Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Individual Assignment
I, Huy Sokleap, hereby certify that the written reviews are of my own work and
where there are referencing texts and or supports paragraphs, they are quoted
accordingly.
Sokleap.
1
Around the Blue Ocean Concept:
Dive into the business ocean of an underdeveloped country of
Cambodia with the mind-set and creativity of value-innovation
By HUY Sokleap
Abstract
Several previous works on strategies to pursue the underdeveloped market and population
has changed paradigms about poverty. Therefore, structuring the entry into
resources, capabilities and strategic model. This paper is then to hope for introducing the
from the perspectives of blue ocean strategy in terms of the mind-set, analysis tools and
The aim of this paper is not to give on prescriptions, but to introduce and create the ideas
about the opportunities available (within the Cambodia market) to companies to build
business that are able to achieve real value challenges for the companies’ benefits and the
Keywords: Blue ocean concepts tools and frameworks, underdeveloped countries, deep
poverty, Cambodia, underdeveloped markets creation, Innovation, Creativity, manager’s
mind-set, poverty alleviation, social entrepreneur.
2
Introduction
Looking at Cambodia
Cambodia is governed by Hun Sen Prime Minister since 14 January 1985 1 until now it
has slowly grown up but it can grow more. Phnom Penh is the capital city of Cambodia.
It has a small size if compare with Hong Kong or Beijing. It is bordered with Thailand to
the north and west, Laos to the northeast, and Vietnam to the east and southeast.
it is developing. A better picture is to imagine about the place where it would be like in
the past 20 years of Bangkok or the past 50 years of London. What’s happening now in
Cambodia is a place that every thing is just starting to emerge in all different industries
activities, hospitality, and more. Cambodia is a small country and has a small Phnom
Penh City indeed, but it a new space – a new ocean – a new opportunity for the
businesses.
Looking from a company point of view, an extreme case of dilemma exists due to the fact
that Cambodia is an underdeveloped country, where mass poverty means that even the
most basic needs of millions of people are not met and markets to serve them are largely
there are competitions that have optimized the price/benefit ratios for their consumers and
their people. Thus enables their people to consume more of the things they want and not
just what they need to survive – an important driver of choice and perceived quality of
1
Sited from http://www.statemaster.com/encyclopedia/Prime-Minister-of-Cambodia.
3
life. Therefore, in the context of deep poverty – by which we mean countries with low
economic wealth creation and significant clusters of people living below recognized
poverty lines, such as Cambodia with daily incomes of less than two US dollars –
First, there could indeed be no markets that a company can enter and an entry decision
might thus revolve more around how to build markets than to enter them; second, doing it
alone might not be feasible, given that company resources and capabilities have evolved
context; and third, the absence of markets translates into a lack of local companies with
which it would be feasible to from the kind of partnerships that might be needed to
The nonexistence of markets for many goods and, indeed, of whole industries in
creating a market space. Though, these ideas sound persuasive in theory, finding ways to
enact them determines success and failure (Seelos and Mair 2006).
There has been preceding efforts on strategies to pursue business opportunities in the
underdeveloped countries. These have helped shift paradigms about poverty (Prahalad
and Hart, 2002) and have intrigued about the concept of viewing the poor as customers
4
and not merely the recipients of donations. However, there still require “some model” for
companies to accomplish this idea (Seelos and Mair 2006). In about 40 years later, it is
estimated that 2.2 billion more people will populate this planet, but only 2.6% of them
will live in high-income countries (the World Bank, 2009). Therefore, these people will
have considerably lesser buying power and they will not be reachable through traditional
corporate channels. As this intriguing matter continues, two questions arise in evaluating
There have been repeatedly urges and communications for why companies should think
about underdeveloped markets (Prahalad and Hammond, 2002; Seelos and Mair, 2005a).
As the existing markets for those high income well developed countries are at declining
growth and fast commoditization, it has created the tensions and twists on managerial
create value (Kim and Maugborne 2005). Cost cutting, reorganizations and layoffs aim to
increase efficiencies and productivity, but may also limit creativity and innovativeness
(Seelos and Mair 2006). By recognizing this, it is an encouragement towards doing the
On the other hand, there is a multifaceted set of issues might explain the lack of
poor, levels of political and economic uncertainties, and many others. Moreover,
5
resources and capabilities that companies have developed in their mature markets maybe
successfully act in such a context and it could be difficult and might take a very long time
to build them. Therefore, a question arises as in how can companies create and occupy
Among the proposed strategies, Christensen and Raynor (2003) have introduced some
concepts and ideas to escape the hyper competition and lack of growth in context of
instead of focusing and obsessing with the existing customers and markets that are “core”
would help to create products and services that fundamentally new quality/price relation
to satisfy a customer need. This could well be an ideal framework from looking at poor
countries, such as Cambodia, where innovation and low-end disruption might be the only
ways to serve the poor people – the customers (Hart and Chirstensen, 2002). Moreover,
Kim and Mauborgne (2004) have suggested creating and occupying new market space
that is just emerging from the war state, there is ultimate opportunity for creating a new
market space in the absence of markets for many goods in the whole industries of the
country.
6
There are many different concept, ideas, tactics and strategies that have been created,
advised, recommended and implement to try to answer how a company should act in
order to capture this context. This paper is then hoped to contribute to a better
space as a blue ocean and access that ocean through blue ocean strategy with an
opportunity for innovation and benefit for the poor as well as the companies.
Kim and Maugborne of Instead Business School have defined the term “Blue oceans” as
all the industries that do not exist. It is the unknown market space and untainted by
competition. In blue oceans, demand is created rather than fought over. There is ample
opportunity for growth. Blue Ocean is a parallel to describe the wider, deeper potential of
market space that is not yet explored 2. With this, the underdeveloped markets (the
Cambodia’s market) is in line with the definition since there are many opportunities,
boundaries and making the competition irrelevant, rather than competing on established
ground. Quoted from the book 3, it is “geared towards creating ‘new market space’ and
encompasses the entire value chain of product, service delivery, costs and pricing, instead
of merely looking at any one function.” By entering the underdeveloped markets, the
2
www.innofuture.com.au. FAQ of BLUE OCEAN STRATEGY. PDF
3
Kim and Maugborne (2005): The Blue Ocean Strategy
7
company is searching for different-new markets, thereby creating new markets with
Under blue ocean strategy, there have many sets of analytical tools and frameworks for
executing the strategy in practice and also lines of thought about ways of executing the
strategy process. Below are the listed principles, frameworks and tools that a manager
could use to tackle the blue ocean strategy (Zainal Abidin Mohamed 2007):
All these concepts and approaches are to assist the company to find its place – creating
the blue ocean. In creating the blue ocean, they then can explore creativity while
searching relevant local resources and capabilities that entrepreneurial pioneers have
already built instead of building them from scratch. However, it is the manager himself,
who after become aware of the strategy, believe in the need to adopt the approach and the
8
strategy so that the company be benefit and at the same time increasing the Cambodia
Blue ocean strategists recognize that “market boundaries exist only in managers’ minds,
and they do not let existing market structures limit their thinking” (Kim and Maugborne
2004). If they look beyond, in this case is to look into the underdeveloped countries, to
them there are further demand out there that are mostly unexploited. Therefore, back to
the core of the dilemma is “how” to create the market, is in turn, requires a change of
mind and attention from supply to demand, from a focus on competing to a focus on
creating innovative value to unlock new demand and serve the people (the poor people).
By expanding the demand side of the economy, hopefully within the underdeveloped
countries, new wealth is created both sides – the company and the people. This paper will
look at Blue Ocean Principles and frameworks in three paths (Pitta, D. 2009):
1. A requirement for a new mindset - how companies put their mind set (by taking
the risk) into this context of deep poverty country to believing it as a blue ocean,
2. Analysis (exploring some concepts and tools mentioned above) - how resources
and capabilities contributed by both the companies and the local pioneers can be
configured into novel business model that satisfy both the needs of the poor and
9
Mindset
There are three ways to start the thinking of blue ocean strategies. The first way is to
redefine an industry and focus on non-customers (Kim and Mauborgne 2004 & 2005). By
creating offerings that are relevant to non-customers (in this case is the poor people), the
companies are looking to new markets and attract business that traditional competitors
did not. There are six paths frameworks to follow in order to reconstruct market
boundaries as Kim and Mauborgne suggested. The six paths are as listed below;
(Hongyul Yoon):
The second approach is to lock their mind to create total solutions. Companies should
sell products that solve problems or supply benefits. Hearsay, is about looking beyond the
benefits customers’ need. In other perspective, it is the approach that the competitors do
not provide or look into the market. In underdeveloped market space, this is the approach
10
In the third way, the companies would need to give attention to the tradeoffs that they
would face. In searching for the balance between price, features, and benefits, the
companies would yield a particular mix for a particular segment (Kim and Maugborne
2009). Tracing back, the balance is based on conventional views of customer needs that
may no longer be relevant but are frozen by factors like sunk costs, established
distribution, and competitive activity. By breaking the compromises within the existing
industry, the companies might de-segment a market to find the underserved, in other
word; they will discover the potential market of the poor to serve the poor while
Setting the mind within this context of deep poverty, would call for the vision and the
willingness to take risks and discard traditional tested methods and targets as important.
Several of the old analytic tools are well suited to determine the efficiency or
effectiveness of the business competitive field (Pitta, D. 2009). However, given this new
way to look into the marketplace, another “task of analysis” is used. It is the task of
analyzing consumer wants, in terms of that “are they currently met and discerning unmet
needs?” The tool that focuses on identifying these unmet needs “issue” is called the
strategy canvas.
(Kim and Mauborgne, 2004). It lists on those elements such as product, service, and
11
delivery, hereinafter simplified as product. It is for analyzes and uncovers all the features
of a product and how much is the consumer’s need. In its graph, the x-axis is made up of
the industry’s significant factors of competition (and is discrete in nature) whilst the y-
always a comparison between the company’s relative score against other players in the
Moreover, another tool is use to challenge an industry’s strategic logic and business
model. It is called the four action framework. It comprise of four set of question as
follows: 1.Which of the factors that the industry takes for granted should be eliminated?
2. Which factors should be reduced well below the industry’s standard? 3. Which factors
should be raised well above the industry’s standard? and 4. Which factors should be
created that the industry has never offered? (Kim and Mauborgne, 2005, p28-37).
Companies begin the method by answering these questions to set up the 'value curve' of
the industry they manage in and then categorize how they can differentiate themselves
from their competitors by ‘eliminating, reducing, raising and creating’ key elements
within their core offering to their customer and noncustomer groups and hence creating a
new value curve which is significantly differentiated from their generic industry value
curve.
Armed with the non-customer assessment of their “needs” level of each attribute, the
company could plot a strategy that would appeal to a group of non-customers, (in this
case are the poor people). The hope is that the strategy would allow reducing the
12
company’s cost structure (low-cost) while delivering the enhanced value to its target
customers (differentiation). This requires creativity as the two criteria of “low-cost and
differentiation” would be added to the strategy canvas for adjusting the relative offering
levels.
Creativity
This differentiation and low cost is about creating exceptional value for the buyer and
compelling profit for the companies. Therefore, the core element is the third element -
creativity, is vital to serve new customers (the poor people) in new ways.
It is the creativity of a company to move away from the traditional product differentiation
of trying to produce and supply with the companies’ production equipments, resources
and logistics available to blue ocean strategy of demand based in term of what customer
want to may want; how can a product give real value for clients? Creativity plays a focal
Joining in value-innovation
Creativity is innovation, and innovation is creativity. It is “an essential concept is that the
innovation (in product, service, or delivery) must raise” 4 and create value for the market,
or eliminating features or services that are less valued for this kind of market. This is the
13
5
“Value innovation places equal emphasis on value and innovation” (Leavy B. 2005).
competition-based strategy, which is the trade-off between value and cost. “It is
conventionally believed that companies can either create greater value to the customers at
higher cost or create reasonable value at a lower cost” (Kim and Maugborne 2005). With
value-innovation, companies don’t have to give off value for cost or cost for value,
instead, they need to create (using their willingness, assessment and creativeness) to raise
value for the poor, people who are the companies’ new non-customers, and simply
Creativity is a constant element of any human action. It is the motor of human action. The
driving force of creativity may be passion for the new – and for creation itself.
