Nomos 17

auction 17
zurich, 26 october 2018
nomos 17
nomos ag, numismatists

zähringerstrasse 27, 8001 zurich, switzerland
phone +41 44 250 51 80, info@nomosag.com
www.nomosag.com zurich, switzerland
nomos . . . . . . auction 17, zürich 26 october 2018 1
zürich, switzerland
auction 17
zürich, 26 october 2018
greek, roman, byzantine, islamic coins and european medals
D SCHW
AN
EI
KER VERB
ZE

R BER
zähringerstrasse 27, ch-8001 zürich, switzerland

phone +41 44 250 51 80, fax +41 44 250 51 89, mobile +41 79 270 86 06
TI
FS
A NU info@nomosag.com, www.nomosag.com
MISM
2 nomos . . . . . . auction 17, zürich 26 october 2018
Limmatquai 54, 8001 Zürich, Switzerland

Tel. + 41 44 251 37 40
time table – zeittafel – ordre de vente

friday 26 october 2018, 12:00 – 16:00 lots 323
viewing – besichtigung – exposition

the coins can be viewed
mondays through fridays from 10 a.m. until 5 p.m.,
and at other times by appointment
the coins can also be viewed online at

www.nomosag.com and at
during the auction live online bidding

is available through
Die Auktion erfolgt unter Mitwirkung eines

Beamten des Stadtammannamtes Zürich I.
Jede Haftung des anwesenden Beamten,
der Gemeinde und des Staates für Handlungen
des Auktionators entfällt.
© 2018 Nomos AG, Zürich

Versteigerungsbedingungen Conditions générales de vente
Die Auktion erfolgt gegen Bezahlung in Schweizer La vente aux enchères a lieu au comptant, en francs-
Franken mit einem Aufgeld von 20% auf den Zu- suisses, et le prix d’adjudication est augmenté de frais
schlagspreis. Ein zusätzliches Aufgeld von 2.5% wird à la charge de l’acheteur de 20%. Des frais
bei allen erfolgreichen Life Internet Geboten additionnels de 2.5% sont ajoutés pour les enchères
hinzugerechnet. Für Auslieferungen in der Schweiz victorieuses effectuées par Internet en temps réel (“live
erhöht sich der Endpreis (Zuschlagspreis und Aufgeld auction bidding”). En cas de livraison en Suisse, au
und Versandspesen) für Silber- und Bronzemünzen prix d’achat global (comprenant le prix d’adjudi-
sowie Medaillen um die MWST von 7.7 %. Im Ausland cation, les frais acheteurs, et les frais d’expédition)
erhobene Gebühren irgendwelcher Art sind vom doit être appliqué la T.V.A. Suisse de 7.7% sur les
Käufer zu bezahlen. Der Gesamtpreis ist nach erfolg- monnaies et les médailles d’argent et de bronze. Tous
tem Zuschlag fällig. Das Eigentumsrecht wird erst mit droits et taxes dus à l’étranger sont à la charge de
der vollständigen Bezahlung vom Käufer erworben. l’acheteur. Le paiement est dû immédiatement après
Für verspätete Zahlung wird ein Verzugszins von 1% l’adjudication. 1% d’intérêt sera facturé en cas de
pro Monat in Rechnung gestellt. Gebote, die 80% des retard. Le transfert de propriété n’est effectif qu’après
Schätzpreises unterschreiten, können nicht berück- le paiement intégral. Les ordres d’achats inférieurs à
sichtigt werden. Schriftliche Gebote haben Vorrang. 80% de nos estimations ne seront pas prix en compte.
A montant égal, les ordres d’achat écrits sont
Jeder Ersteigerer verpflichtet sich, für die durch ihn prioritaires.
getätigte Erwerbung persönlich zu haften. Er kann
nicht geltend machen, im Auftrag Dritter gehandelt zu Chaque adjudicataire s’engage pour ses achats, et il ne
haben. Der Zuschlag verpflichtet zur Abnahme. peut prétendre avoir porté enchères pour le compte
d’un tiers. L’adjudication est un engagement irrévo-
Die Beschreibung der Stücke und deren Erhaltungs- cable pour l’acquéreur.
grade erfolgt nach bestem Wissen und Gewissen. Die
Echtheit der Stücke wird garantiert. Berechtigte Les descriptions des lots, et leurs états de conser-
Reklamationen werden bis 8 Tage nach Erhalt der vation, sont données en bonne foi. L’authenticité des
Stücke berücksichtigt. Der Versand der ersteigerten monnaies est garantie. Toute réclamation justifiée
Stücke erfolgt nach vollständiger Bezahlung der Rech- sera prise en compte pendant les huit jours qui suivent
nung auf Kosten und Risiko des Käufers. Im Übrigen la remise des monnaies. L’envoi des lots adjugés sera
kommen die ortsüblichen Gantbedingungen zur effectué, après paiement, aux frais et aux risques de
Anwendung. l’acheteur.
Der Versand in die Russische Föderation erfolgt La livraison a la Russie est expressément soumise au
ausdrücklich auf eigenes Risiko des Empfängers. propre risque du destinataire.
Gerichtsstand für alle Verfahren ist Zürich 1. Nur der Les conditions locales de vente aux enchères seront
deutsche Text der Auktionsbedingungen ist appliquées. Seul le texte allemand de ces conditions de
rechtsgültig. Durch Abgabe eines mündlichen oder vente fait foi. En tant que de besoin, le tribunal
schriftlichen Gebotes werden die vorliegenden responsable sera celui de Zürich 1. Tout enchérisseur,
Auktionsbedingungen anerkannt. oral ou écrit, reconnaît avoir pris connaissance des
conditions générales de vente ci-dessus.
Conditions of Sale
All sales will be made through payment in Swiss

Francs, with the addition of a buyer’s premium of 20%
on the hammer price. An additional charge of 2.5%
will be added to the invoice of all successful live
internet bids. For all lots delivered in Switzerland
there is an additional Swiss VAT of 7.7% due on the
hammer price and on the buyer’s premium for silver
and bronze coins, and for medals. The purchaser is
responsible for all taxes and fees due for delivery of
lots outside of Switzerland. Payment is due imme-
diately following conclusion of the sale. Full title to
purchases is only obtained upon full payment. A
charge of 1% per month will be assessed for delayed
payments. Bids below 80% of the estimated prices will
not be accepted. Written bids take preference over
room bids.
Buyers are personally responsible for their own

purchases and cannot claim to act on the account or
instructions of a third party. Adjudication occurs on
the fall of the hammer and commits the bidder to
acceptance of the lot.
The lot descriptions, including the degree of

preservation, are opinions and made in good faith.
The authenticity of all coins is guaranteed. Justified
complaints can only be considered if made within
eight days of the auction. Upon receipt of full
payment, shipment of lots will be arranged for the
purchaser at his expense and risk. In general, the usual
conditions applied to auctions held in Zürich apply
here.
Shipping to the Russian Federation is expressly made

subject to the recipient’s own risk.
Exclusive jurisdiction for any legal proceedings shall

be Zürich 1. Although the Conditions of Sale are
provided in English, French and German, only the
German text is legally valid. The bidder accepts these
conditions of sale by the submission of a bid, whether
verbal or written.
Foreword
Welcome to Nomos auction 17: as usual, we have tried to put together an interesting sale, even an exciting one
– we do hope you will enjoy it!
In choosing the coins, we have to try to not only find coins that you will like, but that we like too: they have to
be in excellent condition, to be attractive, to ideally be at least scarce, they should be interesting, and if they
have a pedigree it would be a very nice bonus. In any case, we have put together a sale containing 228 lots of
Celtic and Greek coins, 82 of Roman and Provincial, 7 Byzantine, 2 Islamic, and 4 medals.
This year we will begin selling the Vineyard Collection, a specialized group put together by a collector who is
passionate about wine: all his coins are wine-related in some way. We see wine vessels, for storing, serving
and drinking; we have the gods, goddesses, silens, satyrs and nymphs who are connected to wine; grapevines
and grapes; and coins from cities known for their wine. Very considerable numbers of coins from the
Vineyard Collection will also appear in forthcoming Obolos sales.
But, of course, that’s not all! We have quite a few other wonderful Greek coins, also often with extensive
pedigrees (like the Syracusan tetradrachm in lot 49 – est. CHF 12 500 – that goes back to an English
provincial sale in 1884; or the Punic tetradrachm published by Jenkins – 66, est. 37 500 – that was previously
in the Gillet, Lockett, Locker-Lampson, Weber, Woodward, Rothschild, Carfrae, Bompois and Wigan
Collections!). There is also one of the finest and rarest of all Greek portrait coins (149, est. 24 000, a
tetradrachm with an astoundingly realistic head of Mithradates VI of Pontus).
A highlight of the Roman section is the DeBakey Collection of aurei, which includes coins with good portraits
and interesting reverses (like 253, the aureus of Hadrian with the Disciplina reverse that goes back to Adda
and VQR in 1913: est. 25 000). Otherwise, there are coins from a variety of owners, in a variety of price
ranges: like the extremely rare assarion of Geta from island of Naxos (283, est. 450) or, moving into the
Byzantine period, the very rare billon 30 nummia piece of Justinian II from the mint of Rome (314, est.
1 000 – We have actually never seen one of these before!).
But you will see these and everything else when you look at the catalogue!
Dr. Alan S. Walker Dimitrios Gerothanasis
Checks
Do note that because of ever increasing expenses and both governmental and banking formalities, we can no
longer accept checks.
Special Note
In accordance with US Customs and Border Protection regulations (CFR Part 12), we attest that all ancient
Greek coins of “Italian Type”, from mints that are now within the modern boundaries of Italy, were outside of
Italy prior to 19 January 2011. We also attest that all ancient Greek coins of “Greek Type”, from mints that are
now within the modern boundaries of Greece, were outside of Greece prior to 17 July 2011. And we also attest
that all ancient Greek coins of “Bulgarian Type”, from mints that are now within the modern boundaries of
Bulgaria, were outside of Bulgaria prior to 16 January 2014. In addition, we attest that all coins from mints that
are now within the modern boundaries of Egypt, Iraq or Syria were outside of those countries no later than
2005.
biddr - Live Bidding System
Join our auction simply and conveniently from home. Our live bidding
system does not require Java or anything else other than an
up-to-date web browser and works on all modern devices such as
computers, notebooks, tablets and smartphones.
Important: If you have not signed up yet, please note that you have to register and
get approved as a live bidder at www.biddr.ch/auctions/nomos/ in time before you
can participate in our auction.
i r auction systems
Bibliography Auction 17
ABW C. Arnold-Biucchi, et al. “A Greek Archaic Silver Hoard from Selinus” in ANSMN
33 (1988).
ACGC C. Kraay. Archaic and Classical Greek Coins. London. 1976.
AGC G. Bernardi. Arabic Gold Coins. Vol. I. Trieste. 2010.
Agora J.H. Kroll, The Athenian Agora XXVI. The Greek Coins. Princeton, 1993.
Album S. Album. A Check-List of Islamic Coins. 3 ed. Santa Rosa, 2011.
rd
Alföldi M. R. Alföldi. Caesar in 44 v. Chr. Bonn, 1985

Alram M. Alram, Nomina Propria Iranica in Nummis. IPNB 4. Vienna, 1986.
Amandry M. Amandry. “Les tétradrachmes frappés à Lébédos” in Kraay-Mørkholm Essays.
Louvain. 1989.
AMNG Die antiken Münzen Nord-Griechenlands. Berlin. 1898-1935.
Anastasi M. Anastasi. Monete bizantine di Sicilia. NP. 2009.
Anokhin V.A. Anokhin, Monetnoe delo Khersonesa. Kiev, 1977.
Arnold-Biucchi C. Arnold-Biucchi, The Beginnings of Coinage in the West: Archaic Selinus.
FlorNum.
Ashton R. Ashton, “The Coinage of Rhodes 408 – c. 190 BC”, in Money and its Uses, Oxford
2001.
Asyut M.J. Price & N. Waggoner. Archaic Greek Silver Coinage: The Asyut Hoard. London.
1975
Babelon E. Babelon, Monnaies de la Republique Romaine. Paris, 1885.
Bahrfeldt M. von Bahrfeldt, Die Römische Goldmünzenprägung während der Republik und
unter Augustus. Halle, 1923.
Balcer J.M. Balcer, “The Early Silver Coinage of Teos”, SNR 47 (1968).
B&S A. Banti & L. Simonetti. Corpus Nummorum Romanorum. Florence, 1972-1979.
Banti A. Banti. I Grandi Bronzi Imperiali. 9 Vols. Florence. 1983-1986.
Barron J. P. Barron, The Silver Coins of Samos. London, 1966.
Basel H. Cahn, et al., Griechische Münzen aus Grossgriechenland und Sizilien. Basel,
1988.
Bastien P. Bastien, Le buste monétaire des empereurs romains, I-III. Wetteren, 1992-1994.
-, Monnaie et Donativa au Bas-Empire. Wetteren. 1988.
BCD BCD Akarnania. Münzen und Medaillen DE 23, 18 October 2007.
BCD Boiotia. Triton IX, 10 January 2006.
BCD Corinth. Lanz 105, 26 November 2001.
BCD Euboia. Lanz 111, 25 November 2002.
BCD Lokris - Phokis. NAC 55, 8 October 2010.
BCD Olympia. Leu Numismatics 90, 10 May 2004.
BCD Peloponnesos (I). LHS 96, 8 May 2006.
BCD Peloponnesos II. Classical Numismatic Group 81, 20 May 2009.
BCD Thessaly. Nomos 4, 10 May 2011.
Bedoukian P.Z. Bedoukian. “Coinage of the Armenian Kingdoms of Sophene and Commagene”
in ANSMN 28 (1983).
Bemolt A.J. Bemolt van Loghum Slaterus, Nederlandse familiepenningen tot 1813. Zutphen,
1981.
Betts C. W. Betts, American Colonial History Illustrated by Contemporary Medals. New
York, 1894.
Biaggi Anon. Untitled Photographic Plates of the Leo Biaggi de Blasys Collection of Roman
Gold Coins. Photographs by S. Hurter, c. 1977.
E. Biaggi. Monete e zecche medievali italiane dal seculo VIII al seculo XV. Torino.
1992.
BMFA A. B. Brett, Catalogue of Greek Coins. Boston Museum of Fine Arts. Boston, 1955.
BMC Various authors, Catalogue of the Greek Coins in the British Museum. 29 volumes.
London, 1873-1927
H. Mattingly et al., Coins of the Roman Empire in the British Museum. London,
1932-1962.
BMCRR H. A. Grueber, Coins of the Roman Republic in the British Museum. London, 1910.
BN J. Giard, et al., Bibliothèque Nationale, Catalogue des Monnaies de l’Empire
Romain. Paris, 1976-.
Bodenstedt F. Bodenstedt, Die Elektronmünzen von Phokaia und Mytilene. Tübingen, 1981.
Boehringer C. Boehringer, Chronologie, Zur Chronologie mittelhellenistischer Münzserien
220-160 v.Chr. Berlin. 1972.
Die Münzgeschichte von Leontini in klassischer Zeit. Studies Price.
-. Kataneische. “Kataneische Probleme: Silberne Kleinstmünzen” in Proceedings of
the 9th International Congress of Numismatics (Louvain-la-Neuve, 1982).
-. Ognina. “Rekonstruktion des Schatzfundes von Ognina 1923” SNR 57 (1978).
E. Boehringer, Die Münzen von Syrakus. Berlin, 1929.
Bopearachchi O. Bopearachchi, Monnaies Gréco-Bactriennes et Indo-Grecques. Paris, 1991.
Burgos A. Burgos, La moneda hispanica desde sus origenes hasta el siglo V. Madrid, 1987.
CAA P.Z. Bedoukian. Coinage of the Artaxiads of Armenia. London. 1978.
Cahn H. A. Cahn, Knidos – Die Münzen des sechsten und fünften Jahrhunders v. Chr.
AMUGS IV. Berlin, 1970.
Calciati R. Calciati, Corpus Nummorum Siculorum: la monetazione de bronzo. Mortara,
1983-1987.
See: Pegasi.
Calicó X. Calicó, The Roman Aurei Catalogue. Barcelona, 2003.
Callataÿ F. de Callataÿ, “Le monnayage d'argent au type d'Athéna Parthénos émis au nom des
Ainianes” in Obolos 7.
-, “Les statères de Pergame et les réquisitions d’Alexandre le Grand: l’apport d’un
nouveau trésor (’Statères de Pergame 2004’)” in RN 169 (2012).
-, L’histoire des guerres Mithridatiques vue par les monnaies. Louvain-L-Neuve,
1997.
Caltabiano M. C. Caltabiano, La monetazione di Messana: Con le emissioni di Rhegion dell’età
della Tirannide. Berlin, 1993.
Campana A. Campana. La monetazione degli insorti Italici durante la Guerra sociale (91-87
A.C.). Modena, 1987.
Carradice I. Carradice, Coinage and Administration in the Athenian and Persian Empires. BAR
343. Oxford, 1987.
Casabonne O. Casabonne. La Cilicie à l'époque achéménide. Persika 3. Paris. 2004.
CCCBM D. Allen, et al. Catalogue of the Celtic Coins in the British Museum. London, 1987-.
Cohen H. Cohen, Description historique des monnaies frappées sous l’Empire Romain. 8
vols. Paris, 1880-1892.
Crawford M. Crawford, Roman Republican Coinage. Cambridge, 1974.
CRI D. Sear, The History and Coinage of the Roman Imperators 49-27 BC. London,
1998.
CSE A. Houghton, Coins of the Seleucid Empire from the Collection of Arthur
Houghton. ACNAC 4. New York, 1983.
Dattari G. Dattari, Numi Augg. Alexandrini. Cairo, 1901.
D&T L.-P. Delestrée & M. Tache, Nouvel atlas des monnaies Gauloises. Saint-Germain-
en-Laye, 2002-2008.
Delbridge J.M. Humpris & D. Delbridge. The Coinage of the Opountian Lokrians. London,
2014.
De Luynes J. Babelon, Catalogue de la collection de Luÿnes. Paris, 1924-1936.
De Nanteuil H. de Nanteuil, Collection de monnaies grecques. Paris, 1925.
Dengate J.A. Dengate. “The Triobols of Megalopolis” in MN 13 (1967).
Denicke J. Denicke, Die Brakteaten der Münzstätte Braunschweig 1: Heinrich der Löwe. 1983.
Depeyrot G. Depeyrot, Les monnaies d’or. Wetteren, 1995-1996.
DLT H. de la Tour, Atlas de monnaies Gauloises. Paris, 1892.
Desneux J. Desneux. “Les tétradrachmes d’Akanthos” in RBN 95 (1949)
Dewing L. Mildenberg & S. Hurter, eds., The Dewing Collection of Greek Coins. ACNAC 6.
New York, 1985.
DOC A. Bellinger & P. Grierson, et al. Catalogue of Byzantine in the Dumbarton Oaks
Collection and the Whittemore Collection. Washington DC, 1966-1999.
Donum Burns R. Göbl. Donum Burns. Die Küsanmünzen im Münzkabinett Bern und die
Chronologie. Wien. 1971.
Du Chastel F. de Callataÿ & J. van Heesch, Greek and Roman Coins from the Du Chastel
Collection. London, 1999.
EHC O. Mørkholm. Early Hellenistic Coinage from the Accession of Alexander the Great
to the Peace of Apamea. Cambridge. 1991
Elmer G. Elmer, Die Münzprägung der gallischen Kaiser von Postumus bis Tetricus in
Köln, Trier und Mailand. Bonner Jahrbücher 146, 1941.
Emmett K. Emmett. Alexandrian Coins. Lodi. 2001.
ESM E.T. Newell, revised by O. Mørkholm, The Coinage of the Eastern Seleucid Mints
from Seleucus I to Antiochus III. ANSNS 1, 1978
Essays Robinson C.M.Kraay & G.K. Jenkins, eds., Essays in Greek Coinage Presented to Stanley
Robinson. Oxford, 1968.
Essays Thompson O. Mørkholm & N.M. Waggoner, Greek Numismatics and Archaeology: Essays in
Honor of Margaret Thompson. Wetteren, 1979
Fischer-Bossert W. Fischer-Bossert, Chronologie der Didrachmenprägung von Tarent. Berlin, 1999.
Flesche B. Ziegaus, Kelten Geld: Münzen der Kelten und angrenzender nichtgriechischer
Völkerschaften. Sammlung Flesche. Münich, 2010.
Florence F. Catalli, Sylloge Nummorum Romanorum Italia. Firenze. I. Caesar Augustus.
Florence, 2012.
FlorNum H. Nilsson, ed. Florilegium Numismaticum: Studia in Honorem U. Westermark.
Stockholm, 1992.
Franke P.R. Franke, Die antiken Münzen von Epirus. Wiesbaden, 1961.
Frederiks J. W. Frederiks, De Meesters der Plaquette-Penningen. Amsterdam, 1943.
Füeg F. Füeg, Corpus of the Nomismata from Anastasius to John II in Constantinople,
713-976. Lancaster & London, 2007.
Gallatin A. Gallatin, Syracusan Dekadrachms of the Euainetos Type. Cambridge, 1930.
Gartland S.D. Gartland. “The Electrum Coinage of Thebes” in NC 173 (2013).
Geissen A. Geissen, Katalog alexandrinischer Kaisermünzen, Köln. Cologne, 1974-1983.
Georgiou E. Georgiou. “The mint of Lamia” in Obolos 7
Gielow H. E. Gielow, Die Silberprägung von Dankle-Messana. MBNG 48, 1930.
Gnecchi F. Gnecchi, I Medaglioni Romani. Milan, 1912.
Göbl R. Göbl, Die Münzprägung des Kaisers Aurelianus (270/75). MIR 47. Vienna, 1995.
Gulbenkian E.S.G. Robinson, et al. A Catalogue of the Calouste Gulbenkian Collection of Greek
Coins. Lisbon, 1971 & 1990.
Gutmann-Schwabacher F. Gutmann & W. Schwabacher, Tetradrachmen und Didrachmen von Himera (472-
409 v. Chr.). MBNG 47, 1929.
Häberle A. Häberle, Ulmer Münz- und Geldgeschichte des Mittelalters. Ulm, 1935.
Haeberlin Cahn & Hess, 17 July 1933 (E. J. Haeberlin).
Head B.V. Head. On the chronological sequence of the coins of Boeotia. London, 1881.
Hendin D. Hendin, Guide to Biblical Coins. 5 Edition. New York, 2010.
th
Herzfelder H. Herzfelder, Les monnaies d’argent de Rhegion. Paris, 1957.

Hill P. V. Hill, The Monuments of Ancient Rome as Coin Types. London, 1989.
-, The Undated Coins of Rome A.D. 98-148. London, 1970-
HN III N.K. Rutter. Historia Numorum Italy. London, 2001.
HPM J. Svoronos, L’Hellénisme primitive de la Macédoine, prouvé par la numismatique et
l’or du Pangée. Paris and Athens, 1919.
Holloway R.R. Holloway, The Thirteen-Months Coinage of Hieronymous of Syracuse. Berlin,
1969.
Holloway-Jenkins - & G. K. Jenkins, Terina. Bellinzona, 1983.
Humphris & Delbridge J.M. Humphris & D. Delbridge. The Coinage of the Opountian Lokrians. RNSSP 50.
London. 2014.
Ierardi M. Ierardi. “Tetradrachms of Agathocles of Syracuse” AJN 7-8 (1995-6).
Imhoof-Blumer F. Imhoof-Blumer. Kleinasiatische Münzen. Wien. 1901.

Jameson R. Jameson. Collection R. Jameson. Paris, 1913-1932.
Jenkins G. K. Jenkins, The Coinage of Gela. Berlin, 1970.
-, Coins of Punic Sicily. 2nd corrected edition, Zürich, 1997.
-, “Hellenistic gold coins of Ephesus” in Festschrift Akurgal (Ankara, 1987).
Johnston A. Johnston, The Coinage of Metapontum. ANSNNM 164, 1990.
Jongkees J. H. Jongkees, The Kimonian Dekadrachs, a contribution to Sicilian numismatics.
Utecht, 1941.
Joy Münzen und Medaillen DE 22, 24 May 2007, Sammlung James H. Joy – The Isles of
Greece.
Karwiese S. Karwiese. Die Münzprägung von Ephesos. I. Die Anfänge: Die ältesten Prägungen
und der Beginn der Münzprägung überhaupt. Cologne & Weimar. 1995
Kestner F. Berger, Die mittelalterlichen Brakteaten im Kestner-Museum. Hannover, 1993.
King C.E. King, Roman Qunarii from the Republic to Diocletian and the Tetrarchy.
Oxford, 2007.
Kinns P. Kinns, “The Amphictionic Coinage Reconsidered” in NC 1983
Kleiner & Noe F.S. Kleiner & S. Noe, The Early Cistophoric Coinage. ANSNS 14, 1977.
Klose & Müseler D.O. Klose & W. Müseler, Die Münzen aus Persepolis von Alexander dem Grossen zu
den Sasaniden. Munich, 2008.
Kraay & Hirmer C. Kraay & M. Hirmer, Greek Coins. New York, 1966.
Kroll See: Agora.
Krzyzanovska A. Krzyzanovska. Monnaies coloniales d’Antioche de Pisidie. Warsaw. 1970.
Kunstfreund Bank Leu & Münzen und Medaillen, Griechische Münzen aus der Sammlung eines
Kunstfreundes. 28 May 1974l
Lanz M. Kostial, Kelten im Osten, Gold und Silber der Kelten in Mittel- und Osteuropa –
Sammlung Lanz. München, 2003.
Le Rider G. Le Rider, Antioche de Syrie sous les Séleucides, I: De Seleucos I à Antiochos V.
Paris, 1999.
-, Le monnayage d’argent et d’or de Philippe II. Paris, 1977.
-, Les monnaies Thasiennes. Guide de Thasos. Paris, 1968.
-, Monnaies Crétoises du V au I Siécle av J.C. Paris, 1966.
-, Monnaies de Characène. Syria 36-3/4, 1959.
Lorber C. Lorber. Amphipolis - The Civic Coinage in Silver and Gold. Los Angeles. 1990.
-, “The Early Profile-Head Drachms of Larissa” in SNR 93 (2014.
Lorber & Houghton C. Lorber & A. Houghton. "Cappadocian Tetradrachms in the Name of Antiochus
VII" in NC 166 (2006).
Lyon P. Bastien et al., Le monnayage de l’atelier de Lyon. Paris, 1972-.
M&G K. Morrison & H. Grunthal, Carolingian Coinage. ANSNNM 158, 1967.
Mamroth A. Mamroth, Die Silbermünzen des Königs Perseus. ZfN 38, 1928.
-, Die Silbermünzen des Königs Philippos V. von Makedonien. ZfN 40, 1930.
May J.M.F. May, Ainos, Its History and Coinage. London, 1950.
-. The Coinage of Abdera, 540-345 BC. London. 1966.
-, The Coinage of Damastion. London, 1939.
Mazard J. Mazard. Corpus Nummorum Numidiae Mauretaniaeque. Paris, 1953-1958.
Mazzini G. Mazzini, Monete Imperiali Romane. Milan, 1957-1958.
McAlee R. McAlee, The Coins of Roman Antioch. Lancaster, PA, 2007.
McClean S. Grose, Catalogue of the McClean Collection, Fitzwilliam Museum. Cambridge,
1923-1929.
MEC P. Grierson & M. Blackburn, Medieval European Coinage I. Cambridge, 1986, and
following volumes passim.
Merker I. L. Merker, The Silver Coinage of Antigonos Gonatas and Antigonos Doson.
ANSMN IX, 1960.
M.I. E. Hawkins, A. W. Franks, H. A. Grueber, Medallic Illustrations of the history of
Great Britain and Ireland. London, 1885
MIB W. Hahn, Moneta Imperii Byzantini. Vienna, 1973-1981.
MIBE W. Hahn & M.A. Mettlich, Money of the Incipient Byzantine Empire. Vienna, 2000-.
Milbank S.R. Millbank, The Coinage of Aegina. ANSNNM 24, 1924.
MIR Moneta Imperii Romani: see Woytek
MIRB W. Hahn, Moneta Imperii Romano-Byzantinii. Vienna, 1989.
Mitchiner M. Mitchiner, Indo-Greek and Indo-Scythian Coinage. London, 1975-1976.
MK R. Göbl. Münzprägung des Kusanreiches. Vienna. 1984.
Morgan W. Raymond, The J. Pierpont Morgan Collection. New York, 1953.
Müller L. Müller, Numismatique d’Alexandre le Grand; Appendice les monnaies de Philippe
II et III, et Lysimaque. Copenhagen, 1855-1858.
-, Numismatique de l’ancienne Afrique. Copenhagen, 1860-1862.
Müseler W. Müseler. Lykische Münzen in europäischen Privatsammlungen. Istanbul. 2016.
Nercessian Y.T. Nercessian. Armenian Coins and Their Values. Los Angeles. 1995.
Newell E. T. Newell, The Coinage of Demetrius Poliorcetes. London, 1927.
Nicolet-Pierre H. Nicolet-Pierre. “Argent et or frappes en Babylonie entre 331 et 311 ou de Mazdai a
Seleucos” in Travaux Le Rider.
Noe S. Noe, The Coinage of Caulonia. ANSNS 9, 1958.
-, The Coinage of Metapontum. ANSNNM 32 & 47, 1927, 1931.
-, The Mende (Kaliandra) Hoard. ANSNNM 27 (1926).
-, The Thurian Disastaters. ANSNNM 71, 1935.
Noeske H.-C. Noeske, Die Münzen der Ptolemäer. Frankfurt a/M, 2000.
Olçay-Mørkholm See: Podalia.
Olivier & Lorber J. Olivier & C. Lorber, ‟Three gold coinages of third-century Ptolemaic Egypt.” RBN
CLIX (2013).
OTA R. Göbl, Ostkeltischer Typenatlas. Braunschweig, 1968.
Paeonian Hoard I Sotheby & Co., London, 16 April 1969. Catalogue of the Paeonian Hoard.
Pegasi R. Calciati, Pegasi. Mortari, 1990.
Pink K. Pink. “Der Aufbau der römischen Münzprägung in der Kaiserzeit: VI/1. Probus”
in NZ 73 (1949).
Pixodarus R.H.J. Ashton, et al., The Pixodarus Hoard. CH IX, 2002.
Podalia N. Olçay & O. Mørkholm. “The Coin Hoard from Podalia” in NC 1971.
Pozzi Naville & Co, Monnaies grecques antiques … S. Pozzi. I, 4 April 1921.
Pozzi (Boutin) S. Boutin. Catalogue des monnaies grecques antiques de l’ancienne collection Pozzi:
Monnaies frappées en Europe. Monaco. 1992
Price M. Price, The Coinage in the Name of Alexander the Great and Philip Arrhidaeus.
London, 1991.
Prieur M. & K. Prieur, A Type Corpus of the Syro-Phoenician Tetradrachms and their
Fractions from 57 BC to AD 253. Lancaster, 2000.
Randazzo C. Arnold-Biucchi, The Randazzo Hoard. ANSNS 18 (New York, 1990).
Ratto R. Ratto, 9 December 1930, Monnaies Byzantines… 2701 lots, 68 pls.
Ravel O. Ravel, Les “Poulains” de Corinthe. Basel, 1936 & 1948.
RBW R. Russo et al., The RBW Collection of Roman Republican Coins. Zürich, 2013.
Regling K. Regling, Terina. Berlin, 1906.
Requier P. Requier. “Les premiers tétradrachmes hellénistiques de Cos” in SNR 75 (1996).
RG W. Waddington, et al. Recueil Général des Monnaies Grecques d’Asi Mineure. Paris,
1904-1925.
RIC H. Mattingly, et al. The Roman Imperial Coinage. London, 1923-.
Ricotti-Prina D. Ricotti-Prina. La monetazione aurea delle zecche minore bizantine dal VI al IX
secolo. Rome. 1972.
Rizzo G.E. Rizzo, Monete greche della Sicilia. Rome, 1946.
Robinson E.S.G. Robinson. “Some Electrum and Gold Greek Coins” in Centennial Publication
of the American Numismatic Society. New York. 1958.
Robinson & Clement D.M. Robinson & P.A. Clement. The Chalcidic Mint and the Excavation Coins found
in 1928-1934. Excavations at Olynthus IX. Baltimore. 1938.
Rosen N. Waggoner. Early Greek Coins from the Collection of Jonathan P. Rosen. ACNAC
5. New York. 1983.
RPC A. Burnett, M. Amandry, et al. Roman Provincial Coinage. London and Paris, 1992-.
Rutter N. K. Rutter, Campanian Coinages 475-380 BC. Edinburgh, 1979.
Sambon A. Sambon, Les Monnaies antiques de l’Italie. Paris, 1903.
Slg. Bonhoff Peus 293, Sammlung Bonhoff. 27 October 1977.
Slg. Löbbecke Riechmann 31, Sammlung A. Löbbecke, Deutsche Brakteaten. 3 February, 1925.
Sandwich Earl of Sandwich, British and Foreign Medals relating to Naval and Maritime Affairs.
Greenwich, 1937.
SB D. Sear, et al. Byzantine Coins and Their Values. 2 ed. London, 1987.
nd
SC A. Houghton & C. Lorber, Seleucid Coins: A Comprehensive Catalogue. Lancaster,

2002.
Schönert-Geiss E. Schönert-Geiss, Die Münzprägung von Maroneia. Berlin, 1987.
Selinus Hoard C. Arnold-Biucchi, et al., A Greek Archaic Silver Hoard from Selinus. ANSMN 33,
1988.
Sellwood D. Sellwood, An Introduction to the Coinage of Parthia. 2 ed. London, 1980.
nd
Seltman C.T. Seltman, The Temple Coins of Olympia. Cambridge, 1921.

Seyrig H. Seyrig. “Monnaies Hellénistiques de Byzance et de Calcédoine” in Essays Robinson
Sheedy K. A. Sheedy, the Archaic and Early Classical Coinages of the Cyclades. London,
2006.
Shore F. Shore, Parthian Coins and History. Quarryville, 1993.
Sills J. Sills, Gaulish and Early British Gold Coinage. London, 2003.
SMA E.T. Newell. The Seleucid Mint of Antioch. New York. 1917.
Spoerri M. Spoerri Butcher, Le Monnayage d’argent émis par le roi Juba II de Maurétanie (I):
catalogue des monnaies dates. SNR 94, 2015.
Studies Price R. Ashton & S. Hurter, eds. Studies in Greek Numismatics in Memory of Martin
Jessop Price. London, 1998.
Sutherland C.H.V. Sutherland, N. Olcay & K. E. Merrington, The Cistophori of Augustus.
London, 1970.
Svoronos J. Svoronos, Les monnaies d’Athènes. Munich, 1923-1926. (with B. Pick).
-, L’hellénisme primitif de la Macédoine, prouvé par la numismatique et l’or du
Pangée. Paris and Athens. 1919.
-, Numismatique de la Crète ancienne. Paris, 1890.
-, Ta nomismata tou kratous ton Ptolemaion. Athens, 1904-1908.
Sydenham E. Sydenham, The Coinageof Caesarea in Cappadocia. London, 1933.
E. Sydenham et al., The Coinage of the Roman Republic. London, 1952.
SNG Sylloge Nummorum Graecorum
Alpha Bank. Greece II. The Alpha Bank Collection. Macedonia I: Alexander I -
Perseus. Athens. 2000
ANS. American Numismatic Society. New York, 1969-.
Ashmolean. Great Britain V. Ashmolean Museum, Oxford. London, 1962-.
Berry. Burton Y. Berry Collection. New York, 1961-1962.
BM. Great Britain IX, British Museum, Part 1: The Black Sea. London, 1993.
BM. Great Britain IX, British Museum, Part 2: Spain. London, 2002.
BN. France, Cabinet des Médailles. Paris, 1993-.
Copenhagen. Denmark, Danish National Museum. Copenhagen, 1942-2002.
Delepierre. Bibliothèque Nationale. Paris. 1983.
Fitzwilliam. Great Britain, Volume IV, Fitzwilliam Museum, Leake and General
Collections. London. 1940-1958.
Kayhan. Turkey 1: The Muharrem Kayhan Collection. 2 vols. Istanbul, 2001, 2015.
Keckman. Finland, The Erkki Keckman Collection. Helsinki, 1994.
Kikpe. Greece 7. The Kikpe Collection of Bronze Coins. Volume I. Athens. 2012.
Levante. E. Levante. Bern & Zürich, 1986-1993.
Lewis. Great Britain, VI, The Lewis Collection in Corpus Christi College Cambridge.
London. 1972.
Lloyd. Great Britain II. Lloyd Collection. London, 1933-1937.
Lockett. Great Britain III. London, 1938-1949.
Manchester. Great Britain, Volume VII, Manchester University Museum. London.

1986.
Morcom. Great Britain X. John Morcom Collection. Oxford, 1995.
München. München Staatliche Münzsammlung. Berlin, 1968-.
Pushkin. State Pushkin Museum of Fine Arts Coins of the Black Sea Region. Part I:
Ancient Coins of the Northern Black Sea Littoral. Leuven. 2011.
Spaer. Israel I, The Arnold Spaer Collection of Seleucid Coins. Jerusalem, 1998.
Stancomb. Great Britain XI, The William Stancomb Collection of Coins of the Black
Sea Region. Oxford, 2000.
Von Aulock. Sammlung Hans von Aulock. Berlin, 1957-1968.
Thompson M. Thompson, Alexander’s Drachm Mints I: Sardes and Miletos. ANSNS 16 (1983).
-, Alexander’s Drachm Mints II: Lampsacus and Abydus. ANSNS 19 (1991
-, Philip, “Posthumous Philip II Staters of Asia Minor” in SPNO.
-, The Mints of Lysimachus. Essays Robinson.
-, The New Style Silver Coinage of Athens. ANSNS 10, 1961.
Thurlow-Vecchi B. Thurlow & I. Vecchi, Italian Cast Coinage. Dorchester, 1979.
TMNK Teylers Museum Numismatic Kabinet, Haarlem (web catalogue).
Traité E. Babelon, et al., Traité des Monnaies Grecques et Romaines. Paris, 1901-1932.
Troxell H.A. Troxell. “Arsinoe’s Non-Era” in MN 28 (1983).
Tudeer L. O. Tudeer, Die Tetradrachmenprägung von Syrakus in der Periode der
Signierenden Künstler. Berlin, 1913.
Van Heesch J. Van Heesch. “Une Représentation Remarquable des Quatre Saisons sur Semisses de
l’époque Antoninienne” in SPNO
Van Loon G. van Loon, Histoire métallique des XVII provinces… The Hague, 1732-1737.
Van’t Haaff P.A. van’t Haaff, Catalogue of Elymaean Coinage, ca. 147 BC-AD 228. Lancaster,
2007.
Vecchi I. Vecchi, Etruscan Coinage. Milan 2012.
-. Italian Cast Coinage. London, 2013.
Vlasto O. Ravel, The Collection of Tarentine Coins Formed by M. P. Vlasto. London, 1947.
Von Fritze H. von Fritze, Die autonome Kupferprägung von Kyzikos. Nomisma X, 1917.
-, Die Elektronprägung von Kyzikos. Nomisma VII, 1912.
-, Die Silberprägung von Kyzikos. Nomisma IX, 1914.
Von Kaenel H.-M. von Kaenel, Münzprägung und Münzbildnis des Claudius. AMUGS XI.
Berlin, 1986.
Walker J. Walker. A Catalogue of Arab-Byzantine and Post-Reform Ommayyad Coins.
London. 1956
Warren K. Regling, Die griechischen Münzen der Sammlung Warren. Berlin, 1906.
WCN D. W. MacDowell, The Western Coinages of Nero. ANSNNM 161. New York, 1979.
Weber L. Forrer. The Weber Collection of Greek Coins. 3 Vols. London. 1922-1929.
Weidauer L. Weidauer, Probleme der frühen Elektronprägung. Fribourg, 1975.
Westermark U. Westermark, Das Bildnis des Philetairos von Pergamon. Stockholm. 1960.
-, “Remarks on the Regal Macedonian Coinage ca. 413-359 BC” in Kraay-Mørkholm
Essays.
Wilkes T. Wilkes, Islamic Coins and Their Values (IC). London, 2015.
Williams R. T. Williams, Silver Coinage of the Phokians. London. 1972.
-, The Confederate Coinage of the Arcadians in the Fifth Century BC. ANSNNM 155
(1965).
-, The Silver Coinage of Velia. London, 1992.
Winterthur H. Bloesch. Griechische Münzen in Winterthur. I-II. Winterthur. 1987, 1997.
Woytek B. Woytek, Die Reichsprägung des Kaisers Traianus (98-117). MIR 14. Vienna, 2010.
= MIR.
WSM E.T. Newell, revised by O. Mørkholm, The Coinage of the Western Seleucid Mints
from Seleucus I to Antiochus III. ANSNS 4, 1977.
Zervos O. Zervos. “The Early Tetradrachms of Ptolemy I” in MN 13 (1967.
159 168
131
19
145
67
20
155 137
88
124 32 154
&(/7,&&2,16
%ULWDLQ

$WUHEDWHV 5HJQL9HULFDFLUFD$'0LQLP6LOYHUPP 3:1
J K
0LQL 9LQH /HDI
W\SH &2) 9LQH OHDI 5HY
9(5,&$ +RUVH SUDQFLQJ WR ULJKW $%& %HDQ 9(56
6&%&9DQ$UVGHOO9HU\UDUH$WWUDFWLYHJUH\VXUIDFHV
([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[6RWKHE\
V$SULO

$WUHEDWHV 5HJQL9HULFDFLUFD$'0LQLP6LOYHUPP
JK
&RUQXFRSLDH(DJOH
W\SH7K\UVXVEHWZHHQWZRFRUQX
3:1
FRSLDH DOO VWDQGLQJ ZLWKLQ D WZRKDQGOHG ZLQH FXS 5HY (DJOH
VWDQGLQJ OHIW RQ YLQH KLV KHDG WXUQHG EDFN WR ULJKW SHFNLQJ RQ D
EXQFKRIJUDSHV$%&%HDQ9(&6%0&6&%&
9DQ $UVGHOO &OHDU DQG ZLWK DWWUDFWLYH JUH\ VXUIDFHV
1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
V$SULO

J K
$FRUQV
W\SH &) 7KUHH LQWHUWZLQHG DFRUQV 5HY 3:1
9(5,&$+LSSRFDPSWRULJKW$%&%0&6&%&
9DQ $UVGHOO ([WUHPHO\ UDUH :HOO VWUXFN DQG WRQHG 1HDUO\
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[/HX2FWREHU

JK
:LQH&XS
W\SH5(;'RXEOHKDQGHGJDUQLVKHGZLQH
FXS 5HY 9(5,&$ &200, ) 5RPDQ OHJLRQDU\ $TXLOD WR ULJKW
$%&%HDQ9(56%0&6&%&9DQ$UVGHOO 3:1
9HU\ UDUH 6KDUS DQG ZLWK DWWUDFWLYH JUH\ VXUIDFHV *RRG
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
V$SULO
0LGGOH'DQXEH

QGVW FHQWXULHV %& 2ERO 6LOYHU PP J K

.DSRVWDOHU .OHLQJHOG
RU
.UþHGLQ
W\SH 6W\OL]HG ODXUHDWH DQG
EHDUGHGKHDGRI=HXVWRULJKW5HY6W\OL]HGKRUVHPDQULGLQJWROHIW
&I 1DXPDQQ RERO 0Q] =HQWUXP 5KHLQODQG
3:1 GUDFKPDQG5DXFKGUDFKP$QH[WUHPHO\
LQWHUHVWLQJ SRVVLEO\ XQSXEOLVKHG RERO RU IUDFWLRQ IURP WKH DUHD RI
+XQJDU\$WWUDFWLYHO\WRQHGYHU\ZHOOFHQWHUHGDQGYHU\ZHOOSUHVHU
YHG([WUHPHO\ILQH
*5((.&2,16
&DODEULD

7DUHQWXP&LUFD%&3HQWRQNLRQ6LOYHUPPJ
K 'LDGHPHG KHDG RI $WKHQD WR ULJKW VHW RQ KHU FLUFXODU DHJLV
5HY7$Ȉ.DQWKDURVIODQNHGE\ILYHSHOOHWVYDOXHPDUNV+1,,,
3:1 9ODVWRWKLVFRLQ5DUH&OHDURIH[FHOOHQWVW\OHDQGZLWK
D ILQH ROG FDELQHW WRQH 5RXJK VXUIDFHV DV IRXQG RWKHUZLVH YHU\
ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[3HXV$SULOIURPWKH
FROOHFWLRQ RI 3 0 9ODVWR DQG IURP WKH (OOLRW &ROOHFWLRQ IRUPHG LQ
(QJODQGSULRUWRWKHV

7DUHQWXP&LUFD%&1RPRV6LOYHUPPJK
1XGHHSKHEHKROGLQJJRDGLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGUHLQVLQKLVOHIWRQ
KRUVH JDOORSLQJ WR ULJKW 5HY ȉǹȇǹȈ 3KDODQWKRV QXGH ULGLQJ RQ
GROSKLQWROHIWKROGLQJDNURVWROLRQLQKLVULJKWKDQG)%KWKLV
2:1 FRLQ +1 ,,, 9ODVWR WKLV FRLQ EXW LOOXVWUDWHG IURP D
GDPDJHG FDVW $ VSOHQGLG WRQHG DQG ZHOO FHQWHUHG H[DPSOH UDUH
WKXV([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP D 6ZLVV FROOHFWLRQ SUHYLRXVO\ LQ WKH FROOHFWLRQV RI & *LOOHW
039ODVWRDQG30DWKH\ILUVWDFTXLUHGF

7DUHQWXP&LUFD%&1RPRV6LOYHUPPJK
1XGHKRUVHPDQJDOORSLQJUKROGLQJURXQGVKLHOGDQGWZRVSHDUVLQ
KLV OHIW KDQG DQG VWULNLQJ GRZQZDUGV ZLWK D VSHDU KHOG LQ KLV
XSUDLVHG ULJKW LQ ILHOG WR OHIW Ȅ EHORZ KRUVH $3, 5HY 7$3$Ȉ
3KDODQWKRV QXGH ULGLQJ GROSKLQ WR OHIW KROGLQJ UXGGHU LQ KLV OHIW
KDQGDQGDNDQWKDURVLQKLVULJKWLQILHOGWROHIW.ȁ)%EWKLV
FRLQ+1,,,%0&VDPHGLHV9ODVWR$EHDXWLIXOO\
WRQHG H[DPSOH YHU\ ZHOOVWUXFN IURP IUHVK GLHV *RRG H[WUHPHO\
ILQH 2:1
([1XPLVPDWLFD$UV&ODVVLFD$SULO6SLQN-XO\
DQGIURPWKH(QJODQG&ROOHFWLRQIRUPHGLQWKHVRUEHIRUH
/XFDQLD

0HWDSRQWXP&LUFD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJK
ȂǼȉǹȆ6HYHQJUDLQHGEDUOH\HDUERUGHURIGRWV5HY6HYHQJUDLQHG
EDUOH\HDULQFXVHUD\HGERUGHU+1,,,1RH 61*$16 2:1
VDPH GLHV $ VSOHQGLG VKDUSO\ VWUXFN DQG EHDXWLIXOO\ WRQHG
H[DPSOHYHU\UDUHWKXV*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI $ 7UDPSLWVFK 9LQFKRQ 0RQDFR 1RYHPEHU
WKHUHGHVFULEHGDVEHLQJDSLqFHDJUpDEOHZKLFKLWFHUWDLQO\LV
10

0HWDSRQWXP &LUFD %& 'UDFKP RU 7KLUG 6WDWHU 6LOYHU
PPJKȂǼȉ(DURIEDUOH\ZLWKVHYHQJUDLQVDURXQGERUGHU
RI GRWV 5HY (DU RI EDUOH\ ZLWK VHYHQ JUDLQV DOOLQFXVHUD\HGERUGHU 2:1
+1,,,1RH*UH\WRQLQJ1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
([ 1RPRV 0D\ DQG IURP WKH : ) 6WRHFNOLQ &ROOHFWLRQ
$PULVZLO6ZLW]HUODQGDFTXLUHGSULRUWR
11

