Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
FACULTY OF COMMERCE AND
MANAGEMENT
Organisational Behaviour Paper
CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATIONAL
EFFECTIVENESS
Prepared by
29th September 2008
Maureen GIDEON
CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS 29Sep08
Table of Contents
2 MS601 Paper by Maureen GIDEON,
CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS 29Sep08
CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATIONAL
EFFECTIVENESS.
1.0 INTRODUCTION.
Change Management concepts defined
1.1 Management
Management is that which is entrusted with the responsibility, accountability and authority to
insure attainment of organizational objectives.
1.2 Organization
Organization exist in a dynamic environment, it receive resources from the environment and
gives to the environment its output. It also depends on its internal environment because an
organization consists of individuals, groups and structure.
1.3 Change Management
In thinking about what is meant by “change management,” at least four basic definitions come
to mind:
1. The task of managing change.
2. An area of professional practice.
3. A body of knowledge.
4. A control mechanism.
The Task of Managing Change
The first and most obvious definition of “change management” is that the term refers to the
task of managing change. The obvious is not necessarily unambiguous. Managing change is
itself a term that has at least two meanings.
One meaning of “managing change” refers to the making of changes in a planned and managed
or systematic fashion. The aim is to more effectively implement new methods and systems in
an ongoing organization. The changes to be managed lie within and are controlled by the
organization. (Perhaps the most familiar instance of this kind of change is the “change control”
aspect of information systems development projects.). However, these internal changes might
have been triggered by events originating outside the organization, in what is usually termed
“the environment.” Hence, the second meaning of managing change, namely, the response to
3 MS601 Paper by Maureen GIDEON,
CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS 29Sep08
changes over which the organization exercises little or no control (e.g., legislation, social and
political upheaval, the actions of competitors, shifting economic tides and currents, and so on).
Researchers and practitioners alike typically distinguish between a knee‐jerk or reactive
response and an anticipative or proactive response.
An Area of Professional Practice
The second definition of change management is "an area of professional practice."
There are dozens, if not hundreds, of independent consultants who will quickly and proudly
proclaim that they are engaged in planned change, that they are change agents, that they
manage change for their clients, and that their practices are change management practices.
There are numerous small consulting firms whose principals would make these same
statements about their firms. And, of course, most of the major management consulting firms
have a change management practice area.
Some of these change management experts claim to help clients manage the changes they face
– the changes happening to them. Others claim to help clients make changes. Still others offer
to help by taking on the task of managing changes that must be made. In almost all cases, the
process of change is treated separately from the specifics of the situation. It is expertise in this
task of managing the general process of change that is laid claim to by professional change
agents.
A Body of Knowledge
Stemming from the view of change management as an area of professional practice there arises
yet a third definition of change management: the content or subject matter of change
management. This consists chiefly of the models, methods and techniques, tools, skills and
other forms of knowledge that go into making up any practice.
The content or subject matter of change management is drawn from psychology, sociology,
business administration, economics, industrial engineering, systems engineering and the study
of human and organizational behavior. For many practitioners, these component bodies of
knowledge are linked and integrated by a set of concepts and principles known as General
Systems Theory (GST). It is not clear whether this area of professional practice should be
termed a profession, a discipline, an art, a set of techniques or a technology. For now, suffice it
to say that there is a large, reasonably cohesive albeit somewhat eclectic body of knowledge
underlying the practice and on which most practitioners would agree — even if their
application of it does exhibit a high degree of variance.
A Control Mechanism
4 MS601 Paper by Maureen GIDEON,
CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS 29Sep08
For many years now, Information Systems groups have tried to rein in and otherwise ride herd
on changes to systems and the applications that run on them. For the most part, this is
referred to as “version control” and most people in the workplace are familiar with it. In recent
years, systems people have begun to refer to this control mechanism as “change management”
and "configuration management." Moreover, similar control mechanisms exist in other areas.
Chemical processing plants, for example, are required by OSHA to satisfy some exacting
requirements in the course of making changes. These fall under the heading of Management of
Change or MOC.
To recapitulate, there are at least four basic definitions of change management:
1. The task of managing change (from a reactive or a proactive posture)
2. An area of professional practice (with considerable variation in competency and skill levels
among practitioners)
3. A body of knowledge (consisting of models, methods, techniques, and other tools)
4. A control mechanism (consisting of requirements, standards, processes and procedures).
Generally, change management is a structured approach to transitioning individuals, teams,
and organizations from a current state to a desired future state The current definition of
change management include both organizational change management processes and individual
change management models, which together are used to manage people side of change.
