Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
PREPARED FOR
June 8, 2010
Included sites:
San Francisco
c o nt e nts
2
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
Executive Summary
This report is the result of an assessment of TECHCO Incorporated‟s telecommunications bonding networks
conducted by PANDUIT Global Professional Services in partnership with TCG – Technical Consulting Group on May
st
1 , 2010.
Telecommunications bonding systems are active, functioning networks designed to create a robust path for stray
Voltages and resulting surge currents, allowing them to bypass critical, expensive telecommunications, network, and
computer equipment and safely return to ground. These systems help enterprises maximize network uptime,
maintain system performance, and protect equipment and personnel. Poorly designed or improperly applied
grounding, bonding, and shielding techniques are known to adversely affect network performance and can increase
threats to worker health and safety.
This assessment reports on “current state” practices found in the SAMPLE facilities, highlights best practices for
implementation of a telecommunications bonding network that is reliable, standards compliant, and professional in
appearance, and suggests areas for improvement at SAMPLE‟s site. All suggestions and recommendations are
based on industry standards, best practices, and Panduit engineering expertise and are the professional opinions of
PANDUIT Global Professional Services.
Key Findings:
A detailed assessment of each site can be found in Section III of the report, “Current State Assessment”. An
overview of observed telecommunications bonding practices yields the following:
Telecommunications Bonding is minimal to non-existent within the Main, and West Side facilities
Over 62% of evaluated areas and racks have no telecommunications bonding system whatsoever and therefore
are completely out-of-compliance with telecommunications bonding standards
36% of evaluated areas and racks exhibit minimal compliance with telecommunications bonding standards as a
result of improperly deployed telecommunications bonding systems and components
Only 2% of evaluated areas, racks, and equipment exhibit proper compliance to telecommunications bonding
standards and best practices
Recommended Practices:
A detailed recommendation of telecommunications bonding system Best Practices can be found in Section IV of the
report, “Recommendations”. Based upon on-site assessments and Panduit experience in telecommunications
bonding best practices, the following recommendations are made:
Active Equipment: Bond each piece of active network equipment to a grounding strip or grounding bus bar
installed in compliance with US and International grounding requirements
Racks and Cabinets: Provide a dedicated grounding and bonding system comprised of purpose-built
components (bonded frames, paint-piercing hardware, grounding bards, lugs, ground conductors, etc.) which are
engineered to comply with US and International grounding requirements.
Each site/area: Deploy a telecommunications bonding solution that meets J-STD-607-A, TIA-942, and IEEE Std
1100TM-2005 (The Emerald Book™) requirements and utilizes UL-Listed or CSA-Certified products.
It is possible to retrofit and remediate existing installations at the TECCHO sites by deploying telecommunications
bonding backbones (TBBs), telecommunications grounding busbars (TGBs), bonding hardware, equipment jumpers,
common bonding network (CBN) jumpers, and other grounding and bonding system components. P ANDUIT offers
robust, standards-compliant telecommunications bonding solutions, provides a network of Panduit certified installers
to perform remediation work, and can evaluate the effectiveness of the site upgrade(s).
The PANDUIT team enjoyed the challenge and opportunity presented by TECHCO Incorporated. PANDUIT and TCG
look forward to working closely with TECHCO on subsequent projects and serving an advisory role where appropriate
on other TECHCO Incorporated physical infrastructure deployments and assessments.
3
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
Project Overview
This Telecommunications Bonding Assessment is intended to identify current-state conditions and opportunities for
improvement, if needed, in the telecommunications bonding network(s) and common bonding network(s) for
TECHCO Incorporated‟s Main and West Side facilities located in San Francisco, CA.
Project Objectives
The purpose of the assessment is to determine if the existing telecommunications bonding network(s) conform to
industry standards, best practices, and Panduit recommended deployment methodologies. This assessment includes
an in-depth analysis of each telecommunication area (data center, telecommunications room, or entrance facility) with
a rack-by-rack (or cabinet-by-cabinet) and component-by-component review of the telecommunications bonding
network(s). Panduit will on a best-effort basis take all data communications and telecommunications equipment into
consideration for the assessment. Specifically excluded from the assessment is all Service-Provider (Public Carrier)
equipment, POTS (Plain Old Telephone Service) equipment, and any other non-client owned/operated premises
equipment.
The recommendations presented in this document are based upon standards body documents (TIA, EIA, NEMA,
ANSI, IEEE), industry best-practices, and Panduit engineering expertise. Each section of this document focuses on
specific aspects of the overall Telecommunications Bonding Network deployment.