0HWDSRQWXP&LUFD%&1RPRVRU'LGUDFKP6LOYHUPP
JK+HDGRI'HPHWHU"WRULJKWZHDULQJDSHQGDQWHDUULQJ
DQGDVLPSOHQHFNODFHZLWKKHUKDLUERXQGLQDVDNNRVRUQDPHQWHG
ZLWKVWDUV5HYȂǼȉǹ%DUOH\HDUZLWKOHDIWROHIWEHORZOHDIȁȊ
+1,,,E1RH1LFHO\WRQHGDQGZLWKDORYHO\IHPDOHKHDG
2:1 ([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP D 6ZLVV FROOHFWLRQ DQG IURP WKH % LQ % &ROOHFWLRQ 1RPRV
2FWREHUDQGH[%DQN/HX0D\
:KHWKHU WKH KHDG RQ WKLVFRLQLVUHDOO\WKDWRI'HPHWHULVXQFHUWDLQWKHUH
DUHQRJUDLQHDUVRUOHDYHVLQKHUKDLUDVRQHZRXOGH[SHFWDQGWKHXVHRID
VLPSOH VDNNRV DV D KDLU RUQDPHQW LV ZKDW RQH ZRXOG H[SHFW WR VHH RQ D
Q\PSK,QDQ\HYHQWWKLVKHDGLVDSDUWLFXODUO\QREOHRQHERWKLQWHOOLJHQW
DQGNLQGO\
12
2:1

JK+HDGRI'HPHWHUWROHIWZHDULQJZUHDWKRIEDUOH\HDUV
DQGWULSOHSHQGDQWHDUULQJ5HYȂǼȉǹ(DURIEDUOH\ZLWKOHDIWROHIW
WROHIWRQOHDIDPSKRUDWROHIWEHORZOHDIĭǿ+1,,,FRUUĭ
LQVWHDGRIĭǿ-RKQVWRQ&ODVV&REYHUVHGLH&&UHYHUVH
GLH&&OHDUDQGDWWUDFWLYH1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQERXJKWSULYDWHO\IURP6SLQNVLQ-XQH
2:1
13

JKǻ,+HDGRI'HPHWHUWRULJKWZHDULQJZUHDWKRIEDUOH\HDUV
WULSOHSHQGDQWHDUULQJDQGSHDUOQHFNODFH5HYȂǼȉǹ(DURIEDUOH\RI
VHYHQJUDLQVDQGOHDIWRULJKWWRULJKWDERYHOHDINDQWKDURVZLWKĆ$WR
OHIW +1 ,,, -RKQVWRQ ' VDPH GLHV 61* $16 VDPH
GLHV&OHDUWRQHGDQGRIJRRGVW\OH2EYHUVHVWUXFNIURPDVOLJKWO\UXVW\
GLHRWKHUZLVHQHDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ *RUQ\ 0RVFK2FWREHU

14

J K ǻ, +HDG RI 'HPHWHU WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ ZUHDWK RI EDUOH\
HDUVWULSOHSHQGDQWHDUULQJDQGSHDUOQHFNODFH5HYȂǼȉǹ(DURIEDUOH\
RI VL[ JUDLQV DQG OHDI WR OHIW WR OHIW DERYH OHDI RUQDPHQWHG
FDQGHODEUXPWROHIWEHORZOHDIĆ$WRULJKWORQJILOOHWHGWK\UVRV
+1 ,,, -RKQVWRQ ' VDPH GLHV 61* $16 9HU\
QLFHO\ WRQHG DQG DWWUDFWLYH WKH EHVW DYDLODEOH H[DPSOH RI WKLV UDUH 2:1
YDULHW\ 0LQRU DUHD RI IODWQHVV RQ WKH REYHUVH RWKHUZLVH QHDUO\
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[.QNHU2FWREHUDQG
* 00DUFK
15

JKǻ,+HDGRI'HPHWHUWROHIWZHDULQJZUHDWKRIEDUOH\HDUV
DQG SHQGDQW HDUULQJ 5HY ȂǼȉǹ (DU RI EDUOH\ ZLWK OHDI WR OHIW WR 2:1
OHIW RQ OHDI DPSKRUD WR OHIW EHORZ OHDI Ć $ +1 ,,,
-RKQVWRQ &ODVV ' %ULJKW DQG DWWUDFWLYH 6OLJKWO\ URXJK
VXUIDFHVRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[*RUQ\ 0RVFK0DUFK
16

JK+HDGRI'HPHWHUWRULJKWZHDULQJZUHDWKRIEDUOH\HDUV
5HYȂǼȉǹ(DURIEDUOH\RIVHYHQJUDLQVWRULJKWDERYHOHDIVWDU
2:1
DERYHWZRDPSKRUDVĭ,EHORZ+1,,,-RKQVWRQ'VDPH
GLHV$WWUDFWLYHO\WRQHGQLFHO\FHQWHUHGDQGYHU\VKDUS([WUHPHO\
ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQERXJKWLQHDUO\LQ:HLODP5KHLQ
17

JK>ǻ@+HDGRI'HPHWHUWRULJKWZHDULQJZUHDWKRIEDUOH\HDUV
WULSOHSHQGDQWHDUULQJDQGSHDUOQHFNODFH5HYȂǼȉǹ(DURIEDUOH\
ZLWKOHDIWRULJKWWRULJKWDERYHOHDIVWDUDERYHWZRDPSKRUDHWR
2:1 ULJKW EHORZ OHDI ĭ, +1 ,,, -RKQVWRQ &ODVV ' 61*
$16 VDPH GLHV %ULJKW VKDUS DQG DWWUDFWLYH 9HU\ PLQRU
PDUNVRWKHUZLVHJRRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[*RUQ\ 0RVFK0D\
18

0HWDSRQWXP 3XQLF RFFXSDWLRQ FLUFD %& +DOI 6KHNHO
2:1 6LOYHU PP J K 3XQLF VWDQGDUG +HDG RI $WKHQD WR
ULJKWZHDULQJ&RULQWKLDQKHOPHW5HYȂǼȉǹ*UDLQHDUZLWKOHDIWR
ULJKW +1 ,WDO\ 5RELQVRQ 1& 7KH &RLQDJHV RI WKH
6HFRQG 3XQLF :DU S DQG SO 9, 61* $16 61*
/RFNHWW:HOOVWUXFNFOHDUDWWUDFWLYHO\WRQHGDQGUDUHZLWKRXW
WKHRZORQWKHUHYHUVH*RRGYHU\ILQH
([5RPD6HSWHPEHU
19
2:1

3RVHLGRQLD&LUFD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJK
ȆȅȂǼǿ 3RVHLGRQ VWULGLQJ WR ULJKW EUDQGLVKLQJ WULGHQW DQG ZLWK
FKODP\V RYHU KLV VKRXOGHUV 5HY ȆȅȂǼǿǻǹ UHWURJUDGH %XOO
VWDQGLQJ OHIW RQ GRWWHG JURXQG OLQH +1 ,,, 61* $16
61*&RSHQKDJHQVDPHGLHV%HDXWLIXOO\WRQHGRI
WKH ILQHVW &ODVVLFDO VW\OH DQG XQXVXDOO\ ZHOOSUHVHUYHG IRU WKHVH
SLHFHV6RPHYHU\PLQRUPDUNVRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI 5 0DO\ /+6 $SULO H[
.ULFKHOGRUI ,9 2FWREHU DQG IURP WKH 0DUWLQHWWL 1HUYHJQD
&ROOHFWLRQV6DPERQ&DQHVVD1RYHPEHU
20

6\EDULV&LUFD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJKȂ9
UHWURJUDGH %XOO VWDQGLQJ WR OHIW RQ GRWWHG JURXQG OLQH KLV KHDG
WXUQHGEDFNWRULJKWDOOZLWKLQDERUGHURIGRWV5HY%XOOVWDQGLQJWR
ULJKWRQGRWWHGJURXQGOLQHDURXQGERUGHURIGRWVDOOLQFXVH+1
,,, 61* $16 $ EHDXWLIXOO\ WRQHG DQG VKDUS H[DPSOH
6RPH YHU\ PLQRU PDUNV DQG VOLJKW PHWDO IDXOWV RQ WKH REYHUVH
RWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH55*&ROOHFWLRQ*HUPDQ\IRUPHGEHIRUH
2:1
21

7KXULXP&LUFD%&'LVWDWHU6LOYHUPPJK
VLJQHGRQWKHUHYHUVHE\,VWRURVDQG(X+HDGRI$WKHQDWRULJKW
ZHDULQJ $WWLF KHOPHW DGRUQHG ZLWK 6N\OOD UDLVLQJ KHU OHIW KDQG RQ
WKHERZODERYHWKHYLVRUDQGZLWKDJULIILQZDONLQJULJKWRQWKHQHFN
IODS DQG SHDUO QHFNODFH 5HY ĬȅȊȇǿȍȃ %XOO EXWWLQJ ULJKW ZLWK
PRQRJUDP RI ȊǼ RQ KLV UXPS LQ H[HUJXHILVKWRULJKWRQJURXQG
OLQH LQ PLQXWH OHWWHUV ǿȈȉȅȇȅȈ 'H /X\QHV VDPH GLHV +1
,,,1RH%9HU\UDUH$SDUWLFXODUO\HOHJDQWFRLQRIWKHILQHVW
&ODVVLFDO VW\OH QLFHO\ WRQHG 6RPH WUDFHV RI KRUQ VLOYHU LQ WKH
GHYLFHVZLWKDVFXIIRQWKHREYHUVHDQGYHU\OLJKWGRXEOHVWULNLQJRQ
WKHUHYHUVHRWKHUZLVHDERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPD6ZLVVFROOHFWLRQ
2:1
7KH HQJUDYHU ,VWRURV ZRUNHG LQ 7KXULXP LQ WKH ODWH WK FHQWXU\ DQG ZDV
WKHUHIRUH D FRQWHPSRUDU\ RI WKH JUHDW 6\UDFXVDQ HQJUDYHUV .LPRQ
(XDLQHWRVDQG3KU\JLOORVDQHQJUDYHUZKRDOPRVWFHUWDLQO\DOVRZRUNHGDW
7KXULXP +LV VLJQDWXUH ZDV ILUVW GLVFXVVHG E\ ,PKRRI%OXPHU LQ
0RQQ*USLQFRQQHFWLRQZLWKWKHORYHO\VSHFLPHQLQWKH'H/X\QHV
&ROOHFWLRQDQGKLVZRUNLVRIDSDUWLFXODUO\VHUHQHDQGQREOHVW\OHZLWKRXW
DQ\EDURTXHIODPER\DQFH+LVGLHVDUHDPRQJWKHILQHVWRIDOOWKRVHPDGHDW
7KXULXP
%UXWWLXP
22 2:1

.URWRQ&LUFD%&+HPLGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJK
}32UHWURJUDGH7ULSRGZLWKWKUHHULQJKDQGOHVDQGOHJVHQGLQJLQ
OLRQ
VSDZVEHWZHHQOHJVWZRHUHFWVHUSHQWV5HY.DQWKDURVIODQNHG
E\ WZR VQDNHV %0& *DUUXFFL SO +1 ,,,
([WUHPHO\ UDUH 1LFHO\ WRQHG 7UDFHV RI FRUURVLRQ RWKHUZLVH
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[/HX0D\
23

.DXORQLD &LUFD %& 6WDWHU 6LOYHU PP J K
Ȁǹ9ȁ UHWURJUDGH $SROOR QXGH KLV KDLU ERXQG ZLWK D WDHQLD
DGYDQFLQJ WR ULJKW ZLWK D ODXUHO EUDQFK LQ KLV XSUDLVHG ULJKW KDQG
DQGWUDFHVRIDGDLPRQUXQQLQJWRULJKWRQKLVRXWVWUHWFKHGOHIWDUP
2:1 5HY Ȁǹ9ȁ UHWURJUDGH 6WDJ VWDQGLQJ WR ULJKW WR ULJKW ODXUHO
EUDQFK +1 ,,, 1RH &DXORQLD &OHDU DWWUDFWLYH
ZHOOFHQWHUHGDQGOLJKWO\WRQHG6WUXFNIURPDVOLJKWO\ZRUQREYHUVH
GLHRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPD6ZLVVFROOHFWLRQH[5RPD9,,0DUFK
24
2:1
/RNURL(SL]HSK\ULRL&LUFD%&1RPRV6LOYHUPPJ
KȁȅȀȇȍȃ/DXUHDWHKHDGRI=HXVWROHIW5HY(DJOHVWDQGLQJ
OHIWZLWKVSUHDGZLQJVWHDULQJDWDGHDGKDUHKHOGLQLWVWDORQV+1,,,
61*$VKPROHDQVDPHGLHV%HDXWLIXOO\WRQHGDQGZLWKD
ILQH&ODVVLFDOKHDGRI=HXV1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP D 6ZLVV FROOHFWLRQ H[ *LHVVHQHU 0Q]KDQGOXQJ 2FWREHU

1XPLVPDWLFD $UV &ODVVLFD 0DUFK DQG $XFWLRQHV
-XQH
25

/RNURL (SL]HSK\ULRL &LUFD %& 6WDWHU 6LOYHU PP
JK3HJDVXVIO\LQJWROHIWEHORZWKXQGHUEROW5HYȁ2.3ȍ1
+HDGRI$WKHQDWROHIWZHDULQJ&RULQWKLDQKHOPHWZLWKQHFNIODSDQG
SHDUO QHFNODFH +1,,,3HJDVL61*$16VDPHGLHV
1LFHO\ FHQWHUHG DQG DWWUDFWLYHO\ WRQHG 5HYHUVH DOPRVW LPSHUFHSWLEO\
GRXEOHVWUXFNRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1 )URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQERXJKWSULYDWHO\IURP%DOGZLQ
VLQ/RQGRQ
LQ-XQH
26

/RNURL (SL]HSK\ULRL &LUFD UG FHQWXU\ %& &KDONRXV %URQ]H
PP J K $PSKRUD 5HY ȁ2.3ȍ1 *UDSH FOXVWHU
*DUUXFFL +1,,,61*$16([WUHPHO\UDUH6KDUSO\VWUXFN
DQG ZLWK DQ DWWUDFWLYH ROLYHJUHHQ SDWLQD 9HU\ VOLJKWO\ URXJK
VXUIDFHVRWKHUZLVHDERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ DFTXLUHG IURP + .UHLQGOHU LQ 2FWREHU

27

5KHJLRQ&LUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K/LRQ¶VPDVNIDFLQJWROHIWROLYHVSULJWRULJKWKDUHUXQQLQJ
XSZDUGV 5HY 5(&,126 UHWURJUDGH ,RNDVWRV EHDUGHG DQG
GUDSHG IURP WKH ZDLVW VHDWHG OHIW RQ EDFNOHVV VWRRO KROGLQJ ORQJ
VFHSWHULQKLVOHIWKDQGDQGNDQWKDURVLQKLVULJKWEHKLQGVWRROUDYHQ
VWDQGLQJULJKWDOOZLWKLQROLYHZUHDWK+HU]IHOGHU'5+1
,,,61*/OR\GVDPHGLHV7RQHGDQGZHOOFHQWHUHGRQD
EURDGIODQ9HU\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[&ODVVLFDO1XPLVPDWLF*URXS0DUFK 2:1
/HX 0D\ DQG 0RQQDLHV HW 0pGDLOOHV
-DQXDU\
6LFLO\
28

$NUDJDV&LUFD%&+H[DV%URQ]HPPJ(DJOH
ULJKWFOXWFKLQJILVKLQLWVWDORQV5HYǹ>Ȁ@ȇǹī&UDEWROHIWDQG
ULJKW SHOOHW EHORZ WZR ILVK VZLPPLQJ LQ RSSRVLWH GLUHFWLRQV
:HVWHUPDUN )2)5 $WWUDFWLYH DQG FOHDU ZLWK
JUHHQLVKEURZQSDWLQD([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPDQ$PHULFDQFROOHFWLRQDFTXLUHGIURP3DUV&RLQVLQ&DOLIRUQLDSULRU
WR
29

$NUDJDV3KLQWLDVW\UDQW%&%URQ]HPPJK
ǹȀȇǹīǹȃȉǿ SDUWLDOO\ YLVLEOH /DXUHDWH KHDG RI $SROOR WR OHIW
2:1 5HY ĭǿ (DJOH VWDQGLQJ ULJKW ZLWK FORVHG ZLQJV DQG ZLWK KLV KHDG
WXUQHGEDFNWROHIW&1661*$1661*&RSHQKDJHQ
$SDUWLFXODUO\ILQHDQGDWWUDFWLYHH[DPSOHZHOOVWUXFNIURPIUHVK
GLHVDQGZLWKDGDUNJUHHQEURZQSDWLQD([WUHPHO\ILQH
([*RUQ\ 0RVFK0DUFK
2:1
30

*DODULD &LUFD %& /LWUD 6LOYHU PP J K
Ȉ27(5 UHWURJUDGH =HXV VHDWHG OHIW RQ WKURQH KROGLQJ D ORQJ
HDJOHWRSSHG VFHSWHU LQ KLV ULJKW KDQG DQG UHVWLQJ KLV OHIW RQ WKH
WKURQH 5HY &$ ȁ$ 'LRQ\VRV VWDQGLQJ OHIW KROGLQJ NDQWKDURVLQ
KLVULJKWKDQGDQGLQKLVOHIWDYLQHZLWKDEXQFKRIJUDSHV-DPHVRQ
-HQNLQV &RLQDJHV *URXS , 61* $16 9HU\ UDUH QLFHO\
FHQWHUHGVKDUSDQGDWWUDFWLYHO\WRQHG6RPHUHPDLQLQJHQFUXVWDWLRQV
DVIRXQGRWKHUZLVHQHDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[1XPLVPDWLFD$UV&ODVVLFD0DUFK

2:1 31

*HOD &LUFD %& 'LGUDFKP 6LOYHU PP J
K 1XGH DQG EHDUGHG ZDUULRU ULGLQJ ULJKW RQ SUDQFLQJ KRUVH
ZHDULQJKLJKKHOPHWDQGKROGLQJVSHDULQKLVXSUDLVHGULJKWKDQGDQG
WKH UHLQV LQ KLV OHIW 5HY >&@( ȁǹ UHWURJUDGH )RUHSDUW RI
PDQKHDGHG EXOO $FKHOR|V WR ULJKW -HQNLQV *HOD 25
.UDD\ +LUPHU VDPH GLHV $ EHDXWLIXOO\ WRQHG DQG VKDUSO\
VWUXFN H[DPSOH 6OLJKW WUDFHV RI RYHUVWULNLQJ RWKHUZLVH JRRG
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
([1XPLVPDWLF)LQH$UWV9)HEUXDU\
32

+LPHUD&LUFD%&'LGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJK
ǾǿȂǼ5ǹ &RFN VWDQGLQJ OHIW 5HY &UDE ZLWKLQ VKDOORZ FLUFXODU
LQFXVH /RFNHU /DPSVRQ WKLV FRLQ :HVWHUPDUN +LPHUD
WKLV FRLQ $ ORYHO\ WRQHG H[DPSOH ZHOOVWUXFN RQ D EURDG IODQ
0LQRUWUDFHVRIRYHUVWULNLQJRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH *RGIUR\ &ROOHFWLRQ DFTXLUHG DW WKH VDOH RI WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI * 2:1
/RFNHU/DPSVRQ$UV&ODVVLFD;,,,-XQHIURPWKHFROOHFWLRQ
RI30DWKH\H[0HU]EDFKHU>@1RYHPEHU
33

.DWDQH &LUFD %& /LWUD 6LOYHU PP J K
%DOGLQJKHDGRI6LOHQRVWROHIWZLWKDQDQLPDOHDUDQGDORQJEHDUG
5HYȀǹȉǹȃǼDURXQGZLQJHGWKXQGHUEROW%RHKULQJHU.DWDQHLVFKH
6HULHV,/L-DPHVRQVDPHGLHV5L]]RSO,;2IVSOHQGLG
ODWH DUFKDLFHDUO\ FODVVLFDO VW\OH DQG ZLWK DQ DWWUDFWLYH JUH\ SDWLQD
([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[1XPLVPDWLFD$UV&ODVVLFD0DUFK 3:1

7KHKHDGRI6LOHQRVRQWKLVFRLQPXVWKDYHEHHQPDGHMXVWDIHZ\HDUVDIWHU
WKH IDPRXV WHWUDGUDFKP ZLWK WKHVTXDWWLQJ6LOHQRVIURP1D[RV7KHUDWKHU
SRZHUIXO VW\OH RI WKLV FRLQ ZLWK HFKRV RI WKH ODWH $UFKDLF VKRXOG EH
FRPSDUHG WR WKH IROORZLQJ OLWUD IURP .DWDQH ZKLFK VKRZV D PXFK PRUH
KXPDQKHDGRI6LOHQRVIXOO\FODVVLFDOLQFRQFHSW
34

.DWDQH&LUFD%&+HPLOLWURQ6LOYHUPPJ
K%HDUGHGDQGSDUWLDOO\EDOGKHDGRI6LOHQRVWRULJKW5HY.$
UHWURJUDGH:LQJHGWKXQGHUEROW$SSDUHQWO\XQSXEOLVKHG6HHPLQJO\
3:1
XQLTXHDQGZLWKDVXSHUEO\HQJUDYHGKHDGRI6LOHQRV6RPHVXUIDFH
PDUNVRWKHUZLVHQHDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[1XPLVPDWLFD$UV&ODVVLFD0DUFK

35

.DWDQH&LUFD%&/LWUD6LOYHUPPJK%DOG
DQG EHDUGHG KHDG RI 6LOHQRV WR ULJKW 5HY .$7$1$,ȍ1 :LQJHG
WKXQGHUEROWIODQNHGE\WZRVKLHOGV%RHKULQJHU.DWDQHLVFKH6HULHV,,,
/L 5L]]R SO ;,9 YDU 61* $16 61* /OR\G
%HDXWLIXOO\WRQHGDQGRIILQH&ODVVLFDOVW\OH6RPHXQFOHDQHGGHSRVLWV
RQWKHUHYHUVHRWKHUZLVHQHDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
3:1
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[(OVHQ'HFHPEHUDQG/HX
2FWREHU
36

.DWDQH &LUFD %& +H[DV 6LOYHU PP J K
+HDG RI D \RXWKIXO EHDUGOHVV VDW\U WR OHIW 5HY . $ 9HUWLFDO
WKXQGHUEROW IODQNHG E\ WZR VPDOO VKLHOGV RU SKLDODL %RHKULQJHU
3:1 .DWDQHLVFKHS*URXS,SO+[WKLVFRLQ([WUHPHO\UDUHRI
H[FHOOHQW FODVVLFDO VW\OH DQG ZLWK JUH\ VXUIDFHV DV IRXQG 6OLJKWO\
URXJKRWKHUZLVHJRRGYHU\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[7ULWRQ,,,1RYHPEHU
37

.HSKDORLGLRQ$IWHU&LUFD%&%URQ]HPPJK
,Y\ZUHDWKHG KHDG RI D 0DHQDG WR ULJKW 5HY .(ĭ$ 'LRQ\VRV
EHDUGHG DQG SDUWLDOO\ GUDSHG VWDQGLQJ OHIW KROGLQJ D NDQWKDURV LQ
KLV ULJKW KDQG KROGLQJ KLV WK\UVRV LQ KLV OHIW DQG UHVWLQJ KLV OHIW
HOERZRQDORZFROXPQWRULJKW&DOFLDWL61*&RSHQKDJHQ
61*0QFKHQ$WWUDFWLYHGDUNEURZQJUHHQSDWLQD$SDUWLFX
ODUO\FOHDUH[DPSOH*RRGYHU\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[3HXV$SULO
7KHKHDGRQWKHREYHUVHRIWKLVFRLQKDVEHHQLGHQWLILHGE\VRPHDVEHLQJD
\RXQJ'LRQ\VRVLIVRKHGLIIHUVIURPWKHILJXUHRI'LRQ\VRVRQWKHUHYHUVH
2:1 ZKR LV FOHDUO\ EHDUGHG ,V WKDW OLNHO\" 0RUH SUREDEO\ WKH KHDG RQ WKH
REYHUVHLVRQHRI'LRQ\VRV
VIDYRULWHIROORZHUVD0DHQDGRUQ\PSK
38

0HVVDQD &LUFD %& /LWUD 6LOYHU PP J K
+DUH VSULQJLQJ WR ULJKW EHORZ LY\ EUDQFK 5HY 0(Ȉ ZLWKLQ ROLYH
ZUHDWKZLWKWLHVWROHIW&DOWDELDQR'5WKLVFRLQ61*
$16YDU6RPHZKDWOLJKWO\VWUXFNDQGZLWKJUH\WRQLQJ*RRG
YHU\ILQH
2:1
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ DQG WKDW RI $ 0RUHWWL /HX2FWREHU
DQG IURP WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI &RQWH $ 0DJQDJXWL , 6DQWDPDULD
2FWREHU
39

0HVVDQD&LUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K&KDULRWHHUGULYLQJELJDRIPXOHVZDONLQJWRULJKWDERYH1LNH
IO\LQJ OHIW WR FURZQ WKH GULYHU LQ H[HUJXH ROLYH VSULJ 5HY
ȂǼȈȈǹȃǿȅȃUHWURJUDGH+DUHVSULQJLQJWRULJKWDERYHKHDG
RI EHDUGHG 3DQ WR ULJKW EHORZ ROLYH VSULJ &DOWDELDQR
'55L]]RSO[[YVDPHGLHV61*&RSHQKDJHQ
VDPH GLHV 9HU\ UDUH OLJKWO\ WRQHG DQG VWUXFN RQ D EURDG IODQ
$ERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH 2:1
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ IURP WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI 0DULDQ $ 6LQWRQ
7ULWRQ,,,1RYHPEHUDQGIURPWKHVWRFNRI1XPLVPDWLF)LQH
$UWV6RWKHE\
V=XULFK2FWREHU
40

0HVVDQD&LUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K >ȂǼȈȈǹȃ$@ 7KH 1\PSK 0HVVDQD ZHDULQJ ORQJ FKLWRQ DQG
KROGLQJJRDGDQGUHLQVGULYLQJPXOHGUDZQELJDWROHIWLQH[HUJXH
WZR RSSRVHG GROSKLQV 5HY 0(ȈȈ$1,21 UHWURJUDGH +DUH
VSULQJLQJWRULJKWEHORZJUDVVKRSSHUIHHGLQJWRULJKWRQDEXQFKRI
JUDSHV ZLWK YLQH EUDQFK &DOWDELDQR '5 WKLV FRLQ
5L]]R SO [[YL VDPH GLHV 61* &RSHQKDJHQ VDPH GLHV
9HU\DWWUDFWLYHO\WRQHG2EYHUVHVOLJKWO\RIIFHQWHURWKHUZLVHJRRG
YHU\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQDQGIURPWKHFROOHFWLRQRI$0RUHWWL7ULWRQ 2:1
,'HFHPEHUH[+HVV/HX0DUFK
41

0HVVDQD&LUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJK
7KHQ\PSK0HVVDQDZHDULQJFKLWRQDQGVWDQGLQJOHIWZLWKWKHUHLQVLQ
ERWKKDQGVGULYLQJELJDRIPXOHVZDONLQJWROHIWDERYH1LNHIO\LQJ
ULJKW WR FURZQ 0HVVDQD LQ H[HUJXH WZR RSSRVHG GROSKLQV 5HY
ȂǼȈȈǹȃǿȅȃ+DUHVSULQJLQJWRULJKWEHORZKHDGRI\RXWKIXO3DQWR
ULJKWZLWKFXUO\KDLUDQGZLWKDWLQ\KRUQRYHUKLVIRUHKHDG&DOWDELDQR
'561*$16VDPHGLHV:HOOVWUXFNFDUHIXOO\
FHQWHUHGDQGOLJKWO\WRQHG6RPHXQFOHDQHGGHSRVLWVRIKRUQVLOYHURQ
WKHREYHUVHRWKHUZLVHJRRGYHU\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQDQGIURPWKDWRI'U5$OH[DQGHU1HZ<RUN 2:1
6DOH 9 -DQXDU\ H[ 1XPLVPDWLF )LQH $UWV 1RYHPEHU

42

1D[RV &LUFD %& /LWUD 6LOYHU PP J K
+HDG RI EHDUGHG 'LRQ\VRV WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ LY\ ZUHDWK 5HY 1$;,
UHWURJUDGH*UDSHEXQFKZLWKLQDQLY\ZUHDWK&DKQ95
2:1 WKLV FRLQ WKH REYHUVH LOOXVWUDWHG RQ SO ,9 7RQHG 6WUXFN IURP D
VOLJKWO\ZRUQREYHUVHGLHRWKHUZLVHYHU\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ /HX 2FWREHU DQG LQ D
SULYDWHFROOHFWLRQLQ%DVHO6ZLW]HUODQGSULRUWR
43
2:1
1D[RV &LUFD %& 2QNLD %URQ]H PP J K
<RXWKIXOPDOHKHDGWRULJKWZHDULQJWDLQLD5HY1$9LQHOHDIDQG
SHOOHW &DKQ &DOFLDWL /DIIDLOOH ([WUHPHO\ UDUH :LWK D
ORYHO\ PLGGOHJUHHQ SDWLQD 5HYHUVH VOLJKWO\ RII FHQWHU RWKHUZLVH
YHU\ILQH
2:1 44

1D[RV &LUFD %& /LWUD 6LOYHU PP J K
VLJQHG E\ WKH HQJUDYHU 3URNOHV RQ WKH REYHUVH ȃǹȋǿȍȃ +HDG RI
\RXWKIXO'LRQ\VRVWROHIWZHDULQJLY\ZUHDWKEHORZEDUHO\YLVLEOH
KHUH WLQ\ Ȇ 5HY 9LQH EUDQFK ZLWK EXQFK RI JUDSHV &DKQ
95VDPHGLHV61*$1661*/OR\G5DUH$
ORYHO\ VKDUS WRQHG FRLQ RI H[FHOOHQW &ODVVLFDO VW\OH 1HDUO\
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ * +LUVFK 1DFKI 1RYHPEHU
DQG1HZ<RUN6DOH,,,'HFHPEHU
45
2:1
1D[RV&LUFD%&7HWUDVRU7ULRQNLRQ6LOYHUPPJ
K 1 $ .DQWKDURV DURXQG WKUHH SHOOHWV YDOXH PDUNV 5HY 9LQH
ZLWKDJUDSHEXQFK&DKQ+*&61*$16([WUHPHO\UDUH
3OHDVLQJGDUNJUH\SDWLQD1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[/HX0D\6WHUQEHUJ
1RYHPEHU DQG 0Q]HQ XQG 0HGDLOOHQ )3/
1RYHPEHU'HFHPEHU
46

6HJHVWD&LUFD%&'LGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJK
+XQWLQJGRJVWDQGLQJDOHUWO\WRULJKW5HYȈǼīǼȈȉǹǽǿ'LDGHPHG
KHDG RI WKH Q\PSK 6HJHVWD WR ULJKW KHU KDLU ERXQG XS DW WKH EDFN
DQG WXUQHG XQGHU KHU GLDGHP DOO ZLWK D OLQHDU FLUFOH ZLWK WKH 2:1
LQVFULSWLRQ RXWVLGH +XUWHU F WKLV FRLQ 9HU\ UDUH 6WUXFN IURP
GLHV HQJUDYHG E\ DQ H[FHSWLRQDO HQJUDYHU ZKR ZDV D PDVWHU RI
&ODVVLFDO VW\OH $WWUDFWLYHO\ WRQHG 6RPH WUDFHV RI FRUURVLRQ
RWKHUZLVHJRRGYHU\ILQH
)URPDQ(QJOLVKFROOHFWLRQDQGIURPWKHFROOHFWLRQRI+0DDJ3HXV
1RYHPEHU H[ .XUSIlO]LVFKH 0Q]KDQGOXQJ-XQH
DQG8%6)HEUXDU\
2:1
47

6HOLQRV&LUFD%&2ERO6LOYHUPPJK
/HDIRIZLOGSDUVOH\5HY/HDIRIZLOGSDUVOH\ZLWKLQDOLQHDUFLUFOH
LQVLGH D FLUFOH RU SHOOHWV DOO ZLWKLQ D FLUFXODU LQFXVH &I $UQROG
)ORULOHJLXP 61* $16 61* 0XQLFK YDU &OHDU
ZHOOVWUXFNDQGZHOOFHQWHUHGRQDEURDGIODQ$WWUDFWLYHGDUNSDWLQD
DVIRXQG([WUHPHO\ILQH
([5LFKHOLHX1XPLVPDWLTXH0DUFK
48
2:1

6\UDFXVH 'HLQRPHQLG 7\UDQQ\ %& 7HWUDGUDFKP
6LOYHU PP J K F %HDUGHG FKDULRWHHU
GULYLQJTXDGULJDZDONLQJWROHIWDERYH1LNHIO\LQJOHIWWRFURZQWKH
KRUVHV 5HY Ȉ95ǹȀȅȈǿȅȃ 'LDGHPHG KHDG RI $UHWKXVD WR ULJKW
KHUKDLUWLHGLQDNURE\ORVDURXQGIRXUGROSKLQVVZLPPLQJWRULJKW
%RHKULQJHU 'HZLQJ -DPHVRQ 5DQGD]]R 61*
$16 DOO VDPH GLHV 5DUH :HOOVWUXFN DQG ZHOOFHQWHUHG RQ D
IXOO IODQ WRQHG DQG RI ORYHO\ ODWH $UFKDLF VW\OH 1HDUO\ H[WUHPHO\
ILQH
)URP WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI $ 7UDPSLWVFK 9LQFKRQ 0RQDFR 1RYHPEHU
H[ +LUVFK ;; 1RYHPEHU ERXJKW E\ 5ROOLQ
)HXDUGHQWIRU50DJDLQVW6SLQN
49

6\UDFXVH 'HLQRPHQLG 7\UDQQ\ %& 7HWUDGUDFKP
6LOYHUPPJKF0DOHFKDULRWHHUZHDULQJD
ORQJ FKLWRQ DQG KROGLQJ D JRDG LQ KLV ULJKW KDQG DQG WKH UHLQV LQ
ERWKGULYLQJDZDONLQJTXDGULJDWRULJKWDERYH1LNHIO\LQJULJKWWR
FURZQWKHKRUVHV5HYȈ95ǹȀȅȈǿȅȃWKH5XSVLGHGRZQ+HDGRI
$UHWKXVDWRULJKWZHDULQJQHFNODFHDQGSHDUOGLDGHPDQGZLWKKHU
2:1 KDLU WLHG LQ D NURE\ORV WKDW LV ERXQG XS DQG IDOOV RYHU KHU GLDGHP
DURXQG IRXU GROSKLQV VZLPPLQJ FORFNZLVH %RHKULQJHU WKLV
FRLQ5DQGD]]RVDPHGLHV:HEHUWKLVFRLQ$ORYHO\
WRQHGFRLQZLWKDILQHKHDGRI$UHWKXVD2EYHUVHVWUXFNIURPDZRUQ
GLHRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKHFROOHFWLRQRI6LU+:HEHU$UV&ODVVLFD,9-XQH
ERXJKWIURP:75HDG\LQDQGUHFRUGHGDVEHLQJIURPD7KRPDV
VDOHSRVVLEO\WKDWVROGE\:DUG&RYHQWU\)HEUXDU\
50
2:1
6\UDFXVH 6HFRQG 'HPRFUDF\ %& 7HWUDGUDFKP 6LOYHU
PP J K F &KDULRWHHU GULYLQJ TXDGULJD
ZDONLQJWRULJKWKROGLQJJRDGLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGWKHUHLQVLQERWK
DERYH1LNHIO\LQJOHIWWRFURZQWKHGULYHULQH[HUJXHNHWRVWRULJKW
5HY ȈȊ5ǹȀȅȈ ǿ ȅ ȃ 'LDGHPHG KHDG RI $UHWKXVD WR ULJKW
ZHDULQJ SHQGDQW HDUULQJ DQG SHDUO QHFNODFH DURXQG IRXU GROSKLQV
VZLPPLQJ WR ULJKW %RHKULQJHU 95 /LJKWO\ WRQHG
OXVWURXV ZHOOFHQWHUHG DQG VKDUSO\ VWUXFN 2EYHUVH VWUXFN IURP D
YHU\VOLJKWO\ZRUQGLHRWKHUZLVHJRRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH&RPHU\&ROOHFWLRQ5RPD0DUFK
2:1
51

6\UDFXVH 6HFRQG 'HPRFUDF\ %& +HPLOLWURQ %URQ]H
PP J K FLUFD >Ȉ<3$@ +HDG RI \RXQJ
'LRQ\VRV WR OHIW ZHDULQJ LY\ ZUHDWK 5HY 2FWRSXV ZLWK HQWDQJOHG
IURQW WHQWDFOHV FI %RHKULQJHU VHULHV ;9,,, &16 61* $16
9HU\UDUH*ORVV\GDUNJUHHQSDWLQD9HU\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[9HFFKL0D\
52

6\UDFXVH'LRQ\VLRV,%&'UDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K SUREDEO\ DQ XQVLJQHG ZRUN E\ (XNOHLGDV F
ȈȊȇǹȀȅȈǿȍȃ +HDG RI $WKHQD IDFLQJ ZHDULQJ WULSOH FUHVWHG
$WWLF KHOPHW HDUULQJ DQG QHFNODFH RI SHQGDQW DFRUQV DURXQG IRXU 2:1
GROSKLQV 5HY ȈȊȇǹȀȅȈǿȍȃ /HXNDVSLV QXGH EXW IRU KHOPHW
VWULGLQJ ULJKW KROGLQJ FRXFKHG VSHDU LQ KLV ULJKW KDQG DQG VKLHOG
ZLWKKLVOHIWEHORZDQGEHKLQGWROHIWVTXDUHDOWDUZLWKILUHEXUQLQJ
RQWRSDQGZLWKDJDUODQGRQWKHVLGHEHORZWRULJKWVDFULILFHGUDP
O\LQJ RQLWVEDFNLQH[HUJXHȁǼȊȀǹȈȆǿȈ%0)$ :DUUHQ
VDPH REYHUVH GLH 'H /X\QHV 5L]]R SO ;/9,,
VDPHGLHV.)VDPHREYHUVHGLH61*$16VDPH
REYHUVH GLH 5DUH DQG RI PDUYHORXV &ODVVLFDO VW\OH EHDXWLIXOO\
WRQHG DQG YHU\ ZHOO SUHVHUYHG DQ H[FHSWLRQDOO\ ILQH H[DPSOH
([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPD(XURSHDQFROOHFWLRQIRUPHGZHOOEHIRUH
53

6\UDFXVH 'LRQ\VLRV , %& 7HWUDGUDFKP 6LOYHU PP
J K XQVLJQHG EXW E\ 3DUPHQLGHV F &KDULRWHHU
KROGLQJUHLQVDQGNHQWURQGULYLQJDTXDGULJDUXVKLQJWROHIWDERXWWR
WXUQDERYH1LNHIO\LQJULJKWWRFURZQWKHGULYHUEHORZWKHKRRYHV 2:1
RIWKHKRUVHLQWKHIRUHJURXQGFKDULRWZKHHOLQH[HUJXHEDUOH\HDU
5HYȈȊȇǹȀȅȈǿȍȃ+HDGRI$UHWKXVDWROHIWZHDULQJDPS\[DQG
VSKHQGRQH GHFRUDWHG ZLWK VWDUV WULSOHSHQGDQW HDUULQJ DQG VLPSOH
QHFNODFH DURXQG WKUHH GROSKLQV VZLPPLQJ LQ GLIIHUHQW GLUHFWLRQV
ZLWKDIRXUWKHPHUJLQJIURPXQGHUWKHQHFNWUXQFDWLRQ-DPHVRQ
VDPH GLHV 7XGHHU )LVFKHU%RVVHUW D WKLV FRLQ9HU\UDUH$
EHDXWLIXODQGZHOOVWUXFNFRLQSUREDEO\WKHILQHVWNQRZQ([WUHPHO\
ILQH
([1XPLVPDWLFD$UV&ODVVLFD$SULOIURPWKHFROOHFWLRQRI
/YRQ+RIIPDQQ,6RWKHE\-XO\H[%DQN/HX0D\
DQG0RQQDLHVHW0pGDLOOHV2FWREHU
6LU$UWKXU(YDQVEHOLHYHGKHFRXOGUHDGWKHVLJQDWXUHȆǹȇLQWLQ\OHWWHUVRQ
$UHWKXVD
V QHFN VLQFH WKHQ QR RQH HOVH KDV EHHQ DEOH WR VHH LW 7KH
OLNHOLKRRGLVWKDWKHZDVPLVOHGE\WUDFHVRIFRUURVLRQRUGLHEUHDNVRQWKH
FRLQKHH[DPLQHG7KLVVSOHQGLGSLHFHVKRZVQRVLJQVRIDQ\WLQ\OHWWHUV
54

6\UDFXVH 7LPROHRQ DQG WKH 7KLUG 'HPRFUDF\ %&
6WDWHU 6LOYHU PP J K 3HJDVRV IO\LQJ WR OHIW 5HY
Ȉ<3$.2Ȉ,ȍ1+HDGRI$WKHQDWRULJKWZHDULQJ&RULQWKLDQKHOPHW
&DOFLDWL61*$16VDPHREYHUVHGLH$ORYHO\WRQHGFRLQ
YHU\ZHOOFHQWHUHG9HU\PLQRUDUHDRIIODWVWULNLQJRQWKHREYHUVH
2:1 RWKHUZLVHJRRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
([*LHVVHQHU0Q]KDQGOXQJ2FWREHU
55

6\UDFXVH 7LPROHRQ DQG WKH 7KLUG 'HPRFUDF\ %&
+HPLOLWURQ %URQ]H PP J K FLUFD
Ȉ<3$.2Ȉ, +HDG RI \RXWKIXO 3DQ WR OHIW 5HY 6\ULQ[ ZLWK QLQH
SLSHV ZLWKLQ RDN ZUHDWK &DOFLDWL VDPH GLHV )DYRULWR
61* $16 9LU]L ([WUHPHO\ UDUH DQG SUREDEO\ WKH
ILQHVWNQRZQ:LWKDGDUNJUHHQSDWLQDDQGDILQHKHDGRI3DQ9HU\
PLQRUVPRRWKLQJRQWKHUHYHUVH([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ DQG IURP WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI ' )UHHGPDQ
7ULWRQ9-DQXDU\
2:1
56

6\UDFXVH $JDWKRNOHV %& 7HWUDGUDFKP 6LOYHU PP
JKF:UHDWKHGKHDGRI$UHWKXVDWROHIWZHDULQJ
WULSOH SHQGDQW HDUULQJ DQG SHDUO QHFNODFH DURXQG WKUHH GROSKLQV
EHORZ QHFN ĭǿ 5HY Ȉ<3$.2Ȉ,ȍ1 &KDULRWHHU GULYLQJ TXDGULJD WR
OHIW DERYH WULVNHOHV WR OHIW LQ H[HUJXH PRQRJUDP RI ǹǿ ,HUDUGL
VDPH GLHV 61* $16 $ SDUWLFXODUO\ ILQH H[DPSOH SHUIHFWO\
VWUXFNSHUIHFWO\FHQWHUHGDQGQLFHO\WRQHG([WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1 ([ *DOOHU\ %UXVVHOV 'HFHPEHU ¼ SULYDWHO\
SXUFKDVHGIURP$QQH'HPHHVWHUDQGRQFHZLWK7UDGDUW
57

6\UDFXVH $JDWKRNOHV %& 'HNDGUDFKP RU /LWUDL
(OHFWUXP PP J K F /DXUHDWH KHDG RI 2:1
$SROORWROHIWEHKLQGDPSKRUD5HYȈ<3$.2Ȉ,ȍ17ULSRG%$5
,VVXH %0& VDPH GLHV +*& -HQNLQV *URXS %
25 61* $16 ([FHOOHQW HDUO\ +HOOHQLVWLF VW\OH 6RPH
VXUIDFH LPSHUIHFWLRQV DQG ZLWK D GLH EUHDN RQ WKH UHYHUVH
RWKHUZLVHQHDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ 0Q]HQ XQG 0HGDLOOHQ '( ,
6HSWHPEHU
58

6\UDFXVH3KLOLVWLVZLIHRI+LHURQ,,%&/LWUDL6LOYHU
PPJK'LDGHPHGDQGYHLOHGEXVWRI3KLOLVWLV
WROHIWEHKLQGORQJWRUFK5HYǺǹȈǿȁǿȈȈǹȈ>ĭǿȁǿȈȉǿǻȅȈ@1LNH
GULYLQJTXDGULJDJDOORSLQJWRULJKWEHORZKRUVHVǼ%XUQHWW(QQD
VDPHGLHV&&2'561*$16VDPHREYHUVHGLH
61* &RSHQKDJHQ VDPH UHYHUVH GLH $ ORYHO\ H[DPSOH ZLWK D
ILQH SRUWUDLW DQ HVSHFLDOO\ OLYHO\ UHYHUVH DQG EHDXWLIXO VXUIDFHV
5HYHUVHVWUXFNVOLJKWO\RIIFHQWHUDQGZLWKPLQRUGLHIDXOWVRWKHUZLVH 2:1
QHDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
([&ODVVLFDO1XPLVPDWLF*URXS6HSWHPEHUDQG%DQN/HX
0D\
59
2:1
6\UDFXVH*HORQVRQRI+LHURQ,,%&/LWUDL6LOYHUPP
JKF'LDGHPHGKHDGRI*HORQWROHIW5HYȈȊȇǹȀȅ
Ȉ,2, īǼȁȍȃȅȈ (DJOH ZLWK FORVHG ZLQJV VWDQGLQJ WR ULJKW RQ D
WKXQGHUEROWWROHIW(WRULJKW%$%0&61*$16VDPH
UHYHUVH GLH 61* /RFNHWW *LHVHFNH SO VDPH GLHV
5DUH $Q XQXVXDOO\ ILQH WRQHG DQG DWWUDFWLYH H[DPSOH ZLWK DQ
HOHJDQWSRUWUDLWRIILQH+HOOHQLVWLFVW\OH([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPD6ZLVVFROOHFWLRQH[%DQN/HX0D\SUHYLRXVO\LQD
SULYDWHFROOHFWLRQIRUPHGSULRUWR:RUOG:DU,,
60

6\UDFXVH+LHURQ\PRV%&OLWUDL6LOYHUPPJ
K 'LDGHPHG KHDG RI +LHURQ\PRV WR OHIW 5HY %$Ȉ,ȁ(ȍȈ
,(3ȍ1<02< :LQJHG WKXQGHUEROW DERYH ĭǿ 'H /X¹QHV
VDPH GLHV +ROORZD\ $ YHU\ DWWUDFWLYH VKDUSO\ VWUXFN WRQHG
FRLQ*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
([7ULWRQ;9,,-DQXDU\DQG1XPLVPDWLFD*HQHYHQVLV9,,
1RYHPEHU
2:1
61

6\UDFXVH)LIWK'HPRFUDF\%&/LWUDL6LOYHUPP
J K +HDG RI $WKHQD WR OHIW ZHDULQJ FUHVWHG &RULQWKLDQ
KHOPHWSHQGDQWHDUULQJSHDUOQHFNODFHDQGDHJLVEHKLQGKHUKHDG
PRQRJUDP RI ǹī 5HY ȈȊȇǹȀȅȈǿȍȃ 7KXQGHUEROW EHORZ Ȉ ȍ
%XUQHWW (QQD GLHV 61* $16 9HU\ DWWUDFWLYH
ZHOOVWUXFN DQG QLFHO\ WRQHG 7LQ\ IODQ FUDFN RQ WKH UHYHUVH
RWKHUZLVHJRRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1 )URPD6ZLVVFROOHFWLRQH[*RUQ\ 0RVFK0DUFK
62

