Sie sind auf Seite 1von 6

Development of a High Power Density

GaN-based Transistor Low-Voltage High-Current


Phase-Shift Full-Bridge Current Doubler Converter
for Electric Vehicles
Sangjin Kim, Adhistira M. Naradhipa and Sewan Choi, Fellow, IEEE
Seoul National University of Science and Technology, South Korea
E-mail: schoi@seoultech.ac.kr

Abstract— In this paper, a 1.8kW, 200V-310V/12V-15V,


700kHz DC-DC converter with high power density of 8.1kW/L
(132.7W/in3) is developed for electric/hybrid vehicle application.
In order to achieve high power density, GaN-based transistors
at 700kHz switching frequency are applied to reduce passive
component volumes. Furthermore, reduction of planar
transformer size is achieved by applying the concept of the
matrix transformer with flux cancellation. The characteristics
of the 1st prototype and the 2nd prototype considered to improve
the power density are covered and the design considerations of Fig. 1. Phase shift full-bridge converter with the proposed
the gate driver for a high switching frequency of 700 kHz are
matrix transformer
covered. A three-dimensional (3D) Maxwell FEA simulation
results are presented to give an accurate estimation of the core operating frequency becomes wide, which complicates the
loss and flux distribution of the magnetic components and magnetic design. A single-stage PWM topology with fixed
experimental results are also provided from a 1.8kW prototype. switching frequency is more suitable for wide voltage range
application. However, there is a limit on the leakage
Keywords—DC-DC converter, electric vehicle, high- inductance value due to duty loss, especially when applying
frequency, high power density.
a high switching frequency. Thus, the transformer should be
carefully designed in the single-stage PWM topology.
I. INTRODUCTION
In the previous paper [6], three single-stage PWM topology
As the demand and necessity of automobiles with candidates which are active clamp forward (ACF),
environmentally friendly and high fuel efficiency are asymmetrical half-bridge (ASHB), and phase shift full bridge
increased, the development of hybrid electric vehicles (PSFB) were compared to develop a low-voltage DC-DC
(HEVs) and electric vehicles (EVs) are attracting attention converter with high power density for EV applications. As a
from many automotive companies. In xEV application, an result, the PSFB converter with current doubler (PSFB-CD) is
isolated low-voltage high-current dc-dc (LDC) converter, selected as the most suitable topology for achieving the target
which has the power range of a few kilowatts (1kW-5kW) is power density since the number of passive components and
one of the key components that interface between the high switching devices is small and the circuit is simple [7],[8]. A
voltage battery (200V-440V) and low voltage battery (12V- matrix transformer [9] with flux cancellation [3],[4], which
15V). Due to the increase of the number of electronic devices reduces transformer footprint, core loss, and leakage
such as portable charger, instrument panel, car navigation and inductance was applied in [6] and achieved a power density of
5.63 kW/L (93.26W/in3) as well as a small leakage inductance.
lamp [1], [2], it is required that the power density of the LDC
In this paper, methods for further improving the power
converter is increased in a limited space. The goal of density of the converter system in [3] are discussed. The
increasing the LDC power density is feasible as the wide- change of the PCB configuration and the footprint of each part
bandgap (WBG) devices are easily obtainable. Using WBG, are compared. Also, topics such as transformer redesign,
the converter is able to operate at high-switching frequency. power board, and heat dissipation design considering power
Hence, there are the great passive components size reduction. density improvement are covered. The LDC system in this
The previous work on converter with high power and high- paper is achieving an 8.1kW/L (132.7W/in3) of power density,
switching frequency (500kHz – 1MHz), [3] and [4], is having which is 2.47kW/L (40.47W/in3) higher than the LDC system
a fixed input and output voltage condition. Therefore, a in [6].
resonant converter works as DCX is always selected, which
simplify the transformer design. The work in [5] is applying II. COMPARISON BETWEEN THE 1ST VERSION PROTOTYPE
high switching frequency converter to a wide voltage range, AND 2ND VERSION PROTOTYPE
which uses a two-stage topology with an LLC converter
Table I shows the comparison between the 1st and 2nd
operating as DCX in the isolated stage is applied. Thus, the
prototype of PSFB-CD for low voltage DC-DC converter in
transformer design in [5] is also simple. However, the power
density is not high enough because of the two-stage approach. EV application. In order to increase power density, both
In this paper a single-stage topology with a wide voltage prototypes are using the matrix transformer with flux
range and high-switching frequency are considered to cancellation and power density calculation is excluding the
achieve the required power density. A resonant converter is heatsink [6],[7]. The power density of the 1st prototype is
not suitable for wide voltage range application because the 5.63kW/L, whereas the 2nd prototype is 8.1kW/L. Therefore,
TABLE I
COMPARISON OF 1ST VERSION PROTOTYPE AND 2ND VERSION PROTOTYPE
Parameter 1st version prototype 2nd version prototype