Assessment Methodology
This assessment is based mainly on the information collected on-site by the Panduit Global Professional Services
consultant through direct examination, measurement, and observation of the telecommunications bonding
infrastructure system deployment.
4
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
th
Initial pre-assessment discussions and information gathering was done via teleconference on September 28 , 2009.
st
The on-site assessment was performed on October 1 . The post-assessment analysis and report was completed on
th
October 26 , 2009.
The resulting analysis and recommendations are not based upon any detailed application specific information or “use
case” scenarios but are primarily focused on conformance with industry standards and Panduit best practices.
Implementation of the recommendations provided in this report will require the services of a Panduit certified installer
(PCI) to perform the actual remediation work.
Philosophy
Unified Physical Infrastructure: A Guiding Vision for a Smarter, Unified Business Foundation
The growing interdependence of systems and applications, and the increased demands that they place on physical
infrastructures, requires the integration of traditionally disparate and proprietary systems. This trend is dramatically
changing infrastructure design, management strategies and effective synchronization of critical systems, opening the
door for seamless convergence and interoperability of all core business systems. Panduit provides flexible, end-to-
end solutions for the physical infrastructure that drive operational and financial advantages, allowing businesses to
minimize risk and heighten agility. Tailored by industry and customized by application, Panduit solutions span the
core systems necessary to transform a business, from data center to facility operations, to next generation intelligent
buildings.
Panduit has developed the industry‟s most comprehensive and holistic approach to a Unified Physical Infrastructure
and can help enterprises align, converge, and optimize critical systems – communication, computing, control, power
and security – to build a smarter, unified business foundation. This approach enables the use of an open standards-
based, service-oriented architecture framework and is designed to deliver tangible infrastructure and business
process improvements for increased functionality, interoperability and manageability of mission critical operations
across the enterprise.
Based upon the Unified Physical Infrastructure vision, Panduit Global Professional Services provides a systematic
approach to Assess, Design, and Maintain critical elements within SAMPLE Corporation‟s physical infrastructure
including the Telecommunications Bonding Network.
Step one is a Bonding Assessment. The bonding assessment evaluates existing or new facilities, collects information
about current or anticipated operations, visually inspects the grounding and bonding deployment practices, and
measures and documents key electrical characteristics. The post-assessment report generates telecommunications
bonding system improvement suggestions to facilitate the equalization of electrical potentials and provide a
supplemental return path for electrical transients.
Step two is Site Remediation. A strategy is formulated for improving the existing telecommunications bonding
network to meet established minimum functionality requirements. Best practice installation advice that meets the
intent of the design standards (J-STD-607-A, TIA-942, and IEEE Std 1100TM-2005) is considered for future
telecommunications bonding systems remediation and expansion. A PANDUIT Certified Installer (PCI) is engaged to
perform the actual site remediation work.
Step three is Lifecycle Management. Periodic “health checks” or re-commissioning services are performed. These
ensure that moves, adds, and changes (MACs) and additional deployments have been performed in a manner
consistent with industry standards and best practices.
5
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
6
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
Overall Findings:
Over 90% of evaluated areas, racks, and equipment have no bonding system whatsoever and therefore are out-
of-compliance with all telecommunications bonding standards
Under 10% of evaluated areas, racks, and equipment are in minimal compliance as a result of improperly
deployed telecommunications bonding systems and components although some effort has been made to comply
with telecommunications bonding standards and best practices
Fully Green is assigned when full conformance to industry standards and best
Complies practices exists and no threat or risk condition is found
Not Assessed Blue is assigned when the particular area was not assessed.
The focus areas are assessed in terms of current-state status and “short-term” opportunities for improvement (i.e.,
remediation to compliance with industry standards and best practices that can be accomplished with limited efforts,
costs, or rework). Findings that may require more extensive changes, substantial rework, or complete redesign in
order to bring the systems into compliance with industry standards and best practices are considered “long-term”
opportunities and will require additional investigations and remediation recommendations beyond the scope of this
assessment.
7
Summary of Telecommunications Bonding Assessment:
Main IDF
Main Server West Side West Side
“Other” Server MPOE
Assessment Area Room Exp. IDF IDF
Room
Does Not Does Not Does Not Does Not Does Not
Busbar(s) drilled with holes per NEMA standards
Comply Comply Comply Comply Comply
Telecommunications racks and cabinets Does Not Does Not Partially Partially Does Not
grounded to busbars Comply Comply Complies Complies Comply
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report
8
Busbars connected by backbone or Common
Does Not Does Not Does Not Does Not Does Not
Bonding Network of insulated, solid copper cable
Comply Comply Comply Comply Comply
between all closets, rooms, and busbars
Bonding conductor cable colored green or Does Not Partially Partially Fully Does Not
appropriately labeled Comply Complies Complies Complies Comply
Does Not Does Not Does Not Does Not Does Not
AC and DC currents at acceptable levels
Comply Comply Comply Comply Comply
DC resistance between rack or cabinet and Partially Partially Partially Partially Partially
bondings at acceptable levels Complies Complies Complies Complies Complies
Confidential Information
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
The “Main Server Room” and “Main IDF – Other Server Room” do not have any room-level telecommunications
bonding system or components in place. In these rooms, no telecommunications grounding busbar (TGB) is present
and therefore none of the racks are properly connected to the room-level busbar. In the MPOE Room, the “Main Exp.