6\UDFXVH)LIWK'HPRFUDF\%&6LOYHUPPJ
K /LWUDL +HDG RI $WKHQD WR OHIW ZHDULQJ FUHVWHG &RULQWKLDQ
KHOPHWZLWKVHUSHQWRQWKHERZOSHQGDQWHDUULQJDQGSHDUOQHFNODFH
5HY ȈȊȇǹȀȅȈǿȍȃ $UWHPLV ZHDULQJ KXQWLQJ GUHVV VWDQGLQJ OHIW
GUDZLQJKHUERZDWKHUIHHWKXQWLQJGRJOHDSLQJWROHIWLQILHOGWR
OHIW Ȅǹ %XUQHWW (QQD 61* $16 1LFHO\ WRQHG DQG
2:1 ZHOOFHQWHUHG([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPD6ZLVVFROOHFWLRQH[*RUQ\ 0RVFK2FWREHUDQG
H[0RQQDLHVHW0pGDLOOHV1RYHPEHU
63

6\UDFXVH5RPDQUXOHDIWHU%&%URQ]HPPJK 2:1
-DQLIRUP KHDG RI D EHDUGHG 'LRQ\VRV ZHDULQJ LY\ZUHDWK 5HY
Ȉ<3$.2Ȉ,ȍ1 )LOOHWHG WK\UVRV &DOFLDWL 9LU]L 'DUN
JUHHQ SDWLQD :HOO FHQWHUHG DQG ZLWK XQXVXDOO\ ILQH GHWDLOV UDUH
WKXV$ERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ DQG IURP WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI ' )UHHGPDQ
&ODVVLFDO1XPLVPDWLF*URXS0%66HSWHPEHU
2:1
64

7DXURPHQLRQ&LUFD%&/LWUD6LOYHUPPJK
%XFUDQLXP 5HY 7$<30 %XQFK RI JUDSHV 61* $16 61*
&RSHQKDJHQ61*/RFNHWWVDPHGLHV8QFOHDQHGZLWKDJUH\
SDWLQDDVIRXQGZHOOVWUXFNDQGVKDUS([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[:DGGHOO)3/-XO\
65
2:1

7DXURPHQLRQ5RPDQUXOHDIWHU%&%URQ]HPPJ
K+HDGRI\RXWKIXO'LRQ\VRVWRULJKWZHDULQJLY\ZUHDWK5HY
7$<320(1,7$1 %XOO ZDONLQJ VORZO\ WR ULJKW KHDG IDFLQJ
&DOFLDWL,,,61*&RSHQKDJHQ9LU]LWKLVFRLQ5DUH
/RYHO\DSSOHJUHHQSDWLQD*RRGYHU\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQIURPWKHFROOHFWLRQRI')UHHGPDQ7ULWRQ
9-DQXDU\DQGIURPWKDWRI79LU]L
66

8QORFDWHG3XQLFPLQWV&LUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHU
PPJK+RUVHJDOORSLQJWRULJKWDERYH1LNHIO\LQJULJKW
WR FURZQ WKH KRUVH 5HY 'DWH SDOP ZLWK WZR GDWH FOXVWHUV -HQNLQV
3XQLFWKLVFRLQFLWHG/RFNHU/DPSVRQ 61*/RFNHWW
:HEHUVDPHGLHV61*/OR\GVDPHGLHV([WUHPHO\
2:1 UDUH $ EHDXWLIXOO\ WRQHG DQG H[FHSWLRQDOO\ DWWUDFWLYH H[DPSOH ZLWK D
VSOHQGLGSHGLJUHH1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP D (XURSHDQ FROOHFWLRQ H[ 7UDGDUW -XO\ DQG IURP WKH
FROOHFWLRQVRI&*LOOHW0RQQDLHVHW0pGDLOOHV1RYHPEHU
:+:RRGZDUG5ROOLQHW)HXDUGHQW0D\/RUG5RWKVFKLOG
/DWH&ROOHFWRU6:+0D\5&DUIUDH6:+0D\
DQG)%RPSRLV++RIIPDQQ-DQXDU\DQGIURPWKH
FROOHFWLRQ RI ( :LJDQ VROG SULYDWHO\ WR 5ROOLQ )HXDUGHQW
VKRUWO\DIWHUKLVGHDWK
&DUWKDJH
67

&LUFD%&6KHNHO6LOYHUPPJK+HDGRI
7DQLW3HUVHSKRQH WR OHIW ZHDULQJ SHQGDQW QHFNODFH VLQJOHGURS
2:1 HDUULQJDQGJUDLQZUHDWK5HY+RUVHVWDQGLQJWRULJKWKHDGUHYHUWHG
EHKLQG GDWH SDOP WR ULJKW VWDU RI HLJKW UD\V -HQNLQV *URXS SO
( 61* &RS 5DUH 1LFHO\ WRQHG DQG ZHOOFHQWHUHG 9HU\
PLQRU IODQ IDXOW SHUKDSV IURP VWULNLQJ DQG VRPH PLQRU GLH UXVW
([+-%HUN%RU%0DUFKIURPWKHFROOHFWLRQRI&3HSHU
SXUFKDVHGIRUIURP%XUGHWWH*-RKQVRQRI6W/RXLVGXULQJWKHV
SUHYLRXVO\ YHU\ SRVVLEO\ IURP WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI 9 0%UDQG-RKQVRQZDV
LQYROYHGLQWKHGLVSHUVDORI%UDQGPDWHULDOVWDUWLQJLQWKHV&KULVWLDQ
3HSHU'HFHPEHU-XO\ZDVDSURPLQHQW6W/RXLVODZ\HU
DQGZDVERWKDPHPEHURIWKHERDUGRIDQGDPDMRUGRQRUWRWKH6W/RXLV
$UW0XVHXP6/$0+HZDVDIULHQGRIWKHKLVWRULDQ$UQROG7R\QEHHDQG
XVHGWROLNHWHOOLQJMRNHVLQ/DWLQ
&LPPHULDQ%RVSRUXV
68

3DQWLNDSDLRQ&LUFD%&2ERO6LOYHUPPJK
+HDG RI EHDUGHGVDW\UWROHIW5HYȆ$17,)RUHSDUWRIOLRQWROHIW
EHKLQG WR ULJKW FUHVFHQW ZLWK SRLQWV WR OHIW $QRNKLQ +*&
0DF'RQDOG61*%0%ODFN6HD9HU\UDUH2IILQHVW\OH
DQGZLWKDQDWWUDFWLYHJUH\SDWLQDDVIRXQG8QLPSRUWDQWHGJHNQRFN
RQWKHUHYHUVHDWRWKHUZLVHDERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
3:1
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[6SLQN2FWREHU
69

3DQWLNDSDLRQ &LUFD %& +HPLGUDFKP 6LOYHU PP
J K ,Y\ZUHDWKHG KHDG RI D \RXWKIXO VDW\U IDFLQJ WXUQHG
VOLJKWO\ WR WKH OHIW 5HY Ȇ$1 )DFLQJ OLRQ
V PDVN $QRNKLQ
0DF'RQDOG 61* %0 %ODFN 6HD $ SRZHUIXO ZHOOVWUXFN
H[DPSOH :LWK FU\VWDOL]HG VXUIDFHV RWKHUZLVH QHDUO\ H[WUHPHO\
ILQH
2:1
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ * +LUVFK 1DFKI 0D\

70

3DQWLNDSDLRQ&LUFD%&'UDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K%HDUGHGKHDGRI3DQZLWKSRLQWHGJRDW
VHDUVWROHIWEXWWXUQHG
WKUHHTXDUWHUV IDFLQJ WR IURQW 5HY Ȇ$1 %XOO
V KHDG WR OHIW WXUQHG
VOLJKWO\ WR IURQW $QRNKLQ 0DF'RQDOG 61* %0 %ODFN 6HD
61*&RSHQKDJHQ61*6WDQFRPE:LWKDQREOHKHDGRI
3DQDQGDQDWWUDFWLYHGDUNWRQLQJ:LWKVRPHZKDWFU\VWDOL]HGVXUIDFHV 2:1
DVXVXDORWKHUZLVHDERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[6SLQN2FWREHU
71

3DQWLNDSDLRQ&LUFD%&'UDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K %HDUGHG KHDG RI 3DQ WR OHIW WXUQHG WKUHHTXDUWHUV IDFLQJ WR
IURQW 5HY Ȇ ǹ ȃ %XOO¶V KHDG WR OHIW WXUQHG VOLJKWO\ WR IURQW
$QRNKLQ 0DF'RQDOG 61*%0 61* 6WDQFRPE
7RQHG DWWUDFWLYH DQG EROGO\ VWUXFN )ODQ UDWKHU UDJJHG RWKHUZLVH
DERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1
)URPDQ$PHULFDQFROOHFWLRQH[1RPRV0D\
:KLOH YHU\ VLPLODULQGHHGWKLVFRLQDQGWKHRQHLQWKHSUHFHHGLQJORWDUH
VWUXFNIURPGLIIHUHQWGLHSDLUV
0RHVLD,QIHULRU
72

2:1
7RPLV3HULRGRI$QWRQLQXV3LXV+HPLDVVDULRQ%URQ]H
PPJKȉȅȂȅȊǾȇȍȅɋ'LDGHPHGDQGGUDSHGEXVW
OHIW RI WKH OHJHQGDU\ IRXQGHU RI WKH FLW\ WKH \RXWKIXO KHUR 7RPRV
5HY ȉȅȂǿȉȍȃ %XQFK RI JUDSHV $01* 53& ,9
WHPSRUDU\QXPEHUVDPHGLHV$QHOHJDQWVKDUSO\VWUXFNFRLQZLWK
D ILQH GDUN EODFNLVKEURZQ SDWLQD 0LQRU IODQ FUDFN RWKHUZLVH
QHDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQDQGIURPWKDWRI-35LJKHWWL,,$XFWLRQHV
$*-XQH
7KUDFH
2:1
73

$EGHUD&LUFD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJK
3\WKRQǹǺǻǾȇǿ*ULIILQUHDULQJXSWROHIW5HYȆȊĬȍȃ7ULSRG
0D\ $EGHUD D 9HU\ UDUH $Q LPSUHVVLYH DQG DWWUDFWLYH FRLQ
8QFOHDQHGDVIRXQGRWKHUZLVHDERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
([%DQN/HX0D\
74

$EGHUD &LUFD %& 'UDFKP 6LOYHU PP J
K 0ROSDJRUHV *ULIILQ ZLWK RSHQ ZLQJV DQG ERWK IRUHOHJV
UDLVHG VHDWHG WR OHIW 5HY 02ȁȆ$ī23+Ȉ +HDG RI \RXWKIXO
'LRQ\VRVWROHIWZHDULQJLY\ZUHDWKDOOLQVLGHDOLQHDUVTXDUHZLWKLQ
DVKDOORZFLUFXODULQFXVH0F&OHDQVDPHGLHV0D\$EGHUD
$5 61* &RSHQKDJHQ VDPH GLHV 6KDUS
2:1
ZHOOFHQWHUHGDQGYHU\DWWUDFWLYHO\WRQHG([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[0Q]HQXQG0HGDLOOHQ-XQH

75

$LQRV&LUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K+HDGRI+HUPHVWRULJKWKLVKDLUZRXQGDURXQGKLVKHDGLQD
SODLWZHDULQJDSHWDVRVZLWKDEHDGHGERUGHUDQGDEXWWRQDWWKHWRS
5HY $,1, 0DOH JRDW VWDQGLQJ WR ULJKW WR ULJKW LY\ OHDI ZLWKLQ D
FUHVFHQW DOO ZLWKLQ D VKDOORZLQFXVHVTXDUH$01*0D\G
$3 WKLV FRLQ 5DUH 7RQHG DQG ZLWK D SRZHUIXO KHDG RI
+HUPHVLQDYLJRURXVDOPRVWUXVWLFHDUO\&ODVVLFDOQRUWKHUQ*UHHN
VW\OH1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ DQG IURP WKH 6WDU &ROOHFWLRQ /+6
$SULO DQG IURP WKH FROOHFWLRQV RI ' )pUHW 9LQFKRQ
1RYHPEHUWKH&RPWHVVH0GH%pKDJXH9LQFKRQ$SULO
DQGWKDWRI73URZH(JJHU;/9,0D\
2:1
76

$LQRV&LUFD%&'UDFKP6LOYHUPPJK
+HDG RI +HUPHV IDFLQJ WXUQHG VOLJKWO\ WR WKH ULJKW ZHDULQJ D IODW
SHWDVRVZLWKDEXWWRQDWWKHWRS5HY$,1,21&XOWVWDWXHRI+HUPHV
3HUSKHUDLRV RQ WKURQH WR OHIW WR OHIW JUDSH FOXVWHU RQ YLQH 0D\
$LQRV *URXS /;;,, FI 61* &RSHQKDJHQ YDU
V\PERO ([WUHPHO\ UDUH DSSDUHQWO\ WKH RQO\ H[DPSOH ZLWK WKLV
V\PERO WRQHG DQG RI ILQH ODWH &ODVVLFDO VW\OH $ERXW H[WUHPHO\
ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ &ODVVLFDO 1XPLVPDWLF *URXS
6HSWHPEHU
77

0DURQHLD&LUFD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJK
'HRQ\RV%ULGOHGKRUVHVSULQJLQJWROHIWZLWKWUDLOLQJUHLQDERYHKHDG
RIDEHDUGHGVDW\UIDFLQJ5HY(Ȇ,ǻ(21<2Ȉ*UDSHYLQHZLWKIRXU
EXQFKHVRIJUDSHVZLWKLQOLQHDUVTXDUHDURXQGLQVFULSWLRQDOOZLWKLQ
VKDOORZ LQFXVH VTXDUH 6FK|QHUW*HLVV EXW VDPH UHYHUVH GLH DV
([WUHPHO\ UDUH ZLWK WKLV REYHUVH V\PERO DQG YHU\ QLFHO\ 2:1
WRQHG*RRGYHU\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ 1XPLVPDWLFD $UV &ODVVLFD , 0D\

7KH QDPH 'HRQ\RV LV YHU\ XQFRPPRQ LW RQO\ DSSHDUV RQ FRLQV IURP
$EGHUD DQG 0DURQHLD DQG LV YHU\ SUREDEO\ RI QRUWKHUQ *UHHN RU 7KUDFLDQ
RULJLQ
78

0DURQHLD&LUFD%&7ULRERO6LOYHUPPJ
K(<>Ȇ@)RUHSDUWRIDKRUVHWROHIW5HYȂǹ*UDSHFOXVWHURQ
D YLQH ZLWKLQ GRWWHG VTXDUH 6FK|QHUW*HLVV 95 61*
2:1 &RSHQKDJHQ VDPH REYHUVH GLH 6KDUS DQG QLFHO\ WRQHG
([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[&ODVVLFDO1XPLVPDWLF*URXS-XQH

79

0DURQHLD &LUFD %&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJ
K&KRUHJRV%ULGOHGKRUVHVSULQJLQJWROHIWZLWKWUDLOLQJUHLQ5HY
(Ȇ, ;23+ī2 *UDSH YLQH ZLWK IRXU EXQFKHV RI JUDSHV DOO ZLWKLQ
OLQHDUVTXDUHDURXQGLQVFULSWLRQZLWKDIO\DWWKHXSSHUOHIWDOOZLWKLQ
DVKDOORZLQFXVHVTXDUH6FK|QHUW*HLVV9561*&RSHQ
KDJHQ /LJKWO\ WRQHG ZHOOFHQWHUHG DQG DWWUDFWLYH 6RPH PLQRU
WUDFHVRIKRUQVLOYHURWKHUZLVHQHDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[9HFFKL2FWREHU
2:1
80

0DURQHLD &LUFD %& 7HWUDGUDFKP 6LOYHU PP
J K FLUFD V %& +HDG RI \RXWKIXO 'LRQ\VRV WR ULJKW
ZHDULQJWDHQLDDQGLY\ZUHDWKDQGZLWKKLVKDLUSDUWLDOO\NQRWWHGLQWRD
TXHXH DQG SDUWLDOO\ IDOOLQJ GRZQ WKH EDFN RI KLV QHFN 5HY
ǻǿȅȃȊȈȅȊȈȍȉǾȇȅȈȂǹȇȍȃǿȉȍȃ'LRQ\VRVQXGHVWDQGLQJWR
OHIWZLWKFORDNRYHUKLVOHIWDUPKROGLQJEXQFKRIJUDSHVLQKLVULJKW
KDQG DQG QDUWKH[ VWDONV LQ KLV OHIW EHORZ WR OHIW DQG ULJKW WZR
PRQRJUDPV 6FK|QHUW*HLVV 95 61* &RSHQKDJHQ
7RQHG DQG RI D SRZHUIXO ODWH +HOOHQLVWLF VW\OH 1HDUO\
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[/HX0D\DQG&ODVVLFDO
1XPLVPDWLF*URXS'HFHPEHU
.LQJVRI7KUDFH
81

/\VLPDFKRV%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJK
VWUXFN SRVWKXPRXVO\ 3DULRQ F VV %& 'LDGHPHG KHDG RI
WKHGHLILHG$OH[DQGHUWKH*UHDWWRULJKWZLWKKRUQRI$PPRQRYHU
KLV HDU 5HY %$Ȉ,ȁ(ȍȈ ȁȊȈ,0$ȋ2Ȋ $WKHQD VHDWHG WR OHIW RQ
WKURQH KROGLQJ 1LNH FURZQLQJ WKH NLQJ
V QDPH LQ KHU ULJKW KDQG
DQG OHDQLQJ KHU OHIW HOERZ RQ KHU VKLHOG EHKLQG KHU WUDQVYHUVH
VSHDU RXWHU OHIW WK\UVRV LQQHU OHIW PRQRJUDP RI ĭ< 0H\GDQ
FLNNDOH 0OOHU 6H\ULJ 3DULRQ VDPH GLHV :LWK D
KHDG RI $OH[DQGHU LQ D EROG LQGLYLGXDO VW\OH UHPLQLVFHQW RI D
6HOHXNLG SRUWUDLW $WWUDFWLYHO\ WRQHG 0LQRU PDUNV RWKHUZLVH
H[WUHPHO\ILQH 2:1
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ 7ULWRQ 9,, -DQXDU\ DQG
&ODVVLFDO1XPLVPDWLF$XFWLRQV;,0D\LOOXVWUDWHGRQWKHIURQW
FRYHU
82

3WROHP\.HUDXQRV%&6WDWHU*ROGPPJK
LQWKHQDPHDQGZLWKWKHW\SHVRI/\VLPDFKRV/\VLPDFKHLD
'LDGHPHGKHDGRI$OH[DQGHUWKH*UHDWWRULJKWZLWKKRUQRI$PPRQ
RYHU KLV HDU 5HY ǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈ ȁȊȈǿȂǹȋȅȊ $WKHQD VHDWHG OHIW RQ
ORZEDFNHG WKURQH KROGLQJ 1LNH FURZQLQJ WKH NLQJ¶V QDPH LQ KHU
ULJKWKDQGDORQJWUDQVYHUVHVSHDULQKHUOHIWDQGZLWKKHUOHIWHOERZ
UHVWLQJRQDVKLHOGRUQDPHQWHGZLWKDIDFLQJOLRQ
VKHDGWROHIWEHORZ
1LNH OLRQ
V KHDG WR OHIW WR WKH OHIW RI $WKHQD
V NQHH HOHSKDQW RQ 2:1
WKURQH PRQRJUDP RI ĬǼ +ROOVWHLQ S ILJ WKLV FRLQ 2I WKH
JUHDWHVW UDULW\ WKH VHFRQG NQRZQ H[DPSOH $ FRLQ RI WKH JUHDWHVW
KLVWRULFDOLQWHUHVW6RPHYHU\PLQRUPDUNVRQWKHUHYHUVHSHUKDSVDW
WKHWLPHRIPLQWLQJRWKHUZLVHYLUWXDOO\DVVWUXFN
([%DQN/HX$SULO
)RUWKHYHU\FRQYLQFLQJDWWULEXWLRQRIWKLVJROGVWDWHUDQGLWVDFFRPSDQ\LQJ
VLOYHUWHWUDGUDFKPVWR3WROHP\.HUDXQRVWKHDVVDVVLQRI6HOHXNRV,VHH:
+ROOVWHLQ0Q]HQGHV3WROHPDLRV.HUDXQRV615SSWKH
VHFRQGNQRZQH[DPSOHRIWKHVWDWHUDSSHDUHGLQWKHFROOHFWLRQRIWKHODWH/
$GDPV&1*0%6-XQH 7ULWRQ;,;-DQXDU\
.HUDXQRV ZDV WKH VRQ RI 3WROHP\ , E\ KLV ILUVW ZLIH (XU\GLNH D
GDXJKWHU RI $QWLSDWHU 3DVVHG RYHU IRU WKH VXFFHVVLRQ LQ IDYRU RI KLV
KDOIEURWKHU 3WROHP\ ,, VRQ RI 3WROHP\ , DQG KLV VHFRQG ZLIH %HUHQLNH
.HUDXQRVKDVWLO\IOHG(J\SWIRUWKHFRXUWRI/\VLPDFKRVKLVVLVWHU/\VDQGUD
ZDV WKH ZLIH RI $JDWKRNOHV WKH KHLU RI /\VLPDFKRV DQG KLV KDOIVLVWHU
$UVLQRH ZDV /\VLPDFKRV
SUHVHQW ZLIH $IWHU D YDULHW\ RI LQWULJXHV WKDW
UHVXOWHGLQKLVIOLJKWWR6HOHXNRVZKRPKHFRQYLQFHGWRDWWDFN/\VLPDFKRV
KH ZDV GHIHDWHG DQG NLOOHG E\ WKH 6HOHXNLG DUP\ DW WKH %DWWOH RI
&RUXSHGLRQ LQ KH WKHQ DVVDVVLQDWHG 6HOHXNRV DQG PDQDJHG WR EH
SURFODLPHGNLQJRI0DFHGRQ
,6/$1'62))7+5$&(
83

7KDVRV &LUFD %& 6WDWHU 6LOYHU PP J 1XGH
LWK\SKDOOLF DQG EHDUGHG VDW\U PRYLQJ ULJKW LQ WKH DUFKDLF
µUXQQLQJNQHHOLQJ¶SRVLWLRQKROGLQJDQ\PSKLQKLVDUPVZKRZHDUV
WKLQ UREHV DQG UDLVHV KHU ULJKW KDQG LQ SURWHVW 5HY 4XDGULSDUWLWH
LQFXVHVTXDUH$V\XW/H5LGHU7KDVLHQQHV61*&RSHQKDJHQ
:HOOFHQWHUHG QLFHO\ WRQHG DQG ZLWK D UHPDUNDEO\ GHWDLOHG
REYHUVH VWUXFN IURP IUHVK GLHV 0LQRU PDUNV DQG VFUDWFKHV
2:1 RWKHUZLVHDERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ 0Q]HQ 0HGDLOOHQ 86$
'HFHPEHU
7KH HQJUDYHU UHVSRQVLEOH IRU WKH REYHUVH RI WKLV FRLQ SURGXFHG D GLH WKDW
ZDV XQXVXDOO\ ILQHO\ GHWDLOHG WKH VDW\U
V EHDUG KDLU DQG IDFLDO H[SUHVVLRQ
DUHVKRZQZLWKH[FHSWLRQDOFDUHDVLVWKHQ\PSK
VKHDG7KLVSDLQVWDNLQJ
ZRUN ZDV WRR WLPHFRQVXPLQJ IRU WKH GLHV QHHGHG WR PDNH WKH HQRUPRXV
7KDVLDQ FRLQDJH GHVLJQHG DV D ZD\ RI DGGLQJ YDOXH WR WKH ,VODQG
V VLOYHU
H[SRUWVDQGDVFOHDUIURPWKHYDVWPDMRULW\RIVXUYLYLQJH[DPSOHVVLPSOHU
YHUVLRQVSUHYDLOHG
84
2:1

7KDVRV &LUFD %& 'UDFKP 6LOYHU PP J K
%HDUGHGKHDGRI'LRQ\VRVWROHIWZHDULQJLY\ZUHDWKZLWKEHUULHVDW
KLVIRUHKHDG5HYĬǹȈǿȅȃ+HUDNOHVZHDULQJOLRQ
VVNLQKHDGGUHVV
DQGVKRUWKXQWLQJFKLWRQNQHHOLQJULJKWVKRRWLQJKLVERZWRULJKW
XQGHU +HUDNOHV
ULJKW DUP FLFDGD WR ULJKW %0& /H 5LGHU
7KDVLHQQHV :HVW S 1LFHO\ WRQHG DQG ZLWK DSDUWLFXODUO\
ILQH KHDG RI 'LRQ\VRV 5HYHUVH YHU\ OLJKWO\ GRXEOHVWUXFN
RWKHUZLVHQHDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ 9LQFKRQ $SULO DQG
$XFWLRQHV6HSWHPEHU+HVV/HX0D\DQG
IURPWKHFROOHFWLRQRI*3KLOLSVHQ+LUVFK;;91RYHPEHU
2:1
85

7KDVRV&LUFD%&+HPLGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K<RXWKIXOPDOHKHDGDULYHUJRG"WROHIWZLWKORQJKDLUERXQG
E\ D WKLQ ZUHDWK RI ZDWHU UHHGV 5HY Ĭ$Ȉ,21 +HUDNOHV ZHDULQJ
OLRQ
V VNLQ NQHHOLQJ WR ULJKW GUDZLQJ ERZ WR ULJKW UDFH WRUFK DOO
ZLWKLQ OLQHDU VTXDUH /H 5LGHU 7KDVLHQQHV 5RELQVRQ YDU
V\PERO:HVWSĮWKLVFRLQ9HU\UDUH7RQHG*RRGYHU\
ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[0Q]HQXQG0HGDLOOHQ0D\
DQG 0Q]HQ XQG 0HGDLOOHQ )3/ -DQXDU\ DQG IURP WKH
FROOHFWLRQRI),PKRRI%OXPHU
86

7KDVRV QG FHQWXU\ %& %URQ]H PP J K +HDG RI
EHDUGHG +HUDNOHV WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ OLRQ
V VNLQ KHDGGUHVV 5HY
Ĭ$Ȉ,ȍ1ZLWKERZFRQWDLQLQJD7KDVLDQZLQHDPSKRUDDERYHDQG
EHORZ FOXE RYHU PRQRJUDP RI +3$.ȁ( /H 5LGHU 7KDVLHQQHV
YDU PRQRJUDP 61* &RSHQKDJHQ 9HU\ ZHOO VWUXFN
RI JRRG VW\OH DQG ZLWK D ILQH GDUN JUHHQ SDWLQD DQ XQXVXDOO\
DWWUDFWLYHSLHFH1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH 2:1
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQERXJKWSULYDWHO\ODWHLQ
7KUDFR0DFHGRQLDQ5HJLRQ
87

%HUJHSUHYLRXVO\LGHQWLILHGDVHLWKHU/HWHRU6LULV&LUFD
%& 6WDWHU 6LOYHU PP J SUREDEO\ PLQWHG F
6DW\UVWDQGLQJULJKWJUDVSLQJZLWKKLVULJKWKDQGWKHULJKWDUPRID
Q\PSK IOHHLQJ WR ULJKW WR OHIW DQG ULJKW DERYH DQG EHORZ EHWZHHQ
WKHPIRXUODUJHSHOOHWV5HY0LOOVDLOLQFXVHVTXDUH61*$16
6YRURQRV D SO 9,, WKLV FRLQ IURP WKH 0DWKH\ &ROOHFWLRQ
:HOO FHQWHUHG DQG FOHDU ZLWK D SOHDVLQJ ROG FDELQHW WRQLQJ *RRG
YHU\ILQH
0DUFK &ODVVLFDO 1XPLVPDWLF *URXS 0D\
6WHUQEHUJ;;,91RYHPEHU6WHUQEHUJ;,1RYHPEHU
DQG *OHQGLQLQJ &R 2FWREHU IURP WKH 0DWKH\
&ROOHFWLRQ)HXDUGHQW)UqUHV-XQHEXWXQLOOXVWUDWHG
2:1
0DFHGRQ
88

$NDQWKRV &LUFD %& 7HWUDGUDFKP 6LOYHU PP J
/LRQ WR ULJKW DWWDFNLQJ EXOO FROODSVLQJ WR OHIW ZLWK KHDG UDLVHG WR
ULJKW DERYH Ĭ WR WKH ULJKW RI WKH EXOO
V KRUQ EHORZ EXOO EDVH RI
SHOOHWVEHWZHHQSODLQOLQHVLQH[HUJXHIORUDORUQDPHQW5HY4XDGUL
SDUWLWH LQFXVH VTXDUH ZLWK JUDQXODWHG VXUIDFHV 'HVQHX[ VDPH
REYHUVHGLH7VHOHNDV3HULRG&&ODVV9,,*URXSEXWFI
6KDUSO\VWUXFNDQGLPSUHVVLYH([WUHPHO\ILQH 2:1
)URP WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI 'U + 0DDJ 3HXV 1RYHPEHU
¼
89

&KDONLGLDQ /HDJXH 2O\QWKRV &LUFD %& 7HWUDGUDFKP
6LOYHUPPJK/DXUHDWHKHDGRI$SROORWROHIW5HY
ȋǹȁ_Ȁǿǻ_Ǽȍȃ.LWKDUDZLWKVHYHQVWULQJVDOOZLWKLQYHU\VKDOORZ
LQFXVH VTXDUH %0)$ 5RELQVRQ &OHPHQW *URXS +
$3 %ULJKW LPSUHVVLYH DQG EROGO\ VWUXFN 9LUWXDOO\ DV
VWUXFN
2:1 )URP D (XURSHDQ FROOHFWLRQ H[ 1XPLVPDWLFD $UV &ODVVLFD 0D\

90

6LOYHUPPJK/DXUHDWHKHDGRI$SROORWRULJKW5HY
LQFXVH VTXDUH 5RELQVRQ &OHPHQW *URXS + $3 61*
$16 %ULJKW DQG PRVW DWWUDFWLYH ZLWK D KHDG RI $SROOR RI
2:1 SDUWLFXODUO\HQGHDULQJVW\OH9LUWXDOO\DVVWUXFN
)URPD6ZLVVFROOHFWLRQH[0DLVRQ3DORPER1RYHPEHUEXW
ZLWKFXULRXVUHIHUHQFHV
91

6LOYHUPPJK/DXUHDWHKHDGRI$SROORWRULJKW5HY
2:1 LQFXVH VTXDUH 5RELQVRQ &OHPHQW *URXS + EXW WKHVH GLHV
XQSXEOLVKHG &OHDU DWWUDFWLYH DQG QLFHO\ WRQHG *RRG H[WUHPHO\
ILQH
)URPD%ULWLVKFROOHFWLRQH[5RPD6HSWHPEHU
92

7HURQH &LUFD %& 6WDWHU 6LOYHU PP J
$PSKRUD ZLWK WKUHH JUDSH FOXVWHUV GUDSHG RYHU WKH VKRXOGHU 5HY
4XDGULSDUWLWH LQFXVH VTXDUH $V\XW WKLV FRLQ +DUGZLFN
*URXS,,6KDUSFOHDUO\VWUXFNDQGDWWUDFWLYH'HHSWHVWFXWDW
RQWKHREYHUVHRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQERXJKWSULYDWHO\IURP%DOGZLQ
VLQH[
&ODVVLFDO1XPLVPDWLF*URXS0D\DQGIURPWKH$V\XWILQG
RI
93

7HURQH&LUFD%&7HWURERO6LOYHUPPJ7(
2LQRFKRHWROHIW5HY4XDGULSDUWLWHLQFXVHVTXDUH+DUGZLFNJURXS,9
61* $16 &DUHIXOO\ FHQWHUHG DQG QLFHO\ WRQHG DQ 2:1
H[FHOOHQW H[DPSOH 6RPH XQFOHDQHG HDUWKHQ GHSRVLWV RWKHUZLVH
QHDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[6XSHULRU'HFHPEHU
.LQJVRI0DFHGRQ
94

$OH[DQGHU,,,
WKH*UHDW
%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPP
JK0HPSKLVF+HDGRI\RXWKIXO+HUDNOHVWR
ULJKW ZHDULQJ OLRQ
V VNLQ KHDGGUHVV 5HY ǹȁǼȄǹȃǻȇȅȊ =HXV
VHDWHGOHIWRQORZWKURQHKROGLQJORQJVFHSWHULQKLVOHIWKDQGDQG
LQ KLV ULJKW HDJOH VWDQGLQJ ULJKW ZLWK FORVHG ZLQJV WR OHIW URVH
EHORZ WKURQH DQG WR ULJKW ǻǿ ȅ 3ULFH $ UHPDUNDEO\ ILQH
H[DPSOH RI WKLV GHVLUDEOH W\SH 7RQHG DQG RI WKH ILQHVW VW\OH
([WUHPHO\ILQH
([*RUQ\ 0RVFK2FWREHUDQG7UDGDUW-XO\
95

$OH[DQGHU,,,µWKH*UHDW¶%&'UDFKP6LOYHUPP
JK6DUGHVFLUFD+HDGRI\RXWKIXO+HUDNOHV
WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ OLRQ
VHDWHGOHIWRQDEDFNOHVVWKURQHKROGLQJHDJOHLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQG
2:1 ORQJVFHSWHULQKLVOHIWEHORZHDJOHNDQWKDURV3ULFH/LJKWO\
WRQHGVKDUSDQGRIILQHVW\OH([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[%HUN%%6-DQXDU\
96

$OH[DQGHU,,,µWKH*UHDW¶%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPP
JK7DUVRVF+HDGRI\RXWKIXO+HUDNOHVWRULJKW
ZHDULQJOLRQ
VVNLQKHDGGUHVV5HYǹȁǼȄǹȃǻȇȅȊ=HXVVHDWHGOHIW
RQEDFNOHVVWKURQHKROGLQJHDJOHLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGORWRVWLSSHG
VFHSWHU LQ KLV OHIW WR OHIW SORZ EHORZ WKURQH EXQFK RI JUDSHV
DERYHVWUXWSHOOHW3ULFH$EULJKWVKDUSSLHFHVWUXFNLQKLJK
UHOLHI*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
0DUFK
2:1
97

$OH[DQGHU,,,µWKH*UHDW¶%&'UDFKP6LOYHUPP
JK$E\GRV+HDGRI\RXWKIXO+HUDNOHVWRULJKW
ZHDULQJOLRQ
RQDEDFNOHVVWKURQHKROGLQJHDJOHLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGORQJVFHSWHU
LQKLVOHIWEHORZHDJOHKHDGRI$PPRQWRULJKWEHORZWKURQHLY\
OHDI3ULFH&OHDUDQGVWUXFNRQDEURDGIODQ1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\
ILQH
2:1 )URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[0Q]=HQWUXP5KHLQODQG-DQXDU\

98

JKVWUXFNXQGHU3KLOLS,,,$UUKLGDLRV7DUVRVF
+HDG RI \RXWKIXO +HUDNOHV WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ OLRQ
ǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈǹȁǼȄǹȃǻȇȅȊ=HXVVHDWHGOHIWRQORZWKURQHKROGLQJORQJ
VFHSWHULQKLVOHIWKDQGDQGLQKLVULJKWHDJOHVWDQGLQJWRULJKWZLWKFORVHG
ZLQJVWROHIWEHIRUH=HXV
VNQHHV1LNHIO\LQJXSZDUGVWRULJKWEHDULQJD
ZUHDWKEHORZWKURQHPRQRJUDPRI$17,DERYHĬ3ULFH$ORYHO\
WRQHGFRLQVWUXFNLQKLJKUHOLHIZLWKERWKDVSOHQGLGKHDGRIWKH\RXWKIXO
+HUDNOHV DV ZHOO DV D ILQHO\ GHWDLOHG KHDG RI =HXV RI JHPOLNH TXDOLW\
([WUHPHO\ILQH 2:1
)URPD*HUPDQFROOHFWLRQH[*RUQ\ 0RVFK0DUFK
99

J K VWUXFN XQGHU 3KLOLS ,,, $UUKLGDLRV 0\ULDQGRV F
V VNLQ
KHDGGUHVV 5HY ǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈ ǹȁǼȄǹȃǻȇȅȊ =HXV VHDWHG OHIW RQ
KLJKEDFNHGWKURQHKROGLQJHDJOHLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGVFHSWHULQKLV
OHIWLQILHOGWROHIWPRQRJUDPRIȂǹEHORZWKURQHPRQRJUDPRI
Ȃǿ 3ULFH %HDXWLIXOO\ WRQHG YHU\ ZHOOFHQWHUHG DQG ZLWK DQ
REYHUVH VWUXFN LQ YHU\ KLJK UHOLHI 6RPH PLQRU VFUDWFKHV DQG D
VFUDSHRQWKHKHDGRI=HXVRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
([+LUVFK6HSWHPEHU
100

$OH[DQGHU ,,, µWKH *UHDW¶ %& 'UDFKP 6LOYHU PP
J K 0DJQHVLD +HDG RI \RXWKIXO +HUDNOHV WR
ULJKW ZHDULQJ OLRQ
VHDWHGOHIWRQDEDFNOHVVWKURQHKROGLQJHDJOHLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQG 2:1
ORQJ VFHSWHU LQ KLV OHIW EHORZ HDJOH GROSKLQ VZLPPLQJ XSZDUGV
EHORZWKURQHPRQRJUDPRI$7WRRXWHUULJKWILOOHWHGWK\UVRV3ULFH
5DUH%ULJKWDQGDWWUDFWLYH9LUWXDOO\DVVWUXFN
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[7ULWRQ9,-DQXDU\
101

J K XQFHUWDLQ *UHHN RU 0DFHGRQLDQ PLQW F
V VNLQ KHDGGUHVV
5HY ǹȁǼȄǹȃǻȇȅȊ =HXV VHDWHG OHIW RQ EDFNOHVV WKURQH KROGLQJ
HDJOH LQ KLV ULJKW KDQG DQG VFHSWHU LQ KLV OHIW LQ ILHOG WR OHIW
DPSKRUD 3ULFH &OHDU ZHOOVWUXFN DQG RI ORYHO\ VW\OH $ERXW
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ *RUQ\ 0RVFK2FWREHU
2:1 DQG*RUQ\ 0RVFK0DUFK
102

J K XQFHUWDLQ PLQW LQ ZHVWHUQ $VLD 0LQRU F
+HDG RI \RXWKIXO +HUDNOHV LQ OLRQ
V VNLQ KHDGGUHVV WR ULJKW 5HY
ǹȁǼȄǹȃǻȇȅȊ =HXV VHDWHG WR OHIW RQ WKURQH KROGLQJ HDJOH ZLWK
FORVHG ZLQJV RQ KLV RXWVWUHWFKHG ULJKW KDQG DQG ORQJVFHSWHULQKLV
OHIWWROHIWILOOHWHGSDOPEUDQFK3ULFH61*7ELQJHQ
5DUH :LWK D UHYHUVH RI SDUWLFXODUO\ HOHJDQW VW\OH VWUXFN LQ KLJK
UHOLHI([WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1
103

J K XQFHUWDLQ PLQW LQ ZHVWHUQ $VLD 0LQRU F
V VNLQ KHDGGUHVV
5HYǹȁǼȄǹȃǻȇȅȊ=HXVVHDWHGWROHIWRQEDFNOHVVWKURQHKROGLQJ
HDJOH ZLWK FORVHG ZLQJV RQ KLV RXWVWUHWFKHG ULJKW KDQG DQG ORQJ
VFHSWHU LQ KLV OHIW LQ ILHOG WR OHIW NDQWKDURV 0H\GDQFLNNDOH
3ULFHEWKHVHGLHV9HU\UDUHQLFHO\WRQHGDQGRISDUWLFXODUO\
EROG VW\OH 5HYHUVH VWUXFN VOLJKWO\ RII FHQWUH RWKHUZLVH JRRG
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1 7KH+HUDNOHVKHDGRQWKLVFRLQKDVDQDOPRVWGHPRQLFLQWHQVLW\DERXWLW±
KHDOPRVWORRNVOLNHVRPHUHQDLVVDQFHEUDYRVSRLOLQJIRUDILJKWZLWKDULYDO
104

JK.\]LNRVF+HDGRI\RXWKIXO+HUDNOHVWRULJKW
ZHDULQJ OLRQ
V VNLQ KHDGGUHVV 5HY ǹȁǼȄǹȃǻȇȅȊ=HXVVHDWHGWR
OHIW RQ WKURQH ZLWK HODERUDWH OHJV KROGLQJ HDJOH ZLWK FORVHG ZLQJV
RQKLVRXWVWUHWFKHGULJKWKDQGDQGORQJVFHSWHULQKLVOHIWLQILHOGWR
OHIW ORQJ WRUFK DQG PRQRJUDP EHORZ WKURQH PRQRJUDP RI ȁȊ
ZLWKLQFLUFOH0OOHU3ULFH:HOOVWUXFNDQGLQKLJKUHOLHI
6RPHGHSRVLWVDVIRXQGRWKHUZLVHDERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1
105

J K $OH[DQGUHLD 7URDV F +HDG RI \RXWKIXO
+HUDNOHV WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ OLRQ
ǹȁǼȄǹȃǻȇȅȊ =HXV VHDWHG WR OHIW RQ EDFNOHVV WKURQH KROGLQJ
HDJOH ZLWK FORVHG ZLQJV RQ KLV RXWVWUHWFKHG ULJKW KDQG DQG ORQJ
VFHSWHU LQ KLV OHIW LQ ILHOG WR OHIW KRUVH JUD]LQJ WR OHIW RYHU
WKXQGHUEROW EHORZ WKURQH PRQRJUDP $Q XQSXEOLVKHG YDULDQW VHH
3ULFH YDU FI &1* H VDPH GLHV" ([WUHPHO\ UDUH
/LJKWO\WRQHG0LQRUPDUNVRWKHUZLVHJRRGYHU\ILQH
2:1
106

JKVWUXFNXQGHU$QWLJRQRV,,*RQDWDV$PSKLSROLVFLUFD
%& +HDG RI \RXWKIXO +HUDNOHV WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ OLRQ
V
VNLQ KHDGGUHVV 5HY ǹȁǼȄǹȃǻȇȅȊ =HXV VHDWHG OHIW RQ
KLJKEDFNHGWKURQHKROGLQJORQJVFHSWHULQKLVOHIWKDQGDQGLQKLV
ULJKWHDJOHVWDQGLQJULJKWZLWKFORVHGZLQJVLQILHOGWROHIWFUHVFHQW
DQGPRQRJUDPDERYHDVHFRQGPRQRJUDPXQGHUWKURQHPRQRJUDP
&1* 0%6 VDPH GLHV 0DWKLVHQ $GPLQLVWUDWLYH
*URXS ,,, $3 3ULFH $ UDUH YDULHW\ ZLWK D VXSHUE
KHDGRI+HUDNOHVVKRZQLQDSRZHUIXOO\HPRWLRQDO+HOOHQLVWLFVW\OH 2:1
([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPD(XURSHDQFROOHFWLRQDFTXLUHGLQ
107

J K .DXQRV F +HDG RI \RXWKIXO +HUDNOHV WR ULJKW
ZHDULQJOLRQ
RQ KLJKEDFN WKURQH KROGLQJ HDJOH LQ KLV ULJKW KDQG DQG VFHSWHULQ
KLV OHIW WR OHIW GRXEOH D[ RU ODEU\V 3ULFH 1LFHO\ WRQHG DQG
VWUXFNRQDEURDGIODQ([WUHPHO\ILQH
([5RPD0DUFK
:KLOHWKHHQJUDYHUUHVSRQVLEOHIRUWKHREYHUVHRIWKLVFRLQZDVYHU\VNLOOIXO
DQGVWUDLJKWIRUZDUGWKHKHDGRI+HUDNOHVLVPRVWLPSUHVVLYHDQGSRZHUIXO
WKH HQJUDYHU RI WKH UHYHUVH GLH VHHPV WR KDYH EHHQ SOD\LQJ ZLWK KLV
WHFKQLTXH 1RWLFH KRZ =HXV
V OHJVDSSHDUWREHRXWRISURSRUWLRQZLWKKLV
2:1 WRUVR ± DV LI WKH HQJUDYHU ZDV WU\LQJ WR VKRZ GHSWK RI ILHOG ,Q DGGLWLRQ
ZKLOHWKHELUG=HXVKROGVVKRXOGEHDQHDJOHWKHORQJQHFNPDNHVLWORRN
OLNHDFURVVEHWZHHQDQHDJOHDQGDJRRVH
108

JK0HVHPEULDF+HDGRI\RXWKIXO+HUDNOHVWR
ULJKW ZHDULQJ OLRQ
VHDWHGWROHIWRQWKURQHZLWKHODERUDWHOHJVKROGLQJHDJOHZLWKFORVHG
ZLQJVRQKLVRXWVWUHWFKHGULJKWKDQGDQGORQJVFHSWHULQKLVOHIWLQ
ILHOG WR OHIW FORVH WR =HXV
V ULJKW OHJ WK\UVRV EHORZ WKURQH
&RULQWKLDQKHOPHWWROHIW3ULFHWK\UVRVXQQRWHGEXWDSSDUHQWO\
YLVLEOH RQ SO [OLLL %ROGO\ VWUXFN DQG ZLWK D SRZHUIXO KHDG RI
+HUDNOHV 6WUXFN RQ D VOLJKWO\ WLJKW IODQ DQG ZLWK PLQRU PDUNV
RWKHUZLVHDERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
109

JKXQFHUWDLQPLQWLQZHVWHUQ$VLD0LQRUF+HDG
RI \RXWKIXO +HUDNOHV WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ OLRQ
ǹȁǼȄǹȃǻȇȅȊ =HXV VHDWHG WR OHIW RQ WKURQH KLV IHHW RQ D
2:1 IRRWVWRROKROGLQJHDJOHZLWKFORVHGZLQJVRQKLVRXWVWUHWFKHGULJKW
KDQGDQGORQJVFHSWHULQKLVOHIWLQILHOGWROHIWFRLOHGVHUSHQWZLWKLQ
ZUHDWK 3ULFH $ $ YHU\ UDUH YDULHW\ RI H[FHOOHQW VW\OH 1HDUO\
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
110

JK7HPQRVFLUFD+HDGRI\RXWKIXO+HUDNOHVWRULJKW
ZHDULQJ OLRQ
V VNLQ KHDGGUHVV 5HY ǹȁǼȄǹȃǻȇȅȊ =HXV VHDWHG OHIW
RQ D WKURQH ZLWK D EDFN KROGLQJ HDJOH LQ KLV ULJKW KDQG DQG ORQJ
VFHSWHU LQ KLV OHIW LQ ILHOG WR OHIW RHQRFKRH 0HNWLSLQL VDPH
REYHUVH GLH 3ULFH $ YHU\ UDUH YDULHW\ ZLWK DQ DWWUDFWLYH ROG
FDELQHWSDWLQD/LJKWO\VWUXFNRWKHUZLVHQHDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
1,5:1
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ $QWLRFK $VVRFLDWHV)3/E'HFHPEHU

111

J K 0\ULQD FD +HDG RI \RXWKIXO +HUDNOHV WR
ULJKW ZHDULQJ OLRQ
VHDWHG OHIW RQ EDFNOHVV WKURQH KROGLQJ HDJOH LQ KLV ULJKW KDQG DQG
VFHSWHULQKLVOHIWWROHIWEHORZHDJOH0<3,DERYHDPSKRUD3ULFH
$YHU\DWWUDFWLYHOLJKWO\WRQHGFRLQZHOOFHQWHUHGRQDEURDG
IODQ1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1
112

3KLOLS,,,$UUKLGDLRV%&'UDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K0DJQHVLDFLUFD+HDGRI\RXWKIXO+HUDNOHVWRULJKW
ZHDULQJOLRQ
VVNLQKHDGGUHVV5HYĭǿȁǿȆȆȅȊ=HXVVHDWHGOHIWRQD
EDFNOHVVWKURQHKROGLQJHDJOHLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGORQJVFHSWHULQ
KLVOHIWEHORZHDJOHWK\UVRV3ULFH3%ULJKWDQGFOHDU([WUHPHO\
ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[1&LUF&9,QR0D\
113

7LPHRI3KLOLS9DQG3HUVHXV%&7HWURERO6LOYHUPP
J3HOODRU$PSKLSROLV0DFHGRQLDQVKLHOGRUQDPHQWHGZLWKVL[
2:1 OLQHDU FUHVFHQWV DURXQG WKH HGJH DQG D WHWUDVNHOHV RI FUHVFHQWV DW WKH
FHQWHU5HYȂǹȀǼǻȅȃȍȃ*DOOH\VWHUQDERYHVWDURIHLJKWUD\V
61*$VKPROHDQ61*&RSHQKDJHQ&OHDUDWWUDFWLYHDQG
OLJKWO\WRQHG([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPD*HUPDQFROOHFWLRQDFTXLUHGSULRUWR
114
2:1

