Sie sind auf Seite 1von 24

APRIL 2008 - INSIDE THIS ISSUE:

Working Undercover: Internet Safety: What If:


Undercover officers frequently face danger and a variety of A veteran FBI agent says parental involvement is key to School violence continues to teach us painful lessons.
challenges. Page 3 protecting children from predators. Page 5 Page 11

April 2008 VOL. 2, ISSUE 2

Elder Abuse, While Widely Undetected, Steadily Increasing


By TEALE CALIENDO “There are many 90-year-olds living in the community
Correspondent Elder Abuse - The Numbers: who don’t go into nursing homes …they stay in their own
apartments or in assisted living facilities.”
“I have a case right now where you’d shake your head,” • Only 1 in 14 incidents, excluding incidents of self-neglect, The NCEA says the numbers of abuse cases we know
said John DeMattia of Connecticut’s Elder Abuse Unit. come to the attention of authorities. about is just the tip of the iceberg. It is estimated only
“I have a daughter physically abusing her mother… it got • For every one case of elder abuse, neglect, exploitation, one in 14 cases of neglect and one in 25 cases of financial
to the point of broken ribs, broken nose…and (now) the or self-neglect reported to authorities, about five more go abuse are reported.
mother calls me once a week begging me not to ask for unreported. While the state enforcement unit has 55-60 open
jail time for her daughter because she needs her to take • Only 1 in 25 cases of financial abuse are reported, sug- cases and at least that many more under review, an
care of her.” gesting that there may be at least 5 million financial abuse accurate account of cases in Connecticut is not possible
DeMattia is a supervisory assistant in the State’s victims each year. because some are prosecuted by local jurisdictions and not
Attorney’s Elder Abuse Unit, which was established reported to DeMattia’s office. Since 2000, the unit has
in 2000 to investigate and prosecute crimes against the of elder abuse were made nationally in 2003 (the most averaged about 48 cases a year, and about 90 percent of
elderly (victims 60 years and older). The unit’s employees recent year for which statistics are available), 20 percent them have been financial exploitation. The financial loss
are trained to handle this special category of victims and more than in 2000. It’s projected the problem will only has skyrocketed to approximately $250,000 but the unit
victimizers because of the vital role “family dynamics” escalate with the graying of our population, but accurate now only accepts cases where the loss is $500,000 or more,
plays in the problem. statistics are elusive for a variety of reasons. with some exceptions.
There has been a steady increase in the reporting of “The average age for living now is around 80, and "As the first of the baby boomers hit the age of senior-
domestic elder abuse – abuse occurring in the homes the fastest-growing segment of the population is 85 and ity in Connecticut (60), we expect that unfortunately the
where the elderly reside – according to the National above,” says Alice Deak, director of Information Services
Center on Elder Abuse (NCEA). Nearly 566,000 reports for the Southwestern Connecticut Agency on Aging. - See Elder Abuse on page 15

Good Legal Representation Can


Be Very Expensive, or Free
By RONALD WINTER from “excellent” to “outstanding.”
Correspondent The workload for the public defender’s
office also is far greater than for attorneys
There are two ways to go to court in private practice. Public defenders
in Connecticut charged with a serious can’t pass on a possible case if they
crime and still have an excellent chance already have a full slate of clients, and
at receiving the best legal representation thus Meehan estimates that “the public
with or without mortgaging the farm. defender’s office has 80 percent of cases
You can be rich and hire a really great on the docket.”
attorney, or you can be poor and have In fact, in 2006–07, the total public
a really great attorney assigned to your defender caseload in Connecticut was
case by the judge. 80,854 – an increase of 522 cases from
In between, you still have a great the previous year. Also, public defender
Bridgeport Harbor supports a wide variety and volume of activity from a busy chance of excellent representation, but offices were appointed to 80 murder
ferry schedule, shipping, commercial fishing, and recreational boating. Over not only will you pay for it out of your and capital felony cases. In all five of
five millions tons of cargo is shipped through the port annually. own pocket, but also you’ll definitely the capital cases the state is seeking the
feel the pinch, and depending on the death penalty.
seriousness of the crime, you could go

Bridgeport Harbor Closes deep into debt.


Ask Bridgeport Criminal Defense
$400 per Hour
While the state limits the wages its

Security Gaps with Grants


Lawyer Richard Meehan about the cost attorneys receive, attorneys in private
of defending a client charged with a practice make the point that any
major crime, and he will tell you right up successful law firm is a business, not a
front that hiring him is expensive, but he charity. Clients who are facing serious
By FRANK SZIVOS was a vital link between New York City believes his clients get what they need. charges up to and including capital
Correspondent and Long Island and the rest of New On the flip side, Meehan is highly murder can expect to pay as much as
England. complimentary of the Connecticut $400 per hour.
After 9/11, Joseph Riccio, executive He recalls 9/11 vividly when I-95 public defender system. In his view, some That is not what the lawyer assigned
director of the Bridgeport Port was nearly empty, no planes were in the public defenders, who are employees to the case will be paid, but that is what
Authority (BPA), realized even more of the state and thus have their salaries
than ever that the Bridgeport Harbor - See Bridgeport Harbor on page 14 determined by the government, range - See Representation on page 13
PAGE 2 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL APRIL 2008

1 of 5 Fatal Crashes Nationwide Involves Unlicensed Drivers, Says AAA


At least 20 percent of the drivers license at the time of the crash. Of this ers whose licenses had been suspended study, 238, or 11.5 percent, of all driv-
involved in fatal car crashes on both the number, 226 were Connecticut drivers. or revoked were 3.7 times more likely ers involved in fatal crashes on state
state and national levels between 2001 The AAA Foundation bases its figures to be involved in a fatal crash than highways during that period had their
and 2005 were unlicensed at the time on an analysis of the U.S. Department validly licensed counterparts, and that licenses suspended or revoked in the
of the crash, a AAA study reports. of Transportation’s data on fatal motor unlicensed drivers were 4.9 times more three years preceding the crash.
Aptly titled “Unlicensed to Kill: The vehicle crashes. likely to be involved in a fatal crash. The study recommends 16 reme-
Sequel,” the report by the AAA Founda- The current figures are consistent with The study also found that more than dial actions, including immobilizing
tion for Traffic Safety shows a persistent, prior AAA research that also indicated 17,000 drivers involved in fatal crashes or impounding vehicles of drivers who
deadly pattern among high-risk drivers one out of every five fatal crashes on were driving illegally with suspended have had their licenses revoked or
and raises serious issues about the ability America’s highways involved at least one or revoked licenses, and, of those num- suspended; impounding vehicle plates,
of the states to control the unlicensed driv- driver who was driving illegally at the time ber, a startling 28 percent had three or blocking re-registration of vehicles,
ing situation. of the crash. That study, called “Unlicensed more suspensions or revocations on and establishing mandatory jail time
During the four-year period, the study to Kill,” was based on data from 1993 to their record in the three years prior to for multiple offenders.
reports that more than 40,000 drivers 1999. the crashes. For a downloaded copy of the study,
involved in fatal crashes lacked a valid The recent study showed that driv- In Connecticut, according to the visit www.aaafoundation.org.

Henry Lee Criminal College Appoints Ward New Dean


Dr. Richard H. associate vice president for Research and his career, and continues to be actively sic science, music and sound recording,
Ward has been Special Programs at Sam Houston State involved in the criminal justice profession- engineering, computer science, and crimi-
selected as the dean University (SHSU). Previously, he served al and academic communities throughout nal justice. University College at UNH
of the Henry C. Lee as dean of Criminal Justice at SHSU and the world. develops programs and courses to meet
College of Criminal as associate chancellor for special programs A leader in experiential education, the the emerging educational and training
Justice and Foren- and for 16 years as vice chancellor for University of New Haven provides its stu- needs of educators, businesses, and public
sic Sciences at the administration at the University of Illinois, dents with a combination of solid liberal and social agencies, focusing on academic
University of New Chicago. He has also served as vice presi- arts and real-world, hands-on professional excellence, convenience, and flexibility.
Haven. dent and dean of Graduate Studies at John training. A private university founded in In the last 30 years the Lee College
Dr. Richard Ward will assume Jay College of Criminal Justice. 1920, UNH has a full-time undergradu- has become a world-recognized leader
the leadership of the Ward earned doctorate and master’s ate enrollment of more than 2,400 stu- in forensics and has grown exponentially,
H. Ward Henry C. Lee Col- degrees in criminology at the University dents—with 70 percent residing on its 80- from a small classroom equipped with
lege, named for the forensic scientist and of California, Berkeley, and a bachelor of acre main campus—and a graduate school a single fingerprint kit to a multi-disci-
criminalist who began the forensics pro- science degree from John Jay College of enrollment that exceeds 1,700. The uni- plined department with state-of-the-art
gram in 1975, effective mid-summer 2008. Criminal Justice in New York. He has versity offers more than 80 undergraduate technology specializing in academic pro-
Ward comes to UNH with strong expe- published numerous books and journal degrees and more than 25 graduate degrees grams in criminal justice, forensic science,
rience in academic and higher educa- articles, has successfully garnered more through its four colleges, in fields such fire science, national security, and legal
tion leadership positions. He is currently than $10 million in grants throughout as sports management, nutrition, foren- studies.
APRIL 2008 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL PAGE 3

Undercover Officers Face Mixed Bag of Challenges


By RONALD WINTER federal agent who went by the name “Duke.”
Correspondent Duke is still active, although not undercover, and
doesn’t want to use his real name or give away his
Consider this scenario. location. But in the 10 years he worked undercover,
You are a U.S. Army veteran, with three years in Duke traveled over much of the United States and
the military police, including a tour in Vietnam. made occasional forays into Canada and Mexico,
You come home, enroll in the University of New working to develop evidence and cases on drug
Haven, and graduate with a bachelor’s degree in law suppliers and their networks.
enforcement. By sheer chance, you take an exam Because of his size – well over six feet, two hun-
for the Bureau of Narcotics and Dangerous Drugs dred pounds – Duke was restricted to “playing the
– later the Drug Enforcement Agency – and even heavy,” either a bodyguard, or a rogue biker making
though you had considered joining the Vermont buys from gangs. Sometimes he said nothing but
State Police so you could ski on days off, you pass was on the scene to flash money at appropriate
and are accepted. times. As it turned out, his college courses and
In a relatively short time you find yourself posing professional training helped less than the roles he
as a renegade biker and are on the verge of making had played in local theater productions when he
your first undercover heroin buy. was a child.
All your training, experience, and education are “You have to look the part, and think the part,
racing through your mind, seemingly pent up behind and not waver,” Duke says. “Be simple, be convinc-
a dam of coolness as a real biker pulls up alongside ing, and be brief.”
your motorcycle in a quiet section of a Connecticut “Working undercover is all about control,” he
park. You wait for just the right moment to show says. To establish and maintain control requires
your colleagues watching from a hidden location simplicity. “Any curves from the other side have to
that you have what it takes to outfox this guy. be nullified. Circumstances change, and you have
to be flexible,” Duke says, but the need for control
He looks you up and down. You do the same. never changes.
Finally he speaks. When laying the groundwork to make the actual
“Got the money?” To be sure, even with the stress, danger, and long periods buy, “the target is nervous, until the relationship
You respond. away from his family, there were some high points to his job. is established.” But even a nervous target can be
“ Yeah, I got the money. You got the (expletive)?” Duke, at right, was part of a team that seized $1.5 million in controlled, Duke says.
“ Yeah, I got the (expletive). You got the money?” cash from a drug ring. At the time it was the largest seizure of “You have money, and he is motivated by greed.
“I told you I got the money. You got the (expletive)?” cash on the East Coast. (Faces distorted to protect identity.) But you have to be motivated by safety.”
“I told you I got the (expletive). You got the money?” In fact, Duke says, safety is the number-one
issue facing an undercover agent, and new agents
This scintillating conversation continues for another ners, and drug suppliers, you aren’t exactly working with have to learn quickly to terminate a transaction, regard-
moment and you finally say, “Why don’t you show me the the top of the food chain. less of how promising it may seem, at the first sign that
(expletive) at the same time I show you the money?” The exchange above took place many years ago things are not right.
The biker agrees. He slowly pulls back his vest, show- between a drug-dealing biker and a real-life undercover “If you smelled something going bad, it went sour
ing a package of heroin on his belt quickly and usually at night.”
as you flash a wad of money on your But even control can be overdone,

Undercover Officers Walk Narrow Line


belt. and Duke laughs as he remem-
bers calling off a planned buy right
He speaks again. in the middle of the negotiations.
“OK, give me the money.” On the surface it would appear that necessary to share their information, or at the Duke’s supervisor was new and
You respond. there are considerable differences between very least notify local and regional units that was micromanaging the team to
“Give me the (expletive).” undercover police, who spend days or they are working in the area. Experience has the point that every possibility had
“I ain’t giving you the (expletive) until weeks developing and executing a case, and shown that building a trusting relationship to be reviewed, and then reviewed
you give me the money.” those who work deep undercover, posing is the key to working well with local field again. The list of “what ifs” went on
“I ain’t giving you the money until you as members of organized crime families or officers. and on.
give me the (expletive).” other criminal gangs. The very nature of undercover work and When it came time to make the
But a closer look reveals that there are more the need for teams to protect each other buy, Duke abruptly called it off
Again, a round of scintillating similarities than differences. The primary makes it difficult to be forthcoming with and told the seller to come back
conversation passes until you suggest difference is that deep undercover officers police from different departments. Initially another time. After the seller left,
exchanging your wares simultane- must play their role for as long as it takes it took time for local and regional task forces Duke returned to the team’s meet-
ously. to build a case against the criminal target, to work as partners with state and federal ing place.
The biker agrees, you cautiously and usually neither their police colleagues agents. When his supervisor indignantly
make the switch, and he is on his nor their families know their whereabouts But cooperation between agencies can be demanded to know why he had
way. or what they are doing. These cases can, and instrumental in case development – or as one ended the transaction, Duke replied
A few minutes later at a pre- on occasion do, take up to several years in undercover officer puts it, “Who knows the with as much sincerity as he could
designated meeting place, you are development before arrests are forthcoming. area better than the beat cop? You’re smart muster, “He didn’t do any of the
surrounded by fellow agents who But even deep undercover officers have to develop a mutual trust, to avoid getting things you said he would.”
had the buy under surveillance. They safety nets, including contacts who know caught in a cross fire.”
have the evidence, and you are no where they are and what they are doing. The Often it is necessary for local agents Thus another point was made
longer a virgin undercover cop. deep undercover officer arranges a means to work with others from out of the area – the team had the final say in how
Yet, as they congratulate you, your of contact to higher-ups that enables the if for no other reason than officer safety. the transaction was accomplished,
supervisor notices a certain lack of transfer of information with minimal risk of Undercover agents try to work well away how the target was played, and who
enthusiasm on your part and asks if exposure. from the areas where they live, have families, had control. Duke maintains that
you are OK. Officers who work on cases that take less and lead a totally different life, but that is not undercover work can’t be accom-
“All that training and schooling time to develop still need safety nets, and the always possible. plished from behind a desk.
for this? I could have put a tape length of time they work undercover still is Chance encounters with criminals who In the long run, Duke said he got
recorder on my golden retriever and dictated by the complexity of the case and are or have been targets of undercover work far more satisfaction from working
got the same thing!” how long it takes to develop evidence that not only can destroy a case as it develops on the surveillance teams than from
will hold up in court. In their cases, however, but can also be dangerous for the agent and setting up drug busts. “Surveillance
Welcome to the world of under- there is a team approach that includes a family members, too. is the key,” he says, because the team
cover police work and the realization partner and surveillance units. “has to testify to verify the under-
that when you are dealing with drug On occasion undercover agents will find it -Ron Winter
users, drug manufacturers, drug run- - See Undercover on page 19
PAGE 4 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL APRIL 2008

