You are on page 1of 9

c

Department of Law

LW2031/LW2033/LW2034 EU Law

³Access to judicial review by private


parties after the Treaty of Lisbon´

Kristian Bro

Tutor: Camilla Baasch Andersen


Studentnumber: 109020341

:
1845 words/2136words in entire document
_  
c c  
 c   c c c  
 
c c  c c c c c  c c

c
c  c c  c c c c  c c c 

c cc   c
 c c c  c c c 
 c c c  c   
c c c
  c c  c c c 
c 
c c c  c c  c  
c c

!  "c
  
c 
c  c c  c c 
c 
"c 
c  
c c c c   
c c
 cc c 
cc 

c


   
# cc c 
c c c  c c 
c  c c  c c c c
 c

c c  
c 
   
 c  c c c  
c $
c 
c c "
c
 c
cc

   
# c%&c c  c c  
cc c 
"c 

c c
c  "c
 !  "c 
c

!  "c   
c c  c c c  c c c c

c  c  c '|  ||   |
  =c c  c  c 
c  c %(&c c  c c

"c

c cc c
  c
cc c$)cc ccc c  c
c* 
c c
c c%(&c c  cc
c 
c c%(&cc
c 

c 
c" c
c c cc
 c+cc   c  c
c
c 
"cc" c c cc
c
 c c c c 

c c c
c c  cc
cc
 c
cc    c c cc
 c 

c
cc
c
 
cc c  c" c c c cc
  cc
"c

!
"  c c
c c c
 cc 
c  
c c c 
  c 
c
c c  ,
c c c  c   c -c 
c c  c c c c c   c
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc cccccccc

c.c c/%&c$c

c$ c0 c
c1
c c2c

c+c c(3c

c

c
 c c 
"c c c c"  c c c
c
  cc c$)cc
'|  |   |        | |  | |  =(c  c c c 
c

 
c 
c c 
c " 
c 
c  c 42%&c c -c c c "c  c c '|   
|
    |
 =3c c  cc
cc c c
 c c  c 
c  c  c c     c   c 
c   c  c 

 c

"cc" cc  

"c c 
"c  cc 
  c
   
c
  c !c
c
 c 

c

0 c 

c

c c 

!  c 
 ccc* 
cc  
c
c"c
 c c
* 
c c  
c 
c  c c  c c c 
5c  
c c  c 
c c
 "c c 
c  c  c c c  c  c 
"c c "c  
6c +
c  c
  
c   c " c c  c   c c "c c c  c 
c c c
  
c c" 
c c
c c ccc c c  
c cc"
 c
cc  c
c 
c c   c  c c c c c
c c$)cc

c  cc cc
c
 
c  
cc
c   4c cc
c 
c c
c 
"c c  
 c c cc    c 
cc c ccc cc

c c  c c  c   
c  c c  
 c  c 
c c
 
c " 
c
c
  c c
 c c "2cc c   c  cc c c 

c

c c   c* 
cc"c
 c 
c  c c  ccc"c" c
c 

"c 
c 
c c  c c c 
c 7 
! /c c  c c c
 
c8 
cc
 c cc"c" c c cc' 
 =c
c c

cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc cccccccc
(
c$ c0 c
c1
c c(3c c
c c c
c c  | | | 
     |    c
3
c+c c(3c

c+c c(3c
6
c|      c c4c%
 c !29/c
c c(c
c$ c0 c
c1
c

 cc 429/c-c  &c
c|    c c3c
4
c.cc
 
c| |   c
2
c$ c0 c
c1
c c(c
/
c | |!
| ||  c cc

c

c
c
 cc c* 
cc c 

c cc
c  c 

 c c c
* 
c 
c  
c c  c c  c  c c   c  c 
c  c c c

c  c  cc cc
c"c" c c c
   
c 
c c 

 c
c
c
cc

+
 c 

c

c c 
 
c c 
"cc"  c cc c c
 c 

c c

"c c c | |  " #     c c c '8 

c  =c c
 :c c c
 c 

c  c
c cc c% cc
"
c "  c  c  c &c  c c
 c c c ' |   |  

  |   |        |$ |   | 


 
  | =c+ cc c  c c  c c* 
c
c c'8 

c
 =c
c ccc c 
"c
c  cc  

c cc c
c
 c  cc  

c c* 
cc c c   c  ccc  c
c
c 
c" cc  cc  

cc  ccc c" c-cc cc c
 c  c c c c  c 
 c 

c c " 
c c ;c
(
< 

"c  c c c 
c* 
cc
cc c 5cc cc
c $)c    c 
c c c   
c c  c c c c 5c c
 c 
c
 
c  3!cc 
 
c c" 
c 
c   c 
c  cc

 c cc    c 
cc cc
c" 
c"
 c c  c c  c

c c    c " c c 

c c 
c  c #   c =
c ) c c c

cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc cccccccc

c| | "#    !
| !    c cc
c c 
c
'%  =c

c.
c c'8 

c  >=c cc 


"ccc

c c
c c c-cc$"c8c
' |&'|  | ' | ()   |)=c3/2!/cc
c
c$ c
0 c
c1
c c(2c
 c/3c

c   *  $ | |
 |c
(
c< 
c;c'+  ,-./ 
 | ||  ?=c
3
c.c%
||      
c 0 12    

c;c$c'|)| 
|3 =ccc c
c$"
c
c.,, ,5c cc
c c
 

cc#   c=
c) c
c 0 12    c c32c

c

c
  c  c c '8 

c  =c 
c c  

c 
c 8#6c 
"c c c c " c c
 c cc c c
c" 
c cc
c 
   
c c'
 c 

=c 
c
 c%(&c c" 
cc#   c=
c) cc
 
c c c$)c
 cc c c c 
"
"c c
   
cc c
 c 

c
c c
cc
cc c  c  c "c  c 
 
c"cc c c
 c c%(&c c
 c " c c 
 
c c c c 
c 
 c 

c c $)c
c
c c c c8 

c c c  c 
   
c-c
c c  c c""c
    c   c 
c "c 
"c c 
   
c c c 
c     c

   
c c
 c 4c


   
# c 6c c 5c  c c c c
 
c  c c 5c c c  
c

c  c  c c  c c  c c  c  c  c  
c c
 c 
c c

 
c  c c
 c   
c c  c  
 !c 2c + c " c c

 c c c   c  c c  c c '


