Sie sind auf Seite 1von 11

SPE 90678

A Methodology for Selecting Interventionless Packer Setting Techniques


James G. King, Alvaro J. Arrazola -Baker Oil Tools, SPE

Copyright 2004, Society of Petroleum Engineers Inc.


An improved setting system would include all the features of
This paper was prepared for presentation at the SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition the existing one-trip hydraulic system, but would eliminate the
held in Houston, Texas, U.S.A., 26–29 September 2004.
well intervention. Three one-trip, remotely actuated, completion
This paper was selected for presentation by an SPE Program Committee following review of
information contained in a proposal submitted by the author(s). Contents of the paper, as
systems currently have these capabilities. For actuation, these
presented, have not been reviewed by the Society of Petroleum Engineers and are subject to systems rely either on pressure-pulse communication, absolute
correction by the author(s). The material, as presented, does not necessarily reflect any position
of the Society of Petroleum Engineers, its officers, or members. Papers presented at SPE well pressure, or a hydro-mechanical valve. With three viable
meetings are subject to publication review by Editorial Committees of the Society of Petroleum
Engineers. Electronic reproduction, distribution, or storage of any part of this paper for commercial
technologies, the completion designer has flexibility in choosing
purposes without the written consent of the Society of Petroleum Engineers is prohibited. the right actuation method for the application.
Permission to reproduce in print is restricted to a proposal of not more than 300 words;
illustrations may not be copied. The proposal must contain conspicuous acknowledgment of
where and by whom the paper was presented. Write Librarian, SPE, P.O. Box 833836,
Richardson, TX 75083-3836, U.S.A., fax 01-972-952-9435.
Absolute Well Pressure Actuation System

System Basics. Completion packers actuated by absolute


Abstract well pressure are commonly known as “hydrostatic” or “annular
Eliminating intervention during well completion reduces set” packers. Equipment operated by absolute well pressure is
operating expense and risk. In deepwater, horizontal, and commonplace in other phases of well construction, particularly
extended-reach applications, interventionless actuation systems in drill stem testing and perforating equipment. Such tools hold
for setting completion tools are reducing well intervention and atmospheric air pressure in a chamber as they are run to depth
completion time and associated costs without compromising and use a rupture disc for actuation. When the absolute pressure
reliability or safety. This paper details the operation of three in the well exceeds the differential pressure rating of the rupture
commercially successful technologies that permit disc, the disc ruptures, allowing wellbore fluid into the tool. The
interventionless actuation and provides a methodology for pressure difference between wellbore pressure and the
selecting the optimum solution for a particular application. atmospheric chamber provides the driving force for setting the
tool. (Figure 1)
Introduction Any hydrostatically powered tool will have a range of
hydrostatic pressure at which the tool will operate. At the
Throughout the offshore oil and gas industry, focus is turning minimum extent of the hydrostatic range, the pressure is just
toward the prolific but challenging area of deepwater. Waters sufficient to set the packer, while at the maximum hydrostatic
greater than 1,000 ft are the largest growth segment of the pressure the deflections of the atmospheric chamber will impede
industry. The technologies that enable this growth economically the tool operation.
are those that provide improvements in operational reliability,
flexibility, and cost effectiveness. Well completion is one phase Operational Procedures. When using the absolute well
of well construction that contains technologies providing these pressure actuation system, the packer is made up and run in hole
improvements. in exactly the same manner as a conventional hydraulic set
Conventional completion “best practice” requires setting a packer in a one-trip completion. Once the completion system
production packer to isolate pressure and fluids from the reaches setting depth, the well can be circulated with the desired
producing zone and manage production tubing movement and completion fluid. Pressure in the wellbore is then increased to
loads. To enhance efficiency, the preferred packer setting the point where the pressure ruptures the disc, actuating the
method is a one-trip hydraulic system. The packer is run in on packer. The packer is completely packed off by the hydrostatic
the production string in a single trip. The tubing is plugged by pressure of the well.
landing a wireline or coiled tubing-conveyed blanking plug into It is important to take into consideration that the tool is
a seating nipple below the packer. The packer is then set using actuated by absolute well pressure, and that at any time when the
hydraulic pressure. The one-trip hydraulic system requires well pressure in the wellbore exceeds the rupture disc rating, the
intervention, which can consume from 12 hours to two days of packer will set. For example, if the fluid in the well when the
rig time, and introduces the risk of losing the wireline or coiled packer is initially run has a higher weight than the completion
tubing and associated tools in the well. fluid, the rupture disc must be selected with respect to the more
2 SPE 90678

