Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
CENTURY.
J. A. Onyike M.Sc, M.Phil, ANIVS, RSV.
Acting Head, Department of Estate Management,
Imo State University, Owerri.
INTRODUCTION/BACKGROUND.
The 20th Century saw a number of failed attempts by the Governments of Nigeria to
Nigeria inherited a serious problem of inadequate housing, resulting from many years of
neglect, undeveloped housing finance system, limited supply of long term funds, low
household income levels, high unemployment, high inflation rate, high interest rate on
mortgages, high cost of land and building materials, poor planning and poor
bottlenecks that make the processing and securing of approvals for building plans,
certificates of occupancy and other necessary government permits very difficult, and the
unmitigated corruption in the allocation of government land within the framework of the
Land Use Act, cap.202 LFN 1990 (Ogwu, 2006; Akomolede, 2007; Onyike, 2007). The
situation is compounded by the high incidence of corruption in all other relevant sectors
of the Nigerian economy and the lack of adequate political will by the government to deal
with the housing problem. There is also a conflict of objectives among the major actors in
the housing industry namely, the funding institutions and the developers on one side and
the consumers of housing on the other side. The profit maximization objective of the
developers and funding institutions tends to conflict with the affordability of housing to
Census, 2006 ) and still rising at an annual growth rate estimated at 3.2% (allAfrica.com,
2 October, 2008).
As a result of the above, Nigeria has a large and ever-increasing housing deficit which
stood at approximately 8 million housing units in 1991 and 12-14 million housing units in
puts the figure even higher at 16-17 million housing units (Olusegun Adeniji of FMBN
quoted by Sombo, 2007; Financial System Strategy 2020, 2008; Uroko & Akintola,
2008). At an average cost of N2.5million per housing unit, Nigeria would require
Nigeria’s urban housing problems manifest in overcrowding, slum housing and the
development of shanties in virtually every major Nigerian city. The housing problems
vary from inadequate quantity and quality of housing to the attendant impact on the
intensive. The cost of adequate housing is currently beyond the reach of most Nigerians.
This, thus, brings in the financial dimension - the question of the affordability of housing.
The challenge becomes not only to provide the houses but to make the houses affordable
Before going further, there is need to get the premise right. Shelter, as we know it, is a
structure, permanent or makeshift, designed basically to protect the occupant against the
elements and intruders. We want more for our fellow Nigerians than just shelter. Housing
is much more than mere shelter. There are quality, comfort, social and community
amenity aspects which go with housing. Housing embraces all the social services and
Housing Policy, 1991). Housing is bound up with concepts such as shelter itself, privacy,
satisfies these concepts can be considered adequate. In consonance with the above, the
Draft National Housing Policy 2004 has defined housing as “the process of providing a
infrastructure and social services in planned, decent, safe and sanitary neighbourhoods to
meet the basic and special needs of the population”. Housing affects the health,
productivity and well-being of a person. It has effect on the labour force of a country and
Affordable housing is that housing which can be acquired from household income
without sacrificing any of the other essential needs of the household. According to Struyk
(2005) “housing affordability is the ability to purchase a dwelling of the appropriate size
and minimum physical and sanitary standards and still have sufficient income to enjoy at
least the minimum consumption of other essential goods and services”. In Australia,
Canada, New Zealand and the United States of America, a commonly accepted guideline
for housing affordability is a housing cost that does not exceed 30% of a household’s
gross income ( Struyk, 2005; WIKIPEDIA, 2007). A recent study based on the salary
structure of public servants in Nigeria showed that no public servant in Nigeria below
salary grade level 13 in the Federal Civil Service and salary grade level 16 in the Imo
State civil service can afford a property costing N4.75million on a 25 year mortgage at
6%, if he devotes 50% of his salary per annum to housing (Onyike, 2007). At 18%
mortgage rate, only a Federal Permanent Secretary or his equivalent on grade level 17
can afford the same house. This shows that in the absence of some assistance, adequate
lifetime household income, house prices and rents, nominal and real interest rates, labour
market conditions which determine security of employment and income, mortgage and
rent payments, and the housing supply constraints which may affect the ability of the
market to respond to excess demand for housing (Onyike, 2007; The Treasury New
Zealand, 2008).
