Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Practice
Carol A. Rauen, Mary Beth Flynn Makic and Elizabeth Bridges
Crit Care Nurse 2009;29:46-59 doi: 10.4037/ccn2009287
© 2009 American Association of Critical-Care Nurses
Published online http://www.cconline.org
Subscription Information
http://ccn.aacnjournals.org/subscriptions/
Submit a manuscript
http://www.editorialmanager.com/ccn
Email alerts
http://ccn.aacnjournals.org/subscriptions/etoc.shtml
Critical Care Nurse is the official peer-reviewed clinical journal of the American
Association of Critical-Care Nurses, published bi-monthly by The InnoVision Group
101 Columbia, Aliso Viejo, CA 92656. Telephone: (800) 899-1712, (949) 362-2050,
ext. 532. Fax: (949) 362-2049. Copyright © 2009 by AACN. All rights reserved.
Evidence-Based Practice
Habits: Transforming Research
Into Bedside Practice
Carol A. Rauen, RN, MS, CCNS, CCRN, PCCN
Mary Beth Flynn Makic, RN, PhD, CNS, CCNS
Elizabeth Bridges, RN, PhD, CCNS
A
ctions speak louder of research findings into practice.1
than words. If that The accreditation bodies starting
statement is true clin- to mandate and evaluate evidence-
ically, it could be said based practices may help move the
that nursing practice implementation of research forward.2
is more connected to tradition than We must create a culture of inquiry
it is evidence based. Many common in which nurses are not only aware
practices in critical care nursing of the current evidence but also are
continue today despite clear and applying it to practice and asking
reliable research that contradicts more questions about traditions
them. The barriers to research that should be supported or refuted
implementation that were identified with research.2 Such a culture of
3 decades ago—lack of time, insuffi- inquiry will help to improve patient
cient administrative support, and care and clinical outcomes.3
limited access to information—are This article is a published report
still daunting clinicians today.1 The of a 2008 session at the National
PRIME POINTS importance of basing practice on Teaching Institute and is the second
research is well understood. The report from that annual session on
barrier is the actual transformation evidence-based practice. We focus
• Positioning of patients on 4 areas common to everyday
for monitoring hemody-
critical care practice. Elizabeth
namic parameters.
CEContinuing Education Bridges addresses positioning of
patients for monitoring hemody-
• Can low-dose dopamine This article has been designated for CE credit. A
namic parameters. Mary Beth Flynn
prevent or be used to pre- closed-book, multiple-choice examination follows
this article, which tests your knowledge of the fol- Makic discusses 2 topics: (1)
vent or treat renal dys- lowing objectives:
whether low-dose dopamine pre-
function? 1. Identify the reference lines for the
phlebostatic axis vents or can be used to prevent or
2. Describe the best procedures for prevention
• How to prevent deep of venous thromboembolism
treat renal dysfunction and (2) pre-
vein thrombosis. 3. Discuss the fluid replacement guidelines vention of deep vein thrombosis.
established by the Surviving Sepsis Campaign
Carol A. Rauen describes the facts
• Facts and physiology of ©2009 American Association of Critical-
and physiology of fluid replace-
fluid replacement. Care Nurses doi: 10.4037/ccn2009287 ment. The clinical questions and
current body of evidence that can artery pressure (PAP) and central line from the fourth intercostal space
assist clinicians in moving research venous pressure (CVP) with the at the point where the space joins
to bedside practice are reviewed and patient in the flat and supine position the sternum, drawn out to the side
recommendations are outlined. compared with an alternative posi- of the body; second, a line drawn
tion greater than the spontaneous midway between the anterior and
Positioning Patients for variability in pressure? An exciting posterior surfaces of the chest.11 The
Hemodynamic Monitoring aspect of the evidence to answer phlebostatic level is a horizontal line
One challenge critical care nurses these questions is that most research through the phlebostatic axis. The
face is how to answer the question, on positioning of patients for moni- air-fluid interface of the stopcock of
does my patient need to lie flat for toring hemodynamic parameters has the transducer must be level with
hemodynamic monitoring? In order been conducted by nurse researchers. this axis for accurate measurements.
to address this challenge, a series of In patients with a normal chest wall
questions must be answered: (1) What Position-Specific Reference Level configuration, the midaxillary line is
is the correct reference level for a given Regardless of a patient’s body a valid reference level for the right
position? (2) Are studies in a given position, the key to accurate meas- and left atria; however, use of the
population of patients (eg, patients urements of hemodynamic parame- midaxillary line in patients with a
with heart failure, acute respiratory ters is the use of a position-specific different chest configuration may
distress syndrome [ARDS], sepsis, reference level to correct for hydro- result in a pressure difference of up
cardiac surgery) available that describe static pressure (Table 1, Figure 1). to 6 mm Hg.12 An alternative refer-
the differences in hemodynamic By convention, the phlebostatic axis ence point is 5 cm below the angle
parameters in the supine vs back- is the reference point for the right of the sternum. This reference point
rest elevated position or supine vs and left atria.4,5,7,10 The phlebostatic reflects the middle of the right atrium
lateral or prone position? (3) Are the axis is defined as the intersection of and remains the same up to 60º back-
observed differences in pulmonary 2 reference lines: first, an imaginary rest elevation.13 Use of this alternative
reference point, which is also recom-
mended for evaluation of jugular
Authors
venous distention, results in a CVP
Carol A. Rauen is an independent critical care clinical nurse specialist on the Outer Banks measurement that is 3 mm Hg lower
of North Carolina and is a staff nurse in the surgical intensive care unit at Washington than a CVP measured from a system
Hospital Center, Washington DC.
referenced to the phlebostatic axis.13,14
Mary Beth Flynn Makic is a researcher nurse scientist for critical care and an assistant
professor at the University of Colorado, Denver. In the lateral position, reference
Elizabeth Bridges is the clinical nurse researcher at the University of Washington Medical points have been validated for the
Center in Seattle and an assistant professor at the University of Washington School of 30º and 90º lateral positions with a
Nursing in Seattle. She is also a colonel in the US Air Force Reserve assigned to the 60th 0º backrest elevation5-7,15 (Table 1).
Medical Group at Travis Air Force Base, California.
In studies6,16-22 done to evaluate the
Corresponding author: Carol A. Rauen, RN, MS, CCNS, CCRN, PCCN, 104 Queen Mary Court, Kill Devil Hills,
NC 27948 (e-mail: carol.rauen@charter.net).
effects of a prone position on hemo-
To purchase electronic or print reprints, contact The InnoVision Group, 101 Columbia, Aliso Viejo, CA 92656.
dynamic parameters, the midaxil-
Phone, (800) 899-1712 or (949) 362-2050 (ext 532); fax, (949) 362-2049; e-mail, reprints@aacn.org. lary line or the midanteroposterior
20°
Lateral margin
of sternum Outermost point
of sternum 0°
Outermost point
of posterior chest
C D
30° Left lateral position 30° Right lateral position Right lateral decubitus position Left lateral decubitus position
Figure 1 Reference levels for various body positions. A, Supine/prone. The reference point is the phlebostatic axis, which is the
intersection of 2 reference lines: first, an imaginary line from the fourth intercostal space at the point where the space joins the
sternum, drawn out to the side of the body; second, a line drawn midway between the anterior and posterior surfaces of the
chest. B, Supine with the head of the bed elevated. The phlebostatic level is a horizontal line through the phlebostatic axis.
Measurements of pulmonary artery pressure and central venous pressure can be obtained at backrest elevations of up to 60°.
C, 30° lateral position. The reference point is one-half the distance from the left sternal border to the surface of the bed. (Based
on data from VanEtta et al.6) D, 90° lateral position. In the 90° right lateral position, the reference point is the intersection of the
fourth intercostal space at the midsternum. In the 90° left lateral position, the reference point is the intersection of the fourth
intercostal space at the left parasternal border.
Abbreviations: ICS, intercostal space; L, left; LA, left atrium; R, right.
A and B, Reprinted from Woods and Mansfield,8 with permission. ©Elsevier (1976).