dense fluid. Another important consideration is that in deep actuation system is based on one-way fluid-conveyed
wells, the applied hydraulic pressure at the surface required to communication using pressure pulses down the tubing or
raise the absolute pressure at the packer from the lower weight annulus fluid to an electronically enhanced packer. The system
completion fluid to the higher weight fluid that was in the well consists of a surface module, a communication medium, which
when the packer was initially run plus the extra margin to the is the fluid column in the completion tubing or annulus, and a
rupture disc rating may be quite high. The high applied surface packer. The surface module’s function is to transmit a pre-
pressure must be compared against the casing burst rating in the programmed frequency of pressure pulses. The fluid column
“A” annulus. carries the pulses to the electronically enhanced packer, which is
Many hydrostatic packer designs incorporate a secondary preprogrammed to actuate upon receiving the correct frequency
actuation method, which may be used should the primary of pulses. (Figure 3)
method fail to set the packer. The secondary setting method is Similar to absolute well pressure activated packers, the
preformed through conventional rig intervention methods by pressure-pulse telemetry technology relies on in-situ hydrostatic
landing a blanking plug on wireline or coiled tubing at the pressure for the driving force to set the packer. The tool will
packer or in the tailpipe below the packer and applying hydraulic have a range of hydrostatic pressure at which it will operate. At
pressure. the minimum extent of the hydrostatic range, the in-situ pressure
is just sufficient to set the packer, while at the maximum
Run History. Absolute well pressure actuation systems have hydrostatic pressure the deflections of the atmospheric chamber
resulted in dramatic savings for operators in the Atlantic’s will impede the tool operation.
Northern frontier, which claims some of the world’s harshest
drilling conditions.1 The BP Schiehallion and Foinaven oilfields, Component Descriptions. The surface module consists of a
for example, are benign shallow reservoirs, but lie in a harsh computer controller, an interface box with manual controls, and
subsea environment, in water depths from 1,150 to 1,800 feet. a computer-controlled pulse-generating unit. The pulse-
(Figure 2) generating unit transmits a discrete pressure pulse of specific
With operating costs approaching US$250,000 per day per amplitude and frequency through the tubing fluid. Its
rig, savings in rig time represent substantial cost savings. High- components include two piston accumulators, an air-driven
angle and extended-reach wells are common in this area, often water pump, and two pneumatic actuator-operated valves that
putting completion packers beyond wireline access. Early control discharge of fluid into and out of the well. The surface
completions in the Foinaven and Schiehallion fields relied unit also includes gages that monitor the charging of the
extensively on coiled tubing operations to run and pull plugs as accumulators, and bleeder valves that purge air from the system.
part of completion installation. As a result, completion The frequency of the pulse transmission is automatically
operations often suffered from non-productive time and waiting controlled through a laptop computer.
on weather associated with the coiled tubing work. Completions The electronically enhanced packer is fitted with a frequency
typically required approximately 15 days, excluding installation detector, an onboard electronic controller, an actuator, and a
of the subsea tree. The operator sought a completion system that battery power pack. The frequency detector, which is mounted
required no coiled tubing intervention, in order to reduce these on the packer’s body, constantly measures pulses traveling
risks and costs. through the fluid column. The onboard electronic controller is
Simplicity was a deciding factor in choosing absolute well preprogrammed to register the pressure pulses. When the
pressure-activated tools for these completions in 1998. The controller acknowledges receipt of the proper profile and
incorporation of a liner top isolation valve as a robust fluid loss frequency of pulses, a preprogrammed time delay begins. After
device was an enabling technology. These completions were the the time delay, the actuator receives power from the battery pack
first ever to use absolute well pressure activation on a and sets the packer via hydrostatic pressure.
completion packer. Since the introduction of this technology,
the run history in these fields has been unquestionably Operational Procedures. Before the packer is run in the well,
successful. To date, more than 56 tools have been run without it is checked and preprogrammed with a hand-held terminal to:
failure at Foinaven and Schiehallion. More than 125 absolute 1) recognize a discrete pulse frequency; and 2) actuate after a
well pressure-activated tools have been run worldwide by the predetermined time delay.
authors’ service company. As the completion is being run, the computer controller of
Absolute well pressure activated completion packers have the surface module is preprogrammed to transmit the discrete
saved up to $1,000,000 per well, largely by eliminating coiled pulse frequency, and the surface system is primed so the only
tubing mobilization and operation costs. additional time spent is in connecting hoses for transmission of
pulses through the fluid column. Once in the wellbore, the
Pressure–Pulse Telemetry Remote Actuation System downhole tool’s receiver constantly samples all pulses traveling
through the completion fluid, while its control system filters and
System Basics. Completion packers actuated by pressure-pulse recognizes only pulses of a predetermined profile and amplitude.
telemetry are commonly known as “EDGE” packers, in The tool will not actuate until the preprogrammed, discrete
reference to the trade name of the single product that frequency is matched.
successfully uses this technology. The pressure-pulse remote
SPE 90678 3