7LPHRI3KLOLS9DQG3HUVHXV%&7ULRERO6LOYHUPP
J 3HOOD LQ WKH GLVWULFW RI %RWWLDLD 0DFHGRQLDQ VKLHOG
RUQDPHQWHG ZLWK VHYHQ OLQHDU FUHVFHQWV DURXQG WKH HGJH DQG D
WHWUDVNHOHV RI FUHVFHQWV DW WKH FHQWHU 5HY Ǻȅ@ȉȉǼǹȉȍȃ 6WHUQ RI
JDOOH\DERYHWULSRG%0&&OHDUDQGZHOOFHQWHUHGOLJKWO\WRQHG
([WUHPHO\ILQH
115
2:1
7LPHRI3KLOLS9DQG3HUVHXV%&3VHXGR5KRGLDQ'UDFKP
6LOYHUPPJKVWUXFNGXULQJWKH7KLUG0DFHGRQLDQ:DU
XQFHUWDLQPLQWLQ7KHVVDO\6WUDWRQ+HDGRI+HOLRVIDFLQJWXUQHGYHU\
VOLJKWO\WRULJKW5HYȈȉȇǹȉȍȃ5RVHZLWKEXGWRULJKWWROHIWEXQFKRI
JUDSHV$VKWRQ1&YDU%0&1LFHO\WRQHGZHOOFHQWHUHG
DQGZLWKD
GUDPDWLF
KHDGRI+HOLRV([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[+-%HUN%%60DUFK
(OLPLRWLV
116

$LDQL'HUGDV,,FLUFD%&&KDONRXV%URQ]HPPJ
K/DXUHDWHKHDGRI$SROORWRULJKW5HYǻǼȇǻǹ+RUVHPDQRQ
JDOORSLQJKRUVHWRULJKWZHDULQJSHWDVRVFKODP\VDQGFURZQLQJKLV
KRUVHZLWKDZUHDWKKHOGLQKLVRXWVWUHWFKHGULJKWKDQG%&',,
/LDPSL 'HUGDV 25 9HU\ UDUH XQXVXDOO\ ZHOOSUHVHUYHG
DQGZLWKDGDUNJUHHQSDWLQD*RRGYHU\ILQH
2:1 )URPD*HUPDQFROOHFWLRQDFTXLUHGSULRUWR
7KHVVDO\
117

3KHUDL$OH[DQGHUW\UDQW%&2ERO6LOYHUPPJ
:KHHORIIRXUVSRNHV5HYǹȁǼ'RXEOHD[61*&RSHQKDJHQ
7UDLWp,9SO&&;&,95DUH0LQRUVFUDWFKRQWKHREYHUVH
RWKHUZLVHJRRGYHU\ILQH
)URPDQ$PHULFDQFROOHFWLRQH[2ERORV-XQH
,OO\ULD
2:1
118

'\UUKDFKLRQ&LUFD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJK
&RZ VWDQGLQJ WR ULJKW WXUQLQJ KHU KHDG EDFN WR OHIW WR OLFN FDOI
VXFNOLQJ WR OHIW DERYH ZDVS IO\LQJ WR ULJKW 5HY ǻ Ȋ ȇ 'RXEOH
VWHOODWH SDWWHUQ ZLWKLQ GRXEOH OLQHDU VTXDUH ERUGHU EHORZ FOXE WR
ULJKWDOOZLWKLQOLQHDUFLUFOH&1*VDPHGLHV+*&
0DLHU YDU EXW DOVR ZLWK D OL]DUG RQ WKH UHYHUVH 5DUH
ZLWKWKLVV\PERO$WWUDFWLYHO\WRQHG1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
5HSUHVHQWDWLRQV RI ZDVSV ZKHWKHU DV W\SHV RU V\PEROV RQO\ EHFDPH
FRPPRQRQFRLQVDQGPHGDOVSULPDULO\(QJOLVKIROORZLQJWKH5HIRUPDWLRQ
XQGHU+HQU\9,,,7KHRQHKHUHıĳKȟLQ*UHHNRUWKH/DWLQYHVSDLVDYHU\
UDUH H[DPSOH RI D ZDVS EHLQJ XVHG DV D V\PERO RQ D *UHHN FRLQ $QFLHQW
DXWKRUV SRLQWHG RXW KRZ DJJUHVVLYH DQG XQSOHDVDQW ZDVSV FRXOG EH WKLV
PHDQWWKDWWKH\FRXOGDOVREHDV\PEROIRUDEHOOLJHUHQWVROGLHUWKXVWKHXVH
RIDZDVSDVDVKLHOGGHYLFHRQDOHN\WKRVE\WKH5RXQGDERXW3DLQWHU$59ð
$JRUD 3 ,WV DSSHDUDQFH KHUH DV D PRQH\HU
V EDGJH SUREDEO\
JLYHVXVDQLQVLJKWLQWRWKDWPDJLVWUDWH
VFKDUDFWHU
2:1
.RUN\UD
119

.RUN\UD8QGHU5RPDQUXOHFLUFD%&'LGUDFKP6LOYHU
PPJK+HDGRI\RXWKIXO'LRQ\VXVWRULJKWZHDULQJLY\
ZUHDWK 5HY 3HJDVXV IO\LQJ WR ULJKW EHORZ PRQRJUDPV RIWKHFLW\
QDPH .23 DQG RI D PDJLVWUDWH Ȇ<3Ĭ %0& 61*
&RSHQKDJHQ WKLV REYHUVH GLH 61* 'HOHSLHUUH :HOO
VWUXFNQLFHO\WRQHGDQGRIUHPDUNDEO\JRRGVW\OHIRUWKHLVVXHUDUH
WKXV*RRGYHU\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQIURPWKHFROOHFWLRQRID*HUPDQDFDGHPLF
/HX 2FWREHU DQG IURP WKDW RI WKH +HUPLWDJH
6FKOHVVLQJHU)HEUXDU\
(SHLURV
120

$PEUDNLD&LUFD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJK
3HJDVRV IO\LQJ WR ULJKW EHORZ $ 5HY +HDG RI $WKHQD WR OHIW
ZHDULQJ &RULQWKLDQ KHOPHW EHKLQG QHFN RLQRFKRH WR OHIW &DOFLDWL
([WUHPHO\UDUHDSSDUHQWO\WKHWKLUGNQRZQH[DPSOHZLWKWKLV
UHYHUVH V\PERO 7RQHG DQG ZLWK D YHU\ ZHOOFHQWHUHG UHYHUVH
2:1 2EYHUVH VWUXFN VOLJKWO\ RII FHQWHU IURP D VOLJKWO\ ZRUQ GLH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[0Q]HQXQG0HGDLOOHQ'($SULO
DQG6.$0RQHWDULXP)3/DXWXPQ
121

$PEUDNLD &LUFD %& 'UDFKP RI UHGXFHG ZHLJKW 6LOYHU
PP J K 3HJDVRV IO\LQJ ULJKW EHORZ ǹ 5HY +HDG RI
\RXWKIXO'LRQ\VRVWROHIWZHDULQJLY\ZUHDWKEHKLQGQHFNWRULJKW
NDQWKDURV %0& VDPH GLHV +*& VDPH GLHV 61*
&RSHQKDJHQVDPHGLHV1LFHO\WRQHGDQGZHOOVWUXFNH[WUHPHO\
UDUH([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ * +LUVFK 1DFKI 1RYHPEHU
2:1
$NDUQDQLD
122

/HXNDV&LUFD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJKȁ
3HJDVRVIO\LQJOHIWEHORZ5HY+HDGRI$WKHQDWRULJKWEHKLQGKHU
QHFNǹEHKLQGYLQHZLWKJUDSHFOXVWHURYHUDYROXWHNUDWHUSODFHG
RQ D VWDQG D K\SRVWDWRQ &DOFLDWL YDU VDPH UHYHUVH GLH EXW
3HJDVRV IO\LQJ ULJKW :LWK WKLV V\PERO H[WUHPHO\ UDUH DQG PRVW
LQWHUHVWLQJ([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[7ULWRQ,'HFHPEHU
2:1 7KLV FRLQ PDNHV LW FOHDU WKDW ZH DQG VR PDQ\ RWKHUV KDYH LQFRUUHFWO\
LGHQWLILHG WKH YHVVHO WKDW DSSHDUV RQ WKH UHYHUVHVRI7KHEDQVWDWHUVDQGLQ
PDQ\RWKHUSODFHVWKLVPLVLGHQWLILFDWLRQGRHVQRWVROHO\FRPHIURPWKHFRLQ
WUDGH LW LVHYHU\ZKHUH)RUH[DPSOHLQ%0&%RHRWLDSXEOLVKHGLQ
DQGDPRQJRWKHUSODFHVLQ+HDG
V+LVWRULD1XPRUXPDQGLQWKHFDWDORJXHV
RI WKH GH +LUVFK GH /X\QHV DQG GX &KDVWHO &ROOHFWLRQV :KHQ WKLV FRLQ
DSSHDUHG LQ 7ULWRQ , LQ WKH V\PERO ZDV GHVFULEHG DV EHLQJ DQ
DPSKRUDWKHVWDQGZDVQRWQRWLFHGWKHVDPHYHVVHORQD%RHRWLDQVWDWHU
WKLV WLPH EXW GHVFULEHG DV KDYLQJ DQ HORQJDWHG IRRW ZKDWHYHU WKDW PLJKW
EH DSSHDUHG DV %&' %RLRWLD 7ULWRQ ,; 7KH SUREOHP LV WKDW
12 WDOOKDQGOHG ZLGHPRXWKHG DPSKRUD DFWXDOO\ H[LVWV WKHUH LV WKH
VRPHZKDWVLPLODU6,WDOLDQYHVVHOWKHQHVWRULVEXWWKHKDQGOHVGLIIHUZKDW
WKLVDFWXDOO\LVLVDYROXWHNUDWHU<HWPDQ\VFKRODUVKDYHORQJNQRZQWKLV
7KH ODWH &ROLQ .UDD\ LQ .UDD\ +LUPHU LGHQWLILHG WKH YHVVHO DV D NUDWHU
7KDVRV 7KHEHV DQG /DPLD DQG-HQNLQVLQ*XOEHQNLDQ,,
WHUPHGLWDYROXWHNUDWHU7KHEHVDQG0HORV%UHWWDOVRWHUPHGLWD
YROXWHNUDWHULQWKH%RVWRQFDWDORJXHKRZHYHUE\.UDD\WHUPHGLWDQ
DPSKRUD DJDLQ LQ $&*& :K\ WKLV KDV QRW EHHQ FDUULHG RYHU LQWR DOO
QXPLVPDWLF OLWHUDWXUH LV EH\RQG PH ,Q DQ\ FDVH WKLV LV FHUWDLQO\ ZKDW ZH
KDYHKHUH$QGNUDWHUVDUHGLIIHUHQWIURPDPSKRUDHQRWHWKHDPSKRUDHRQ
WKH HDUO\ REROV IURP /RNURL 2SXQWLL RU WKRVH IURP 7HURQH*XOEHQNLDQ,,
.UDD\DQGLQWKLVFDWDORJXHWKH7HURQHDERYHORWRUWKH
ZRQGHUIXO VWDWHU IURP DQ XQFHUWDLQ QRUWKHUQ *UHHN PLQW WKDW VKRZV WZR
Q\PSKVFDUU\LQJDQDPSKRUD.UDD\1RWHWKHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKLV
YHVVHODQGWKDWRQWKHIROORZLQJORW
2:1
123

/HXNDV &LUFD %& 6WDWHU 6LOYHU PP J K
ȁǼȊ 3HJDVRV IO\LQJ ULJKW 5HY +HOPHWHG KHDG RI $WKHQD WR ULJKW
EHKLQGQHFNǹEHKLQGKHDGJUDSHYLQHZLWKEXQFKRIJUDSHVRYHU
WKH PRXWK RI D WDOO DPSKRUD RQ D VWDQG %&' YDU %0&
&DOFLDWLYDU&1*H6DOHVDPHGLHV7RQHGDQG
ZHOOFHQWHUHG 6RPH PLQRU PDUNV RWKHUZLVH YHU\ ILQHDERXW
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQDFTXLUHGSULYDWHO\LQ
2:1
%RHRWLD
124

7KHEHV &LUFD %& 6WDWHU 6LOYHU PP J
%RHRWLDQ VKLHOG DW WKH FHQWHU FRXQWHUPDUN RI D SHOOHW ZLWKLQ D
FLUFXODU LQGHQW 5HYĬǼ7KHLQIDQW+HUDNOHVVHDWHGIDFLQJQXGH
DQGZLWKKLVKHDGWXUQHGWRULJKWVWUDQJOLQJWZRVHUSHQWVLQILHOGWR
OHIWERZLQILHOGWRULJKWFOXE%&'%RLRWLD*XOEHQNLDQ
DQG 61* &RSHQKDJHQ DOO VWUXFN IURP WKH VDPH UHYHUVH GLH
5DUH:HOOVWUXFNFOHDUDQGOLJKWO\WRQHG2QHRIWKHILQHVWH[DPSOHV
RIWKLVW\SHNQRZQ1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPDQ(QJOLVKFROOHFWLRQIRUPHGLQWKHVH[*+LUVFK1DFKI
6HSWHPEHU
(XERLD
125

(XERLDQ/HDJXH&LUFD%&'UDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K (UHWULD +HDG RI WKH Q\PSK (XERHD WR OHIW KHU KDLU UROOHG
2:1 ZHDULQJDWULSOHSHQGDQWHDUULQJ5HY(<3URWRPHRIDFRZWRULJKW
KHDG IDFLQJ DQG GUDSHG ZLWK D ILOOHW WR ULJKW EXQFK RI JUDSHV
:DOODFH GLHV ;;;9, WKLV FRLQ %HDXWLIXOO\ WRQHG D
UHPDUNDEO\ ORYHO\ FRLQ RI ILQH VW\OH SHUIHFWO\ FHQWHUHG DQG
ZHOOVWUXFNIURPQHZGLHV([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[/HX0D\DQG3HXV
$SULO DQG IURP WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI WKH 5HYHUHQG ( 5RJHUV
5DWWR-XQH
$WWLFD
126

$WKHQV &LUFD %& 2ERO 6LOYHU PP J IURP
WKH :DSSHQPQ]HQ 6HULHV F 2LO DPSKRUD 5HY ,UUHJXODU
LQFXVHVTXDUH%0&&HRV6HOWPDQSDQGSO,97UDLWp
, SO;;;,,,9HU\UDUH7RQHGDQGEROGO\VWUXFNLQKLJK
UHOLHI:LWKVRPHZKDWFU\VWDOL]HGVXUIDFHVDVXVXDORWKHUZLVHJRRG
3:1 YHU\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[/HX0D\
127

$WKHQV&LUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJK
+HDGRI$WKHQDWRULJKWZHDULQJFUHVWHG$WWLFKHOPHWDGRUQHGZLWK
WKUHH ROLYH OHDYHV DQG SDOPHWWH URXQG HDUULQJ DQG SHDUO QHFNODFH
5HYǹĬǼ2ZOVWDQGLQJULJKWZLWKKHDGIDFLQJWROHIWFUHVFHQWDQG
ROLYHVSULJDOOZLWKLQLQFXVHVTXDUH6WDUU*URXS96YRURQRVFISO
II$ZRQGHUIXOIUHVKH[DPSOHYHU\ZHOOFHQWHUHGZLWKPXFK
2:1 RULJLQDO OXVWHU DQG ZLWK D ZRQGHUIXO RZO 2EYHUVH VWUXFN IURP D
VOLJKWO\ZRUQGLHRWKHUZLVHYLUWXDOO\DVVWUXFN
128

$WKHQV&LUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
KVWUXFNHDUO\LQWKHV+HDGRI$WKHQDWRULJKWZHDULQJFUHVWHG
$WWLF KHOPHW DGRUQHG ZLWK WKUHH ROLYH OHDYHV DQG SDOPHWWH URXQG
HDUULQJ DQG SHDUO QHFNODFH 5HY ǹĬǼ 2ZO VWDQGLQJ ULJKW KHDG
IDFLQJ EHKLQG ROLYH VSUD\ DQG FUHVFHQW PRRQ DOO ZLWKLQ LQFXVH
VTXDUH 6YRURQRV SO $ FOHDU DQG PRVW DWWUDFWLYH H[DPSOH
2:1
ZLWK DQ RZO ZLWK D VODQWHG KHDG YHU\ VLPLODU WR WKRVH RI WKH 6WDUU
SHULRG9LUWXDOO\DVVWUXFN
129

RZO ZLWK D KRUL]RQWDOO\ SODFHG KHDG WKH VW\OH RI WKH PDLQ
PDVV
LVVXHV F V +HDG RI $WKHQD WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ FUHVWHG $WWLF
KHOPHWDGRUQHGZLWKWKUHHROLYHOHDYHVDQGSDOPHWWHURXQGHDUULQJDQG
SHDUO QHFNODFH 5HY ǹĬǼ 2ZO VWDQGLQJ ULJKW KHDG IDFLQJ EHKLQG
2:1
ROLYHVSUD\DQGFUHVFHQWPRRQDOOZLWKLQLQFXVHVTXDUH6YRURQRVSO
$Q DWWUDFWLYH DQG XQXVXDOO\ ZHOOFHQWHUHG H[DPSOH ZLWK WKH
IXOOFUHVWRI$WKHQD
VKHOPHW9LUWXDOO\DVVWUXFN
130

$WKHQV&LUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K V +HDG RI $WKHQD WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ FUHVWHG $WWLF KHOPHW
DGRUQHG ZLWK WKUHH ROLYH OHDYHV DQG SDOPHWWH URXQG HDUULQJ DQG
SHDUO QHFNODFH 5HY ǹĬǼ 2ZO VWDQGLQJ ULJKW KHDG IDFLQJ EHKLQG
ROLYHVSUD\DQGFUHVFHQWPRRQDOOZLWKLQLQFXVHVTXDUH6YRURQRVSO 2:1
II %ULJKW ZHOOVWUXFN FOHDU OXVWURXV DQG SDUWLFXODUO\ QLFH
*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
131

ZLWK DQ RZO ZLWK D KRUL]RQWDOO\ SODFHG KHDG WKH VW\OH RI WKH PDLQ

PDVV
LVVXHV V +HDG RI $WKHQD WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ FUHVWHG $WWLF
KHOPHW DGRUQHG ZLWK WKUHH ROLYH OHDYHV DQG SDOPHWWHURXQGHDUULQJ
DQG SHDUO QHFNODFH 5HY ǹĬǼ 2ZO VWDQGLQJ ULJKW KHDG IDFLQJ
EHKLQG ROLYH VSUD\ DQG FUHVFHQW PRRQ DOO ZLWKLQ LQFXVH VTXDUH
2:1
6YRURQRV SO $ EULJKW SHUIHFWO\ VWUXFN DQG ZHOOFHQWHUHG
SLHFHRIH[FHSWLRQDOTXDOLW\9LUWXDOO\DVVWUXFN
132

V+HDGRI$WKHQDWRULJKWZHDULQJFUHVWHG$WWLFKHOPHWDGRUQHG
ZLWK WKUHH ROLYH OHDYHV DQG SDOPHWWH URXQG HDUULQJ DQG SHDUO
QHFNODFH 5HY ǹĬǼ 2ZO VWDQGLQJ ULJKW KHDG IDFLQJ EHKLQG ROLYH
VSUD\DQGFUHVFHQWPRRQDOOZLWKLQLQFXVHVTXDUH6YRURQRVSO
2:1
$ EULJKW OXVWURXV ZHOOVWUXFN DQG ZHOOFHQWHUHG SLHFH RI
H[FHSWLRQDO TXDOLW\ 5HYHUVH YHU\ OLJKWO\ GRXEOHVWUXFN RWKHUZLVH
JRRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
133

2:1
$WKHQV&LUFDVV%&'UDFKP6LOYHUPPJK
+HDGRI$WKHQDWRULJKWZHDULQJFUHVWHG$WWLFKHOPHWDGRUQHGZLWK
ROLYHOHDYHVDQGSDOPHWWHGLVFHDUULQJDQGSHDUOQHFNODFH5HYǹĬǼ
2ZO VWDQGLQJ ULJKW ZLWK KHDG IDFLQJ WR OHIW ROLYH VSUD\ DOO ZLWKLQ
LQFXVHVTXDUH6YRURQRVSO$YHU\DWWUDFWLYHZHOOVWUXFNDQG
WRQHGH[DPSOH6RPHYHU\PLQRUWUDFHVRIFRUURVLRQDQGDSSDUHQWO\
XQFOHDQHGDVIRXQGRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP D (XURSHDQ FROOHFWLRQ H[ 0LOORQ -XQH DQG IURP WKH
FROOHFWLRQ RI 9 0 %UDQG 6RWKHE\
V =XULFK -XQH
H[0HU]EDFKHU1RYHPEHU
134

&LUFD VV %& +HDG RI $WKHQD WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ FUHVWHG $WWLF
KHOPHW DGRUQHG ZLWK WKUHH ROLYH OHDYHV DQG SDOPHWWHURXQGHDUULQJ
DQGSHDUOQHFNODFH5HY$Ĭ(2ZOVWDQGLQJWRULJKWKHDGIDFLQJWKH
YLHZHU WR OHIW ROLYH VSULJ DQG FUHVFHQW PRRQ DOO ZLWKLQ LQFXVH
VTXDUH $JRUD 'HZLQJ II 6YRURQRV SO II 1LFHO\
WRQHG*RRGYHU\ILQH
)URPD6ZLVVFROOHFWLRQERXJKWSULYDWHO\IURP6WHUQEHUJLQWKHODWHV
,VODQGVRII$WWLFD
135

$HJLQD &LUFD %& 6WDWHU 6LOYHU PP J
6PRRWKVKHOOHG WXUWOH ZLWK D FROODU DQG D OLQH RI ILYH SHOOHWV GRZQ
WKH FHQWHU RI WKH VKHOO 5HY ,UUHJXODU LQFXVH VTXDUH GLYLGHG LQWR
URXJK FRPSDUWPHQWV %0)$ VDPH GLHV 0LOEDQN SO , 2,5:1
7UDLWp,,SO[[L[9HU\UDUH$UHPDUNDEO\HOHJDQWWRQHGFRLQ
YHU\ZHOOVWUXFNDQGZHOOFHQWHUHGRIRXWVWDQGLQJTXDOLW\
([0RUWRQ (GHQ0D\IURPDQ(QJOLVKFROOHFWLRQ
DQGIURPWKHFROOHFWLRQRI-'HVQHX[+HVV/HX$SULO
7KLV LV RQH RI WKH HDUOLHVW FRLQV WR EH VWUXFN LQ $HJLQDLWPXVWKDYHEHHQ
OHVV WKDQ D GHFDGH DIWHU .URLVRV VWUXFN WKH ILUVW FRLQV WR EH PDGH RI SXUH
JROGDQGSXUHVLOYHUUDWKHUWKDQWKHHOHFWUXPXVHGHDUOLHU
&RULQWKLD
136

&RULQWK &LUFD %& 6WDWHU 6LOYHU PP J K
} 3HJDVXV IO\LQJ WR OHIW 5HY +HDG RI $SKURGLWH WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ
&RULQWKLDQKHOPHWZLWKDOHDWKHUQHFNJXDUGEHKLQGQHFNK\GULDDQG
1 %&' &RULQWK &DOFLDWL 5DYHO %ULJKW DQG FOHDU
([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[3RQWHULR0DUFK
7KH K\GULD D YHVVHO WKDW FRQWDLQHG ZDWHU XVHG WRGLOXWHZLQHDWV\PSRVLD
DFWXDOO\ KDG WKUHHKDQGOHVDKRUL]RQWDOKDQGOHRQHDFKVLGHDQGDYHUWLFDO
KDQGOH UXQQLQJ IURP WKH VKRXOGHU WR WKH OLS )RU SUDFWLFDO UHDVRQV WKH GLH
FXWWHURPLWWHGWKHKRUL]RQWDOKDQGOHV
(OLV
137
2:1

2O\PSLD&LUFD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJK
(DJOHIO\LQJXSZDUGVZLWKVSUHDGZLQJVJUDVSLQJKDUHE\WKHEHOO\
DQG WHDULQJ DW KLP ZLWK KLV EHDN 5HY ) ǹ 1LNH VWULGLQJ WR OHIW
KROGLQJ ZUHDWK LQ KHU RXWVWUHWFKHG ULJKW KDQG DQG WKH KHP RI KHU
FKLWRQLQKHUOHIW%&'2O\PSLD6HOWPDQ7HPSOHEXWREYHUVH
GLH $. SDLUHG ZLWK UHYHUVH GLH ȕĮ 9HU\ UDUH 9HU\ DWWUDFWLYHO\
WRQHG ZHOOFHQWHUHG DQG ZHOOVWUXFN 6RPH VOLJKWO\ URXJK DUHDV
)URP D (XURSHDQ FROOHFWLRQ DQG IURP WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI D 7H[DV 2LOPDQ
1XPLVPDWLFD *HQHYHQVLV 6$ 'HFHPEHU H[ 0Q]HQ XQG
0HGDLOOHQ 9,, 'HFHPEHU 127 0Q]KDQGOXQJ %DVHO 9,, DV
JLYHQLQWKH1*6$FDWDORJXH
138
2:1

2O\PSLD&LUFDVV%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJK
/DXUHDWH KHDG RI =HXV WR ULJKW 5HY ) ǹ _ ǹ ȇ>ǿ@ (DJOH ZLWK
FORVHGZLQJVVWDQGLQJWRULJKWWROHIWYHUWLFDOWKXQGHUEROWWRULJKW
ZUHDWK%&'2O\PSLD,,/+6 6HOWPDQ7HPSOHYDU
$Q DWWUDFWLYH WRQHG H[DPSOH ZLWK D VHQVLWLYH DQG QREOH KHDG RI
=HXV VWUXFN RQ DQ RYDO FDPHROLNH IODQ 5DUH $ERXW H[WUHPHO\
ILQH
)URPWKH3URVSHUR&ROOHFWLRQ7KH1HZ<RUN6DOH;;9,,-DQXDU\
DQGIURPWKHFROOHFWLRQRI1%+XQW,,6RWKHE\
V1HZ<RUN-XQH

157
149 173
209
226 213
225
210
215 216
221 219 223

&\FODGHV
139

$QDSKHUGFHQWXU\%&'LFKDONRQ%URQ]HPPJK
/DXUHDWHKHDGRI$SROOR$LJOHWHVIDFLQJWXUQHGVOLJKWO\WRULJKW5HY
ǹ >1$@ 6N\SKRV ZLWK EHH DERYH %0& 61* &RSHQKDJHQ
2:1 5DUH'DUNUHGJUHHQSDWLQDDQGQLFHO\VWUXFN9HU\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[&ODVVLFDO1XPLVPDWLF*URXS0%6
0D\
140

$QGURVUGVWFHQWXU\%&&KDONRXV%URQ]HPPJK
/DXUHDWHKHDGRI=HXVWRULJKW5HYǹȃ$PSKRUD%0&9HU\
UDUH DQG ZLWK DQ DWWUDFWLYH GDUNEURZQSDWLQD2EYHUVHVOLJKWO\RII
2:1 FHQWHU DQG ZLWK D GLH EUHDN RQ WKH UHYHUVH RWKHUZLVH JRRG YHU\
ILQH
0D\
141

.HRV,RXOLV&LUFD%&2ERO6LOYHUPPJ*UDSH
FOXVWHU 5HY 4XDGULSDUWLWH LQFXVH VTXDUH %0& &UHWH II .DUWKDHD
3DSDJHRUJLDGRX%DQLV 6HULHV , [[LLL 6KHHG\ FI SO 61*
&RSHQKDJHQ9HU\UDUH7RQHG*RRGYHU\ILQH
3:1
0D\
,WVKRXOGEHQRWHGWKDW6KHHG\LVXQVXUHZKHWKHUWKLVW\SHEXQFKRIJUDSHV
DORQH LV DFWXDOO\ IURP ,RXOLV 3DSDJHRUGLDGRX KRZHYHU UHWDLQV WKH
DWWULEXWLRQ
142

.HRV,RXOLV&LUFD%&&KDONRXV%URQ]HPPJK
%HDUGHG KHDG RI %DFFKXV WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ LY\ ZUHDWK 5HY ǿȅȊ
%XQFKRIJUDSHV%0&VDPHGLHV3DSDJHRUJLDGRX%DQLV;,9
253R]]L%RXWLQWKLVFRLQ61*&RSHQKDJHQ
5DUH'DUNJUHHQSDWLQD9HU\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ DQG IURP WKRVH RI & 0RUFRP &ODVVLFDO 3:1
1XPLVPDWLF *URXS 0%6 6HSWHPEHU 6 3R]]L DQG ( 3
:DUUHQILUVWDFTXLUHGLQWKHODWHWKFHQWXU\
143

.HRV .HLDQ .RLQRQ /DWH WKHDUO\ UG FHQWXU\ %& &KDONRXV
%URQ]HPPJK(<Ȅ%HDUGHGKHDGRI$ULVWDLRVWR
ULJKW5HYȀǼ>ǿ@*UDSHFOXVWHUKDQJLQJIURPDYLQHEUDQFK3DSD
JHRUJLDGRX%DQLV 6HULHV , 61* &RSHQKDJHQ 9HU\ UDUH 'DUN
EURZQJUHHQSDWLQD6RPHIODWQHVVRWKHUZLVHYHU\ILQH 2,5:1
0D\
$ULVWDLRV ZDV D VRPHZKDW PLQRU UXVWLF JRG WKH VRQ RI $SROOR DQG WKH
$UWHPLVOLNHKXQWUHVV.\UHQHODWHUVKHEHFDPHWKHIRXQGUHVVRI.\UHQHLQ
/LE\D+LVFXOWZDVFHOHEUDWHGRQ.HRV
144

1D[RV &LUFD %& 7ULKHPLRERO 6LOYHU PP 3:1
J .DQWKDURV ZLWK LY\ OHDI DERYH 5HY 4XDGULSDUWLWH LQFXVH
VTXDUH 6KHHG\ 25 WKLV FRLQ 9HU\ UDUH 7RQHG
ZHOOVWUXFNDQGYHU\DWWUDFWLYH*RRGYHU\ILQH
DQG0Q]HQXQG0HGDLOOHQ)3/6HSWHPEHU
&UHWH
2:1
145

*RUW\QD&LUFD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJK
(XURSD WXUQHG KDOIULJKW VHDWHG LQ D SODQH WUHH KHU ULJKW KDQG
UHVWLQJRQDEUDQFKDQGH[WHQGLQJKHUOHIWWRULJKW5HY%XOOVWDQGLQJ
WRULJKWWXUQLQJLWVKHDGEDFNWROLFNLWVIODQNV%0&VDPHGLHV
%0)$VDPHGLHV*XOEHQNLDQVDPHGLHV/H5LGHUSO
;,,, VDPH GLHV 6YRURQRV 1XPLVPDWLTXH $ EHDXWLIXOO\
WRQHG YHU\ ZHOO VWUXFN H[DPSOH ZLWK QR DSSDUHQW WUDFHV RI
RYHUVWULNLQJYHU\UDUHWKXV0LQRUVFXIIRQWKHREYHUVHRWKHUZLVH
JRRGYHU\ILQH
)URPWKHFROOHFWLRQRIWKH0RQH\0XVHXP=ULFK7ULWRQ;9,,,-DQXDU\
H[ 1XPLVPDWLFD $UV &ODVVLFD $SULO DQG
1XPLVPDWLFD$UV&ODVVLFD)HEUXDU\
146

,WDQRV&LUFD%&2ERO6LOYHUPPJ+HDGRI
$WKHQD WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ FUHVWHG $WWLF KHOPHW 5HY 6WDU RI VHYHQ
UD\V6YRURQRV1XPLVPDWLTXH%ULJKWDQGFOHDU2EYHUVHOLJKWO\
VWUXFN IURP D VOLJKWO\ ZRUQ GLH UHYHUVH YHU\ VKDUSO\ VWUXFN
147
2:1 2:1

3KDLVWRV&LUFD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJK
ȉǹȁȍȃ7DORVQXGHVWDQGLQJIDFLQJRQJURXQGOLQHKLVZLQJV
VSUHDG UDLVLQJ KLV ULJKW KDQG WR KXUO D VWRQH DQG KROGLQJ DQRWKHU
VWRQHLQKLVOHIWGRZQE\KLVVLGH5HYĭǹǿȈȉǿȍȃ%XOOEXWWLQJWR
ULJKW RQ JURXQG OLQH /H 5LGHU S DQG SO [[LY DQG
6YRURQRV 1XPLVPDWLTXH S DQG SO [[LY ERWK VDPH
GLHV9HU\UDUHDQGXQXVXDOO\QLFHIRUWKLVLVVXHRUIRUDQ\&UHWDQ
LVVXHVRIWKLVSHULRG6KDUSO\VWUXFNYHU\DWWUDFWLYHDQGQLFHO\WRQHG
([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPD(XURSHDQFROOHFWLRQDQGIURPWKH+XQWHU&ROOHFWLRQ*ROGEHUJ
)HEUXDU\ ZLWKRXW HDUOLHU SURYHQDQFH EHFDXVH WKH FROOHFWRU
V
WLFNHWZDVORVWIURPDQ$PHULFDQFROOHFWLRQDFTXLUHGIURP+-%HUNDQG
IURPDVSHFLDOL]HG(XURSHDQFROOHFWLRQ%DQN/HX0D\
7KLVFRLQZDVVROGE\%DQN/HXRQEHKDOIRIDQHOGHUO\FROOHFWRUZKRZDV
SDUWLFXODUO\ LQWHUHVWHG LQ &UHWDQ FRLQV KRZHYHU KH OLNH FHUWDLQ RWKHU
FROOHFWRUV HQMR\HG WKH VHQVH RI DQWLTXLW\ KH JRW IURP FRLQV WKDW ZHUH
XQFOHDQHG DV IRXQG 7KXV KLV FROOHFWLRQ ZKLFK KDG EHHQ IRUPHG LQ WKH
VDQGVFRQWDLQHGPDQ\SLHFHVWKDWZHUHXQFOHDQHGDVWKLVRQH
$IWHU LWV SXUFKDVH DW WKH VDOH LWV QHZ RZQHU KDG LW YHU\ FDUHIXOO\ DQG
VXFFHVVIXOO\FOHDQHGWKXVPDNLQJLWDQHYHQPRUHPDJQLILFHQWFRLQWKDQLW
ZDVEHIRUH
148
1,5:1 1,5:1

8QFHUWDLQ&LUFD%&2ERO6LOYHUPPJK
/DXUHDWHKHDGRI$SROORWROHIWKLVORQJKDLUIDOOLQJGRZQWKHEDFN
RIKLVQHFN5HYȁ7ULSRGZLWKWKUHHULQJKDQGOHVEHKLQGROLYHDQG
ODXUHO EUDQFK LQ VDOWLUH ZLWK D ILOOHW KDQJLQJ GRZQ IURP HDFK
6YRURQRV 8QIRXQG DQG DSSDUHQWO\ XQNQRZQ 2I JUHDW UDULW\
DSSDUHQWO\XQLTXH$QDWWUDFWLYHSLHFHRIJRRGVW\OHZLWKDQREYHUVH
LQ KLJK UHOLHI DQG ZLWK D GHHSO\ FRQFDYH UHYHUVH *RRG YHU\
ILQHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
7KLV FRLQ LV D UHDO HQLJPD ,W ZDV RULJLQDOO\ DFTXLUHG ZLWK WKH,WDQRVRERO
DERYH ORW DQG LW LV OLNHO\ WKDW WKH\ ZHUH IRXQG WRJHWKHU DSSDUHQWO\
ZLWK RWKHU FRQWHPSRUDU\ &UHWDQ VLOYHU IUDFWLRQV 7KXV WKH DWWULEXWLRQ WR
&UHWH XVHG KHUH WKH GHHSO\ FRQFDYH UHYHUVH LV DOVR FORVHO\ FRPSDUDEOH WR
WKH,WDQRVREROV%XWZKHUHZDVLWPLQWHG"/DSSDVXJJHVWVLWVHOIWKDQNVWR
WKH VROLWDU\ ȁ RQ WKH UHYHUVH KRZHYHU WKH VW\OH RI WKLV FRLQ LV VR
RXWVWDQGLQJO\ILQHWKDWWKHUHLVDFWXDOO\QRWKLQJFRPSDUDEOHDW/DSSD7KXV
IRUWKHPRPHQWQRIXOODWWULEXWLRQFDQEHVXJJHVWHG
.LQJVRI3RQWRV
149

0LWKUDGDWHV 9, (XSDWRU FLUFD %& 7HWUDGUDFKP 6LOYHU
PP J K $PDVHLD RU 6LQRSH F 'LDGHPHG
KHDGRI0LWKUDGDWHV9,WRULJKWVKRZQDVD\RXQJPDQZLWKVOLJKWO\
XQUXO\KDLUDVKRUWEHDUGRQKLVFKHHNVDQGEHORZKLVFKLQDQGZLWK
KLV GLDGHP HQGV IOXWWHULQJ EHKLQG KLP 5HY ǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈ
ȂǿĬȇǹǻǹȉȅȊ>Ǽ@ȊȆǹȉȅȇȅȈ3HJDVRVVWDQGLQJOHIWKLVULJKWOHJ
EHQWXSZDUGVDQGKLVKHDGEHQWGRZQWRJUD]HDERYH3HJDVRV
VKHDG
WROHIWHLJKWUD\HGVWDUDERYHFUHVFHQWEHORZEHOO\PRQRJUDP'H
&DOODWD¹EXWVHH'5IRUDYHU\VLPLODUGLHSDLU+*&&I
:DGGLQJWRQ DQG :LQWHUWKXU VDPH W\SHV EXW VWUXFN IURP
GLIIHUHQWGLHV2IWKHKLJKHVWUDULW\RQHRIRQO\IRXUNQRZQFRLQVRI
WKLV W\SH DQG WKH RQO\ H[DPSOH QRW LQ D PXVHXP 6RPH WUDFHV RI
FRUURVLRQDQGPLQRUPDUNVRWKHUZLVHJRRGYHU\ILQH
)URPD(XURSHDQFROOHFWLRQ
7KLVFRLQLVQRWRQO\H[WUHPHO\UDUHEXWLWDOVREHDUVRQHRIWKHILQHVWDQG
PRVWUHDOLVWLFSRUWUDLWVHYHUWRKDYHDSSHDUHGRQD*UHHNFRLQ0LWKUDGDWHV
9,(XSDWRUZDVERUQF%&DQGEHFDPHNLQJXSRQWKHDVVDVVLQDWLRQRI
2:1 KLVIDWKHU0LWKUDGDWHV9LQ+HZDVKRZHYHUXQGHUWKHUHJHQF\RIKLV
PRWKHU /DRGLNH 9, EHFDXVH RI KLV DGDPDQWO\ LQGHSHQGHQW QDWXUH DQG KLV
PRWKHU
V REYLRXV SUHIHUHQFH IRU KLV \RXQJHU EURWKHU 0LWKUDGDWHV &KHVWRV
(XSDWRUIHOWLQFUHDVLQJO\WKUHDWHQHG&RQVLGHULQJKRZSUHYDOHQWPXUGHUE\
SRLVRQZDVLQ+HOOHQLVWLFFRXUWV(XSDWRU
VIDWKHUZDVPXUGHUHGE\SRLVRQ
DWDEDQTXHWKLVIHDUZDVVXUHO\MXVWLILHG6RDORQJZLWKDVPDOOQXPEHURI
KLV IULHQGV ZKR VHUYHG DV KLV OR\DO FRPSDQLRQV KH ZHQW LQWR D
VHOILPSRVHG LQWHUQDO H[LOH GXULQJ ZKLFK KH WUDYHOHG DOO DURXQG KLV
NLQJGRP /LYLQJ URXJK PRVW RI WKH WLPH VXUYLYLQJ E\ KXQWLQJ ± WKRXJK
RIWHQVWD\LQJLQORFDOSDODFHVRUORGJHV±(XSDWRUDOVRFDUHIXOO\YLVLWHGDQG
IDPLOLDUL]HG KLPVHOI ZLWK DOO RI WKH PLOLWDU\ XQLWV LQ KLV NLQJGRP $IWHU
DSSUR[LPDWHO\ ILYH \HDUV KH UHWXUQHG GLVSRVHG RI ERWK KLV PRWKHU DQG
\RXQJHU EURWKHU WKRXJK KH JDYH WKHP KRQRUDEOH IXQHUDOV DQG EHJDQ KLV
WXPXOWXRXVUHLJQ7KHWHWUDGUDFKPDQGVWDWHUFRLQDJHRI0LWKUDGDWHV9,KDV
EHHQDEO\VWXGLHGE\WKHGLVWLQJXLVKHG%HOJLDQVFKRODU)UDQoRLVGH&DOODWD¹
KHGLYLGHGWKHPLQWRWZRPDLQJURXSVDQXQGDWHGVHULHVZKLFKKHLPSOLHG
EHJDQFDQGDPXFKPRUHPDVVLYHGDWHGVHULHVVHSDUDWHGLQWROHVVDQG
PRUH LGHDOL]HG SRUWUDLW JURXSV EHJLQQLQJ F +RZHYHU (XSDWRU ZDV D
YHU\ DFWLYH FDPSDLJQHU ZKR H[SDQGHG KLV NLQJGRP FRQVLGHUDEO\ LQ WKH
\HDUV SULRU WR DQG WKH SRVVLELOLW\ WKDW KHKDGLVVXHGQRFRLQDJHDWDOO
GXULQJ WKDW SHULRG VHHPV XQOLNHO\ LQ WKH H[WUHPH ,Q IDFW WKRVH XQGDWHG
LVVXHVDFWXDOO\IDOOLQWRDQXPEHURIJURXSVZKLFKDUHQRWRQO\VW\OLVWLFDOO\
GLVFUHWH EXW FKURQRORJLFDOO\ DV ZHOO 7KH SUHVHQW FRLQ DQG WKH RWKHU WKUHH
NQRZQH[DPSOHVRIWKLVJURXSZDVLVVXHGDWWKHWLPHRI(XSDWRU
VUHWXUQWR
IXOOSRZHULQF,WGLIIHUVIURPDOORIKLVUHPDLQLQJLVVXHVE\KDYLQJD
SRZHUIXOO\UHDOLVWLFSRUWUDLWRIWKH\RXQJNLQJWKHQDERXWKHLVVKRZQ
ZLWKDOLJKWVWUDJJO\EHDUGDQGWUDFHVRIDPXVWDFKHVRPHZKDWXQUXO\KDLU
DQGDGHWHUPLQHGH[SUHVVLRQ,QDGGLWLRQWKHUHYHUVHVKRZV3HJDVRVIHHGLQJ
OHIWZLWKDKDUSDEHORZDQGZLWKWKHLQVFULSWLRQVDERYHDQGXQGHUQHDWKWKH
W\SH$OOEXWWKHYHU\HDUOLHVWUHPDLQLQJLVVXHVVKRZ0LWKUDGDWHVEHDUGOHVV
DQG DQ LQFUHDVLQJO\ LGHDOL]HG $OH[DQGHUWKH*UHDWOLNH SRUWUDLW VLPLODU WR
WKRVHRQWKHFRLQDJHRI/\VLPDFKRV±VHHWKHIROORZLQJWZRORWV
150

PP J K 3HUJDPXP \HDU %&"'LDGHPHG
KHDG RI 0LWKUDGDWHV 9, WR ULJKW KLV KDLU IORZLQJ ZLOGO\ 5HY
ǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈȂǿĬȇǹǻǹȉȅȊǼȊȆǹȉȅȇȅȈ6WDJIHHGLQJWROHIW
WR OHIW VWDU RI HLJKW UD\V ZLWKLQ FUHVFHQW WR ULJKW GDWH ī RYHU
PRQRJUDP DOO ZLWKLQ LY\ ZUHDWK &DOODWD¹ '5 " $ FOHDU DQG
DWWUDFWLYH H[DPSOH QLFHO\ FHQWHUHG 6RPH PLQRU PDUNV RWKHUZLVH
QHDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH 2:1
151

PPJK3HUJDPXP\HDUWKPRQWK -XO\
%& 'LDGHPHG KHDG RI 0LWKUDGDWHV 9, WR ULJKW KLV KDLU VWUHDPLQJ
RXW EHKLQG 5HY ǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈ ȂǿĬȇǹǻǹȉȅȊ ǼȊȆǹȉȅȇȅȈ
6WDJIHHGLQJWROHIWWROHIWVWDUZLWKLQFUHVFHQWRYHUPRQRJUDPWR
ULJKW GDWH ǺǿȈ RYHU PRQRJUDP EHORZ OHJHQG PRQWK ǿ DOO ZLWKLQ
2:1
LY\ZUHDWK'H&DOODWD¹,GHDOL]HG6W\OH'5&OHDUDWWUDFWLYHDQG
ZHOOFHQWHUHG 0LQRU PDUNV DQG VFUDWFKHV RWKHUZLVH DERXW
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
%LWK\QLD
152

+HUDNOHLD 3RQWLND &LUFD %& 'LGUDFKP 6LOYHU PP
JK+HDGRI\RXWKIXO+HUDNOHVWRULJKWZHDULQJOLRQ
VVNLQ
KHDGGUHVV 5HY ǾȇǹȀȁǼȍȉǹȃ 'LRQ\VRV VHDWHG OHIW RQ EDFNOHVV
2:1 WKURQH KROGLQJ D NDQWKDURV LQ KLV RXWVWUHWFKHG ULJKW KDQG DQG D
WK\UVRVZLWKKLVOHIW61*%0%ODFN6HDVDPHUHYHUVHGLH
61* 6WDQFRPE YDU PRQRJUDP XQGHU WKURQH 61* YRQ
$XORFN YDU PRQRJUDP XQGHU WKURQH 1LFHO\ WRQHG DQG
DWWUDFWLYH$ERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[*RUQ\ 0RVFK0DUFK
0\VLD
153

.\]LNRV &LUFD %& 6WDWHU (OHFWUXP PP J
/LRQ VFDOS IDFLQJ EHORZ WXQQ\ ILVK VZLPPLQJ WR OHIW 5HY
4XDGULSDUWLWH LQFXVH VTXDUH %0& %RVWRQ *LOOHW
WKLV FRLQ *UHHQZHOO 9RQ )ULW]H :DUUHQ 5DUH DQG
OLJKWO\ WRQHG 6RPH GLH UXVW DQG WZR VFUDWFKHV RQ WKH REYHUVH
RWKHUZLVHYHU\ILQH
([ 6LQFRQD 0D\ DQG IURP WKH FROOHFWLRQV RI -DPHV
6QHMD9HONRY9LQFKRQ1RYHPEHUDQG&*LOOHW
2:1
154

.\]LNRV &LUFD %& 6WDWHU (OHFWUXP PP J
/LRQ FURXFKLQJ WR ULJKW ELWLQJ VZRUG KHOG LQ KLV IRUHSDZV EHORZ
WXQQ\ ILVK VZLPPLQJ WR ULJKW 5HY 4XDGULSDUWLWH LQFXVH VTXDUH
%RVWRQ 0)$ *UHHQZHOO -DPHVRQ 61* %1
9RQ )ULW]H 7RQHG DQG EROGO\ VWUXFN 0LQRU PDUNV RWKHUZLVH
2:1 YHU\ILQH
)URPD(XURSHDQFROOHFWLRQ
3:1
155

.\]LNRV&LUFD%&6WDWHU(OHFWUXPPPJ%HDUGHG
KRUVHPDQ YHU\ SUREDEO\ 3KLOLS ,, RI 0DFHGRQ ZHDULQJ D NDXVLD
FKODP\VDQGULGLQJERRWVULGLQJDKRUVHJDOORSLQJWRULJKWKHKROGV
WKH UHLQV LQ KLV ULJKW KDQG DQG WXUQV WKHKRUVH
VKHDGVOLJKWO\WRKLV
ULJKW RQ WKH KRUVH
V EDFN OHRSDUG
V VNLQ VDGGOH FORWK EHORZ WKH
KRUVH
V EDFN OHJV WXQQ\ ILVK VZLPPLQJ WR ULJKW 5HY 4XDGULSDUWLWH
LQFXVHVTXDUH%RVWRQ6XSSOHPHQW61*)UDQFH9RQ)ULW]H
([WUHPHO\ UDUH WKH ILQHVW NQRZQ H[DPSOH VKDUSO\ VWUXFN DQG
DWWUDFWLYHO\WRQHG*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
([5RPD6HSWHPEHU
156 156
2:1