C and D, Reprinted from Bridges and Woods,9 with permission.
diameter of the chest has been used to 60º if the patient’s legs are paral- position. Although PAP and CVP
as the reference point, although the lel to the floor (ie, the patient is not increase when patients are in the
accuracy of this reference has not sitting up with the legs in a depend- Trendelenburg position, neither
been validated. The reference point ent position).8,24-31 Thermodilution intrathoracic blood volume (pre-
should be marked on the patient’s cardiac output can be reliably meas- load) nor cardiac function increases.35
chest, and the air-fluid interface of ured with the head of the bed ele- No research has been done on the
the system should be leveled by using vated up to 20º.32,33 In one study,34 effect of the common practice of
a laser or carpenter’s level and not continuous cardiac output was elevating the head of the bed and
the “eyeball” method.23 measured with the head of the bed then placing the entire bed in the
elevated up to 45º. A limitation of Trendelenburg position to prevent
Effect of Position on this research is that it has involved the patient from sliding down in the
Hemodynamic Parameters primarily patients whose hemody- bed. Also, no research has been done
Supine, Head of Bed Elevated. namic condition was stable; thus, to directly evaluate the effect of use
Studies in a variety of patients in each patient’s response to a given of the reverse Trendelenburg position
medical-surgical and cardiac inten- body position should be evaluated. on PAP and CVP. However, compared
sive care units (ICUs) indicate that in Supine, Trendelenburg/Reverse with the supine position, a 15º pas-
general PAP and CVP can be obtained Trendelenburg. Hemodynamic meas- sive tilt decreases cardiac output by
reliably with a patient supine with urements should not be obtained 10%, and a 45º tilt decreases cardiac
the head of the bed elevated from 0º with patients in the Trendelenburg output by approximately 20%.36 This
Abbreviations: ALI, acute lung injury; ARDS, acute respiratory distress syndrome; CI, cardiac index; CO, cardiac output; CVP, central venous pressure; DO2, oxygen
delivery; DO2I, oxygen delivery index; EDV, end-diastolic volume; HR, heart rate; ITBVI, intrathoracic blood volume index; MAL, midaxillary line; MAP, mean arterial
pressure; Mid-AP, midanteroposterior chest diameter; PAM, mean pulmonary artery pressure; PAOP, pulmonary artery occlusion pressure; SV, stroke volume; SVI,
stroke volume index.
a P < .05 (prone vs supine measurement).
b Cardiac index, calculated as cardiac output in liters per minute divided by body surface area in square meters.
c Intrathoracic blood volume index, calculated as intrathoracic blood volume in milliliters divided by body surface area in square meters.
d Oxygen delivery index, calculated as oxygen delivery in milliliters per minute divided by body surface area in square meters.
e Stroke volume index, calculated as stroke volume in milliliters divided by body surface area in square meters.
widely accepted clinical practice for to prevent or treat renal dysfunction. Dopamine is a drug with diverse
preventing or treating renal dys- In fact, multiple studies59-63 have effects at multiple receptor sites in
function.59 Does this agent truly shown no evidence that dopamine the body; this endogenous cate-
protect the kidneys from acute dys- prevents renal dysfunction or pro- cholamine regulates cardiac, vascu-
function? The evidence does not vides renal protection, and the agent lar, and endocrine function.
support the use of low-dose dopamine may even be harmful for patients. Dopamine is a complex agent; the
b Cardiac index, calculated as cardiac output in liters per minute divided by treat renal dys- on the effectiveness of renal dose
body surface area in square meters. function began dopamine, the evidence indicates
to appear in the that low-dose dopamine temporar-
response to it depends on which literature in the ily improves renal output but does
receptors in the body are stimulated early 1990s. Denton et al65 wrote a
68
not prevent renal dysfunction or
(Table 5). Conventional dosing of classic article discussing the science death. Thus, the evidence is conclu-
dopamine suggests that low dosages related to renal dose dopamine. sive: use of low-dose dopamine
(0.5-3.0 μg/kg per minute) stimulate They reviewed the literature and does not prevent or improve renal
dopaminergic receptors and result discussed the findings from several dysfunction long-term in critically
in coronary and renal vasodilata- research studies in which low-dose ill patients.59,60,62,64-66 These findings
tion, natriuresis, and diuresis. dopamine augments renal blood should not be confused with
Midrange dosing (3-8 μg/kg per flow, glomerular filtration rate, and results of studies that examined
minute) activates β-adrenergic urine output in healthy humans. the effectiveness of higher doses of
receptors, increasing cardiac inotropy Denton et al,65 however, did not find dopamine in critically ill patients
and chronotropy. Dosages greater similar outcomes when critically ill with heart failure and septic shock.
than 8 μg/kg per minute predomi- patients were studied. They In such patients, dopamine is bene-
nantly stimulate α-adrenergic reported that most studies in ficial for its inotropic and vasoac-
receptors, resulting in splanchnic humans on the effects of renal dose tive properties.60,65
64-67
and peripheral vasoconstriction. dopamine and critical illness did So why does urine output increase
This conventional dosing is inaccu- not indicate an improvement in when a dopamine infusion is started?
rate. Research suggests that dopamine renal function and prevention of Dopamine has both natriuretic and
infusions at similar infusion rates acute renal failure. Denton et al diuretic properties that stimulate
produce different responses from discouraged the use of renal dose urine output, and the response
patient to patient.66 One explanation dopamine in critically ill patients to appears to be more pronounced at
of the variation in responses is that prevent or treat renal dysfunction. lower dosages.64,66,67 This response,
the activation of the receptor sites In a report published in 1999, however, is often temporary, and
depends more on the patient than Marik and Iglesias63 concluded that urine output tapers off within the
on the dose; thus the concept of giving low-dose dopamine to patients first 24 hours.62 Dopamine at doses
dose range affecting specific recep- with septic shock and oliguria did as low as 2 μg/kg per minute improves
tors is not universal for all patients.66,67 not lead to any significant differ- cardiac output and mean arterial
As a result, traditional dopamine ences in the incidence of acute renal pressure, enhancing renal perfusion
dosing should not be used as a stan- failure, need for dialysis, or 28-day and urine output.66-68
dard regimen. The desired effects survival. Then Kellum and Decker59 Concerns about the use of low-
of dopamine infusion depend on did a meta-analysis of the use of dose dopamine extend beyond the
the specific patient’s response to dopamine in acute renal failure. evidence that the drug is not effec-
the agent.59,64,66,67 They concluded that the use of low- tive in preventing renal dysfunction.
Compare hemodynamic parameters in supine, flat position with pressures from alternative position
PAS: Normal LV function: ± 5 mm Hg/Decreased LV function ± 7 mm Hg
PAEDP: Normal LV function: ±5 mm Hg/Decreased LV function ±6 mm Hg
PAOP: Normal LV function: ±4 mm Hg/Decreased LV function ±5 mm Hg
CO <10%
Yes No
Perform pressure/CO measurements with patient Perform pressure/CO measurements
in the alternative position with patient in the supine/flat position
Figure 2 Algorithm for research-based practice for measurement of central venous pressure, pulmonary artery pressures, and
cardiac output with the head of the bed elevated and the patient in lateral or prone position.
Abbreviations: AP, anteroposterior; BP, blood pressure; CO, cardiac output; ECG, electrocardiogram; HOB, head of bed; HR, heart rate; ICS, intercostal space; LV, left
ventricular; PAEDP, pulmonary artery end-diastolic pressure; PAOP, pulmonary artery occlusion pressure; PAS, pulmonary artery systolic pressure; SvO2, venous
oxygen saturation.
Adapted with permission from Gawlinski.57
Current evidence suggests low-dose hypercarbia.61,69,70 Administration of does not protect the kidneys from
dopamine may cause harm by wors- dopamine should be continually renal dysfunction.59,61,63
ening splanchnic oxygen consump- evaluated to match the dose to the
tion, impairing gastric motility, desired outcome without causing Prevention of Deep Vein
inducing tachyarrhythmias (espe- adverse consequences for the patient. Thrombosis: What Is Best?
cially in elderly patients), and blunt- Does renal dose dopamine Venous thromboembolism is the
ing ventilatory response to exist? No, it does not. Dopamine combined term that describes both
most common reasons cited for Prevention of venous throm- when the patient is admitted to
lack of proper prophylaxis of venous boembolism begins with assessment the unit.