Cheshire Murders Inspire Interest in Self-Defense Training for Women


By NATALIE MISSAKIAN
Correspondent

There was a young mom looking to protect herself and


her children, a single woman fearful of evening jaunts to
the supermarket, and an older lady who lived for decades
on an isolated road but recently stopped feeling safe there.
These very different women, and many of the others who
gathered on a recent evening in a Cheshire gymnasium,
had one thing in common: the deadly home invasion that
rocked their town last summer had shaken the sense of
security they once took for granted.
“Obviously we live in a small town that was turned
upside down,” said a 47-year-old woman whose name was
withheld to protect her identity. “Being single and living
by myself, you never know.”
The women are students in the Cheshire Police
Department’s Rape Aggression Defense (R.A.D.)
Systems course, launched by the department in March.
The nationally recognized, women-only course is free
to anyone 18 and over who lives or works in the town.
The department received a $15,000 federal grant to cover
expenses.
Police said the demand for self-defense programs has
skyrocketed since the tragic Petit murders last July, when
two men killed three women in a Cheshire family after
breaking into their home. The men followed the mother
and one of her daughters home from a local supermarket. A participant in Cheshire’s Rape Aggression Defense Systems course practices her self-defense moves on
“I think living in a small town, you get complacent,” Cheshire Police Training Officer James Nemphos. (Photo by Natalie Missakian)
said a 37-year-old mother of two small children. “You’re
just thinking about the kids, putting them in the car. Prevention and Awareness First of attempted sexual assault found women who did not
You’re not really thinking about your surroundings, and The program teaches prevention and awareness first, use defensive measures such as screaming or physical
that’s when things go wrong.” seeking to arm women with enough strategies to avoid resistance all were ultimately raped, he said.
The trainers, Cheshire Police Officers Brian Schechter becoming a target. When that fails, it shows them simple The R.A.D. moves are aimed at playing up a woman’s
and James Nemphos, said while the course involves some techniques to help them flee a potential attacker. strength, which is concentrated in her legs, hips, and
simple martial arts techniques, they are not trying to turn Statistically, it is in a woman’s best interest to resist an
the women into overnight black belts. aggressor, said Nemphos. A UCLA study of 94 victims - See Self Defense on page 22

Graphic Design and Desktop Publishing


CONNECTICUT POLICE CHIEFS ASSOCIATION
Brochures - Flyers - Page Design - Posters LUCIANO AWARDS PRESENTED
Menus - Logos - Business Cards & More
Each year we present awards to the graduates of all Connecticut
police academies with the highest scholastic average in each recruit
mariodesign@snet.net 203.377.8088 mariodesigngraphics.com training class in honor of Chief Samuel J. Luciano. Chief Luciano
believed in the need to provide adequate training for every police recruit.
He worked long and hard for legislation requiring a mandatory training
period and for the establishment of a statewide police academy. Chief
Luciano suffered a fatal heart attack prior to the completion of the Con-
necticut Police Academy.

The following graduates were presented the Luciano Award at the


CPCA Winter Meeting: Jonathan Carreiro, Connecticut State Police
Two-Way Radios • Mobile Data Systems –Troop I, Julian Cokic, Orange Police, Justin Gilbert, University of
Radar Unit Sales - Service - Calibration Connecticut Police, Renee LaMark-Muir, Hartford Police, Michael
Luckingham, New Haven Police, John Martin, Connecticut State Police
Whelen Emergency Vehicle Lighting –Troop C, Joseph Miceli, Weston Police, Richard P. Monge, Manchester
Vehicle Locating Systems • Consulting Police, Needasabrina Russell, New Britain Police, Michael J. Stempien,
Stamford Police, and Jonathan Youens, Hartford Police.
Complete Motorola Product Line
Sales & Service of Communications Equipment for Over 40 Years CONGRATULATIONS
920 Sherman Avenue (203) 287-1306 www.cpcanet.org
Hamden, Connecticut 06514 (800) 443-1306
www.utilitycommunications.com
APRIL 2008 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL PAGE 5

Internet Environment Traps Both Predators and Victims


Profile
By LEISA TAYLOR treated and healed, it’s always with them. Their life is
Correspondent now seen through that screen.”
Shumaker feels stress can be a motivator in the work
Kathy Shumaker is petite, friendly, and the single she does. “A supervisor of mine in Chicago believed that
mother of a nine-year-old son. FBI Special Agent stress was good – that you needed it to do the job. And
Kathy Shumaker is determined, no-nonsense, and a I think I believe that, too. If I’m not stressed, I don’t feel
protector of Connecticut’s children from often horrific like I’m working. But that’s just who I am.”
and unspeakable crimes. Shumaker is also humble. She does not like to
“As a parent, you think of how your child looks at you advertise her achievements, which include several United
so innocently, and then you think how all those victimized State’s Attorney’s awards for cases she has successfully
kids had that same innocent look,” said Shumaker. “They investigated. Additionally, Shumaker reaches out to the
trusted somebody who took them out of their world of community to help educate children, parents, and schools
safety and did horrific things to them just because they about Internet crime. For example, she addresses parent-
could.” teacher organizations, and she was a participant in a 2007
A 22-year veteran of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, seminar to encourage Fairfield County educators to teach
Special Agent Shumaker has worked the last nine years in students to steer clear of Internet predators.
Connecticut. She spent the vast majority of that time A native of Ohio, Shumaker first thought of law
in New Haven as coordinator for the Computer Crimes enforcement while in high school. “But at the time I
Task Force, a specialized unit that investigates child grew up, that just wasn’t something girls did,” she said.
pornography (possession, distribution, or production) and “My father said the FBI was not going to let a girl in, so I
criminal sexual activity with a child. The latter involves didn’t pursue it. But when I was working on my master’s
either travel across state lines or use of the computer to degree (in communications), my father said, ‘What do
engage in sex with a child. you really want to do?’ And I wanted to be an FBI agent.
Shumaker definitely has an issue with the computer, There was a huge advertisement in the paper that day
or more specifically the Internet, which she says has recruiting for the FBI. My father said, ‘If you want to do
redefined the world of sexual predators. In fact, she it, you’d better get off your butt and apply and do it.’ So
maintains that if not for the Internet, 70 percent of I did.”
these crimes against children would not occur. “In 1950, The application process took a year, during which time
children were still molested, but it wasn’t so easy. The Shumaker was teaching in Texas. “It takes a year to get
Internet predators would not have gone to the effort to in,” she said. “I think it’s a test to see how bad you really
get a mailbox to have child pornography mailed to them want it. That’s why the FBI doesn’t make it easy to get in.
in a brown paper bag. They wouldn’t have chased after If you hang in there for that year, I think that’s the first
their daughter’s friends.” test of getting into the Bureau.”

Becomes Accepted No Comfort Zone


“But today, if you have a random thought about what Special Agent Kathy Shumaker Shumaker was accepted in 1986, and at the age of 29
it would be like to have sex with a 13-year-old, you can (Photo by Martin Barrett of BarrettFam Creations.) was sent for training at the FBI Academy in Quantico,
go online and watch guys do it all the time. They don’t Virginia. “I went from an academic community to one
look like they’re unhappy, so suddenly it must not be where you had to run and shoot,” she said. “I wasn’t
too bad. It becomes accepted. My whole theory of the guy thinks, ‘Hey, I can talk to them. That’s easy.’ But athletic, I had never shot a gun before, and I didn’t know
Internet is that these are men who, had it not been for men have to realize that once they go down that road, anything about the law. I had no comfort zone.”
the Internet, would never have offended. People change they’re going to lose everything. Their kids will not go to The training was rigorous, as Shumaker acknowledges.
on the Internet. Suddenly there is this whole new world. college, and they’re going to lose their homes.” Shumaker “It was a whole new environment,” she said. “I wasn’t who
They’re up all night on the computer and talking to this said there can be no worse combination than a 13-year- I used to be. I felt like Private Benjamin when she said, ‘I
crazed 13-year-old who doesn’t know what’s going on. old girl and a 50-year-old man. “You put them talking to want to be normal again.’ I felt like that every day of my
She’s telling him everything he wants to hear, there’s no each other online, she has no sense of right and wrong, life at Quantico.”
pressure, and they develop a relationship. And yes, they and he doesn’t think of her as a real person.” Her father’s initial sentiment also proved true. “By the
will travel to have sex.” time I got in, we were still considered ‘female agents’ as
Shumaker concurs with Internet information that opposed to just agents,” Shumaker said. “But I owe a lot
states that 90 percent of child sex offenders are middle-
“Every day, at some level, people are tested. to the women who came in 10 years before me. In my
aged, white men. “If you look at your neighbor, that’s what It’s as innocuous as a pretty girl walking by class, there were eight women out of 40. It wasn’t that
an Internet sex offender looks like. And that’s what’s so and the guy deciding to look or not look I wasn’t equal, it was just that I learned early on that as
scary about it. They don’t look like the disgusting guy on a female, you had to work twice as hard to be as good.”
at her. That’s basically what the Internet is, Because the training was hard and challenging, Shumaker
a park bench. They look like people you would trust your
children with. except magnified a thousand times.” said her graduation was rewarding. “When I made it,” she
“I’ve arrested people who are millionaires as well as - FBI Special Agent Kathy Shumaker said, “I felt I had earned it. It wasn’t something that was
people who can barely scrape two dimes together. I’ve given to me.”
arrested everybody except perhaps a funeral director. Shumaker’s first assignment was with foreign
We’ve arrested men when their wives were pregnant. counterintelligence in the Phoenix office. However, she
Some tell me they’re happily married men. We arrested Not Seen as People quickly discovered that her interests lay with another
one man when his daughter was getting ready to go to Making the predator understand the harm he’s caused squad. “The bank robbery squad was like the run and
the prom.” is one of Shumaker’s goals upon an arrest. “With the gun, kick in the door type of fun,” she said. “I loved
Internet predators, I get satisfaction in making them that work so much that I used to take vacation time so I
Benign Beginnings realize what they’ve done, because they don’t look at could work cases with the bank robbery guys. If I knew
For some, the road to becoming a sexual predator may these children as people. I had one guy say to me, ‘Yes, something was coming up, I would work my normal day
begin fairly benignly. For example, Shumaker said, “They I downloaded the series.’ I said, ‘The series that you and then go back and work with them. It was just the
may get to a point in their lives where maybe they’re downloaded is a five-year-old girl whose uncle took her best work around.” Needless to say, Shumaker was soon
having a bad day or get bored, and they start looking at somewhere and molested her for years. She was too transferred to the bank robbery squad.
adult pornography. Depending on where they are in their scared and too terrified to tell anybody. And every day
life and how extreme the adult pornography is, they get that you got your hee-haws looking at her, you victimized “Horrific Case”
bored with it. It doesn’t do it for them anymore. her again. It was a rape and murder case, however, that stays
“If you look at enough adult pornography, someone’s “The subject never thought of her as a person; she was with her from her years in Phoenix. “It was probably in
going to send you something illegal, and you’re going to just a series with a name next to it. Predators need to realize my second year,” recalls Shumaker. “We were called up
get a picture of a 17-year-old. So they start looking at that they’ve changed people’s lives. When people offend, to Flagstaff on a kidnapping, and the girl that had gone
younger children, and once they get satiated at that level, that crime affects that child, the child’s relationships, missing was on vacation with her parents. The girl had
they learn there are chat rooms to talk to these girls. The and future relationships. Even when children have been
- See Internet Predators on page 16
PAGE 6 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL APRIL 2008

VERSUS:
Certainly one of the most controversial
topics the state Legislature will grapple with
Weighing in on "Three Strikes" Legislation
THREE STRIKES IS ONE OF THE STATE’S MOST CONTROVERSIAL ISSUES
than eight years; under three strikes they
would receive 60 years.
reduced sentence. The legal system has
so many loopholes, compromising judg-
Strikes law say it will escalate the prison
population dramatically, and will cause
in its pending session will be the so-called When President Clinton first pro- es, and lawyers administering the state’s the need for more prison facilities to
“Three Strikes” legislation. It is intended posed the federal three strikes law in laws. Until the court system and the pro- be built, courts would be clogged with
to remove repeat offenders from society for 1994, I was very skeptical. It sounded fessionals in the system – cops, judges, more cases going to trial, just to men-
extended periods of time, or life, depending
on the nature of their crimes. Lawmakers, like a slick slogan rather than pru- attorneys, and social services – decide to tion a few concerns. Is this true, and
however, do not agree on specifics of the dent public policy. However, scientific apply the law strictly and fairly it is just are these immediate concerns going to
law. research by criminologists demonstrates another public relations effort. Consis- prevent us from investing in the future
Connecticut already has legislation that those individuals who are convicted tent violent criminals drain society. security of the citizens and their families
allowing increased penalties for multiple three times are very likely to commit So I say pass the strongest Three Strikes in Connecticut? There is a time that it
convictions but leaves the sentencing to the dozens or even hundreds of crimes. For law possible, and just maybe some of it is necessary to spend money to have a
discretion of the court. example, the younger of the two indi- will be used as it should be. It is time we safer future.
State Republicans want new legislation viduals accused in the Cheshire murders stop making the victim the criminal. Will Governor Rell’s Three Strikes
calling for criminals convicted of three violent was convicted only once as an adult yet Submitted by Thomas Daly proposal with no parole pass? No it
felonies to be automatically sentenced to life committed 18 burglaries before being won’t. It is necessary to view a criminal’s
in prison without the possibility of parole.
State Democrats want a judge to review each
caught. Three Strikes Worked violent conviction history. Let judges
case individually at the time of sentencing, At a September 2007 Connecti- in California review the circumstances, let prosecutors
arguing that misdemeanor and juvenile cut Judiciary Committee Informational If the legislators are going to usurp and judges take a fair look at each case.
offenses could be counted as a strike. Hearing, James P. Fox, a California pros- the power of sentencing from the judicial Don’t make it life with no parole auto-
ecutor and president of the National Dis- branch of the state government, then it matically; make it 25 years to life with no
Editor’s Note: trict Attorneys Association, testified that is incumbent that the success of strin- parole. Let violent criminals think about
While the most recent of bills to enact a he vigorously opposed the three strikes gent Three Strikes Laws be evaluated. It life 23 hours a day in a room the size of
Three Strikes Law dies in committee, pro- proposition in 1993, but after working poses the question, How successful has it a closet. Make it known to every convict
ponents of such legislation, mostly minority with the law since 1994, believes it is been in the country’s toughest state, Cal- in prison what the impact of the Three
Republicans and Governor Rell, plan to effective and has accomplished its pur- ifornia, since adopting the Three Strikes Strikes law is once they are released.
amend other bills with similar language pose of incarcerating career criminals. Law in 1994? When you compare the The citizens of Connecticut are
before the session ends at midnight on May I will continue to support Three 10 years before Three Strikes to the 10 compassionate and fair people. But when
7. Some lawmakers think it will be difficult Strikes because science and experience years since, there have been over 2 mil- a violent criminal commits reprehensible
to pass it this year. show it works! lion fewer crimes. crimes over and over and over, then it is
Submitted by Arthur J. O’Neill That includes homicide, rape, robbery, time to lock them up. Three Strikes and
Here are a sample of opinions (State Representative Arthur J. O’Neill assault, burglary, and auto theft. When you are in for a very long time.
expressed by our readers based on the (R) of Southbury has served in the state you consider that fewer crimes means Submitted by Jonathan Banks
issue. House of Representatives since 1988 and is fewer arrests, prosecutions and incarcer-
a practicing attorney.) ations. The National Institute of Justice Three Strikes Not the Answer
Republican Legislator has estimated that the cost of prosecu- There needs to be a greater outcry to
Supports Three Strikes Laws Need to be Applied Fairly tion for every murder is $2,940,000. For change the attitudes of society and the
I voted in favor of the three strikes The three strikes and you’re out means every rape and sexual assault the cost is way people think in terms of someone
proposal during the Legislature’s January nothing if you are a violent convicted $86,500 to take to trial. So for Califor- who made a bad decision resulting in a
22 special session. It applies to about 100 felon with a history of crime. It’s just nia, fewer murders and rapes alone have criminal record. Three strikes is not the
cases per year. Under current law, these another law that is marginally applied, saved over $20 billion dollars.
repeat offenders, on average, serve less and a good lawyer will get you off or a Those that oppose a strict Three - See Versus on page 22