1.4 Organizational Change Management.
Organizational change management includes processes and tools for managing the people side
of change at an organizational level. These tools include a structured approach that can be used
to effectively transition groups or organizations through change. When combine with an
understanding of individual change management, these tools provide a framework for
managing the people side of change. Organizational change management processes include
techniques for creating a change management strategy (readiness assessments), engaging
senior managers as change leaders, (sponsorship), building awareness of the need for change
(communications), developing skills and knowledge to support the change (education and
training), helping employees move though the transition (coaching managers and supervisors),
and methods to sustain the change (measurement systems, rewards and reinforcement).
1.5 The Role of Management.
Management’s responsibility (and that of administration in case of political changes) is to
detect trends in the macro environment as well as in the microenvironment so as to be able to
identify changes and initiate programs. It is also important to estimate what impact a change
will likely have on employee behavior patterns, work processes, technological requirements,
5 MS601 Paper by Maureen GIDEON,
CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS 29Sep08
and motivation. Management must assess what employee reactions will be and craft a change
program that will provide support as workers go through the process of accepting change.
1.6 Organizational Effectiveness.
Organizational effectiveness implies the ability of organization to realize its multiple goals that
is profitability, productivity, employee satisfaction, social responsibility, financial stability and
survival in a changing environment.
1.7 Types of Change
• A change is external and internal environment if not well managed can completely halt the
organization and makes very hard to achieve its purpose.
• The external environment includes technology, political, social economic conditions, legal
market condition etc. In order for an organization to attain its multiple objectives, it must
manage the internal and external environment as well as any change that occurs in either
the internal or external environment. Thus change management focus on proper
coordination, planning, controlling, directing and rising firms resources which are both
internal and external so as to attain its multiple objectives.
• The ultimate goal of any organization is to be effective .This means be able to attain its
goals which are the purpose of its being.
• The survival of an organizational will depend on its ability to adopt and control the changes
in its environment, which is the source of its resources these can be either proactive or
reactive.
• A technological development changes the method of producing and providing goods and
services, jobs become increasingly complex and technologically interdependent, such
changes can present challenges for organizations and their managers. They need to be
effectively managed.
2.0 IMPORTANCE OF ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGE.
The environment provides the resources and opportunities for the organization’s existence. It
also determines what an organization can do and what it cannot do. If the organization wants
to be effective as it should, then it must adapt to the demands of the environment. Since these
demands/conditions are constantly changing, organizations must also change.
Changes are usually introduced through people, people must therefore be willing to accept the
need and responsibility for organizational change, if the intended changes has to occur.
Nevertheless people also depend on the organization; they must therefore learn to change
their attitudes and behavioral patterns to match the constantly changing environment for the
sake of the survival of the organization.
6 MS601 Paper by Maureen GIDEON,
CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS 29Sep08
A flexible organizational structure should encourage adaptation. Rapidly controlled
organizational relationships between and within work groups can impede the information
processing activities.
Task complexity occasioned by technological changes require people to be trained in their jobs
for the future and the present .Task interdependency demands people work together in groups
rather than as individuals. Members must therefore be technically and psychologically prepared
to adapt, faiure to which may lead to major problems.
3.0 CHANGE OVER TIME – SIGMOID CURVE
Every organization will follow its own sigmoid curve, but different organizations will move at
different paces for different reasons. Charles Handy, who basically suggested that change might
result in improvement and progress but that progress will plateau and eventually decline,
highlighted the sigmoid curve in relation to management studies. To avoid such decline,
decisions have to be made about further improvement at the point where success is growing
and before the business starts to experience this plateau. For many in business, this is a difficult
thing to get staff to do; many may have just been through testing and anxious times and just
when it appears that there might be time to relax and bask in success, the management are
asking for further sacrifices and effort to be made.
Charles Handy describes how the Sigmoid Curve can be used as a concept for change
management. The Sigmoid Curve sums up the story of life itself. We start slowly, experimentally
and falteringly, we wax and then we wane. It is also the story of a product's life‐cycle and of
many an organization’s rise and fall. Luckily, there is life beyond the curve. The secret of
constant growth in any organization is to start a new Sigmoid Curve before the first one peters
out. The right place to start that second curve is at point X.
At this point there is the time, as well as the resources and the energy, to get the new curve
through its initial explorations and floundering before the first curve begins to dip downwards.
That would seem obvious, were it not for the fact that at point X all the messages coming
through to the individual or the institution are that everything is going fine, that it would be
folly to change when the current recipes are working so well.