thromboembolism include lack of of a patient’s risk factors. A venous Additional risk factors beyond
knowledge among providers, under- thromboembolism is an intravascu- venous stasis, immobility, and vas-
estimation of patients’ risk for venous lar fibrin clot that usually forms in cular injury should be included in
thromboembolism, and overestima- regions of slow or disturbed blood the assessment of each patient’s risk
tion of the potential risk of bleeding flow. Typically the clot forms in a for venous thromboembolism. Risk
associated with prophylaxis.74-77 large vein in the lower extremities, factors can be grouped in many ways
Prevention of venous thromboem- but it may form in any large vein and to include patient-specific variables,
bolism is considered a clear oppor- poses a great risk when it occludes a type of procedure a patient is under-
tunity for improving safe care of pulmonary vessel, potentially result- going (eg, orthopedic surgery), and
patients.77 Several national organi- ing in a fatal pulmonary embolism. reason for admission (eg, traumatic
zations and accrediting bodies list Classic risk factors for ICU patients event; Table 6). Top risk factors
the prevention of venous thromboem- are well known by nurses. The vari- include prolonged immobility,
bolism as a patient safety indicator ables are referred to as the Virchow including use of neuromuscular
and measure of quality of care or triad: venous stasis or obstruction, blockade and/or heavy sedation; an
“never events.”71,78 In 2003, The blood vessel injury, and increased indwelling central venous catheter;
American Public Health Associa- coagulability. Frequent procedures major surgery; cancer; active infec-
tion published guidelines to advance disrupt a patient’s vessels, and the tion; pregnancy; hormone therapy;
public awareness of DVT.76 Geerts fluid shifts, immobility, and coagu- obesity; respiratory failure; heart
et al75 published evidence-based lation disorders associated with crit- failure; cerebral vascular accident;
guidelines for the prevention of ical illness place ICU patients at high trauma (especially fractures of the
venous thromboembolism, and risk for venous thromboembolism. pelvis, hip, or leg); history of previ-
that seminal article was followed in DVT develops in up to 30% of ICU ous venous thromboembolism; and
2008 with practice guidelines for patients within the first week of older age (ie, risk increases in patients
antithrombotic therapy for venous admission, a characteristic that 40 years or older).75,81 The more risk
thromboembolism.79 Evidence is further emphasizes the importance factors a patient has, the more aggres-
available to guide practice for provid- of early interventions.80 To decrease sive the interventions should be.
ing interventions to prevent venous the prevalence of venous thromboem- Preventive actions are categorized
thromboembolism. The challenge is bolism, critical care nurses must as mechanical or pharmacological
to use this evidence in the daily evaluate each patient’s risk and interventions and are implemented
practice of critical care nursing. implement preventative interventions on the basis of the assessment of
•
d tmore
To learn more about fluid replacement, read
“Weaning Readiness and Fluid Balance in
need that will cause the least harm.
Nurses must continue to conduct
research to find a better answer.95
atrial level in relation to patient position
[abstract]. Heart Lung. 1987;16:334.
5. Kee LL, Simonson JS, Stotts NA, Skov P,
Schiller NB. Echocardiographic determina-
tion of valid zero reference levels in supine
Older Critically Ill Surgical Patients” by and lateral positions. Am J Crit Care. 1993;
2(1):72-80.
Carol Diane Epstein and Joel R. Peerless in Summary 6. VanEtta D, Gibbons E, Woods S. Estimation
the American Journal of Critical Care, of left atrial location in supine and 30 lateral
2006;15(1):54-64. Available at This article is the second article position [abstract]. Am J Crit Care. 1993;
www.ajcconline.org. published in Critical Care Nurse that 2(3):264.
1. Which of the following reference levels is used for measuring hemody- 7. Which of the following percentage of patients at risk for venous throm-
namic parameters in supine patients with the head of the bed (HOB) boembolism receives prophylactic therapy?
elevated? a. 25% c. 50%
a. Half of the anterior-posterior diameter of the chest at the second b. 33% d. 66%
intercostal space
b. Half of the anterior-posterior diameter of the chest at the third 8. Which of the following patients are at the highest risk for venous throm-
intercostal space boembolism?
c. Half of the anterior-posterior diameter of the chest at the fourth a. Patients younger than 40 years old who have had minor surgery
intercostal space b. Patients older than 40 years old who have with minor surgery and an
d. Half of the anterior-posterior diameter of the chest at the fifth additional risk factor
intercostal space c. Patients older than 60 years old with surgery
d. Age greater than 40 years with multiple risk factors
2. Which of the following HOB elevations provides reliable measurements
of pulmonary artery pressure and central venous pressure in supine 9. Evidence suggests that the most effective method for providing mechanical
patients? prevention of venous thromboembolism is which of the following?
a. 0° to 30° c. 0° to 60° a. Thigh-high compression stockings
b. 0° to 45° d. 0° to 90° b. Knee-high compression stockings
c. Intermittent pneumatic compression devices
3. Which of the following HOB elevations provides reliable measurements d. Compression stockings and compression devices
of thermodilution cardiac output?
a. 20° c. 45 10. Which of the following endpoints is used for fluid replacement in the
b. 30° d. 60° Surviving Sepsis Campaign guidelines?
a. Central venous pressure of 12 to 15 cm H2O
4. The reverse Trendelenburg position has which of the following effects b. Urine output greater than 1 mL/kg per hour
on hemodynamic parameters? c. Central venous oxygen saturation of 60%
a. Decreased pulmonary artery pressure d. Mean arterial pressure greater than 65 mm Hg
b. Decreased mean arterial pressure
c. Decreased central venous pressure 11. Which of the following is recommended as fluid replacement in the
d. Decreased cardiac output Surviving Sepsis Campaign guidelines?
a. 250 mL of colloids over 30 minutes
5. Which of the following dosages of dopamine activates beta-adrenergic b. 500 mL of colloids over 60 minutes
receptors, increasing cardiac inotropy and chronotropy? c. 1000 mL of crystalloids over 30 minutes
a. 1 to 3 μg/kg per minute d. 2000 mL of crystalloids over 60 minutes
b. 3 to 8 μg/kg per minute
12. Which of the following hemoglobin levels is recommended as a trigger
c. 8 to 12 μg/kg per minute
value for blood replacement in the Surviving Sepsis Campaign guidelines?
d. 12 to 16 μg/kg per minute
a. 6 to 7 g/dL
b. 7 to 9 g/dL
6. Current evidence suggests that low-dose dopamine can be harmful
c. 9 to 10 g/dL
due to which of the following?
d. 9 to 10 g/dL
a. Worsening splanchnic oxygen consumption
b. Excessive natriuresis and diuresis
c. Increased gastric emptying
d. Blunting ventilatory response to hypocarbia
Test answers: Mark only one box for your answer to each question. You may photocopy this form.
1. K a 2. K a 3. K a 4. K a 5. K a 6. K a 7. K a 8. K a 9. K a 10. K a 11. K a 12. K a
Kb Kb Kb Kb Kb Kb Kb Kb Kb Kb Kb Kb
Kc Kc Kc Kc Kc Kc Kc Kc Kc Kc Kc Kc
Kd Kd Kd Kd Kd Kd Kd Kd Kd Kd Kd Kd
Test ID: C092 Form expires: April 1, 2011 Contact hours: 1.25 Fee: AACN members, $0; nonmembers, $10.50 Passing score: 9 correct (75%) Category: CERP A Synergy CERP A
Test writer: John P. Harper, RN-BC, MSN
Program evaluation Name Member #
Yes No
Address
Objective 1 was met K K
Objective 2 was met K K City State ZIP
Objective 3 was met K K
Content was relevant to my Country Phone
For faster processing, take
nursing practice K K
this CE test online at E-mail
My expectations were met K K
www.ccnonline.org This method of CE is effective RN Lic. 1/St RN Lic. 2/St
(“CE Articles in this issue”) for this content K K
The level of difficulty of this test was: Payment by: K Visa K M/C K AMEX K Discover K Check
or mail this entire page to:
K easy K medium K difficult
AACN, 101 Columbia To complete this program, Card # Expiration Date
Aliso Viejo, CA 92656. it took me hours/minutes. Signature
The American Association of Critical-Care Nurses is accredited as a provider of continuing nursing education by the American Nurses Credentialing Center’s Commission on Accreditation.
AACN has been approved as a provider of continuing education in nursing by the State Boards of Nursing of Alabama (#ABNP0062), California (#01036), and Louisiana (#ABN12). AACN
programming meets the standards for most other states requiring mandatory continuing education credit for relicensure.