Having considered the above, we can now look at the efforts made by Government in the
An attempt at proffering solutions may not be well informed, if we do not first look at the
efforts made in the past at tackling the problems, not minding that they failed to achieve
the desired result. We run the risk of recycling the mistakes of the past if we ignore them.
outbreak of bubonic plague. This resulted in the construction of a few segregated housing
estates for expatriates and few selected essential indigenous staff. The other notable
developments during the Colonial era were the establishment of the Nigeria Building
Society (NBS) in 1956 and the creation of some Housing Corporations. The NBS did not
achieve much owing to poor funding while the housing corporations were unable to
extend their services to the low-income earners (National Housing Policy, 1991).
In the Post-Independence era (1960-1979) a major land reform aimed at improving land
availability for development took place, namely the Land Use Decree of 1978. The Land
Use Decree (now Act) unfortunately has failed to achieve this important objective. The
Federal Housing Authority (FHA) was established under Decree No. 40 of 1973 to,
Government. It should be noted that the FHA could only complete 30,000 housing units
en ligne, 2008). In 1976, the NBS was transformed to the Federal Mortgage Bank of
Nigeria, which subsequently became the apex institution of the Nigerian mortgage
financial system.
During the Second Republic (1979-1983), the Federal Government made a number of
bold attempts to address the housing problem. In 1979, the World Bank-assisted urban
development programme was launched in Imo and Bauchi States resulting in the
development of a few sites and services schemes in those states. Other states preferred
infrastructural development and went for the Infrastructure Development Fund. The
National Low-Cost Housing Programme was launched during this period but ended up a
big failure. Some of the reasons advanced for the failure included the adoption of a single
house design for the entire country, irrespective of the differences in culture and climate;
the distribution and choice of sites bore little relationship to the effective demand for
housing; and the houses were allocated not according to need but to satisfy political party
patronage (NHP,1991).
The Post-Second Republic era (1984-1999) saw the launching of the National Housing
Policy 1991 and the establishment of the National Housing Fund (NHF) vide Decree No.
3 of 1992. The main strategy of the Policy was the establishment of the NHF scheme to
mobilize loanable funds from workers, which would be disbursed via the primary
mortgage institutions (PMIs), with the FMBN as the apex/supervisory body (Draft NHP,
2004). The 1991 Policy created a two-tier institutional financial structure, with PMIs as
primary lenders and the FMBN as the apex institution with a supervisory role over the
PMIs (Aribigbola,2008). The supervisory role was taken over by the Central Bank of
Nigeria in 1997. Various roles were created for the three tiers of government and other
government institutions and agencies such as FMBN, FHA, State Housing Corporations,
Ministries and Departments towards achieving the goal of “housing for all by the year
2000”. The NHF scheme and hence the 1991 Policy failed to achieve its objective.
i. Banks and insurance companies refused to contribute/invest in the NHF for what they
described as “unattractive terms” while the regulators of the scheme in the financial
industry, namely the Central Bank of Nigeria and the NAICOM, did nothing. The
commercial and merchant banks were reluctant to apply their funds, sourced short-
ii. The Federal Government which should have been the prime mover had not yet
have refused to deduct and remit staff contributions to the Fund. Many State
Fund.
iv. Difficulty in land acquisition and the corresponding high cost of land transfers in
Nigeria, and
v. The FMBN is not empowered to prosecute any defaulters of the NHF Act.
In all, the various efforts of Government to provide affordable housing for majority of
Nigerians in the 20th Century failed. The causes of this failure have already been
The 21st Century opened with the realization of Government that the earlier efforts have
failed to provide adequate and affordable housing for the vast majority of Nigerians. In
2002, the Government published the White Paper on the Report of the Presidential
facilitate the realization of the objective of housing for all Nigerians. In 2004, a draft new
National Housing Policy was produced. This draft is still making the rounds and has not
yet been signed into law. Given that home ownership in Nigeria is currently put at 10%
compared to 72% USA, 78% UK, 60% China, 54% Korea and 92% Singapore and
outstanding mortgage loans at just 0.5% (2005) of GDP compared to 77% USA, 80%
UK, 50% Hong Kong, 33% Malaysia and 61% Singapore (Financial System Strategy
2020, 2008), a lot of work needs to be done for Nigeria to approach the standards
achieved in the developed world. The Yar’adua Government appears serious about
leading Nigeria to the promised land. A number of committees and think tanks are
working to fashion out the best ways and strategies for achieving the objective. Recently,
There is no better time than now to address issues of far-reaching importance as housing.