Once the completion system reaches setting depth, the well “disappearing plugs.” This obvious reference to wireline plugs
can be circulated with the desired completion fluid. Generally, belies the sophistication of these systems. These devices
before the matching pulse frequency is sent, a single pressure- typically operate by pressure cycles down the tubing and may
pulse is transmitted through the fluid column. The reflected enable the pressure testing of the completion tubing before
pulse received at surface is recorded via the laptop computer’s setting the packer. Uni-directional and bi-directional devices are
data acquisition system. This “test pulse” allows the user to available. Some varieties of hydromechanical valve are single
assess, in real time, the quality of pulses delivered and, action, while others may be re-cocked to the closed position by a
therefore, ensures that effective communication is established mechanical device. Advanced models have additional
between the surface system and the downhole tools. functionality allowing them to be used as barriers for well
Following the communication check, the pressure-pulse control or well suspension. (Figure 6)
generating process continues automatically, under the When run in hole, the device has a ball, flapper, plug, or disk
computer’s control. After the matching frequency has been sent, type obstruction in the tubing. Commonly, if the valve does not
received and confirmed by the control system of the downhole permit self-filling of the tubing, a separate device is run to
tool, and the preprogrammed time delay has occurred, the tool accomplish this action. Pressure down the tubing will set the
sets hydrostatically. completion packer. Additional pressure cycles down the tubing
Should the laptop computer system fail to send the matching then actuate the tool, removing the obstruction. (Figure 7)
frequency, the actuator may be controlled manually. Usually, hydro-mechanical valves leave a full-open internal
Should the primary actuator fail to set the completion tool, diameter.
secondary actuation is achievable through conventional rig Hydro-mechanical valves have wide applicability. In general,
intervention methods. This secondary actuation method for the the pitfalls of hydro-mechanical valve use are debris tolerance
packer requires landing a blanking plug in the tubing below the and overbalance issues. Some designs have much more debris
packer and applying hydraulic pressure.2, 3 tolerance than others. Hydro-mechanical valves generally
operate as a result of differential cycles between the tubing
Run History. Previous literature on pressure-pulse remote pressure and the pressure in the annulus or the tubing below the
actuation of completion tools introduced this innovative valve. An extreme overbalance situation will interfere with the
technology to the industry and documented case studies to “return” cycle. So the pressures at the valve must be considered
support its continued use. 4, 5 when evaluating this technology.
The Gulf of Mexico area has seen continuous use of
pressure-pulse-telemetry-actuated equipment since 1996, when Operational Procedures. Completion designs vary from region
the technology was first introduced on Shell Mars Subsea #4. to region in the world and even from well to well within a field.
This completion was performed in 2,940 feet of water, at a depth For the purposes of this discussion, running a hydro-mechanical
of 16,894 feet. (Figure 4) valve in the upper completion of a deepwater well featuring a
Pressure-pulse telemetry technology has also been used sandface completion will be described.
successfully in record-setting extended reach drilling (ERD) After a lower completion, such as a gravel pack or frac pack,
applications. In wells off the coast of Tierra del Fuego, is run, the upper completion is made up and run in hole. (Figure
Argentina, packers have been set at measured depths up to 8) The completion hookup generally consists of:
26,450 feet, and at aspect ratios up to 5.2.6 (Figure 5) 1. A locator type seal to cover the gravel pack ports in the
Optimization of on-line vs. off-line preparation has lowered lower completion;
packer setting time to around 15 minutes. In one application, 2. Ported sub to allow locator to enter lower completion
concurrent circulating and pressure pulse transmission without hydraulic resistance;
(thumping) permitted the total rig time attributed to packer 3. Hydro-mechanical barrier tool;
setting to be reduced to zero. 4. Self filling apparatus;
Managing time in this manner moves well operations toward 5. Profile nipple;
the technical time limit of well completion efficiency. In these 6. Completion packer;
wells, the alternate process of running, setting, and retrieving a 7. Other equipment such as gas lift mandrels, permanent
wireline- or coiled tubing-conveyed blanking plug to a seating downhole gauges, and tubing retrievable safety valves.
nipple below the packer requires several hours. The primary cost
saving from this technology is direct rig time reduction. Space out is essential to success. Operators use different
However, additional economic benefits accrue from avoiding methods to insure proper spacing of the locator into the lower
costs and risks associated with intervention. completion when landing the tubing hanger, such as shearable
centralizers or telescoping joints.
Hydro-Mechanical Valve Systems Once the upper completion is landed, the completion fluid is
forward or reverse circulated into the annulus, with fluid passing
System Basics. Hydro-mechanical devices, run as part of the through the self-filling device. The self-filling device is closed
completion tailpipe, provide a third method of actuating by circulating from tubing to annulus at a pre-determined rate,
completion packers without intervention with coil tubing or faster than the circulation rate used to place the completion fluid.
wireline. Hydro-mechanical valves as commonly referred to as
4 SPE 90678