.\]LNRV VW FHQWXU\ %& &KDONRXV %URQ]H PP J K
'UDSHGEXVWRI.RUHWRULJKWKHUKDLUWLHGXSLQDEXQDWWKHEDFN
5HY Ȁ Ȋ _ ǽ ǿ /\UH DERYH PRQRJUDP RI ĭȊ %0& 61*
)UDQFH9RQ)ULW]H*URXS,9$SSDUHQWO\YHU\UDUH$ORYHO\
H[DPSOH VKDUS DQG ZLWK D GDUN SDWLQD 2EYHUVH YHU\ VOLJKWO\
GRXEOHVWUXFNRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
157

/DPSVDNRV&LUFD%&6WDWHU*ROGPPJK
/DXUHDWH KHDG RI =HXV WR OHIW ZLWK VFHSWHU RYHU KLV IDU VKRXOGHU
EHKLQG KLV QHFN 5HY )RUHSDUW RI 3HJDVRV WR ULJKW %DOGZLQ
/DPSVDNRV V %0)$ .UDD\ +LUPHU 61* )UDQFH
2:1 VDPH GLHV 61* YRQ $XORFN VDPH GLHV 5DUH DQG
ZLWKDQREOHKHDGRI=HXVRIVSOHQGLGODWH&ODVVLFDOVW\OH0LQRUGLH
EUHDNVRQWKHREYHUVHDQGZLWKVRPHVWULNLQJIODWQHVVRQWKHUHYHUVH
([5RPD;,,6HSWHPEHUIURPWKH3URVSHUR&ROOHFWLRQ1HZ
<RUN 6DOH ;;9,, -DQXDU\ ERXJKW SULYDWHO\ IURP 6SLQN
V LQ
/RQGRQ $XJXVW DQG IURP WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI * 3KLOLSVHQ +LUVFK
;;91RYHPEHU
7URDV
158
2:1
$E\GRV&LUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJK
3KHUHQLNRV 'UDSHG EXVW RI $UWHPLV WR ULJKWZLWK ERZ DQG TXLYHU
RYHU KHU VKRXOGHU 5HY $%+ǻ+1ȍ1 ĭ(3(1,.2< (DJOH
VWDQGLQJULJKWZLWKVSUHDGZLQJVWRULJKWEXQFKRIJUDSHVDOOZLWKLQ
ODXUHO ZUHDWK WLHG DW WKH ERWWRP &DOODWD¹ $E\GRV VXU $HVLOODV
'561*YRQ$XORFNYDUDUUDQJHPHQWRIPDJLVWUDWH
V
QDPH/LJKWO\WRQHGDQGFOHDUO\VWUXFN*RRGYHU\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[/DQ]1RYHPEHU
3:1 159

.HEUHQWKFHQWXU\%&+HPLKHNWH6LOYHUPPJK
5DP
VKHDGWRULJKW5HY*RUJRQHLRQZLWKLQVKDOORZLQFXVHVTXDUH
%HPHQW VDPH GLHV 61* YRQ $XORFN 5DUH :HOO
FHQWHUHGZHOOVWUXFNDQGWRQHG*RRGYHU\ILQH
)URPDQ$PHULFDQFROOHFWLRQH[1DXPDQQ-XQH
7KLVFRLQZDVVWUXFNIURPWKHVDPHGLHVDVWKHVSOHQGLGSLHFHWKDWDSSHDUHG
DVORWRI*RUQ\ 0RVFKLQWKDWFRLQUHDFKHG¼IURPDQ
HVWLPDWHRI¼
,VODQGVRII7URDV
160

7HQHGRV &LUFD %& 'UDFKP 6LOYHU PPJK
-DQLIRUPKHDGIRUPHGE\WKHKHDGVRIDODXUHDWHDQGEHDUGHG=HXVWR
OHIW DQG D GLDGHPHG +HUD WR ULJKW 5HY ȉǼȃǼǻǿȍȃ 'RXEOH D[H
EHORZ OHIW PRQRJUDP DQG EXQFK RI JUDSHV WR OHIW EHORZ ULJKW
WULSRGDOOZLWKLQODXUHOZUHDWK&DOODWD¹7HQHGRVVDPHREYHUVH 2:1
GLH9HU\UDUH&OHDUDQGDWWUDFWLYHZLWKDGDUNSDWLQD6RPHVXUIDFH
URXJKQHVVRWKHUZLVHDERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
0D\
161

7HQHGRV&LUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K -DQLIRUP KHDG FRPSRVHG RI D ODXUHDWH DQG EHDUGHG KHDG RI
=HXVWROHIWDQGDGLDGHPHGKHDGRI+HUDWRULJKW5HYȉǼȃǼǻǿȍȃ
'RXEOH D[H EHORZ WR OHIW PRQRJUDP RI īǹȊ DQG EXQFK RI JUDSHV
EHORZWRULJKWRZOVWDQGLQJOHIWKHDGIDFLQJIURQW&DOODWD¹7HQHGRV
'5WKLVFRLQ5DUH7RQHG0LQRUPDUNVLQFOXGLQJDGLH
IDXOWRQWKHREYHUVHRWKHUZLVHJRRGYHU\ILQH 2:1
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[.QNHU6HSWHPEHU
6RWKHE\
V2FWREHU9HFFKL)3/QGDQG1XPLVPDWLFD
:LHQ,9$SULO
$HROLV
162

.\PH&LUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJK
+HUDNOHLGHV %& +HDG RI WKH Q\PSK .\PH WR ULJKW KHUKDLU
ERXQG XS ZLWK D EURDG WDHQLD 5HY ȀȊȂǹǿȍȃǾȇǹȀȁǼǿǻǾȈ
+RUVH VWDQGLQJ ULJKW OHIW OHJ UDLVHG RYHU HDJOH VWDQGLQJ ULJKW RQ D
WKXQGHUEROWEHORZKRUVHRQHKDQGOHGYDVHDOOZLWKLQROLYHZUHDWK 2:1
2DNOH\FWKLVFRLQ7RQHGDQGDWWUDFWLYH([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[6XSHULRU-XQHDQGIURP
WKH5XE\&ROOHFWLRQ6XSHULRU-XQH
163

$(2/,60\ULQD&LUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPP
JK/DXUHDWHKHDGRI$SROORWRULJKW5HY0Ȋȇ,1$,ȍ1
$SROOR *U\QLRV VWDQGLQJ ULJKW KROGLQJ EUDQFK LQ KLV OHIW KDQG DQG
SKLDOH LQ KLV ULJKW RPSKDORV DQG DPSKRUD DW KLV IHHW LQ OHIW ILHOG
PRQRJUDPRIȆȊ6DFNV,VVXHREYHUVHGLH61*YRQ$XORFN
%ULJKW DQG DWWUDFWLYH 9HU\ PLQRU GLH VKLIW RQ WKH REYHUVH

([&ODVVLFDO1XPLVPDWLF*URXS6HSWHPEHU
2:1
/HVERV
164

0\WLOHQH&LUFD%&+HNWH(OHFWUXPPPJK
+HDG RI D OLRQ URDULQJ WR ULJKW 5HY +HDG RI D FDOI ULJKW DW QHFN
3:1 WUXQFDWLRQ WR OHIW PLQLDWXUH LUUHJXODU LQFXVH UHFWDQJOH DOO LQFXVH
1LFHO\FHQWHUHGDQGFOHDU*RRGYHU\ILQH
165

0\WLOHQH&LUFD%&+HNWH(OHFWUXPPPJK
+HDGRIOLRQURDULQJWRULJKW5HY+HDGRIFDOIWROHIWDWWUXQFDWLRQ
PLQLDWXUHLUUHJXODULQFXVHUHFWDQJOHDOOLQFXVH%RGHQVWHGW:LWK
DQDWWUDFWLYHUHYHUVH*RRGYHU\ILQH
3:1
,RQLD
166

8QFHUWDLQ &LUFD %& 7ULWH (OHFWUXP PP J
/\GR0LOHVLDQ VWDQGDUG *OREXODU VXUIDFH ZLWK DQ XQFHUWDLQSDWWHUQ
RIGRWV5HY2EORQJLQFXVHGLYLGHGLQWRWZRVTXDUHV%RVWRQ0)$
3R]]L 5RVHQ 61* YRQ $XORFN 7UDLWp ,
5DUH $Q LPSRUWDQW GRFXPHQW LQ WKH KLVWRU\ RI FRLQDJH RQH RI WKH
HDUOLHVW FRLQV RI WKH ZHVWHUQ ZRUOG 7LQ\ VWULNLQJ FUDFNV DQG ZLWK
3:1
VXUIDFHVDVIRXQGRWKHUZLVHDVPDGH
$W WKLV HDUO\ SHULRG LQ WKH KLVWRU\ RIFRLQDJHDGLHPDGHIRURQHGHQRPL

QDWLRQ PLJKW DOVR EH XVHG IRU DQRWKHU LI WKH VL]HV ZHUH FRPSDWLEOH 7KLV
FRLQ DQG WKHRQHLQWKHIROORZLQJORWDUHSHUIHFWH[DPSOHVRIWKLVSKHQR
PHQRQ VLQFH WKH\ DUH FOHDUO\ VWUXFN IURP WKH VDPH REYHUVH GLH +RZHYHU
WKHGLHPXVWKDYHILUVWEHHQXVHGIRUWKHKHNWHVLQFHKHUHRQWKHWULWHLWLV
FOHDUO\PRUHZRUQWKDQLWZDVZKHQLWZDVXVHGWRVWULNHWKHKHNWDL
167
3:1
8QFHUWDLQ &LUFD %& +HNWH (OHFWUXP PP J
/\GR0LOHVLDQVWDQGDUG*OREXODUVXUIDFHZLWKDQXQFHUWDLQSDWWHUQRI
GRWV5HY2EORQJLQFXVHGLYLGHGLQWRWZRVTXDUHV%RVWRQ0)$
YDU9HU\UDUH+HNWDLRIWKLVVHULHVDUHDSSDUHQWO\YHU\PXFKUDUHUWKDQ
WKHWULWDLDVWKHSUHFHHGLQJORW$ERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
6WUXFNXVLQJDQREYHUVHGLHWKDWZDVDSSDUHQWO\DOVRXVHGIRUWULWHVDVWKH
SUHFHGLQJORW
4:1
168

(SKHVRV3KDQHVFLUFD%&7ULWH(OHFWUXPPPJ
ĭǹȃǼȅȈ UHWURJUDGH LQ DUFKDLF OHWWHUV 6WDJ JUD]LQJ ULJKW ZLWK LWV
ERG\ RUQDPHQWHG ZLWK D OR]HQJH SDWWHUQ UHPLQLVFHQW RI WKH ILOOLQJ
RUQDPHQWV IRXQG RQ FRQWHPSRUDU\ (DVW *UHHN SDLQWHG SRWWHU\ 5HY
7ZRLUUHJXODUVTXDUHLQFXVHVHDFKRUQDPHQWHGZLWKUDLVHGLQWHUVHFWLQJ
OLQHV$&*&.UDD\ +LUPHU61*0QFKHQ:HLGDXHU
9HU\ UDUH SHUKDSV WKH EHVW H[DPSOH VWLOO LQ SULYDWH KDQGV DQG D
FRLQRIJUHDWLPSRUWDQFH$ERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI WKH ODWH 'U / $ $GDPV 7ULWRQ ;,; -DQXDU\

7KLVHOHFWUXPWKLUGVWDWHUFRPHVIURPWKHILUVWVHULHVRIFRLQVHYHUWREHDUD
SHUVRQDO QDPH ± KHUHWKDWRIDQRWKHUZLVHXQNQRZQ3KDQHV7KHVWDJZDV
WKHWRWHPDQLPDORI$UWHPLVWKHJUHDWJRGGHVVRI(SKHVRVZKHWKHU3KDQHV
ZDV DQ DFWXDO RIILFLDO RI WKH VDQFWXDU\ RU MXVW D SURPLQHQW PHUFKDQW RU
EDQNHUZKRZDVUHVSRQVLEOHIRUWKHFRLQVDQGZKRRXWRISLHW\KRQRUHGWKH
JRGGHVVE\WKHW\SHLVXQNQRZQ
3:1
169

(SKHVRV &LUFD %& 6WDWHU 6LOYHU PP J
%HH5HY,UUHJXODULQFXVHVTXDUH.DUZHLVH6HULHV,,,&I61*
.D\KDQ VWDWHU 9HU\ UDUH 6KDUS WRQHG DQG XQXVXDOO\
QLFHIRUWKLVLVVXH*RRGYHU\ILQH
170

(U\WKUDL&LUFD%&+HNWH(OHFWUXPPPJF
+HDG RI +HUDNOHV WR OHIW ZLWK DQ DOPRQGVKDSHG IURQWDO
H\H DQG ZHDULQJ OLRQ¶V VNLQ KHDGGUHVV ZLWK WKUHH UD\V DERYH WKH
OLRQ
V H\H 5HY 4XDGULSDUWLWH LQFXVH VTXDUH &I %RVWRQ 0)$
± 61* .D\KDQ ± DQG 61* YRQ $XORFN EXW DOO
ZLWKRXWUD\VRQWKHREYHUVH3HUIHFWO\FHQWHUHG$YHU\UDUHYDULHW\
ZLWKWKHUD\VRQWKHREYHUVH$ERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
([&ODVVLFDO1XPLVPDWLF*URXSH6DOH0DUFK 3:1
7KHKHNWDLRI(U\WKUDLZLWKWKHLUDSSHDOLQJKHDGVRI+HUDNOHVDUHEDVLFDOO\
FRPPRQHQRXJKQRZEXWWKLVYDULHW\LVDFWXDOO\YHU\UDUH:KDWZHKDYHLV
D OLRQ
V VNLQ KHDGGUHVV WKDW DSSHDUV WR KDYH EHHQ WDNHQ IURP WKH OLRQ WKDW
DSSHDUVRQWKHKHNWDLRI$O\DWWHVRI/\GLD7KLVLVEHFDXVHRIWKHUD\VWKDW
DSSHDU DERYH WKH OLRQ
V H\H ZKLFK DUH MXVW OLNH WKRVH RQ WKH/\GLDQOLRQV
7KLVDVGRHV+HUDNOHV
GLVWLQFWO\DOPRQGVKDSHGH\HVXJJHVWVWKDWWKLVFRLQ
PXVWGDWHWRWKHYHU\VWDUWRIWKHVHULHV
171

.OD]RPHQDL &LUFD %& 6WDWHU 6LOYHU PP J
)RUHSDUW RI ZLQJHG ERDU WR ULJKW 5HY 4XDGULSDUWLWH LQFXVH VTXDUH
$V\XW 61* &RSHQKDJHQ 1LFHO\ FHQWHUHG DQG WRQHG 2,5:1
6RPHZKDWURXJKVXUIDFHVZLWKYHU\PLQRUGHSRVLWVRWKHUZLVHJRRG
YHU\ILQH
)URP WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI : ) 6WRHFNOLQ $PULVZLO 6ZLW]HUODQG DFTXLUHG
IURP 0Q]HQ XQG 0HGDLOOHQ LQ %DVHO SULRU WR EXW SUREDEO\ EHIRUH

172

.OD]RPHQDL &LUFD %& +HPLGUDFKP 6LOYHU PP
JK0QHVLWKHRV+HDGRI$SROORIDFLQJWXUQHGVOLJKWO\WR
OHIW ZLWK D FKODP\V WLHG DURXQG KLV QHFN 5HY ȀȁǹȄȅ 3:1
ȂȃǾȈǿĬǼȅȈ 6ZDQ VWDQGLQJ OHIW ZLWK RSHQ ZLQJV WR OHIW
NDQWKDURV %0& 61* &RSHQKDJHQ 61* 0QFKHQ
7RQHG DQG ZLWK DQ HPRWLYH KHDG RI $SROOR 2EYHUVH VOLJKWO\ RII
FHQWHURWKHUZLVHJRRGYHU\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQERXJKWSULYDWHO\IURP6SLQNLQ-XQH
173

0DJQHVLDDG0DHDQGUXP&LUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHU
PPJK+HUDVLSSRVVRQRI$ULVWHRV'LDGHPHGEXVWRI
$UWHPLV WR ULJKW ZLWK ERZ DQG TXLYHU DW KHU VKRXOGHU 5HY
0$ī1+7ȍ1 (3$Ȉ,ȆȆ2Ȉ $3,Ȉ7(2< $SROOR VWDQGLQJ WR OHIW RQ
PDHDQGHUSDWWHUQKROGLQJDILOOHWHGODXUHOEUDQFKZLWKKLVULJKWKDQG
DQG OHDQLQJ KLV OHIW HOERZ RQ D WULSRG EHKLQG KLP DOO ZLWKLQ ODXUHO
ZUHDWK -RQHV REYHUVH GLH 61* %HUU\ VDPH REYHUVH GLH
61* YRQ $XORFN 9HU\ DWWUDFWLYHO\ WRQHG DQG RI ORYHO\ VW\OH
6RPHVWULNLQJIODWQHVVRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1
174

0LOHWRV &LUFD %& 6WDWHU (OHFWUXP PP J
/LRQVHDWHGOHIWKLVKHDGWXUQHGEDFNWRULJKWDOOZLWKLQRUQDPHQWDO
UHFWDQJXODUIUDPH5HY7KUHHRUQDPHQWDOLQFXVHVDERYHDVTXDUH
SXQFK FRQWDLQLQJDVWDURIILYHSHOOHWVFRQQHFWHGE\OLQHVDWWKH
FHQWHU D UHFWDQJXODU SXQFK FRQWDLQLQJ D IR[ UXQQLQJ WR OHIW DQG DQ
RUQDPHQW RI WKUHH SHOOHWV EHORZ D VTXDUH SXQFK FRQWDLQLQJ D
VWDJ¶VKHDGWROHIW%0)$.RQXN /RUEHUILJ.UDD\
2:1
+LUPHU61*.D\KDQ:HLGDXHU5DUH$SDUWLFXODUO\
ZHOOVWUXFN DQG FOHDU H[DPSOH IRU WKLV LVVXH 1LFHO\ WRQHG $ IHZ
PLQRUPDUNVDQGVFUDWFKHVRWKHUZLVHJRRGYHU\ILQH
([ &ODVVLFDO 1XPLVPDWLF *URXS 6HSWHPEHU DQG IURP
WKH 6WHYHQVRQ &ROOHFWLRQ &ODVVLFDO 1XPLVPDWLF *URXS ;;9, -XQH

175

2,5:1 0LOHWRV&LUFD%&&KDONRXV%URQ]HPPJK
(XNWHPRV/DXUHDWHKHDGRI$SROORWRULJKW5HYǼȊȀȉǾȂȅ/LRQ
VWDQGLQJWRULJKWKHDGWXUQHGEDFNWROHIWWROHIWVHYHQUD\HGVWDU
'HSSHUW $Q H[FHOOHQW H[DPSOH ZLWK D VKLQ\ GDUN SDWLQD
([WUHPHO\ILQH
176

3KRNDLD &LUFD %& +HNWH (OHFWUXP PPJF
HDUO\ V %DOG DQG ZUHDWKHG KHDG RI 6LOHQRV IDFLQJ ZLWK ZLGH
RSHQ H\HV EURDG EHDUG DQG ORQJ PXVWDFKH WR OHIW VHDO VZLPPLQJ
XSZDUGV5HY4XDGULSDUWLWHLQFXVHVTXDUH%RGHQVWHGWDĮ$YHU\
ZHOOVWUXFN WRQHG DQG DWWUDFWLYH H[DPSOH SUREDEO\ WKH EHVW RI
DSSUR[LPDWHO\H[DPSOHVNQRZQ1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
3:1
177

6P\UQD&LUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K 7XUUHWHG KHDG RI WKH 7\FKH RI 6P\UQD WR ULJKW 5HY
ǽȂȊȇȃǹǿȍȃ LQ WZR OLQHV ZLWK PRQRJUDP RI ǼȊȉ EHORZ DOO
ZLWKLQ DQ RDN ZUHDWK 0LOQH $XWRQRPRXV 61* %HUU\
:HEHU :HOOVWUXFN QLFHO\ WRQHG DQG DWWUDFWLYH ([WUHPHO\
ILQH 1,5:1
)URPD(XURSHDQFROOHFWLRQDFTXLUHGSULYDWHO\IURP+-%HUN&KLFDJR
RQ-XO\
178

7HRV &LUFD %& 6WDWHU 6LOYHU PPJ*ULIILQ
ZLWKRSHQPRXWKDQGZLWKWZRFXUYHGWHQGULOVIDOOLQJGRZQKLVQHFN
VHDWHGWRULJKWRQRUQDPHQWDOSHGHVWDOKLVOHIWIRUHSDZUDLVHG5HY
4XDGULSDUWLWH LQFXVH VTXDUH %DOFHU VDPH UHYHUVH GLH 1$& 2:1
VDPH GLHV 9HU\ UDUH 1LFHO\ WRQHG ZHOOVWUXFN DQG
ZHOOFHQWHUHG([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH:LOKHOPVWUDVVH&ROOHFWLRQ
,VODQGVRII,RQLD
179

&KLRV &LUFD %& +HPLGUDFKP 6LOYHU PP J
6SKLQ[VHDWHGWROHIWRQJURXQGOLQHWROHIWEXQFKRIJUDSHVRYHU&KLDQ
DPSKRUD WR ULJKW PRQRJUDP RI Ǿī 5HY *UDQXODWHG TXDGULSDUWLWH
LQFXVH VTXDUH &I %0& GLIIHUHQW PRQRJUDP 0DYURJRUGDWR
3HULRG 9, EXW RQO\ GUDFKPV 5DUH HVSHFLDOO\ LQ WKLV FRQGLWLRQ
1LFHO\WRQHGDQGYHU\ZHOOFHQWHUHG1HDUO\YHU\ILQH
2:1
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQDFTXLUHGLQ1RYHPEHU
,W LV UHPDUNDEOH KRZ EDGO\ SUHVHUYHG PRVW WK FHQWXU\ %& &KLDQ VLOYHU
GUDFKPV DQG KHPLGUDFKPV WHQG WR EH 7KH\ DUH XVXDOO\ EDGO\ FHQWHUHG DQG
VHULRXVO\ ZRUQ WKXV WKH SUHVHQW SLHFH LV DFWXDOO\ XQXVXDOO\ ZHOOSUHVHUYHG
7KH FHQWHULQJ LV SHUIHFW ZLWK DOO GHWDLOV IXOO\ YLVLEOH DQG WKH WRQLQJ DORQJ
ZLWKWKHH[FHOOHQWVXUIDFHVLPSOLHVWKDWWKLVFRLQKDVEHHQORQJLQFROOHFWLRQV±
DOPRVW FHUWDLQO\ JRLQJ EDFN WR WKH HDUOLHU WK FHQWXU\ LI QRW EHIRUH
8QIRUWXQDWHO\WKHRQO\UHFRUGZHKDYHLVWKDWLWZDVDFTXLUHGLQ
180

&KLRV&LUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K 6RFUDWHV 6SKLQ[ VHDWHG WR OHIW WR OHIW EXQFK RI JUDSHV RYHU
&KLDQDPSKRUD5HY6WULDWHGVTXDUHGLYLGHGE\WZRFURVVHGEHDPV
2:1 RQWKHKRUL]RQWDOEHDPȈȍȀȇǹȉǾȈ+DUGZLFN&+,;S
WKLVFRLQ0DYURJRUGDWR3HULRG9,,FI9HU\UDUH%HDXWLIXOO\
WRQHG6RPHYHU\PLQRUPDUNVRWKHUZLVHDERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQHYHU\
ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ /DQ] 1RYHPEHU
0OOHU-XQH%XUJDQ'HFHPEHU*LHVVHQHU
0Q]KDQGOXQJ 0D\ 5DXFK 2FWREHU
0Q]=HQWUXP1RYHPEHU(OVHQ)3/0D\
(OVHQ )3/ -XO\$XJXVWDQG*LHVVHQHU0Q]KDQGOXQJ
0DUFK
181

&KLRV &LUFD %& 'UDFKP 6LOYHU PP J K
2:1 'HUN\ORV 6SKLQ[ VHDWHG OHIW LQ ILHOG WR OHIW EXQFK RI JUDSHV 5HY
;,2Ȉ ǻǼȇȀȊȁȅȈ &KLDQ DPSKRUD LQ ILHOG WR OHIW FRUQXFRSLD DOO
ZLWKLQ FLUFOH RI GRWV 0DYURJRUGDWR 3HULRG ,; Ȗ 61*
&RSHQKDJHQ61*YRQ$XORFN1LFHO\WRQHG9HU\
ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ 0Q]HQ XQG 0HGDLOOHQ '(
6HSWHPEHU
182
1,5:1 1,5:1

&KLRV7LPHRI$QWRQLQXV3LXVWR&RPPRGXV%URQ]H
PPJK$VVDULDSRVVLEO\PLQWHGHDUO\LQWKHUHLJQ
RI $QWRQLQXV 3LXV F ;,ȍȃ 35 6SKLQ[ VHDWHG ULJKW
UHVWLQJ IRUHSDZ XSRQ &KLDQ DPSKRUD WR ULJKW 5HY $&&$3,21
+0<&<7ZRFURVVHGWK\UVRLZLWKLQDYLQHZUHDWKZLWKDEXQFKRI
JUDSHVKDQJLQJEHWZHHQWKHWK\UVRL%0&0DYURJRUGDWRE
53& ,9 RQOLQH WHPSRUDU\ QXPEHU 61* &RSHQKDJHQ
VDPHGLHV$YHU\DWWUDFWLYHSLHFHZLWKDGDUNDQGVOLJKWO\URXJK
SDWLQD([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ %DQNKDXV $XIKlXVHU 2FWREHU

3:1
183

6DPRV&LUFD%&+HPLVWDWHU(OHFWUXPPPJ
(XERLF6DPLDQ VWDQGDUG 5RXJK VXUIDFH ZLWK LUUHJXODU PDUNLQJV
5HY$VTXDUHDQGDUHFWDQJOHLQFXVHHDFKZLWKLUUHJXODUPDUNLQJV
%DUURQ SO ;;; 7UDLWp , VDPH GLHV .RQXN (OHFWUXP
7\SHSO% 61*.D\KDQ7ULWRQ;9,,,VDPH
GLHV 9HU\ UDUH DQG PRVW LQWULJXLQJ 2QH RI WKH HDUOLHVW NQRZQ
FRLQV([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPD6ZLVVFROOHFWLRQ
&DULD
184

$QWLRFKDG0DHDQGUXP&LUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHU
PP J K 0HOHDJHU /DXUHDWH KHDG RI =HXV WR ULJKW
5HY ǹȃ_ȉǿȅ_ȋǼ_ȍȃ ȂǼ_ȁǼǹ_īȇȅȈ (DJOH ZLWK FORVHG ZLQJV
VWDQGLQJ RQ WKXQGHUEROW WR OHIW DOO ZLWKLQ PDHDQGHU ERUGHU
2:1 8QSXEOLVKHG VDYH IRU LWV SUHYLRXV DXFWLRQ DSSHDUDQFH EXW IRU WKH
W\SHVHHWKHWHWUDGUDFKPLQ3DULV%0&SO;/9DQGWKDWRQFH
LQ WKH YRQ $XORFN FROOHFWLRQ 61* YRQ $XORFN ERWK ZLWK
RWKHUPDJLVWUDWHV
QDPHV([WUHPHO\UDUHWKHVHFRQGDQGE\IDUWKH
EHWWHU H[DPSOH NQRZQ :HOOVWUXFN DQG QLFHO\ WRQHG $ERXW
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
([*RUQ\ 0RVFK2FWREHU
$IWHUWKH5RPDQVSXQLVKHG5KRGHVZLWKWKHORVVRIKHUPDLQODQGWHUULWRULHV
±VKHZDVWKRXJKWWRKDYHEHHQWRRIULHQGO\ZLWK3HUVHXVRI0DFHGRQ±WKH
FLWLHV LQYROYHG EHJDQ LVVXLQJ WKHLU RZQ FRLQDJHV 7KLV SLHFH LV RQH RI WKH
YHU\UDUHWHWUDGUDFKPVSURGXFHGE\$QWLRFKRQWKH0DHDQGHU
185

.QLGRV &LUFD %& 'UDFKP 6LOYHUPPJK
)RUHSDUWRIOLRQWRULJKWZLWKRSHQMDZVDQGRXWVWUHWFKHGULJKWSDZ
5HYȀȃǿ+HDGRI$SKURGLWHWRULJKWKHUKDLUERXQGZLWKDWDHQLD
DQG WLHG LQ D ORQJ SRQ\WDLO DW WKH EDFN ZHDULQJ DVLPSOHQHFNODFH
DQGZLWKDSHDUOHGQHFNWUXQFDWLRQDOOZLWKLQDQLQFXVHVTXDUH&DKQ
-DPHVRQWKLVFRLQ7RQHGDQGRIILQHVW\OH([WUHPHO\
ILQH
)URPWKH:LOKHOPVWUDVVH&ROOHFWLRQH[0Q]HQXQG0HGDLOOHQ-XQH
2:1 DQGIURPWKHFROOHFWLRQVRI:1LJJHOHU,%DQN/HX±0Q]HQ
XQG0HGDLOOHQ'HFHPEHUDQG5-DPHVRQDFTXLUHGSULRUWR

186

7DEDL VW FHQWXU\ %& 'UDFKP 6LOYHU PP J K
6HOHXNRVVRQRI%UDFK\OOLGHV7$%+1ȍ1+HDGRI\RXWKIXO'LRQ\
VRV WR ULJKW ZLWK LY\ZUHDWK IORZLQJ IURP KLV KHDG GRZQ WR KLV 2:1
VKRXOGHUV 5HY &(ȁ(9.2& %3$;9ȁȁǿǻ29 3RVHLGRQ
VWDQGLQJULJKWZLWKKLVOHIWIRRWVHWXSRQDSURZKROGLQJWULGHQWZLWK
KLV OHIW KDQG DQG UHVWLQJ KLV ULJKW RQ KLV KLS EHKLQG KLP GROSKLQ
VZLPPLQJ GRZQZDUGV %0& VDPH GLHV :LQWHUWKXU ,,
5DUH*RRGYHU\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ 6SLQN 1XPLVPDWLF &LUFXODU &9, QR
6HSWHPEHU
$QRWKHU%UDFK\OOLGHVLVNQRZQIURP7DEDL.DOOLNUDWHVVRQRI%UDFK\OOLGHV
ZKR ZDV D PDJLVWUDWH XQGHU $XJXVWXV 53& , S $OWKRXJK LW LV
DOPRVWVXUHWKDWWKRVHWZRDUHUHODWHGWKH%UDFK\OOLGHVIDWKHURI.DOOLNUDWHV
ZDV SUREDEO\ WKH JUDQGVRQ RI WKH %UDFK\OOLGHV ZKR ZDV WKH IDWKHU RI
6HOHXNRVDQGQRWWKHVDPHSHUVRQ,WZDVLVFRPPRQIRUWKH*UHHNVWREH
JLYHQ WKHLU JUDQGIDWKHU
V QDPH DV WKHLU ILUVW QDPH DQG WKHLU IDWKHU
V DV D
VXUQDPH
,VODQGVRII&DULD
187
2:1

5KRGRV/LQGRV&LUFD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJ
/LRQ¶V KHDG ZLWK RSHQ MDZV WR ULJKW EHORZ RUQDPHQWDO EDQG 5HY
,UUHJXODUUHFWDQJXODULQFXVHGLYLGHGLQWRWZRHTXDOFRPSDUWPHQWVE\
DUDLVHGEDQGRIWKUHHOLQHV&DKQJURXS(YDUZLWKDUDLVHGEDQG
RQ WKH UHYHUVH +XQWHULDQ YDU DQG 61* YRQ $XORFN
YDU ERWK ZLWK D VLQJOH EDQG RQ WKH UHYHUVH $ EROG WRQHG DQG
DWWUDFWLYHH[DPSOH$SSDUHQWO\XQLTXHZLWKWKLVUHYHUVH*RRGYHU\
ILQH
)URP D (XURSHDQ FROOHFWLRQ DQG IURP DQ $PHULFDQ FROOHFWLRQ 1RPRV
2FWREHUH[7ULWRQ;9-DQXDU\
.LQJVRI/\GLD
188

$O\DWWHV,,FLUFD%&7ULWH(OHFWUXPPPJ
3:1 6DUGHV F $@ȁȊǹ LQ /\GLDQ 2QWKHOHIWOLRQ
VKHDGWRULJKW
ZLWKRSHQMDZVFRQIURQWLQJRQWKHULJKWDVLPLODUOLRQ
VKHDGWROHIW
DOVR ZLWK RSHQ MDZV SXQFWDWHEDFNJURXQG5HY7ZRVTXDUHLQFXVH
SXQFKHV$SSDUHQWO\XQSXEOLVKHGVDYHIRULWVDSSHDUDQFHDWDXFWLRQ
VHH 5RPD ,,, ([WUHPHO\ UDUH RQH RI OHVV WKDQ KDOI D
GR]HQNQRZQH[DPSOHV1LFHO\FHQWHUHGDQGZHOOVWUXFN([WUHPHO\
ILQH
189

$O\DWWHV ,, FLUFD %& 7ULWH (OHFWUXP PP J
3:1 6DUGHV)ǹȁ)ǼȉUHWURJUDGH2QWKHOHIWOLRQ
VKHDGWRULJKWZLWK
RSHQMDZVFRQIURQWLQJRQWKHULJKWDVLPLODUOLRQ
VKHDGWROHIWDOVR
ZLWK RSHQ MDZV SODLQ EDFNJURXQG 5HY 7ZR LUUHJXODU LQFXVH
SXQFKHV :HLGDXHU *URXS ;9,, VDPH GLHV :HOOFHQWHUHG
FOHDUDQGZLWKDIXOOOHJHQGUDUHWKXV([WUHPHO\ILQH
190

4:1 $O\DWWHV,,FLUFD%&6WDWHU(OHFWUXPPPJ
6DUGHV/LRQ¶VSDZ5HY,UUHJXODULQFXVHVTXDUH.DUZLHVH6HULHV,
*URXS DVFULEHG WR (SKHVRV $Q DWWUDFWLYH SLHFH YLUWXDOO\ DV
IRXQG*RRGYHU\ILQH
)URPDQ$PHULFDQFROOHFWLRQ
3:1
191

.URLVRVFLUFD%&+HDY\6WDWHU*ROG[PPJ
6DUGHV 2Q WKH OHIW IRUHSDUW RI D OLRQ WR ULJKW FRQIURQWLQJ RQ WKH
ULJKW WKH IRUHSDUW RI D EXOO WR OHIW 5HY 7ZR LQFXVH VTXDUHV RI
XQHTXDO VL]H VLGH E\ VLGH %0)$ 61* %HUU\ 61*
&RSHQKDJHQ 61* 0XQLFK $ ORYHO\ VKDUS DQG SRZHUIXO
SLHFH YHU\ ZHOO VWUXFN DQG FDUHIXOO\ FHQWHUHG *RRG H[WUHPHO\
ILQH
3:1
192

.URLVRVFLUFD%&+HDY\6WDWHU6LOYHU[PPJ
6DUGHV 2Q WKH OHIW IRUHSDUW RI D OLRQ WR ULJKW FRQIURQWLQJ RQ WKH
ULJKW WKH IRUHSDUW RI D EXOO WR OHIW 5HY 7ZR LQFXVH VTXDUHV RI
XQHTXDOVL]HVLGHE\VLGH$&*&61*YRQ$XORFN7UDLWp,
SO;$WWUDFWLYHZHOOVWUXFNEROGDQGQLFHO\WRQHG1HDUO\
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPD(XURSHDQFROOHFWLRQDQGWKDWRI50DO\/+6$SULO
H[6WHUQEHUJ;,,1RYHPEHU
/\GLD
193

+\UFDQLV7LPHRI&RPPRGXVWR&DUDFDOOD+HPLDVVDULRQ
2:1 %URQ]HPPJKȂǹȀ(ǻȅȃȍ,Y\ZUHDWKHGPDVNRI
6LOHQXV WR ULJKW 5HY <ȇȀǹȃȍȃ <RXWKIXO QXGH VDW\U GDQFLQJ WR
ULJKWUDLVLQJKLVULJKWDUPDQGKROGLQJSHGXPZLWKKLVOHIW%0&
,PKRRI%OXPHU0*53&2QOLQH,9WHPSRUDU\QXPEHU
9HU\UDUH$EHDXWLIXOSLHFHVKDUSO\VWUXFNSHUIHFWO\FHQWHUHGDQG
ZLWKDGDUNEODFNLVKJUHHQSDWLQD([WUHPHO\ILQH
LOOXVWUDWHGRQWKHIURQWFRYHU
194

3KLODGHOSKLD &LUFD QGUG FHQWXU\ $' +HPLDVVDULRQ %URQ]H
PPJK+HDGRIWKH\RXWKIXO'LRQ\VRVWRULJKWZHDULQJ
DQ LY\ ZUHDWK DQG ZLWK KLV KDLU ORQJ DQG IORZLQJ GRZQ WR KLV
2:1 VKRXOGHUV 5HY ĭǿȁǹǻ Ǽȁ ĭǼȍȃ 3DQWKHU SURZOLQJ WR ULJKW
$SSDUHQWO\ XQSXEOLVKHG VDYH IRU LWV DXFWLRQ DSSHDUDQFH ([WUHPHO\
UDUH'DUNEURZQSDWLQD([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[/DQ]0D\
195
2:1
6DUGHV&LUFD%&'UDFKP6LOYHUPPJK
+HDGRI\RXWKIXO'LRQ\VRVWRULJKWZHDULQJLY\ZUHDWK5HYȈ$3
/DUJHEXQFKRIJUDSHVDERYHVPDOOFRUQXFRSLDEHORZPRQRJUDP
RI ī DQG $ " WKH ZKROH ZLWKLQ LY\ ZUHDWK %0& 61*
&RSHQKDJHQ 61* YRQ $XORFN $SSDUHQWO\ XQSXEOLVKHG
([WUHPHO\UDUHSHUKDSVWKHVHFRQGDQGEHVWH[DPSOHNQRZQ6RPH
WUDFHVRIFRUURVLRQRWKHUZLVHDERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
3KU\JLD
196

$SDPHLD&LUFD%&%URQ]HPPJK$QWLSKRQ
VRQRI0HQHNOHV%XVWRI$WKHQDWRULJKWZHDULQJFUHVWHG&RULQWKLDQ
KHOPHW DQG DHJLV 5HY $ȆǹȂǼȍ1 ǹȃȉǿĭȍȃ _ ȂǼȃǼȀȁǼȅȊȈ
(DJOH ZLWK VSUHDG ZLQJV IO\LQJ ULJKW DQG ODQGLQJ RQ D PDHDQGHU
SDWWHUQIODQNHGE\WKHFDSVRIWKHGLRVFXULHDFKVXUPRXQWHGE\DVWDU
RIHLJKWUD\VDERYHDVWDURIHLJKWUD\V%0&61*&RSHQKDJHQ
$Q RXWVWDQGLQJ H[DPSOH 6KDUSO\ VWUXFN RI H[FHOOHQW VW\OH DQG 2:1
ZLWKDQDWWUDFWLYHGDUNSDWLQD([WUHPHO\ILQH
([6ROLGXV0D\
&LOLFLD
197

.HOHQGHULV&LUFD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJK
1XGH ULGHU KROGLQJ ZKLS LQ KLV OHIW KDQG MXPSLQJ IURP KRUVH
JDOORSLQJ WR OHIW SHUIRUPLQJ WKH NDOSp D KRUVH UDFH LQ ZKLFK WKH
ULGHUMXPSVIURPKLVKRUVHDQGUXQVEHVLGHLWEHORZKRUVHǻ5HY 2:1
ȀǼȁǼȃ*RDWNQHHOLQJWROHIWKHDGWXUQHGEDFNWRULJKWDERYHLY\
EUDQFK&DVDERQQHW\SH&0.UDD\7KH&HOHQGHULV+RDUG1&
E WKLV FRLQ 61* 3DULV 61* YRQ $XORFN WKLV
FRLQ7RQHGDQGPRVWDWWUDFWLYH([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[/HX0D\DQGIURPWKH
FROOHFWLRQRI+6YRQ$XORFN
198
3:1
0DOORV&LUFD%&2ERO6LOYHUPPJK+HDG
RI EHDUGHG 6LOHQRV IDFLQJ 5HY 6ZDQ ZDONLQJ WR OHIW DOO ZLWKLQ
LQFXVH VTXDUH 61* )UDQFH 61* /HYDQWH 9HU\ UDUH WRQHG
DQG ZLWK D UHPDUNDEOH KHDG RI 6LOHQRV 6RPH VXUIDFH URXJKQHVV DV
IRXQG*RRGYHU\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[%DOGZLQ
V2FWREHUDQG
0Q]HQXQG0HGDLOOHQ-XQH
,W LV ZRUWK SRLQWLQJ RXW WKDW WKH LOOXVWUDWLRQ LQ %DOGZLQ LV UHPDUNDEO\
DZIXO &RPSDUHG WR WKH RQH KHUH DQG WKH RQH LQ 0 0 EDFN LQ LW
VHHPVWREHIURPDQRWKHUSODQHW
199

1DJLGRV&LUFD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJK
$SKURGLWH VHDWHG OHIW RQ WKURQH KROGLQJ SKLDOH LQ KHU RXWVWUHWFKHG
ULJKWKDQGDQGUHVWLQJKHUOHIWHOERZRQWKHWKURQHEDFNWROHIWDOWDU
WRULJKW(URVVWDQGLQJOHIWFURZQLQJ$SKURGLWHZLWKDZUHDWKKHOGLQ
KLV ULJKW KDQG 5HY ȃǹīǿǻǼȍȃ 'LRQ\VRV VWDQGLQJ OHIW KROGLQJ
EXQFKRIJUDSHVLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGWK\UVRVZLWKKLVOHIWLQILHOGDW
XSSHU OHIW ǹ ZLWKLQ FLUFOH DW ILHOG RQ ORZHU OHIW ȃ UHWURJUDGH
%0&&DVDERQQHW\SH/HGHUHU%ULJKWDQGOXVWURXV6RPH
WUDFHV RI GLH UXVW DQG VRPH XQFOHDQHG GHSRVLWV RWKHUZLVH JRRG
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[(GJDU2ZHQ0%61RYHPEHU
200

6RORL&LUFD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJK+HDG
RI $WKHQD WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ D FUHVWHG $WWLF KHOPHW ZLWK D JULIILQ
UXVKLQJ ULJKW RQ WKH ERZO DQG D SDOPHWWH RQ WKH QHFN JXDUG DQG D
QHFNODFH RI SHDUOV 5HY Ȉȅȁ ǿȀȅ %XQFK RI JUDSHV RQ VWHP DOO
ZLWKLQWULDQJXODULQFXVHVTXDUH61*YRQ$XORFNYDU7RQHG
2:1 ZHOOVWUXFNDQGEROG1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[%.ULWW)3/-DQXDU\
201

6RORL&LUFD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJK+HDG
RI $WKHQD WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ D FUHVWHG $WWLF KHOPHW DGRUQHG ZLWK D
JULIILQ RQ WKH ERZO DQG D SDOPHWWH RQ WKH QHFNSLHFH DQG D SHDUO
QHFNODFH 5HY Ȉȅȁ,.21 %XQFK RI JUDSHV RQ VWHP SODFHG
GLDJRQDOO\EHWZHHQ7,DOOZLWKLQDOR]HQJHVKDSHGLQFXVHVTXDUH
2:1 RXWVLGH WKH LQFXVH LQVFULSWLRQ %0& &DVDERQQH W\SH 61*
/HYDQWH YDU 61* 3DULV YDU &OHDU ZHOOVWUXFN DQG QLFHO\
WRQHG1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQDQGIURPDQROG*HUPDQFROOHFWLRQ/HX
2FWREHUH[.ULFKHOGRUI;,9-XO\
202

6RORL &LUFD %& 6WDWHU 6LOYHU PP J K
+HDG RI $WKHQD WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ D FUHVWHG $WWLF KHOPHW DGRUQHG
ZLWK D JULIILQ RQ WKH ERZO DQG D SDOPHWWH RQ WKH QHFNSLHFH DQG D
SHDUO QHFNODFH 5HY Ȉȅȁ %XQFK RI JUDSHV ZLWK VWHP DQG WZR
WHQGULOV SODFHG GLDJRQDOO\ ZLWKLQ D OR]HQJHVKDSHG LQFXVH VTXDUH
&DVDERQQHW\SH&I61*)UDQFHDQG61*YRQ$XORFN 2:1
%ROGO\VWUXFNDQGZLWKDQDWWUDFWLYHJORVV\GDUNSDWLQD([WUHPHO\
ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ *RUQ\ 0RVFK 2FWREHU

203
3:1

6RORL &LUFD %& +HPLRERO 6LOYHU PP J K
+HOPHWHG KHDG RI $WKHQD WR ULJKW 5HY Ȉȅ *UDSH FOXVWHU 61*
/HYDQWHWKLVFRLQ1LFHO\WRQHG([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[7ULWRQ9,,-DQXDU\DQG
IURPWKHFROOHFWLRQRI(/HYDQWH
204

6RORL&LUFD%&+HPLRERO6LOYHUPPJK
+HDGRI$WKHQDWRULJKWZHDULQJPRGLILHG$WWLFKHOPHWZLWKWHQGULO 3:1
RQ WKH ERZO 5HY %XQFK RI JUDSHV ZLWKLQ OLQHDU FLUFOH DOO ZLWKLQ
VKDOORZ FLUFXODU LQFXVH %0& 9HU\ UDUH $Q DWWUDFWLYH FRLQ
SHUIHFWO\ FHQWHUHG 6OLJKWO\ URXJK VXUIDFHV RWKHUZLVH H[WUHPHO\
ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQERXJKWSULYDWHO\IURP/HXLQ0DUFK
7KLVFRLQDFWXDOO\LVPRVWSUREDEO\IURP6RORLEXWLWLVXQIRUWXQDWHWKDWLWV
RULJLQDO VWRFN WLFNHW YHU\ SUREDEO\ ZULWWHQ E\ 6LOYLD +XUWHU QR ORQJHU
H[LVWV,WZRXOGEHWRNQRZLILWKDGDSURYHQDQFHDIWHUDOO6+KDGDKDELW
RIILQGLQJH[WUDRUGLQDU\LWHPVLQROGWUD\V
205

6RORL%DODNURVVDWUDSRI&LOLFLD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPP
J K %DDOWDUV VHDWHG OHIW RQ EDFNOHVV WKURQH KROGLQJ
ORWXVWLSSHGVFHSWUHLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGUHVWLQJKLVOHIWRQKLVZDLVW
LQILHOGWROHIWJUDLQHDUDQGEXQFKRIJUDSHVDERYHȈEHORZWKURQH
PRQRJUDP RI Ǻȉ LQ ILHOG WR ULJKW Ǻ RYHU Ƞ 5HY 'UDSHG EXVW RI
$WKHQD 3DUWKHQRV IDFLQJ WXUQHG VOLJKWO\ WR OHIW ZHDULQJ WULSOH
FUHVWHGKHOPHWHDUULQJVDQGSHDUOQHFNODFH61*/HYDQWH 61*
/RFNHWW 61* YRQ $XORFN WKLV FRLQ 1LFHO\ WRQHG
*RRGYHU\ILQH
2:1 )URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ 7ULWRQ 9,, -DQXDU\ DQG
IURP WKH FROOHFWLRQV RI ( /HYDQWH + 6 YRQ $XORFN 5 & /RFNHWW ;,,
*OHQGLQLQJ
V )HEUXDU\ DQG 6 3R]]L 1DYLOOH , 0DUFK