It is generally believed that the Government has abused the trust of the people as far as
the Land Use Act cap 202 LFN 1990 was concerned. The Act has become an obstacle
reversed. The Land Use Act or any future land reform legislation should not form part of
the Nigerian constitution; this will make any necessary amendment of the law easier to
achieve thereby making the law responsive to the needs of the times. Apart from the
problem of corruption and abuse of trust which has bedeviled the application of the Act,
there is the ownership issue which rendered the use of bare land as security for loans very
unattractive and risky to the financial institutions. The Act provides for compensation for
land, technically, does not attract any compensation except for the ground rent paid in the
year of the revocation; the Government which graciously permitted you to occupy her
land will not pay compensation when she takes back what was hers in the first place.
This, therefore, rendered bare land an unsafe and unacceptable security for a mortgage
loan, thereby reducing the potential for raising funds for additional housing development.
The requirement of governor’s consent should be expunged from the Land Use Act to
facilitate easy transfer, assignment and foreclosure of mortgages which are essential for
the efficiency of the mortgage market. A new land reform which guarantees private
hereby proposed, to increase land availability and improve accessibility of funds for
housing development.
2. Review of fiscal and monetary policies to reduce inflation and interest rate.
High inflation and high interest rates constitute a disincentive to property development
and investment. With inflation rate at 14% and maximum lending rate at 17.92% in July
Inflation and interest rates must be reduced to single digits. The Government should work
hard to achieve low inflation and low interest rates in the 21st century.
majority of Nigerians, namely the low and middle income earners, without viable long-
term lending arrangements, which can only be achievable if there is a viable secondary
mortgage market. The secondary mortgage market is therefore a sine qua non for mass
development cannot proceed unless and until the primary market is able to produce a
sufficient volume of high quality mortgages to meet the servicing and performance
recent floatation of a ^100 billion mortgage bond for the purchase of Federal Government
houses is a step in the right direction. The Federal Mortgage Bank of Nigeria should
become a major operator in the capital and secondary mortgage markets to ensure access
to adequate funding and create investor confidence in the Nigerian mortgage industry.
This is the case in the United States where Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae are the
securities in the USA secondary mortgage market system. There is need however to
firstly amend all laws critical to housing investment to facilitate the issuance of housing-
trusts(REIT) which will be traded on the secondary mortgage market. The laws include
the Land Use Act (Decree 6, 1978), the National Housing Fund Act 1992, the Federal
Mortgage Bank Act (Decree 82, 1993), the Mortgage Institutions Act (Decree 53, 1989),
the Trustees Investment Act 1962, the Nigeria Social Insurance Trust Act 1993, The
Insurance Act 2002, The Investment and Securities Act 1999, the Federal Housing
Authority Act 1990, Land Instrument Registration Act, and Conveyancing (Capital
A new FMBN law should give legal backing to the bank to operate as a secondary
mortgage institution with right to issue mortgage securities. Pension and insurance
companies should be mandated to release much of their long term funds to the mortgage
market.
To further improve liquidity, the National Housing Fund (NHF) contributions should be
raised to 5% of monthly income and deducted at source: a new FMBN law should give
the bank the authority to prosecute any defaulters, for non-payment, non-remittance,
the NHF contributions can be integrated into the personal income taxation system such
that “a defined proportion of taxes paid are allocated to the housing fund pool, as is done
The minimum asset base of any operating PMI should be raised to ^500 million; the
figure for an average PMI should indeed stand at ^1 billion. This will build confidence in
the investing public and will indeed attract larger deposits and patronage to the mortgage
finance industry.
The absence of a clear-cut foreclosure law scares some investors and funding institutions
from the housing sector. The very long delays in the disposal of cases in our law courts
It is necessary to sound a note of warning! One of the causes of the subprime mortgage
crisis in the USA was that due to securitization, mortgage loans with high risk of default
could be originated, packaged and the risk readily transferred to investors in securities
(Wikipedia, 2008). The secondary mortgage market in Nigeria must be strictly regulated
A nationwide credit database that can provide credit information of all individuals that
enjoy financial services in Nigeria is not available (Akeju, 2007). As a result, the
financial institutions in trying to establish the financial background and credit worthiness
of the loan applicants, take several days or weeks to process most loan applications. A
prospective loan applicants possible has the potential to reduce the loan processing period
to a matter of hours. It will also encourage the financial institutions to extend their loan
facilities beyond the few well-known rich people. Going by the USA experience,
however, the success of this system depends very much on the integrity of the credit
scoring agencies. Two major credit scoring agencies in the USA are the Equifax and the
Trans Union. The most widely-used credit scoring system in the United States is the
FICO system which attach scores to various aspects of the loan applicant’s credit profile,
namely: previous credit performance, current level of indebtedness, time credit has been
in use and types of credit available to the applicant in the past, and pursuit of new credit
The building up of the required databank and the associated networking in Nigeria will
take some time. In the interim and until the national credit database is in place, the
encourage lending to the lower income people. The USA government, an avowed
advocate of the free market, is precisely providing similar guarantees today in response to
expensive, inefficient and time-consuming. The process is very prone to corruption. The
introduction of the Geographic Information System (GIS) in land registration will solve
most of the afore-mentioned problems. The initial cost of establishing the system is quite
high but the enormous benefits make the system very cost-effective. The experiences in
both Abuja and Lagos where the GIS has been implemented are very encouraging. Other
Slum areas are the breeding grounds for diseases, crimes and other socially-deviant
behaviour. Slum clearance is necessary to improve the quality of life in such areas. Slum
clearance, however, must have a human face. Driving away the slum dwellers without
providing an alternative and better accommodation for them elsewhere is a sin against the
people’s fundamental human rights.. The ugly experience of Maroko is still fresh in the
minds of many Nigerians. Urban Planning in the 21st Century must provide for the poor
must guide the designing of houses in the 21st century. According to Alao (2008) the
starting point for the design of affordable housing unit is to establish the affordable rent
for the area in which the project is to be located. Affordability through design also entails
the determination of the best property development methods available to achieve cost
reduction without compromising quality. The design must also be sympathetic to both the
physical and cultural environment. A good design should aim at achieving affordability,
An idea akin to housing development efforts in the African traditional setting is the
pooling of resources to develop houses by members of a given social group for the
benefit of their members. Members contribute into a common pool for a pre-arranged
order of housing development for members; this form of development strategy is most
applicable among low-income earners for cheap, albeit adequate low-cost housing.
9. Social Housing.
Social housing refers to rental housing which may be owned and managed either by the
State or non-profit organizations, or a combination of the two, with the aim of providing
affordable housing (Wikipedia, 2007). For majority of the low income earners rented
tax waivers assist the housing corporations and certain private developers to provide
social housing to alleviate the housing problems of majority of the urban low income
earners.
roads, power, water and drainage facilities to proposed housing development areas. The
developers will then channel available funds to provide the houses proper and thus
The provision of basic infrastructure such as access roads, power, water and drainage
facilities will significantly reduce the cost of housing development. Sites and services
schemes involves the allocation of serviced or partly developed plots to people. The plot
allocation is usually accompanied with mortgage loans provided with terms and
conditions tailored to suit the income flow of the average allotee, to facilitate the
development of the plots. This is especially helpful in low income housing and thereby
recommended as a useful option for the upper category of low income earners.
The inability of the Government to enforce development control is one of the major
reasons for the deterioration of housing and housing infrastructure in most urban areas in
13. Taxation.
The hoarding of available residential land by monopolist land owners increases the cost
of land and hence the cost of housing. Residential land banks should be taxed to make it
Essential building materials should enjoy tax subsidies to achieve reductions in their
The Presidential Committee on Affordable Housing has suggested that developers who
construct more than 150 housing units a year should enjoy tax holidays while companies
who invest in housing should enjoy 50% tax relief (Onwuemenyi, 2008). This is a
welcome idea at this early stage, to attract more investment into housing.
14. Research on local building materials.
Readily available local building materials should be studied and improved to render them
suitable for producing cost-effective and durable houses. Such improved local materials
There should be a policy to locate certain categories of industries in the rural areas to
stock. To enhance the appeal of this policy, Government should improve the access roads
to such rural areas and provide necessary support to ensure adequate availability of land
enable payment for housing the present and prospective homeowners should have good
and sustainable means of income. The economy should be strong enough to provide jobs
Corruption militates against the success of, even, the best of policies. The Nigerian nation
has suffered greatly from corruption; best thought-out policies and projects have
collapsed .as a result of this national malaise. Contract costs are fraudulently inflated,
incompetent contractors are favoured over and above experienced and capable hands,
projects are sabotaged for narrow personal gains, etc. Bribery in whatever name is not
good for the system. Badly-executed projects are certified satisfactory by corrupt
Government and company officials. What ever we are proposing for housing in the 21 st
century can only succeed as planned if corruption is kept under control. The judiciary
should be up and doing. Justice delayed is justice denied. Delays in the courts have
turned profit-making projects to loss-making ones. The long arms of the law must be
made to reach both the rich and poor alike. Justice in the housing industry must be quick
and right because of the enormous cost implications of unnecessary delays and injustice.
CONCLUSION
Thank you.
REFERENCES.