Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Dear
I write to you on some major issues concerning the Annual Work Plan &
Budget (AWP&B) exercise, which you would be initiating for the year 2011-12. The
planning exercise for the AWP&B, 2011-12 will be especially important since this
will be the first year when we will be comprehensively planning Sarva Shiksha
Abhiyan (SSA) interventions from the perspective of the provisions of the Right of
Children to Free and Compulsory Education (RTE) Act, 2009.
ACCESS:
3. Neighbourhood Schools: Section 6 of the RTE Act mandates the
establishment of a school by the appropriate government or local authority within
the prescribed area or limits of the neighborhood in a three year time span from the
commencement of the Act. Therefore, based on the norms for neighbourhood
school prescribed under your State RTE Rules, you will need to undertake a
mapping exercise in habitations which are unserved by a regular school, or are
served by EGS-type centres, and (i) arrive at an authentic and correct assessment
of the requirements of the new primary and upper primary schools, (ii) identify EGS
centres which need to be upgraded to regular schools, or closed down, and (iii)
identify children in those habitations where setting up a full fledged school may be
unviable for providing residential school facilities or transportation/escort
arrangements.
-2-
4. I may add that we had clarified in the PAB meetings held for the approval of
the Supplementary Plans for 2010-11 that the states will have to submit a detailed
justification for proposing residential or transport facilities, clearly indicating the
habitations or the localities intended to be covered, the reasons for not providing
regular schools in the neighborhood, location of the proposed residential facility
and availability of land or an existing building, mode of transport in case of
transport facility, number of children to be covered, the mechanism for the
identification of the children and willingness of the parents to utilize these facilities.
It will not be possible for the PAB to approve proposals for residential or
transport/escort facilities in the absence of such justification.
identification of children who must be enrolled. For this the State Government,
Local Authority and School Management Committee will need to undertake a
community level school mapping exercise. The school mapping exercise will be
followed by (i) a formal enrolment process to enter the child’s name in the school
records (ii) organisation of Special Training of flexible duration to enable the child
to be at par with other children, (iii) actual admission of the child in the age
appropriate class on completion of Special Training, and his/her participation in all
class activities, (iv) continued support to the child, once admitted to the regular
school, so that the child can integrate with the class socially, emotionally and
academically. States will be required to plan context-specific strategies for Special
Training. An important preparatory activity for providing Special Training would be
the development of appropriate material by the academic authority notified by the
State under section 29 of the RTE Act.
9. The RTE Act in different sections makes reference to gender and social
inclusion both explicitly and implicitly. Some of the relevant provisions are: no
discrimination against children from ‘disadvantaged groups’ and ‘weaker sections’
on any grounds; inclusion of women in school monitoring committees; provision of
good quality education that includes equity issues, curriculum development in
conformity with constitutional stipulations; training, enrolment in age appropriate
classes (which will largely apply to girls, especially from disadvantaged
communities). There is a need to consider retention as an equity issue, as SC, ST,
Muslim girls, are vulnerable, and most likely to dropout. In the context of RTE,
gender and social disadvantage must become integral to concerns of quality and
equity. Gender and social inclusion, as a crosscutting issue, should be viewed as
an integral and visible part of the quality agenda. It is, therefore, important that
you work towards ensuring that issues of exclusion and disadvantage are
addressed: -
10. The annual plan must focus on addressing these challenges. We would like
to see a separate chapter on the areas and challenges identified and strategies
devised to prevent explicit and implicit discrimination against the children of the
disadvantaged groups and weaker sections in pursuing and completing elementary
education.
11. Interventions for children with special needs: - In the case of Children
with Special Needs (CWSN), the key priority areas are (a) strengthening the
identification system of CWSN, (b) ensuring full coverage of CWSN by preparing
schools to address the diverse needs that different categories of CWSN have,
especially children with Autism Spectrum Disorders, cerebral palsy, deaf-
blindness, etc (c) strengthening the resource support team for regular and effective
academic support to the CWSN (d) strengthening and upgradation of resource
rooms (e) augmentation of training facilities in BRC/ CRC keeping in mind the
needs of CWSN and by placing adequate number of special educators (f)
adaptation of curriculum and evaluation processes for CWSN (g) sensitization of
teachers, parents, community and peers to create an inclusive school environment
(h) coordination with special schools and (i) barrier-free access through the
availability of ramps with handrails and barrier free toilets.
RETENTION
12. Retention: - The RTE Act makes it mandatory for states to ensure that every
child stays on and completes elementary education. Retention is therefore, the
litmus test for all the efforts that go into strengthening the formal education
system; it is necessary that robust and vibrant processes are put in place to keep
close and constant watch on the attendance pattern of children enrolled, and
ensure timely interventions to hold them from dropping out. This will require inter
alia following measures:-
a) Situation analysis of each school, cluster and block reporting low retention
rate to understand the barriers coming in the way of children staying on in
school.
b) Ensuring constant dialogue between the school, parents, SMC and the
community at large to facilitate children’s regular attendance and
participation in school activities.
d) Capacity building of the teachers and CRC and BRC level functionaries to
conceptualise appropriate child specific interventions to remove the existing
barriers.
