Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
There are several basic problems with this volume. The first is the
Sims's list of challenges itself: Why should HRIS be listed as a primary
challenge, for example, when attention to such arguably more important
issues as the future of legislative and regulatory reform, or the problems
of building a committed and productive workforce in a rising sea of con-
tingent workers are not more fully addressed? A second problem is even
more fundamental: The authors have combined two different books into
one. In reading it, I was not sure whether I was reading an introduction
to the fundamentals of HRM or a review of trends impacting HRM. In
terms of the former, the reader would be better advised to simply pick
up a competent introductory text. For the latter, one would be equally
if not better served by the Coates, Jarratt and Mahaffie volume. Future
Work (1990) or by Bridges'/ofe Shift (1994). Third, the authors tend to
repeat information, so that one reads this book with a continuing sense of
dijh. vu. Better editing should have caught this problem. Finally, there
are a number of difficult, if not dubious, assertions sprinkled throughout
the text. The example offered earlier about separate training for women
and disabled people is but one of a chain of 10 or so question marks I
found threaded through the text.
The HRM professional will find less that is new but more that is to
quibble about in this volume. Students starting out may benefit from the
introduction to HRM provided but would be counseled to shop around
a bit before putting their $60 down here.
REFERENCES
Coates JF, Jarratt J, Mahaffie JB. (1990). Future work. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Bridges W. (1994). Job shift. New York: Addison-Wesley.