give grounds for further price rises.
unemployment rate was flat in
leading the way. In 2011 we expect Consumer inflation expectations
October-December. Businesses are
only marginal increases in hourly wage have grown, attributed to concerns
still very cautious in their employment
rates and most of the wage increase to about food prices in early autumn
plans, and job creation is expected
come from reintroduction of motivation and announced tax rises. We believe
to be slow. The rapid improvement in
schemes that were put on hold during that improving competition and taking
2010 may to a large extent have been
the recession. action to reduce the imbalances
a one-off rebound after excessive
in the labour market are crucial in
job destruction in 2009. The 2011 Although due to the above factors we
order to keep inflation under control.
government budget consolidation have raised somewhat the nominal net
The government has confirmed its
measures do not effectively support wage forecast for 2011, higher inflation
commitment to introduce the euro
and in some cases – e.g., the increase will eliminate most of this gain and real
in 2014 and will try to contain price
in the minimum wage – even hamper wage growth is forecast at just 1%.
growth; however, it might turn out that,
job creation by increasing labour costs. Higher inflation in 2011 is not expected
even if – as currently planned – there
to be a driver to raise wages. We are
We are lowering somewhat our job- are no more tax increases in 2012,
keeping our real net wage forecast
seekers’ forecast for 2011 and 2012 inflation might still turn out higher than
of 2.4% for 2012; however, there is
due to the better 2010 developments, anticipated.
a risk it will be stronger if no policy
reaching on average 14.5% in 2012.
action is taken to prevent structural Uneven household consumption
If opening of German and Austrian
unemployment. development
labour markets significantly spur
emigration, decline in unemployment Higher inflation due to tax Household consumption growth will
might be faster, but it would also increases remain slow and fragile in 2011.
exacerbate, e.g., pension system Its development so far is best
We are forecasting higher consumer
sustainability problems. Structural characterized as “two steps forward,
price inflation in 2011, mostly due to
challenges in the labour market one step back” – after a rebound at
VAT increases.3 We expect average
remain, and part of the cyclical the end of 2009–beginning of 2010,
consumer price growth to be about
unemployment is very likely to turn into it inched downwards in the second
3% in 2011 (1.5% previously) and are
structural unemployment.1 and third quarters. Due to past data
keeping a 2.5% forecast for 2012. We
revision, we now estimate a smaller
The gap between real wages and believe that such inflation is not yet
fall in household consumption in
productivity has nearly disappeared2 competitiveness destroying due to
2010 of -1%. From its trough in
and with labour productivity growth productivity improvements.
the third quarter of 2009, however,
continuing, there are grounds for
Global commodity price growth it will be up by about 3% by the
moderate wage rises. Another factor
(although slower in 2011) remains end of the year. We are lowering
behind wage growth will be structural
one of the main inflation drivers. the forecast somewhat for 2011 to
However, local price pressures are 2.5%, as household consumption
1 See our latest Swedbank Analysis (De- slowly strengthening – domestic will be undermined by tax increases
cember 2010) for more details
2 See our monthly newsletter on the 3 The base VAT rate was raised from 21% and higher inflation; meanwhile, it is
Latvian economy (September 2010) for to 22%; the reduced rates are up from 10% expected to grow by 4.5% in 2012
more details to 12% (for electricity, from 10% to 22%). (same as in our September’s forecast).
Slowly increasing incomes are
Trade in goods and services
supporting household consumption
900 300
– during the first three quarters of
2010, real net wages had grown by
600 200 nearly 1% and employment by about
3% since the end of 2009 (seasonally
adjusted). Residential household
300 100
deposits started to retreat in the
-30
The ongoing deleveraging and tax
1Q 06 1Q 07 1Q 08 1Q 09 1Q 10
increases, as well as emigration and
Job-seekers' rate FTE* productivity, yoy Unit labour costs, yoy Real gross wage, yoy
high unemployment, will continue to
* FTE - employment in full-time equivalent
dampen the recovery in household Source: CSBL.