The pre-determined circulation rate creates a known tubing tests without opening the valve or setting the completion
backpressure, which closes the self-filling device. packer. The system permits autofill and circulation through the
With the self-filling device closed, hydraulic pressure is self-filling device. When a pre-determined forward circulation
increased to the full setting pressure of the completion packer as rate is achieved, the self-filling device shuts off circulation,
in a traditional hydraulic-set packer scenario. allowing a tubing pressure test. After the tubing test, the self-
At this point the hydromechanical valve may be “opened” by filling device re-opens, permitting self fill and circulation to
the addition of the correct number of pressure cycles. Various resume. This process is repeated for each tubing test. After a
devices on the market open by different mechanisms including pre-determined number of tubing tests have been performed, the
cutting a disc with a hydrostatic pressure powered cutter, self-filling device locks closed. A subsequent pressure cycle will
dissolving a salt plug from within a rubber bladder, rotating a open a control line port to the completion packer, allowing the
ball, and lifting a flapper from a seat. packer to be set by hydraulic tubing pressure. At this point the
well may be left in a suspended mode, or more pressure cycles
Additional Functionality - Temporary Suspension. In subsea may be applied to open the “disappearing plug.”
wells with vertical trees, one advanced variety of hydro-
mechanical valve provides a “disappearing” barrier that permits Run History. As previously noted, there are several varieties of
bringing the well onto production directly from the host, without hydro-mechanical valves in the marketplace. Some of these
intervention. In one method of vertical tree subsea well devices have reached a point of product maturity and are used
completion, the BOP stack is removed prior to running the tree. throughout the world for setting completion packers. At least
Commonly, a back pressure valve or blanking plug is run to one design has more than 350 runs, attesting to its maturity.
temporarily suspend the well during the time between BOP stack The added functionality of temporary suspension with a bi-
removal and tree installation. The TRSSSV provides an directional flapper has been used in the North Sea, Gulf of
additional barrier. Intervention is required to remove the BPV or Mexico, and off the West Coast of Africa.
blanking plug from the well when the well is brought on line, The tubing testing function, with control line set packers, has
and this action requires the running of a completion riser to the been used in the North Sea and in other markets.
tree.
By running a bi-directional barrier hydro-mechanical valve, Methodology for Technology Selection
the well may be temporarily suspended by leaving the valve
closed after setting the completion packer, and again using the Interventionless or Conventional Setting. The first step in
TRSSSV as an additional barrier. In this case the hydro- selecting an interventionless method for setting the completion
mechanical valve is tested for pressure integrity before being run packer in a well is to determine whether the wells are good
in the hole. The TRSSSV is inflow tested after the completion candidates for the technology. Candidate wellbores are
packer is set. characterized by high rig rates, WOW risk, NPT sensitivity, high
The tree, jumpers, and flowlines are installed while the well deviation, horizontal wellbores, extended reach, and extreme
is controlled by the closed hydromechanical valve and TRSSSV. depths.
To bring the well on line, the TRSSSV is opened hydraulically
through the umbilical. The hydromechanical valve is opened Choosing an Interventionless Method. Well construction
from the host by pressure cycles through the flowline or through factors drive the process of selecting an interventionless method.
a chemical injection line. A completion riser does not have to be (Figure 9)
rerun to pull the BPV or blanking plug from the well to put the The primary applications of hydro-mechanical valves are
well on production. 8 when functionality is added to the completion beyond setting the
packer. As described above, some advanced hydro-mechanical
Additional Functionality - Tubing Testing. Advanced valve systems permit hydro-testing of the completion string and
varieties of hydro-mechanical valve also can provide the ability suspension of a well in a sub-sea application, in addition to
to test the entire tubing of a completion to a pressure higher than packer setting.
the initiation pressure of the completion packer. Pressure-pulse-telemetry-activated tools may be used in
Operators use a combination of internal hydro-testing, wells that will support a full column of fluid. Generally the
external pressure testing, and “torque turn” techniques to ensure pressure pulse is transmitted down through the fluid in the
proper thread make-up and pressure integrity in their casing and tubing. However, in some instances it is better to pulse through
tubing strings. The efficacy and efficiency of these methods of the annulus. This technology is ideal in a dry tree deepwater
testing tubing are outside the scope of this paper. However, in application where a frangible fluid loss device is deployed in a
the case where the tubing is internally hydro-tested to a higher lower sandface completion. There are also temperature
pressure than the initiation pressure of the hydraulic set limitations due to the electronics on board the packer.
completion packer, either the test must occur from a point above Absolute well-pressure-activated tools may be used in any
the packer, or the tubing pressure must be prevented from setting well where sufficient pressure can be applied to the rupture disc.
the packer. There are several parameters to consider when analyzing the
In one embodiment, sufficient pressure cycle capability is pressure that must be applied to rupture the disc which are
built into the hydro-mechanical valve to allow internal hydraulic discussed above. This technology is ideal in wells where an
SPE 90678 5