206

7DUVRV7DUNXPXZD'DWDPHVVDWUDSRI&LOLFLDDQG&DSSDGRFLD
%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPPJKVWUXFNFLUFD
%
/75=%DDOWDUVVHDWHGWRULJKWRQEDFNOHVVWKURQHKROGLQJEXQFKRI
JUDSHV DQG JUDLQ HDU LQ KLV OHIW KDQG DQG HDJOHWLSSHG VFHSWHU LQ KLV
ULJKWLQILHOGWRULJKWWK\PLDWHULRQXQGHUWKURQHIRUHSDUWRIDEXOOWR
2:1 ULJKW5HY75'0:7DUNXPXZDVHDWHGWRULJKWLQIXOO3HUVLDQJDUE
PHDVXULQJDUURZKHOGLQKLVOHIWKDQGRQWKHORZHUULJKWERZLQILHOG
LQXSSHUULJKWZLQJHGVRODUGLVN&DVDERQQHW\SH61*)UDQFH
9HU\DWWUDFWLYHO\WRQHG([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[:HLO)3/$XJXVW
207

7DUVRV0D]DLRVVDWUDSRI&LOLFLD%&6WDWHU6LOYHUPP
J K %¶/75= %DDOWDUV VHDWHG OHIW RQ EDFNOHVV WKURQH KLV
ERG\WXUQHGWRIURQWKROGLQJDQHDJOHDJUDLQHDUDQGDYLQHEUDQFK
ZLWKDEXQFKRIJUDSHVLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGORQJVFHSWHULQKLVOHIW
WROHIW71EHORZWKURQH05HY0='</LRQDWWDFNLQJEXOOWROHIW
EHORZ PRQRJUDP RU V\PERO &DVDERQQH 6HULHV *URXS & 61*
2:1
/HYDQWH6KDUSWRQHGZHOOFHQWHUHGDQGSDUWLFXODUO\QLFH*RRG
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH*HUPDQ53*&ROOHFWLRQIRUPHGLQWKHV
208

7DUVRV 0D]DLRV VDWUDS RI &LOLFLD %& 6WDWHU 6LOYHU
PP J K %¶/75= %DDOWDUV VHDWHG OHIW RQ EDFNOHVV
WKURQHKLVERG\WXUQHGWRIURQWKROGLQJDQHDJOHDJUDLQHDUDQGD
YLQH EUDQFK ZLWK D EXQFK RI JUDSHV LQ KLV ULJKW KDQG DQG ORQJ
VFHSWHU LQ KLV OHIW WR OHIW 71 EHORZ WKURQH 0 5HY 0='< /LRQ
DWWDFNLQJEXOOWROHIWEHORZPRQRJUDPRUV\PERO&DVDERQQH6HULHV
*URXS & 61* /HYDQWH :HOOVWUXFN DQG EULJKW 0LQRU PDUNV
RWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH 2:1
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ +XVWRQ )3/ -DQXDU\)HEUXDU\

.LQJVRI&DSSDGRFLD
209

$ULDUDWKHV,9FLUFD%&'UDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K 'UDSHG EXVW RI $ULDUDWKHV ,9 WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ KLJK EDVKO\N
RUQDPHQWHGZLWKDVWDUDQGDWRUFDURXQGKLVQHFN5HYǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈ
2:1
_ ǹȇǿǹȇǹĬȅȊ $WKHQD VWDQGLQJ OHIW ZHDULQJ KHOPHW DQG FKLWRQ
KROGLQJ1LNHVWDQGLQJOHIWRQKHUULJKWKDQGUHVWLQJKHUOHIWKDQGRQ
D VKLHOG E\ KHU VLGH DQG ZLWK D WUDQVYHUVH VSHDU EHKLQG KHU &I
6LPRQHWWD $ULDUDWKHV 9, S EXW ODFNLQJ D PRQRJUDP
$SSDUHQWO\ XQLTXH DQG XQSXEOLVKHG VDYH IRU LWV SUHYLRXV DXFWLRQ
DSSHDUDQFH 7RQHG DQG ZLWK DQ H[WUDRUGLQDULO\ ILQH DQG SRZHUIXO
\RXWKIXO SRUWUDLW 6OLJKW URXJKQHVV DQG D IHZ PLQRU PDUNV
([ 7NDOHF )HEUXDU\ DQG IURP D VSHFLDOL]HG FROOHFWLRQ RI
SRUWUDLWFRLQVIRUPHGLQWKHVV
.LQJVRI&RPPDJHQH
210

$QWLRFKRV , 7KHRV FLUFD %& 'LFKDONRQ %URQ]H PP
JK'UDSHGEXVWRI$QWLRFKRV,WRULJKWZHDULQJKLJKWLDUD
ZLWKILYHSLQQDFOHVRQWKHWRSHDUIODSVDQGZLWKLWVVLGHRUQDPHQWHG
ZLWKDVWDUEHWZHHQWZRHDJOHVWKHLUKHDGVUHYHUWHGWRORRNDWHDFK
RWKHU 5HY ǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈ ǹȃȉǿȅȋȅȊ /LRQ RI &RPPDJHQH ZDONLQJ
VWLIIO\ WRULJKWKLVKHDGVOLJKWO\ORZHUHG%HGRXNLDQ&$$
1HUFHVVLDQ 5DUH $ VKDUS DQG ZHOOVWUXFN SLHFH RI XQXVXDOO\ 2:1
ILQHTXDOLW\([WUHPHO\ILQH
([5RPDH6DOH0D\
&\SUXV
211

8QFHUWDLQ PLQW &LUFD %& 6WDWHU 6LOYHU PP
2:1 J K /DQG WRUWRLVH 5HY :LOG JRDW VWDQGLQJ OHIWZLWKWDOO
FXUYHG KRUQ DQG D ORQJ EHDUG DERYH WR ULJKW DQNK DOO ZLWKLQ D
VKDOORZ LQFXVH VTXDUH ZLWK D GRWWHG ERUGHU 8QSXEOLVKHG DQG
XQNQRZQ VDYH IRU DQ LQIHULRU SLHFH WKDW DSSHDUHG DV ORW LQ
1XPLVPDWLFD$UV&ODVVLFD:HOOVWUXFNDQGWRQHG:LWKD
GLH EUHDN RQ WKH REYHUVH DQG VRPH URXJK DUHDV RWKHUZLVH YHU\
ILQH
,Q D %ULWLVK FROOHFWLRQ SULRU WR DQG SUREDEO\ DFTXLUHG DURXQG WKH
WLPHWKH1$&H[DPSOHZDVSXUFKDVHG'HFHPEHU
7KH 1$& FDWDORJXHU DVVRFLDWHG WKH WRUWRLVH RQ WKLV FRLQ ZLWK $SKURGLWH
2XUDQLDDJRGGHVVPXFKZRUVKLSSHGLQ&\SUXVZKRZDVIRQGRIWRUWRLVHV
WKRXJKLWLVXQOLNHO\WKDWWKHWRUWRLVHKHUHUHDOO\LVDV\PERORI$SKURGLWH
7KH JRDW DQG WKH DQNK UDWKHU SRLQW WR 6DODPLV RU SHUKDSV D QHDUE\ PLQW
XQGHU6DODPLQLDQLQIOXHQFH
6HOHXNLG.LQJV
212
2:1
6HOHXNRV,1LNDWRU%&+HPLGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K6HOHXNHLD,,PLQWDIWHUF%&/DXUHDWHKHDGRI=HXV
WR ULJKW 5HY ǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈ ȈǼȁǼȊȀȅȊ $WKHQD KXUOLQJ VSHDU ZLWK
KHUULJKWKDQGDQGKROGLQJVKLHOGZLWKKHUOHIWVWDQGLQJULJKWLQELJD
RI HOHSKDQWV PRYLQJ WR ULJKW DERYH WR ULJKW DQFKRU $% DQG Ĭ
PRQRJUDPVEHKLQGDQGEHIRUH$WKHQD(606&D5DUH$Q
HVSHFLDOO\ ILQH DQG DWWUDFWLYH SLHFH WRQHG DQG ZHOOVWUXFN 8Q
FOHDQHGDVIRXQGRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPD6ZLVVFROOHFWLRQDFTXLUHGSULRUWR
2:1
213

$QWLRFKRV,6RWHU%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K 6HOHXNHLDRQWKH7LJULV F 'LDGHPHG KHDG RI
$QWLRFKRV , WR ULJKW 5HY ǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈ ǹȃȉǿȅȋȅȊ $SROOR VHDWHG
OHIWRQRPSKDORVKROGLQJDUURZLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGUHVWLQJKLVOHIW
RQ D ERZ WR RXWHU OHIW DQG ULJKW PRQRJUDPV RI $3 DQG +3(60
+*& J 6& D $Q H[FHSWLRQDOO\ ILQH SLHFH
EHDXWLIXOO\WRQHGVWUXFNLQKLJKUHOLHIIURPQHZGLHVRQHRIWKHYHU\
ILQHVWH[DPSOHVRIWKLVW\SHNQRZQ6RPHPLQRUXQFOHDQHGGHSRVLWV
RWKHUZLVHJRRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPD(XURSHDQFROOHFWLRQDFTXLUHGSULRUWR
214 214
1,5:1

6HOHXNRV ,, .DOOLQLNRV %& 7ULFKDONRQ %URQ]H PP
JK6DUGHVF+HOPHWHGKHDGRI$WKHQDWRULJKW
5HY ǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈ ȈǼȁǼȊȀȅȊ $SROOR VWDQGLQJ WR OHIW KROGLQJ
DUURZLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGUHVWLQJKLVOHIWRQDERZE\KLVVLGH6&
:60 $ SOHDVLQJ FRLQ ZLWK DQ DWWUDFWLYH GDUN SDWLQD
$ERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1
215

'HPHWULRV ,, 1LNDWRU ILUVW UHLJQ %& 7HWUDGUDFKP
6LOYHUPPJK0DOORV%&'LDGHPHGKHDG
RI 'HPHWULRV WR ULJKW EHKLQG QHFN 0 5HY %$ȈǿȁǼȍȈ _
ǻǾȂǾȉȇǿȅȊ ĭ,ȁ$ǻ(ȁĭ2< _ 1,.$7232Ȉ &XOW ILJXUH RI
$WKHQD 0DJDUVLD VWDQGLQJ IDFLQJ ZHDULQJ D WULSOHFUHVWHG $WWLF
KHOPHW DQ DHJLV DQG ORQJ UREHV ZLWK KHU KDQGV KHOG RXW IURP KHU
VLGHVZLWKORQJILOOHWVKDQJLQJIURPERWKDQGKROGLQJDVSHDULQKHU
ULJKWRYHUKHUVKRXOGHUVWROHIWDQGULJKWURVHWWHDWKHUIHHWWROHIWDQG
>ULJKW@PRQRJUDP%DEHORQVDPHGLHV&6(,,VDPHGLHV
+*& +RXJKWRQ 0DOORV ± $3 6& ([WUHPHO\
UDUH OLJKWO\ WRQHG DQG RI VXSHUE TXDOLW\ ZLWK D ILQH SRUWUDLW DQG D
IDVFLQDWLQJUHYHUVH1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
([7ULWRQ;,;-DQXDU\DQG/DQ]-XQH
2:1
216

7U\SKRQFLUFD%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
KXQFHUWDLQPLQWSUREDEO\LQQRUWKHUQ6\ULD'LDGHPHGKHDGRI
7U\SKRQ ZLWK IORZLQJ KDLU WR ULJKW 5HY ǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈ ȉȇȊĭȍȃȅȈ
ǹȊȉȅȀȇǹȉȅȇȅȈ2UQDWH0DFHGRQLDQKHOPHWWROHIWZLWKVSLNHRQ
WRSDQGZLWKDZLOGJRDW¶VKRUQRYHUWKHYLVRUWKHZKROHZLWKLQRDN
ZUHDWKERUGHU+*&6&,,VDPHUHYHUVHGLH60$
61* 6SDHU 5DUH DWWUDFWLYH DQG QLFHO\ WRQHG $ IHZ
PLQRUPDUNVRWKHUZLVHJRRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
([ *HPLQL ,; -DQXDU\ IURP WKH $EUDPRZLW] )DPLO\
&ROOHFWLRQ6XSHULRU'HFHPEHUH[+HVV/HX0D\
DQGIURPWKH.KDQHO$EGHKRDUGRI,*&+
217

$QWLRFKRV9,'LRQ\VRV%&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPP
JK7DUVRVF'LDGHPHGKHDGRI$QWLRFKRV9,
WRULJKW5HYǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈǹȃȉǿȅȋȅȊǼȆǿĭǹȃȅȊȈǻǿȅȃȊȈȅȊ
2:1 3\UHRI6DQGDQ6DQGDQVWDQGLQJULJKWRQKRUQHGOLRQEHWZHHQWZR
RPSKDORL DOO RQ D JDUODQGHG DOWDU EHQHDWK D S\UDPLGDO EDOGDFFKLQR
EHORZWZRPRQRJUDPV&I6&VDPHW\SHVEXWWKHPRQRJUDPV
RQ WKH UHYHUVH GLIIHU IURP WKRVH KHUH DQG WKLV SLHFHLVVWUXFNIURPD
GLIIHUHQW REYHUVH GLH ([WUHPHO\ UDUH RQH RI WKUHH NQRZQ H[DPSOHV
RIWKLVW\SHEXWZLWKWKHVHPRQRJUDPVXQLTXH6RPHZKDWURXJKDQG
FRUURGHGVXUIDFHVRWKHUZLVHJRRGYHU\ILQH
)URPD*HUPDQSULYDWHFROOHFWLRQ
7KLVFRLQLVTXLWHH[WUDRUGLQDU\,WLVRQHRIWKUHHNQRZQH[DPSOHVRIWKLV
W\SH IURP 7DUVRV WKH RWKHU WZR ERWK KDYH WZR PRQRJUDPV LQWKHH[HUJXH
RQ WKH UHYHUVH DQG DUH ERWK VWUXFN IURP WKH VDPH SDLU RI GLHV 6&
+RZHYHU WKH SUHVHQW FRLQ LV VWUXFN IURP GLIIHUHQW GLHV DQG KDV GLIIHUHQW
PRQRJUDPVWKXVVKRZLQJWKDWLWFRPHVIURPDVHFRQGLVVXH
218

$QWLRFKRV9,'LRQ\VRV%&+HPLGUDFKP6LOYHUPP
J K $QWLRFK XQGHU WKH PLQLVWHU 6WDPHQHV XQGDWHG EXW F
'LDGHPHGDQGUDGLDWHKHDGRIWKH\RXQJ$QWLRFKRV9,WR
ULJKW 5HY ǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈ ǹȃȉǿȅȋȅȊ Ȉȉǹ ǼȆǿĭǹȃȅȊȈ
2:1 ǻǿȅȃȊȈȅȊ3DQWKHUPRYLQJOHIWKROGLQJEURNHQVSHDULQLWVPRXWK
6& 60$ 61* 6SDHU 9HU\DWWUDFWLYHO\WRQHGDQG
ZLWKVVSOHQGLGSRUWUDLW5HYHUVHVWUXFNIURPDZRUQGLHRWKHUZLVH
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
DQG0Q]HQXQG0HGDLOOHQ)3/
219

$QWLRFKRV9,,,(SLSKDQHV*U\SRV%&7HWUDGUDFKP
6LOYHUPPJK6LGRQ\HDU 'LDGHPHG
KHDGRI$QWLRFKRV9,,,WRULJKWDURXQGILOOHWERUGHU5HYǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈ
ǹȃȉǿȅȋȅȊ ǼȆǿĭǹȃȅȊȈ =HXV 2XUDQLRV VWDQGLQJ OHIW GUDSHG WR
WKHZDLVWKROGLQJVWDULQKLVRXWVWUHWFKHGULJKWKDQGDQGORQJVFHSWHU
ZLWKKLVOHIWLQILHOGWROHIWȈǿǻȍǿǼȇǹȈDERYHPRQRJUDPLQ 2:1
H[HUJXH=}ȇDOOZLWKLQODXUHOZUHDWK&6('&$+*&
J6&%HDXWLIXOO\WRQHGSHUIHFWO\FHQWHUHGDQGZLWKDQ
HVSHFLDOO\ HOHJDQW DQG LGHDOL]HG SRUWUDLW RI $QWLRFKRV 9,,, *RRG
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP D (XURSHDQ FROOHFWLRQ ERXJKW SULYDWHO\ IURP )UHHPDQ 6HDU LQ
DQGIURPWKHFROOHFWLRQRI:% 5(0RQWJRPHU\
6\ULD
2:1
220

6HOHXNLV DQG 3LHULD $SDPHLD VW FHQWXU\ %& %URQ]H PP
J K \HDU %& +HDG RI 'LRQ\VRV WR ULJKW
ZHDULQJ LY\ ZUHDWK 5HY ǹȆǹȂǼȍȃ ȉǾȈ ǿǼȇǹȈ Ȁǹǿ
ǹȈȊȁȅȊ7K\UVRVWROHIWDQGULJKWȋȇWROHIWGDWHǼ}Ȉ53&,
WKLV FRLQFLWHG$QDWWUDFWLYHSLHFHZLWKDGDUNJUHHQEURZQ
SDWLQDZLWKHDUWKHQKLJKOLJKWV9HU\ILQH

0DUFK
.LQJVRI3DUWKLD
221

0LWKUDGDWHV , %& 'UDFKP 6LOYHU PP J K
6HOHXNHLDRQWKH7LJULV F 'LDGHPHG EHDUGHG DQG GUDSHG
EXVW RI 0LWKUDGDWHV WR ULJKW 5HY ǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈ _ ȂǼīǹȁȅȊ
ǹȇȈǹȀȅȊ=HXVVHDWHGOHIWRQEDFNOHVVWKURQHKROGLQJHDJOHLQKLV
2:1 ULJKW KDQG DQG VFHSWHU LQ KLV OHIW LQ H[HUJXH PRQRJUDP RI ȋǹȇ
6HOOZRRG6XQULVH([WUHPHO\UDUH:LWKDVXSHUESRUWUDLWLQ
IXOO\+HOOHQLVWLF*UHHNVW\OH7RQHG$ERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
([7UDGDUW'HFHPEHU
7KLVFRLQLVSDUWRIDVPDOOJURXSRIFRLQVVWUXFNDWZKDWZDVRULJLQDOO\WKH
UR\DO 6HOHXNLG PLQW RI 6HOHXNHLDRQWKH7LJULV 7KH FLW\ ZDV FDSWXUHG E\
WKH 3DUWKLDQV LQ DQG EHFDPH WKHLU ZHVWHUQ FDSLWDO LW VXEVHTXHQWO\
H[SDQGHGVRPXFKWKDWRIDOOWKHFLWLHVLQWKH:HVWRQO\5RPH$OH[DQGULD
DQG$QWLRFKZHUHODUJHU7KHEXVWRQWKLVFRLQLVSUREDEO\WKHILQHVW*UHHN
VW\OH SRUWUDLW HYHU WR DSSHDU RQ D 3DUWKLDQ FRLQ 7KH HQJUDYHU ZDV
XQGRXEWHGO\ D *UHHN ZKR KDG SUHYLRXVO\ ZRUNHG IRU WKH 6HOHXNLGV DQG
ZKHQKHZDVFDOOHGRQWRFXWGLHVIRUWKH3DUWKLDQVKHVKRZHGKLVQHZUXOHU
LQ D FRPSOHWHO\ KHOOHQL]HG ZD\ :KLOH KDYLQJ D EHDUG ZRXOG KDYH EHHQ
XQXVXDO IRU D *UHHN UXOHU DW WKLV WLPH LW ZDV QRW XQKHDUG RI DQG DQ\
FRQWHPSRUDU\ YLHZLQJ WKLV FRLQ PLJKW WKLQN WKH UXOHU SRUWUD\HG ZDV D
SKLORVRSKHU UDWKHU WKDQ VRPHRQH ZKR KDG ULGGHQ RXW RI WKH ,UDQLDQ
KLJKODQGV :KLOH VRPH RI 0LWKUDGDWHV
LPPHGLDWH VXFFHVVRUV DOVR KDG
*UHHNVW\OH SRUWUDLWV PRVW ZHUH VKRZQ LQ D FRPSOHWHO\ IRUHLJQ RULHQWDO
PDQQHU KLJKO\ UHPLQLVFHQW RI WKH KHDGV RI WKH %DE\ORQLDQ DQG 3HUVLDQ
NLQJVWKDWFDPHEHIRUH
%DFWULDRU3DUWKLD
2:1 222

6RSK\WHV RU $QGUDJRUDV FLUFD RU %&
7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJK+HDGRI$WKHQDWRULJKW
ZHDULQJ PRGLILHG $WWLF KHOPHW GLVF HDUULQJ DQG SHDUO QHFNODFH
EHKLQG KHDG PRQRJUDP 5HY ǹĬǼ 2ZO VWDQGLQJ WR ULJKW KHDG
IDFLQJEHKLQGLQILHOGWROHIWJDOOH\SURZULJKWDQGYLQHEUDQFKZLWK
OHDI DQG EXQFK RI JUDSHV 0LWFKLQHU + 1LFROHW3LHUUH 0
$PDQGU\51VDPHGLHV61*$167RQHGFOHDUDQG
ZHOOFHQWHUHG 9HU\ VOLJKWO\ URXJK VXUIDFHV RWKHUZLVH QHDUO\
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[+DXFN $XIKDXVHU0DUFK
DQGIURPDILQGWKDWDSSHDUHGLQ3DULVLQ
1RWRQO\LVWKHUHFRQVLGHUDEOHFRQWURYHUV\RYHUZKRLVVXHGWKHVHFRLQVEXW
WKHUH LV DOVR FRQVLGHUDEOH XQFHUWDLQW\ RYHU ZKHQ DQG ZKHUH WKH\ ZHUH
VWUXFN1LFROHWDQG$PDQGU\DVVXPHGDVGLGHYHU\RQHHOVHWKDWWKHHDVWHUQ
LPLWDWLRQV RI $WKHQV ZHUH DOO SURGXFHG E\ D FHUWDLQ 6RSK\WHV ZKRVLJQHG
VLOYHU LVVXHV LQ WKH YHU\ ODWH WK DQG HDUO\ UG FHQWXULHV +RZHYHU LW KDV
EHHQ PRUH UHFHQWO\ VXJJHVWHG WKDW WKH 6RSK\WHV FRLQDJH WKH DQRQ\PRXV
$WKHQLDQ LPLWDWLRQV DQG WKH FRLQDJH RI DQRWKHU HDVWHUQ SRWHQWDWH
$QGUDJRUDV DOO EH EURXJKW GRZQ WR F RU %& ZLWK WKH
$WKHQLDQ W\SHV EHLQJ PLQWHG LQ WKH 3DUWKLDQ FLW\ RI +HNDWRPS\ORV DQG
WKRVHRI6RSK\WHVDVFULEHGWRDQXQFHUWDLQPLQWLQWKH2[XVDUHD
*UHFR%DNWULDQ.LQJGRP
2:1
223

$QWLPDFKRV,FLUFD%&'UDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K $WWLF VWDQGDUG 3XVKNDODYDWL 'LDGHPHG DQG GUDSHG EXVW RI
$QWLPDFKRV WR ULJKW ZHDULQJ IODW WRSSHG NDXVLD 5HY ǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈ
ĬǼ>ȅȊ@ ǹȃȉǿȂǹȋȅȊ 3RVHLGRQ QXGH WR WKH ZDLVW VWDQGLQJ
IDFLQJKROGLQJORQJWULGHQWLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGILOOHWHGSDOPEUDQFK
LQ KLV OHIW WR ULJKW PRQRJUDP RI ȃȅ %RSHDUDFKFKL 6pULH %
0LWFKLQHU D 61* $16 $WWUDFWLYHO\ WRQHG DQG ZLWK D
VSOHQGLGO\H[SUHVVLYHSRUWUDLW([WUHPHO\ILQH
3ULYDWHO\SXUFKDVHGIURP1*6$LQ-XQHH[7NDOHF)HEUXDU\

-XGDHD
2:1
224

%DU.RFKED5HYROW&(=X]RU'HQDULXV6LOYHUPP
J K XQGDWHG DWWULEXWHG WR \HDU 6LPRQ 3DOHR
+HEUHZ%XQFKRIJUDSHVZLWKEUDQFKDQGWZRWHQGULOV5HY)RUWKH
IUHHGRP RI -HUXVDOHP 3DOHR+HEUHZ (ORQJDWHG O\UH ZLWK WKUHH
VWULQJV+HQGLQ0LOGHQEHUJ256KDUSFOHDUDQG
IUHVK 7UDFHV RI RYHUVWULNLQJ DV XVXDO RWKHUZLVH JRRG H[WUHPHO\
ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ EURXJKW SULYDWHO\ LQ 1HZ <RUN &LW\ LQ
0DUFK
3WROHPDLF.LQJVRI(J\SW
3:1
225 225

3WROHP\,,3KLODGHOSKRVZLWK$UVLQ|H,,%&3HQWLNRQWD
GUDFKPRQ RU +DOI 0QDLHLRQ *ROG PP J K
ǹǻǼȁĭȍȃ -XJDWH EXVWV RI 3WROHP\ ,, GLDGHPHG DQG GUDSHG DQG
$UVLQRH,,GLDGHPHGDQGYHLOHGWRULJKWEHKLQG*DOOLFVKLHOG5HY
ĬǼȍȃ -XJDWH EXVWV RI 3WROHP\ , GLDGHPHG DQG GUDSHG DQG
%HUHQLNH,GLDGHPHGDQGYHLOHGWRULJKWWRORZHUULJKW./RUEHU
2OLYLHU$5 $5ERWKLQHUURUUHIHUULQJWR
WKLV FRLQ6YRURQRVYDU$YHU\UDUHYDULHW\ZHOOFHQWHUHGDQG
ZLWK LQGLYLGXDOLVWLF SRUWUDLWV (GJH EDQJV RWKHUZLVH H[WUHPHO\
ILQH
([ 6LQFRQD 0D\ DQG IURP WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI - DQG
69HONRY9LQFKRQ1RYHPEHUDFTXLUHGLQWKHPLGV
226

3WROHP\ 9 (SLSKDQHV %&7HWUDGUDFKP6LOYHUPP
J K XQFHUWDLQ PLOLWDU\ PLQW LQ 3KRHQLFLD F
'LDGHPHGDQGGUDSHGEXVWRI3WROHP\9WRULJKW5HYǺǹȈǿȁǼȍȈ
ȆȉȅȁǼȂǹǿȅȊ (DJOH ZLWK FORVHG ZLQJV VWDQGLQJ OHIW RQ D
WKXQGHUEROWWROHIW00¡UNKROP9$3WKHVHGLHV6YRURQRV
SO ;/, 9HU\ UDUH :HOO VWUXFN DQG DWWUDFWLYH 6RPH
UHPDLQLQJGHSRVLWVRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
3ULYDWHO\SXUFKDVHGIURP7UDGDUWF
2:1
227

&OHRSDWUD9,,%&'LFKDONRQ%URQ]HPPJK
&KDONLV DG /LEDQRQ UHJQDO \HDUV (J\SW DQG &KDONLV
%& Ǻǹ&ǿȁǿ&&Ǿ& ȀȁǼȅȆǹȉȇǹ& 'LDGHPHG DQG GUDSHG EXVW RI
&OHRSDWUD 9,, WR ULJKW 5HY ǼȉȅȊ& Ȁǹ ȉȅȊ Ȁǹǿ  ĬǼǹ&
ȃǼ:ȉǼȇǹ& $WKHQD DGYDQFLQJ OHIW KROGLQJ VSHDU DQG VKLHOG 53&
$QDWWUDFWLYHSLHFHZLWKJUHHQSDWLQDRYHUODLGE\HDUWKHQHQFUXV
WDWLRQV8QFOHDQHGDVIRXQGRWKHUZLVHQHDUO\DVVWUXFN
)URPWKH*LEUDQ&ROOHFWLRQ
6WUXFN LQ WKH \HDU RI WKH %DWWOH RI $FWLXP ZKHUH &OHRSDWUD
V GUHDP RI 2:1
UXOLQJWKHZRUOGDWWKHVLGHRI$QWRQ\ZDVVKDWWHUHGIRUHYHU
.LQJVRI0DXUHWDQLD
228

-XED,,%&$''HQDULXV6LOYHUPPJK\HDU
ǹȂ 5(;,9%$+HDGRI-XEDWRULJKWZHDULQJWKH
OLRQ
V VNLQ KHDGGUHVV RI +HUFXOHV EHKLQG QHFN FOXE 5HY (7 $0
&RUQXFRSLD ILOOHG ZLWK JUDSHV LQ IURQW RI KRUL]RQWDO ILOOHWHG WULGHQW
WROHIW0D]DUG61*&RSHQKDJHQYDU6SRHUUL%XWFKHU 2:1
WKLV FRLQ $ VSOHQGLG VKDUS EHDXWLIXOO\ WRQHG H[DPSOH
*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[1HZ<RUN6DOH,,'HFHPEHU
DQG &RLQ *DOOHULHV -XO\ DQG IURP WKH FROOHFWLRQ RI WKH
+HUPLWDJH6FKOHVVLQJHU)HEUXDU\
520$1,03(5,$/&2,16
229

2FWDYLDQ 'HQDULXV 6LOYHU PP J K %UXQGLVLXP RU
5RPH %& %DUH KHDG RI 2FWDYLDQ WR ULJKW 5HY $UFK ZLWK
2FWDYLDQVWDQGLQJIDFLQJLQDTXDGULJDRQWKHWRSRQWKHDUFKLWUDYH
2:1 ,03&$(6$5%0&%1&RKHQ5,&ð$SOHDVDQW
H[DPSOH ZLWK DQ LQWHUHVWLQJ UHYHUVH %RWK VLGHV VOLJKWO\ RII FHQWHU
DQGVRPHPLQRUPDUNVRWKHUZLVHDERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
([6WHUQEHUJ,1RYHPEHU
230

7LEHULXV$V&RSSHUPPJKUHVWLWXWLRQLVVXH
VWUXFN XQGHU 7LWXV 5RPH 7, &$(6$5 ',9, $9* )
$9*967,039,,,5HY,037&$(6',9,9(63)$9*5(67
DURXQG ODUJH 6& %0& 7LWXV %1 &RKHQ .RPQLFN
2:1 5,&ð7LWXV:LWKDQDWWUDFWLYHSDWLQDDQGDJRRGSRUWUDLW
6RPH VNLOOIXO DQG ZHOOGRQH VPRRWKLQJ LQ WKH ILHOGV RWKHUZLVH
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
([*HPLQL,9-DQXDU\EXWVPRRWKLQJQRWGHVFULEHG
231

*DLXV &DOLJXOD ZLWK $JULSSLQD 6HQLRU 7HWUDGUDFKP
6LOYHU PP J K $QWLRFK \HDU ī$,2<
.$,Ȉ$32Ȉ Ȉ(%$ ī(30$ /DXUHDWH KHDG RI &DOLJXOD WR ULJKW
5HY >$ī3,ȆȆ(,1@+Ȉ $17,2 0+732 (7 $ 'UDSHG EXVW RI
2:1 $JULSSLQD 6HQLRU WR ULJKW LQ ILHOG WR ULJKW $ DERYH (7 0F$OHH
3ULHXU D 53& 5DUH DQG LQ XQXVXDOO\ JRRG FRQGLWLRQ
IRUWKHVHULHV6WUXFNIURPVOLJKWO\ZRUQGLHVDQGZLWKVRPHGHSRVLWV
DQGGLHEUHDNVRWKHUZLVHJRRGYHU\ILQH
232

$JULSSLQD6HQLRUGLHG6HVWHUWLXV2ULFKDOFXPPPJ
K VWUXFN XQGHU &ODXGLXV 5RPH $*5,33,1$ 0 )
*(50$1,&, &$(6$5,6 'UDSHG EXVW RI $JULSSLQD WKH (OGHU WR
ULJKWKHUKDLUIDOOLQJLQDTXHXHGRZQWKHEDFNRIKHUQHFN5HY7,
&/$9',96 &$(6$5 $9* *(50 3 0 75 3 ,03 3 3 DURXQG
6&%0&%1&RKHQ5,&ð$QDWWUDFWLYHH[DPSOH
ZLWKDJRRGSRUWUDLWRI$JULSSLQDDQGJORVV\GDUNVXUIDFHV+DVEHHQ
H[SHUWO\FOHDQHGRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
1,5:1
233

1HUR'XSRQGLXV2ULFKDOFXPPPJK5RPH
1(52 &/$9' &$(6$5$9* *(53 0 75 3 ,03 3 3
5DGLDWHKHDGRI1HURWRULJKW5HY0$&$9*6&)DoDGHRIWKH
0DFHOOXP 0DJQXP ZLWK PDUN RI YDOXH ,, LQ WKH H[HUJXH %0&
5,&ð:&1:LWKDILQHGDUNJROGHQEURZQSDWLQDDQGDQ
H[FHOOHQWSRUWUDLW6RPHWUDFHVRIFDUHIXOFOHDQLQJRWKHUZLVHQHDUO\
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
1,5:1
234

1HUR $' 6HVWHUWLXV 2ULFKDOFXP PP J K
/XJGXQXP /\RQ 1(52 &/$9' &$(6$5 $9* *(5 3 0
753,0333/DXUHDWHKHDGRI1HURWRULJKWZLWKJOREHDWSRLQWRI
QHFN 5HY 520$ 6 & 5RPD VHDWHG RQ D FXLUDVV WR OHIW KROGLQJ
9LFWRU\LQKHUULJKWKDQGDQGDSDUD]RQLXPZLWKKHUOHIWEHKLQGKHU
WKUHH VKLHOGV %0& %1 &RKHQ 5,&ð :LWK D
ORYHO\ ROLYH JUHHQ SDWLQD DQG D EROG SRUWUDLW 5HYHUVH YHU\ OLJKWO\
GRXEOHVWUXFNRWKHUZLVHJRRGYHU\ILQH
235

1HURZLWK'LYXV&ODXGLXV'LGUDFKP6LOYHUPPJ
K &DHVDUHD F 1(52 &/$9' '>,9, &/$@9' )
&$56$5VLF$9**(50$/DXUHDWHKHDGRI1HURWRULJKW5HY
2:1 ',926 &/$9' 9$*967 VLF *(50$1,& 3$7(5 $9*
/DXUHDWH KHDG RI &ODXGLXV WR ULJKW 5,&ð YDU 53& ,
YDUDQG6\GHQKDP&DHVDUHDYDUWKLVW\SHEXWZLWKWKHVSHOOLQJ
HUURUV XQQRWHG $ FRLQ RI XQXVXDOO\ ILQH TXDOLW\ YHU\ DWWUDFWLYHO\
WRQHGDQGZLWKYHU\JRRGSRUWUDLWV([WUHPHO\ILQH
([7ULWRQ;9-DQXDU\
7KH VSHOOLQJ HUURUV WKDW DSSHDU LQ WKH OHJHQGV RQ ERWK VLGHV RI WKLV FRLQ
VHUYH WR UHPLQG XV WKDW WKH HQJUDYHUV LQ &DHVDUDHD ZHUH SULPDULO\ *UHHNV
VRPHRIZKRPKDGDVKDN\JUDVSRI/DWLQVSHOOLQJ
236
2:1

*DOED $V &RSSHU PP J K 5RPH -XO\
-DQXDU6(569/3,*$/%$,03&$(6$5$9*30753
%DUH KHDG RI *DOED WR ULJKWVHWRQJOREH5HY$(49,7$66&
$HTXLWDV VWDQGLQJ WR ULJKW KROGLQJ VFDOHV ZLWK KHU ORZHUHG ULJKW
KDQG DQG ORQJ VFHSWHU ZLWK KHUOHIW$&*3[LLLVDPHUHYHUVH
GLH5,&ðFIREYHUVHLQVFULSWLRQDQGSRUWUDLWW\SHYDULDWLRQV
([WUHPHO\UDUHZLWKDQDSSDUHQWO\XQSXEOLVKHGREYHUVHGLH7KLVLV
DVSOHQGLGFRLQZLWKXQWRXFKHGVXUIDFHVDVIRXQGDVXSHUEPDWWH
GDUN JUHHQ SDWLQD DQ RXWVWDQGLQJ SRUWUDLW RI *DOED DQG D ILQH DQG
VREHUILJXUHRI$HTXLWDV([WUHPHO\ILQH
([*RUQ\ 0RVFK0DUFK
*LDUGLQ%1,,,KDVVXJJHVWHGWKDWWKLVFRLQZLWKLWVUHPDUNDEO\SRZHUIXO
EDUHKHDGHG PLOLWDU\ SRUWUDLW RI *DOED ZLWK WKH JOREH DW WKH SRLQW RI WKH
EXVW PLJKW SRVVLEO\ EH DWWULEXWDEOH WR WKH PLQW RI /XJGXQXP 7KH ZD\
$HTXLWDV ILUPO\ VWDQGV RQ WKH UHYHUVH PDNHV LW PRUH WKDQ OLNHO\ WKDW LW LV
EDVHGRQDWKHQH[LVWLQJVWDWXHIDPLOLDUWRWKHGLHFXWWHU
237

9HVSDVLDQ $V &RSSHU PP J K /XJGXQXP
/\RQ,03&$(69(63$6,$1$9*&26,,,/DXUHDWHKHDG
RI9HVSDVLDQWRULJKWVHWRQJOREH5HY6&(DJOHVWDQGLQJIDFLQJ
RQJOREHLWVKHDGWRULJKWZLWKKLVZLQJVVSUHDG&I%0&%1
5,&ðVDPHGLHV&RKHQYDU9HU\UDUHYDULHW\$
VSOHQGLGSLHFHZLWKDJORVV\GHHSUHGGLVKEURZQSDWLQDDQGDVWURQJ
2:1
SRUWUDLW([WUHPHO\ILQH
([ *DGRXU\ $XFWLRQ 'HFHPEHU DQG1XPLVPDWLF)LQH
$UWV;,,0DUFK
238

9HVSDVLDQ$XUHXV*ROGPPJK5RPH
,03 &$(6$5 9(63$6,$196 $9* /DXUHDWH KHDG RI 9HVSDVLDQ
WR ULJKW 5HY &26 9,,, 9HVSDVLDQ LQ PLOLWDU\ GUHVV VWDQGLQJ OHIW
KROGLQJVSHDUZLWKKLVULJKWKDQGDQGSDUD]RQLXPLQKLVOHIWEHKLQG
KLPWRULJKW9LFWRU\VWDQGLQJOHIWFURZQLQJKLPZLWKDZUHDWKKHOG
LQ KHU ULJKW KDQG DQG KROGLQJ D SDOP EUDQFK ZLWK KHU OHIW %LDJJL
%0& %1 &DOLFy D VDPH UHYHUVH GLH&RKHQ
5,&ð$QDEVROXWHO\VSOHQGLGWRQHGH[DPSOHZLWKDVXSHUE
SRUWUDLW*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH'H%DNH\&ROOHFWLRQDQGIURPWKDWRIWKH0RQH\0XVHXP=XULFK
7ULWRQ;9,,,-DQXDU\H[/HX0D\
2:1
239

'LYXV9HVSDVLDQGLHG'HQDULXV6LOYHUPPJVWUXFN
XQGHU 7LWXV 5RPH ',996 $9*96796 9(63$6,$196
/DXUHDWH KHDG RI 9HVSDVLDQ WR ULJKW 5HY )RUHSDUWV RI WZR FDSUL
FRUQVEDFNWREDFNVXSSRUWLQJDURXQGVKLHOGLQVFULEHG6&EHORZ
JOREH %0& %1 &RKHQ 5,&ð 7LWXV :HOO
FHQWHUHGZHOOVWUXFNVKDUSDQGQLFHO\WRQHG6RPHVXUIDFHURXJK
QHVVDQGDPLQRUHGJHEDQJRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
240

7LWXV DV &DHVDU 'HQDULXV 6LOYHU PP J K
(SKHVXV,03(5$7257&$(6$5$9*967,)/DXUHDWHKHDG
RI7LWXVWRULJKW5HY$9*(3+(LQWZROLQHVZLWKLQRDNZUHDWK
ZLWK WLHV EHORZ %1 &RKHQ 5,&ð 9HVSDVLDQ 53&
6WUXFN IURP WKH VDPH GLHV DV WKH DXUHXV 5,&ð %0&
DQG 53& 5DUH 9HU\ ZHOO VWUXFN DWWUDFWLYHO\ WRQHG DQG
ZLWKDQLQWHUHVWLQJSRUWUDLWRI7LWXV([WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1
)URPWKHFROOHFWLRQRI$/\QQH[+HOLRV2FWREHU
7KH IDFW WKDW WKLV FRLQ VKDUHV LWV GLHV ZLWK DQ DXUHXV LV SDUWLFXODUO\
LQWHUHVWLQJ LQ 5RPH DXUHXV GLHV VHHP WR LQYDULDEO\ KDYH EHHQ VSHFLDOO\
PDGH VROHO\ IRU VWULNLQJ JROG FRLQV DURXQG WKH PLG UG FHQWXU\ WKLV
FKDQJHGZLWKRIIPHWDOVWULNHVEHLQJNQRZQDQGZLWKJROGFRLQVHVSHFLDOO\
RI*DOOLHQXVEHLQJVWUXFNIURPUHYHUVHGLHVXVHGIRUVLOYHURUELOORQLVVXHV
&OHDUO\WKLVSUDFWLFHZDVQRWIROORZHGLQ5RPDQ(SKHVRV
241

7LWXVDV&DHVDU'XSRQGLXV2ULFKDOFXPPPJ
KVWUXFNXQGHU9HVSDVLDQ5RPH7&$(6$59(63$6,$1
,03 321 75 327 &26 ,, 5DGLDWH KHDG RI 7LWXV WR ULJKW 5HY
520$ 6 & 5RPD VHDWHG WR OHIW RQ D FXLUDVV DQG WZR VKLHOGV
KROGLQJ D ZUHDWK LQ KHU ULJKW KDQG DQG D SDUD]RQLXP ZLWK KHU OHIW
%0&%1&RKHQ5,&ðXQGHU7LWXVVDPHGLHV)URPWKH
VDPHGLHVDV1XPLVPDWLFD$UV&ODVVLFDEXWLQDVOLS
GHVFULEHGDV5,&ð9HU\UDUHQLFHO\FHQWHUHGZHOOVWUXFNDQG
FOHDU ZLWK D ORYHO\ GDUN JUHHQ SDWLQD DQG D EROG SRUWUDLW 1HDUO\
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1
242

7LWXVDV&DHVDU$XUHXV*ROGPPJK5RPH
7 &$(6$5 ,03 9(63 /DXUHDWH KHDG RI 7LWXV WR ULJKW 5HY
3217,) 75 327 )RUWXQD VWDQGLQJ IURQW RQ JDUODQGHG FLSSXV KHU
KHDG WXUQHG WR OHIW KROGLQJ UXGGHU ZLWK KHU ULJKW KDQG DQG
FRUQXFRSLD ZLWK KHU OHIW %0& %1 9HVSDVLDQ &DOLFy
D&RKHQYDU5,&ð9HVSDVLDQ$VKDUSDQGDWWUDFWLYH
SLHFH ZHOOVWUXFN DQG ZLWK D ILQH SRUWUDLW 6RPH WLQ\ WUDFHV RI GLH
UXVWRWKHUZLVHJRRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
([3DUV\3DULV2FWREHU
243

'RPLWLDQ $V &RSSHU PP J K 5RPH
1RYHPEHU'HFHPEHU ,03 &$(6 '20,7 $9* *(50 &26
;,&(163(533/DXUHDWHKHDGRI'RPLWLDQWRULJKWZLWKDHJLVRQ
VKRXOGHU 5HY 021(7$ $9*967, 6& 0RQHWD VWDQGLQJ OHIW
KROGLQJ VFDOHV LQ KHU ULJKW KDQG DQG FRUQXFRSLD LQ KHU OHIW %0&
%1&RKHQ5,&ð$QDWWUDFWLYHSLHFHZLWKDJORVV\
EURZQJUHHQ SDWLQD 6RPH WUDFHV RI FDUHIXO FOHDQLQJ RWKHUZLVH
H[WUHPHO\ILQH 2:1
244

'RPLWLDQ 'XSRQGLXV 2ULFKDOFXP PP J K
5RPH ,03 &$(6'20,7$9**(50&26;9,,&(16
3(5 3 3 5DGLDWH KHDG RI 'RPLWLDQ WR ULJKW 5HY 9,5797,
$9*967, 6 & 9LUWXV VWDQGLQJ ULJKW OHIW IRRW VHW RQ KHOPHW
KROGLQJVSHDUZLWKULJKWKDQGDQGSDUD]RQLXPZLWKOHIW%0&
%1&RKHQ5,&ð$QDWWUDFWLYHFRLQZLWKDILQHSRUWUDLW
DQGDJORVV\GDUNJUHHQSDWLQD([WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1
245

'RPLWLDQ 7ULDVVDULRQ %URQ]H PP J K
,UHQRSROLV1HURQLDV \HDU >ǹȊȉȅȀȇ@ǹȉȍȇ ȀǹǿȈǹȇ
ǻȅȂǿȉǿǹȃȅȈ/DXUHDWHEXVWRI'RPLWLDQWRULJKWZLWKDHJLVDWKLV
QHFN 5HY ǿȇǾȃȅȆȅȁǼǿȉȍȃ Ǽȉȅ ǺȂ 7KH 7\FKH RI ,UHQRSROLV
VHDWHG WR ULJKW RQ URFNV KROGLQJ SRSS\ ZKHDW HDU DQG EXQFK RI
JUDSHV LQ KHU ULJKW KDQG EHIRUH KHU WR ULJKW ULYHU JRG 3\UDPRV
VZLPPLQJWRULJKWIDFLQJRXWZDUGV%0&YDU.DUEDFK61*
9RQ $XORFN 5DUH 'DUN ROLYHEURZQ SDWLQD DQG ZLWK D ILQH
KHDGRI'RPLWLDQ([WUHPHO\ILQH 2:1
246

1HUYD'HQDULXV6LOYHUPPJK5RPH,03
1(59$ &$(6 $9* 3 0 75 3 &26 ,,, 3 3 /DXUHDWH KHDG RI
1HUYD WR ULJKW 5HY )25791$ $9*967 )RUWXQD VWDQGLQJ OHIW
2:1 KROGLQJUXGGHULQKHUULJKWKDQGDQGFRUQXFRSLDZLWKKHUOHIW%0&
&RKHQ5,&%ULJKWOLJKWO\WRQHGDQGZLWKDILQHSRUWUDLW
([WUHPHO\ILQH
([3RQWHULR-DQXDU\
247

1HUYD$V&RSSHUPPJK5RPH,03
2:1 1(59$ &$(6 $9* 3 0 75 3 &26 ,,, 3 3 /DXUHDWH KHDG RI
1HUYD WR ULJKW 5HY )25791$ $9*967 6 & )RUWXQD VWDQGLQJ
OHIWKROGLQJUXGGHULQKHUULJKWKDQGDQGFRUQXFRSLD%0&%1
&RKHQ 5,& :LWK D SRZHUIXO DQG VWHUQ SRUWUDLW DQG D
SOHDVLQJ GDUN JUHHQEURZQ SDWLQD 6RPH YHU\VOLJKWROGVPRRWKLQJ
248
2:1

7UDMDQ $XUHXV *ROG PP J K 5RPH
,03 75$,$12 $9**(5'$&30753&26933/DXUHDWH
EXVWRI7UDMDQWRULJKWZLWKDHJLVRQKLVIDUVKRXOGHU5HY6345
237,02 35,1&,3, LQ WKUHH OLQHV ZLWKLQ DQ RDN ZUHDWK ZLWK WLHV
EHORZ %LDJJL YDU GLIIHULQJ EXVW %1 YDU GLIIHULQJ
EXVW &DOLFy &RKHQ YDU GLIIHULQJ EXVW 5,& YDU
GLIIHULQJ EXVW :R\WHN F RQO\ H[DPSOHV UHFRUGHG 9HU\
UDUH$QHOHJDQWFRLQ$ERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 'H%DNH\ &ROOHFWLRQ H[ 5RPD 6HSWHPEHU DQG
&ODVVLFDO1XPLVPDWLF*URXS0D\
249

7UDMDQ 6HVWHUWLXV 2ULFKDOFXP PP J K
5RPH ,03 &$(6 1(59$( 75$,$12 $9* *(5
'$&30753&269,33/DXUHDWHDQGGUDSHGEXVWRI7UDMDQWR
ULJKW5HY)(/,&,7$6$9*9676&)HOLFLWDVVWDQGLQJWROHIW
KROGLQJ FDGXFHXV LQ KHU ULJKW KDQG DQG FRUQXFRSLD ZLWK KHU OHIW
%0& &RKHQ 5,& :R\WHN Y $ YHU\ DWWUDFWLYH
SLHFH ZHOOVWUXFN DQG ZLWK D ILQH DSSOHJUHHQ SDWLQD 1HDUO\
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
1,5:1
250

7UDMDQ 'HQDULXV 6LOYHU PP J K 5RPH
,03 &$(6 1(5 75$,$12 237,02 $9* *(5 '$&
/DXUHDWHDQGGUDSHGEXVWRI7UDMDQWRULJKW5HY30753&269,
3363450DUVZDONLQJULJKWKROGLQJORQJVSHDULQKLVULJKWKDQG
DQG WURSK\ RYHU KLV OHIW VKRXOGHU %0& %1 &RKHQ
5,&:R\WHNY6KDUSDQGWRQHG'DUNVWDLQLQWKHREYHUVH
ILHOGRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
251
1,5:1
+DGULDQ 6HVWHUWLXV 2ULFKDOFXP PP J K
5RPH ,03 &$(6$5 75$,$196 +$'5,$196 $9*
/DXUHDWHKHDGRI+DGULDQWRULJKWZLWKFKHVWH[SRVHGDQGZLWKVOLJKW
GUDSHU\RQKLVIDUVKRXOGHU5HY32170$;75327&26,,,6
&5RPDVHDWHGOHIWRQFXLUDVVULJKWIRRWRQKHOPHWKROGLQJ9LFWRU\
ZLWK KHU ULJKW KDQG DQG D VSHDU ZLWK KHU OHIW EHKLQG KHU DW WKH
ERWWRPRIKHUVSHDUVKLHOG%0&&RKHQ+LOO5,&
E :LWK D EHDXWIXO JORVV\ DSSOHJUHHQ SDWLQD DQG DQ H[FHOOHQW
SRUWUDLW RI +DGULDQ 0LQRU WUDFHV RI FOHDQLQJ RWKHUZLVH QHDUO\
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
252

+DGULDQ 'HQDULXV 6LOYHU PP J K 5RPH
+$'5,$196 $9*96796 /DXUHDWH EXVW RI +DGULDQ WR
ULJKW ZLWK VOLJKW GUDSHU\ RQ KLV IDU VKRXOGHU 5HY &26 ,,, *HQLXV
2:1 VWDQGLQJOHIWKROGLQJDFRUQXFRSLDZLWKKLVOHIWKDQGDQGVDFULILFLQJ
IURPSDWHUDKHOGLQKLVULJKWRYHUDOLJKWHGDQGILOOHWHGDOWDUWROHIW
%0& &RKHQ 5,& 6KDUS DQG DWWUDFWLYH ([WUHPHO\
ILQH
253

+DGULDQ $XUHXV *ROG PP J K 5RPH
+$'5,$196$9*&26,,,33%DUHKHDGRI+DGULDQWR
ULJKW5HY',6&,3/,1$$9*+DGULDQLQPLOLWDU\GUHVVDGYDQFLQJ
2:1
WRULJKWOHDGLQJWKUHHVLJQLIHUVHDFKZHDULQJDOLRQ
VVNLQKHDGGUHVV
DQG HDFK EHDULQJ D VWDQGDUG &DOLFy D WKLV FRLQ EXW DFWXDOO\
WKHVDPHW\SHDVVLQFH+DGULDQLVQRWYHLOHGDVGHVFULEHGE\
&DOLFy&RKHQ%0&%RXUJH\ 'HVQLHUSJWKLV
FRLQ5,&945YRO,SQWKLVFRLQ9HU\UDUHDQ
LQWULJXLQJUHYHUVHW\SHDQGDQH[FHSWLRQDOSURYHQDQFH6RPHPLQRU
PDUNVRQWKHREYHUVHDQGZLWKPLQRUPDUNVDQGDVSDGHFXWRQWKH
UHYHUVHRWKHUZLVHJRRGYHU\ILQH
)URP WKH 'H%DNH\ &ROOHFWLRQ DQG IURP WKRVH RI * : /D %RUGH
1XPLVPDWLFD $UV &ODVVLFD 0D\ 5 2 (EHUW 6WDFN
V
-DQXDU\ %+DXVPDQ9$GGD,&KULVWLH
V2FWREHU
&6%HPHQW1DYLOOH9,,,-XQHDQG09LGDO4XDGUDV\
5DPRQ%RXUJH\'HFHPEHU
254

+DGULDQ'HQDULXV6LOYHUPPJK5RPH
+$'5,$196$9*&26,,,33%DUHKHDGRI+DGULDQWRULJKW5HY
2:1 6$/96$9*6DOXVVWDQGLQJULJKWKROGLQJSDWHUDLQKHUOHIWKDQGIURP
ZKLFKVKHIHHGVDVQDNHFRLOHGDURXQGDQDOWDURQWKHULJKW%0&
&RKHQ +LOO 5,& 9HU\ VKDUSO\ VWUXFN DQG ZLWK DQ
H[FHOOHQWSRUWUDLWOLJKWO\WRQHG([WUHPHO\ILQH
255

$HOLXV&DHVDU$XUHXV*ROGPPJKVWUXFN
XQGHU +DGULDQ 5RPH / $(/,96 &$(6$5 %DUH KHDG RI
$HOLXV WR ULJKW 5HY 75,% 327 &26 ,, &21&25' &RQFRUGLD
VHDWHGOHIWRQWKURQHZLWKDEDFNKROGLQJSDWHUDLQKHURXWVWUHWFKHG
ULJKW KDQG DQG UHVWLQJ KHU OHIW DUP RQ D FRUQXFRSLD %0&
+DGULDQ&RKHQ&DOLFy5,&D+DGULDQ9HU\UDUH
([WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1
)URPWKH'H%DNH\&ROOHFWLRQH[5RPD6HSWHPEHU
256

1LQLND&ODXGLRSROLV ,PSHULDO 7LPHV 6HFRQG FHQWXU\ $VVDULRQ
%URQ]H PP J K &2/ 0DUV\DV ZDONLQJ WR ULJKW KLV
ULJKW KDQG UDLVHG DQG ZLWK D ZLQHVNLQ RYHU KLV OHIW VKRXOGHU 5HY
1,1,&$7KH5RPDQ:ROIDQG7ZLQVWROHIW61*YRQ$XORFN 2:1
YDU 9HU\ UDUH SRVVLEO\ XQSXEOLVKHG DQG ZLWK DQ DWWUDFWLYH GDUN
JUHHQ SDWLQD 6RPH XQFOHDQHG HDUWKHQ GHSRVLWV RWKHUZLVH DERXW
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ *RUQ\ 0RVFK 0DUFK

257
2:1
$QWRQLQXV 3LXV 'HQDULXV 6LOYHU PP J K
5RPH $1721,196 $9* 3,96 3 3 75 3 ;, /DXUHDWH
KHDG RI $QWRQLQXV 3LXV WR ULJKW 5HY &26 ,,,, 6DOXV VWDQGLQJ OHIW
KROGLQJ UXGGHU VHW RQ JOREH ZLWK KHU OHIW KDQG DQG ZLWK KHU ULJKW
KROGLQJDSDWHUDIURPZKLFKVKHIHHGVDVHUSHQWDULVLQJIURPDQDOWDU
WROHIW%0&&RKHQ5,&([WUHPHO\ILQH
232 230
240
233 235
236 247
237
244
243
251
263
258
252 261
298
271
282
274
293
299
258

$QWRQLQXV3LXV6HVWHUWLXV2ULFKDOFXPPPJ
K 5RPH $1721,196 $9* 3,96 3 3 75 3
/DXUHDWH KHDG RI $QWRQLQXV 3LXV WR ULJKW 5HY &26 ,,,, 6 &
$QWRQLQXV 3LXV KROGLQJ HDJOHWLSSHG VFHSWHU LQ KLV OHIW KDQG DQG
VWUHWFKLQJ KLV ULJKW RXW WR OHIW GULYLQJ VORZ TXDGULJD WR OHIW %DQWL
%0& &RKHQ 5,& D :LWK D ILQH EURZQ SDWLQD
DQG D VSOHQGLG SRUWUDLW 6RPH YHU\ PLQRU VPRRWKLQJ LQ WKH ILHOGV
2:1
259

$QWRQLQXV 3LXV %URQ]H PP J K *D]D
\HDU $<7.$,ǹΔȇ,$12ǹȃȉ:1(,12/DXUHDWH
GUDSHG DQG FXLUDVVHG EXVW RI $QWRQLQXV 3LXV WR ULJKW 5HY ī$=$
Ĭ&7XUUHWHGYHLOHGDQGGUDSHGEXVWRIWKH7\FKHRI*D]DWRULJKW
EHIRUH V\PERO RI 0DUQDV 5RVHQEHUJHU 53& ,9 WHPSRUDU\
6RIDHU$QLPSUHVVLYHSLHFHZLWKDGDUNSDWLQDDQGVDQG\
KLJKOLJKWV9HU\ILQH
2:1
260

$QWRQLQXV 3LXV $XUHXV *ROG PP J K
5RPH$1721,196$9*3,9633753;9,/DXUHDWH
GUDSHGDQGFXLUDVVHGEXVWRI$QWRQLQXV3LXVWRULJKW5HY&26,,,,
$QWRQLQXV3LXVVWDQGLQJOHIWWRJDWHKROGLQJJOREHLQKLVULJKWKDQG
DQG D VFUROO LQ KLV OHIW %0& &DOLFy WKLV FRLQ &RKHQ
2:1 YDU GLIIHULQJ EXVW 5,& G 7RQHG ZHOO VWUXFN DQG VKDUS
*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 'H%DNH\ &ROOHFWLRQ H[ 1XPLVPDWLFD *HQHYHQVLV 6$
1RYHPEHUDQG+HVV/HX$SULO
261

$QWRQLQXV 3LXV 'HQDULXV 6LOYHU PP J K
5RPH " $1721,196 $9* 3,96 3 3 75 3 ;9,,
QXPHUDOXQFHUWDLQ/DXUHDWHKHDGRI$QWRQLQXV3LXVWRULJKW5HY
&26,,,,$QQRQDVWDQGLQJOHIWKROGLQJJUDLQHDUVLQKHUULJKWKDQG
DQGUHVWLQJKHUOHIWRQDPRGLXVVHWRQDORZDOWDUEHKLQGKHUWRULJKW
%0&&RKHQ5,&$SOHDVLQJFRLQZLWKDILQHSRUWUDLW
DQG DQ DWWUDFWLYH WRQLQJ 5DUH ZLWK WKH VOLJKWO\ JDUEOHG OHJHQG
([WUHPHO\ILQH
7KH GDWH RI WKLV FRLQ LV QRW TXLWH FHUWDLQ EHFDXVH WKH GLH FXWWHU VHHPV WR 2:1
KDYH KDG TXLWH VRPH WURXEOH ZLWK WKH OHWWHUV DW WKH HQG RI WKH REYHUVH
LQVFULSWLRQ ,QLWLDOO\ LW ORRNV OLNH LW PLJKW EH HLWKHU 9,, RU 9,,, EXW VLQFH
WKRVHGDWHVDUHXQNQRZQDQGWKHKHDGVHHPVVW\OLVWLFDOO\ODWHULQWKHUHLJQ
UDWKHUWKDQHDUOLHUZHVXJJHVWWKDWLWVKRXOGEH753;9,,
262

'LYD)DXVWLQD6HQLRUGLHG$XUHXV*ROGPPJK
VWUXFN XQGHU $QWRQLQXV 3LXV 5RPH FLUFD ',9$
)$967,1$'UDSHGEXVWRI'LYD)DXVWLQDWRULJKWKHUKDLUDGRUQHG
ZLWKSHDUOVDQGSLOHGXSRQWRSRIKHUKHDG5HY$9*967$&HUHV
VWDQGLQJOHIWKROGLQJWRUFKHVLQKHUXSUDLVHGKDQGV%HFNPDQQGLHV
GI&% E WKLV FRLQ %LDJJL %0& $QWRQLQXV 3LXV 2:1
&DOLFy &RKHQ 5,& D $QWRQLQXV 3LXV 6WUDFN
7RQHG([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH'H%DNH\&ROOHFWLRQH[7ULWRQ;9,,,-DQXDU\DQG
&1* 'HFHPEHUDQGIURPWKHFROOHFWLRQVRI-3LHUSRQW
0RUJDQ 6WDFN
V 6HSWHPEHU DQG WKH 0DUFKHVH &DUOR6WUR]]L
6DQJLRUJL$SULODFTXLUHGSULRUWRWKHV
263

0DUFXV$XUHOLXVDV&DHVDU$V%URQ]HPPJ
K 5RPH $95(/,96 &$(6$5 $9* 3,, ) %DUH KHDG RI
0DUFXV$XUHOLXV&DHVDUWRULJKWZLWKOLJKWGUDSHU\RQKLVIDUVKRXOGHU
5HY&26,,6&DURXQGFRUQXFRSLDZLWKDFXUYHWROHIW%0&
YDU &RKHQ YDU 5,& $QWRQLQXV3LXV$UDUHYDULDQWZLWK 2:1
WKHFRUQXFRSLDWXUQHGWROHIW:LWKDQDWWUDFWLYHUHGGLVKEURZQSDWLQD
DQGDQH[FHOOHQWSRUWUDLW([WUHPHO\ILQH
([*DGRXU\'HFHPEHUDQGDSSDUHQWO\IURPDQXQFHUWDLQO\
LGHQWLILHG)UHQFKVDOHRI)HEUXDU\
264

0DUFXV $XUHOLXV DV &DHVDU 'HQDULXV 6LOYHU PP
J K 5RPH$95(/,96&$(6$5$9*3,,)
%DUHKHDGRI0DUFXVWRULJKWZLWKVKRUWQHDWEHDUG5HY75327
,,,&26,,0LQHUYDVWDQGLQJULJKWKROGLQJLQYHUWHGVSHDULQKHUULJKW
KDQGDQGOHDQLQJRQVKLHOGZLWKKHUOHIW%0&&RKHQ5,&
6KDUS QLFHO\ WRQHG DQG ZLWK DQ HOHJDQW SRUWUDLW ([WUHPHO\
ILQH
2:1
265

0DUFXV $XUHOLXV $XUHXV *ROG PP J K
5RPH 0 $95(/ $1721,196 $9* /DXUHDWH GUDSHG DQG
FXLUDVVHG EXVW RI 0DUFXV $XUHOLXV WR ULJKW 5HY 75 3 ;;;,, ,03
9,,,,&26,,,33$QQRQDVWDQGLQJOHIWKROGLQJWZRFRUQHDUVLQKHU
ULJKWKDQGDQGFRUQXFRSLDZLWKKHUOHIWDWKHUIHHWWROHIWDOWDUKHDSHG
ZLWKIUXLWVWRULJKWJDOOH\VWHUQDGRUQHGZLWKDVZDQ
VKHDG%0&
YDU EXW ZLWK D PRGLXV LQVWHDG RI DQ DOWDU RQ WKH UHYHUVH &DOLFy
YDU EXW ZLWK D PRGLXV LQVWHDG RI DQ DOWDU RQ WKH UHYHUVH
&RKHQ5,&YDUEXWZLWKDPRGLXVLQVWHDGRIDQDOWDURQWKH
UHYHUVHVDPHGLHVDVWKHRQO\RWKHUDYDLODEOHH[DPSOH1*6$
1RYHPEHU $Q H[WUHPHO\ UDUH YDULHW\ LQ H[FHSWLRQDO
FRQGLWLRQ7RQHGDQGVKDUS*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1 )URP WKH 'H%DNH\ &ROOHFWLRQ H[ 1XPLVPDWLFD $UV &ODVVLFD 0D\

$QLQWHUHVWLQJIDFWDERXWWKLVFRLQFRQFHUQVWKHVKLSRQWKHUHYHUVHDOPRVWDOO
FDWDORJXHUV FDOO LW D VKLS
V SURZ EXW DV FDQ EH VHHQ KHUH WKHUH LV D FXUYHG
IHDWXUHRQWRSRIWKHVKLS
VGHFN7KLVLVLQIDFWDVZDQ
VKHDGZKLFKZDVWKH
W\SLFDO RUQDPHQW RI WKH VWHUQ RI D 5RPDQ PHUFKDQW VKLS 2I FRXUVH D
PHUFKDQW YHVVHO LQ WKLV FDVH VXUHO\ RQH RI WKH JUDLQ VKLSV IURP $OH[DQGULD
ZDVSDUWLFXODUO\DSSURSULDWHIRU$QQRQDWKHJRGGHVVRIWKHJUDLQGROH
266

)DXVWLQD-XQLRU$XJXVWD$V&RSSHUPPJ
K VWUXFN XQGHU $QWRQLQXV 3LXV 5RPH )$967,1$
$9*3,,$9*),/'UDSHGEXVWRI)DXVWLQD,,WRULJKWKHUKDLUWLHG
LQDEXQDWWKHEDFNRIKHUKHDG5HY/$(7,7,$(39%/,&$(6&
2:1 /DHWLWLDVWDQGLQJOHIWKROGLQJDZUHDWKLQKHUULJKWKDQGDQGDORQJ
VFHSWHUZLWKKHUOHIW%0&&RKHQ5,&E$WWUDFWLYH
GDUNJUHHQSDWLQD6RPHWUDFHVRIFDUHIXOFOHDQLQJ$ERXWH[WUHPHO\
ILQH
3:1
267 267

/XFLXV9HUXV$XUHXV*ROGPPJK5RPH
/9(596$9*$50(1,$&96%DUHKHDGRI/XFLXV9HUXV
WRULJKW5HY753,,,,,03,,&26,,5(;$50(1'$7/XFLXV
9HUXV VHDWHG OHIW RQ SODWIRUP EHWZHHQ DQ RIILFHU RQ KLV ULJKW DQG D
VROGLHU RQ KLV OHIW EHIRUH KLP RQ WKH JURXQG EHORZ $UPHQLDQ NLQJ
6RKDHPXV VWDQGLQJ OHIW UDLVLQJ KLV ULJKW KDQG WR DFFHSW WKH FURZQ
SODFHG RQ KLV KHDG E\ 9HUXV %LDJJL VDPH GLHV %0&
&DOLFy VDPH GLHV &RKHQ 5,& 0DUFXV $XUHOLXV
6KDUSFOHDUDQGZHOOFHQWHUHG*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 'H%DNH\ &ROOHFWLRQ DQG IURP WKH FROOHFWLRQV RI - - *UDQR
1XPLVPDWLFD *HQHYHQVLV 6$ 1RYHPEHU $ %DOO\+HU]RJ
0Q]HQ XQG 0HGDLOOHQ 'HFHPEHU DQG $ %DLQ 6RWKHE\
:LONLQVRQ +RGJH -XO\ DQG IURP WKH $YHQWLQH KRDUG RI

7KLV LVVXH RI /XFLXV 9HUXV LV RI JUHDW KLVWRULFDO LQWHUHVW EHFDXVH LW
FRPPHPRUDWHV WKH UHHVWDEOLVKPHQW RI *DLXV -XOLXV 6RKDHPXV DV NLQJ RI
$UPHQLD6RKDHPXVZDVDPHPEHURIWKHUR\DOIDPLO\RI(PHVDDVZHOODV
EHLQJ D 5RPDQ 6HQDWRU DQG KDG EHHQ PDGH NLQJ RI $UPHQLD LQ +H
ZDVGHSRVHGE\WKH3DUWKLDQVLQEXWZDVWKHQUHVWRUHGWRWKHWKURQHDV
D UHVXOW RI WKH VXFFHVVIXO 5RPDQ FRXQWHU RIIHQVLYH 7KH IDFW WKDW DXUHL RI
WKLVW\SHDUHNQRZQLQVXSHUEFRQGLWLRQLVEHFDXVHRIWKH$YHQWLQH+RDUGRI
IRXQG LQ 5RPH GXULQJ FRQVWUXFWLRQ ZRUN WKLV KRDUG FRQWDLQHG
VHYHUDOKXQGUHGDXUHLRI0DUFXV$XUHOLXVDQG/XFLXV9HUXVPDQ\IUHVKDQG
DV VWUXFN :KLOH D FRQVLGHUDEOH QXPEHU ZHUH UHWDLQHG E\ WKH 9DWLFDQ
PXVHXP DOO RI WKH UHPDLQGHU LQFOXGLQJ PDQ\ H[DPSOHV VWUXFN IURP WKH
VDPHSDLURIGLHVZHUHVROG$VDUHVXOWYLUWXDOO\DOORIWKHFRLQVNQRZQRI
WKLVW\SHGHULYHIURPWKDWILQG
268

/XFLOOD $XJXVWD $XUHXV *ROG PP J K
ZLIH RI /XFLXV 9HUXV DQG VWUXFN GXULQJ WKH MRLQW UHLJQ RI /XFLXV
9HUXVDQG0DUFXV$XUHOLXV5RPH/9&,//$$9*967$
'UDSHG EXVW RI /XFLOOD WRULJKWZLWKKHUKDLUUROOHGLQDEXQDWWKH
EDFN5HY39',&,7,$3XGLFLWLDYHLOHGDQGGUDSHGVWDQGLQJIDFLQJ
WXUQHGVOLJKWO\WROHIWGUDZLQJEDFNKHUYHLOZLWKKHUULJKWKDQGDQG
2:1 UHVWLQJKHUOHIWDWKHUVLGH%LDJJL%0&0DUFXV$XUHOLXV
&DOLFy VDPH GLHV &RKHQ 5,& 0DUFXV $XUHOLXV
*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 'H%DNH\ &ROOHFWLRQ H[ 1XPLVPDWLFD $UV &ODVVLFD 0D\

269

&RPPRGXV'HQDULXV6LOYHUPPJK5RPH
2:1 0 &200 $17 3 )(/ $9* %5,7 3 3 /DXUHDWH KHDG RI
&RPPRGXVWRULJKW5HY0$573$&30753;,,,,&269'(6
9,0DUVVWDQGLQJIDFLQJWXUQHGVOLJKWO\WRWKHOHIWDQGZLWKKLVKHDG
WROHIWQXGHEXWIRUKLVKHOPHWDQGFORDNRYHUKLVVKRXOGHUVKROGLQJ
ROLYHEUDQFKLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGORQJUHYHUVHGVSHDUZLWKKLVOHIW
%0& &RKHQ 5,& $Q XQXVXDOO\ ZHOOVWUXFN DQG
ZHOOSUHVHUYHGH[DPSOHQLFHO\WRQHG*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
5DUHO\FDQGHQDULLRI&RPPRGXVEHIRXQGLQVXFKXQLIRUPO\ILQHFRQGLWLRQ
QRW RQO\ DUH WKH UHYHUVHV HLWKHU OLJKWO\ VWUXFN RU IURP ZRUQ GLHV EXW WKH
REYHUVHVDUHDOVRFRPPRQO\LPSHUIHFWDVZHOO7KLVPXVWKDYHEHHQFDXVHG
E\ FKDQJHV LQ WKH RUJDQL]DWLRQ RI WKH PLQW LQ 5RPH 7KH SUHVHQW H[DPSOH
ZDV FDUHIXOO\ VWUXFN IURP D SDLU RI IUHVK GLHV WKXV PDNLQJ LW D WUXO\ UDUH
FRLQ
270

&RPPRGXV+HPLDVVDULRQ%URQ]HPPJK
3KLOLSSRSROLV ǹȊȉ Ȁǹǿ ȁ $<ȇǾ .202ǻ2& /DXUHDWH DQG
EHDUGHGKHDGRI&RPPRGXVWRULJKW5HYĭǿȁǿȆȆȅȆȅȁǼǿȉȍ1
.DQWKDURV ZLWK D WDOO ERG\DQGKLJKKDQGOHV%0&0RXFKPRY
2:1 53&,9RQOLQH9DUEDQRYVDPHGLHV$QDWWUDFWLYH
H[DPSOH ZLWK D ILQH JUHHQ SDWLQD DQG D JRRG SRUWUDLW $ERXW
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
271

3HUWLQD['HQDULXV6LOYHUPPJKSRVVLEO\VWUXFN
YHU\ HDUO\ LQ WKH UHLJQ RI 6HSWLPLXV 6HYHUXV 5RPH ,03 &$(6 3
+(/9 3(57,1 $9* /DXUHDWH KHDG RI 3HUWLQD[ WR ULJKW 5HY
$(49,7$9*753&26,,$HTXLWDVVWDQGLQJIURQWKHDGWROHIW
KROGLQJVFDOHVLQKHUULJKWKDQGDQGDFRUQXFRSLDZLWKKHUOHIW%0&
&RKHQ 5,& D $Q H[WUDRUGLQDU\ DQG UDUH LVVXH ZLWK DQ
H[FHSWLRQDOSRUWUDLW*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
([7NDOHF0D\EXWZLWKWKHOHJHQGVLQFRUUHFWO\JLYHQ 2:1
7KLV SRUWUDLW RQ WKLV FRLQ LV VR XQXVXDO WKDW LW VHHPV SRVVLEOH WKDW LW ZDV
DFWXDOO\VWUXFNXQGHU6HSWLPLXV6HYHUXVWKHUHYHUVHOHJHQGEUHDN$(49,7
$9 & 75 3 LV DOPRVW QHYHU IRXQG RQ GHQDULL GHILQLWHO\ VWUXFN E\
3HUWLQD[ WKH UHVHPEODQFH WR WKH DFWXDO SRUWUDLWV RI 6HYHUXV LV PXFK
VWURQJHUWKDQLWLVWRWKHXVXDOSRUWUDLWVRI3HUWLQD[,QDZD\WKLVFRLQPD\
KDYHEHHQSDUWRIDQLVVXHDXWKRUL]HGE\6HYHUXVLQRUGHUWRHPSKDVL]HKLV
FRQQHFWLRQ WR KLV PXUGHUHG SUHGHFHVVRU E\ VKRZLQJ KRZ VLPLODU WKH\
ORRNHG
272

6HSWLPLXV 6HYHUXV $XUHXV *ROG PP J K
5RPH 6(9(596 3,96 $9* /DXUHDWH KHDG RI 6HSWLPLXV
6HYHUXVWROHIW5HY9,&725,$($9**9LFWRU\KROGLQJZKLSLQKHU
ULJKW KDQG DQG UHLQV LQ KHU OHIW GULYLQJ TXDGULJD JDOORSLQJ WR ULJKW
%LDJJL ± %0& ± &DOLFy D &I 5,& KHDG RI 6HYHUXV WR
ULJKW([WUHPHO\UDUHSRVVLEO\WKHVHFRQGH[DPSOHRIWKHW\SHNQRZQ
ZLWK WKH RWKHU LQ /HX 0D\ EXW IURP GLIIHUHQW GLHV
6RPHYHU\PLQRUPDUNVRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 'H%DNH\ &ROOHFWLRQ DQG IURP WKRVH RI WKH 0RQH\0XVHXP
=XULFK7ULWRQ;9,,,-DQXDU\DQGRI*|W]*UDEHUW/+6
0D\H[*LHVVHQHU0Q]KDQGOXQJ1RYHPEHU 2:1
/HIW IDFLQJ SRUWUDLWV RI 6HSWLPLXV6HYHUXVDUHSDUWLFXODUO\XQFRPPRQWKLV
LVDQHVSHFLDOO\DWWUDFWLYHH[DPSOH
273

6HSWLPLXV6HYHUXV'HQDULXV6LOYHUPPJK
5RPH 6(9(596 3,96 $9* /DXUHDWH KHDG RI 6HSWLPLXV
6HYHUXV WR ULJKW 5HY 3 0 75 3 ;9,,, &26 ,,, 3 3 1HSWXQH
VWDQGLQJWROHIWKLVULJKWIRRWRQDURFNUHVWLQJKLVULJKWKDQGRQKLV
ULJKWNQHHDQGKROGLQJWULGHQWLQKLVOHIW%0&&RKHQ5,&
6KDUSDQGOLJKWO\WRQHG*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
248
238
242
253 255
260
265
267
262 268
286
272
276
296 289
302
303
305
304
307
274

6HSWLPLXV6HYHUXV3HQWDVVDULRQ%URQ]HPPJ
K 1LFRSROLV DG ,VWUXP $XUHOLXV *DOOXV OHJDWXV FRQVXODULV
$<.ȁ&(Ȇ&(9+32&Ȇ/DXUHDWHKHDGRI6HSWLPLXV
6HYHUXVWRULJKW5HY<Ȇ$<3ī$ȁȁ2<1,.2Ȇ2ȁ,7ȍȆ32&
, <RXWKIXO 'LRQ\VRV QXGH VWDQGLQJ IDFLQJ ZLWK KLV KHDGWXUQHGWR
OHIW SRXULQJ D OLEDWLRQ IURP D NDQWKDURV KHOG LQ KLV ULJKW KDQG DQG
KROGLQJDILOOHWHGWK\UVRVLQKLVOHIW$01*,6KDUSDWWUDFWLYH
DQG ZLWK D GDUN EODFNJUHHQ SDWLQD 6RPH PLQRU FOHDQLQJ PDUNV
2:1
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ ERXJKW SULYDWHO\ IURP 3HWHU %XUEXOHV LQ
1HZ<RUNDWWKH1<,1&LQ'HFHPEHU
275

'LYXV 6HSWLPLXV 6HYHUXV GLHG 7ULDVVDULRQ %URQ]H PP
J K +HOLRSROLV VWUXFN XQGHU &DUDFDOOD ',92
6(9(52 /DXUHDWH GUDSHG DQG FXLUDVVHG EXVW RI WKH GHLILHG
6HSWLPLXV6HYHUXVWRULJKW5HY&2/+(/,20+9LHZRIWKH
WHPSOH RI =HXV LQ +HOLRSROLV VKRZQ LQ SHUVSHFWLYH DQG VHHQ IURP
DERYH DQG WR OHIW %0& 61* 0XQLFK 9HU\ GDUN JUHHQ
SDWLQD RYHUODLG ZLWK HDUWKHQ KLJKOLJKWV 6RPH DUHDV RI IODWQHVV
2:1 RWKHUZLVHJRRGYHU\ILQH
276

-XOLD'RPQD$XJXVWD$XUHXV*ROGPPJK
5RPH ,9/,$ '201$ $9* 'UDSHG EXVW RI -XOLD 'RPQD WR
ULJKWKHUKDLULQILYHZDYHVDQGERXQGXSDWWKHEDFN5HY9(1(5,
9,&75 9HQXV KDOI QXGH DQG VHHQ IURP EHKLQG ZLWK KHU GUDSHU\
IROGHG XQGHUQHDWK KHU VWDQGLQJ WR ULJKW KROGLQJ D SDOP EUDQFK LQ
KHUOHIWKDQGDJOREHLQKHUULJKWDQGOHDQLQJZLWKKHUOHIWHOERZRQ
D ORZ FROXPQ WR KHU OHIW %0& &DOLFy D &RKHQ +LOO
2:1 5,& $Q DWWUDFWLYH VKDUSO\ VWUXFN DQG OLJKWO\ WRQHG
H[DPSOH([WUHPHO\ILQH
([1RPRV0D\EXWXQSDLG
277

&DUDFDOOD +HPLDVVDULRQ %URQ]H PP J K
6HUGLFD ǹȊȉ Ȁ Ȃ ǹȊ &Ǽ9 ǹȃȉȍȃ(ǿȃȅȈ /DXUHDWH EXVW RI
&DUDFDOOD WR ULJKW 5HY &(3ǻȍ1 ,QIDQW 'LRQ\VRV VHDWHG OHIW LQ KLV
OLNQRQ D VDFUHG EDVNHW KROGLQJ D EXQFKRIJUDSHVLQKLVULJKWKDQG
DQGDWK\UVRVLQKLVOHIW5X]LFND6HUGLFD9DUEDQRY9HU\UDUH
$QDWWUDFWLYHSLHFHZLWKDGDUNJUHHQSDWLQD*RRGYHU\ILQH
2:1
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ *RUQ\ 0RVFK 2FWREHU

278

&DUDFDOOD 7ULDVVDULRQ %URQ]H PP J K
3DXWDOLDFǹ9ȉȀȂǹ9ȇǾǹȃȉȍȃǼǿȃȅ&/DXUHDWH
KHDGRI&DUDFDOODWRULJKW5HYȅ9ȁȆǿǹ&Ȇǹ9ȉǹȁǿǹ&+HUPHV
QXGH EXW IRU FORDN DURXQG KLV VKRXOGHUV VWDQGLQJ WR OHIW KROGLQJ
SXUVHLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGNHU\NHLRQZLWKKLVOHIWDWKLVIHHWWROHIW
URRVWHU VWDQGLQJ OHIW 0RXFKPRY 9DUEDQRY :LWK
DQ DWWUDFWLYH GDUN JUHHQ SDWLQD DQG DQ XQXVXDO IDPLOLDU DQLPDO
YHU\ZHOOGHSLFWHG9HU\PLQRUWUDFHVRIFOHDQLQJRWKHUZLVHDERXW
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1
)URPD*HUPDQFROOHFWLRQDFTXLUHGEHIRUH
279

&DUDFDOOD $VVDULRQ %URQ]H PP J K
$ULDVVXVFǹȊȉȀȂǹȊǹȃȉȍȃǼǿȃȅ&/DXUHDWHDQG
GUDSHGEXVWRIWKH\RXWKIXO&DUDFDOODWRULJKW5HYǹȇǿǹ&&Ǽȍȃ
'LRQ\VRV VWDQGLQJ OHIW QXGH EXW IRU KLV ERRWVDQGDFORDNRYHUKLV
VKRXOGHUV KROGLQJ VWDII ZLWK KLV OHIW KDQG DQG SRXULQJ IURP D
NDQWKDURVKHOGLQKLVULJKWWROHIWDWKLVIHHWSDQWKHUNQHHOLQJOHIW
KLV KHDG WXUQHG EDFN WR ULJKW 61* 3DULV 61* YRQ $XORFN
9RQ$XORFN3LVLGLHQ,VDPHGLHV$YHU\DWWUDFWLYH
SLHFH ZLWK DSOHDVLQJSRUWUDLWRIWKHWHHQDJH&DUDFDOODDQGDJUHHQ 2:1
SDWLQD1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQH[.RYDNV,QWHUQHW/LVW'HFHPEHU
J
280

&DUDFDOOD %URQ]H PP J K 6HOHXFLD DG
&DO\FDGQXPVWUXFNDIWHU$9.0$$17ȍ1,12&/DXUHDWH
KHDG RI &DUDFDOOD WR ULJKW 5HY >&(ȁ(<.( ȍ1@ 7ȍ1 Ȇ32&
.$ȁ<.$ ǻ ȃȍ 'LRQ\VRV VWDQGLQJ ULJKW LQ D ELJD GUDZQ E\ WZR
SDQWKHUV KROGLQJ D WK\UVRV LQ KLV ULJKW KDQG DQG LQ KLV OHIW D
NDQWKDURV IURP ZKLFK KH SRXUV ZLQH RYHU WKH KHDG RI RQH RI WKH
SDQWKHUV WKH KHDG RI ZKLFK LV WXUQHG EDFN WR OHIW WR ULJKW 6LOHQRV
NQHHOLQJ IDFLQJ KLV KHDG WXUQHG WR OHIW DQG KLV ULJKW KDQG
RXWVWUHWFKHG WR FDWFK VRPH IDOOLQJ ZLQH 61* )UDQFH 61*
/HYDQWH 61*YRQ$XORFN$YHU\DWWUDFWLYHZHOOVWUXFN
FRLQZLWKDILQHROLYHWDQSDWLQDDQGDZRQGHUIXOO\GHWDLOHGUHYHUVH
([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH9LQH\DUG&ROOHFWLRQERXJKWSULYDWHO\LQ'HFHPEHU
2:1
281

&DUDFDOOD 3HQWDVVDULRQ %URQ]H PP J K
.RLQRQ RI &\SUXV 3DSKRV Ȃ ǹȃȉȍȃǼǿȃȅ& ǹ9īȅ9&ȉȅ&
/DXUHDWH KHDG RI &DUDFDOOD WR ULJKW 5HY Ȁȅǿȃȅȃ ȀȊȆȇǿȍȃ 7KH
WHPSOH FRPSOH[ RI WKH VDQFWXDU\ RI WKH 3DSKLDQ $SKURGLWH ZLWK WKH
FRQLFDO [RDQRQ ZLWKLQ D FHQWUDO WRZHU IODQNHG E\ WZR IODWURRIHG
VKULQHVHDFKFRQWDLQLQJDQLQFHQVHEXUQHUDQGZLWKDGRYHRQWKHURRI
EHIRUH VHPLFLUFXODU IRUHFRXUW DERYH VWDU ZLWKLQ FUHVFHQW %0&
3DUNV61*&RSHQKDJHQ&OHDUDQGQLFHO\FHQWHUHGZLWKDGDUN
EODFNLVKJUHHQSDWLQDDQGUHGHDUWKHQGHSRVLWV9HU\ILQH
)URPD6ZLVVSULYDWHFROOHFWLRQIRUPHGEHIRUH
282

*HWDDV&DHVDU'HQDULXV6LOYHUPPJK
5RPH36(37*(7$&$(63217%DUHKHDGHGGUDSHG
DQG FXLUDVVHG EXVW RI *HWD WR ULJKW VHHQ IURP WKH IURQW 5HY
6(&95,7 ,03(5,, 6HFXULWDV VHDWHG OHIW RQ D KLJKEDFNHG WKURQH
2:1 KROGLQJJOREHLQKHUULJKWKDQGDQGOHDQLQJKHUOHIWRQWKHDUPRIWKH
WKURQH%0&YDU&RKHQYDU5,&EYDUDOOZLWKEXVWV
VHHQIURPEHKLQGUDWKHUWKDQIURPWKHIURQWDVKHUH9HU\UDUHZLWK
WKLVEXVWYDULDQW:LWKDVSOHQGLGSRUWUDLWRIWKH\RXQJSULQFHQLFHO\
WRQHGDQGZHOOFHQWHUHG([WUHPHO\ILQH
283

*HWDDV&DHVDU$VVDULRQ%URQ]HPPJK
1D[RVȁ&(Ȇī(7$&%DUHKHDGRI*HWDWROHIW5HYȃǹȄǿȍȃ
:LQHNUDWHU0LRQQHW6XSSO,9S([WUHPHO\UDUH:LWKD 2:1
JUHHQUHGEURZQSDWLQD*RRGYHU\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ ERXJKW SULYDWHO\ IURP .LUN 'DYLV LQ

'HFHPEHU
5RPDQSURYLQFLDOFRLQVIURPWKH&\FODGHVDUHXQLIRUPO\YHU\XQFRPPRQ
LVVXHG WR VHUYH WKH SRSXODWLRQ RI WKH LVODQGV WKH\ VHOGRP OHIW WKHP DQG
VLQFH WKH\ VHOGRP OHIW WKHLU LVODQGV RI LVVXH WKH\ WHQGHG WR FLUFXODWH VR
LQWHQVHO\WKDWVXUYLYLQJH[DPSOHVDUHVHOGRPLIHYHULQJRRGFRQGLWLRQ
284
2:1

*HWD &DHVDU 7HWUDGUDFKP 6LOYHU PP J K
6HOHXFLD DG &DO\FDGQXP Ȇȅ &ǼȆ īǼȉǹ& Ȁǹǿ %DUHKHDGHG DQG
GUDSHG EXVW RI *HWD WR ULJKW 5HY &ǼȁǼȊȀǼȍȃ ȉȍȃ Ȇȇȅ&
ȀǹȁȊȀǹ ǻȃȍ & Ǽ 'LRQ\VRV VWDQGLQJ OHIW ZHDULQJ ORQJ
UREHVDQGKROGLQJORQJVWDIIWK\UVRV"ZLWKKLVOHIWKDQGDQGSRXULQJ
IURPDNDQWKDURVKHOGLQKLVULJKW3ULHXU 61*/HYDQWH
61* YRQ $XORFN WKLV FRLQ ([WUHPHO\ UDUH LI QRW XQLTXH
7RQHG DWWUDFWLYH DQG ZLWK DQ REYHUVH SRUWUDLW RI GLVWLQJXLVKHG
TXDOLW\9HU\ILQH
IURPWKHFROOHFWLRQVRI(/HYDQWHDQG+YRQ$XORFN
285

(ODJDEDOXV $QWRQLQLDQXV 6LOYHU PP J K
5RPH ,03 &$(6 0 $95 $1721,196 $9* 5DGLDWH
GUDSHGDQGFXLUDVVHGEXVWRI(ODJDEDOXVWRULJKW5HY0$569,&725
0DUV DGYDQFLQJ ULJKW QXGH EXW IRU FORDN IORDWLQJ EHKLQG KLV ZDLVW
KROGLQJWUDQVYHUVHVSHDULQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGZLWKKLVOHIWWURSK\RYHU
KLV OHIW VKRXOGHU %0& &RKHQ 5,& $WWUDFWLYHO\ WRQHG 2:1
DQGZLWKDILQHSRUWUDLW1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
286

(ODJDEDOXV $XUHXV *ROG PP J K5RPH
,03 &$(6 $1721,196 $9* /DXUHDWH GUDSHG DQG
FXLUDVVHG EXVW RI (ODJDEDOXV WR ULJKW 5HY 3217,) 0$; 75 3 ,,
&26,,335RPDKHOPHWHGDQGGUDSHGVHDWHGOHIWRQWKURQHZLWKD
EDFNVKHKROGV9LFWRU\LQKHUULJKWKDQGDQGDVFHSWHUZLWKKHUOHIW
WR ULJKW OHDQLQJ DJDLQVW KHU WKURQH VKLHOG %LDJJL %0&
&DOLFy &RKHQ 5,& 5DUH :LWK D ILQH SRUWUDLW DQG
2:1 ZHOOVWUXFN*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
IURPWKH
3HUIHFWLRQLVWFROOHFWLRQ
/HX0D\
DQG IURP WKHFROOHFWLRQRIWKH6DQWD%DUEDUD0XVHXPRI$UW1XPLVPDWLF
)LQH$UWV,0DUFK
287

'LDGXPHQLDQDV&DHVDU+HPLDVVDULRQ%URQ]HPP
J K 'HXOWXP 0 23(/ $1721,196 ',$'9 & %DUH
KHDGHGGUDSHGDQGFXLUDVVHGEXVWRI'LDGXPHQLDQWRULJKW5HY&)
2:1 3' 0DUV\DV VWDQGLQJ ULJKW UDLVLQJ KLV ULJKW KDQG LQ JUHHWLQJ DQG
KROGLQJDZLQHVNLQRYHUKLVOHIWVKRXOGHU'UDJDQRY25
9DUEDQRY<XUXNRYD'HXOWXP$QDWWUDFWLYHH[DPSOHZLWKD
GDUNJUHHQSDWLQD1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG FROOHFWLRQ H[ *RUQ\ 0RVFK 0DUFK

7KHILJXUHRI0DUV\DVRQWKHUHYHUVHRIWKLVFRLQLVFRSLHGIURPDVWDWXHWKDW
VWRRGLQWKH5RPDQ)RUXPQHDUWKHFRPLWLXPLWZDVVHHQDVDV\PERORI
OLEHUW\DQGLWVEDVHZDVXVHGDVDVLJQERDUGIRUSRVWLQJUXGHSROLWLFDOYHUVHV
E\ PHPEHUV RI WKH SOHEV ,Q DGGLWLRQ DFFRUGLQJ WR 0DUWLDO WKH VWDWXH LQ
5RPHVHHPVWRKDYHEHHQDPHHWLQJSODFHIRUERWKFRXUWHVDQVDQGODZ\HUV
3UHVXPDEO\LWVDSSHDUDQFHRQWKLVFRLQPXVWKDYHUHIHUUHGWRLWVFRQQHFWLRQ
ZLWKOLEHUW\UDWKHUWKDQZLWKSURVWLWXWHVRUODZ\HUV,QDQ\FDVHWKLVVWDWXH
DOVRDSSHDUVRQWKHFRLQDJHVRIRWKHU5RPDQFRORQLHVVHHEHORZORW
IRUWKHVDPHW\SHRQWKHFRLQDJHRI1LQLFDXQGHU0D[LPLQXV,DQGDERYH
IRUDQHDUOLHU1LQLFDH[DPSOH
288

6HYHUXV $OH[DQGHU $XUHXV *ROG PP J K
5RPH ,03 & 0 $95 6(9 $/(;$1' $9* /DXUHDWH DQG
GUDSHG EXVW RI 6HYHUXV $OH[DQGHU WR ULJKW 5HY 9,5796 $9*
9LUWXVVWDQGLQJULJKWKROGLQJDQLQYHUWHGVSHDULQKLVULJKWKDQGDQG
2:1 UHVWLQJ KLV OHIW RQ KLV VKLHOG %0& &DOLFy D 5,&
$WWUDFWLYH DQG ZLWK D JRRG SRUWUDLW 0LQRU PDUNV RQ WKH HGJH
289

6HYHUXV $OH[DQGHU $XUHXV *ROG PP J K
5RPH ,03 & 0 $95 6(9 $/(;$1' $9* /DXUHDWH
GUDSHG DQGFXLUDVVHGEXVWRI6HYHUXV$OH[DQGHUWRULJKW5HY30
75 3 9, &26 ,, 3 3 0DUV DGYDQFLQJ WR ULJKW KROGLQJ WUDQVYHUVH
VSHDULQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGDWURSK\LQKLVOHIW%0&&DOLFy
WKLV UHYHUVH GLH &RKHQ 5,& &OHDU DQG DWWUDFWLYH 2:1
6RPHPLQRUPDUNVRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPD(XURSHDQFROOHFWLRQIRUPHGLQWKHV
290

6HYHUXV $OH[DQGHU $V &RSSHU PP J K
5RPH ,03 6(9 $/(;$1'(5 $9* /DXUHDWH KHDG RI
6HYHUXV $OH[DQGHU WR ULJKW ZLWK OLJKW GUDSHU\ RQ KLV IDU VKRXOGHU
5HY 3 0 75 3 9,,,, &26 ,,, 3 3 6 & 6HYHUXV $OH[DQGHU LQ
2:1
PLOLWDU\ GUHVV VWDQGLQJ OHIW KLV ULJKW IRRW RQ D KHOPHW KROGLQJ D
JOREHLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGDUHYHUVHGVSHDUZLWKKLVOHIW%0&
&RKHQ 5,& $WWUDFWLYH DQG ZHOOVWUXFNZLWKDGDUNJUHHQ
SDWLQDDQGDILQHSRUWUDLW*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
([%HUWRODPL'HFHPEHU
291

6HYHUXV$OH[DQGHU'HQDULXV6LOYHUPPJK 2:1
5RPH ,03 $/(;$1'(5 3,96 $9* /DXUHDWH DQG GUDSHG
EXVWRI6HYHUXV$OH[DQGHUWRULJKW5HY30753;,,&26,,,33
6RODGYDQFLQJWROHIWUDLVLQJKLVULJKWKDQGDQGKROGLQJZKLSLQKLV
OHIW %0& &RKHQ 5,& 7RQHG DQG ZHOOVWUXFN
([WUHPHO\ILQH
292

0D[LPLQXV,7KUD['LDVVDULRQ%URQ]HPPJ
K1LQLFD&ODXGLRSROLV,030$;,0,1963,/DXUHDWHKHDGRI
0D[LPLQXV WR ULJKW 5HY &2/ &/8ǻ 1,1,& %HDUGHG PDOH
ILJXUH SUREDEO\ 0DUV\DV QXGH DQG ZHDULQJ D WDHQLD DQG ERRWV
VWDQGLQJWROHIWUDLVLQJKLVULJKWKDQGLQVDOXWHDQGKROGLQJZLWKKLV
2:1
OHIW D ZLQHVNLQ RYHU KLV OHIW VKRXOGHU %0& YDU 61* /HYDQWH
6XSSO WKLV FRLQ 61* 3DULV YDU 61* YRQ $XORFN
VDPH GLHV $ UHPDUNDEO\ ILQH DQG FOHDU H[DPSOH ZLWK D ORYHO\
ROLYHJUHHQSDWLQD$ERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
IURPWKHFROOHFWLRQRI(/HYDQWH
)RU DQ H[SODQDWLRQ IRU WKHDSSHDUDQFHRI0DUV\DVRQWKLVFRLQVHHDERYH
WKHQRWHWRORWDFRLQRI'LDGXPHQLDQIURP'HXOWXP
293

*RUGLDQ , 'HQDULXV 6LOYHU PP J K 5RPH
$SULO ,03 0 $17 *25',$196 $)5 $9* /DXUHDWH
GUDSHGDQGFXLUDVVHGEXVWRI*RUGLDQ,WRULJKW5HY30753&263
3(PSHURUWRJDWHVWDQGLQJOHIWKROGLQJEUDQFKLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQG
SDUD]RQLXP ZLWK KLV OHIW %0& &RKHQ 5,& $ VSHFWDFXODU
H[DPSOH SHUIHFWO\ VWUXFN RQ D EURDG IODQ OLJKWO\ WRQHG DQG ZLWK D
VSOHQGLGSRUWUDLWRIWKHHOGHUO\HPSHURU6XSHUEH[WUHPHO\ILQH
([ *ROGEHUJ 6HSWHPEHUDQGIURPWKH/\QQ&ROOHFWLRQ
2:1 7ULWRQ9-DQXDU\
$VLVZHOONQRZQVHYHUHGLVVDWLVIDFWLRQZLWK0D[LPLQXV,RQWKHSDUWRIWKH
6HQDWH DQG XSSHU FODVVHV LQ 5RPH OHGWRDQHODERUDWHSORWWRPDNHRQHRI
WKHLURZQWKHDULVWRFUDWLFDQGHOGHUO\*RUGLDQ,WKHQSURFRQVXODUJRYHUQRU
RI$IULFD3URFRQVXODULVWKHQHZHPSHURU$OOZHQWZHOOIRUDVKRUWZKLOH
*RUGLDQDVVRFLDWLQJKLVVRQ*RUGLDQ,,ZLWKKLPDVPLOLWDU\FRPPDQGHUEXW
WKH JRYHUQRU RI QHLJKERULQJ 1XPLGLD GHIHDWHG DQG NLOOHG *RUGLDQ ,, LQ
EDWWOH DQG *RUGLDQ , FRPPLWWHG VXLFLGH 7KH DFWXDO UHLJQ ODVWHG IRU WKUHH
ZHHNV DQG ERWK HPSHURUV ZHUH LQ $IULFD VR KRZ GLG WKH PLQW LQ 5RPH
PDQDJH WR SURGXFH D TXLWH FRQVLGHUDEOH FRLQDJH WKRXJK RQH WKDW LV YHU\
UDUH WRGD\" 7KH RQO\ H[SODQDWLRQ LV WKDW WKH UHYROW KDG EHHQ ORQJ LQ
SODQQLQJ DQG WKH FRQVSLUDWRUV RUGHUHG FRLQV WR EH VWUXFN LQ VHFUHW VR WKDW
GRQDWLYHVFRXOGEHPDGHDVVRRQDVWKHQHZHPSHURUVKDGEHHQSURFODLPHG
294

%DOELQXV $QWRQLQLDQXV 6LOYHU PP J K 5RPH
,03 &$(6 ' &$(/ %$/%,196 $9* 5DGLDWH GUDSHG DQG
FXLUDVVHG EXVW RI %DOELQXV WR ULJKW 5HY 3,(7$6 0979$ $9**
7ZR FODVSHG ULJKW KDQGV %0& &RKHQ 5,& $WWUDFWLYH
ZHOOVWUXFNZHOOFHQWHUHGDQGOLJKWO\WRQHG([WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1
295

*RUGLDQ,,,'HQDULXV6LOYHUPPJK5RPH
,03 *25',$196 3,96 )(/ $9* /DXUHDWH GUDSHG DQG
FXLUDVVHGEXVWRI*RUGLDQ,,,WRULJKW5HY30753,,,&2633
*RUGLDQ ,,, ULGLQJ RQ KRUVHEDFN OHIW UDLVLQJ KLV ULJKW KDQG DQG
KROGLQJDVFHSWHULQKLVOHIW&RKHQ5,&:HOOVWUXFNZLWKD 2:1
VSOHQGLGO\FHQWHUHGREYHUVH([WUHPHO\ILQH
296

*RUGLDQ,,,$XUHXV*ROGPPJK5RPH
ODWHHDUO\,03*25',$1963,96)(/$9*/DXUHDWH
GUDSHG DQG FXLUDVVHG EXVW RI *RUGLDQ WR ULJKW 5HY 9,5797,
$9*967, +HUFXOHV )DUQHVH VWDQGLQJ ULJKW UHVWLQJ KDQG RQ KLS
DQGKROGLQJFOXEVHWRQURFNDQGZLWKKLVOLRQ
VVNLQEHVLGHKLVFOXE 2:1
%LDJJL &DOLFy &RKHQ YDU YDULDQW EXVW 5,&
$QDWWUDFWLYHOXVWURXVDQGOLJKWO\WRQHGFRLQZLWKDILQHSRUWUDLW
DQGYHU\ZHOOVWUXFNUHYHUVH([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH'H%DNH\&ROOHFWLRQH[5RPD6HSWHPEHU
297

*RUGLDQ ,,, 'LDVVDULRQ %URQ]H PP J K
%UX]XV ǹ9ȉ Ȁ Ȃ ǹȃȉ ȍ īȅȇǻǿǹȃȅ& /DXUHDWH GUDSHG DQG
FXLUDVVHG EXVW RI *RUGLDQ ,,, WR ULJKW 5HY Ǻȇȅ<ǽ Ǿ ȃ ȍȃ
'HPHWHUKROGLQJWZRWRUFKHVGULYLQJFKDULRWGUDZQE\WZRZLQJHG
VHUSHQWV WR ULJKW %0& VDPH GLHV 53& 9,, $5
9HU\ UDUH $Q DWWUDFWLYH DQG ZHOOFHQWHUHG H[DPSOH ZLWK D GDUN
SDWLQD$ERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1
298

7UDMDQ 'HFLXV 'RXEOH 6HVWHUWLXV 2ULFKDOFXP PP
JK5RPH,03&0475$,$196'(&,96$9*
5DGLDWH DQG FXLUDVVHG EXVW RI 'HFLXV WR ULJKW ZLWK KLV
SDOXGDPHQWXPRQKLVIDUVKRXOGHU5HY)(/,&,7$66$(&9/,6
& )HOLFLWDV VWDQGLQJ OHIW KROGLQJ VWDQGDUG LQ KHU ULJKW KDQG DQG
FRUQXFRSLDZLWKKHUOHIW%DQWL&RKHQ5,&D$VSOHQGLG
ZHOOVWUXFNDQGZHOOSUHVHUYHGH[DPSOHZLWKDSRZHUIXOSRUWUDLWDQG
DILQHUHGGLVKEURZQDQGJUHHQSDWLQD6RPHPLQRUVPRRWKLQJLQWKH
ILHOGVRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
1,5:1 )URPD(XURSHDQFROOHFWLRQDQGIURPWKH+XQWHU&ROOHFWLRQ*ROGEHUJ
)HEUXDU\ H[6XSHULRU'HFHPEHUDQG6WDFN
V
'HFHPEHUIURPWKHFROOHFWLRQRI1%+XQW,96RWKHE\
V
-XQHH[/HX0D\
299

+HUHQQLD(WUXVFLOOD$XJXVWD$QWRQLQLDQXV6LOYHUPP
J K 5RPH +(5 (7596&,//$ $9* 'LDGHPHG DQG
GUDSHG EXVW RI +HUHQQLD (WUXVFLOOD VHW RQ FUHVFHQW WR ULJKW 5HY
39',&,7,$ $9* 3XGLFLWLD YHLOHG VHDWHG OHIW RQ WKURQH ZLWK KHU
ULJKWKDQGGUDZLQJYHLODQGKROGLQJDWUDQVYHUVHVFHSWHULQKHUOHIW
2:1 &RKHQ 5,& E :LWK D UHPDUNDEO\ ILQH DQG ZHOOFHQWHUHG
SRUWUDLWRIWKHHPSUHVV5HYHUVHVRPHZKDWOLJKWO\VWUXFNIURPDZRUQ
GLHRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQHYHU\ILQH
)URPWKH*HUPDQ55*&ROOHFWLRQIRUPHGEHIRUH
300

9DOHULDQ , 7ULDVVDULRQ %URQ]H PP J K
$QHPXULXP\HDU ǹ9ȀȆȅȁǿȅ9ǹȁǼȇǿǹȃȅȃ5DGLDWH
GUDSHGDQGFXLUDVVHGEXVWRI9DOHULDQWRULJKWVHHQIURPEHKLQG5HY
Ǽȉ Ǻ ǹȃǼȂȅ9ȇǿǼ:ȃ 'LRQ\VRV QXGH EXW IRU FORDN DURXQG KLV
VKRXOGHUVVWDQGLQJOHIWKROGLQJWK\UVRVZLWKKLVOHIWKDQGDQGSRXULQJ
IURPDNDQWKDURVKHOGLQKLVULJKWDWKLVIHHWWROHIWSDQWKHUVWDQGLQJ
OHIWKLVKHDGWXUQHGEDFNWRULJKW61*/HYDQWHWKLVFRLQ61*
YRQ $XORFN 6WUXFN IURP GLHV HQJUDYHG LQ DQ LQWHUHVWLQJ ORFDO
VW\OHEXWFOHDUDQGZLWKDILQHJUHHQSDWLQD0LQRUHGJHGDPDJHRQWKH 2:1
UHYHUVHRWKHUZLVHDERXWH[WUHPHO\ILQH
)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ DQG WKDW RI ( /HYDQWH 7ULWRQ 9,,
-DQXDU\
301

$XUHOLDQ$XUHXV*ROGPPJK0HGLRODQXP
DQG7LFLQXPF,03&'$95(/,$196$9*/DXUHDWH
GUDSHG DQG FXLUDVVHG EXVW RI $XUHOLDQ WR ULJKW 5HY ),'(6 0,/,
)LGHV VWDQGLQJ IDFLQJ KHDG WXUQHG WR OHIW KROGLQJ D VLJQXP ZLWK
HDFK KDQG &DOLFy &RKHQ 5,& 9HU\ UDUH FOHDU DQG 2:1
ZLWK DQ XQXVXDOO\ WRXJK DQG DJJUHVVLYH SRUWUDLW RI$XUHOLDQ0LQRU
PDUNVRWKHUZLVHQHDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
7KLV SRUWUDLW LV SDUWLFXODUO\ LQWULJXLQJ ZKHQ FRPSDUHG ZLWK WKH XVXDO RQHV
ZHVHHRI$XUHOLDQFRXOGLWEHWKDWWKLVLVZKDWWKHHPSHURUZKRZDVDYHU\
WRXJK DQG VHULRXV JHQHUDO DFWXDOO\ ORRNHG OLNH" 2U FRXOG LW EH WKDW WKLV
REYHUVHGLHZDVGHVLJQHGE\DQHQJUDYHUZKRKDGQRLGHDRIZKDW$XUHOLDQ
ORRNHGOLNHDQGVLPSO\PRGHOHGKLPRQ&ODXGLXV*RWKLFXV"
302

$XUHOLDQ$XUHXV*ROGPPJK0HGLRODQXP
UG HPLVVLRQ ,03 & / '20 $85(/,$196 3 ) $9* 2:1
/DXUHDWHDQGFXLUDVVHGEXVWRI$XUHOLDQWRULJKW5HY9,5796$9*
0DUVDGYDQFLQJWRULJKWKROGLQJWUDQVYHUVHVSHDULQKLVULJKWKDQGDQG
DWURSK\LQKLVOHIWDWKLVIHHWWRULJKWVHDWHGFDSWLYH%1&DOLFy
5,&$QXQXVXDOO\DWWUDFWLYHH[DPSOHZHOOVWUXFNDQGZLWK
DQ REYHUVH LQ KLJK UHOLHI 6RPH YHU\ PLQRU PDUNV RWKHUZLVH JRRG
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
303

7DFLWXV $XUHXV *ROG PPJK6LVFLD
,03&0&/7$&,796$9*/DXUHDWHGUDSHGDQGFXLUDVVHGEXVW
RI7DFLWXVWRULJKW5HY520$($(7(51$(5RPDKHOPHWHGDQG
GUDSHG VHDWHG OHIW RQ D KLJKEDFNHGWKURQHKROGLQJ9LFWRU\LQKHU
ULJKW KDQG DQG D VFHSWHU ZLWK KHU OHIW EHORZ WKURQH VKLHOG %1
&DOLFy &RKHQ 5,& 5DUH $ EULJKW OXVWURXV
H[DPSOH([WUHPHO\ILQH
DQG/HX2FWREHU
2:1
304

&DUXV $XUHXV *ROG PP J K $QWLRFK
,03 & 0 $95 &$596 3 ) $9* /DXUHDWH GUDSHG DQG FXLUDVVHG
EXVW RI &DUXV WR ULJKW 5HY 9,&725,$( $9** 60$ 9LFWRU\
DGYDQFLQJULJKWKROGLQJSDOPIURQGRYHUOHIWVKRXOGHUDQGZUHDWKLQ
KHUULJKWKDQG&DOLFy5,&9HU\UDUH:LWKDQLQWHUHVWLQJ
SRUWUDLWRIWKHHOGHUO\&DUXVZHOOVWUXFNDQGOXVWURXV6OLJKWVWDLQLQJ
RQWKHREYHUVHYHU\PLQRUHGJHNQRFNDQGVRPHGLUWLQWKHGHYLFHV
2:1
305

&DULQXV DV &DHVDU$XUHXV*ROGPPJK
6LVFLD0$95&$5,19612%&$(6/DXUHDWHDQGFXLUDVVHG
EXVWRI&DULQXVWRULJKW5HY9,&725,$$9*9LFWRU\VWDQGLQJOHIW
RQ JOREH KROGLQJ ZUHDWK LQ KHU RXWVWUHWFKHG ULJKW KDQG DQG SDOP
EUDQFK RU D WURSK\" LQ KHU OHIW &DOLFy VDPH GLHV &RKHQ
5,& $Q H[FHOOHQW VKDUSO\ VWUXFN SLHFH 6RPH PLQRU
)URPWKH'H%DNH\&ROOHFWLRQDQGIURPDQ(QJOLVKFROOHFWLRQ1RPRV
0D\
7KHILJXUHRI9LFWRU\RQWKHUHYHUVHRIWKLVFRLQLVUDWKHUFXULRXV,QWKHILUVW
2:1 SODFH VKH DSSDUHQWO\ KDV QR ZLQJV VHFRQGO\ ZKLOH XVXDOO\ GHVFULEHG DV
FDUU\LQJ D WURSK\ ZKDW VKH VHHPV WR KDYH LQ KHU OHIW KDQG LV TXLWH RGG
DSSDUHQWO\ D ORQJ VWUDLJKW SDOP EUDQFK ZLWK VRPH VRUW RI EDQQHU DWWDFKHG
7KLV ODVW FRXOG EH VRPH NLQG RI RGG WURSK\ EXW LW DOVR FRXOG MXVW EH D
FXULRXVEUDQFKZLWKDYHU\SHFXOLDUZLQJEHKLQG<HWWKDWZRXOGPHDQWKDW
9LFWRU\
VZLQJVZHUHVKRZQLQDYHU\VWUDQJHZD\,IWKLVLVPHDQWWREHD
ZLQJOHVV 9LFWRU\ LW ZRXOG LPSO\ WKDW VKH ZDV PHDQW WR EH D SHUPDQHQW
FRPSDQLRQWR&DULQXVLHVKHFRXOGQRWIO\DZD\
306

&DULQXVDV&DHVDU$QWRQLQLDQXV%LOORQPPJ
K $QWLRFK ,03 & 0 $95 &$5,196 12% & 5DGLDWH DQG
FXLUDVVHGEXVWRI&DULQXVWRULJKW5HY9,5796$9**ī;;,2Q
WKHOHIW3ULQFHVWDQGLQJULJKWLQPLOLWDU\GUHVVUHFHLYLQJ9LFWRU\RQ
JOREH IURP -XSLWHU RQ WKH ULJKW VWDQGLQJ OHIW DQG KROGLQJ ORQJ
VFHSWUH5,&6KDUSDQGSHUIHFWO\VWUXFNZLWKWUDFHVRIVLOYHULQJ
DQGDILQHSDWLQD9LUWXDOO\DVVWUXFN 2:1
307

0D[LPLDQXV+HUFXOLXVILUVWUHLJQ$XUHXV*ROGPP
JK5RPH,03&0$959$/0$;,0,$1963)
$9* /DXUHDWH GUDSHG DQG FXLUDVVHG EXVW RI 0D[LPLDQXV WR ULJKW
5HY,29,&216(59$7$9**-XSLWHUVWDQGLQJOHIWQXGHEXWIRU
GUDSHU\RYHUKLVVKRXOGHUVKROGLQJWKXQGHUEROWLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQG
VFHSWHU LQ KLV OHIW &DOLFy &RKHQ 5,& D 9HU\
DWWUDFWLYHO\WRQHG*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH 2:1
)URPWKH'H%DNH\&ROOHFWLRQH[7UDGDUW'HFHPEHUDQG
7UDGDUW1RYHPEHU
308

0D[HQWLXV +DOI )ROOLV %URQ]H PP J K
LVVXHGIRUKLV'HFHQQDOLDLQ5RPHUGRIILFLQD0$;(17,96
3)$9*+HOPHWHGDQGFXLUDVVHGEXVWRI0D[HQWLXVWROHIWKROGLQJ
VSHDU SRLQWHG IRUZDUG DQG GHFRUDWHG VKLHOG 5HY 9,&725,$ 2:1
$(7(51$$9*1579LFWRU\VWDQGLQJULJKWOHIWIRRWRQEDVHRI
FLSSXV VXSSRUWLQJ VKLHOG RQ ZKLFK VKH LQVFULEHV 927 ; EHKLQG
KHUDWKHUIHHWWROHIWFDSWLYHVHDWHGOHIW'URVWF5,&5DUH
ZLWK D JUHHQ SDWLQD DQG D PRVW DWWUDFWLYH DQG XQXVXDO EXVW RI WKH
HPSHURU1HDUO\H[WUHPHO\ILQH
309

$QRQ\PRXV 7LPH RI 9DOHQWLQLDQ , WR 7KHRGRVLXV , FLUFD
+DOIVLOLTXD6LOYHUPPJK7UHYHUL7ULHU+HOPHWHG
DQG GUDSHG EXVW RI 5RPD WR OHIW 5HY ; ZLWKLQ ZUHDWK EHORZ
75%0&&RKHQ5,&DV5([WUHPHO\UDUH6RPHZKDW
URXJKVXUIDFHVZLWKVRPHUHPDLQLQJHQFUXVWDWLRQVRWKHUZLVHQHDUO\
H[WUHPHO\ILQH
2:1 &RLQVOLNHWKLVZHUHXVHGDVGRQDWLYHVIRUWKHFHOHEUDWLRQVRIWKHGHFHQQDOLD
,WLVXQFHUWDLQWRZKLFKODWHUWKFHQWXU\FHOHEUDWLRQWKLVFRLQUHIHUV
310

7KHRGRVLXV ,, 6ROLGXV *ROG PP J K
&RQVWDQWLQRSOH VW RIILFLQD ' 1 7+(2'26,96 3 )
$9* 3HDUOGLDGHPHG KHOPHWHG DQG FXLUDVVHG EXVW RI 7KHRGRVLXV
IDFLQJKLVKHDGWXUQHGVOLJKWO\WRULJKWKROGLQJDVSHDURYHUKLVULJKW
VKRXOGHUDQGZLWKDVKLHOGRUQDPHQWHGZLWKDKRUVHPDQVSHDULQJD
IDOOHQIRHRYHUKLVOHIW5HY927;;;09/7;;;;$&212%
&RQVWDQWLQRSROLVVHDWHGOHIWRQWKURQHKHUOHIWIRRWRQSURZKROGLQJ
JOREXV FUXFLJHU LQ KHU ULJKW KDQG ORQJ VFHSWHU ZLWK KHU OHIW DQG
2:1 OHDQLQJKHUOHIWHOERZRQDVKLHOGDWKHUVLGHLQILHOGWRULJKWVWDU
'HSH\URW 5,& :HOOFHQWHUHG ZHOO VWUXFN DQG DWWUDFWLYH
([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPWKH*HUPDQ55*&ROOHFWLRQIRUPHGEHIRUH
%<=$17,1($1',6/$0,&&2,16
311

$QDVWDVLXV , 6ROLGXV *ROG PP J K
2:1 &RQVWDQWLQRSOH WK RIILFLQD ' 1 $1$67$6,96 3 3
$9& +HOPHWHG DQG FXLUDVVHG EXVW RI $QDVWDVLXV IDFLQJ KLV KHDG
WXUQHGVOLJKWO\WRULJKWZHDULQJFURVVGLDGHPKROGLQJDVSHDUZLWK
KLV ULJKW KDQG DQG D VKLHOG RUQDPHQWHG ZLWK D KRUVHPDQ RYHU KLV
OHIW VKRXOGHU 5HY 9,&725, $ $9&&& + &212% 9LFWRU\
VWDQGLQJ OHIW KROGLQJ ORQJ FURVV EHKLQG KHU HLJKWSRLQWHG VWDU
'2& 0,%( 6% 8QXVXDO ZLWK WKH FURVV GLDGHP RQ WKH
REYHUVH&OHDUVKDUSDQGZHOOVWUXFN([WUHPHO\ILQH
312

3HULRGRI$QDVWDVLXV,-XVWLQLDQ,FLUFD3HQWDQXPPLXP
%LOORQ PP J K &RQVWDQWLQRSOH"'LDGHPHGDQGGUDSHG
EXVWRIHPSHURUWRULJKWLQILHOGWRULJKWFURVVDURXQGERUGHURIODUJH
SHOOHWV 5HY /DUJH FXUVLYH (ZLWKFURVVWRULJKWDOOZLWKLQERUGHURI 2:1
ODUJHSHOOHWV'2&0,%6EDSSDUHQWO\XQSXEOLVKHG([WUHPHO\
UDUH $WWUDFWLYHO\ WRQHG DQG VWUXFN LQ KLJK UHOLHI 6OLJKWO\ URXJK
VXUIDFHVRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
$Q H[WUDRUGLQDU\ DQG LQH[SOLFDEOH FRLQ ,Q IDFW SUHFLVHO\ ZKDW WKLV FRLQ
DFWXDOO\ LV LV UDWKHU D P\VWHU\ 7KH FRLQ VHHPV WR EH ELOORQ UDWKHU WKDQ
EURQ]HZKLFKPDNHVLWH[FHSWLRQDOLQHYHU\ZD\DIWHUDOOWKHGHQRPLQDWLRQ
PDUNHGRQLWLQGLFDWHVWKDWLWLVDQXPPLDSLHFHEXWWKDWKDVQRWKLQJWR
GR ZLWK VLOYHU 7KH REYHUVH W\SH RI D VPDOO EXVW DQG HVSHFLDOO\ WKH ODUJH
SHOOHWVWKDWIRUPLWVERUGHUKDVDIILQLWLHVZLWKDYDULHW\RI%\]DQWLQHPLQWV
LQWKHWKFHQWXU\EXWLVH[DFWO\SDUDOOHOHGQRZKHUH7KHRQHFHUWDLQW\ZH
KDYH LV WKDW LW LV FOHDUO\ JHQXLQH DQG PXVW KDYH EHHQ PDGH LQ HDUO\
%\]DQWLQHWLPHV
2:1
313

8PD\\DG&DOLSKDWH
$EGDO0DOLNLEQ0DUZDQ$+$'
)DOV &RSSHU PP J K 3VHXGR'DPDVFXV
1RWKLQJ YLVLEOH
(PSHURU
VHDWHGIDFLQJRQWKURQHZHDULQJFXULRXV
KHDGGUHVVORQJUREHVDQGKROGLQJDORQJFURVVDQGJOREXVFUXFLJHU
WR OHIW ELUG RQ VWDQG 5HY ǹĬ ȋ8ǿǿ /DUJH Ȃ DERYH FURVV
EHWZHHQWZRVWDUVEHORZFXUVLYHȂLQH[HUJXHLOOHJLEOHLQVFULSWLRQ
ΔȂ? ,UELG SS GLHV 2(5' $WWUDFWLYH
ZHOOVWUXFNDQGFOHDU*RRGYHU\ILQH
314

-XVWLQLDQ ,, ILUVW UHLJQ %LOORQ PP J K
VWUXFNRQIODQVPDGHE\FXWWLQJVKHHWPHWDOUDWKHUWKDQE\FDVWLQJRU
RYHUVWULNLQJ HDUOLHU FRLQV 5RPH )DFLQJ EXVW RI -XVWLQLDQ ,, 5HY
;;; EHORZ LQ H[HUJXH 52P '2& 0,% 6% 9HU\ 2:1
UDUH DQG XQXVXDO 5RXJK JUHHQ SDWLQD DV IRXQG 1HDUO\ H[WUHPHO\
ILQH
)URPWKH6HUJLXV & GZDOOD&ROOHFWLRQ
7KH EHVW GLVFXVVLRQRIWKHVHXQXVXDO%\]DQWLQHLVVXHVFDQEHIRXQGLQWKH
LQWURGXFWLRQ WR '2& ,, S ZKLFK H[SODLQV WKHLU DWWULEXWLRQ DQG WKHLU
IXQFWLRQ 7KH UDULW\ RI WKHVH FRLQV LV SUREDEO\ EHVWH[SODLQHGE\WKHLUWLQ\
VL]HDQGWKHLUORZVLOYHUFRQWHQWVXUYLYLQJSLHFHVVLPSO\ZRXOGQRWEHVHHQ
E\ PRGHUQ VHDUFKHUV ZKLOH RWKHUV ZRXOG VLPSO\ KDYH GLVLQWHJUDWHG RYHU
WLPH
315
2:1

8PD\\DG&DOLSKDWH
$EGDO0DOLNLEQ0DUZDQ$+&(
)DOV%URQ]HPPJKRYHUVWUXFNRQDFOHDUO\
YLVLEOHIROOLVRI&RQVWDQWLQH,PLQWHGLQ5RPHLQ+RPVF$+

DEGDOODK
DEGDOPDOLNDPƯUDOPX
PLQƯQ6WDQGLQJ
ILJXUH RI EHDUGHG &DOLSK IDFLQJ RYHUVWUXFN RQ WKH RULJLQDO FRLQ
V
UHYHUVH 5HY OƗ LODKD LOOƗ DOODK ZDKGDKX PXKDPPDG UDVǌO DOODK
7DOOĭRQEDVHDQGWKUHHVWHSVLQILHOGWROHIWVWDURIVL[SRLQWVLQ
ILHOGWRULJKWPLQWQDPHEL‫ۊ‬LP‫܈‬RYHUVWUXFNRQWKHRULJLQDOFRLQ
V
REYHUVH'2&&I*RRGZLQRYHUVWUXFNRQDIROOLVRI
&RQWDQWLQH,IURP$UHODWHRI([WUHPHO\UDUHZLWKDFOHDUO\
YLVLEOHXQGHUW\SH'DUNSDWLQD([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPD*HUPDQFROOHFWLRQ
:KLOHWKHVWDQGLQJ&DOLSKLVVXHVRI
$EGDO0DOLNDUHZHOONQRZQDQH[DPSOH
RYHUVWUXFN RQ D 5RPDQ FRLQ LVVXHG RYHU \HDUV HDUOLHU LV TXLWH VLPSO\
VSHFWDFXODU:LWKPRVWFRLQVWKDWZHUHVWUXFNRQIODQVPDGHIURPHDUOLHUFRLQV
LW LV XVXDOO\ GLIILFXOW WR LGHQWLI\ WKH XQGHUW\SHVVLQFHDWEHVWWKH\DUHRQO\
SDUWLDOO\YLVLEOH6RPHWLPHVDOOZHFDQVD\LVWKDWWKHUHDUHWUDFHVRIRULJLQDO
W\SHVXQGHUQHDWKWKHSUHVHQWRQHVSHUKDSVWKHEHVWNQRZQVHULHVRIFRLQVWKDW
DUHRYHUVWUXFNRQRWKHULVVXHVDUHWKRVHRI%DU.RFKEDWKHXQGHUW\SHVUDQJH
IURPLQYLVLEOHXQLGHQWLILDEOHWRSHUIHFWO\FOHDU7KHSUHVHQWFRLQQRWRQO\KDV
D YHU\ YLVLEOH XQGHUW\SH EXW WKDW W\SH FDQ EH IXOO\ LGHQWLILHG LW LV D IROOLV
VWUXFNLQWKHQDPHRI&RQVWDQWLQH,LQ5RPHLQDV5,&9,,S
REYHUVH ,03 &2167$17,196 3 ) $9* /DXUHDWH EXVW RI &RQVWDQWLQH WR
ULJKWUHYHUVH62/,,19>,&7@2>&@20>,7,@ 536RO0RVWLQWHUHVWLQJO\
Undertype *RRGZLQ
V UHVHDUFK KDV UHYHDOHG WKDW GXULQJ WKLV SHULRG WKH PLQW RI +RPV
PRUH SURSHUO\ ‫ۉ‬LP‫ ܈‬XVHG D QXPEHU RI&RQVWDQWLQLDQIROOHVDVIODQVPRVWO\
IRU WKH ,PSHULDO %XVW W\SH EXW DOVR IRU 6WDQGLQJ &DOLSK LVVXHV 6WDQGLQJ
&DOLSKRYHUVWUXFNRQDIROOLVGDWLQJWRIURP$UHODWHLVWKHRQO\
RWKHUNQRZQH[DPSOH7KLVZRXOGVXJJHVWWKDWWKHPLQWPXVWKDYHDFTXLUHGD
IDLUO\ VXEVWDQWLDO KRDUG RI &RQVWDQWLQLDQ IROOHV WR XVH DV IODQV VXFK D KRDUG
PLJKWZHOOKDYHEHHQKLGGHQGXULQJWKHFLYLOZDUEHWZHHQ&RQVWDQWLQH,DQG
/LFLQLXV , LQ 7KH ZULWHU ZRXOG OLNH WR WKDQN $ *RRGZLQ IRU KLV
LQYDOXDEOH KHOS ZLWK WKLV FRLQ $Q\ PLVWDNHV RU PLVLQWHUSUHWDWLRQV LQ WKLV
GHVFULSWLRQDUHZKROO\P\RZQ
316
2:1 2:1

,UHQH 6ROLGXV *ROG PP J K 6\UDFXVH F
,5,(1 $ī2967 %XVWRI,UHQHIDFLQJZHDULQJFKODP\VDQG
FURZQ ZLWK SHQGLOLD DQG D FURVV RQ D VHPLFLUFOH EHWZHHQ WZR
SLQQDFOHVKROGLQJDQDNDNLDLQKHUOHIWKDQGEHKLQGKHUVKRXOGHUV
WKHWZRFXUYHGOLQHVRIDWKURQHEDFN5HY$ī2967,%XVWRI,UHQH
IDFLQJ ZHDULQJ ORURV DQG FURZQ ZLWK SHQGLOLD DQG D FURVV RQ D
WULDQJOHEHWZHHQWZRSLQQDFOHVKROGLQJDFURVVSRWHQWRQEDVHLQKHU
ULJKW KDQG $QDVWDVL '2& 6% 6SDKU ([WUHPHO\
UDUHEHDXWLIXOO\VWUXFNRQDYHU\EURDGIODQZLWKDOOGHWDLOVFOHDUO\RQ
WKHFRLQ*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
317
2:1 2:1

,UHQH 6ROLGXV *ROG PP J K 6\UDFXVH
(,5,K E$6,/,66,, &URZQHG EXVW RI ,UHQH IDFLQJ ZHDULQJ
ORURV DQG KROGLQJ D JOREXV FUXFLJHU LQ KHU ULJKW KDQG DQG D
FURVVWLSSHG VFHSWHU LQ KHU OHIW 5HY (,5,K E$6,/, &URZQHG EXVW RI
,UHQHIDFLQJZHDULQJORURVDQGKROGLQJDJOREXVFUXFLJHULQKHUULJKW
KDQGDQGDFURVVWLSSHGVFHSWHULQKHUOHIWLQILHOGWROHIW&LQILHOGWR
ULJKW,$QDVWDVLYDUQRSHOOHWRQWKHREYHUVH&I'2& 6%
YDU QR OHWWHUV LQ WKH UHYHUVH ILHOGV ([WUHPHO\ UDUH 6KDUSO\
VWUXFNRQDIXOOIODQDVSOHQGLGSLHFH*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
318
2:1 2:1

1LFHSKRUXV,6ROLGXV*ROGPPJKXQFHUWDLQ
6LFLOLDQ PLQW SUREDEO\ 6\UDFXVH K,)2526 E$6 %HDUGHG
DQGIDFLQJEXVWRI1LFHSKRUXV,ZHDULQJFURZQZLWKDFURVVRQFLUFOHW
D FKODP\V DQG KROGLQJ D FURVV SRWHQW LQ KLV ULJKW KDQG DQG DQ
DQH[LNDNLDLQKLVOHIW5HY,K686;5,6786K,&$;&URVVSRWHQW
RQEDVHDQGWKUHHVWHSVWROHIWDQGULJKW&,$QDVWDVL'2&5RPD
VDPHGLHV6%6SDKU([WUHPHO\UDUHVKDUSDQGVWUXFN
RQDIXOOIODQDQH[FHSWLRQDOO\ILQHH[DPSOH9HU\PLQRUGLHUXVWDQG
319
2:1 2:1

1LFHSKRUXV , ZLWK 6WDXUDFLXV 6ROLGXV *ROG PP
JK6\UDFXVH1,)R5RVE$%HDUGHGIDFLQJEXVW
RI1LFHSKRUXV,ZHDULQJFURZQZLWKDFURVVRQFLUFOHWFKODP\VDQG
KROGLQJDFURVVSRWHQWLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGDQDQH[LNDNLDLQKLVOHIW
5HY67
$,Vǻ%HDUGOHVVIDFLQJEXVWRI6WDXUDFLXVZHDULQJFURZQ
ZLWKDFURVVRQFLUFOHWFKODP\VDQGKROGLQJDJOREXVFUXFLJHULQKLV
ULJKW KDQG DQG DQ DQH[LNDNLD LQ KLV OHIW $QDVWDVL YDU
LQVFULSWLRQ '2& 6% YDU 1LFHSKRURV ZHDULQJ D ORURV
([WUHPHO\UDUHVKDUSDQGZHOOFHQWHUHGRQDEURDGIODQ9LUWXDOO\DV
VWUXFN
(8523($10('$/6
,WDO\
320

3DGXD0LGWK&HQWXU\0HGDOOLRQ%URQ]HPPJK
E\ *LRYDQQL GD &DYLQR RQ 0DUFXV $XUHOLXV &DHVDU
$95(/,96 &$(6$5 $9* 3,, ) &26 , %DUHKHDGHG DQG
FXLUDVVHGEXVWRI0DUFXVWRULJKWZLWKGUDSHU\RQKLVIDUVKRXOGHU
5HY2QWKHULJKW0LQHUYDVWDQGLQJWROHIWUHVWLQJKHUOHIWKDQGRQD
VKLHOG LQVFULEHG 9,&$9* DQG SRLQWLQJ ZLWK KHU OHIW DW $UJRV
VHDWHGWRULJKWEHIRUHDEXLOGLQJZLWKDQDUFKHGGRRUZRUNLQJRQWKH
SURZ RI DJDOOH\WRKLVULJKW.ODZDQV/DZUHQFH0DUWLQL
EXWERWKRIWKRVHDUHODWHUDQGUDWKHUFRDUVHFDVWV$
SDUWLFXODUO\ VKDUS FRQWHPSRUDU\ VWUXFN H[DPSOH ZLWK D ILQH EURZQ
SDWLQD([WUHPHO\ILQH
)URPD(XURSHDQFROOHFWLRQDQGIURPWKHFROOHFWLRQRI/6WDFN0RUWRQ
(GHQ'HFHPEHUH[6WDFN
V&RLQ*DOOHULHV-XO\
1HWKHUODQGV
321

7KH'XWFK5HSXEOLF0HGDO6LOYHUPPJKRQWKH
PXUGHURIWKH'H:LWWEURWKHUV,//9675,66,0,)5$75(6
,2+$1(7&251(/'(:,7-XJDWHEXVWVRIWKH'H:LWWEURWKHUV
WR ULJKW 2Q WKH HGJH URVHWWH 9,2/(17$ 0257( '(/(7,
+$*&20,7,6$9*$
2 YLROHQWO\GRQHWRGHDWKLQ
WKH +DJXH $XJXVW 5HY :LWKLQ D ZUHDWK LQVFULSWLRQ RI
HLJKWOLQHV7ZHH:LWWHQHHQVJH]LQW*HYORHFNWJKHKDHWJHPLQW
7HQ VSLHJHO YDQ GH *URRWHQ 9HUKHYHQ HQ YHUVWRRWHQ ,Q DOOHV
/RWJHPHHQ 6WDHQ QDHU KXQ GRRW ELMHHQ *KHOLMFN ]LM KLHU QDH
W
OHYHQ =RR NRQVWLJ ]LMQ JHGUHYHQ 7KH WZR GH :LWWV DUH VKRZQ
KHUHDVWKH\ZHUHWKH\ZHUHHTXDOO\FXUVHGKDWHGORYHGUDLVHGXS
DQG KXUOHG GRZQ DQG WKH\ VHUYHG DV DQ H[DPSOH WR WKH KLJK DQG
PLJKW\$QLPDWHGZLWKWKHVDPHVSLULWWKH\VXIIHUHGWKHVDPHIDWH
701. 9DQ /RRQ ,,, SS LLL /RYHO\ WRQHG 0LQRU
HGJHPDUNVRWKHUZLVHH[WUHPHO\ILQH
322

7KH'XWFK5HSXEOLF0HGDO6LOYHUPPJKRQWKH
O\QFKLQJRIWKH'H:LWWEURWKHUVLQWKH+DJXHE\3$XU\"
,2+$11(6 '( :,77 1$7 $ &251(/,96 '(
:,771$7$%XVWVRIWKH'H:LWWEURWKHUVIDFLQJHDFKRWKHU
RQWKHOHIWDUPRUHGEXVWRI&RUQHOLXVIDFLQJULJKWRQWKHULJKWFLYLO
EXVW RI -RKDQQHV IDFLQJ OHIW EHORZ WKH EXVWV $95< )(& RQ
ULEERQIORDWLQJEHORZEXVWV+,&$50,60$;,096,//(72*$
RQH ZDV JUHDW LQ ZDU WKH RWKHU LQ SHDFH EHKLQG WKH KHDG RI
-RKDQQHV ,17(*(5 9,7$( LUUHSURDFKDEOH LQ KLV FRQGXFW
EHKLQGWKHKHDGRI&RUQHOLXV6&(/(5,649(39596 IUHHIURP
FULPH 5HY 181& 5('(817 $1,0,6 ,1*(17,$ &2168/,6
$&7$ (7 )250,'$7, 6&(375,6 25$&/$ 0,1,675, 1RZ
ZH UHFDOO WKH FKDUDFWHU RI WKH JUHDW GHHGV RI RXU EXUJRPDVWHU DQG
WKH VSHHFKHV RI RXU PLQLVWHU RI VWDWH PDGH NLQJGRPV WUHPEOH 7KH
'H :LWW EURWKHUV KHURLFDOO\ QXGH DWWDFNHG DQG NLOOHG E\ D
PDQ\ERGLHGPRQVWHUFRPSRVHGRIVDYDJHDQLPDOVEHDUEXOOERDU
XQLFRUQOLRQWLJHUDQGKRUVHEHORZOHIW$95<)DURXQGZUHDWK
HQWZLQHG ZLWK D ULEERQ LQVFULEHG 0(16 $&7,$7 02/(0 (7
0$*12 6( &25325( 0,6&(7 9LUJLO $HQHLG RQH
SULPDO0LQGLPPLQJOHGZLWKWKHYDVWDQGJHQHUDOIUDPHILOOVHYHU\
SDUW LQ H[HUJXH 12%,/( 3$5 )5$7590 6$(92 )9525
25( 759&,'$7 ;; $9*967, 7KLV QREOH SDLU RI EURWKHUV
ZDV SXW WR GHDWK E\ DQ LQKXPDQ IUHQ]\ $XJXVW ZLWK WKH
\HDU DV D FKURQRJUDP 6FKHU 7KH 3URXG 5HSXEOLF 701.
9DQ /RRQ ,,, SS 5DUH DQG RI JUHDW KLVWRULFDO
LPSRUWDQFH 6RPHZKDW SROLVKHG VXUIDFHV RWKHUZLVH H[WUHPHO\
ILQH
)UDQFH
1,5:1
323

5R\DO/RXLV;,9OH5RL6ROHLO±0HGDO%URQ]HPP
J K SDUFHO JLOW RU GDPDVFHQHG E\ -HDQ 0DXJHU
RQ WKH 7UHDW\ RI WKH 3\UHQHHV LQ /8'29,&86 ;,,,,
5(;&+5,67,$1,66,086%DUHKHDGRI/RXLV;,9WRULJKWXQGHU
QHFN WUXQFDWLRQ LQ VPDOO OHWWHUV -0$9*(5) 5HY 5(*90
&21*5(66,2 7KH NLQJV RI )UDQFH RQ WKH OHIW DQG 6SDLQ RQ WKH
ULJKW VWDQGLQJ IDFLQJ HDFK RWKHU FODVSLQJ WKHLU ULJKW KDQGV EHKLQG
WKHPODQGVFDSHZLWKEULGJHFURVVLQJWKHULYHU%LGDVVRDZKLFKIRUPHG
WKH )UDQFR6SDQLVK IURQWLHU LQ WKH 3\UHQHHV ,Q H[HUJXH 3$; $'
3,5(1$(26 0'&/; 'LYR YDU 3D[ LQ 1XPPLV YDU
VLOYHU JLOW 9DQ /RRQ ,, S 9HU\ UDUH 5DLVHG VXUIDFHV ZLWK
FRQWHPSRUDU\ SDUFHO JLOGLQJ UHPDLQLQJ VXUIDFHV ZLWK DQ DWWUDFWLYH
GHHSEURZQWRQLQJ*RRGH[WUHPHO\ILQH
$JUHDW)UHQFKVSHFLDOW\RIWKHODWHUWKDQGWKFHQWXULHVZDVWKHFDUHIXO
JLOGLQJ RI WKH UDLVHG VXUIDFHV RI EURQ]H PHGDOV WKDW ZHUH WKHQ XVHG DV
SUHVHQWDWLRQ SLHFHV HVSHFLDOO\ GXULQJ WKH UHLJQ RI WKH µ6XQ .LQJ¶ /RXLV
;,97KHFRORUFRQWUDVWEHWZHHQWKHEULJKWDQGSDOHJROGRQWKHUHOLHIDQG
WKH GHHS EURZQ RI WKH WRQHG EURQ]H RI WKH ILHOGV LV SDUWLFXODUO\ DWWUDFWLYH
WKH VDPH WHFKQLTXH ZDV XVHG IRU WKH OX[XU\ IXUQLWXUH DQG REMHWV G¶DUW WKDW
ZHUHVRFKDUDFWHULVWLFRIWKLVSHULRG
bo 18
.co b n
/o 20
ag em o
s
lo
os ec i
m e r
m D ct
u
ba
-
we
no r
w. be
w w ovem
N

zurich, switzerland
info@nomosag.com, www.nomosag.com
SWISS INTERNATIONAL COIN AUCTION AG
SINCONA AUCTIONS 48 – 53
22 – 25 OCTOBER 2018 · ZURICH
AUCTION 48 · 22 OCT. 2018

Russian Coins & Medals

THE KIAN COLLECTION
The finest collection of machine struck
Iranian coinage of the Qajar & Pahlavi
dynasties 1212 AH – 1320 SH
( 1797 – 1941 AD ).
One collection – 1 Lot
In cooperation with BALDWIN’S of St. James’s

SINCONA Jubilee Auction 50
AUCTION 51 · 23 – 24 OCT. 2018

World Coins & Medals
SINCONA Gold Auction
Swiss Coins & Medals

World Banknotes, Stocks
and Bonds
In cooperation with HIWEPA

The Collection of Ruedi Kunzmann
Part 2, Swiss Coins
www.sincona.com
SINCONA AG · Limmatquai 112, 8001 Zurich · T + 41 44 215 10 90 · F + 41 44 215 10 99 · info@sincona.com

auction 17
zurich, 26 october 2018
nomos 17

zähringerstrasse 27, 8001 zurich, switzerland
phone +41 44 250 51 80, info@nomosag.com
www.nomosag.com zurich, switzerland

Nomos 17

Hochgeladen von

Dokumentinformationen

Copyright

Verfügbare Formate

Dieses Dokument teilen

Dokument teilen oder einbetten

Freigabeoptionen

Stufen Sie dieses Dokument als nützlich ein?

Sind diese Inhalte unangemessen?

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

Nomos 17

Hochgeladen von

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

auction 17

zurich, 26 october 2018

nomos ag, numismatists

nomos ag, numismatists

zähringerstrasse 27, ch-8001 zürich, switzerland

Limmatquai 54, 8001 Zürich, Switzerland

time table – zeittafel – ordre de vente

viewing – besichtigung – exposition

the coins can also be viewed online at

during the auction live online bidding

Die Auktion erfolgt unter Mitwirkung eines

© 2018 Nomos AG, Zürich

Versteigerungsbedingungen Conditions générales de vente

All sales will be made through payment in Swiss

Buyers are personally responsible for their own

The lot descriptions, including the degree of

Shipping to the Russian Federation is expressly made

Exclusive jurisdiction for any legal proceedings shall

Dr. Alan S. Walker Dimitrios Gerothanasis

computers, notebooks, tablets and smartphones.

Alföldi M. R. Alföldi. Caesar in 44 v. Chr. Bonn, 1985

Herzfelder H. Herzfelder, Les monnaies d’argent de Rhegion. Paris, 1957.

Imhoof-Blumer F. Imhoof-Blumer. Kleinasiatische Münzen. Wien. 1901.

SC A. Houghton & C. Lorber, Seleucid Coins: A Comprehensive Catalogue. Lancaster,

Seltman C.T. Seltman, The Temple Coins of Olympia. Cambridge, 1921.

Manchester. Great Britain, Volume VII, Manchester University Museum. London.

)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ *RUQ\ 0RVFK2FWREHU

)URP D 6ZLVV FROOHFWLRQ H[ *LHVVHQHU 0Q]KDQGOXQJ  2FWREHU 

221 219 223

$W WKLV HDUO\ SHULRG LQ WKH KLVWRU\ RIFRLQDJHDGLHPDGHIRURQHGHQRPL

)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ +XVWRQ )3/  -DQXDU\)HEUXDU\

)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ &ODVVLFDO 1XPLVPDWLF *URXS  

)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ ERXJKW SULYDWHO\ IURP .LUN 'DYLV LQ

nomos ag, numismatists

AUCTION 48 · 22 OCT. 2018

AUCTION 49 · 23 OCT. 2018

AUCTION 50 · 23 OCT. 2018

AUCTION 51 · 23 – 24 OCT. 2018

AUCTION 52 · 25 OCT. 2018

AUCTION 53 · 25 OCT. 2018

SINCONA AG · Limmatquai 112, 8001 Zurich · T + 41 44 215 10 90 · F + 41 44 215 10 99 · info@sincona.com

nomos ag, numismatists

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen

)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ *RUQ\ 0RVFK2FWREHU

)URP D 6ZLVV FROOHFWLRQ H[ *LHVVHQHU 0Q]KDQGOXQJ 2FWREHU

$W WKLV HDUO\ SHULRG LQ WKH KLVWRU\ RIFRLQDJHDGLHPDGHIRURQHGHQRPL

)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ +XVWRQ )3/ -DQXDU\)HEUXDU\

)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ H[ &ODVVLFDO 1XPLVPDWLF *URXS

)URP WKH 9LQH\DUG &ROOHFWLRQ ERXJKW SULYDWHO\ IURP .LUN 'DYLV LQ