Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Forests of high biodiversity and endemism in 2002, participant farmers were introduced to
once covered the Andean region of Colombia, a variety of sustainable alternatives and apprised
today the country’s most densely populated to their ecological, economic and social ben-
area. Fragmentation occurred over the past cen- efits. Technical assistance and small payments
tury as the landscape was transformed into an were provided to encourage their adoption.
agricultural mosaic. Shade coffee became the Within five years, forest cover increased and
dominant land use along the La Vieja River land management practices improved, achieving
watershed, between the Quindío and Valle del a substantial transformation of the study area.
Cauca departments, but it was later replaced by Understanding the factors that motivated farm-
sun exposed, higher yielding varieties. Even ers to adopt these systems will be instrumental
tually, crises in the global coffee market resulted in designing strategies to scale up this initiative.
in conversion of most lands to cattle pastures;
loss of productivity and soil degradation fol- Technology adoption and
lowed rapidly (Calle and Piedrahita 2007). the role of early adopters
Contrary to popular belief, cattle ranching
need not be detrimental for the environment. The decision to adopt a new technology or
Agroforestry systems for animal production innovation is driven by a complex combination
have been developed as alternatives to make it of household preferences, resource endowment,
sustainable. The large-scale adoption of such market incentives, biophysical factors and risk
systems in the tropical Andes could potentially and uncertainty (Pattanayak et al. 2003). Inno-
transform the landscapes from barren pastures vations are subjectively associated with higher
into providers of key environmental services risks, so before adoption can happen they need
like carbon sequestration and biodiversity pro- to be tested, modified and adapted to the spe-
tection. But as for other innovations, adoption cific context in order to minimize risk percep-
rates for these techniques remain low. tion. Only then will large scale diffusion occur
The Regional Integrated Silvopastoral Eco as the innovation spreads through a region by
systems Management Project (RISEMP) was combining with or displacing the alternatives
a Global Environmental Facility-funded pilot (Mercer 2004).
attempt to promote better ranching practices Adaptation of new technologies usually en-
along the La Vieja River watershed. Beginning tails costs that only a few innovators are willing
to bear. These early adopters play a fundamental
Alicia Calle is a Colombian biologist and graphic role in technology diffusion, assuming the most
artist. Her past work has combined art and sci- risks and incurring the highest costs. This article
ence to develop environmental education strate focuses on the motivations and decisions made
gies targeting diverse publics including children,
rural communities, technicians and academia. She
by two early adopters within the RISEMP. In
hopes to contibute to tropical ecosystem conserva- learning by doing, they generated a wealth of
tion by helping rural landowners find alternatives knowledge about how to make silvopastoral sys-
to make a more sustainable use of their lands. tems work under local conditions, facilitating
BOX 1
Advantages of Inga trees in silvopastoral systems
Native guamo (Inga sp.) trees traditionally provided the shade for coffee in Quindío. Inga
trees are legumes that fix atmospheric nitrogen through their roots providing natural fertiliza-
tion. They shed leaves constantly, creating a layer of nutrient-rich leaf litter that protects soils
from erosion and maintains moisture even during the summer. Insects, worms and microor-
ganisms that live in this environment recycle the nutrients into the organic matter preventing
the loss of fertility. Inga trees also foster biodiversity; pollinators are attracted to their flowers,
birds seek the fleshy fruit and a variety of insects, many beneficial, frequently visit their extra-
floral nectaries (Photographs 1 and 2).
When planted at high densities in pastures, these trees eliminate the need for expensive
chemical fertilizers. One hectare planted with 70 Inga trees can produce 6.5 tons of leaf litter
every year, containing about 120 kg of nitrogen, plus phosphorus and calcium (Cardona and
Sadeghian 2005). Cattle dung cycling underneath these trees is extremely fast due to the pres-
ence of an active soil biota that processes the nutrients back into the soil in a matter of days.