unperforated liner or robust liner-top isolation valve are present Abbreviations


and 2,500 psi hydraulic pressure can be applied.
Absolute well pressure activation requires the well to be BOP = Blow Out Preventer
unperforated or to have the lower completion hydraulically BPV = Back Pressure Valve
isolated. Thus, pressure-pulse telemetry technology has wider ERD = Extended Reach Drilling
application, but the simplicity of the absolute well pressure TSL = Tubing Stability Latch
activation system would encourage an operator to use that ILT = Invisible Lost Time
technology whenever feasible. NPT = Non-Productive Time
The technologies that permit interventionless setting do add TLP = Tension Legged Platform
to the capital expenditure directly associated with equipment for HSE = Health, Safety and Environment
the well. Depending on the technology, metallurgy, and other TRSSSV = Tubing Retrievable Sub-Surface Safety Valve
factors, the interventionless technology may far exceed the cost WOW = Waiting on Weather
of the completion packer itself. The most direct value of an RiskEX = Risk Expense
interventionless technology is the rig time savings. The CapEX = Captial Expense
increased capital expense must be balanced against not only the OpEX = Operating Expense
spread cost over rig time saved but also the less tangible costs of
NPT, WOW, and RiskEX. This economic balance in
combination with the technical evaluation will aid in selecting References
the best packer setting method for a completion.
1. Mason, John N.E., Moran, Paul, and King, James G. - Baker
Conclusions Oil Tools, and Cameron, Paul D. - BP: “Interventionless
Hydrostatic Packer Experience in West of Shetland
1. Setting completion packers without intervention has Completions,” OTC 13288 presented at the 2001 Offshore
taken place in the harshest and most remote working Technology Conference, Houston, April 30 - May 3.
environments throughout the world, including the North 2. Jones, Kevin R.: “Electronics Add New Dimensions to Well
Sea, North Atlantic frontier, and Tierra del Fuego. Completions,” Oil & Gas Journal (Oct. 2, 1995), 68.
2. Pressure-pulse-telemetry-activated tools can be used in 3. Bussear, Terry: “Remote Actuation System Speeds Deepwater Well
Completions,” Oil & Gas Journal (Oct. 7, 1996), 56.
wells that will support a full column of fluid. 4. Godfrey, D.G., et al.: “The Mars Project Overview,” paper OTC
3. Absolute-well-pressure-activated tools can be used in 8368 presented at the 1997 Offshore Technology Conference,
wells with an unperforated liner or liner top isolation Houston, May 5-8.
valve. 5. Smith, Michael V., Lowe, Evan, Coull, Craig - Baker Oil Tools
4. Hydro-mechanical valves can be used to set packers “Deewater Remotely Actuated Completions for the 21st Century,”
without intervention. OTC 8844, paper presented at the Offshore Technology
5. Rig time associated with wireline and coiled tubing Conference, 4-7 May 1998.