-2
-4
-6
-8
Jan Feb Mar Apr Mai Jun Jul Aug Sep Okt Nov Dec
will be transferred to this year, but this Government consumption Household consumption GDP growth
Source: LDS, HBM forecast Sources: Statistics Lithuania, Swedbank
will not be enough to ensure growth.
The private sector, on the other hand,
confidence indicator also suggests an at a slower pace – unemployment
has been lagging in investments in
imminent increase in investments. will continue declining along with
fixed tangible assets – they have been
the total labour force. The biggest
declining since the third quarter of The inflow of foreign direct investment
issue with the labour market is that
2008 and in nominal terms are around to Lithuania this year will amount to 1%
most unemployed have not suitable
levels not seen since 2001. This trend of GDP. More than half of this will be
qualifications or relevant skills and
cannot last – subdued investments reinvestment of profits made in 2010,
have been unemployed for more than
in machinery and equipment dent but new foreign investments will also
one year. At the end of 2009, every
competitiveness and sustainable contribute. The current Prime Minister
10th jobless had been unemployed for
growth. Increasing profits, capacity and the Minister of the Economy spent
longer than one year; by the middle of
utilisation, and slightly better lending some time last year wooing foreign
this year, almost every other will qualify
conditions will underlie a change in companies to invest in Lithuania,
for the status of “long-term jobless.”
trend. mostly in the high-tech and IT sectors.
The persistence of joblessness is
These efforts bore fruit in 2010 and,
In the first half of 2010, corporate intensified by widespread unofficial
along with the stabilised economic
profits increased more than fivefold employment. Last year, the Personal
environment, are expected to have
from a year ago, which, admittedly, Finance Institute of Swedbank
positive effects this year.
was a very bad year. Although profits conducted market research that
are below the levels seen in 2008, the Labour market remains indicated that more than half (54%) of
growth trend is expected to continue challenged officially registered jobless have work-
throughout this year and into 2012. In related incomes. If the government
Our forecast for labour market
the first half of 2010, the pre-tax profit finds ways to nudge these unofficially
developments remains the same: the
margin widened to 3.5% but is still employed into the official labour
recovery in the labour market will be
below the 2005-2008 average of 6.2%. market, the unemployment rate will
slow – both in terms of new workplaces
drop faster than currently forecast.
Capacity utilisation is at 68% – still and net real wage increases. We
Some of these measures include
below the booming years – but the expect that 40,000 workplaces, mostly
requiring long-term jobless to perform
trend is upward pointing, and some in the private sector, will be created
public works, in order to identify “fake”
sectors (wearing apparel and wood) this year, bringing unemployment down
jobless who claim the benefits but are
are already at pre-crisis levels. by 2 percentage points to 15.5%. The
not looking for employment. Other
The upward trend of the industry trend will continue into 2012, although
temporary changes in legislation
(which will expire in July 2012)
Swedbank’s GDP Forecast – Lithuania
introduced social tax breaks for
Changes in volume, % 2009 2010e 2011f 2012f companies who employ workers who
GDP -14.7 0.5 (0.5) 3.0 (3.0) 4.5 (4.5) have never been employed before.
Household consumption -17.7 -5.0 (-5.0) 1.0 (1.0) 3.0 (3.0)
We are keeping our forecast that net
General government consumption -1.9 -3.0 (-3.0) -1.5 (-1.0) 1.0 (1.0)
real wages will be flat this year, after
Gross fixed capital formation -40.0 -5.0 (-9.0) 8.0 (7.0) 8.5 (8.5)
declines of 7.2% and 5.0% in 2009
Export of goods and services -12.7 13.4 (10.5) 6.5 (6.5) 7.7 (7.7) and 2010, respectively, and will grow
Import of goods and services -28.4 12.1 (8.8) 5.0 (5.0) 5.5 (5.5) by 2.5% next year. On the other hand,
Net exports contribution to GDP growth 15.3 0.2 (0.6) 0.8 (0.8) 1.4 (1.4) labour productivity, which grew by
Stockbuiding contribution to GDP growth -5.9 6.4 (6.4) 0.6 (0.6) -0.6 (-0.6) approximately 5% last year, is likely to
Sources: LCD and Swedbank. go up by around 1.5% this year and
1/ The figures from our forecast in September are given in brackets.