Photograph

5.63kW/L 8.1kW/L
Power density
(88mm × 158 mm × 23mm) (85mm × 152mm × 17mm)
4EA 3EA
PCB components (Full bridge IMS board, Driver board, (Full bridge IMS board, Driver board,
Diode IMS board, Power board) Power board)
Height 23mm 17mm
FB IMS
3,080mm2 3,655mm2
board &
(88mm × 35mm) (85mm × 43mm)
Gate driver
Footprint 11,088mm2 7,735mm2
Power board
(88mm × 126mm) (85mm × 91mm)
1,530mm2
Input filter -
(85mm × 18mm)
22,724mm3 21,658mm3
Transformer volume
(52mm×19mm×23mm) (49mm×26mm×17mm)

Fig. 2. Secondary diode voltage rating according to Fig. 3. Leakage inductance limitation according to
turn ratio of transformer switching frequency and turn ratio
the 2nd prototype is achieving a power density improvement FB IMS board, the driver board, and power board. The FB
of 2.47kW/L. The prototypes are designed and built under the IMS board is a board with a full bridge circuit using an IMS
same specifications, and the specifications are as follows: board. It is designed using a GaN transistor and contains only
Po=1.8kW, Vin=200V~310V, Vo = 12.8-15.1V, and fs = 700 a power circuit. The gate driver for driving GaN transistor is
kHz. designed using a separate PCB board from the FB IMS board,
The power density improvement is due to two factors, which and it is fabricated using the 6-layer FR-4 PCB. The power
are the reduction of the prototype height and number of PCB. board is mainly composed of magnetic components and the
Firstly, compared to the 1st prototype, the number of PCBs in output terminal. In the case of the 1st prototype, the secondary
the 2nd prototype decreased from four to three. Secondly, the rectifier diode is using a separate IMS board referred by diode
prototype height decreased from 23mm to 17mm. Therefore, IMS board. On the other hand, the 2nd prototype includes not
the power density of the 2nd prototype is higher. only magnetic components but also secondary rectifier diode
on the power board. This integration of the power board and
A. Components decription
the diode IMS board reduces the total system footprint,
The prototypes are composed of three parts which are the thereby achieving a significant power density increase.
(a) (b) Fig. 6. 3D drawing of clamps
Fig. 4. Design result of transformer (a) 1st version, (b) 2nd
version

Fig. 7. 3D drawing of fully assembled 1.8kW low voltage


DC-DC converter with clamps
than 1.2 uH by referring to the reference literature [3]-[4] and
Fig. 5. Design result of power board [10]-[11]. Therefore, the switching frequency is selected to
be 700 kHz in order to achieve high power density while
B. Turn ratio and switching frequency selection achieving leakage inductance.
The target specification of this paper should be capable of
regulating at wide input voltage (200V~310V) and output
C. Transformer redesign
voltage (12.8V~15.1V) while achieving high power density.
Therefore, the turn ratio and switching frequency of the PSFB The 1st prototype transformer and inductor had the highest
should be carefully selected. component height of 23mm. Hence, a reduction in the height
Generally, as the number of turns of the transformer of the magnetic components was required to achieve the
increases, the leakage inductance increases, so it is desirable target power density of 6kW/L.
to design the number of turns small. On the other hand, if the Fig. 4(a) and Fig. 4(b) show the 1st and 2nd design results
number of turns is small, the voltage rating of the secondary of the transformer, respectively. As can be seen in Fig. 4, the
side diode becomes high and the leakage inductance becomes 2nd version transformer has a 7mm height reduction compared
small, which may cause the ZVS turn on of the switch to fail. to the 1st version transformer. By modifying the minimum
As shown in Fig. 2, when the turn ratio of the transformer is height of the output terminal block placed on the PCB to
4 or less, the Schottky diode having the voltage rating of 100 6.5mm, the overall height of the transformer can be designed
V can not be used since the margin of the voltage rating of to be 17mm with the height of the upper plate of 6.5mm, the
the secondary side diode is insufficient. Also, if the turn ratio height of the bottom plate of 6.5mm and the height of the
is 6 or more, the number of turns increases, and the leakage transformer leg is 4mm. As a result, the height of the 2nd
inductance may be made large, so output voltage regulation prototype of the converter became 17mm in Fig. 4(b) and the
may not be possible at wide input and output voltage range. cross-sectional area (Ac) of both transformers should remain
Therefore, a turn ratio of 5 : 1 was selected to use a diode with the same according to (1) when the maximum flux density
a voltage rating of 100V. (Bmax) is 80mT.
The following equations (1) and (2) show the leakage ϕ ⋅Vin
Ac = (1)
inductance limit and the duty loss (Dloss) of the PSFB for 2 ⋅ Bmax ⋅ N p ⋅ f s ⋅ 360°
regulating the output voltage under a wide input voltage
(Vin)range, respectively.
The width of the 2nd version of the transformer should be
n ⋅ Vin ⋅ Dloss
Lk = (1) increased to keep the same Bmax, which means Ac1, Ac2, Ac3 and
2 ⋅ Io ⋅ fs Ac4 are same in Fig. 4. Therefore, no significant change in the
D transformer volume as shown in Table I. However, the power
n density increases greatly from 5.63kW/L to 7.29kW/L
Dloss = 0.5 − (2) because of the reduction of the entire system maximum
2 ⋅ Rds (on ) RD
⋅D+ + 1 height, which comes from the reduction in the height of the
n2 ⋅ Ro Ro transformer.
where n is turn ratio of the transformer, fs is switching
frequency, D is duty ratio, Rds(on) is on resistance of the switch,
D. Power board and clamp design
RD is on resistance of diode and Ro is load resistance. Fig. 3
shows the leakage inductance limit value using the selected As shown in Table I, the footprint of the 2nd prototype
turn ratio, equation (1) and (2). The leakage inductance limit power board is the largest improvement for the power density
value becomes smaller as the frequency becomes higher, and compared to the 1st prototype. The power board footprint
it is considered that the leakage inductance can be made lower reduction in the 2nd prototype is approximately 31% from the
(a) (b) (a)
Fig. 8. Design results of full bridge driving circuit (a) FB
IMS board, (b) Driver board
1st prototype. This comes from the integration of the diode
IMS board with the 2nd power board.
The IMS board was used in the 1st prototype because of
the high temperature of the output diodes were expected due
to high conduction losses caused by large output currents.
Using the IMS board solved the heat problem of the diode. (b)
However, the production cost increased due to an increase in
the number of boards. In addition, the terminal blocks, which Fig. 9. Maxwell FEA simulation results of transformer: (a)
connect the diode IMS board to the power, board results in a Flux distribution (b) Core loss distribution
larger footprint of the power board. The design results of the 2nd driver board reflecting the
Fig. 5 shows the power board of the 2nd prototype. One of above three design considerations are shown in Fig. 8. The
the major changes is to reduce the footprint by placing the improvement results can be confirmed from the experimental
output diode on the power board and remove the terminal results in Section V.
blocks. And the thermal interface material (TIM) is inserted
between the power board PCB and the heatsink to cool it. III. FEA SIMULATION RESULTS
However, due to the high thermal resistance of the PCB, the
diode cannot be not effectively dissipated, the heat of the A three-dimensional (3-D) Maxwell FEA simulation is
diode is further dissipated using a clamp. Fig. 6 shows the carried out after 3D modeling of the core shape, primary and
clamps that helps dissipate the heat of the diodes and the secondary windings. An accurate dimension modeling is
magnetic components. As shown in Fig. 7, these clamps are needed to estimate the flux distribution and core loss of the
connected to the prototype to hold the magnetic components designed transformer. Fig. 9(a) and Fig. 9(b) show the flux
and dissipate the heat of diodes. distribution and core loss distribution, respectively. the FEA
simulation results. From Fig. 9(a), it can be seen that the
E. FB IMS board & Driver board average flux density of the top core is 48mT and average flux
The design concept of full bridge circuit is to design the density of the bottom core is 53mT, which is matched between
GaN transistor board and the gate driver board on separate the transformer design and the results. From Fig. 9(b), it can
boards, respectively. The IMS board is used to effectively be seen that the total average core loss is 6.62W. This value is
dissipate the heat generated by the GaN transistor due to the still below the core loss limitation which is 7W.
high frequency operation of 700 kHz. The driver board is IV. EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
designed using a 6-layer PCB and inserted into the FB IMS
board. This minimizes the stray inductance by minimizing the As shown in Table I, a 2nd version 1.8kW prototype of the
distance between the gate terminal of GaN transistor and full bridge phase shift converter has been built according to
the following specification : Po=1.8kW, Vin=200V~310V,
driver IC outputs as well as effectively dissipating the heat
Vo=12.8V~15.1V and fs=700kHz. The measured leakage
generated by the GaN transistor.
inductance of the experimental prototype is 0.7μH, which is
Generally, GaN transistor has very good switching below the maximum leakage inductance limit in the Table. I.
characteristics which are fast switching speed (high dv/dt) Therefore, the experimental prototype can operate for the
and low loss compared to Si MOSFET. However high whole voltage range at the rated load. The 2nd prototype is
frequency interference caused by high dv/dt characteristic achieving an 8.1kW/L(132.7W/in3) of power density, which
may lead to overstressing the GaN transistor since the is an improvement of 2.45kW/L compared to the power
threshold voltage of GaN transistor is very low. Therefore, density of the 1st version laboratory prototype. The power
for high-frequency switching of 700kHz of GaN transistor, density improvement is from the reduction of the height of
very careful gate driver PCB layout design is needed. both transformer and inductor. Fig. 10 and Fig. 11show the
Actually, the 1st prototype was not able to test more than experimental results at the rated load. Fig. 10 shows the
400W due to switching malfunction caused by high waveform of switch drain-source voltage (vDS), and Fig. 11
frequency interference. The switching malfunction is shows leakage current (iLk), secondary voltage of transformer
considered that this occurred due to the following reasons (vsec) and diode voltage (vD). It can be seen that the switching
from GaN systems application notes [12]-[14]. frequency of switch is applied at 700kHz. All switches
achieve ZVS turn on when Vin is 200V. When Vin is 310V,
1. Overlap between gate drive signal and drain copper pour. only lagging leg switches achieve ZVS turn on because of the
2. Current path without flux cancellation. transformer intrawinding capacitance. Voltage oscillation,
which is caused by resonance between leakage inductance and
3. Not enough ground copper pour. the parasitic capacitance of the diode, is minimized by adding
Fig. 10. Experimental waveform of switch drain-source Fig. 12. Measured efficiency of 2nd version experimental
voltage prototype

Fig. 13. Loss analysis of experimental prototype at full


load (Vin=200V, Vo=13.9V, Po=1.8kW)
(a)
material between the PCB layers. Moreover, reduction of the
magnetizing inductance also results in ZVS range increase,
which we plan to do for the future work.

V. CONCLUSION
In this paper, a PSFB-CD converter with high power
density of 8.1kW/L (132.7W/in3) is developed by applying
700kHz of switching frequency. Method to improve the power
density was analyzed by comparing the characteristics of the
1st prototype and the 2nd prototype in terms of the number of
PCBs, the size of the transformer, and the structure design.
The matrix transformer concept is applied to split the
secondary current and reduce the leakage inductance effect of
(b) the secondary windings. The FEA simulation results are
provided to verify the validity of the proposed transformer
Fig. 11. Experimental results of 1.8kW prototype @ design concept. The experimental results show that the 2nd
Full load. (a) Vin=200V, Vo=13.9V, (b) Vin=310V, prototype is able to operate over a wide input voltage range
Vo=13.9V (200V~310V) and wide output voltage (12.8V~15.1V) with
snubber capacitor. The snubber capacitance was tuned until 1.8kW of rated load. The 2nd prototype achieves 90.1%
the diode peak voltage reached avalanche energy guaranteed efficiency at the power of 1kW (Vin=200V), and the efficiency
in the diode datasheet. improvement is possible by applying a synchronous
Fig. 12 shows the measured efficiency curve of the rectification in future work.
prototype. The measured peak efficiency is 90.1% at
REFERENCES
Vin=200V, Vo=15.1V, and Po=1kW. At the rated load, the
largest part of the loss is from the conduction loss of diode, [1] B. Kim, K. Kim and S. Choi, “A 800V/14V Soft-
which is 5.4%, as shown in Fig. 13. In order to increase the switched Converter with Low-Voltage Rating of
rated load efficiency, synchronous rectification will be applied Switch for xEV applications,” 2018 International
in future work. In terms of light load efficiency, most of the Power Electronics Conference (IPEC-Niigata 2018-
loss is from switching loss of the GaN transistor. Although ECCE Asia), Niigata, Japan, 2018, pp. 256-260.
GaN FET has a very small output capacitance, the transformer [2] A. Stippich et al., “ Key components of modular
intrawinding capacitance causes the reduction of the ZVS propulsion systems for next generation electric
range. Increasing the ZVS range can be done by reducing the vehicles,” in CPPS Transaction on Power Electronics
transformer intrawinding capacitance. Thus, we plan to reduce and Applications, vol. 2, no. 4, pp. 249-258, December
transformer intrawinding capacitance by adding insulation
2017.
[3] D. Reusch and F. C. Lee, "High frequency bus converter
with integrated matrix transformers for CPU and
telecommunications applications," 2010 IEEE Energy
Conversion Congress and Exposition, Atlanta, GA,
2010, pp. 2446-2450.
[4] C. Fei, F.C. Lee and Q. Li, “High-Efficiency High-
Power-Density LLC Converter With and Integrated
Planar Matrix Transformer for High-Output Current
Applications,” in IEEE Transactions on Industrial
Electronics, vol. 64, no 11. Pp. 9072-9082, Nov. 2017.
[5] Z. Pang, X. Ren, J. Xiang, Q. Chen, X. Ruan and W.
Chen, "High-frequency DC-DC converter in electric
vehicle based on GaN transistors," 2016 IEEE Energy
Conversion Congress and Exposition (ECCE),
Milwaukee, WI, 2016, pp. 1-7.
[6] A. M. Naradhipa, S.Kim and S.Choi “A Compact
700kHz 1.8kW GaN-based Transistor Low Voltage
High Current DC-DC Converter for xEV using Planar
Matrix Transformer,” 2019 10th International
Conference on Power Electronics-ECCE Asia, Busan,
2019, pp. 2737-2742.
[7] N. H. Kutkut, “ A full bridge soft switched telecom
power supply with a current doubler rectifier,”
Proceedings of Power and Energy Systems in
Converging Markets, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia,
1997, pp. 344-351.
[8] J.H. Cho, H. W. Seong, S.M. Jung, J.S. Park, G.W.
Moon and M.J. Youn, “Implementation of digitally
controlled phase shift full bridge converter for server
power supply,” 2010 IEEE Energy Conversion
Congress and Exposition, Atlanta, GA, 2010, pp.802-
809.
[9] E. Hebert, “Flat Matrix Transformer,” United States
Patent and Trademark Office 4,665,357, May 12, 1987.
[10] K. D. T. Ngo, E. Alpizar and J. K. Watson, "Modeling
of magnetizing inductance and leakage inductance in a
matrix transformer," in IEEE Transactions on Power
Electronics, vol. 8, no. 2, pp. 200-207, April 1993.
[11] D. Huang, S. Ji and F. C. Lee, "LLC Resonant Converter
With Matrix Transformer," in IEEE Transactions on
Power Electronics, vol. 29, no. 8, pp. 4339-4347, Aug.
2014.
[12] “PCB Layout Considerations with GaN E-HEMTs,”
GN009 Application Note, GaN systems, 2019.
[13] On Semiconductor Application note:
www.onsemi.com/pub/Collateral/TND6242.pdf
[14] A. Lidow and J. Strydom, "eGaN FET Drivers and
Layout Considerations," Application Note, EPC inc,
2016.

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen