Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Abstract- Blood transfusions are routinely used to treat Microvascular perfusion is also dependent on blood viscosity
victims experiencing hemorrhagic shock. However, patients [12, 16]. Together, perfusion pressure and blood viscosity
often face the threat of life-threatening reactions to these determine blood flow which is essential to the delivery of
blood transfusions, which may also carry diseases from oxygen and nutrients and the removal of waste, which can
donors. Additionally, current blood supply will not be able to accumulate to create lethal toxicity levels [12, 14]. In fact,
sustain the current demand. As such, a possible solution to studies have found that the maintenance of functional
the inadequacies of the current system for allogeneic blood capillary density (FCD), or the number of capillaries with
transfusions would be the development of a blood substitute. blood flow per unit surface of tissue, determines survival
Currently, perfluorocarbon and hemoglobin based oxygen after hemorrhagic shock independent of oxygen delivery [12,
carriers are the blood substitutes furthest in development. 14-15].
Consequently, restoring circulating volume is the primary
However, due to side effects discovered in clinical trials, no
goal to treat hemorrhagic shock. Although the ideal volume
blood substitutes are currently approved in the U.S. restitution fluid, or plasma expander, has yet to be
ascertained, current practices use colloidal solutions, such as
I. INTRODUCTION albumin, and crystalloids, such as Ringers lactate or saline
[4]. For example, the Advanced Trauma Life Support
A. Necessity of Blood Transfusions guidelines recommend using crystalloid solutions, while the
American College of Surgeons recommends using albumin
Class
after trauma [4, 17].
Parameter I II III IV
Blood loss <750 750– 1500– >2000 2) Oxygen Delivery
(mL) 1500 2000 Impact of Insufficient Oxygen- In addition to lowered organ
Blood loss <15% 15–30% 30–40% >40% perfusion pressure and viscosity, a sudden loss of blood
(%) volume also lowers cardiac output. Since the amount of
Pulse rate <100 >100 >120 >140 oxygen delivered to tissues depends on cardiac output and
(beats/min) arterial oxygen content, a drop in circulating blood volume
Blood Normal Decreas Decreas Decreas results in decreased oxygen delivery [4]. When the total
oxygen concentration drops to a critical level (i.e. 2 mmHg
Pressure ed ed ed and 7 mmHg for the interstitial and intravascular partial
Respiratory 14–20 20–30 30–40 >35 pressure of oxygen respectively 1), cells switch to anaerobic
rate respiration [15]. However, as anaerobic metabolism yields
(breaths/min much less ATP, when ATP levels become insufficient to
) sustain membrane-associated ion transport pumps and other
CNS Normal Anxious Confuse Lethargi essential cellular functions, cellular swelling and acidosis
symptoms d c result- ultimately causing cell death, as shown in Figure 1
[4].
Table 1: Symptoms of hemorrhage classes. Modified from [4]
Figure 1: As circulating blood volume decreases, total oxygen hepatitis B and C viruses, human immunodeficiency virus
delivery also decreases. When over 30% of total blood volume is lost, (HIV), human T cell lymphotropic virus (HTLV), and
a critical point in total oxygen delivery is reached. At this point, cells syphilis [20-21]. Donor interviews and blood tests, such as
begin using anaerobic metabolism to generate ATP. When ATP nucleic acid testing, has dramatically reduced the risk of
supply is insufficient to meet cell demands, cell death occurs. infection in ABT recipients to 1 in 250,000 – 500,000 for
Modified from [4]
hepatitis B, 1 in every 1,600,000 for hepatitis C, and 1 in
Hemoglobin- Arterial oxygen content depends on the
every 1,800,000 for HIV [21-22]. At the same time, the
concentration of hemoglobin in the blood and the degree to
prevention of some infections, such as malaria, Chagas
which hemoglobin is saturated with oxygen [4]. Hemoglobin disease (also known as American trypanosomiasis), West
is a 64 kDa protein found in red blood cells, as shown in Nile virus (WNV), and severe acute respiratory syndrome
Figure 2. (SARS), is completely dependent on the veracity of donor
interviews. Additionally, these blood donor interviews reduce
an already shrinking pool of blood donors [21]. No standards
are available to detect and screen against prion diseases, such
as the fatal neurodegenerative disease variant Creutzfeldt-
Jakob disease (vCJD) [21-22]. In other words, current safety
measures do not completely prevent the transmission of
blood borne pathogens; overall, infectious diseases account
for 14.4% of transfusion-related deaths reported to the US
FDA since 2006 [23-24].
2) Noninfectious Dangers
Transfusion reactions pose a greater threat to ABT
recipients than infectious diseases [25]. One common
example of noninfectious complications is an acute
hemolytic transfusion reaction (HTR), or the destruction of
donor red blood cells by the recipient’s immune system
within 24 hours [24]. Acute HTR occurs due to an ABO
incompatible transfusion- the leading direct cause of
Figure 2: Structure of hemoglobin. Adult hemoglobin is composed of
4 polypeptides- specifically two α polypeptides and two β transfusion-related death Chen [24, 26-27]. The rate of
polypeptides. Modified from [2] mislabeled blood samples in the US is 1,000 to 10,000 times
greater than the risk of transfusion-transmitted viral
Each of the protein’s four polypeptide subunits attaches to a infection, with the risk of fatality under one in 1.5 million
heme molecule. Heme molecules are ring structures that transfusions [20]. Other noninfectious dangers include
reversibly bind to oxygen [18]. As the oxygen-transporter in transfusion-related acute lung injury, graft-versus-host
blood, hemoglobin’s binding affinity to oxygen rises with the disease, and anaphylactic reactions [20, 24, 28].
partial pressure of oxygen (pO2) in the environment in an
sigmoidal relationshipTherefore,
Blood Transfusions. [19]. the goal of transfusing red C.Blood Shortage
blood cells is to raise the hemoglobin concentration in the There is a projected shortage of 3 to 4 million units of
blood and thus the delivery of oxygen to tissues. During the blood per year in the US by 2020 due to blood’s limited shelf
last forty years, the standard treatment for trauma victims life and shrinking donor pool [29]. This estimated shortage
requires blood transfusion when circulating blood does not consider the impact of pandemics or wars.
hemoglobin has fallen between 6 and 8 g/dL, a value that is The number of suitable blood donors is shrinking. As
lower in young individuals and higher for the elderly. Blood potential blood-borne diseases are identified, restrictions are
raised, disqualifying potential donors from giving blood [24].
transfusions are also standard when 2L of blood volume
At the same time, given that about two thirds of all
expanders does not appear to affect the patient’s blood
transfusions in the US are associated with surgery, an
pressure [4]. However, many complications are associated increasing older population places increasing demand for
with allogeneic blood transfusion. blood [18].
B. Dangers of Allogeneic Blood Transfusion Blood, when refrigerated, has a shelf life of 42 days [29].
During this time, many changes occur including increased
Although there have been many advancements in
concentrations of lactate and potassium ions from 1 to 15
screening processes to improve the safety of allogeneic blood mM and 4 to 20 mM in three weeks respectively. At the
transfusions (ABT), there are still many hazardous infectious same time concentrations of glucose and ATP are reduced
and noninfectious complications. These complications can [25]. In fact, the pH drops from 7.4 to 6.9 within a few hours,
lead to death or longer, and more expensive, ICU stays [7]. which lowers hemoglobin’s affinity to oxygen [3]. Perhaps
1) Infectious Hazards the most alarming change is the reduction of 2,3-
Although blood screening has dramatically reduced the diphosphoglycerate (DPG), which lowers hemoglobin’s
chances of acquiring diseases from blood transfusion, the risk binding affinity to oxygen, allowing the release and delivery
to ABT recipients has not been eliminated; additionally, of oxygen to tissues [25, 29]. With the exception of rare
present tests cannot effectively detect new blood-borne blood types, exhaustive efforts to rejuvenate outdated RBCs
pathogens. Currently, all donated blood is screened for
Topics in Bioengineering, Fall 2010 3
are often foregone in favor of discarding expired blood units protection, of the carbon skeleton. Additionally, in this
[3, 25]. helical configuration, fluorine’s strong attraction for
electrons causes the C-C bonds to shrink- raising the C-C
D.Blood Substitutes
bond energies. Since single bonds between carbons and
1) Necessity of a Blood Substitute fluorines are also very strong, no low energy orbitals are
The creation of a substitute for the oxygen-carrying readily available for reactions [1]. Consequently, the
capacities of red blood cells could eliminate the issue of substitution of hydrogens with fluorines results in a very
blood shortages and make blood transfusions safer. chemically stable and inert molecule [1, 5, 7, 28, 31].
Additionally, the creation of a blood substitute could allow 2) Impact of Nonpolarity
surgical procedures that require blood transfusions to take PFCs are nonpolar due to fluorine’s low polarizability and
place in rural and third world countries, and treatments to be the symmetrical structure of fluorocarbons. This nonpolar
given to those who would normally refuse blood transfusions character contributes to PFCs’ ability to dissolve oxygen and
on the basis of their religion or culture, as in the case of biological inertness [1]. However, since nonpolar substances
Jehovah’s witnesses [30]. In fact, the sheer potential of blood cannot dissolve in water, an emulsifier is needed for PFCs to
substitutes has been recognized- annual prospective sales for be used as an artificial oxygen carrier.
blood substitute are at twelve billion dollars [29]. Oxygen Delivery Ability- The ability of perfluorocarbons
2) Design Requirements to deliver oxygen is rooted in its capacity to dissolve oxygen.
The ideal blood substitute should be safe, convenient, and Since it is difficult to polarize fluorine, the electron cloud of
economical. Safe blood substitutes should be pathogen-free, PFCs as a whole does not have many fluctuations in polarity.
non-toxic, and nonimmunogenic. For convenience’s sake, As a result, not many van der Waals forces develop in
blood substitutes should have universal compatibility, an between PFCs. Given that nonpolar molecules are only held
extended shelf life (compared to packed red blood cells), and together by van der Waals interactions, the intermolecular
be easily administrated and transported. For wide-spread use, forces in PFCs are low - allowing liquid PFCs to act like a
blood substitutes should also be cost-effective [5, 29, 31]. gas and dissolve other gases of low cohesivity [1].
3) Current Types Although PFCs can dissolve 100 times more oxygen than
Presently, there are two types of artificial oxygen carriers, or blood plasma, its ability to carry oxygen is still much less
blood substitutes, undergoing clinical trials: hemoglobin efficient than hemoglobin’s at alveolar pO2, as shown in
(Hb)-based oxygen carriers (HbOCs) and perfluorocarbon- Figure 4 [31]. To improve oxygen-saturation in PFCs,
based oxygen carriers (PFCOCs). environmental pO2 is raised artificially by having patients
breath 70-100% oxygenated gas [28].
II.PERFLUOROCARBON-BASED OXYGEN CARRIERS (PFCOCS)
3) Current Status
No HBOCs are approved for clinical use in the US and many
clinical trials have been placed on hold by the FDA due to
the observed side-effects [39]. In 2001, Hemopure was
approved for clinical use in South Africa by the Ministry of
Health [7].
IV. CONCLUSION
While the development of artificial oxygen carriers may
bring a solution to the threats of a diminishing blood supply
and transfusion-related dangers, the process of this
development has illuminated topics that needed, and still
need, greater understanding. In particular, these topics
include the toxicity mechanisms of HBOCs and PFCOCs [6,
33]. From a logistical standpoint, the investigation into
blood substitutes has also shown the need for increased
transparency from the FDA and companies; currently, the
FDA mandates that all material, submitted by a company
Figure 7: Four methods of improving molecular stability: (1) cross- during the development of a product, is to be treated as
linking between polypeptides, (b) polymerization, (c) modifying the confidential. Data from clinical trials is only provided
surface of hemoglobin – usually with polyethylene glycol (PEG), and through press releases and advisory committee presentations
(d) encapsulating hemoglobin in liposomes. Image modified from [3] [39]. Many details, such as the methods used in the trials, are
and [8]. often unavailable. This purposeful obscuration of safety and
effectiveness data has hampered the improvement of AOCs
to the frustration of many [39-41]
REFERENCES
Biophysica Acta (BBA) - Proteins & Proteomics, 2008. 1784(10): 39. Natanson, C., et al., Cell-Free Hemoglobin-Based Blood
p. 1421-1427. Substitutes and Risk of Myocardial Infarction and Death: A Meta-
16. Tsai, A.G., et al., Plasma viscosity regulates capillary perfusion analysis. JAMA, 2008: p. 299.19.jrv80007.
during extreme hemodilution in hamster skinfold model. American 40. Akira, T.K., Artificial Oxygen Carriers: A Clinical Point of View,
Journal of Physiology - Heart and Circulatory Physiology, 1998. in Artificial Organs. 2009, Wiley-Blackwell. p. 97-99.
275(6): p. H2170-H2180. 41. Hess, J.R., Deconstructing hemoglobin-based oxygen carriers, in
17. Spinella, P.C., et al., Effect of Plasma and Red Blood Cell Transfusion. 2008, Wiley-Blackwell. p. 2051-2052.
Transfusions on Survival in Patients With Combat Related
Traumatic Injuries. The Journal of Trauma, 2008. 64(2): p. S69-
S78 10.1097/TA.0b013e318160ba2f.