3-4% in 2012. The growth of labour
productivity has been below that of now in a negative area, slightly below prices have prompted us to update
wage increases between 2004 and the level seen at the onset of the our forecast on consumer prices. We
2009; a reversal of this relationship global financial crisis and subsequent expect average annual consumer
would have a positive influence on economic recession. inflation to be 2% this year and 2.5%
Lithuanian competitiveness, going in 2012, up from 1.3% in 2010. The
The confidence of retail and services biggest increase is expected in prices
forward. This is especially important
sectors is above zero now, indicating of food and non-alcoholic beverages,
now that peripheral euro zone
that the outlook for consumption is housing, water, electricity, gas, and
countries will be embarking on internal
more positive. However, we expect transport.
devaluation strategies and will intensify
that spending on necessities will be flat
the competition, at least within the EU. Consumer price inflation will be the
this year, and households will spend
Consumers are ready but careful more on nonnecessities, i.e., the first main hurdle Lithuania will have to
households to increase consumption clear to become a member of the
Disposable income will remain close Economic Monetary Union. Although
will be the ones that never actually
to current levels; thus, consumption we do not expect price increases to be
faced any challenges in terms of
recovery this year will be driven anywhere near the levels seen during
decreasing disposable income. This
by a slightly lower savings rate the pre-crisis economic boom, even
trend was already visible in 2010 –
and better expectations. During 2.5% inflation could be high enough
retail sales of transport vehicles and
two years of economic recession, to block fulfilment of this Maastricht
entertainment goods rose, whereas
households accumulated additional criterion. There is a high probability
sales of food and wearing apparel
savings of almost LTL 2 billion. that, in the next couple of years, of
continued to decline. Furthermore,
In 2012, an increase in net real the 27 European Union (EU) member
higher inflation this year will put a
wages, employment, and consumer countries, at least a few will have
cap on spending of lower-income
confidence, as well as better lending close to zero inflation – probably the
households.
conditions, will give a stronger boost PIIGS countries (Portugal, Ireland,
to household consumption. We are Prices will rise faster, euro may Italy, Spain, and Greece), the ones that
keeping our forecast of household have to wait will be undertaking severe austerity
consumption growth of about 1% this programmes. This would set the
The average annual increase of the
year and 3% next year. inflation criterion threshold at around
producer price index spiked to 10% in
Lithuanian consumers, unlike most 2010, after declining by 13% in 2009. 1.5%, which would be very difficult for
citizens in most other developed This was caused mainly by higher Lithuania to meet in 2012 (given that
countries, need not undergo a long energy prices, which went up by about upward price pressure in the country
and painful process of deleveraging 24%. The average price of oil went up will be caused by not only external but
and fixing their balance sheets. Total by 27%, whereas, after the shutdown also internal factors).