The Annual Plan 2011-12 must, therefore, reflect the mechanism and processes
conceived of to track the attendance pattern of the children and respond to the
specific situations.
QUALITY
13. Curriculum, syllabus and textbook development: - Section 29 of the Act
makes specific mention of eight factors which should be taken into consideration by
the designated academic authority to lay down the curriculum and the evaluation
procedure. It needs, however, to be emphasized that while designing curriculum,
material and learning material States must take cognizance of the ground realities
of children. Focus should be on selection and formulation of topics such that there
is continuity across grades and themes, and an interdisciplinary focus across
subjects is maintained. Linkages should be developed between school knowledge in
different subjects and children’s everyday experiences. Besides, while undertaking
revision of textbooks, it will be important to rationalize the number of subjects and
books both at primary and upper primary levels, so that there is no additional
curriculum load and burden on children. Textbooks developers would need to
design books that focus on understanding concepts; encourage reflective thinking;
and provide interactive spaces for children and activities for group as well as
individual work with evaluation happening in a continuous manner. The textbooks
should keep the principle of equity and inclusion at the forefront, proactively break
extant stereotypes and reflect sensitivity to gender, caste and class parity, peace,
health and needs of children with disabilities. SSA should get closely associated
with the curriculum renewal and syllabus and textbook development processes,
and provide necessary support to the academic authority and agencies concerned.
The annual plan document must give an unambiguous idea of these processes and
the mechanism worked out for inter-agency coordination.
17. Training of untrained teachers: The RTE Act necessitates that a person
must possess the minimum qualifications laid down by the Academic Authority
authorized by the central government to be eligible to work as a teacher. You are
aware that NCTE has been notified as the Academic Authority for this purpose, and
it has laid down the minimum qualifications for teachers. The States having under
qualified and untrained teachers must develop strategies to train all untrained
teachers within the next four years. The states will have to, therefore, clearly
indicate in the plan document (a) the number of under qualified and untrained
teachers, (b) institutional capacity in terms of DIETs and teacher training
institutes, which exist in the state for teacher education, (c) proposed measures for
increasing the institutional capacity to address the teacher qualification needs of
untrained teachers, including alternative strategies through distance learning to
clear the backlog in the given time frame.
18. Reviewing teacher recruitment rules: There will also be need for revisiting
the existing teacher recruitment and promotion rules in some of the states to
ensure the availability of (i) subject-specific teachers, (ii) teachers with the requisite
qualifications at the upper primary level and (iii) head teachers. Part-time
Instructors for Art Education, Work Education and Health and Physical Education,
mandated by RTE, were sanctioned in the Supplementary Plans, 2010-11 of many
states. However, we would like to see a write-up on the strategy prepared by the
States to meet the requirement of the Part-time Instructors indicating the
qualification and experience criteria, mode of recruitment, remuneration, job chart,
etc.
19. In-service teacher training: The States must draw up a long term in-service
teacher development plan, defining parameters such as the periodicity, content and
methodology of the programmes. The training design will be such that it integrates
content, pedagogy, materials and resources of a particular concept. This should be
followed through adequate support at block and cluster level. Arrangements for
class room observation after training programmes by the Resource Persons are to
be put in place. The cluster level meetings should develop into a professional forum
for teachers to reflect and plan together.
-7-
COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION
20. Strengthening of SMCs: - The RTE Act places emphasis on process of
planning to commence at the school level, and requires the School Management
Committees to make School Development Plans which shall be the basis for the
plans and grants to be made by the appropriate Government (Section 22). This
entails a massive effort to create capacity at the SMC level to look at the challenges
of quality education in the light of the Act. Empowered and professionally equipped
SMCs would be crucial for anchoring community awareness and participation
efforts. The revised SSA norms provide for residential and non-residential mode of
community training. States will have to invest in capacity building of SMC
members to address this enormous challenge and work out a comprehensive and
cohesive plan of action which should inter alia incorporate the development of a
training module and framework for the School Development Plan, creation of a
strong network of resource persons with the active involvement of the civil society
organizations and putting in place an institutional mechanism for constant
dialogue at the community level. This is a huge exercise and can easily go awry if
not planned meticulously, taking into account the logistical implications.
21. Community has an important role to play in the improvement of the learning
environment in the schools. While making School Development Plan, the SMC has
to pay adequate attention to quality issues including teacher training, availability of
child entitlements, teaching learning materials in schools, pupil assessment in
consonance with the principles of continuous and comprehensive evaluation, and
preparation of pupil cumulative record. The SMC can also act as a bridge for
community involvement in sharing knowledge with schoolchildren. Encouragement
to work experience would require the attachment of children with professionals,
farmers, and artisans. In addition, there should be greater involvement with
various extension workers i.e. agriculture, health, anganwadi workers for more
experiential learning. The community leaders and groups, therefore, will need to be
sensitized on issues related to monitoring of children's progress and other quality
related school activities. This will have to be preceded by the community
mobilization as well training of SMC on issues pertaining to quality.