Happenings of creativity keep moving like waves in an ocean – endlessly. Thus the
improvement; easier use, better function, and better life for the poor and simultaneously
create the benefits for the company’s value and profits as well.
Real challenges for creative forces – an opportunity for blue oceans in Cambodia
value innovator are unlimited (Virpi Haavisto). A great challenge for the company is to
recognize the creative ideas. In underdeveloped countries level, there exist plenty of
5
See also: Kim, W.C. and Mauborgne, R. (2005), “Value innovation: a leap into the blue
ocean”, Journal of Business Strategy, Vol. 26 No. 4, pp. 22-8.
14
serious problems to be solved, care of lonely and marginalized people, health services
Cambodia, illiteracy and un-educated give rise to numerous challenges to the society.
Tackling these social issues can open up to real challenges for creativeness which open
for opportunity in creating the market. If a company is to have an open question “What
may a human being want? Basic needs for the poor?” ends up with a larger certainty in a
clear blue ocean than a question “How should we differ our product to get it better in the
eyes of a client than the ones of the competitors?” The mind-set surrounded in the first
It would be imperative to start the use of creativity and blue ocean strategy making
towards real problems of societies and populations, such a case like underdeveloped
countries (i.e. Cambodia), not only the ones of business. That is a huge challenge for the
people in power; leaders, managers and decision-makers – both in business and politics
(Kirkpatrick, D. 2001).
A real world blue ocean strategy case of Cambodia would be to turn the fact of illiteracy
and basic needs into an advantage to exploit investments. The central questions might be
the following:
How to secure equal possibilities for good health-care and education for every
citizen?
15
How to keep tax-flow sufficient for the poor and the companies?
The center of blue ocean strategy making is “in the thinking about the human beings and
their needs” (Haavisto Virpi 2006). With this positive mind-set, attitude, and idea, given
the context of underdeveloped countries such as Cambodia, can lead to ultimately good
results, and also strengthen responsibility in individual, societal and worldwide level
(Haavisto Virpi 2005). “In Aristotle’s words, in true value-innovation lies a potential for
a good life”
From this, a company could manage to see that there is a possibility of altering the
business playing field. It takes a mindset that conditions can be changed. Past success or
the value of companies that have achieved success shouldn’t be constraint the mind-set
toward entering the underdeveloped market. As a matter of fact, within the undeveloped
market the resources and capabilities could be sought locally, creativity and cheaply
(UNDP 2009)6. Thus, success can be achieved with the willingness to change, a great
deal of courage and internal persuasion. In the process, it also requires the use of new
analytical tools that could show series of the product characteristic that need to be
provided and served. The strategy canvas can show the overall picture of products and
which of their attributes need to change. Where as the four action frameworks can tackle
6
Cambodia Economic Forum UNDP (2009), “Cambodia Competitiveness Study”, Overseas Development
Institute Presentation Case.
16
answers to how to produce picture of those products. Finally, it requires a great deal of
creativity in context of value-innovation, real value challenges, humanity and social costs
and contributions7.
Build relationships, connections, and networking with the locals and its social
Analyze the local business models and examine how they are creating resources
that could support a joint effort in targeting the large underdeveloped customer
base in poor countries. Think about what organizational structures would best
Invest in the most promising initiative in the form of “social venture capital”.
They could e maximizing social impact from your capital while you are buying an
7
Furthur readings: Prahalad, C. K. and A. Hammond (2002), Prahalad, C. K. and A. Hammond (2002), and
Cambodia Economic Forum UNDP (2009)
8
Collaborate from Seelos C. and Mair, J. (2006), Feeney, Don. and Minor, Peter. (2007), and Cambodia
Economic Forum UNDP (2009)
17
option that the initiatives you are funding will create strategic resources on which
For Investment in Cambodia, it is preferable for only those requisites and basic everyday
uses. This country is far from fashion and luxurious thing. Every idea you have to thank
about it is really important for life and make it in better quality is the solution. This is an
exciting city; it has a lot of opportunity for investment in Cambodia (Souen Say, 2008).