Improved soil quality delays the flowering of the grasses allowing for longer rotations. Prun-
ing is required to guarantee enough sunlight
for the pastures, but the excellent charcoal pro-
duced from these cuttings brings extra income
to the farm.
to nourish the pastures using chemical fertiliz- said I was crazy, that underneath the trees pas-
ers, but what we really need to nourish is the ture would not grow, that this would become a
soil so that there is decomposition of organic wetland…” So Olimpo was relieved when the
matter.” From his experience as a coffee grower project supported his idea and encouraged him
he deduced “…if coffee under guamo shade to continue. With someone to turn to for fur-
needed no fertilization or chemical inputs, why ther advice, Olimpo has since perfected his tree-
don’t I plant some guamo trees in the pastures?” planting designs and techniques.
Following his instinct, he gave up chemical fer- Iván had taken a more skeptical approach.
tilization and planted guamo trees (Inga sp.) in The thought of using trees—not chemical fertil-
the pastures instead (see Box 1). “Everybody izers—to increase pasture productivity seemed
ridiculous to him at first. Nevertheless, his curi- his farm after removing the cattle. But he most-
osity made him join the first group who visited ly focused on establishing hundreds of trees in
a demonstration farm. His persistent questions his pastures (Photograph 3). This proved to be
to the owner about every topic prolonged the a major challenge since trees planted in pastures
visit for several hours, and no one has forgotten face several threats: competition with aggressive
his entry in the visitor’s book: “Thanks to this grasses, structural damage by cattle, herbivore
visit, 5 cuadras of guadua forest in Quindío have attacks, desiccation, nutrient deficiencies and in
just been saved.”1 He meant it, and upon re- his case, a hardened layer of clay that prevent-
turning to his farm he cancelled the order to cut ed root penetration. Olimpo patiently devised
down a bamboo stand, marking the beginning methods to overcome each of these challenges
of a transformation that changed his productive and came up with his own tree planting strate-
system as well as his attitude. gy. He uses east-west facing, double-fenced lines
of trees every 20 m, mixing timber species with
Try and err… and try again ornamentals and other valued species, especially
Failure when trying an innovation often guamos. But developing this method came at a
leads people to conclude that the problem lies cost in time, labor and resources.
in the innovation. But early adopters, usu- Iván trusted his employee, Efrén, to execute
ally impatient to see results, often take a more the changes in his farm. They protected and re-
hands-on trial and error approach. They are forested all water sources and established several
also perseverant: they fail once, learn from their kilometers of live fences. They also decided to
mistakes, make adjustments and try again, fre- establish an intensive silvopastoral system (SPS),
quently several times. By assuming the costs of a high density plantation of the leguminous tree
learning by doing, they facilitate the task and Leucaena leucocephala combined with pastures
reduce the risk for later adopters. (see Box 2). This type of SPS had been success-
Olimpo personally supervised the imple- fully used elsewhere but its adaptation to the
mentation of the desired changes in his farm. He specific conditions of Quindío required time
fenced off and reforested all water courses with and investment. Armed with only some general
native tree species and giant bamboo and he instructions, his observation and tree-planting
planted a timber forest on the steepest slopes of skills and Iván’s support, Efrén made several
successive trials. Eventually they were the first to costs and productivity, but they are often also
successfully establish the system by direct plant- aware of benefits that go unnoticed to others.
ing, skipping the nursery stage (Photograph 5). This attention to detail is best explained by the
Since then, they have consistently improved risk involved in their investment and their first-
the technique and reduced the costs. For Iván, hand experience with the systems.
persevering in the establishment of this system Olimpo’s high tree density pastures provide
despite the initial failures meant not only a big an excellent example. Visitors are impressed by
investment but a huge departure from the days the intense green of the grass growing under-
when “paying labor for planting or caring for neath the guamo trees, where no urea fertiliz-
trees was a waste of money and time.” er has been applied for years (Photograph 6).
But the farmer also understands—and clearly
Making the less obvious links explains—other less visible benefits: how the
Early adopters are keen when evaluating guamo’s shade and litter favor nutrient cycling
their results. They can cite specific figures of and provide habitat for manure-processing
BOX 2
Intensive silvopastoral system with Leucaena
Intensive silvopastoral systems combine high densities of Leucaena leucocephala—more
than 10,000 shrubs ha-1—with enhanced pasture varieties. Leucaena is a sun-loving shrub na-
tive to Mexico, which can fix between 150 and 400 kg of nitrogen ha-1 each year through an
association with Rhizobium bacteria in its roots (Photograph 4). This natural fertilization elimi-
nates the need for chemical inputs, supporting high biomass production even during the dry
months. The plant is hardy and flexible and resists repetitive browsing, providing high quality
animal feed and shade that helps reduce heat stress in the cattle. The system is highly produc-
tive and long-lived as has been demonstrated in Colombia, where intensive SPS established 25
years ago are still in full production (Murgueitio et al. 2006).
The Leucaena system also has many environmental benefits. Lack of chemical fertiliza-
tion enables the presence of beneficial organisms that work the soil enhancing its structure.
The dense matt of Leucaena roots helps
reduce the impact of cattle trampling and
their quick decomposition after browsing
creates tunnels that prevent soil compac-
tion. Roots penetrate the deeper soil layers,
cycling nutrients vertically and facilitating
infiltration of rainfall. This helps recharge
aquifers and prevent erosion by runoff, es-
pecially in steep slopes. The dense system
also provides good habitat for small mam-
mals like agoutis and armadillos.
Photograph 5. During
establishment, Leucaena seedlings
are susceptible to flooding, attack
by ants and shade from weeds.
Once established, intensive SPS
with Leucaena are resistant and
very productive, and require no
fertilization.
Finca La Ramada
microorganisms; why well nourished pastures investment, but soon made an amazing obser-
delay their flowering and allow for longer rota- vation: the birds that now nest in his recently
tions and high energy feed; how the presence planted live fences were eating those worms
of trees supports fungi that control cattle ticks (Photograph 7). Still excited, he showed me the
reducing the need for chemical baths; or how birds: “those guys are the ones giving me a hand
the increased lizard habitat reduces the presence with the Leucaena worm; we were about to start
of annoying insects. spraying pesticides when they came.” Iván has
For Iván, the realization of these unexpec also realized that better pastures grow fewer
ted benefits occurred suddenly months after hav- weeds, fewer weeds demand less herbicides, and
ing established an area in intensive silvopastoral less herbicides enable the natural regeneration
system. He was desperate when he discovered a of the same tree species he once struggled to es-
worm outbreak that threatened his substantial tablish.
Endnotes References
1 1 cuadra = 0.64 hectares. Calle, Z. and L. Piedrahita. 2007. ¿Cómo diseñar
Guadua is a native giant bamboo. estrategias para el manejo de plantas de interés
para la conservación en paisajes ganaderos?
Acknowledgements Agroforestería en las Américas 45: 117-122.
Andrés Felipe Zuluaga assisted me in the field with Cardona, D.A. and K.S. Sadeghian. 2005. Ciclo de
unrivaled enthusiasm, facilitating the contacts and nutrimentos y actividad microbiana en cafe-
generously sharing his wealth of knowledge about tales a libre exposición solar y con sombrío de
this project; the Center for Research on Sustainable Inga spp. Revista Cenicafé 56(2): 127-141.
Agriculture Production Systems CIPAV provided Gutiérrez, Iván. Owner, finca La Ramada, Quimba-
instrumental guidance and support in Colombia; ya, Quindío. Personal communication. August
participating farmers welcomed me to their farms 14, 2007.
and willingly shared their experiences. This research Mercer, D.E. 2004. Adoption of Agroforestry Inno-
would not have been possible without their help. vations in the Tropics: A Review. Agroforestry
Amity Doolittle and Florencia Montagnini offered Systems 61: 311-328.
valuable insight and guidance throughout the Montes, Olimpo. Owner, finca Pinzacuá, Alcalá,
process. Funding was provided by the Compton Valle del Cauca. Personal communication.
Foundation and Yale’s Tropical Resources Institute. June 18, 2007.
Murgueitio, E., P. Cuéllar, M. Ibrahim, J. Gobbi,
C.A. Cuartas, J.F. Naranjo, A. Zapata, C.E.
Mejía, A.F. Zuluaga and F. Casasola. 2006.
Adopción de sistemas agroforestales pecuarios.
Pastos y Forrajes 29(4): 365-382.
Pattanayak, S.K., D.E. Mercer, E. Sills and J. Yang
2003. Taking stock of agroforestry adoption
studies. Agroforestry Systems 57:173-186.
Source: http://www.oldbookillustrations.com/index.php?lng=en