18. Anbari, K.K., J.P. Garino, and C.F. Mackenzie, Hemoglobin
substitutes. European Spine Journal, 2004. 13(0): p. S76-S82.
19. Sadava, D., Hillis, D., Heller, C., Berenbaum, M., Life: The
Science of Biology. 9th ed. 2009, Sunderland, MA: Sinauer
Associates, Inc. 140, 1037-1038.
20. Alter, H.J. and H.G. Klein, The hazards of blood transfusion in
historical perspective. Blood, 2008. 112(7): p. 2617-2626.
21. Dodd, R.Y. and D.A. Leiby, Emerging Infectious Threats to the
Blood Supply. Annual Review of Medicine, 2004. 55(1): p. 191-
207.
22. Busch, M.P., S.H. Kleinman, and G.J. Nemo, Current and
Emerging Infectious Risks of Blood Transfusions. JAMA, 2003.
289(8): p. 959-962.
23. Vamvakas, E.C. and M.A. Blajchman, Blood Still Kills: Six
Strategies to Further Reduce Allogeneic Blood Transfusion-
Related Mortality. Transfusion Medicine Reviews, 2010. 24(2): p.
77-124.
24. Vamvakas, E.C. and M.A. Blajchman, Transfusion-related
mortality: the ongoing risks of allogeneic blood transfusion and
the available strategies for their prevention. Blood, 2009. 113(15):
p. 3406-3417.
25. Ketcham, E.M. and C.B. Cairns, Hemoglobin-Based Oxygen
Carriers: Development and Clinical Potential. Annals of
Emergency Medicine, 1999. 33(3): p. 326-337.
26. Chen, J.-Y., M. Scerbo, and G. Kramer, A review of blood
substitutes: examining the history, clinical trial results, and ethics
of hemoglobin-based oxygen carriers. Clinics, 2009. 64: p. 803-
813.
27. O'Neill, E., Richardson-Weber, L., McCormack, G., Uhl, L.,
Haspel, R., Strict Adherence to a Blood Bank Specimen Labeling
Policy by All Clinical Laboratories Significantly Reduces the
Incidence of “Wrong Blood in Tube. Coagulation and Transfusion
Medicine, 2009. 132: p. 164-168.
28. Barbosa, F.T., et al., Artificial oxygen carriers as a possible
alternative to red cells in clinical practice. Sao Paulo Medical
Journal, 2009. 127: p. 97-100.
29. Simoni, J., Artificial Oxygen Carriers: Scientific and
Biotechnological Points of View, in Artificial Organs. 2009, Wiley-
Blackwell. p. 92-96.
30. Everts, S., ARTIFICIAL BLOOD. Chemical & Engineering News,
2009. 87(8): p. 52-55.
31. Cohn, C.S. and M.M. Cushing, Oxygen Therapeutics:
Perfluorocarbons and Blood Substitute Safety. Critical Care
Clinics, 2009. 25(2): p. 399-414.
32. Ferguson, E., et al., Acceptability of blood and blood substitutes.
Journal of Internal Medicine, 2008. 263(3): p. 244-255.
33. Winslow, M., Robert M., NEW TRANSFUSION STRATEGIES: Red
Cell Substitutes. Annual Review of Medicine, 1999. 50(1): p. 337-
353.
34. Lippi, G., M. Montagnana, and M. Franchini, Ex-vivo red blood
cells generation: A step ahead in transfusion medicine? European
Journal of Internal Medicine. In Press, Corrected Proof.
35. Buehler, P.W., F. D'Agnillo, and D.J. Schaer, Hemoglobin-based
oxygen carriers: from mechanisms of toxicity and clearance to
rational drug design. Trends in Molecular Medicine, 2010. 16(10):
p. 447-457.
36. Harris, D.R. and A.F. Palmer, Modern cross-linking strategies for
synthesizing acellular hemoglobin-based oxygen carriers.
Biotechnology Progress, 2008. 24(6): p. 1215-1225.
37. Huang, K., Keszler, A., Patel, N., Patel, R., Gladwin, M., Kim-
Shapiro, D., Hogg, N., The Reaction between Nitrite and
Deoxyhemoglobin. The Journal of Biological Chemistry, 2005.
280(September 2): p. 31126-31131.
38. Gaucher-Di Stasio, C., et al., The importance of the effect of shear
stress on endothelial cells in determining the performance of
hemoglobin based oxygen carriers. Biomaterials, 2009. 30(4): p.
445-451.