All that we know of change, be it personal change or change in organizations, tells us that the
real energy for change only comes when you are looking disaster in the face, at point B on the
first curve. At this point, however, it is going to require a mighty effort to drag oneself up to
where, by now, one should be on the second curve.
7 MS601 Paper by Maureen GIDEON,
CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS 29Sep08
Wise are they who start the second curve at point X, because that is the way to build a new
future while maintaining the present. Even then, however, the problems do not end. The
second curve, be it a new product, a new way of operating, a new strategy or a new culture, is
going to be noticeably different from the old. It has to be.
Without further change, the business will eventually witness a decline in progress around point
Y. For many businesses in a rapidly changing global market this may be too late. However, if the
business looks at its position at point X it can look back to see how far it has come and could sit
back and reflect on its success. If it looks ahead, it can try to forecast the likely dip in progress
and begin to implement changes that will take it onto a new sigmoid curve (the gold line). This
period (indicated by the shaded area) is a very difficult time for leading change, there may well
be anxiety, confusion and cultural change required before the successful transition to the new
curve. The leadership skills here could make or break the change process and it is this skill that
many corporations are willing to pay big money to acquire!
4.0 FORCES FOR CHANGE.
More organizations face a dynamic and changing environment. This in turn, is requiring these
organizations to adapt “change or die”.
8 MS601 Paper by Maureen GIDEON,
CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS 29Sep08
4.1 Nature of work force.
Human resource policies and practices have to change to reflect the needs of an aging labor
force, so companies are required to spend more money on training so as to upgrade
employee’s skills.
4.2 Technological Advancement.
Technology is changing jobs and organizations for example introduction of computers, now
almost every organization they use computers.
4.3 Competitions are changing.
Because of globalization, competitors are likely to come from outside and inside the country.
Then it makes necessary for organizations to defend themselves against competitor who
develops new products and services. Successful organization will be the one that can change in
response to the competition.
4.4 Social changes.
Social changes reflect in terms of people’s aspirations, their needs, and their way of working
Social changes have taken place because of the several forces like level of education.
5.0 CHANGE STYLES.
The right change style is needed to implement the change management process. Different
types of change styles include:‐
• Collaborative: the target populations are engaged in the change process, typically through
cascading workshops or meeting. They will be kept up to date on the issues. Their views will
be actively sought and acted upon. Feedback will demonstrate how their input has been
acted upon.
• Consultative: The target population is informed about the changes and their views are
sought.
• Directive: Informing the work force about the changes and why those changes are
important.
• Coercive: Telling the work force that change is taking place and the new rules must be
obeyed.
Organizational change management may provide various types of change styles, but defines a
specific outline that is easy to follow for the future success of the company or entity involved.
6.0 RESISTANCE TO CHANGE.
9 MS601 Paper by Maureen GIDEON,
CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS 29Sep08
Several things have to be in place for organizational change management to work. Many
projects fail when certain things do not line up. Some of the major reasons for failure include:
• Technical issues.
• Management problems.
• Lack of definite objectives.
• Lack of communication: When change is not communicated to all parties affected by the
change, resistance becomes a huge problem.
• Inexperience and complexity: It is another major cause for failure of organization so there
has to be an understanding involved for the change to take place, resistance to change can
be overt, implicit, immediate or differed. It is easier to deal with resistance when it is overt
and immediate for example a change is proposed and employees quickly respond by
complaining ,engaging in a work slow down, threatening to go strike or the like. The greater
challenge is managing resistance that is implicit and differed these results to loss of morale
to work, increased errors or mistakes.
7.0 WAYS TO OVERCOME RESISTANCE TO CHANGE.
• Education and communication: Help the employees to see the logic of a change. This
assumes the source of resistance is misinformation or poor communication.
• Participation: It is difficult for individual to resist a change decision in which they
participated before making a change for those who resist can be brought into the decision
process.
• Facilitation and support: Change agents can do a range of supportive efforts to reduce
resistance.
• Planned organizational change: A technical change necessitates a change in production
systems.
A change in consumer demands calls for a change in the company’s products and services.
Some changes in an organization may occur naturally, however most of them require careful
planning and implementation.
The change process involves three stages:
• Unfreezing: This involves looking of existing attitudes and values systems, managerial
behavior and organizational structure
• Change: This is the action stage whereby actual changes occur in the current value systems,
managerial behaviors and structures.
• Refreezing: This involves the refreezing of the newly acquired values, behaviors and
structure, this leads to status quo.
