Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Source: Latin American Perspectives, Vol. 3, No. 1, Imperialism and the Working Class in
Latin America (Winter, 1976), pp. 157-168
Published by: Sage Publications, Inc.
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2633259 .
Accessed: 04/05/2011 12:00
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless
you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you
may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use.
Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at .
http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=sage. .
Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed
page of such transmission.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Sage Publications, Inc. is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Latin American
Perspectives.
http://www.jstor.org
TODAY:A REIGNOFTERROR
ARGENTINA
Nowhere in Latin America is the struggleof the workingclass against imperialism and its
national allies as fierce as in Argentina. Daily newspaper stories document the intensityof the
undeclared civil war raging in that country.A briefglimpse of the reality of this struggle,which
claims hundreds of lives, emerges from the followingarticle. It is excerpted from the Report sub-
mitted to the Latin American Studies Association by its Sub-Committee on Academic Freedom
and Human Rightsin Argentinaof the Committeeon Academic Freedom and Human Rightscom-
posed of Juan E. Corradi (New York University),Chairperson,Eldon Ken worthy(Cornell Univer-
sity),and William Wipfler(National Council of Churches). The Report and its lengthydocumen-
tarysupplement "Argentinade hoy: un r6gimende terror,informesobre la represiondesde julio
de 1973 hasta diciembre de 1974," discusses the historical background of the current struggle,
outlines its present dimensions, and amply documents repression against specific groups and in-
stitutions.Among the latter it treats: political parties, workers and unions, universities, the
Church, the mass media and artisticcommunity,and marginalgroups. It also includes testimony
frompolitical prisoners and persons torturedunder thepresentgovernment(on Argentinain gen-
eral, see Corradi 1974a and 1974b and NACLA, 1975).
We publish below a somewhat abbreviated version of the chapter "Repression of the Work-
ing Class." The issue editors take full responsibilityfor editorial changes from the original text.
The complete Reportmay be obtained from the LASA Secretariat,Box 13362, UniversityStation,
Gainesville, Florida 32601.
oftheWorking
Repression Class
This study penetratesto the very core of the currentrepressive system in
Argentina.It not only deals with the all importantthemeof class strugglebut it
underscores its uniqueness, form,and scope. Consequently,it is indispensable
for a full understandingof what is taking place in Argentina.In this context
the repressionof the workingclass becomes the most profoundexpression of a
generalized repressionwhich affectsall Argentinesociety.
In a certain sense, what follows is only a reportand does not exhaust the
question. On the other hand, it should be read in the context of a more exten-
sive social conflictthatobviously includes the workingclass but which is in no
way limited to it. This social conflicthas multiple internallevels and also in-
cludes the participationof very explicit U.S. imperialistinterests.In any case,
a reading of the factual informationin the Chronologyclearly shows in terms
of specific events the extraordinarycomplexityof the Argentineconflict.
To place the repression in historical context, the firstrecorded instance
occurred on July 17, 1973, just four days after the resignation of Hector
Campora fromthe Presidency. During his fiftydays in power, in a continua-
tion of previous trends,diverse social groups mobilized which, consciously or
unconsciously,moved towards changingthe structuresof social participation.
The workingclass proved one of the most dynamic in this process. This phen-
LatinAmerican Issue8, Winter1976, Vol. li, No. 1
Perspectives: 157
158 LATIN AMERICAN PERSPECTIVES
omenon broughta crisis in termsof the power to controlthe masses inside the
labor movement.This movementhad existed for many years and was recog-
nized by law and by the society as a whole in that powerful Confederaci6n
General de Trabajo (CGT), consolidated during the firstPeronist period, an
undisputed social institutionwhich carries a permanentinfluence throughout
all Argentinesociety. The move towards a dismantlingof the existing union
structureplayed an importantpart in Campora's resignationon July13 - in
which the CGT bureaucracy played the role of spokesperson forthe bloodless
coup - but it also lay behind the increasing repression that this report
describes.
This repression in terms of the agents who carry it out, its victims, the
methods used, takes varied forms.This points out one differencebetween the
traditionalmethods of repressionused against the workingclass and the more
"modern" methods which many countries now employ against workers. De-
spite this differencein method,however,the goal of the repressionremains the
same: to paralyze the ability of workers to act as a class. In this case we can
distinguishparticularformswhich define a new stage in class struggleas can
be seen clearly fromthe incidents presented in the Chronology.These forms
have two basic characteristics:first,an attemptto maintain in fact the monop-
oly of power in the officiallyrecognized trade-unionbureaucracy- except, of
course, in the cases of those unions opposed to the centralized union bureauc-
racy; and second, an attemptto preventthe spread of labor strugglesbeyond
the sphere of wage demands. As the reader will see, the Chronology docu-
ments the firstpoint more than the second, because the firstis quantitatively
more accessible.
The repressive agents that participate in this process can be classified as
follows: 1) civilian groups armed with weapons that only can be obtained -
one way or the other- frommilitarydistributorsor factorieslicensed only to
sell to these distributors(Itaka rifles,tear gas grenades, 11.25 caliber pistols,
etc.); 2) pro-governmenttrade unions or their leaders; 3) state, national, or
provincial security forces;' 4) the state itself in its administrativecapacity
when it declares as illegal rank-and-filestrikes which threaten to spill over
outside traditionalunion politics; 5) a factor hardly distinguishablefromthe
state apparatus and only tangentiallymentioned here, Jose L6pez Rega - the
private secretaryof President Juan Peron and later also of his wife who suc-
ceeded him. L6pez Rega played a separate role in the process and still has an
undeniable importancein shaping events. [L6pez Rega since the writingof this
reporthas been forcedinto exile - editors.]
The victimsof this repressioncan be classified as follows: 1) militanttrade
unions such as Luz y Fuerza, Mecanicos Automotores y Talleres Afines
(SMATA), Transporte Automotor, all from C6rdoba Province, and the
Federacion Grafica Bonaerense, Musicos y Periodistas, from Buenos Aires,
etc.; 2) individual workers who have defied theirown bureaucracy by assum-
ing combative or dissident positions in a general sense or in specific strikesor
union matters;3) activists,both leaders and rank and file,affiliatedwith work-
ers' caucuses belonging to specific political groupings such as the Juventud
Trabajadora Peronista (a leftistPeronistWorker'sgroup), Partido Socialista de
'Security forces refersto the armed branches of any government,provincial,or municipal agency
including,forexample, internalsecurityoperatives, undercoveragents,etc.
ARGENTINA TODAY: REIGN OF TERROR 159
between 1966 and 1973. Now, however, the elected majority party - whose
main base is Peronism - controls the political apparatus and it carries out
repression by dictatinglaws or by administeringthem throughthe executive
and judicial branches. AfterJuly13, 1973, however, the security forces have
steadily regained the power they once held under the militarydictatorship.
They have slowly increased their influence over general policy, making their
opinions about repression heard not only throughthe use of arms but also
throughinputinto bureaucraticdecisions.
Since the Cold War, Argentinesecurityforces have maintained both ideo-
logical and material ties with the United States. The public revelations of CIA
interventionin Brazil, Chile, and Uruguay indicate that what is happening in
Argentinais intimatelylinked to U.S. strategyforLatin America. In this lightit
must be noted that that trade union bureaucracy has been and is one group
singled out to implement that strategyat the local level. The CIA admits to
having worked with the AFL-CIO and internationallabor organizations (e.g.,
ITS, ICFTU, etc.), which it controlsor significantlyinfluences,in order to cap-
ture the allegiance of union leaders and organizations through "trade union
educational programs"and a series of otherrelationshipswhich closely resem-
ble a networkof trade union espionage (NACLA, 1975; Agee, 1975; also Spald-
ing,and Erickson and Peppe in this issue).
In sum, repression of the Argentina working class takes place in the fol-
lowing manner: 1) repression is a joint effortof the trade union bureaucracy,
the security forces, and the state, which may have differentmotives, but
which in this particularcase happen to coincide; 2) the repression carried out
by the union bureaucracy appears to have as its immediategoal the defense of
its own power position in the face of workingclass mobilization aimed at in-
creased participationin decisions governingtrade unions and politics in gener-
al; 3) the repressiveactions of the securityforces and the political apparatus of
the state seems to facilitatethe bureaucratic repression and is aimed at main-
taininga systemwhich guarantees theirpositions of power; and 4) the goals of
all these repressive agencies coincide with many of the aims of U.S. imperial-
ism - as admitted to in the recent CIA-related episodes - to the point that
theycould safely be said not only to coincide with these aims but to aid them.
Violationsof theArgentineConstitution
The above provisions contradictspecific rightsguaranteed by the Argen-
tine Constitution:the rightof free association for a socially useful purpose
(Article 14), the rightof free and democratic trade-unionorganization (Article
14 bis) and the equality of all inhabitantsbefore the law, which prohibitsdis-
criminationon the groundsof birthor national origin(Article 16).
26 (Cordoba) The police continue to search the homes of private citizens, this
timethe houses of municipal employees appointed duringthe governorship
of Obregon Cano.
27 (Cordoba) A letterto the newspaper La Voz del Interior fromMs. Nelida
B. de Tosco, wife of the labor leader AgustfnTosco, publicly denounces the
repeated threats she has received. These threats warn her to leave her
home which - according to these anonymous voices - will be blown up at
the firstopportunity.
October
4 (Cordoba) The AAA threatensseveral members of the governingboard of
the Sindicato de Trabajadores de Motores Diesel Livianos. To protestthese
death threats,an assembly of workers from Perkil company decide on a
work stoppage on the sixth of the month.
10 (Buenos Aires) Jose Oscar Bordon, Secretary General of the Asociacion de
Encargados de Trabajadores del Puerto, is murdered. The CGT calls a fif-
teen minute work stoppage to protesthis assassination and the violence in
general.
11 (Avellaneda) During a disturbance among rival groups fromthe Federacion
de Empleados de Comercio, the union leader Horacio Avalos is killed.
12 (Cordoba) The local police search the headquarters of the union Luz y
Fuerza (a class orientedunion) and claim that they found numerous weap-
ons and subversiveliterature.Seven persons are arrested.
21 (Tucumain)A bomb explodes in the buildingused by the Federacion Obrera
de los Trabajadores de la IndustriaAzucarera.
24 (Mendoza) The union militantHector Mario Palvareda is murdered.
25 (Chubut) An armed band attacks the house of Osvaldo Rosales, Secretary
General of the Sindicato Unido de Petrolerosdel Estado.
November
4 (Buenos Aires) People identifyingthemselves as police kidnap JuanCarlos
Nievas, a worker for the Nestle Corporation. One hour and a half later,
Nievas is found dead.
10 (Cordoba) While the workersof Transax, a subsidiary of Ford, hold a meet-
ing in supportof the deposed officialsof SMATA, armed groups invade the
meetinghall threateningthe lives of the workers and shooting.
23 (Cordoba) The police announce that a shoot-out took place but that
AugusthnTosco, leader of the class oriented forces in Luz y Fuerza and
wanted by the police, was able to escape.
December
1 (Tucuman) Mr. Juande la Cruz Olmos, Secretary General of the Sindicato
de Obreros y Empleados Municipales de Famailla, is killed by a bomb ex-
plosion in his home.
14 (Cordoba) A Federal Judge,Adolfo Zamboni Ledesma, orders freedom for
four union leaders of SMATA arrested aftera search of the headquarters
of the Luz y Fuerza union. Immediately,however, they are arrested under
Executive Order.
15 (Avellaneda) The bodies of two leftistmilitants,Miguel Angel Bujano and
JorgeFischer,both union delegates fromthe Miluz paint factory,are found.
16 (Tucuman) The headquarters of the union of Molino "La Providencia" is
searched and its secretaryarrested.
ARGENTINA TODAY: REIGN OF TERROR 167
REFERENCES
Agee, Phillip
1975 Inside the Company: CIA Diary, Harmondsworth,England: Penguin
Corradi, JuanEugenio
1974a "Argentina,"pp. 305-407in Ronald H. Chilcote and JoelC. Edelstein (eds.), Latin Amer-
ica: The Struggle With Dependency and Beyond, Cambridge, Massachusetts: Schenkman
Publishing
1974b "Argentina and Peronism: Fragmentsof the Puzzle," Latin American Perspectives, I,
(Fall), 3-20
NACLA
1975 Argentinain the Hour of the Furnaces, New York: NACLA
LATINAMERICAN PERSPECTIVES
MICROFILMSERIES
Latin American Perspectives now has available on mlcri)fulm. puiblic itions which art dliffic;ultto fin(din
this countryas well as in the country of origin. I hi mph,iss of our mnirifilm is on Braz.ilia-n.('uhban
and Mexican materials, although we have filmed ittms from(Colombi,. tIIroigltay iintl(Chile. The follow-
ing items aireavailalble immediately (some titles havel not been filmnedas we art tryingto fin(dmissing
issues.) All itermsare filmed on 35mm roll film aindlthi cost is S2(0pvr rvi. Positivi microfilmwill be,
provided unless negative is specified. A 10% discount will t given on ill orders if SlIXE or more. Stnd
yoturorder to oiir diistri
botor:
CUSTOMMICROFILM SYSTEMS,INC.
PostOfficeBox 792 Riverside,
California92502
CHILE SERIES
Chile Hoy (Santiago) (CH2). Importantweekly reflectingUnidad Popular perspectives of the Allende period. Edited by
Marta Harnecker with Jaime Barrios, Theotonio dos Santos, Pio Garcio, Rui Mauro Marini and others. Vol. 1, 1972, Nos
1-17, 19-23, 25-26. 1 Reel
Cuadernos de Ia R*alidad (Santiogo) (CH3). One of the major social science tournals published during the Allende
period. Founded and edited by Jacques Chonchol and others and published at the CERAN of the Catholic University (to
be microfilmed.)
Punto Final (Santiogo) (CHS). Importantfor documents and analysis of Chileon affairs. Weekly reflectingviews to the
leftof the Unidad Popular. (to be microfilmed.)
El Rebilde (Santiago) (CH6). Official orgon of the Movimiento de lzquierda Revolutionorio(MIR). Aug. 28, 1971
Jan. 22, 1973. 1 Reel
COLOMBIAN SERIES
El Tiempo (Bogota) (COI). One of Colombia s and Latin America s leading daily newspapers. Jan., 1971 through 1974
and current.(Yeorly subscriptionavailable 48 Reels
URUGUAY SERIES
El National (Montevideo) (UR 1). July,1953 throughJuly,1954 - December, 1963 throughOctober, 1966 3 Reels
Marcha (Montevideo) (UR2) Significantleft independent weekly and a major source for onalysis of socio-economic,
political ond culturaloffairsin latin America Volumes 30 through35. Jan, 10, 1969 throughMay 31, 1974 8 Reels
MEXICAN SERIES
La Vot de la Fronteria (Mexicali) (ME 1). September, 1964 throughDecember, 1974 One of Baja California s leoding
daily newspopers, Complete collection Yeorly subscriptionavailable 82 Reels
Supemento Dominicol de El National (Mexico City) (ME2) April, 1947- Morch, 1968. 15 Reels
Mexico En la Cultura (MEXICO CITY) (ME3). February, 1949 - May, 1968, 8 Reels
El Diario de Culiacan (Culiacan, Rosales) (ME4). Januory,1968 - May, 1974. Daily newspaper of Sinola State
El Imparcial (Hermosillo, Sonora) (ME5). September, 1967 - December, 1970. Daily newspaper of Sonoro State,
La Opinion (Torreon,Coahuila) (ME6) 1967-1 973 (several missingissues), Leoding daily newspaper of Coahuila State
Siempre (Vallorta) (ME7). 1973 - 1974. Liberal-leftweekly containing political and culturalanalysis 8 Reels
El Fronterizo (Juarez) (ME8). May, 1967- October, 1973 A daily newspoper of Chihuahua State 52 Reels
El Mexicano (Tijuana) (ME9) October, 1959 to December, 1974 Daily newspaper of Balo California State Yearly
subscriptionavailable.
Tribuna (San Luis) (ME 10). Nov. 30, 1974- Feb. 28, 1975. Daily newspoper Yearly subscriptionavailable 1 Reel