Danbury Police Will Enforce Immigration Laws


By MARK BOUGHTON sibility to elevate concerns to our federal

Illegal immigration has been and will


continue to be a difficult challenge for
Commentary legislators regarding the impact of their
failure to address this critical issue.
I’m honored to have served Danbury
our community, our state, and our nation. expanding beyond anticipated projections our country, but to add another critical as mayor for the past six years. With a
While the federal government has failed because of illegal immigration. There has piece to our law enforcement efforts by population of more than 80,000, our
at one of its fundamental responsibilities, been stress placed on our social services targeting criminals who are exploiting low crime and unemployment rates are
securing our borders, many communities and pressure on our housing stock. We both legal and illegal immigrants. No outstanding. Our schools are exceptional,
across the country have had to struggle have also apprehended a number of indi- one’s civil liberties will be ignored, but and we enjoy a vibrant arts and cultural
with the effect of a failed federal policy. viduals wanted for serious crimes outside recognition of such will not allow us to atmosphere. We have an advancing uni-
Danbury is no different. the United States. A cottage industry equivocate on our responsibility to law versity, a world-class hospital, a business
In Danbury, immigrants have long of manufacturing fake documents has and order. environment that is poised for continued
been a solid and celebrated part of the developed, as well as cases of human As mayor, my responsibilities are to growth, and an abundance of parks and
social and economic fabric. We have trafficking and hundreds of unlicensed, provide a safe and healthy environment recreation areas. This year, Danbury is
citizens from almost every continent, uninsured drivers on our city streets. for all of Danbury’s residents. On Dec. 2, proud to be hosting both the Nutmeg
and more than 49 languages can be After much consideration, Danbury’s 2007, at 4 p.m., I took the oath of office Games—Connecticut’s version of the
heard spoken across the city. We wear our common council approved the federal for the fourth time as mayor. I pledged to Olympics—and the Connecticut Film
diversity as a badge of honor. Immigration and Customs Enforcement uphold all of our laws in a fair and com- Festival.
Illegal immigration is a complicated (ICE) agency’s Access program, which passionate way without regard to the sta- Danbury will continue to celebrate
and emotional issue. Immigration is good will enable several detectives in our police tus, ethnicity, or religion of our residents. its rich diversity and will continue to
for America and for our community. The department to receive training from ICE. It is my job to ensure that our police have be both a lawful community and a wel-
effect of unchecked illegal immigration Once trained, the officers will have the access to training and to the proper tools coming community. A partnership with
on a community, however, is profound. authority to enforce immigration law as necessary to enforce the law. Immigration and Customs Enforcement
A recent investigative report revealed part of any criminal investigation. As mayor, it is my responsibility to will only preserve that and keep our city
that Danbury Hospital spent millions for The intended objective of our part- support federal law enforcement agen- a wonderful place to live, work, and be
treatment of illegal immigrants that was nership is not to deport every person cies when they are working to secure our educated.
not reimbursed. School enrollments are who has sought refuge or a better life in country. Finally, as mayor, it is my respon- Mark Boughton is mayor of Danbury.
APRIL 2008 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL PAGE 7

Commentary DOUG JOHNSTON Publisher


TED HOLCOMB General Manager
JOHN C. PETERSON Interim Editor

The Most Valuable Course Bill Bittar


b.bittar@thejusticejournal.com
Correspondents
Natalie Missakian
n.missiakian@thejusticejournal.com
Leisa Taylor
l.taylor@thejusticejournal.com

I Ever Had in High School


Teale Caliendo Grant Stinchfield Ronald Winter
t.caliendo@thejusticejournal.com g.stinchfield@thejusticejournal.com r.winter@thejusticejournal.com
Pamela Falcigno Frank Szivos
p.falcigno@thejusticejournal.com f.szivos@thejusticejournal.com

Contributing Analysts Art/Production Office Manager


“When I think back on all the crap I learned in high school, it’s a won- Capt. Gary MacNamara Mario J. Recupido Robin Kozakiewicz
der I can think at all. And though my lack of education hasn’t hurt me Richard Meehan, Esq. Proofreader
none, I can read the writing on the wall.” Distribution
Advertising Sales Richard Gabriele - Martha C. Stewart
--Lyrics from “Kodachrome” by Paul Simon © Lisa Levitt Direct Marketing Distribution Intern
Ben Johnston, Intern Evan Wagner
A high school classmate of mine was killed in a crash shortly Advisory Board:
after our graduation ceremonies. The police report said he was driv- Aaron Graham, Vice President Purdue Pharma
Pamela Hayes, Executive Director of
Chief Robin Montgomery, Chief of Brookfield P.D.
Lt. J. Paul Vance, Connecticut State Police
ing over 100 miles an hour when the crash occurred. Some of his Connecticut Police Chiefs Association Kenn Venit, Former Editor, The Justice Journal
closest friends unsuccessfully tried to start a fund in his memory.
Most of the class chose not to contribute because his death was so Editorial & Corporate Headquarters APB Media LLC E-mail: info@thejusticejournal.com
editor@thejusticejournal.com
By KENN VENIT senseless. Maybe that was wrong of us. Perhaps a memorial fund Doug Johnston, CEO Ted Holcomb, COO advertising@thejusticejournal.com
would have helped make generations of students at my alma mater 21 Charles Street, Suite 114 Website: www.thejusticejournal.com
aware of how he died, thus using his death to illustrate a very important lesson in life. Westport, CT 06880 The Justice Journal is published monthly.
Telephone: (203) 454-5910 • FAX (203) 227-0092
I was 16 and a junior in an all-boys public high school when proudly I received my Entire contents Copyright © 2008

driver’s license. Part of my training for that license was a driver education course offered
by my high school. It was the most valuable course I ever had there, or anywhere for that
matter. A family friend also helped me learn how to drive, always emphasizing safety
and warning of the potentially fatal dangers of recklessness and carelessness. Nearly
Events & Notices
a half-century later, maybe with the help of some Divine Intervention, I have never The Melanie Ilene Reiger Memorial Conference
received so much as a scratch in any of the few (and always relatively minor) accidents A conference on “Angry Youth: School & Community Tragedies” will be held April 23-24th
in which I have been involved. at the Maloney Center for Training and Staff Development at 245 Jarvis Street in Cheshire. The
The course was titled, “Defensive Driving.” We learned how to avoid accidents we 12th annual conference, established in memory of Melanie Reiger, is sponsored by the Melanie
might otherwise cause, as well as how to anticipate potential accidents others might Ilene Reiger Memorial Foundation and The Connecticut Department of Correction. Among
cause. I still use all those techniques. the speakers scheduled are Peter Yarrow, member of Peter, Paul & Mary, founder of Operation
Respect, and author of the bestseller “Puff the Magic Dragon”; Carroll Ann Ellis, director of
Back then, seat belts had not yet become mandatory. The AM radios had five push- Victim Services for the Fairfax County Police Department; William Modzeleski, associate assis-
buttons for stations – we would hit a button as soon as a commercial would come on, so tant deputy secretary of the U.S. Dept. of Education Office of Safe and Drug Free Schools; and
we could keep the music playing. There were no cellphones. victims and survivors of the Columbine & Virginia Tech tragedies. For more information and
“Making out” was something we did while parked, not while driving. Maybe there registration see: http://www.melanieriegerconference.com
would be a quick kiss when stopped at a red light. At worst, I recall driving with my
left hand while my right arm was wrapped around my date. (We were always supposed Amber Alert Kids ID Sessions
to keep both hands on the wheel in the “10 o’clock and 2 o’clock” position.) Perhaps I Sponsored by the Danbury Rotary Club, sessions will be held on Saturday, April 12th at the
was a “square,” but there never was any alcohol in the car, or in my system, when I was YMCA of Trumbull, time to be announced. Also at the Grace Baptist Church in Waterbury from
driving or for that matter, when I was a passenger in anyone else’s car. The legal age for 10-1pm on April 26th; and on May 3rd at the South Church in Hartford from 11-3pm.; June
drinking was 18. 7th at Fairfield Middle School in Fairfield from 10-4pm. For more information call Bob Vetter
Today, there is an epidemic of teenage motorists being killed on Connecticut’s streets at (203) 748-1105.
and highways. The Governor’s Task Force on Safe Teen Driving came up with a list of
possible legislative actions to help remedy the situation including raising the age for Triathlon Fundraiser
obtaining a learner’s permit to 16½ years, increasing penalties for moving violations Sunday, June 29th, Kids in Crisis is sponsoring a triathlon to be hosted by the city of Stam-
by teen drivers (as Massachusetts is now doing), increasing behind-the-wheel training ford. The event is being organized to raise funds for the Cos Cob–based Kids in Crisis organiza-
from 20 hours to 50 hours, and having an 11 p.m. driving curfew. tion. The event will include a 1-mile swim, a 24-mile bicycle ride, and a 6.2-mile run that ends in
David Preusser of the Trumbull-based Preusser Research Group, informed the task Columbus Park. There are 500 spots available. For further registration information go to www.
force that crash rates for teens are highest when driving after consuming alcohol, driving kidsincrisis.org and click on the link to the triathlon.
at night, having teen passengers, and in the first few months after receiving a driver’s
license. He also noted that in Connecticut, crash rates are 50 percent higher for 16- and Safe and Sound Class
17-year-olds than for drivers between the ages of 35 and 49. Furthermore, when teen Thursday, May 15th at Greenwich Hospital, Greenwich, 7 pm. The class is designed for
drivers were involved in collisions, about 75 percent of the 16- and 17-year-olds were at parents and grandparents with children between birth and five years of age. It is 2-2 1/2 hours
fault, compared to a 45 percent “fault rate” for drivers ages 35 to 49. in length and covers issues of home safety and car seat safety. The fee for the class is $40 (for
up to 2 people) and registration is available by contacting the Tender Beginnings Department at
The task force blamed television for exacerbating the situation by emphasizing exces-
Greenwich Hospital at (203) 863-3655.
sive speed and reckless driving in commercials – no matter what the “disclaimer” may
say regarding “closed track” or “professional driver.” TV shows and movies also were
cited for glamorizing the kind of behavior behind the wheel that often leads to death Child Passenger Safety Seat Technician Course
and destruction. Such behaviors, especially unsafe passing maneuvers and illegal racing, Tuesday, April 22nd in Waterbury at 8am. The standardized child passenger safety technician
(CPST) certification course is usually 4-5 days long and combines classroom instruction, hands-
have been evident in fatal crashes in recent times involving teenagers in our state and on work with car seats and vehicles, and a community safety seat checkup. Attendance is required
in others. for entire course. For more information contact Pat Zanic at (203) 346-3908.
While the First Amendment protects commercials and entertainment media, obvi- Tuesday, June 3rd the same class will be offered in New Milford, 8am - 5pm. The course will
ously presentations showing reckless behavior when driving may offset efforts in schools run for four days and will give successful participants a national certification as a Child Passen-
and by various organizations to educate teenagers in the proper use of motor vehicles ger Safety Seat Technician. Two fees are associated with this class. The first is $60 to National
– and to fully understand the critical responsibilities involved. Media aside, any driver, Safe Kids which is the certification body. The second is to Fairfield County Safe Kids for $350.
any day, may see such reckless behavior in real life, whether or not art imitates it. Breakfast and lunch are included each day. If you are interested please contact Bob Cordes at
I do not remember the name of my high school driver education teacher, or the name (203) 853-7115.
of that classmate who died at the wheel of a car going over 100 miles an hour shortly
after graduation, but I do remember the lessons each taught me about life…and death. Greenwich Safety Town 2008
The Greenwich Chapter of the American Red Cross will be offering sessions about aware-
(Kenn’s opinions are his own, and not necessarily those of The Justice Journal. He is the immedi- ness and prevention skills for children entering a Greenwich kindergarten program in Fall 2008.
ate past president of the Connecticut Pro Chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists. Kenn Sessions are week long, for half days and will be June 9-13 and June 16-20 at the Greenwich
teaches journalism courses at Quinnipiac University and Southern Connecticut State University.) Boys and Girls Club. Topics covered include automobile, pedestrian, fire, bike, gun, animal,
playground, and water safety, along with information about medicines and poisons, traveling
trains and buses, stranger awareness, and more. Morning sessions meet 9-11:30am and after-
Note: Connecticut’s Department of Motor Vehicles offers a downloadable booklet, noon sessions meet 12:15-2:45pm. The fee for the week long program is $140 and financial aid
“How Parents Can Help Their Teens Become Safe Drivers,” at: www.ct.gov/dmv/lib/ is available. Registration forms are available online at greenwichredcross.org or can be picked
dmv/20/29/Howto.pdf up at the Chapter office.
PAGE 8 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL APRIL 2008

Common Sense, Secure Home Best Burglary Protection


By BILL BITTAR
Correspondent

It is early afternoon in a neighborhood


in any Fairfield County community. The
school bus has already picked up the children
from their bus stop, and most people left for
work long ago.
A car coasts slowly down the road,
passing a brown colonial with a Honda
in the driveway. A light illuminates a
window on the first floor. The house beside
it is closer to the curb. A “Beware of the
Dog” sign is affixed to the front gate.
Then the driver notices three newspapers
stuffed in blue plastic bags scattered on the
driveway of the third house. A thick green
bush pressing against the side of the white
colonial looks like it needs to be trimmed. A
high wooden fence beside it provides ample
privacy from the neighbors to the right.
A smile spreads across the driver’s face,
and he finds a secluded place to park. He
slips on a pair of gloves and picks up a bag
of tools from his passenger seat.
Moments later, the burglary is in
progress.