10 MS601 Paper by Maureen GIDEON,
CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS 29Sep08
8.0 CHANGE MANAGEMENT PROCESS.
Change management process is a process of requesting, determining attainability planning,
implementing and evaluation of change to a system.
Change management is an important process because it can deliver vast benefits by improving
the system and then by satisfying customer needs.
8.1 Role for the Change Management Process.
• Customer: the customer is the role that requests a change due to problems encountered or
new functionality requirements can be in – or external to the company that is asked to
implement the change.
• Management: It is management responsibility to estimate what impact a change will likely
have on employee behavior patterns, work processes, technological requirements and
motivation. Management must assess what employee reactions will be and craft a change
program that will provide support as workers go through the process of accepting change.
The program must then be implemented, disseminated throughout the organization,
monitored for effectiveness and adjusted where necessary.
8.2 Activity Description for the Change Management Process.
• Identify potential change.
− A customer desires new functionality and formulates a requirement.
− A customer encounters a problem in the system and this leads to a problem report.
− A customer proposes a change through creation of a change request.
• Analyze change request.
− Management determines the technical feasibility of the proposed change request,
leading to a change technical feasibility. Management or change agent determines the
costs and benefits of the proposed change request, resulting in change costs and
benefits.
• Evaluate change.
Based on change requested its change technical feasibility and change costs and benefits
then change committee or management makes go/no‐ go decision.
• Plan a change.
Analyze a change impact; the extent of change is determined in a change impact analysis. A
change planning is created for the implementation of the change.
11 MS601 Paper by Maureen GIDEON,
CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS 29Sep08
• Implement change.
The change is programmed then a new system is released which reflects that the applied
change is made public.
9.0 ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS.
Organizational effectiveness can be achieved through a number of points of view;
• Theoretical point of view.
• Developmental point of view.
• Managerial point of view.
9.1 Theoretical View.
This assumes that an organizational effectiveness can be achieved when there exist a fit
between:
• Organization and its environment.
• Various organizational components.
This perspective defines organizational effectiveness as one with;
• Satisfactory profit or return on investment.
• An ability to achieve its current goals.
• An ability to satisfy its members/stakeholders.
• An ability to adapt continuously to changes and to survive in the changing environment.
The organization should be concerned with both current and future state.
This view is based on two hypothesis;‐
• That an organization is composed of several components, and
• That it is part of the environment in which it functions.
The organization ability to transform the inputs into outputs depends on its ability to organize
the internal components and respond to the changing conditions in the environment.
Thus there should exist fundamentally two fits:
• Among the various internal organizational components, and
• Between the organization and its external environment.
a. Internal organizational fit;
These include;
• Task‐Individual fit; Matching people and the jobs they do.
• Task‐group fit; matching the group to the group task.
12 MS601 Paper by Maureen GIDEON,
CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS 29Sep08
• Task‐structure fit; matches the task informational requirements.
• Task‐leader fit; matching manager’s leadership style with the task.
• Leader‐group fit; matching leadership style with the people.
• Reward‐group fit; Reward system can encourage cooperation or promote competition.
• Reward‐task fit; Tasks differ in their international requirements, some tasks require a high
degree of interaction, others do not.
b. External Organizational fit;
Environmental forces have a major impact on the nature of organizational tasks, information
processing requirements and the organization structure:
Thus managers need to maintain three key fits to deal with the external environmental threats;
• Environmental task fit; is the environment simple and static or is it simple and dynamic?
• Mass production system fits simple static environment intensive technological system fits simple
dynamic environment.
• Environment information fit;
• Simple static environment requires low level of information processing.
• Complex dynamic environment requires higher level of information processing.
o Information structure fit;
• Functional structure fits well to simple static environment
• Matrix structure fits well to complex dynamic environment.
9.2 Development Point of View.
This focuses on the effort to increase the ability of its internal components to fit to the
demands of the environmental changes.
The managerial effort to find the sources of misfits and to correct them is defined as
organizational development.
This involves;
• Diagnosing organizational components.
• Identifying the sources of misfits, and
• Undertaking corrective action.
c. Identifying the sources of misfits,
The most common misfits are;
• Environmental –task misfit
• Environmental‐structure misfit.
• Individual –structure misfit (too restrictive from individual).
13 MS601 Paper by Maureen GIDEON,
CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS 29Sep08
• Task individual misfits; Individual needs not adequately met by the task or the individual
does not have the necessary skills.
• Individual‐group misfit.
• Leader‐member misfit
• Reward –task misfit.
d. Undertaking corrective actions.
Once the misfits have been identified the management can undertake developmental activities
aimed at correcting them.
These include two categories;
• Behavioral, and
• Structural.
e. Behavioral Programmes
These target the development of both individuals and groups. They aim at changing attitudes,
behavior and interaction patterns and the ability to solve problems by changing in the authentic
and cooperative behavior.
Some of the popular development programmes are;
i. Career development; improving individual’s capacities to function productively in the
organization at different levels of their lives and planning human resource utilization.
ii. Assertiveness training; this is given to employees to help then express themselves in a
constructive way.
iii. Sensitive training; a method of changing peoples attitudes and behavior through
unstructured group interaction.
iv. Transactional analysis; when a person communicates with another the pattern of
interaction can either be complimentary or conflicting .Understanding this pattern can
help people interact in a connective way.
v. Process consultation.
vi. Team building; this focus on solving task‐related problems rather than on improving
interpersonal sensitivity.
vii. Inter group team building; this focuses on helping group interact better with each other.
f. Structure Programmes.
These seek to change the task, structural and managerial components of an organization .They
includes;
i. Behavior modification; this integrates the re‐enforcement theory with managing
organizational rewards.
ii. Job enlargement.
iii. Job enrichment.
iv. Flex time.
14 MS601 Paper by Maureen GIDEON,
CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS 29Sep08
v. Linking –pro organization; this uses participative workgroups at all levels of
management.
vi. Matrix organization; this facilitate the flow of information within the organization and
its environment.
vii. Management by objective.
viii. Survey feedback.
9.3 Managerial Point of View.
Managers need to have certain skills in order to carry out their managerial responsibilities most
effectively and efficiently some of these skills include,
a. Human relation skills; these include interpersonal skills, leadership and group process skills
• Group process skills are the ability to work through and with various groups.
• Interpersonal skills are needed to create and maintain a network of contacts with people
outside the chain of command.
• Leadership skills includes the ability to ;
o Match the people with jobs.
o Motivate and lead employees.
o Know what is expected from a leader in a given leadership situation and meet this
expectation
o Function effectively in various situations and with varying tasks and followers.
b. Conceptual skills; these mental abilities to acquire, analyze, and interpret information
received from various sources. These include analytical, entrepreneurial, decision making
and allocation skills.
c. Administrative skills; these include the ability to establish and follow policies and
procedures process paper work in an orderly manner and manage expenditure within the
budget.
d. Technical skills; these include the ability to use knowledge, tools and techniques of a
specific functional field.
e. Personal qualities; although there is no definite list of these qualities, there are certain
qualities found more frequently among successful managers than among less successful
managers and non‐managerial personnel. These include;
• Intelligence, physical health, energy, drive, emotional and mental health, emphathy, desire to
manage and influence people , the ability to tolerate ambiguity, frustration and pressure and
willingness to take risk..
15 MS601 Paper by Maureen GIDEON,
CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS 29Sep08
10.0 CONCLUSION.
Change management and organizational effectiveness involves taking necessary steps to
combat changes within and without the organization so as to ensure the organization maintains
positive fits between itself and its components and between itself and the environment.
To achieve this management would require to apply several strategies such as:
• Adaption strategies.
• Avoidance strategies.
• Control strategies.
As a means of copying with the environment and apply the the three step strategy of planned
organizational change namely:
• Unfreezing ‐ change ‐ Refreeze –
And finally should ensure existence of both internal and external organizational fits, carry out
necessary organizational development programmes as well as development of managerial
skills.
11.0 REFERENCES.
1. Organisational behaviour by Stephen. P. Robbins.
10th Edition pg 555‐576
2. Organisational Behaviour by John M. and Matteson, Michael J.
Pg 554‐580 and Pg 18‐42
3. Management and organizational Behaviour by Mullins, Laurie. J.
Pg 520‐524 and pg 499‐504
4. Human relations: A job oriented approach. By Dubrin, Adrew J.
Pg 393‐414
5. The Planning of Change (2nd Edition). Warren G. Bennis, Kenneth D. Benne, and Robert
Chin (Eds.). Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York: 1969.
6. Human Problem Solving. Allen Newell and Herbert A. Simon. Prentice‐Hall, Englewood
Cliffs: 1972.
7. Organizations in Action. James D. Thompson. McGraw‐Hill, New York: 1967.
8. Fred Nickols Article: "Change Management 101: A Primer."
9. Handy, C. (1994) The Empty Raincoat, London: Random House
16 MS601 Paper by Maureen GIDEON,