    |      
 |       |   &     |    
    |   4|   
3  56&|    |)|   |   | 
 
| | =/c+ cccc  ccc  cc c c cc ccc c5cc
c  c # c 44c c
 c  c  c * 
c c   c  c  
c  c c
 cc ccc cc' 
c=c c 5c c cc c c
cc

cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc cccccccc
6
c+c
4
c.c
c  c
c@ c.  
c'  |   |   || 

||

|  7  )|#89.4:6;!=c


2
c#   c=
c) c 

c
c 0 12    c c(ccc
c
@c  c
c@c. 
c' $      7|  
 <=c c(c
/
c@c  c
c@c. 
c' $      7|  
 <=c c(c

c=|' >

  c

(c

c
ð   
+ c c   c
c c   c  c  c c  c c 
c c c  c c c

"c " c  c 
c  c c 
c
c c  c  c 

c c c

c ccc 

c  cc" c cc  cc

! ! 
ccc
 
  c 
 c c 
"c-c 
c 
c  c c c c c 
"c 
c 
c
 
c c 
 
c  c c "  c   c  c c 
c c  c
 c

"c 
"c 
c  
c c  c  c 
c
 c c c c  c c
c# c c" 
c
c 8#cc cc c  c c  c c c
c 
"c "cc  c 
 
c c  c  c cc " c   
 c c
 
 c
c c    c  c cc
c
c  c c c
" 
cc
 c  c
c c 
c

c cc c'=cc" 
"cc c c c
 
 c 
c c    c -c  c 
"
c c c 
"c    c 
c c
 
c #c  c  
 
c  c c c c  c  c  c
c  c 
c c c "   c c '$
   
c  =c  c
 c   c c
  c
c 
   
c c  !c 
c 
 c 

c  c     c
  c 
c  
c "c c  c c 
c c  c c c 5c  
c c
 
"c  c c $)c c c  c  c c c " c  c   c ' |
  =c

c   c c c 


   
c 
c c  
 c c c  c c  c c c
 c c 
"c c c c c c# c c  
c c$)ccc c"c
5c  c c 
c 
c c c   
c c 
"c c  c-c c
c  cc
"c  
"c  c c cc
c c+ cc
c c c 
c
c 5c c c c  c  c  c c
 c 
c  c "
 
c #
 c
" 
c c  c ' |   |   
|
|  )    
   
  | 
  =(c
c c"c  c
c c 
c

cc  c

c  c 
c  c -c  c c   c c "c 
c " 
c c " 
c c
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc cccccccc

c$c3/9///c8c c(c

c@ c.  
c'  |   |   || 
||

|  7  )


|#89.4:6;!=c
(
c$ c0 c
c1
c c(c

3c

c
 

"c 
c "
 c c  *c  c c c   c  c c  c  c c
  c  c
c
cc
c  c c c 
5c c  
c 
c c
 c c
c  
 
c c c  c c 
c  c c  ,cc c  

c 
c
 
c c  c   c 

c c  c   c  c c c c c

"c"
c" 
cc" 
c
c  c c c

c
c c
ccc cc   c  c
c  c c  cc
cc
 cc c  c

 
 
c

   

  
c  cc
c

c  c


c c


"cc c 
c

c

c

c
$
 c 
cc c  c 
"c c 
c$ 
 c

ð 
    

$c9c | | |      |   


 cA2Bc$<c(6c

$c$!3/9///c8c  12   # A//Bc$<c+!66c

$c$!(49/c8c | |!


| ||  cA//(Bc$<c+!42c

$c$!329/6c8c   *  $ | |


 |cA//2Bc$<c+!/////c

$c !669/c3  5c

$c !429/c|      cA//2Bc$<c++!4c

$c !34392c%
||      c%223&c$<c++!/3c

$c396c=|' >

  A26Bc$<c263c

$c94c| |   cA243Bc$;<c/6c

$c292c|    cA26/Bc$<c43c

ï


ï 
$ c0 
:c0 c= c
c1
c="c%//&c' 
c

c=c

6c

c
%
  
c$ "c
  c8c$ "c//&c

$"
c# c
c.,, ,5c5c%//4&c'
 

"cc=c%
c 
c
 
c. cCc1c

c//4&c c

7"cc
c7
c< c%//&c'c< =c% c 
c  
c< c
$ 
"
c//&c

-  
@ c.  
c'  |   |   || 
|
|

|  7  )|#89.4:6;!=c%//&c-c 


cc< c3(c
c
@c  c
c@c. 
c' $      7| 
 <=c%//3&c-c$ c)  cD c(c
c
$"c8c'" c. 

"c
c. 
 c< c
c$ 
 c=c%22(&c
Ec)
cc"c. c(%(&c3/6c
c
;c$c'|)| 
|3 =c%//&c3c1
cc< cc

4c