Connecticut State Police Crime their home wouldn’t be burglarized,” “A lot of it is common sense,” Monroe Police Lt. Sean Cooney said. “The
Analysis Unit’s most recently available Fairfield Police Lt. Michael Walsh said. Police Lt. Brian McCauley said. “If you vast majority of burglars don’t want
statistics indicate that 3,462 burglaries “I think it’s a rude awakening.” look at your house, what do you see? Do confrontation.”
were reported in Fairfield County in Most burglars on the prowl seek out you see open doors and windows? Large All three lieutenants said homeowners
2004, netting an estimated total of $7.1 the easiest targets, and police officers bushes by windows that are easy to hide should stop their mail and newspaper
million worth of stolen property. interviewed for this story say the best behind?” deliveries when going on a long vacation,
“I think often times people that fall defense is having secure locks and an “Burglaries typically occur during the
victim to burglaries probably felt that alarm, and using your head. day when nobody’s home,” Stamford - See Burglary on page 12

Fritz Blau, President

CT's ONLY Licensed


Segway Dealer

155 Research Drive • Stratford, CT 06615


Tel: (203) 380-2600 Fax: (203) 380-2583 Info@BPTHD.com

Fritz Blau, President

575-579 Pacific Street Tel: (203)975-1985 x5


Stamford, CT 06902 Fax: (203)325-4782
www.Fritzshd.com Fritz@hd-stamford.com
APRIL 2008 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL PAGE 9

PCAC Honors Stamford Officer Norwalk Officer Dies in Shooting


Stamford Police Officer Bicycle Helmet Giveaway, Norwalk Police Offi- letters from the public.
Glenn Coppola has been selected following their son’s fatal injury cer Matthew Morelli While assigned to the
by the Police Commissioners from a riding accident. Since was fatally shot while patrol division, he had
Association of Connecticut 1995, with the help of volunteers, on-duty shortly after also served in the Com-
(PCAC) as one of three they have given away more than midnight on March 21, munity Policing Unit as
Connecticut lawmen to receive 24,000 free bicycle helmets to 2008, after calling in well as a member of the
its distinguished public safety area children. a report of suspicious SCUBA Team.
award. Also being recognized by the activity while on patrol. Officer Morelli was
Coppola has served the people organization are Cheshire Police Officers who respond- a veteran of the United
of Stamford for 30 years and has Sergeant Philip Giampietro and ed less than one minute States Marine Corps,
made a significant impact on the Glenn East Haven Police Captain later found him shot honorably discharged in
department and the community Coppola James LaBanca. Giampietro and he was pronounced 1996. He served as an
with his professionalism and has distinguished himself as dead at the scene with a intelligence analyst, held
caring manner, according to a release by a leading educator and law enforcement head wound. Matthew Morelli a security clearance and
the department. He and his wife Peggy advocate in the area of driving while Officer Morelli, 38 was a combat veteran.
are well-known for their involvement in intoxicated. Captain LaBanca is being years old, had served for more than 11 An intensive multi-agency inves-
turning a personal tragedy into a positive honored for his numerous and varied years with pride and distinction and tigation is currently under way. At
for the community when they started contributions as one of the state’s longest- had received numerous departmental time of press, the cause of death is still
the annual Timothy Coppola Memorial serving police officers. commendations and complimentary undetermined.

Hamden Officer Receives State, National Elks Association Awards


Lieutenant Kevin Samperi of the Ham- trying to stop drug traffickers in Street Crime Unit. His work paraphernalia, and firearms, resulting in
den Police Department has been named Mexico, just over 20 years ago. there lead to his placement the arrest and jailing of many high-level
both the state and national recipient of Samperi, nominated by the with the Connecticut State- drug dealers.
the 2007-2008 Enrique S. Camarena Hamden Elks, began his police wide Narcotics Task Force as Samperi, presently assigned as shift
Award by the Connecticut Elks Associa- career at age 19 with the Anso- undercover investigator where commander in the patrol division, has
tion and the Benevolent and Protective nia Police Department. As a he assumed a leadership role as been recognized with numerous unit
Order of Elks of the USA. young rookie he worked with the primary undercover offi- citations and awards, including the New
The award honors law enforcement residents of a housing complex cer. Working in cooperation England Narcotic Enforcement Officers’
officers who have made a significant to remove drugs and drug deal- with state police, FBI, and Association 2003 Special Achievement
contribution in the field of drug preven- ers. With the Hamden police, DEA task forces, the group Award. He also has been cited for his
tion and is named after a young Drug he was assigned to undercover Lt. Kevin seized hundreds of thousands accomplishments in a letter from Con-
Enforcement agent who gave his life work as an investigator with the Samperi of dollars worth of narcotics, necticut Governor Jodi Rell.
PAGE 10 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL APRIL 2008

Safe Drinking Water for Fairfield County


Joint Effort of Federal, State, and Local Agencies
By PAMELA FALCIGNO
Correspondent

The simple act of turning on a fau-


cet to get clean, safe drinking water is
easy to take for granted, but behind
the scenes is a collaborative effort by
federal, state, and local agencies and a
complicated network of local reservoirs,
treatment facilities, and distribution
pipelines working to get it to homes and
businesses in Fairfield County.
Both the adequacy of supply and
purity of public drinking water to over
2.5 million people fall to the supervision
of the Connecticut Department of Pub-
lic Health (DPH), which is responsible
for all aspects of public drinking water
throughout the state.
Federal standards require testing for
safe levels of more than 83 chemical and
bacteriological regulated contaminants
in drinking water, according to Darrell
Smith, who manages the state DPH
Drinking Water Section. Anything “out
of line” during a routine water quality
test is a “tip,” says Smith, pointing to
a potential mechanical problem related
to water treatment, or even a security
breach of the system.
Aquarion Water Company, head-
quartered in Bridgeport, which supplies
drinking water to most of Fairfield
County, conducts daily testing at its var-
ious treatment facilities and reservoirs
for contamination from either natural
or deliberate sources.
Should tests show a particular water
source to be “unsafe” for the general cus-
tomer, Aquarion would take that water
supply off line and use an alternate
supply, says Len DeJong, who as man-
ager of Watershed and Environmental Unwanted visitors are warned by signs and deterred by barbed wire and fences that block water supply areas.
Management is responsible for overall
security at Aquarion. to the state DPH and incidents are for- upon arrival were unable to detain the ters such as hurricanes which can cause
Aquarion has its own police depart- warded to the State Police, Homeland plane, so they contacted the Federal power outages and contamination.
ment with full- and part-time officers Security, and the FBI. Aviation Administration. The water “The public needs to know that secu-
certified by the state. They carry weap- Security alerts will also flow down source was temporarily shut down, the rity and safety of the water is a high
ons and have arrest powers in towns from Homeland Security and may DPH was contacted, and samples were priority,” says Sandford.
where the water authority has respon- result in the issue of a general alert to taken from the area of the landing. Connecticut’s Wastewater Agency
sibility. These include “service towns” all involved agencies. When the plane landed at its destina- Response Network, or WARN, is a vol-
where Aquarion supplies water to cus- Aquarion’s police force works closely tion, state troopers met up with the pilot untary organization comprised of utili-
tomers and where treatment plants are with many local police departments. and discovered it was an innocent act of ties providing assistance to each other
located, and “land towns” in which “They are our eyes and ears,” says refueling. in the form of personnel and resources
watersheds and reservoirs are located. DeJong. The Department of Environ- “It was a good exercise for us,” says during emergencies by means of a pre-
Use of water authority property is by mental Protection and its conservation Sandford, “because we were able to arranged mutual aid agreement. The
permit only, and trespassing is the most officers are also strong allies as they engage the FAA to track the plane, mission, according to the agency’s Web
common security issue. DeJong says the focus their patrol on land where the different law enforcement agencies to site, is to support and promote state-
officers are good at judging innocence reservoirs are located. be there when they landed, and health wide emergency preparedness, disaster
from a deliberate act of trespass. In the The Connecticut Department of department and Metropolitan District response, and mutual assistance matters
event of repeat trespass violations, police Emergency Management and Home- Commission to do testing of water. All for public and private water and waste-
have powers to enact fines and issue land Security acts as a coordinating tests came back negative, showing that water utilities.
arrest warrants. agency for all those involved. That role the water was safe to drink.” With renewed emphasis since 9/11,
“Nothing goes unchecked, if you was illustrated in an incident related by All state and law enforcement agen- water companies are communicating
will,” says Smith. On a day-to-day basis, Deputy Commissioner Wayne Sand- cies are aware of any potential vulner- and emphasizing to customers the need
Aquarion is diligent in monitoring ford. ability to public drinking water supplies. to contact police or the local water
facilities by limiting access with chain A pontoon plane made an unauthor- Groups meet on a periodic basis to authority should they see suspicious
link fences, surveillance cameras, and ized landing on one of the Metropoli- discuss security issues, threats, and vul- activity near public water supply facili-
other devices. tan District reservoirs serving Greater nerabilities to public drinking water sys- ties or reservoirs.
Aquarion’s chief of Law Enforcement Hartford, and onlookers described what tems. Full-scale and desktop drills are For more information go to www.
and Security, Ralph Fensore, says that appeared to be liquid being poured into conducted for worst case scenarios for ctwarn.org.
breaches in security must be reported the water. Police were contacted but not only terrorist acts, but natural disas- (p.falcigno@thejusticejournal.com)
APRIL 2008 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL PAGE 11

What If…?
By CAPT. GARY MACNAMARA
Fairfield Police Department
Special to The Justice Journal

School Violence Continues to Teach Us Painful Lessons


What if the word “Columbine” was only of school violence happened again, in at least
the name of a high school in Colorado? Prior seven separate incidents, in 2001. One of the
to Tuesday, April 20, 1999, it was, but that worst that year occurred in March, when two
was the day that changed “Columbine” from were killed and 13 injured at Santana High
just a name, to a word synonymous with School in California.
school violence. In 2002, the most violent incident occurred
In these days it has been used as a verb, as in Germany, where 16 were killed and 10
in “I will ‘columbine’ this school.” It has been were injured. In fact, every year since Col-
used as an adjective: “I will commit a ‘colum- umbine, at least one significant incident of
bine-like’ attack,” and as a noun. school violence has occurred in the United
That change was caused by two Colum- States. There are also less publicized events
bine students who killed 12 students and a that occur in schools around the country
teacher in a devastating and shocking attack. everyday. According to the Institute of Edu-
The attack would change how our nation, and cation Services for the U.S. Department of
the world, would think about school safety Education, in 2005 through 2006, 78 percent
and school violence and the way in which law of schools experienced one or more violent
enforcement would deal with future incidents incidents of crime.
in a school atmosphere. The major focus on What if the devastating incidents of school
lockdown procedures today came from study- violence continued to happen? Could it get
ing the events at Columbine High School. It worse? It did. On April 16th, 2008, members
also sparked a huge debate on the effects of of the Virginia Tech community plan to
video games, violent movies, bullying, and school cliques Eight days after the Columbine shooting, the first fatal remember the first anniversary of the shooting rampage
in our high schools, and the role any of these may have high school shooting in Canada in 20 years occurred. A on their campus. Thirty-three were killed and countless
played in the attack. Columbine lingers as a painful ref- month later, six students were injured at Heritage High others were injured. The killing started in a dorm room,
erence point in every instance of school violence since. School in Conyers, Georgia. The remainder of 1999 where two students were killed, and continued several
What if it happened again? What if, after all the ended with at least three more school violence incidents hours later in an academic building, where the rest of the
lessons learned, all the preventative procedures imple- resulting in one death and eight injuries. The year 2000 victims were attending classes.
mented, and all the pain felt, another incident of school was no better. In February a 6-year-old girl in Michi- Once again, as in “Columbine,” “Virginia Tech” has
violence occurred? After all the attention and discussion, gan was shot and killed by a 6-year-old classmate in an become synonymous with school violence. Student
could it happen again? elementary school. At least four more students were
It has, maybe more than we would like to admit. killed and two injured in four other incidents. Incidents - See What if on page 20

������� ������ ���� ���� � ���������� ��


���� � ����
SCAP CHRYSLER JEEP - THE WAY CAR BUYING SHOULD BE
WRANGLER �������
SEASON IS NOW OPEN
��� ��� ��� ������ ������ ���
2008

��������
EASY TO GET TO:
103 Exit 44 Merritt
Route 58 South 2.8 miles

360 - 430 Tunxis Hill Road


Fairfield

GET YOURS TODAY 384-0005 ext 3102


Easy to get to...
Exit 44 Merritt, Rte 58 South 2.8 miles
PAGE 12 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL APRIL 2008

Burglary–
Continued from page 8

because the buildup is a telling sign of it advertises desirable items such as


inactivity. power equipment and ATVs, McCauley
said.
Grass and Snow Indicators He said people with alarms often
“If the grass is not cut or if it snowed make the mistake of shutting them off
three days ago and nobody shoveled when they go to bed.
the driveway, those are indications that “You can disable the motion part of it
no one is present—a green light for a so it’s just an outside alarm for exterior
burglar,” Cooney said. doors and windows,” McCauley said. “If
Walsh agreed with Cooney’s people have questions about how to use
assessment, adding, “Anything you can their alarm, they should contact their
do primarily to make it so your home alarm provider.”
doesn’t appear invitingly vacant would When someone breaks into a home
help.” and attacks or robs its occupants, such
Cooney suggests placing something as in the deadly tragedy in Cheshire, it
in the front yard that you would not miss is called a home invasion, according to
if it disappeared, like a tricycle, so your Cooney, who added that such crimes
house looks more active. are rare.
“If you leave a car in the driveway A rare type of burglar, who tries to
rather than in the garage, it will look sneak in and sneak out when people are
like someone’s home,” he said, offering home, is called a cat burglar, Cooney said.
another tip. Other times, a burglar and a homeowner
McCauley recommends that may cross paths because the burglar
homeowners install outdoor lights with mistakenly thinks nobody is home.
motion sensors so they know when “If you hear someone downstairs, lock
someone is in their yard at night, and so yourself in your bedroom, dial 911, and
a would-be burglar may think someone stay on the phone,” McCauley said.
is home when they’re actually away. “Confronting a burglar is a personal
decision,” Cooney said. “But I would
When You Are Away not advise risking your life for personal
Walsh said all first-floor windows property. Do you want to risk your life
should be shut and locked. “If windows over a piece of jewelry?”
are closed or locked, a burglar would “I would not advise a physical
probably have to break the glass,” he said. confrontation with an unknown person,”
“We sometimes get calls of breaking glass he continued. “Obviously, it’s a different
when neighbors are alerted. Burglars are story if he attacks you or threatens your
sometimes apprehended by way of a children.”
quick response.” Whether they hear a suspicious noise
Cooney said a neighbor could be and think someone has broken into
asked to watch your place. But in most their home, or see a suspicious person or
cases, he added, you should tell only vehicle in their neighborhood, Walsh said
close family members or friends, people citizens should never feel uncomfortable
you can trust, that you are going on a about calling police to report it.
trip.
Cooney explained how personal Protecting Your Valuables
information could easily fall into the No matter how vigilant people are
wrong hands. “The guy who runs the at protecting their homes, burglars
dry cleaner might be a good guy,” he will still succeed from time to time.
said, “but he may have a kid who does McCauley suggests keeping a list of
deliveries who tells a friend.” valuables, increasing the likelihood that,
Lock your door and check to make following a burglary, they may one day
sure it is secure when going out, Walsh be returned.
said, adding that while no lock will “If you are able to engrave them
make your home a fortress, a deadbolt is and put an identifying mark on them,
always a good idea. they’re easier to identify if they’re stolen,”
“Deadbolts that actually enter into McCauley said.
the doorjamb—the framing surrounding However, he said homeowners should
the door—are much more resilient to never use numbers from sensitive
forcible entries,” he said. information, such as a Social Security
Just as breaking glass to climb through number.
a window could give a burglar away, “If you have valuables, it’s not a bad
Walsh said such a deadbolt would make idea to videotape the rooms in your house
the intruder use a higher—and louder— with everything in place,” McCauley said.
degree of force. “Insurance companies recommend that.”
McCauley said not to hide a spare key But if the proper measures are taken
outside, because burglars are aware of to discourage burglars from striking,
the practice. But Walsh is not dead set Walsh believes most homeowners will
against it as long as the key is not hidden never have to deal with their insurance
in an obvious place. companies.
“I think if we take the real
What if I’m Home? commonsensical steps to make sure our
There are also precautions that should homes are not easy prey, there’s a good
be taken when you are home, according chance we can live burglary free,” he
to McCauley. Do not leave garage doors said.
open, even when you are home, because (b.bittar@thejusticejournal.com)
APRIL 2008 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL PAGE 13

that someone answer the phone when


the call is made for help, rather than who
that person may be.
It can easily cost $5,000 just to get an
A successful defense of appearance in a serious criminal or civil
case. But appearing on behalf of a client
a person charged with is just the beginning of a long process.
Case preparation can include
a major crime can cost exhaustive interviews with witnesses
well upwards of $50,000. for the defense and the prosecution,
document reviews, and preparation for
testimony.
Defense attorneys often rely on former
police detectives or FBI agents for
private investigations because their law
enforcement backgrounds ensure they
will “think like a prosecutor.” Homicides
and sexual assault cases are typical of
those where a private investigator is
essential.
It is important to find out before
going to trial if there are flaws in a
witness’s testimony or if the story has
changed from one interview to another.

