Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
ScienceDirect
www.elsevier.com/locate/bushor
a
McCallum School of Business, Bentley University, Waltham, MA 02452, U.S.A.
b
Beedie School of Business, Simon Fraser University, Vancouver, BC, Canada
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bushor.2018.10.003
0007-6813/# 2018 Kelley School of Business, Indiana University. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
132 MARKETING & TECHNOLOGY
non, and this immediately presents problems. Mind- 2. Why now? Reasons for the rise in
fulness’ marketplace meaning has become so defuse interest in mindfulness
as to render the term almost meaningless, while the
widely adopted psychological definition of the term is
at best partial and at worst myopic. There are three important reasons for the surge of
In terms of the marketplace, there are courses interest in mindfulness. The first is that there is an
(mindfulness training is one of the fastest growing ever-rising tsunami of information and stimuli that
industries in the U.S. with over 25% of companies clamor for our attention. Indeed, Nobel laureate
now offering mindfulness training). There are over Herbert Simon (1971) argued almost half a century
1000 apps. The most popular, Headspace, has been ago that in an information-rich world, attention
downloaded over 10 million times. There are nu- becomes our scarcest resource. In this attention
merous wearable devices that assist mindfulness, economy (Davenport & Beck, 2001), there are
such as headbands that monitor brain activity and some ever-proliferating demands on our mental
provide feedback on one’s mental state (Scott, processes and designers of offerings from foods
2017). Beyond this, there are products such as to TV series are becoming more and more adept
mindfulness bracelets (a type of rosary), mindful at hooking our attention and, in the extreme,
bites (a collection of high-calorie snacks), mindful making us addicted to the stimuli they charge
oils (aromatic lotions), mindful meats (organic for (Cooper, 2017). Simply, we live in an age of
meat), services such as mindful farms (organic digital distraction.
farms where you can volunteer), mindful chefs, Thus, mindfulness–—a type of attentional
mindful cleaners, and mindful lawyers. On the book skill–—has risen in prominence. It is offered as a
front, there are a profusion of titles. Some are solution to many of the cognitive ills that plague
thematic, such as the mindful mom-to-be, mindful modern society. These include afflictions such as
birthing, and the mindful child, quickly followed by burn out, depression, anxiety, ADD, stress, and
mindful discipline. Other titles are miscellaneous, addiction. Moreover, there is substantial empirical
such as the mindful athlete, mindful education, evidence of its efficacy, not only for improving the
mindful eating, mindful money, and the mindful health of the afflicted (e.g., Gotink et al., 2015) but
entrepreneur. Recently, there was even a Mindful also in enhancing the cognitive performance of the
Pledge Drive on National Public Radio. healthy in a range of settings from schools to busi-
Its Western psychological definition–—as non- ness (e.g., Good et al., 2016; Meiklejohn et al.,
elaborative, nonjudgmental, present-centered 2012; Wang, Berthon, Pitt, & McCarthy, 2016).
awareness (Bishop et al., 2004)–—is a far cry from The second reason is that, in our technological
the original meaning of the Buddhist term, sati, age, the costs of mindlessness are increasing. The
which initially meant ‘to remember,’ but was ex- misuse of carbon-based fuels, weapons of mass
panded upon and evolved as Buddhism developed. destruction, potent drugs, sophisticated machines,
Indeed, the ‘bare attention’ meaning of mindful- and the emotions that often drive this misuse are
ness only arose in the 20th century through the orders of magnitudes higher in size and distribution
writings of Nyanaponika Thera (1962), a German- of impact than in our bucolic past, where the results
born Sri-Lankan monk. Thus, the semantic range of of mindlessness were local and limited. Even the
the term mindfulness has become substantially cur- mindless sending of an emotional email or the
tailed in Western psychology and, in the general mindless posting of a tweet or photo can reverber-
marketplace, its scope has been stretched so far as ate quickly around the world. Simply, technology
to render it a Rorschach figure onto which people has magnified the contents of our minds to such an
project almost anything (Hefferan, 2015). extent that we are being forced to confront this
This article has three goals. First, to explore the content as a matter of urgency–—for both the planet
context and conditions that have led to the surge in and ourselves.
interest in mindfulness. Second, we clarify what is The third reason is that mindfulness appeals to
meant by mindfulness by tracing its hermeneutical the modern mind. Rationality and individualism
Buddhist roots and offer a typology to show that have led to the questioning of established, dogmat-
there are at least four different types of, or aspects ic religions. Increasingly, proofless beliefs and ad-
to, mindfulness. These can be mapped onto two herence to handed-down codes are looked at with
dimensions and can be organized into a nested suspicion. Thus, mindfulness–—an individual en-
progression. Third, we explore some of the oppor- deavor, relatively free of religious baggage, which
tunities and challenges that mindfulness poses to emphasizes ‘the now’ rather than some promised
managers and, especially, marketing. future heaven or recoverable Lyonesse–—has certain
obvious appeal (Dunne, 2014).