IDF Room”, and the “West Side IDF Room”, a telecommunications ground busbar (TGB) does exist; however, in the
“West Side Exp IDF Room” and the “West Side IDF Room”, this TGB is painted-over, prohibiting proper electrical
contact and thus defeating the purpose of the busbar. The busbar in the “MPOE Room” is a proper thickness,
unpainted busbar. However, the absence of pre-drilled NEMA standard holes and the use of 1-hole mechanical lugs
with multiple bonding connectors per lug prevent this deployment from being in full compliance.
Figure 1: Telecommunications Grounding Busbar practices at TECHCO Main Server and IDF rooms showing
painted-over busbar (top left, top right), use of one-hole mechanical lugs (top right, bottom), and absence of
pre-drilled mounting holes throughout.
9
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
Both the Main and West Side rooms use single-hole mechanical lugs throughout. Where deployed, these 1-hole
mechanical lugs do provide a degree of telecommunications bonding but do not represent “best practice” installations
as the industry standards – TIA-607-A and IEEE Standard 1100 – call for two-hole compression-style lugs for all
grounding and bonding terminations.
Best practices are adhered to in the “MPOE Room”, the “West Side Exp. IDF Room”, and the “Main IDF Room” by
using green jacketed copper conductors where these components are deployed. Conversely, foil strips or other non-
copper-cable conductors are installed in these rooms to act as “bonding” or “grounding” systems. These components
do not conform to any industry standards or best practices and are not capable of carrying the currents and Voltages
found in telecommunications bonding systems. Furthermore, these non-standard conductors can result in a false
sense of security for equipment and personnel protection, giving the appearance of a supplemental bonding system
while being unable to function as such.
In general, the telecommunications bonding network within TECHCO‟s Main and West Side facilities is not labeled,
tagged, or otherwise clearly marked.
10
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
Figure 3: Rack level Telecommunications Bonding Network installation practices in TECHCO Main and West Side
rooms. Non-compliant practices observed include unused single-hole mechanical lug (top left), cage-nut style
mounting points "floating" in painted equipment rack rails (top right), no thread forming screws used for any
equipment mounting points and unmounted equipment (bottom left), and adhesive foil strip “grounding tape” run
on top of rack rail (bottom right)
11
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
Figure 4: Active equipment Telecommunications Bonding installation practices in TECHCO Main and West
Side rooms. Practices observed include not using equipment manufacturer provided system ground
attachment pads (top left), un-bonded, un-racked stacked equipment (top right), and not installing
manufacturer provided equipment bonding jumpers (bottom).
12
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
Two pieces of key networking and computing gear – a Cisco Systems Catalyst 6513 switch and an HP C7000 blade
center, both located in the Main Server Room – are placed directly on the floor. There are no provisions for
grounding or bonding this gear to an appropriate telecommunications bonding network. Additionally, there is no cable
management or cabling pathway for this equipment. This represents a significant operational risk as all data cabling
runs are completely unprotected and run haphazardly on the floor.
Figure 5: Critical networking and computing equipment placed on floor in Main Server Room. Note
Cisco Catalyst 6513 switch (top left) and HP C7000 Blade Center (top right, bottom left) not
mounted in any equipment rack and absence of Telecommunications Bonding Network, proper
cable management, cable pathways, or cable patching organization (bottom right).
13
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
Best Practices
The telecommunications bonding system is more than just an insurance policy against a lightning strike or other
surge event. It is an active, functioning system that provides protection for personnel and equipment. The use of
best practices for proper telecommunications bonding deployment is essential for efficient network performance in
telecommunications spaces, computer rooms, and data centers.
A reliable network infrastructure is comprised of sufficient power and cooling capacity, effective telecommunications
bonding and proper grounding of system elements (active and passive), and pathways that route, manage, and
protect electrical and data cabling. Effectively managed cabling also maximizes the accessibility of other facilities
elements by enabling faster moves, adds, and changes (MACs) and by reducing required administration and
maintenance work.
By using robust systems comprised of quality components and materials, deployed according to industry standards
and best practices, network stakeholders can minimize network interruptions and maximize uptime and business
continuity.
The primary purpose of this system is to create a suitable path for the equalization of stray Voltages and their
resultant surge currents, allowing them to safely return to their source. Lightning, power system fault currents, circuit
switching (motors starting and stopping), activation of surge protection devices, and electrostatic discharges (ESD)
are common causes of transient Voltages and electrical surges.
Poorly designed or improperly implemented grounding, bonding, and shielding techniques often adversely affect the
performance of electronic equipment, from the circuit board level all the way up to and including the overall network
system. IT budgets can be quickly stressed when the additional cost to maintain and replace damaged equipment is
factored in – especially so when maintenance and replacement is due to an easily preventable cause such as
improper grounding and bonding. Moreover, personal injury from electric shock due to lack of grounding and bonding
systems or inappropriately deployed grounding and bonding can cause both immeasurable suffering and significant
expense.
14
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
According to these standards, reliable and effective grounding and bonding systems have the following general
characteristics:
1. Intentional design – each connection must be engineered and installed to properly handle the
anticipated surge currents.
2. Bonds all metallic components to the grounding system (e.g., equipment, racks, cabinets, access floors,
ladder racks, cable trays, water pipes, electrical conduit, building steel, etc.).
3. Visually verifiable and generally arranged for ease of inspection and testing.
4. Provides equalization paths and ports for ESD protection wrist straps.
5. Supports the proper operation of surge protection devices for equipment and power circuits.
6. Promotes electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) with the telecommunications closet, entrance facility, or
data center environment.
7. Adheres to all local electrical codes and utilizes components listed with a nationally recognized test lab
(such as Underwriters Laboratories, Inc., or similar).
15
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
Recommendations Summary
To bring TECHCO Incorporated‟s Main and West Side, San Francisco, CA, telecommunications bonding networks
into conformance with industry standards and best practices, we recommend each room be retrofitted using UL-
Listed products to meet J-STD-607-A, TIA-942, and IEEE Std 1100TM-2005 requirement. For racks and cabinets,
this translates to providing a dedicated bonding system comprised of dedicated bonding network jumpers, busbars,
and paint-piercing hardware. Each piece of active equipment should then be attached to this bonding system via
equipment bonding jumpers and bonding hardware. More specific recommendations for each of these areas – the
telecommunications rooms, racks, and active equipment – are detailed below.
Figure 6: Best practice layout and installation for Telecommunications Room bonding network
16
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
The bonding system should be connected with suitable wiring that is consistently sized, terminated, and visually
verifiable to ensure safety and ease of management. Industry standards recommend green or green-with-yellow-
stripe cable jacketing. Additionally, all bonding and grounding connections should be labeled and tagged at both
ends for clear identification and network continuity verification (traceability).
All telecommunications grounding busbars (TGBs) should then be grounded to the Telecommunications Main
Grounding Busbar (TMGB). The TMGB itself should be bonded to uncoated and unpainted building steel and
grounded to the electrical service ground according to J-STD-607-A guidelines. Each TGB within each room should
be bonded to uncoated and unpainted building steel and to the electrical panel serving equipment in the room.
The gauge of the connecting ground/earth cable, known as the Telecommunications Bonding Backbone (TBB) should
follow J-STD-607-A guidelines, as outlined in the table below.
The Telecommunications Bonding Backbone should be routed to each Telecommunications Grounding Busbar in as
straight a path as possible. The TBB should be installed as a continuous conductor, avoiding splices where possible.
As a final note, any metallic component that is part of the telecommunications space, computer room, or data center,
including all electronic equipment, racks, cabinets, ladder racks, enclosures, and cable trays, etc., must be properly
connected to the telecommunications bonding system.
17
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
Figure 7: Best practice deployment of telecommunications bonding network for cabinets and open racks
For the Main and West Side rooms, a Retrofit Cabinet Grounding Kit can be used to ensure proper grounding. The
Retrofit Cabinet Grounding Kit includes a copper busbar that acts as the main collection point before connecting to
the Telecommunications Bonding Network. The busbar can be mounted at the top or the bottom of each rack
depending on the location of the room-level Telecommunications Grounding Busbar. All equipment in the rack
should then be grounded to the busbar using equipment-grounding jumpers as described in “Detailed
Recommendations: Active Equipment”.
The rack-level busbar should then be connected to the telecommunications bonding network utilizing a common
bonding network jumper. PANDUIT‟s retrofit kit includes a #6 AWG cable with one factory installed two-hole
compression lug and hardware to connect to the busbar and one HTAP to connect to the Telecommunications
Bonding Network.
18
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
Figure 8: Best practice deployment of Retrofit Cabinet or Rack Grounding Busbar. Note use of two-hole
compression lug, mounting holes per NEMA standards, and paint-piercing mounting hardware
Figure 9: Best practice deployment for connecting rack or cabinet common bonding network jumper to
Telecommunications Bonding Backbone or Mesh Common Bonding Network via the use of HTAP
In addition to grounding the racks and cabinets, electrostatic discharge (ESD) ports should be mounted on the back
of every rack and cabinet and also on the front of every cabinet. These ESD ports should be mounted at
approximately 48 inches from the floor on both the front and the back of the racks and cabinets. The ESD ports
should be connected directly to the rack or cabinet rail and should be clearly labeled with protection identification
stickers directly above the ESD ports.
19
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
“Grounding through the equipment AC (alternating current) power cord does not meet the intent of this
standard. It is intended that the AC power ground path and the telecommunications ground path offer
redundant and specific ground paths for the equipment. While the AC-powered equipment typically has
a power cord that contains a ground wire, the integrity of this path to ground cannot be easily verified.
Rather than relying on the AC power cord ground wire, it is desirable that equipment be grounded in a
verifiable manner as described in this Standard.”
The best strategy to meet the intent of this statement is to use a discreet jumper wire that bonds from a lug mounting
pad (if provided by the manufacturer) on the active equipment and terminates via a two-hole compression lug at a
rack-level busbar. The busbar is then used to provide a visually verifiable, all-copper grounding path.
Figure 10: Best practice deployment of telecommunications bonding for active equipment. Note use of
equipment bonding jumpers featuring two-hole compression lugs (left image) and paint-piercing
equipment mounting screws (right image)
When equipment does not provide a lug mounting pad, the next best option is to bond the equipment mounting
flanges directly to the rack rails. If the equipment mounting flanges are painted or covered in a non-conductive
coating, bonding screws can be used to make this bond (i.e., thread-forming screws with serrations under the head of
the screw will remove coatings from the surface to which they are mounted).
All active equipment in TECHCO‟s facilities should be retrofitted with grounding jumpers that are connected with
thread forming screws to the rack rail.
20
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
Conclusions
An overview of observed telecommunications bonding systems determined that best practices are minimally in use
within TECHCO Incorporated‟s Main and West Side facilities and that significant remediation work will be required to
bring all rooms into compliance with industry standards and best practices. 62% of evaluated areas have no bonding
system whatsoever while the remaining 38% of evaluated areas are in partial compliance with telecommunications
bonding standards as a result of either incomplete telecommunications bonding networks or improperly deployed
systems and components.
To bring all of the Main and West Side facilities telecommunications bonding systems into alignment with industry
standards and best practices, the following remediation should be performed:
Each room: Deploy a telecommunications bonding solution that meets J-STD-607-A, TIA-942, and IEEE Std
1100TM-2005 (The Emerald Book™) requirements and utilizes UL-Listed or CSA-Certified products.
Equipment Racks: Provide a dedicated grounding and bonding system comprised of purpose-built components
(rack-level bonding busbar, paint-piercing hardware, lugs, ground conductors, etc.) which are engineered to
comply with US and International grounding requirements.
Active Equipment: Bond each piece of active network equipment to a grounding bus bar installed in
compliance with US and International grounding requirements
It is possible to retrofit and remediate existing installations at TECHCO „s site by deploying the appropriate
telecommunications bonding network systems and components. To this end, Panduit Global Professional Services
recommends taking the following actions and “next steps”:
Remediation planning: Develop a detailed remediation plan and inventory of remediation steps and associated
Bill-of-Materials for each site.
Installation: Install and/or retrofit all telecommunications bonding system components as identified in the
Remediation Plan. All installation work should performed by a PANDUIT Certified Installer (PCI).
Validation: Verify proper installation of telecommunications bonding networks and components to ensure
quality-of-work and compliance with industry standards and best practices. All verification work should be
performed by personnel certified by Panduit Global Professional Services.
21
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
Room Layout
P1 P2
22
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
P3 P4
P5 P6
P7 P8
23
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
P9 P10
P11 P12
P13 P14
24
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
P15 P16
P17 P18
P19
25
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
26
Grounding & Bonding Assessment – Sample Report Confidential Information
Note: Right and Left determined when looking at cabinet from the front
Notes:
1. Begin numbering items to be bonded (equipment, shielded patch panels) at the top of the rack
2. Always enter an item description for future identification
3. Itrems requiring bonding: active equipment associated with the IP network, shielded patch panels
27