intervention to set completion packers can largely be 6. Proano, Enrique M. Baker Oil Tools, Clergier, Alberic, Total Austral
eliminated through the use interventionless techniques. S.A.: “Advanced Completion Techniques For Extended Reach
Wells,” OTC 8805 presented at the 1998 Offshore Technology
6. Added value may be gained in completion design by Conference, 4-7 May 1998.
using hydromechanical valves, including tubing testing 7. Azuara, Aurelio, King, James G., Walker, Graeme J.-Baker Oil
and temporary well suspension in subsea applications. Tools: “Summary of Remotely Actuated Disappearing Plug
7. Value is added to the completion phase of well Technology in Deepwater Wells,” OTC 16534 presented at the
construction by decreasing operational complexity of the 2004 Offshore Technology Conference, 3-6 May 2004.
completion and thus reducing HSE, waiting on weather, 8. Stair, Craig – Shell, Nelson, Ron N. –Shell, Stuckey, Joe, and
and NPT risks. Walker, Graeme – Baker Oil Tools: “Riserless Subsea
8. Interventionless packer setting techniques should be Completion with Disappearing Plug Technology,” SPE
considered when reduction of intervention-associated 77712 presented at the 2002 SPE Annual Technical
risk and rig time are drivers of completion design. Conference, San Antonio, September 29 - October 2, 2002.

Acknowledgments

The author wishes to thank Baker Oil Tools for permission to


publish this paper, and thanks Shell, BP, Total and various other
operators for their investment in the future of interventionless
packer setting.
6 SPE 90678

Figure 1. – Absolute Well Pressure Activated System For Down-Hole Completion Tools

Figure 2. First Absolute Well Pressure Completions in North Atlantic Frontier in 1998.

5 4 3 2 1 0 3
9 8 7 6

Schiehallion Shetland
Islands

60

A T L AN T I C
OCE AN

59
Orkney
Islands

Wick

58

Scotland

Aberdeen
57
SPE 90678 7

Figure 3 – Pulse Communications System For Down –Hole Completion Tools

Figure 4 – First Pressure Pulse Telemetry Completion on Mars in 1996

New Orleans

Tahoe

GULF Pompano
OF
MEXICO
Mars

Auger
8 SPE 90678

Figure 5. Pressure Pulse Telemetry Completions in Extended Reach Applications - Tierra Del Fuego, Argentina
SPE 90678 9

Figure 6. Hydro-Mechanical Valve:

Figure 7. Hydro-mechanical Valve Completion:


10 SPE 90678

Figure 8. Hydro-mechanical Valve Completion with Temporary Suspension Functionality.


SPE 90678 11

Figure9. Interventionless Decision Tree.

High Rig Rate


WOW Risk
NPT Sensitive Conventional
Deviated No Completion
Horizontal Methods
Extended Reach
Extreme Depth

Yes

Consider
Interventionless
Completion

Test Tubing
Prior to Packer Yes
Setting?

No
No

Suspend Yes
Yes
Subsea Well

No
No
No

High Fluid Loss

No

Can Entire Wellbore Economic Hydro-Mechanical


Withstand 2,500 psi Applied Yes or No Yes
Justification Valve
Hydraulic Above Max
Hydrostatic?

Economic Absolute Well


Yes Yes
Justification Pressure

Economic Pressure Pulse


No Yes Telemetry
Justification

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen