Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Motivation
in Today’s
Workplace:
The Link to
Performance
SECOND QUARTER–2010
Motivation in Today’s Workplace:
The Link to Performance
ABSTRACT
In today’s hyper-competitive marketplace, understanding what fosters and forwards employee motivation—and,
thus, organizational performance—is critical. Based on theories, studies, best practices, case studies and
resources about motivation, this solutions-focused research article presents valuable information for the senior
HR leader seeking competitive advantage.
1
fact, some companies and research- without the other. To provide people that face-to-face interactions—no
ers are beginning to look at “work with meaningful work and rewards, matter how superficial—can lead
spirituality”—not in a religious organizations need to be successful. to significant improvements in
sense, but in a sense that what an And to be successful, organizations performance, and that motivation
employee does aligns with his or her need high-performing individuals. and performance increase simply
greater sense of life and purpose. The challenge is to design organiza- by an employee’s awareness of the
Aside from monetary gain, work tions that perform at high levels and impact of his or her job on others.
provides people with fulfillment on treat people in ways that are reward- Dr. Grant has observed this result
various levels, from earning a living ing and satisfying.” To describe this through studies of all types of
and “doing good work” to aspiring mutually beneficial relationship, jobs and roles in the workplace,
to a vision and ultimately having Lawler uses the term virtuous spiral, from customer service representa-
an impact on the quality of life. a relationship that occurs when the tives, managers, nurses, doctors
These reasons can change over time organization values its employees, and medical technicians to security
in response to changes in people’s and in return, workers are com- guards, engineers, salespeople,
home life and responsibilities. Fur- mitted to high performance.4 police officers and fire fighters—
ther, in response to drastic economic based on when people can directly
Leadership and Making
changes and natural disasters, com- see the impact of their efforts.5
a Difference
panies can change over time as well.3
In today’s pressure-cooker environ- Mini Case Study
Management Acknowledgment ment, performance is carefully noted In a study published in the Jour-
and Appreciation at all levels of the organization. No nal of Applied Psychology, Dr.
How employees are treated is a matter an individual’s title, everyone Grant found that lifeguards at
strong determinant of employee has the opportunity to lead in some a community recreation center
motivation and performance. capacity and have a positive impact who read about how their abil-
Edward E. Lawler III, author and on performance. Understanding the ity to avoid fatalities made a dif-
consultant for human resource value that can be achieved through ference were stronger leaders/
management, emphasizes that different roles is one way of provid- performers. Their work improved
“treating people right is funda- ing motivation, performance and by 40% in contrast to lifeguards
mental to creating organizational thus leadership skills. A recent article who merely learned that life-
effectiveness and success. It is also published on Knowledge@Wharton, guarding can be personally en-
easier said than done.” According titled “Putting a Face to a Name: riching. Grant points out that in
to Lawler, this includes “a highly The Art of Motivating Employ- today’s economy, where work
is often virtual without the end
user physically present, “it is im-
“Treating people right is fundamental to
portant for employers to build in
creating organizational effectiveness and systems that reinforce employ-
ees’ awareness of whom they
success. It is also easier said than done.”
are helping.”6 As HR leaders
work on processes and systems
complex set of actions on the part of ees,” emphasizes that workers have designed to improve motivation
both organizations and employees. better results when they can identify and performance, it is important
Organizations must develop ways to with those they serve. Specifically, to be cognizant of the issue of
treat their employees so that they are face-to-face interactions and task technology and how it can cre-
motivated and satisfied; employees significance (“what I do makes a dif- ate distance between employees
must behave in ways to help their ference”) are key drivers for motiva- and the end users of their work.
organizations become effective tion and performance. Research Dr. Grant suggests that focus on
and high-performing.” This win- by Adam Grant, Ph.D., a Wharton the mission of the organization is
ning combination for performance management professor, indicates that one way to overcome the chal-
requires a partnership between the making human connections is criti- lenge of a virtual workplace and
organization and the employees. cal for motivation, leadership and lack of direct interaction and is a
Lawler states: “One can’t succeed high job performance. He found successful strategy for creating
3
Employees need to have acknowl- a SHRM white paper “The Sci- place: 1) meeting basic expecta-
edgment and respect and know ence of Motivation,” emphasize tions (hygiene factors) and 2)
that their contributions are valued. that “people join organizations for leading to increased performance
It cannot be stressed enough how specific reasons and usually with (motivation factors). Examples
demotivating it can be when manag- some purpose in mind.” The white of basic needs are a comfortable
ers do not recognize, acknowledge paper highlights the following theo- working environment, adequate
or appreciate employees and their ries that have shaped the concept pay, good relationships with co-
hard work. Two strategies that can of motivation in the workplace:14 workers and effective supervision.
help motivate employees are 1) to Motivation factors for high job
provide training (including cur-
■■ Expectancy Theory: Victor H. satisfaction include opportuni-
rent job, new technologies and the Vroom’s theory suggests that ties for recognition, advance-
ability to keep up with changes in motivation is high when employ- ment and professional growth.
the employees’ areas of expertise) ees believe that high levels of ■■ McClelland’s Needs for
and 2) promotional opportuni- effort lead to high performance Achievement, Affiliation
ties (promote from within).11 and high performance leads to and Power: In this theory
attainment of desired outcomes. from David McClelland, each
Positive and supportive leadership Maslow’s Hierarchy of
■■
person has three needs: 1)
clearly makes the difference for an Needs: People seek to satisfy five achievement—strong desire to
engaged and motivated workforce. basic needs: physiological, safety, perform well; 2) affiliation—
In an interview with Hospitals and belongingness, self-esteem and being liked, having positive
Health Networks, Jo Manion, R.N.,
self-actualization needs. Abraham interpersonal relationships; and
Ph.D., points to the bottom line
Maslow placed these needs in a 3) power—the extent to which
for hospital and patient care, as
pyramid, with the most basic on an individual desires control or
outlined in her book, The Engaged
the bottom and self-actualization influence on others. People have
Workforce: Proven Strategies to Build
at the top. When the lower-level these needs to varying degrees.
a Positive Health Care Workforce.12
needs are met, the next higher ■■ Equity Theory: Formulated by J.
Since excellent health care is criti-
level begins to motivate behavior. Stacy Adams, this theory is about
cal for everyone at different points
■■ Herzberg’s Motivator-Hygiene people’s perceptions of fairness of
in life, employee motivation that
Theory: This theory from Fred- their work outcomes in relation to
results in excellent patient care is
erick Herzberg focuses on two their work inputs. It suggests that
one example of motivation that
factors applicable to the work- motivation is influenced by com-
all can relate to on personal and
professional levels (see text box).
Inspired Staff Make the Difference in Difficult Times13
Motivational Theories In the health care field, engaged and motivated employees make the dif-
As HR professionals seek to support ference in patient care. From her years as a nurse and executive working
their organizations in attracting in hospitals, Dr. Manion emphasizes that it is hospital leaders who hold
and retaining the best and bright- the key to promoting passion in employees for their work, thus retain-
est talent, motivational theories can ing essential talent and saving the organization money. By establishing a
offer insight into how to motivate workplace that promotes well-being, leadership can inspire staff, resulting
employees, what is important and in loyalty to the organization and to the patients and their families. “If you
what the rewards may be—with the have engaged workers who are happy to be there, who feel happy about
ultimate goal of improved and/or what they do, who feel respected, who feel honored, then they treat people
sustained performance by individual the same way: It ripples. Patients can pick up unhappiness in employees in
a nanosecond.” She urges leaders to know and understand their employ-
employees and the organization
ees. Also, through workforce mapping, HR leaders can better understand
as a whole. Motivation is at the
the demographics of the workforce, learn who plans to retire in five years
heart of performance, essential for
and then be able to look to the future for retention and hiring. The quality of
success for both the organization
patient service depends on an inspired and motivated staff.
and its workforce, as a group and
Source: The Engaged Workforce: Proven Strategies to Build a Positive Health Care Workforce (American
as individuals. Dr. Teresa A. Daniel Hospital Association, 2009)
and Dr. Gary S. Metcalf, authors of
5
2. Psychological Capital: Developing “carrots and sticks” approach to ager as a role model, the following
the Human Competitive Edge. motivation, noting that tradi- key relationships are identified as
In their 2007 book, researchers tional rewards (“if-then”) do not essential for motivational success—
Fred Luthans, Carolyn M. Youssef give people what they want and, all inter-related and contributing
and Bruce J. Avolio present their in fact, tend to diminish intrinsic toward feelings of motivation:21
PsyCap theory with a compelling motivation and performance and
1. Organizational structure and
view of factors critical to motiva- can encourage unethical behaviors
processes—performance manage-
tion and performance. Resilience and foster short-term think-
ment, reward systems, training,
is a key component of PsyCap, de- ing. The three elements of true
interesting work—must be sup-
fined as “the capacity to rebound motivation—autonomy, mastery
ported by a clear vision, strong
or bounce back from adversity, and purpose—will lead to greater
communication processes, quality
conflict, failure, or even positive performance, particularly when
decision-making and an organiza-
events, progress and increased the objective is in the service of a
responsibility.” The PsyCap higher cause.20 tional culture of mutual respect.
resiliency process is not a linear ex- 2. Organizations need to pay atten-
perience; rather, the assets and risk A Study on Employee tion to the working environment.
factors—as a group—are both cu- Engagement and Motivation For example, too many meetings
mulative and interactive in nature, The Ashridge Business School, and poor meeting management
with implications for performance one of the world’s leading business will have a negative impact on
and the development of resiliency schools, conducted a study about employees’ level of motivation.
of leaders, employees and organi- motivation from the employee view- 3. The individual employee needs
zations. For example, confidence, point. While financial rewards were to know what motivates him or
hope and optimism are assets in often mentioned, the most common her and be aware of how work
the resiliency process. The resilient were intrinsic motivators. The top satisfies these needs. The manager
leader has the ability to grow in most important motivator was the and/or organization can sup-
times of turmoil, managing and work itself, followed by the need for port this process by facilitating
integrating assets, risk factors and work to be challenging and interest- opportunities for employees to
values. Such leaders use resiliency ing as well as valued and recognized meet, talk and share their views
as a tool to assist employees to see by the organization. The key moti- with colleagues and managers.
difficult times as opportunities for vators were praise and recognition 4. Colleagues: Working with people
advancement (career resiliency), from the manager and the organi- who respect and support each
thus owning more of the respon- zation, and celebration of success. other is positively motivating.
sibility for success for themselves The study also found that a very
and for the organization.19 As Lu- important theme is the employee A New Model for
thans notes, “The current reality is desire for autonomy and freedom to Employee Motivation
not if employees will need to draw do his or her job, the ability to make In their 2002 book, Driven: How
from their psychological capital decisions and the authority to deliver Human Nature Shapes Our Choices,
resilience in order to recover and the work in a way the employee con- researchers Paul R. Lawrence and
reinvent themselves, but when.” siders the best. Another important Nitin Nohria identify four basic
3. Drive: The Surprising Truth employee motivator is being trusted emotional needs/drives. These
About What Motivates Us. In his to get the job done—without being drives, based on research in cross-
2009 book, author Daniel H. micro-managed. Other key themes disciplinary fields such as biol-
Pink states, “The secret to high are communication, objectives and ogy, evolutionary psychology and
performance and satisfaction—at goals, and a shared vision. Ulti- neuroscience, are: 1) acquire (obtain
work, at school, and at home—is mately, the quality of leadership scarce goods, including intangibles
the deeply human need to direct is paramount to good employee such as social status); 2) bond (form
our own lives, to learn and create morale. Poor leadership will result in connections with individuals and
new things, and to do better by poor employee engagement and thus groups); 3) comprehend (master the
ourselves and our world.” Pink in poor performance. In addition to world around us); and 4) defend
challenges the organizational the critical function of the man- (protect against external threats
7
engagement. This group of young stand what motivates the Millennial than those that differentiate us.
workers has a distinctly different set generation and learn to use these In my experience, employees
of expectations than other gen- factors to the advantage of both everywhere want to feel respected
erations.26 Cam Marson, author of the employee and the employer. and treated fairly, to work for an
Motivating the “What’s in it for me” employer in which they have pride
Global HRM and Motivation
Workforce, notes that while Millen- and to have an opportunity to
In an interview about motiva-
nials expect to be accommodated by grow. What is critical is for HR
tion, SHRM talked with Kenneth
their employer, it is strongly recom- and business leaders to understand
Somers, a member of the SHRM
mended that young workers learn how these universals manifest in
Global Special Expertise Panel.
everything they can from the older varying cultures. Understanding
Somers has more than 30 years of
generations. He points out that the and applying those learnings with
experience in senior HR leader-
Millennial workers have a responsi- sincerity and consistency is the table
ship roles, working both domesti-
bility in the work relationship, too, stakes for successfully motivat-
cally and internationally in global
and that it is not all about them.27 ing performance across borders.
organizations. This exchange offers
Further, in a unique position in a close-up view of key aspects SHRM: What are some of the
time, Millennials are the first gen- about motivation and performance ways that HR leaders can create a
eration to be part of a truly global in today’s global marketplace. workplace that is motivating in a
economy. Most have had access global company, and why would
SHRM: In the global HRM
to technology all of their lives. A this make a difference for over-
context, when you think of moti-
2010 study by Accenture explored all performance—of employees
vation—regarding the individual
how students and young work- and, thus, the organization?
employee and as a key factor for
ers in 13 countries use technology
organizational performance—what Somers: There are many things
in their personal and professional
are some of the top issues that come that employers can do to stimulate
lives. The findings are important
to mind and why are they impor- greater engagement. If you agree
for HR and organizational lead-
tant in today’s global workplace? that the bigger challenge is to
ers because there is a direct line
create sustainable engagement,
to talent management. The study Somers: This is a place where the
it then follows that sustainable
points out that companies that “fail research and my own anecdotal
engagement flows from consistent,
to embrace Millennial behavior experience coalesce. Employees
high-quality people leadership.
are at risk of failing to attract and everywhere are recession and RIF-
Employers need to take these steps:
retain new hires, while also seeing weary. Those whose positions have
their competitive edge erode from not been affected by reductions are ■■ Communicate with staff on a
lack of innovation in information looking for signs that “it” is over. regular basis: Everyone under-
technology.” Regardless of country, Neither businesses nor governments stands the world has changed.
Millennials are jumping ahead of the have defined the “new normal.” Explain what is going on, how
boundaries of corporate IT. They Most people are hunkered down it affects the business and the
expect to use their own technology/ and only marginally engaged. The resulting impact on people. Tell
devices in the workplace, and 45% corollary is that businesses will be the truth without drama. But
of Millennials globally use social impeded in their attempts to tap into even more importantly, tell a
networking sites at work, even if employees’ discretionary capacity. story about where you are going.
there is a corporate policy prohibit- Engagement also flows from
SHRM: In your experience in
ing it. Additionally, 72% of Millen- people buying into a future
the global marketplace, what are
nials in India, 52% in the United and wanting to be part of it.
some of the primary motivators
States and 45% in China say that an ■■ Follow communications with
for employees and why are they
important factor in their choice of actions that are consistent
important for HR leaders and
employer is the organization’s use of with the messaging. If part of
organizational leaders to know?
state-of-the-art equipment.28 Thus, the future story is to capture
to be competitive today, HR and Somers: I believe there are more market share from a previously
organizational leaders must under- motivators we hold in common untapped segment, create and
9
PROJECT TEAM
Project leader: Nancy R. Lockwood, M.A., SPHR, GPHR manager, HR Content Program, SHRM Research
Project contributors: Chana Anderson, CCP, SPHR-CA, SHRM Employee Relations Special Expertise Panel member
Margaret Fiester, SPHR, operations manager, SHRM HR Knowledge Center
Kenneth Somers, SHRM Global Special Expertise Panel member
This publication may not be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in whole or in part, in any form or by any means,
electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the Society for Human Resource
Management, 1800 Duke Street, Alexandria, VA 22314, USA.
ABOUT SHRM
The Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) is the world’s largest association devoted to human resource management.
Representing more than 250,000 members in over 140 countries, the Society serves the needs of HR professionals and advances
the interests of the HR profession. Founded in 1948, SHRM has more than 575 affiliated chapters within the United States and
subsidiary offices in China and India. Visit SHRM Online at www.shrm.org.
Disclaimer
This report is published by the Society for Human Resource Management. All content is for informational purposes only and is
not to be construed as a guaranteed outcome. The Society for Human Resource Management cannot accept responsibility for any
errors or omissions or any liability resulting from the use or misuse of any such information. Reference to any specific commercial
product, process or service by trade name, trademark, service mark, manufacturer or otherwise does not constitute or imply
endorsement,
ISBN: 978-1-586-44200-2
SHRM Store# 62.37010
10-0235