MARKETING & TECHNOLOGY 133
2011). Mindfulness then becomes a way of detecting experiential field so that they may be investigated.
skillful or unskillful ways of working with and alle- Indeed, mindfulness and investigation lead to pan-
viating suffering (Stanley, 2013). Indeed, the whole na, or insight into the true nature of phenomena. As
thrust of Buddhism is the cultivation of insight so as Dreyfus (2011) pointed out, in the Satipatthana
to, in a direct and personal manner, see the chain of Sutta, mindfulness involves the mind’s ability to
cause and effect that leads to suffering. This also attend to and retain an arising experience so as
implies that one may free oneself of the delusions to develop a clear understanding of the phenome-
(or habits of the unreflective mind) that result in non. Mindfulness here is the cognitive ability to hold
suffering (Burton, 2017). together the various aspects of the perceptual pro-
In the Pali Canon, this evolved into a distinct form cess so as to make sense of them. Furthermore, the
of mindfulness: appamanda (Lomas, 2017). Appa- Tibetan tradition developed the notion of a second
mada means earnestness, vigilant care, diligence, type of mindfulness, wise mindfulness (see right
and carefulness. Thus, mindfulness became aware- mindfulness), which comprises mindfulness with
ness infused with ethical care, which in the Bud- clear comprehension that leads to insight (Dreyfus,
dhist context meant right speech, right action, right 2011). Lomas (2017) said that there are at least
morality, and right livelihood. A number of authors three types of mindfulness: awareness of the pres-
have pointed out that, in its incorporation into ent moment, awareness infused with evaluation,
Western psychology, the ethical component to Bud- and awareness that builds on the previous two so as
dhist mindfulness has been neglected (Rosenbaum, to lead to awareness infused with insight.
2009; Stanley, 2012).
Wise
Insight into phenomenon
mindfulness
Right
mindfulness Evaluation of phenomenon
Remembering
mindfulness Returning to phenomenon
(Bodhi, 2011); the latter reflects the degree to mindfulness, comprehension emerges leading to in-
which mindfulness is an act of evaluation rather sight into the true nature of things (wise mindful-
than sight or insight (Gethin, 2011). ness). This is depicted in Figure 2.
Defined by experiential focus and receptive
awareness lies observational mindfulness, the pop-
ular, mainstream definition of mindfulness as bare 5. Challenges and opportunities of
attention or lucid awareness. With a focus on the mindfulness for marketing
experiential, but with an active, evaluative compo-
nent lies remembering mindfulness whereby devi- Tristan Harris, a former product manager at Google,
ation from the object of attention is noticed and recently launched a nonprofit called Time Well
remedied. Again, with an active, evaluative com- Spent, which is devoted to stopping “tech compa-
ponent combined with a more abstract, conceptual nies from hijacking our minds” (Thompson, 2017).
mode lies discriminatory mindfulness, or as the Harris argues that the big platforms (e.g., Apple,
Buddhist sutras call it right mindfulness. Finally, Facebook, Google, YouTube, Snapchat, Twitter, and
with an abstract conceptual mode combined with Instagram) devour our attention with their offer-
receptive and more specifically a reflect mode lies ings. They appropriate the time that, on reflection,
insightful contemplation, or what is known in Bud- we might just wish we had never given.
dhism as wise mindfulness. Harris contends that companies are explicitly
The relationship between these different types of succeeding in hijacking our minds to make money
mindfulness may be arranged as follows. The first (Cooper, 2017). Users of Facebook who merely
mode of mindfulness is that of bare attention or lucid wanted to see their friends’ holiday snaps and be
awareness; here, one is aware of the present moment alerted to upcoming birthdays are now exposed to
or object of attention (observational mindfulness). countless ‘likes’ of mere acquaintances and ads at
However, attention wanders, so the second modality every third or fourth post that no amount of hiding
of mindfulness is the ability to monitor, detect, and or blocking will ever get rid of. Firms such as Face-
return to the object of attention (remembering mind- book, Twitter, Snapchat, and Instagram are also
fulness). Once attention and returning have stabi- spending billions on cutting-edge psychological re-
lized, right mindfulness is the ability to detect search to reveal how to get consumers hooked (in
and evaluate mind states and discern wholesome terms of attention and time spent) on their offer-
from unwholesome states (right mindfulness). Final- ings (Eyal, 2014). Examples include gamification
ly, through the foundations of the other types of strategies such as Snapchat’s streaks, which manip-
136 MARKETING & TECHNOLOGY
ulates kids into sending messages back and forth with 3. The model allows marketers to rethink the ‘at-
their contacts every single day as proof of friendship tention capturing’ and ‘more consumption is bet-
and engendering a fear of breaking the cycle. There ter’ business models and innovate so as to develop
are also the not-so-subtle nudges, such as YouTube’s more mindful modes of business practice.
autoplay that automatically cues up the next video
calculated (from the lots of information Google While present-centered, non-evaluative mindfulness
knows about the viewer) to keep you watching. is an excellent tool for disengaging from habitual and
Increasingly, our attention is not under our own often negative patterns of discursive and affective
control. Choices are made for us not necessarily in reactivity, it has its limitations. For example, obser-
our interest but in the interest of social media com- vational mindfulness may be of little help with ad-
panies and the advertisers they serve. In short, busi- dictive technology platforms and their associated
ness models are designed to make us mindless. content–—being more immersed in a moment-by-
Now before we get all hot and bothered about moment Snapchat streak may even be counterpro-
nasty companies commandeering our minds, it is ductive. Here, evaluative (right) mindfulness is need-
worthwhile to reflect on how we got to where we ed, with the ability to discern the wholesome from
are now. With the rise of the internet, the cost of unwholesome capturing of attention and thereby
duplicating and distributing almost any digital prod- opening us up to the possibility of choice. Further-
uct fell to essentially zero. Physical CDs costing more, mindfulness as remembering or returning to a
anywhere from $10 to $20, could be ripped and particular activity or task in hand–—reminding us to
shared with millions of others in the blink of an exercise, stand up from our desks, or take our med-
eye. Suddenly valuable offerings, such as film, video, ications–—is particularly efficacious in a world of
music, or text became almost worthless. Consumers distraction. Finally, wise mindfulness or mindfulness
got used to getting stuff for free, so business had to that leads to insight is essential if we are to see how
develop new models to generate revenues. They did, our minds are undermined by the technologies and
and a few firms–—because of network effects–—have content we interact with, and equally importantly,
become fabulously large and wealthy in the process. how the mind undermines itself.
The model they developed is the advertising model
we have come to know and mostly loathe. In the world
of the well-known internet dictum: “If you’re not 6. Summary
paying for it, you are the product.” Here, the tradi-
tional offering-consumer relationship is inverted: It is important to stress that there is no one right
Instead of consumers paying for products, they be- view of mindfulness; sati is polysemous–—it has
come the product. And the individual’s attention has many meanings. Buddhism is not monolithic; it
become the currency of the age. has evolved and changed over time (Lopez,
This phenomenon goes a long way toward ex- 2005). And with this evolution, the meaning of
plaining the rise of interest in mindfulness amongst mindfulness has changed.
consumers. So why is it that companies are at the In this article, we elaborate on the types of mind-
forefront of promoting mindfulness within their own fulness found in Buddhism and offer a typology of
organizations? It turns out that employees are just mindfulness that differentiates and integrates them.
as distracted by social media as consumers, and We also propose a nested model of modes of mindful-
firms see mindfulness practice as a way of enhanc- ness and show how each mode can augment the
ing employee’s productivity and well-being. It is previous mode. We also briefly explore the opportu-
telling that Silicon Valley parents are far more nities and challenges that mindfulness poses to firms.
rigorous in limiting or even eliminating their child- Opportunities to develop offerings that promote and
ren’s access to social media than parents in general enable different modes of mindfulness, and chal-
(Fleming, 2015). lenges to innovate to develop new business models
So, let us return to the model of mindfulness pre- that do not run on attention become readily apparent.
sented here. Our typology of mindfulness and nested
model of modes of mindfulness allows three things:
References
1. A better understanding of the phenomenon of
mindfulness. It expands the notion of mindful- Bishop, S. R., Lau, M., Shapiro, S., Carlson, L., Anderson, N. D.,
ness while identifying four distinct modalities. Carmody, J., et al. (2004). Mindfulness: A proposed
operational definition. Clinical Psychology: Science and Prac-
tice, 11(3), 230—241.
2. Once differentiated, it allows firms to develop Bodhi, B. (2011). What does mindfulness really mean? A canoni-
offerings to help particular modes of mindfulness. cal perspective. Contemporary Buddhism, 12(1), 19—39.