This paper could have conduct case analysis, with many more examples of collaborative
efforts to learn and understand how a company has been structured and managed within
mentioning this, it remains to be seen that to how far the extent of the blue ocean strategy
described here are just some observations or recommendation that could become a
possible start-up on the thinking (in mind-set), strategy, and or model for companies to
build a large-scale market presence that is positively driven by but also positively drives
Conclusion
Within this paper context of deep poverty, the aim of blue ocean strategy is to find what
products and concept are needed and serves people as well as possible. Companies get
their share via a good selling. Customers (the poor people) get what they need and
companies get their bit according to market economy in terms of good results. Blue ocean
18
Using blue ocean strategy of creative and value innovation concept, business manager
can challenge their mind-set while using the blue ocean strategy frameworks and tools to
explore their creativity. Therefore insights are generated into how to structure and
execute the business to the poor people to generate the necessary profits for companies to
justify investments into market entry and market building, while at the same time
integrating and serving the poorest and their unique needs as well.
On one point, the blue ocean strategy can be beneficial to companies, businesses,
practical approach to create the ideas that will lead to breakthrough profitable growth. At
another point, in the heart of blue ocean strategy making is in thinking about the human
beings and their needs. That is a positive idea which in goods cases can lead to ultimately
good results, and also strengthen responsibility in individual, societal and worldwide
level.
19
References:
4. Feeney, Don. and Minor, Peter. (2007), “Factory-Level value Chain Analysis of
Cambodia’s Apparel Industry” USAID
5. Haavisto Virpi, 2005. Creative forces make blue oceans – a study of creativity
accompanying industrial strategy making, University of Art and Design Helsinki,
Finland.
7. Kirkpatrick, D. (2001), “Looking for Profits in Poverty The Third World is a ripe
market for HP, argues CEO Fiorina. Is she a crackpot? No, a visionary.” The
Fortune Magazine.
8. Kim, W.C. and Mauborgne, R. (2004), “Blue ocean strategy”, Harvard Business
Review, October, pp. 76-84.
9. Kim, W.C. and Mauborgne, R. (2005), “Value innovation: a leap into the blue
ocean”, Journal of Business Strategy, Vol. 26 No. 4, pp. 22-8.
10. Kim, W.C. and Mauborgne, R. (2009), “How Strategy Shapes Structure”, Harvard
Business School Publishing Corporation.
11. Leavy B. (2005), “Value Pioneering – How to discover your own “blue ocean”:
Interview with W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne” Emerald Group Publishing,
Vol. 33 No.6 pp.13-20.
12. Pitta, D. (2009), “Issues in a down economy: blue oceans and new product
development”, Journal of Product & Brand Management, Vol. 18 No.4 pp. 292-
296.
13. Prahalad, C. K. and A. Hammond (2002), “Serving the world’s poor profitably”,
Harvard Business Review, 80 (9), pp. 48-57.
20
14. Prahalad, C. K. and A. Hammond (2002), “The fortune at the bottom of the
pyramid”, Strategy + Business (26), pp.54-67.
16. Seelos C. and Mair, J. (2006), “Profitable Business Models and Market Creation
in the Context of Deep Poverty: A Strategy View” Occasional Paper, University
of Navarra, Madrid, Spain.
17. Seelos C and Mair J. (2006) “Research, Education and Training Programme on
Corporate Responsibility” Final Report, European Academy of Business in
Society, Barcelona.
18. Souen Say (2008), “Inside Business: For Cambodia’s mini-marts, it’s all about
convenience” The Phnom Penh Post, Cambodia.
19. Virpi Haavisto, “Creative Forces make Blue Oceans – A study of creativity
accompanying industrial strategy making.” University of Art and Design Helsinki
Finland.
20. The World Bank, “Health, Nutrition and Population data platform, Population
Projections” Accessed April 2009.
21. Yoon Hongyul, “Full Scheme Thinking and Feature Transfer for Creation of Blue
Ocean” TRIZ Center, TRIZ Specialist
22. Zainal Abidin Mohamed, Analysis of the Use of the Blue Ocean Strategy; Case
Study Analysis on 14 Different Agencies, Graduate School of Management/
Faculty of Economics and Management, University Putra Malaysia.
23. http://www.statemaster.com/encyclopedia/Prime-Minister-of-Cambodia.
26. http://www.innovationmanagement.org/Wiki/index.php?
title=Blue_Ocean_Strategy
21