SCHOOL INFRASTRUCTURE
22. Improving school infrastructure: The Schedule to the RTE Act makes it
mandatory for the schools to comply with the norms and standards, and SSA
norms have been appropriately revised. States need ensure that they saturate their
infrastructure requirements in the next two years e.g. by March 2013. Construction
of new school buildings will continue to receive the highest priority. States will have
to ensure that each new school has a composite building, containing all features
specified in the Schedule to the RTE Act, and is designed in a manner that
available physical spaces serve as an aid to learning. States will need to ensure
that appropriate barrier free features, keeping in view the different requirements
children with special needs, are incorporated in all new building designs, so that
they are able to enter the school building and negotiate their way around the school
easily. The school buildings shall also provide safety features in the structural
design to ensure appropriate safety to the children against natural and man-made
hazards such as earthquake, cyclone, flood and fires etc.
-8-
URBAN PLANNING
24. Urban Planning: -Urban areas have unique features like a high density of
population, a heterogeneous community, extremely high cost/unavailability of
land, slums, migrating population, homeless population, infrastructural barriers to
school, urban deprived children etc. As such, planning in the context of RTE
would also be somewhat different warranting relevant and more specific strategies
especially while planning for school access (physical as well as social), special
training, community participation, classroom processes, academic support and
convergence etc.
25. The most critical factors while planning for neighbourhood schools in urban
areas would be finalizing relevant and need based criteria for neighbourhood school
and interface between school and community. Special training would have to be
planned very specifically to address the needs of urban deprived children like street
& working children, rag-picking children, children of slum/pavement dwellers,
children working in industry, household, tea shops, garages etc. Effective
convergence with municipal agencies and departments of health, PHE, welfare,
WCD etc. especially in the context of planning residential facilities, to refurbish
unused public buildings or under-utilised school buildings, would be a necessary
precondition for access and retention of urban deprived children without adult
protection.
26. Urban specific strategies should reflect in the entire district Annual Work
Plan under SSA. The cities with large population (Million Plus Cities) shall make
separate plans, while for other cities and urban areas, urban component shall be a
separate chapter of every district plan. The State component too shall clearly focus
on urban issues. Major cities would need a dedicated programme management
structure at city level to plan and implement SSA in the urban context.
-9-
27. Strengthening the Project Management Structure: - The RTE Act requires
the entire education department to be geared in a unified manner to take up the
task of the implementation of its provisions. In the long run this would require the
unification of the existing SSA structures with the regular education department.
While total unification may take time, convergence of overlapping or dichotomous
SSA structures with the regular education department and the SCERT should
commence immediately. In doing so, you may ensure structures at the State,
District and Sub-District levels are strong and vibrant enough to implement the
programmatic activities in a time-bound manner more so in the context of
expanded activities and enhanced funding to support these activities. Existence of
a large number of vacancies against the sanctioned posts and under-staffing of
some crucial components has been discussed in the previous PAB and review
meetings. States should not only fill up the vacancies, but also make a realistic
assessment of the requirement of manpower for various components and at
different levels.
29. Revised SSA norms provide for a full fledged MIS unit at the BRC level. This
should enable the states to develop appropriate online systems for the monitoring
of the functioning of schools at sub-distinct level structures. Online systems
developed by Madhya Pradesh (for child tracking and education administration and
management), Orissa (child tracking system), Gujarat (tracking of migrant
children), Andhra Pradesh (monitoring of IE resource persons and care givers) and
TSG (teacher placement and redeployment) have been shared with the states in
various National level workshops. States should plan for development of online
systems for child tracking, teacher placement and redeployment, quality
monitoring, on-site academic support to teachers by the BRCs and CRCs, special
training arrangements, tracking of migrant children etc.
33. In addition to above, we are enclosing the Annexures, as detailed below for
use in preparation of AWP&B 2011-12:-
35. Spillover & revised AWP&B: - I wish to draw your attention specifically to
the tendency of underestimating spillovers in AWP&B estimates with the
expectation of garnering more funds for fresh works. This leads to unfortunate
situations later, suggesting not only improper planning, but also a grave financial
impropriety. AWP&B approved by PAB for 2011-12, will be revised by end May
2011, after the States report their actual spillovers and unspent balances
separately to the GoI/PAB after closure of 2010-11 accounts by 15th May, 2011
latest. Furthermore, on receipt of annual audited accounts, the variation between
the spillover funds declared and audited unspent balances will be deducted from
further releases of Central share by GOI.
36. Appraisal: - At the National level, we would be starting the Appraisal process
of AWP&B 11-12, for districts and States from the third week of February, 2011.
The appraisal format and important aspects of the plan preparation process will
also be discussed in the National level workshops to be held in the month of
December, 2010. I would urge you to complete the process of plan formulation in
time and submit the plan by the date fixed for
this purpose. It must be ensured that the district plans are based on the School
Development Plans and approval of the State Executive Committee has been
obtained before the submitting the plan for appraisal.
With regards,
Yours sincerely,
(Anita Kaul)
Copy to: -
(Anita Kaul)