Logistical Problems
In addition, lawyers can’t do much
of the pretrial questioning themselves
because they would become a witness in
their own case if a witness flip-flopped.
The logistical problems associated with
that scenario are extensive, since another
lawyer would have to take over the case.
There are, however, ways to reduce
the financial impact of adequate legal
representation, since many of the driving
factors behind high costs are ingrained in
our present system.
Representation– advertisements. But, the ads don’t tell
a potential client everything that is
necessary to know before deciding on
For instance, once a case goes to trial
it is not uncommon to spend two weeks
Continued from page 1 whom to hire. on jury selection. In the present system,
the firm will charge to pay all of its costs occasion he has dropped the fee to the Many lawyers advocate testing and jurors are called to court only for one
associated with defending clients. A $2,000 range. certification by the National Board day.
typical law firm not only has attorneys “I don’t charge that much if a person of Trial Advocacy, which maintains a In that day they first go through a
on staff but paralegals, secretaries, and is in a bad spot,” he says. Walsh notes database of lawyers that can be narrowed basic orientation period and then another
clerical staff, too. All of their salaries that people who are convicted of driving by type of practice and specialties, all instruction period on the case they may
and benefits, as well as overhead such as under the influence of alcohol or drugs online. be judging. Jurors may not be questioned
basic utilities, must be paid in addition also are going to lose their driver’s license, “Without a board certification it is hard on their qualifications to serve on a
to the salary of the lawyer assigned to which may have an additional financial to decide who to hire,” Meehan says. He particular case until nearly 11 a.m. Then
a case. impact for wage earners. supports state laws that require specialty the voir dire process of interviewing
A murder case can involve as many Criminal cases involving misdemeanors certifications as a means of consumer individual jurors who are brought in to
as 100 hours of research costs incurred or lower-level felonies will naturally cost protection in the legal profession. the courtroom one at a time can take
before it even goes to jury selection. In more than a DUI case, because they Nonetheless, even defendants of up to an hour per person for both the
addition, depending on the case, legal usually involve more court appearances. average means who are charged with prosecution and defense.
firms may have to hire the services The price range in those cases can be serious crimes can end up so deep in a Selecting sufficient jurors for a 12-
of a private investigator and other wide depending on the nature of the financial hole that they ultimately have member panel, plus two alternates, can
professionals to bolster the defense. case. public defenders handling their cases. be an exhaustive exercise. In addition,
That doesn’t mean that lawyers are the defense lawyer is working on the
only out for the buck and don’t care about Simple First Offense, $5,000 Most Don’t Have Means case, and thus billing the client, both
the financial status of their clients. A first-offender who has made Patrick Culligan, managing attorney before and after court.
Take Attorney Joseph Walsh, for a mistake and is remorseful still may for the Capital Defense Unit of the Jury section can take four full days in
instance, of the Bridgeport law firm end up paying up to $5,000 for quality Division of Public Defender Services the courtroom. Trials themselves can run
Cohen and Wolf, which handles a representation. But, as the case becomes says that in most cases involving serious two or three weeks for serious charges,
wide range of legal issues ranging from more difficult and defending the client crimes, and virtually all capital felonies, and again, the lawyer must prepare for
appellate law to criminal and personal becomes more complex, requiring more the bail is set at $1 million. each day of testimony.
injury to commercial litigation cases. court appearances, the fees steadily climb Most defendants can’t afford that bail. Defense attorneys can spend days
upward. “Even if they own a home, they don’t preparing each individual question
DUI Case Averages $2,500 The truth is, when charged with a have enough equity” to make that bail, for each witness, leaving nothing to
Walsh, the resident attorney in serious crime, most people can’t afford a Culligan notes. As a result, the accused chance. There are very specific rules
Cohen and Wolf ’s Danbury office, has private firm, and most don’t fall within stays in jail, which usually means loss for examining and cross-examining
been known to be a bit soft-hearted at the financial guidelines to qualify for a of jobs and loss of income, and then the witnesses, in addition to pitfalls that can
times. Walsh estimates that a first-time public defender. case is referred to the public defender. trip up the unwary trial attorney.
offender who seeks representation for a But the average middle-class client Not only is it outside the ability of There also is enormous preparation
driving under the influence charge can still can obtain highly competent legal most people to afford high-end trial time, as the defense attorney must review
expect to pay an average of $2,500 before representation if care is taken to research attorneys, most consumers don’t spend the state’s evidence and prepare witnesses
the case is completed. That could go as the field. Most law firms take out ads in much time researching qualifications for testimony. All in all, a successful
high as $3,500, however, depending on professional publications and telephone when they are in trouble. A lawyer is defense of a person charged with a major
the lawyer handling the case and the directories, many have Web sites, and a lawyer, the saying goes, and when a crime can cost well upwards of $50,000.
circumstances. But Walsh said that on some have regular television and radio defendant is in jail it is more important (r.winter@thejusticejournal.com)
PAGE 14 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL APRIL 2008

Bridgeport Harbor–
Continued from page 1
sky, and trains had stopped running or Club, and the PS&G power plant.
were on limited schedules. The exception What’s more, ships and barges hauling
that day was the ferry steaming into coal and gasoline and oil tankers use the
the Bridgeport Harbor, which was still harbor waters. Approximately five million
open and running. It was the only link tons of cargo are shipped into the harbor
between New York and Connecticut annually. Derecktor Shipyard, one of the
and one of the limited options to leave premier builders of private yachts and
Manhattan. Even the U.S. Coast Guard high-speed ferries, also generates a great
allowed foreign-flag vessels to dock in deal of maritime traffic in the harbor.
Bridgeport on 9/11, and cruise ships In Riccio’s opinion, BPA has spent the
requested to offload passengers who grant money wisely on state-of-the-art
were stranded at sea with no other ports security equipment and software, which
open to them. has also allowed it to put more stringent
Since then, the BPA, a quasi-public security measures and procedures in place.
entity that has jurisdiction over the entire Some of those security improvements
Bridgeport Harbor, has taken significant are:
steps to beef up this vital water link, • A second high-speed police boat,
applying for Homeland Security grants. operated by the Bridgeport Police
In three rounds of federal funding Department Marine Unit, is capable
beginning in 2003, the BPA has received of speeds up to 50 miles per hour.
about $5 million to improve harbor area The patrol boat is fully equipped with
security. security and communication devices Bridgeport Harbormaster Joseph Savino on patrol in the harbor.
The result today is Bridgeport Harbor for patrolling the harbor and Long
has become a highly secured port, featuring Island Sound;
• A command center of monitors based Harbor, has played a major role in helping stranded boaters. Our new boat is already
the latest high-tech security equipment
at the ferry terminal and headquarters to procure Homeland Security grants for paying for itself.”
and a greatly reduced vulnerability to
of the BPA, to survey the harbor the BPA. He places port security as a Fortunately, there have been no
terrorist attacks. As Riccio pointed out,
area; high priority for Connecticut. terrorist attacks, but Savino, a retired
the BPA owed it to the region and
• High-intensity lighting and fencing “Our waterways are crucial to the Bridgeport police officer, and the
the more than one million people who
around the ferry terminal; economy in our region, so we need to Bridgeport Police Marine Unit have
annually travel the Bridgeport & Port
• Sophisticated sonar equipment for take every step we can to keep them responded to several distress calls with
Jefferson Steamboat Company ferry that
monitoring the harbor bottom as well secure. The federal funding received has the new 24-foot Boston Whaler. Savino
lands at the Water Street dock located at
as the submerged hulls of tankers helped the Bridgeport Port Authority recalls that the special dive door in the
the waterfront.
docking in the harbor; improve their surveillance and detection bottom of the boat allowed the police
“Bridgeport Harbor is a vital and
• Explosive-detecting devices to scan capabilities to help keep the port safe,” to rescue two windsurfers, who were in
active port,” Riccio said. “Between the
vehicles using the ferry as well as Shays said. distress and floating out to sea. Because
commercial boats coming in here and the
portable barriers to contain vehicles. Bridgeport Harbormaster Joseph one windsurfer had a severe shoulder
ferry passengers, we need to make our
“Our security system is so sensitive, Savino, who works along with the injury, the police were able to maneuver
harbor as secure as possible. We’ve been
it can detect the difference between an Bridgeport Police Department Marine him onto the boat through the dive
fortunate to receive Homeland Security
intruder and the wind blowing,” Riccio Unit to keep the harbor area secure, says door.
grants that have allowed us to create as
said. “This allows us to make the entire it is a demanding job but he is relieved “We're still in training with a lot of
safe an area as possible.”
maritime complex safe from any security to have the state-of-the-art security our equipment,” Savino said. “But we
It’s a big job protecting the Bridgeport
threats.” equipment to keep a vigilant eye on the can see how the sonar equipment gives
Harbor area that stretches for a couple of
U.S. Representative Christopher harbor. us a much better understanding of what
miles and includes several businesses,
Shays of Connecticut, a member of “We're happy to have all the security the bottom of the harbor is really like.
such as Derecktor Shipyard, Coastline
the Homeland Security Committee who equipment that we can,” Savino said. We plan to conduct a study that will
Terminal for general cargo, lobster and
represents the Fourth Congressional “This is a busy port area. We also assist map out the exact depth of the entire
oyster fishing companies, several private
District, which encompasses Bridgeport the Customs Department and the Coast harbor.”
marinas, the Fairfield University Rowing
Guard with patrolling and helping While the BPA has installed state-
of-the-art equipment with its federal
funding, there is always more that can
be done. Riccio is aware that security is a
relative term, and no place is impervious
to a sophisticated terrorist attack. The
BPA plans to continue to apply for
additional federal grants in the future
to keep pace with the latest equipment
improvements and to accommodate the
changing face of the waterfront.
The BPA views the harbor as an
alternative transportation mode to the
highway and trains with a tremendous
potential to grow in the future. To
keep the port thriving as an important
economic development tool for the
Fairfield County region demands that it
be secure.
“We've installed the best equipment
to create as secure an environment as
possible,” Riccio said. “It's been money
well spent that closes any gaps in our
security and makes us significantly less
vulnerable to terrorists' attack or natural
disaster. Our port is in a key strategic
area. We're taking the necessary steps
now to make our future more secure.”
(Photo by Robert J. Jiménez) (f.szivos@thejusticejournal.com)
APRIL 2008 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL PAGE 15

for 15 minutes.”
Elder Abuse– DeMattia says this isolation makes elders
easy targets for stranger predators. “When you
FACT SHEET - NATIONAL CENTER ON ELDER ABUSE:

Elder Abuse
Continued from page 1 are looking forward to a telemarketing call
number of elder abuse crimes will only increase," because you don’t have any relatives or nieces
or nephews or sons or daughters calling you,