MARKETING & TECHNOLOGY 137
Burton, D. (2017). Buddhism, knowledge, and liberation: A Kornfield, J. (1977). Living Buddhist masters. Santa Cruz, CA:
philosophical study. Abingdon-on-Thames, UK: Routledge. Unity Press.
Cooper, A. (2017). What is “brain hacking”? Tech insiders on why Lomas, T. (2017). Recontextualizing mindfulness: Theravada
you should care. 60 Minutes, CBS News. Available at http:// Buddhist perspectives on the ethical and spiritual dimensions
www.cbsnews.com/news/ of awareness. Psychology of Religion and Spirituality, 9(2),
brain-hacking-tech-insiders-60-minutes/ 209—219.
Davenport, T. H., & Beck, J. C. (2001). The attention economy: Lopez, D. (2005). The story of Buddhism: A concise guide to its
Understanding the new currency of business. Brighton, MA: history and teachings. New York, NY: Harper.
Harvard Business Press. Meiklejohn, J., Phillips, C., Freedman, M. L., Griffin, M. L.,
Dreyfus, G. (2011). Is mindfulness present-centred and non- Biegel, G., Roach, A., et al. (2012). Integrating mindfulness
judgmental? A discussion of the cognitive dimensions of training into K-12 education: Fostering the resilience of
mindfulness. Contemporary Buddhism, 12(1), 41—54. teachers and students. Mindfulness, 3(4), 291—307.
Dunne, J. (2014). Dharma and the modern world. Mandala Olendzki, A. (2011). The construction of mindfulness. Contem-
Magazine, January—March. Available at https://issuu.com/ porary Buddhism, 12(1), 55—70.
fpmtinc/docs/mandala_jan-mar2014 Rosenbaum, R. (2009). Empty mindfulness in humanistic psycho-
Eyal, N. (2014). Hooked: How to build habit-forming products. therapy. The Humanistic Psychologist, 37(2), 207—221.
London, UK: Penguin. Scott, B. (2017, March 1). Why meditation and mindfulness
Fleming, A. (2015, May 23). Screen time v play time: What tech training is one of the best industries for starting a business
leaders won’t let their own kids do. The Guardian. Available in 2017. Inc. Available at https://www.inc.com/bartie-scott/
at https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/may/ best-industries-2017-meditation-and-mindfulness-training.
23/screen-time-v-play-time-what-tech-leaders-wont-let- html
their-own-kids-do Simon, H. A. (1971). Designing organizations for an information-
Gethin, R. (2011). On some definitions of mindfulness. Contem- rich world. In M. Greenberger (Ed.), Computers, communi-
porary Buddhism, 12(1), 263—279. cation, and the public interest. Baltimore, MD: The Johns
Gogerly, D. (1908). The books of discipline. In A. S. Bishop (Ed.), Hopkins Press.
Ceylon Buddhism being the collected works of Daniel John Stanley, S. (2012). Intimate distances: William James’ introspec-
Gogerly (pp. 45—100). Whitefish, MT: Kessinger Publishing. tion, Buddhist mindfulness, and experiential inquiry. New
Good, D. J., Lyddy, C. J., Glomb, T. M., Bono, J. E., Brown, K. W., Ideas in Psychology, 30(2), 201—211.
Duffy, M. K., et al. (2016). Contemplating mindfulness at Stanley, S. (2013). From discourse to awareness: Rhetoric, mind-
work: An integrative review. Journal of Management, 42(1), fulness, and a psychology without foundations. Theory and
114—142. Psychology, 23(1), 60—80.
Gotink, R. A., Chu, P., Busschbach, J. J., Benson, H., Fricchione, Thera, N. (1962). The heart of Buddhist meditation: A handbook
G. L., & Hunink, M. M. (2015). Standardised mindfulness- of mental training based on the Buddha’s way of mindful-
based interventions in healthcare: An overview of systematic ness. London, UK: Rider and Company.
reviews and meta-analyses of RCTs. PloS One, 10(4), Thompson, N. (2017, July 26). Our minds have been hijacked by
e0124344. our phones. Tristan Harris wants to rescue them.
Hefferan, V. (2015, April 19). Mind the gap. New York Times Wired. Available at https://www.wired.com/story/our-
Magazine, p. MM13. minds-have-been-hijacked-by-our-phones-tristan-harris-
James, W. (1890/1950). The principles of psychology. New York, wants-to-rescue-them/
NY: Henry Holt. Wang, E. J., Berthon, P., Pitt, L., & McCarthy, I. P. (2016).
Kabat-Zinn, J. (1994). Wherever you go, there you are. New Service, emotional labor, and mindfulness. Business Hori-
York, NY: Hyperion. zons, 59(6), 655—661.