household debt is less than 30% of of the Ignalina nuclear power plant Public finances to remain
GDP – one of the lowest in Europe. A average price of electricity rose by strained
bigger drag on consumption in recent more than 30%. Producer prices will
years has been decreasing disposable keep increasing this year, but the pace The biggest internal risk in the short-
income and uncertainty about the will be only half of that seen in 2010. to-medium term will be the health of
future. The risk of unemployment has public finances and the slow pace of
Faster producer price increases last structural reforms. The budget deficit
declined and consumer confidence has
year and further projected increases is likely to be lower this year – at
been increasing for more than a year
in commodities, food, and energy around 6% of GDP – but still above
now. The latter indicator has stabilised
the Maastricht criterion of 3% of GDP
and well above a comfortable level
Export of goods and services, LTL millions for a balanced budget. Although the
6000 1200 national budget this year is exactly
5000 1000 the same as in 2010 – LTL 29.4
4000 800 billion – government consumption will
be lower, mainly due to higher debt-
3000 600
servicing costs, which will amount to
2000 400
LTL 1.9 billion. The ratio of general
1000 200 government debt to GDP almost tripled
0 0 in three years from 15.6% in 2008 to
07-01 07-07 08-01 08-07 09-01 09-07 10-01 10-07
42% in 2011. Although still below the
Exports of goods (ls)
Exports of goods produced in Lithuania (ls) threshold of 60% of GDP, the steep
Exports of services (rs)
Sources: Statistics Lithuania, Bank of Lithuania, Swedbank accumulation of debt is nevertheless
Confidence indicators, %
40
20
0
-20
-40
-60
-80
-100
Sweden
Cecilia Hermansson +46 8 5859 7720 cecilia.hermansson@swedbank.se
Group Chief Economist
Chief Economist, Sweden
Magnus Alvesson +46 8 5859 3341 magnus.alvesson@swedbank.se
Senior Economist
Jörgen Kennemar +46 8 5859 7730 jorgen.kennemar@swedbank.se
Senior Economist
Marie-Anne Larsson +46 8 5859 7740 marie-anne.larsson@swedbank.se
Assistent
Estonia
Maris Lauri +372 6 131 202 maris.lauri@swedbank.ee
Chief Economist, Estonia
Elina Allikalt +372 6 131 989 elina.allikalt@swedbank.ee
Senior Economist
Annika Paabut +372 6 135 440 annika.paabut@swedbank.ee
Senior Economist
Latvia
Mārtiņš Kazāks +371 67 445 859 martins.kazaks@swedbank.lv
Deputy Group Chief Economist
Chief Economist, Latvia
Dainis Stikuts +371 67 445 844 dainis.stikuts@swedbank.lv
Senior Economist
Lija Strašuna +371 67 445 875 lija.strasuna@swedbank.lv
Senior Economist
Lithuania
Nerijus Mačiulis +370 5 258 2237 Nerijus.Maciulis@swedbank.lt
Chief Economist, Lithuania
Lina Vrubliauskienė +370 5 268 4275 lina.vrubliauskiene@swedbank.lt
Senior Economist
Ieva Vyšniauskaitė +370 5 268 4156 ieva.vysniauskaite@swedbank.lt
Senior Economist
Disclaimer
This research report has been prepared by economists of Swedbank’s Economic Research Department. The Economic
Research Department consists of research units in Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and Sweden, is independent of other
departments of Swedbank AB (publ) (“Swedbank”) and responsible for preparing reports on global and home market
economic developments. The activities of this research department differ from the activities of other departments of
Swedbank and therefore the opinions expressed in the reports are independent from interests and opinions that might be
expressed by other employees of Swedbank.
This report is based on information available to the public, which is deemed to be reliable, and reflects the economists’
personal and professional opinions of such information. It reflects the economists’ best understanding of the information at
the moment the research was prepared and due to change of circumstances such understanding might change accordingly.
This report has been prepared pursuant to the best skills of the economists and with respect to their best knowledge this
report is correct and accurate, however neither Swedbank or any enterprise belonging to Swedbank or Swedbanks directors,
officers or other employees or affiliates shall be liable for any loss or damage, direct or indirect, based on any flaws or faults
within this report.
Enterprises belonging to Swedbank might have holdings in the enterprises mentioned in this report and provide financial
services (issue loans, among others) to them. Aforementioned circumstances might influence the economic activities of such
companies and the prices of securities issued by them.
The research presented to you is of informative nature. This report should in no way be interpreted as a promise or
confirmation of Swedbank or any of its directors, officers or employees that the events described in the report shall take place
or that the forecasts turn out to be accurate. This report is not a recommendation to invest into securities or in any other way
enter into any financial transactions based on the report. Swedbank and its directors, officers or employees shall not be liable
for any loss that you may suffer as a result of relying on this report.
We stress that forecasting the developments of the economic environment is somewhat speculative of nature and the real
situation might turn out different from what this report presumes.
IF YOU DECIDE TO OPERATE ON THE BASIS OF THIS REPORT THEN YOU ACT SOLELY ON YOUR OWN RISK AND
ARE OBLIGED TO VERIFY AND ESTIMATE THE ECONOMIC REASONABILITY AND THE RISKS OF SUCH ACTION
INDEPENDENTLY.