Prevalence and Incidence


DeMattia observed.
DeMattia says the course of elder abuse gets it’s pretty sad. These people end up being the
progressively worse, and if discovered, the elder victims with whom I work because their own
usually tries to shield the abuser from punish- families aren’t paying attention to them or
ment. It is not only because the victim fears the people that are out there preying on the No one knows precisely
the abuser; shame and guilt also play into the seniors.” DeMattia adds, “(Some) seniors are on how many older Americans
reluctance to admit what’s going on. It some- an island and when they get abused they don’t are being abused, neglected,
times follows a lifelong pattern of protecting know where to turn or what to do.” or exploited.
the abuser, who is usually a child or family Deak says keeping the elderly connected to While evidence accumu-
member. society is vital. “There’s a whole variety of ser- lated to date suggests that
“The saddest part is, the son rips off the mom vices out there to assist the person from being many thousands have been
and the mom ends up broke. She is now forced isolated,” she explains. “When people are at harmed, there are no official
to move in with the son…and that can escalate risk in the community, and that could include national statistics for several
to physical abuse,” explained DeMattia. being quite frail or having mobility impair- reasons:
“Sadly…about 75 percent of the time it’s a ments, there are programs that can assist people • Definitions of elder abuse
family member and usually involves embezzle- in their homes. One of them is the Connecticut vary. It is difficult to pinpoint
ment,” DeMattia said. “They have power of Home Care Program for Elders. If the person exactly what actions or inac-
attorney or conservatorship and they end up is eligible, a case manager can go out and do tions constitute abuse, and
taking the money for their own use…leaving the an assessment with the individual and/or with the problem remains greatly
parents destitute. It’s almost insulting because the family…(about) what kinds of services are hidden.
it tends to be people in my age bracket, 45, needed.” • State statistics vary widely
and they tell me, ‘I didn’t steal the money…my In addition, Deak notes, senior centers are as there is no uniform report-
parents are leaving it to me in their will, and it’s focal points in many communities, meals on ing system.
mine.’ They justify it as their inheritance.” wheels are offered, churches minister to the • Comprehensive national
DeMattia says he’s heard that excuse so often elderly, and in many communities adult daycare data are not collected. In
his department coined the phrase, "accelerated is also an option. the absence of a large-scale,
inheritance." DeMattia’s responsibilities include educating nationwide tracking system,
“And, they will literally look at you and say, the elderly about those services, so he regularly studies of prevalence and incidence conducted over the past few years by
‘That’s my money. My mom said I could use it.’ addresses senior groups across the state. independent investigators have been crucial in helping us to understand the
I say, ‘Yes, maybe to take fifty dollars or so…not “They respond,” he says. “You see in their magnitude of the problem.
to re-mortgage her house twice and lose it.’ The eyes how appreciative they are that someone is
victims,” DeMattia says, “end up on Title 19, paying attention. I think a lot have the feeling
which means the taxpayers subsidize them, or in
a nursing home, or living hand-to-mouth.”
that they are forgotten, and we get a lot of satis-
faction in our job because we get to help.” What Do the Studies Say?
Such financial and emotional devastation But most often that help comes too late to
also impacts an elder’s physical health. Victims salvage the elders' savings. Prevalence
often make themselves physically ill after being “We’ve arrested a lot of people who have • According to the best available estimates, between 1 and 2 million
robbed and wind up in a nursing home to live gone to jail," DeMattia says. “But I can count Americans age 65 or older have been injured, exploited, or otherwise mis-
out their last years. on one hand the times we’ve gotten their money treated by someone on whom they depended for care or protection.
DeMattia decries what he sees as a change back. By the time my department gets involved, (Elder Mistreatment: Abuse, Neglect and Exploitation in an Aging
in our society in which we isolate or warehouse the money is gone. Even if the guilty party goes America. 2003. Washington, DC: National Research Council Panel to
seniors. “When I grew up we were in neighbor- to jail, I’d much prefer getting the money back, Review Risk and Prevalence of Elder Abuse and Neglect.)
hoods where everyone knew everyone else and so (the elder) doesn’t have to worry about pay- • Data on elder abuse in domestic settings suggest that 1 in 14 incidents,
everyone helped everyone else. If someone got ing the rent or getting medicine. All I can do is excluding incidents of self-neglect, come to the attention of authorities.
laid off you brought food over…you got your put the person in jail. Then they come out, end (Pillemer, Karl, and David Finkelhor. 1988. “The Prevalence of Elder
kids looked after. (But) as everyone became up on probation, and pay $50 or $100 a month Abuse: A Random Sample Survey,” The Gerontologist, 28: 51-57.)
more affluent, no one wanted to know anything. back to the victim for five years" – not much • It is estimated that for every one case of elder abuse, neglect, exploita-
It’s all about privacy. We don’t want to have help to those at the end of their lives. tion, or self-neglect reported to authorities, about five more go unreported.
grandma and grandpa and uncles living with us. DeMattia says an alert public can help inter- (National Elder Abuse Incidence Study. 1998. Washington, DC: National
We want to do our own thing so we end up put- vene in cases before it’s too late. Center on Elder Abuse at American Public Human Services Association.)
ting them in assisted living or a nursing home. “You know how everyone fears the nosy • Estimates of the frequency of elder abuse range from 2 percent to 10
And everyone feels like they are heroes when neighbor? Well, I like the nosy neighbor. percent based on various sampling, survey methods, and case definitions.
they call mom or dad or grandma or grandpa Someone looking out his or her window sees (Lachs, Mark S., and Karl Pillemer. October 2004. “Elder Abuse,” The
something. We’ve developed cases from situ- Lancet, Vol. 364: 1192-1263.)
ations like that,” he says. In addition, as with • Current estimates put the overall reporting of financial exploitation at
Types of Neglect and Abuse child abuse and neglect, there is a list of only 1 in 25 cases, suggesting that there may be at least 5 million financial
mandated reporters for elder abuse, including abuse victims each year.
There are several classifications of elder doctors, nurses, nursing home staff, patient (Wasik, John F. 2000. “The Fleecing of America’s Elderly,” Consumers
abuse outlined by the Prudence Crandall Center advocates, and clergy. Digest, March/April.)
for Women in New Britain: DeMattia loves his work, because he can see
• Passive Neglect: The unintentional failure the difference it makes in the lives of seniors. Incidence
to fulfill a caretaking obligation. “It’s the best job I could do because of the group • In 1996, nearly 450,000 adults aged 60 and over were abused and/or
• Active Neglect: The intentional failure to we serve. We in this department get a lot of neglected in domestic settings. Factoring in self-neglect, the total number of
fulfill caretaking obligations. satisfaction knowing that we get to help.” incidents was approximately 551,000.
• Psychological Abuse: The infliction of men- If you suspect domestic elder abuse and you (National Elder Abuse Incidence Study. 1998. Washington, DC: National
tal anguish, including name-calling and ignoring are in Connecticut, call 1-888-385-4225; out- Center on Elder Abuse at American Public Human Services Association.)
the senior, and behavior that is demeaning, of-state, call 1-800-203-1234. If you suspect • In 2000, states were asked to indicate the number of elder/adult reports
insulting, and humiliating to the senior. abuse in a nursing home, residential facility, or received in the most recent year for which data were available. Based on
• Material & Financial Abuse: The illegal assisted living community, contact Connecti- figures from 54 states and territories, the total number of reports was
or unethical exploitation of funds, property, or cut’s Long Term Care Ombudsman Program 472,813.
other assets of an older person for personal at 1-866-388-1888. If you would like informa- (A Response to the Abuse of Vulnerable Adults: The 2000 Survey of
gain. tion concerning services and programs to assist State Adult Protective Services. 2003. Washington, DC: National Center
• Physical Abuse: The infliction of physical seniors and their families, call your local Area on Elder Abuse.)
pain, including pushing, shoving, restraining, Agency on Aging at 1-800-994-9422. (National Ombudsman Reporting System Data Tables. 2003. Washing-
slapping, and punching. (t.caliendo@thejusticejournal.com) ton, DC: U.S. Administration on Aging.)
PAGE 16 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL APRIL 2008

Educating and Talking With Children


is the Best Protection from Internet Predators
Anyone with a computer is a potential make a comment like you grew up loving the
target of Internet predators, but the best way Beatles, and it goes right over their head. Of
to protect your children is by educating them, course, if you loved the Beatles, you’ve got
believes FBI Special Agent Kathy Shumaker. to be over 13, but they’re not thinking like
The profile for a child victim defies that.”
description, but there are conditions that Because of freedom of the press, cyber-
make them vulnerable. “I can’t tell you how sex — or just talking about sex online — is
many homes I’ve sat in and felt like I was in not criminal, but Shumaker believes it has
my own home,” Shumaker said. “Their house harmful effects. “When you do that with a
is cleaner than I’ve kept my house. There’s a 13- or 14-year-old girl, it breaks down their
stay-at-home mom and a hard-working dad. inhibitions,” she said. “So the next time
And I would say there are just as many boy they’re talking to somebody, they’ve already
victims as there are girls. I don’t think it’s been exposed to thoughts and ideas. They’re
accurate that the vast majority of victims are more sexually aware and aggressive. So
girls, based on what I’ve seen here. I think cyber-sex is still a subtle way of victimizing
girls may be more reported because there is the kids.”
not the homosexual aspect.” Possession of child pornography is another
Shumaker, a 22-year FBI veteran who way to victimize children. “With possession,”
recently completed a nine-year assignment Shumaker said, “you’re looking at pictures of
as coordinator of the Computer Crimes Task children who did nothing other than maybe
Force in New Haven, added that a victim is have an uncle or a neighbor or a friend
often someone who tends to be a risk-taker, victimize them. It’s not just possession,
has low self-esteem, feels he or she doesn’t because every time those pictures are up, that
have any friends, or can’t talk to his or her child is being victimized again. And every
parents. day, some old guy looks at those pictures and
“But you have to realize that it’s not gets off on that child being molested.”
necessarily that every day they have low self- Shumaker says that the most rewarding
esteem,” she said. “They could be online one (and also the hardest) cases are the ones
day and they’ve failed a test or had their best where she is dealing with the victims. “So
friend say, ‘That’s an ugly dress’ or ‘I don’t often,” she said, “they are 13- or 14-year-old
want to talk to you anymore.’ And that is girls, and they feel so responsible. They feel
the day that John Smith is out there and says, guilty. They don’t realize that this guy, who
‘Hey, I’ll be your friend.’ ultimately they had sex with, planned for
“That girl could be a perfect A-student months and was online looking for anybody
every other day of the week, and suddenly, the who would bite. They fall in love with these
girl is this guy’s goal now. His job is to get guys and want to marry them. These girls
her to meet him. Some will take months and don’t see that it was somebody’s mission to
some will do it in a matter of weeks.” persuade them to have sex.”
To try and catch a predator, Shumaker That mission can be well-planned. “One
would often go online with a fake name and thing the bad guy will do is send adult
pose as a girl. “Everybody makes it sound like pornography first, and if the kid says, ‘Hey,
it’s hard,” she said. “But these guys, once they that’s disgusting’ or never talks to him again,
get in that mode, they don’t care. Once they
get in that mindset, you could accidentally - Continued on next page

Internet Predators– boys to engage in.


“But what was really bizarre is that he
had initially duped this family in Iowa
prostitution cases. Shumaker said she
made the move in the fall of 2007 to
take a break from the pace of eight years
Continued from page 5
into believing that he was an alien and with the Computer Crimes Task Force.
gotten up in the morning and told her he did. The girl didn’t ask to be targeted, he was going to make them wealthy “I tend to get extremely emotionally tied
mom she was riding her bike over to the and that parent did som ething any of us by going up on the towers of financial to the cases, and I think you sometimes
stables. And mom says, ‘I’ll meet you would have done. There was nothing she buildings and taking all the pennies when have to,” Shumaker said. “If you don’t
over there.’ So mom gets in her truck, could have done to prevent that.” people would wire money. And these have any sense of emotion toward the
waves to her daughter, and drives to the In 1991, Shumaker was routinely people bought it! So he was living in cases, I don’t think you should be doing
stables. Well, the girl never makes it transferred to Chicago, where she worked their basement for a year and a half. them. But I think you need to take a
there. Mom comes back and sees the on domestic terrorism, money laundering, They’re thinking he’s making the money, break every now and then because you
bike lying in the grass.” undercover drugs, bank robberies, and and all he’s really doing is talking to boys can become ineffective if you’re always
The case made a huge impact on violent crimes. It was there she encountered online.” The family eventually found in the panic mode.” She says she looks
Shumaker. “It was horrific,” she said. a kidnapping that was probably her most some child pornography in the basement forward to the different pace and cases in
“The mom hadn’t done anything wrong. bizarre case. A 13-year-old boy who and demanded that the subject move her newest role with the Bureau.
It just turned out that day that somebody didn’t show up for school had gotten on a out.” At age 51, Shumaker has five more
had gotten up and said, ‘I’m going to rape bus with a stranger. It was subsequently Shumaker worked in Chicago until years with the FBI, where the mandatory
and murder a little girl.’ And that’s what learned that the boy had been talking to 1999 when she transferred to Connecticut. retirement age is 56. She confesses she has
the subject online for about nine months. After a year as the coordinator for a gang no idea what she will do after retirement,
task force in Hartford, Shumaker was although, of course, her job as a mother
Warning Signs for Victims Satanic Sex Rituals asked to head up the Computer Crimes will continue. Even now, Special Agent
“We got the boy off the bus in Task Force in New Haven. “As I go Shumaker has her priorities. “I never say
• Risk-taker. Kentucky,” Shumaker recalls. “The guy through it historically now,” she said, “my to my son that I have to go to work and
• Low self-esteem, at times. had been taking him to Florida, where whole career has been a foreshadowing of it’s more important than he is,” she said.
• Feel they lack friends. the subject was living with another boy where I ended up.” “I always try to make my son the most
who was a runaway. The subject had these Where Shumaker recently landed important.”
• Can’t talk to parents. satanic sexual rituals that he wanted the was back in Meriden, focusing on child (l.taylor @thejusticejournal.com)
APRIL 2008 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL PAGE 17

Educating Children–
Continued from previous page
he goes on to the next person. But 70 he’s in the fourth grade, he doesn’t roll
percent of the kids don’t do that. Some his eyes and think I’m crazy. If you teach
of the kids look at it and say ‘Whatever’ them from day one that the Internet has
or ‘Why are you sending this to me?’ Or issues, and there’s good and bad on the
they may want to be nice and not hurt Internet, they learn that as well as learning
somebody’s feelings. The minute the bad how to use the Internet. As they grow
guy sees that weakness, he moves in. Then older, they can be more aware of the more
he’ll start sending child pornography and sophisticated issues and problems out
saying, ‘You’re so special to me, I’d like to there. I think you will maybe head off that
meet you, I’d never hurt you.’ He gets the young girl on that one bad day. Maybe her
girl thinking that it’s her idea, so by the antenna will be up a little bit when she’s
time the hookup actually happens, the girl online, and when the guy hits on her, she’ll
feels responsible.” think, ‘I don’t need you; you’re just going
Shumaker resists efforts to place any to make my day worse.’”
blame on a child victim or on the parents. A teenager’s private password, of course,
“I often hear that ‘The parents should have can be an obstacle for parents. Shumaker
known better,’” she said. “But you have said, “I wouldn’t let my son have a computer
a case where a girl is a normal adolescent that I didn’t have password control over or
with all the crazy urges and is taking risks. I didn’t know his password, although that
She’s online with a guy who’s decided to may be unrealistic. It’s like having a gun
do whatever he wants, so he sneaks into in your house and the only one with the
the house and has sex with her while the bullets is your kid. It just doesn’t make any
parents are sleeping. I hear, ‘Why aren’t sense. I understand their need for privacy,
the parents aware of that?’ But aren’t they but again, you need to start early and say,
allowed to sleep at night? What are they ‘These are the rules.’ On the other hand,
supposed to do – sleep outside their kid’s you can have this perfect set of rules in
door? You cannot blame the parents.” your own home, and your child can go to
According to Shumaker, education, a friend’s house or to school or the library
education, education is the key to and open up a whole new account. So
prevention of computer sex crimes. “You that’s why you have to educate them.”
have to sit down and let your kid know As a child’s sense of right and
the dangers,” she said. “You can’t take wrong can be tested on the Internet, so
the computer away, because they need the Shumaker views an adult’s life as a whole.
computer. You don’t want to deny your These beliefs, and her Christian faith,
child the technology, so you have to let have helped her deal with the stress and
them know what’s involved. You have to pressures accompanying crimes of this
educate yourself and then be willing to sit nature. “I believe we’re tested every day,
down with your kids and say, ‘This is what and that’s part of my faith,” she said. “I
you’re going to see out there.’” believe God puts tests in front of us every
Shumaker is adamant that the education day, and I think sex is one of the greatest
must start early. “If your mom tells you tests. Every day, at some level, people are
when you’re 13 to stay off-line, guess tested. It’s as innocuous as a pretty girl
what? That 13-year-old is going to go on walking by and the guy deciding to look or
the Internet. If she can’t at your house, not look at her. That’s basically what the
she’s going to go to a friend’s house. You Internet is, except magnified a thousand
need to talk to your kids when they’re times.”
young. When I talk to my son now, and - Leisa Taylor
PAGE 18 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL APRIL 2008

Due Process RICHARD T. MEEHAN JR.

Serving Alcohol to Intoxicated Creates


Criminal and Civil Responsibilities
Connecticut recognizes two theories The Act applies to the sale of liquor As the Connecticut Supreme Court the minor guests, who, after leaving
of responsibility for those who serve by those persons licensed by the state. observed in a recent case: the party, operated an automobile while
liquor to intoxicated persons who, as a The definition of “person” includes cor- “To prevail, a plaintiff simply must intoxicated and killed another guest. The
consequence of their intoxication, cause porations and businesses. It also pro- prove: (1) the sale of the alcoholic liquor; court expressed doubt about the logic,
harm to others. The first focuses on vides a strict time limit for notice of a (2) that the sale was to an intoxicated when applied to a minor, of the com-
persons, including businesses, licensed claim to be made and lessens the time person; and (3) that the intoxicated mon-law presumption that intoxication
by the state to sell liquor, under a law within which such a claim can be filed person caused injury to another’s per- results from the voluntary conduct of a
entitled the Dram Shop Act. The sec- in court. son or property as a result of his or her person who has exercised a knowing and
ond area of responsibility focuses on pri- Under the common law, prior to the intoxication. . . Accordingly, the act cov- intelligent choice to consume intoxicat-
vate persons and is referred to as “social creation of the Act, one could recover ers all sales of liquor that result in an ing liquor. Further, the court found it
host liability.” against only the intoxicated person, the intoxicated person causing injury, irre- persuasive that our state’s public policy,
Although ancient in the derivation theory being that the proximate cause spective of the bar owner’s knowledge or as manifested in numerous relevant civil
of its name, the Dram Shop Act has of intoxication was the consumption of state of mind. The act thereby provides and criminal statutes, ‘reflects a continu-
recently been amended to increase the alcohol, not the furnishing of it. The Act an action in strict liability, both without ing and growing public awareness and
penalty on violators. Section 30-102 of is not grounded in the law of negligence, the burden of proving the element of concern that children as a class are sim-
the Connecticut General Statutes pro- but rather is considered a penalty for scienter [intent or knowledge of wrong- ply incompetent by reason of their youth
vides in part: serving an already intoxicated person. doing] essential to a negligence action and inexperience to deal responsibly
“If any person, by such person or such The key is that there must be proof and without the benefit of the broader with the effects of alcohol.’”
person’s agent, sells any alcoholic liquor to that the one served was intoxicated at scope of recovery permitted under such In recognizing a claim for social host
an intoxicated person, and such purchaser, the time. Merely furnishing liquor to an action. It sets, in essence, a minimum liability grounded in common law negli-
in consequence of such intoxication, thereaf- someone who then causes injury does recovery opportunity for persons injured gence, the Connecticut Supreme Court
ter injures the person or property of another, not create responsibility. as a result of the sale of liquor to an has cited the National Highway Traffic
such seller shall pay just damages to the per- Prior to 2003 the amount that a intoxicated person.” Safety Administration statistics for the
son injured, up to the amount of two hun- single injured party could recover under In that decision the Supreme Court nation and Connecticut:
dred fifty thousand dollars, or to persons the Act was $20,000, and the aggregate attempted to broaden the rights of an • “In 2000, 16,653 people died in
injured in consequence of such intoxication limit was $40,000. The aggregate limit is injured person to recover under common alcohol-related motor vehicle accidents
up to an aggregate amount of two hundred the total amount recoverable if multiple law negligence. Such an action would on our nation's highways, an average
fifty thousand dollars. . .” parties are injured by a single drunk. provide a significantly greater amount of one alcohol-related death every thir-
that could be recovered as damages. The ty-two minutes. Thirty-one percent of
Legislature did not agree, and the most these accidents involved intoxicated per-
recent amendments to the Act increased sons with blood alcohol concentration
the penalty to the $250,000 limit but also of 0.10 or greater; in those accidents,
made clear that common law negligence almost one third of the fatalities were
actions could not be brought against the passengers, non-intoxicated drivers or
liquor seller if the person served was 21 non-occupants.
or older: “Such injured person shall have • “In 2000, approximately 310,000
no cause of action against such seller for people were injured in alcohol-related
negligence in the sale of alcoholic liquor motor vehicle accidents, an average of
to a person twenty-one years of age or one person injured every two minutes.
older.” • “In 2000, it was estimated that
One Supreme Court jurist, the late about three in every ten Americans will
Justice Bogdanski, observed the differ- be involved in an alcohol-related crash
ence in modes of transportation when at some time in their lives.
negligence actions were not permitted, • “In 2000, 158 people died in Con-
and our modern conveyances that sub- necticut in alcohol-related motor vehicle
stantially increase the risk of harm from accidents, constituting 46 percent of all
intoxicated drivers: “When most people traffic fatalities. Connecticut had one of
walked and few had horses or carriages, the highest alcohol-related traffic fatal-
or even in the days when the horse and ity rates in the nation, with only nine
buggy was a customary mode of travel, states having higher rates.”
it may have been that the common law (National Highway Traffic Safety
rule of non-liability arising from the Administration, Traffic Safety Facts
sale of liquor to an intoxicated person 2000, at www.nhtsa.dot.gov/people/
was satisfactory. But the situation then injury/alcohol/facts.htm.)
and the problem in today’s society of the The National Highway Traffic Safety
imbiber going upon the public highways Administration also cited these addi-
and operating a machine that requires tional statistics:
quick response of mind and muscle and • “In 1998, alcohol-related traffic
capable of producing mass death and accidents cost Connecticut more than
destruction are vastly different.” $900 million, including more than $300
Social host liability attaches most million in monetary costs and more than
frequently in the context of the parents $600 million in quality of life costs.
who allow minor guests to consume • “In 1998, the average cost to Con-
alcohol and then the minor leaves and necticut per alcohol-related fatality
causes injury. In another landmark deci- was $4.2 million. The estimated cost
sion the Supreme Court reexamined the per injured survivor was on average
logic of its previous decisions rejecting a $105,000.”
common-law action in negligence, and (National Highway Traff ic Safety
concluded that “. . .[social] hosts could
be liable for injuries caused by one of - Continued on next page
APRIL 2008 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL PAGE 19

Undercover–
Continued from page 3
cover agent’s story.” ened to use baseball bats to kill an agent
In fact, his closest call to being discov- making an undercover buy. They hadn’t
ered came when he was camped out under discovered his identity; they just intended
a camouflage tarp in a wooded border to rob him of the money he was carrying.
alongside a suburban home for three days, The surveillance team saved that agent
watching a suspect who was believed to be in what turned out to be an all-out brawl.
operating a drug factory. Like most people in his profession,
A box of specialized chemicals had Duke found undercover work to be
been delivered to the home, and the demanding on his family. He wasn’t deep
agents had to keep an eye on it to establish undercover, like the police seen in mov-
a chain of evidence. ies who join gangs and organized crime
But there lies one of the harder-to- families, living the lifestyle and often not
understand aspects of surveillance work. seeing their real families for months or
After time, the person doing the surveil- years at a time.
lance begins to think that every move Nonetheless he traveled to far parts
made by the target is a reaction to some- of the country, where he wouldn’t be
thing the agent has done. known, often staying for weeks. One of
The longer the surveillance continues, the hardest days of his job occurred when
the easier it is to believe the spotters he reported in to join a team in a large
have been discovered. From that point municipality and was assigned the desk
on, every move made by the subject gives previously occupied by a well-liked and
the impression that he knows he is being respected agent who had been killed in
watched. This is rarely true, but don’t tell the line of duty.
that to people who are on the stakeout. Even when he worked closer to home,
“They get into your head,” Duke said. Duke would spend days on end working
In the case of the suburban drug lab, cases, and often not arrive home until very
the suspect came out of his house, took late at night.
a double-edged ax from his garage, and “You have to consciously leave the job
headed straight for Duke’s hideaway. “He outside – don’t bring it home, don’t talk
was almost on top of me with that ax, and about it,” he advises. The job is demanding
I almost shot him,” Duke said, thinking enough, and the divorce rate is high for
he had been discovered and was about to married agents.
be attacked. To be sure, even with the stress, danger,
But at the last second the suspect and long periods away from his family,
turned in a different direction, walked there were some high points to his job.
several yards further away, and trimmed Duke was part of a team that seized $1.5
some tree limbs. million in cash from a drug ring. At the
Duke had had a double-action revolver time it was the largest seizure of cash on
pointed straight at the suspect’s midsec- the East Coast.
tion. “My whole hand was shaking,” he But after 10 years he called it quits and
said, describing how he quietly eased the went to work for another federal agency,
hammer back from its cocked position. leaving both the stress and the excitement
There were other confrontations that behind. He had a family by then, Duke
became violent or near violent, such as says, and “I wanted a real life.”
when four members of a biker gang threat- (r.winter@thejusticejournal.com)

Due Process–
Continued from previous page
Administration, Impaired Driving in . . in such dwelling unit or on such private
Connecticut, at www.nhtsa.dot.gov/peo- property, fail to make reasonable efforts to
ple/injury/alcohol/CT.htm/facts.htm.) halt such possession. For the purposes of this
The Supreme Court concluded that subsection, ‘minor’ means a person under
an injured person has a right to sue a twenty-one years of age. (b) Any person
social host if that host negligently serves who violates [this act] for a first offense,
alcohol to an obviously intoxicated per- have committed an infraction and, for any
son and such guest consequently causes subsequent offense, be fined not more than
injury to another. Thus voluntary con- five hundred dollars or imprisoned not
sumption of alcohol no longer serves to more than one year, or both.”
bar a negligence action against a social Thus the parent who permits minors
host. to possess liquor faces not only civil
In 2006 the legislature passed Pub- responsibility, but potential criminal
lic Acts 2006, No. 06-112, § 1, which prosecution as well. As prom season
amended General Statutes § 30-89 as approaches again, parents are reminded
follows: that they face the serious consequences
“1. . . . (Effective October 1, 2006) of a major lawsuit if they fail to monitor
(a) No person having possession of, or the activities of their guests, regardless
exercising dominion and control over, any of age. Allowing a social guest, of any
dwelling unit or private property shall age, to consume alcohol to the point of
(1) knowingly permit any minor to possess impairment, in essence, makes the social
alcoholic liquor . . . in such dwelling unit or host a guarantor of the safety of others Dichello Distributors, inc.
on such private property, or (2) knowing on the highway when the drunken guest
that any minor possesses alcoholic liquor . is allowed to leave.
PAGE 20 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL APRIL 2008

What If– teach, students to learn, maintenance


personnel to maintain the operation of
the building, and administrators to man-
moments before the shootings in the
academic building, several stakeholders
noticed not-normal, but never reported
Continued from page 11
age it all. Everyone’s secondary role is it. It might not have helped, but it might
notification systems, lockdown capabili- room and escalated two hours later when that of crisis leader. have.
ties, guns for students, and the response shots rang out in Norris Hall, leaving When do you change roles? When- Even weeks before the shooting, clues
of mental health professionals to signs frightened students and staff fighting for ever there is a disruptive event – anytime of a pending attack, including an obser-
and signals given out by the shooter prior their lives. something happens that is unplanned, vation of someone chaining doors, were
to his rampage are all being discussed. Just prior to opening fire, Seung-Hui noneducational, and disruptive – any- observed but dismissed as insignificant
Some lessons learned from Virginia Tech Cho secured the exits with chains, pre- thing that interrupts that primary role. and were never reported. Police found
are already being implemented nation- venting escape and delaying the respond- When the shooting started at Virginia the doors chained as the incident was
wide, specifically the notification of stu- ers’ entry to the building. Once he start- Tech, some people in the surrounding occurring, and never knew of prior obser-
dents as soon as possible when an inci- ed shooting, he went from room to room hallway and classrooms recognized it as vations. Only after the incident were
dent occurs. killing his victims as some sat in their such and took action, either trying to authorities able to piece together obser-
Is there more that can be learned? I chairs. Others were killed while trying block the door or running from the area. vations made by people prior to the
recently traveled to Blacksburg, Virginia, to hide, and still others were killed trying Some of those who took quick action attack that could have helped the police
home of Virginia Tech, to share my expe- to prevent entry into some classrooms. saved their own lives. Others initially understand what was taking place as the
riences as the lead crisis negotiator dur- Just as police made their way to the sec- dismissed the gunshots as maintenance events were unfolding.
ing a hostage situation in 2002 on the ond floor, Cho took his own life, and the noises in the basement and tried to What else did we learn? The lessons
campus of Fairfield University, with the event ended as quickly as it started. continue their primary role. Remember, learned from prior incidents are helping
emergency responders at Virginia Tech. So what else can be learned, besides there may be an explanation for the dis- to prepare those who may find themselves
Although the Fairfield incident was six the highly publicized notification issues ruption, but there may not. Teachers and in similar incidents. By studying and
years ago, agencies often find value in and mental health response to Cho’s prior students should not go on teaching and learning the facts of the tragedies that
the experiences of others. I left learning problems? If from the Columbine High learning, without determining the reason have occurred we can continue to speak
just as much as I shared, having had an School attacks we learned the impor- for the disruption. If it is determined to to all those involved in school activities,
opportunity to discuss the events of that tance of locking down areas of the school be nothing, then continue your purpose. to ensure they have an understanding
day in April at Virginia Tech with one to delay and hopefully prevent the threat But if there is more to it, quick notifica- of their role in a crisis at the school. It
of the lead investigators of that incident. from reaching the staff and students, we tion to authorities and quick initiation may be frightening information, but it is
Although at first glance it might appear must learn from this event and continue of safety procedures may help prevent nonetheless enlightening and important.
as if life has returned to normal, the to make our schools safer. further tragedy. What if? That question always lingers
events of that day are clearly still felt on First, teachers, staff, parents, students, What else can we learn from Vir- in tragedies. If we learn how to make our
campus. The hotel clerk spoke about it, and anyone else who has a stake in keep- ginia Tech? Know what normal is, and schools safer because of these incidents,
waitresses referred to it, and the memori- ing our schools safe have to acknowledge don’t dismiss what you may feel is not then we have fulfilled our mission. What
als – pins, bumper stickers, and banners and be aware that these tragedies can normal. In his book on fear, Author if we don’t? Then we are destined to
– were visible everywhere. happen in their schools. They probably Gavin DeBecker speaks of intuition as a repeat mistakes.
The responders that day will never won’t, but they can. Every stakeholder powerful tool. It is, but only if you fol- As the Northern Illinois University
forget it. Their day on April 16, 2007, in the school should understand the dual low it. If you feel something is out of the shootings, which left six dead just a few
started as any other on any campus in the role they serve. ordinary, report it. It may be nothing, months ago, remind us, unfortunately
United States. It quickly changed when The first role is part of the institution’s or it may be a significant indication of there continue to be more incidents to
two students were murdered in a dorm primary mission. We want teachers to a pending disruption. At Virginia Tech, learn from.
APRIL 2008 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL PAGE 21

SCAM of the Month By GRANT STINCHFIELD


Correspondent

Tax Time is Opportunity Time for Identity Thieves


Thieves are now preying on taxpay- The IRS insists it will never contact taxpayers via e-mail. “Other fraudulent e-mails come embed-
ers who are eager to receive their refund ded with a virus that gets downloaded
check, and the Internal Revenue Service It always uses the United States Postal Service, and the onto your computer. It then records all
(IRS) is warning people about a series correspondence will always be addressed to the taxpayer your keystrokes in an attempt to steal
of e-mail and phone scams designed to your passwords,” warns Foley.
steal your identity. by name. The IRS insists it will never contact
Thieves are using the guise of the IRS taxpayers via e-mail. It always uses the
to dupe people into giving up their per- United States Postal Service, and the
the phone. “He sounded so professional The caller, posing as an IRS employee, correspondence will always be addressed
sonal information. That includes bank
and he said he just needed my social states that he needs the target’s bank to the taxpayer by name.
account numbers, birth dates, and social
security number and birth date to con- account number because the only way By far the most important step a
security numbers… everything a scam-
firm who he was talking to,” says Butzer. to receive the rebate is through direct person can take during tax time is to
mer needs to commit identity theft.
Even though Butzer could use the cash, deposit. If the victim refuses to give up protect his or her private and personal
The latest scheme takes advantage of
she hesitated. “My husband told me the information, he is told he cannot documents. W-2 forms, 1099 forms, pay
taxpayers eager to benefit from the fed-
never to give out that information over receive the rebate. The call is a scam. stubs, and credit card receipts being used
eral government’s new economic stimu-
the phone so I didn’t, but I almost did. The IRS points out, no legislation has to file taxes are often left unguarded and
lus package. The scam artists use the
Anyone could be fooled by them.” ever been enacted that would allow the out in the open. It only takes seconds
new tax rebates as bait to trick people
The IRS is sending out letters to IRS to provide advance payments to tax- for someone with ill intentions to copy
into giving up their private financial
families as part of an outreach effort payers, and the IRS never forces people this private and personal information.
information. The caller or e-mail writer
informing them how to get their share to use direct deposit. Identity theft is the fastest-growing
will claim to be from the IRS working
of the $168 billion economic stimulus Agents say all the information the crime in the nation. Thieves will do
to speed up the distribution of the new
plan. In May, the U.S. Treasury will start IRS needs to process a tax return and anything to steal a good name. The
rebates recently approved by Congress.
sending out payments to 130 million refund is gathered on the filing forms. key is to take steps to prevent becom-
“I was so excited when I got the call, I
households as part of the package passed The IRS never gathers information by ing a victim. Once someone’s iden-
had just seen it on the news that I could
by Congress. telephone. “Sometimes the scams will tity is stolen, it can take years to fix
get up to $1,500 back this year,” says
Another tax time scheme has the come in the form of an e-mail try- the damage. With tax time here, many
Maya Butzer of Stamford. She says she
bogus caller telling the victim he is eli- ing to get you to fill out a form on a people become so eager to receive their
was all set to give up her social security
gible for a rebate for filing his taxes early. Web site that looks like a government refund, they lose all common sense.
number to the man on the other end of
agency Web site,” warns Linda Foley, Beware: The person pretending to be
director of the Identity Theft Resource
State Experiencing Rash of Scam Calls Center, a nonprofit group based in San
Diego, CA, formed to help people pro-
the tax man may actually be an identity
thief in disguise.
(g.stinchfield@thejusticejournal.com)
Many Connecticut consumers have without their consent. tect themselves from identity thieves.
received unwanted cell phone calls from However, cell phone numbers that are not
telemarketers pitching extended auto registered are fair game for telemarketers,
warranties, and Consumer Protection
Commissioner Jerry
as long as an automatic dialer isn’t used, so
consumers looking to NOW AVAILABLE - ORDER TODAY!
Farrell Jr. wants people eliminate telemarketing

13 Minutes
to be careful. calls should register
“Don’t fall for it,” both their cell and
he says. “Consumers home phone numbers
are often fooled by the on the Do Not Call
pitch -- ‘your warranty Registry.
is about to expire, this There is no special
is your last warning, Do Not Call list just for Read the blunt details of how an
this is a final offer.’ cell phones. Personal
Extended warranties cell phone users have exceptional officer
are contracts, and always been able to
any consumer who is add their numbers to lost everything
interested in such a the National Do Not because he performed his job as
program needs to see it Call Registry — the he was trained to do.
in writing and should not make a decision same Registry consumers use to register
on the phone.” their land lines. To list your home and
Farrell said his department is cell phone numbers on the Do Not Call Keith Fangman, Vice President
investigating the recent rash of unwanted Registry, visit www.donotcall.gov online for Ohio FOP said, "Every police
calls to consumers. or call toll-free 1-888-382-1222 from the officer and their spouse should
“Connecticut was one of the first states telephone number you wish to register. read 13 Minutes."
to implement a no-call registry before it Registrations become effective within 31
became part of the national Do-Not-Call days of signing up. There is no cutoff date
effort, and we vigorously pursue companies or deadline for registrations. This is a true story about a thoughtful, caring, professional and
that violate Connecticut law,” Farrell said. Business-to-business calls are not decent police officer with a promising career in law enforcement.
If your number is listed on the Do covered under the Registry. Blaine had outstanding performance appraisals and received
Not Call registry, automated, recorded Consumers can file automated dialer numerous commendations. Blaine Jorg had his career ruined and
messages also violate the Connecticut No complaints online with the FCC at www.
Call law. fcc.gov . Consumers who are registered with his life turned upside down by greedy politicians.
Federal Communications Commission the National Do Not Call Registry should
(FCC) regulations prohibit telemarketers complain in writing to the Connecticut
Order online at
from using automated dialers to call
cell phone numbers. Because automated
dialers are standard in the industry, most
Department of Consumer Protection
about any unwanted telemarketing calls
they receive. Complaint forms can be
www.13minutes.org
telemarketers are thus prevented from found on the department’s Web site at or send $19.95 to 3400 Fairfield Street, The Villages, Fl 32162
calling consumers on their cell phones www.ct.gov/dcp.
PAGE 22 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL APRIL 2008

Self Defense– rush of an attack.


“It’s very, very empowering,” Nemphos
said. “It really lets them know what
University in Danbury, and Southern
Connecticut State University in New
Haven.
Continued from page 4
they can do, and it’s a great confidence-
abdomen. Men tend to rely more on their as the women threw fists in the air. booster.” Positive Reviews
strong arms and chest. Next it was time to practice on the R.A.D. was founded in 1989 by a Although concerns about liability
“You cannot physically stand toe-to- trainers. As their instructors equipped Virginia police officer and has been taught can be a deterrent for some police
toe with a male and hope to win that their arms with thick foam pads, the to more than 300,000 women across the departments, Schechter said R.A.D.
fight. Eventually, his strength is probably women lined up and took turns going country. Nemphos and Schechter recently Systems’ credentials make it a “low-
going to overcome you,” Nemphos told at them, each time yelling, “No!” as they became certified trainers. liability, court-defensible” program.
the women during a recent class. “The struck. Privacy is a key aspect of the program. “We asked several departments about
primary goal of R.A.D. is to escape.” The shouting and aggressive behavior Participants were not permitted to their experience with R.A.D., and it’s
The instructors spent the first part of doesn’t always come easy for women, who reveal their identities for this article. had very positive reviews,” he said.
class discussing what-if scenarios, like are often socialized to be polite in tough The locations of the classes are kept One participant said she feels much
what to do if you’re stopped by an situations, so the hands-on experience secret, and the women are asked never safer knowing she can rely on herself
unmarked police car and have doubts can be lifesaving. to practice their moves at home on loved instead of depending on weapons like
about the officer’s authenticity. (Answer: “You’ve just started doing these strikes, ones, since their success relies on the pepper spray or Tasers, which are often
Call 911 to verify the traffic stop. No and some of you are hitting very hard element of surprise and striking with buried in a woman’s purse.
legitimate police officer would mind.) already,” Nemphos reassured them. “As intensity. “If you have a gun or a Taser or some
you get more confident with the moves, Although the R.A.D. program is kind of equipment, you might not have
Ready-to-Fight Position the speed and power will increase.” offered by dozens of police departments the opportunity to take it out and use it,”
After a series of warm-ups, the dozen in neighboring Massachusetts, only three said the woman. “And if you’re on a plane
women formed a circle around Schechter. Confidence Booster other Connecticut departments – East or traveling overseas, you can’t have a gun
Focusing their gaze directly at him, they The last night of the five-class series is Windsor, New Britain, and Suffield in certain situations.”
swiftly turned on their feet and raised their a simulation course where the instructors, – offer the program, according to the “I think it’s a very valuable and timely
hands into a ready-to-fight position. dressed in full-body padded suits, “attack” R.A.D. Web site. course that they’re offering, and I’m glad
“Get back!” they shouted in unison, the women, who must escape their The program is also offered on several that the Cheshire Police Department is
practicing the warning stance he taught advances using moves they’ve learned. college campuses, including Fairfield being proactive,” she said.
them. Then came a more insistent “No!” It is designed to recreate the adrenaline University, Western Connecticut State (n.missakian@thejustice journal.com)

Versus– crimes, (where treatment is more appro-


priate in any event). Unfortunately, for
all the wrong reasons, it has become
the cogs of our broken sentencing system.
And while the main argument seems to
be that the three strikes bill take away
Continued from page 6
standard operating procedure in dealing judicial discretion- it is this very “discre-
answer. You have no right to paint every- desperate need for much needed reform with all violent crimes including felony tion” that has become utterly misused
one with the same brush because we are all within our state’s criminal justice system. assault, sexual assault, kidnapping and and abused, leading to a system ruled by
different levels of consistency. The abduction, assaults, and eventual yes- even murder “discretion” rather than law. The reasons
There are various crimes commit- murders of three members of Petit fam- A three strikes law (or steadfastly for this misuse are many; professional
ted everyday in every part of our state, ily by two career criminals have come to utilized persistent offender law) for laziness, apathy and cynicism-- crony-
and some people should do life for stand as representative highlights of the violent offenders is a good idea as one ism, favor swapping, and yes, things like
some crimes. However, why must society endemic and pervasive flaws within our part of a multi-prong re-formation of directives regarding prison overcrowding.
continually degrade people who have Connecticut courts and Parole system Connecticut’s Judicial system , There are None of these things seem to belong in
a record and turned their lives around Many of our state legislators seem several versions successfully being uti- the sacred place where committed pro-
by denying them the basic things in to be banging the table with their shoe, lized in various states and they do appear fessionals are supposed to be battling the
life such as a good job, decent housing, amid the hue and cry from their citizens, to be reducing violent crime. Some of the rigors of life and death crime.
and a second chance in life? Why must claiming that a broad and sweeping sen- first broader versions created unforeseen The truth is that precious few would
we continue to pay for a crime we have tencing law such as the three strikes law issues- sometimes creating severe sen- seem to be battling anything anymore
done time for and paid for, in life time would serve to deprive prosecutors -and tences for less serious non-violent felo- in our Connecticut courthouses, and it
installments every time we try to move judges, - of their “discretion” in sentenc- nies, many of them drug-related and/or is the victims of crime that are paying
forward, only to get stopped dead in our ing defendants of crime. This discretion motivated. The argument is also being the heaviest price. Not only the victims
tracks? Why should the labels such as is empirical, so it is argued, and at all made that three strikes laws result in a of the endless cases bargained down to
“ex-convict” or “ex-offender” or other costs must be preserved. disparity of high sentences for minority next to nothing in viable punishment or
labels be used to describe someone who First of all it should be clarified that and low income offenders-This perhaps accountability, but also the future vic-
got in trouble with the law? Why can’t this concern is really about prosecutorial is an unintended effect of the fact that tims of these same offenders, who, after
we just be a person who made a mistake discretion: Practically speaking, criminal many repeat minority offenders rely on receiving little to no actual prison time,
or a bad decision? It seems that when we judges in this state have very little to do public defenders who are either less go right back out, committing more
go out and patronize, our money is no with the actual charges of which most motivated, less adept, or simply lack the violence, more crime, confident that they
different, and when we vote (those of us offenders are eventually “convicted” – pull that an expensive private attorney can depend on the same lackadaisical
who know we can vote) it doesn’t matter and the same with their actual sentences. may have with the local prosecutors system which they have become experts
if we had or have a record. That is unless there is a trial by judge office (in getting their charges reduced). at navigating, almost always escalating
I wish someone would tell me what or jury, and trials are extremely rare. Ironically, this is an important reason their crimes, and always against those
does an ex-offender or ex-convict look The majority of cases never go to trial that one sentencing system is needed defenseless.
like? Because where I sit, I don’t see because they are routinely plea bargained for violent offenders; to create a uniform And consider this, most of the vic-
ex-convicts or ex-offenders, I see people by defense attorneys and prosecutors.; steadfast system for sentencing our most tims of the countless bargained down”
who made bad decisions who paid their often resulting in an even lesser criminal dangerous repeat offenders. crimes remain nameless and their expe-
debt to society (so they thought) and are record and corresponding sentence This There is no doubt that we must be rience forever invalidated by the “deal”
looking to break the invisible chains and leaves a formal record for the criminal diligent and meticulous in choosing and that belies the reality of the crimes
shackles that prevent them from mov- that does not reflect the severity of the crafting our own version of a three strikes committed against them. That is, until
ing forward. How long is long enough? crimes that he or she has actually com- bill. We need to use our collective intel- the next especially atrocious and brutal
That’s something to think about. mitted. And with few exceptions, Con- lects experience and conscience in devis- crime is committed by another irrespon-
Submitted by Jacqueline Caron, necticut judges will rarely overrule what ing a bill that makes sense in its practical sibly paroled or under-sentenced chronic
Founder/CEO of the Connecticut a prosecutor has already worked out with application. But there is one thing I am offender; and precious lives are stolen,
Pardon Team, Inc. the defendant’s lawyer. certain of, as an activist and a survivor and nightmares are all that remain for
This “deal -away- a -crime”- sys- of violent crime; that is; the main reason those that survive.
“Deal-Away-a-Crime” System tem wouldn’t be so abhorrent if it were that our lawmakers are reluctant to pass Submitted by Laurel O’Keefe
Needs Change limited to non-victim crimes, such as a strict sentencing law, is the very same Laurel O’Keefe is a victim of a violent
This past July one night of brutal our overburdened motor vehicle dockets, reason that it is so desperately needed. crime and writes the blog,
criminal rampage brought to light the petty larcenies and non-violent drug Something tangible needs to be stuck in chasingnormal.blogspot.com,
APRIL 2008 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL PAGE 23

BUSINESS DIRECTORY
Please support these businesses. They have joined the fight to make our communities safer!

patrick sean flaherty


president / creative director

203-912-0731

BRANDHALO
BRANDING ADVERTISING INVENTING EVENTING

pflaherty@brandhalo.com www.brandhalo.com

consignmart

To include your business in the next Justice Journal Business Directory, please call Lisa Levitt at 203-454-5910
PAGE 24 THE JUSTICE JOURNAL APRIL 2008

“ We can see what’s going on and


cover more ground in less time.

Lt. Richard Ricko
Maryland Transportation Authority Police
Baltimore-Washington International Airport

With over 600 police and security


installations worldwide, the Segway®
Personal Transporter (PT) is quickly
becoming the most efficient way to patrol
downtown areas, airports, transit stations,
parks, shopping malls and campuses.

The Segway i2 Police model will elevate


your patrols to a higher level of productivity.
The Segway i2 Police enables your patrol
officers to cover more ground and respond
quickly to incidents wherever they occur.
It is equipped with revolutionary Segway
LeanSteerTM technology that makes riding
incredibly intuitive, and a wireless InfoKeyTM
controller that provides useful trip data
and arms a state-of-the-art theft alarm
whenever the unit is unattended.

The i2 Police also includes a complete set of


police accessories, including LED taillight,
comfort mat, handlebar bag and lower
cargo structure for carrying extra gear or
emergency medical equipment.

For a free two week no obligation trial


Call Fritz’s Segway +203.975.1985.
Visit www.GOFRITZ.net to learn more.

Segway® and the Segway ‘flyguy’ logo are registered trademarks of Segway Inc. (“Segway”). Segway reserves all rights in its trademarks. Copyright © 2008. Segway Inc. All rights reserved.

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen