Sie sind auf Seite 1von 78

INSTITUTE OF

BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY

Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players


of Pakistan Cement Industry

Submitted By

Mohammad Mustafa
(BME/663)
Faisal Bin Hasan
(BM/15024)

Course Code : MKT-606


MBA (Banking and Finance)

FACULTY OF MANAGEMENT SCIENCES

SPRING-2011
Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

CONTENTS

Page No

ACKNOWLEDGMENT 04

ABSTRACT 05

CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 Introduction 07
1.2 Purpose of Study 08
1.3 Research Objectives 09
1.4 Research Methodology 09

CHAPTER 2 LITERATURE REVIEW


2.1 Literature Review 11

CHAPTER 3 CEMENT INDUSTRY OF PAKISTAN


3.1 Growth 22
3.2 Current Scenario 25
3.3 Production 33
3.4 Consumption 36
3.5 Exports 39
3.6 Future prospects 47

CHAPTER 4 GIANTS OF PAKISTAN CEMENT INDUSTRY


4.1 Lucky Cement 53
4.2 Attock Cement 55
4.3 D. G. Khan Cement 57
4.4 Maple Leaf Cement 59
4.5 Lefrage Cement 60

Institute of Business and Technology Page 2


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

CHAPTER 5 FINANCIAL ANALYSIS OF CEMENT INDUSTRY


5.1 Profit and Loss Statement Analysis 62
5.2 Balance Sheet Analysis 64
5.3 Cash Flow Statements 68
5.4 Statement of changes in equity 68

CHAPTER 6 SWOT ANALYSIS OF CEMENT INDUSTRY


6.1 Strength 68
6.2 Weakness 71
6.3 Opportunities 72
6.4 Threats 72

CHAPTER 7 CONCLUSION AND RECOMENDATIONS


7.1 Conclusion 74
7.2 Recommendations 75

REFERENCES 77

Institute of Business and Technology Page 3


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

First of all we would like to thank Almighty Allah who enabled us potency and courage
to successfully research and pen this project, to achieve our target and complete this
report up to our ultimate level.

We would like to extend our special thanks to DR. NOOR MEMON, who conducted our Project
course and continuously guided and supported us during our project and enabled us the
opportunity of practically performing all that we had studied during the semester.

We are very thankful to him for his support throughout this project for proof reading,
formulating and information gathering of this report. We are also grateful to him for the
valuable time he has given us for this report in particular and for the over all learning of
finance and research at large.

We would also like to thank the endurance of our parents and family members for
bearing up with us throughout this endeavor both time and money wise.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 4


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS AND


TECHNOLOGY
ABSTRACT SUBMITTED BY: Mohammad Mustafa
Faisal Bin Hasan

DISCIPLINE: MBA (Banking and Finance)

TITLE OF PROJECT REPORT: Financial Analysis of Top Five Major


Players of Pakistan Cement Industry

MONTH OF SUBMISSION: April 2011

NAME OF PROJECT SUPERVISOR: Dr. Noor Ahmed Memon

Abstract

Cement is one of the major industry of Pakistan’s economy. Pakistan is rich in cement
raw material. Currently many cement plants are operating in private sector. Pakistan
Cement industry has huge potential for export of cement to neighboring countries like
India, United Arab Emirates, Afghanistan, Iraq & Russian States. There has been a
robust growth of cement demand seen both in domestic and export market.

Construction sector exhibited a strong 15.3% growth in FY-10 compared with a


contraction of 11.2% in FY-09. This remarkable performance was driven mainly by a
decline in building material prices, which in turn, was caused by reduction of duty on
cement sales and decline in global prices of coal, iron, and wood. Anecdotal evidence
suggests that most of the construction growth was led by the private sector.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 5


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Total growth in construction industry is indeed a welcome development giving the


existing backlog of housing units in the country and the industry’s backward and forward
linkages with other industries. It is estimated that the country has a backlog of around 8
million housing units which is increasing every year due to inadequate spending on
housing sector.

This report is based on introduction and Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of
Pakistan Cement Industry, in this report we are considering five major cement
companies i.e. Lucky Cement, Attock Cement, D.G. Khan Cement, Maple Leaf Cement,
Lefrage Cement, which are cement Manufacturing Companies and they export to many
countries of the world.

This report focuses on evaluating the industry’s service process, resources, financial
statements, current market scenario and other aspects. The report helps us to know the
current position of Cement Industry, and its strength, weakness, opportunities and
threats, by their customer analysis, their market strategy, implementation and future
prospects.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 6


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

1. INTRODUCTION

1.1 Introduction

At the time of independence in 1947, only one or two units were producing grey cement
in the country. During the decade of 1948-58, the number of cement units increased to
six. During the Ayub Khan era the economy started to grow and the construction
activities underwent a boom. To meet the growing demand of cement new units were
set up. During the decade of 1958-68, the number of cement units increased from 6 to
9. During the following period of Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto all the industrial units, including
cement industry, were nationalized, therefore, no new unit was set up during 1971-77.
During the period of General Zia-ul-Haq, 1977-88, denationalization of industrial units
boosted the investments. Housing and construction industries picked up and the
demand for cement increased. Thus, the number of cement units increased from 9 to 23
and finally almost 30. The cement industry in Pakistan has come a long way since
independence when country had less than half a million tones per annum production
capacity. By now it has exceeded 10 million tones per annum as a result of
establishment of new manufacturing facilities and expansion by existing units.
Privatization and effective price control in 1991-92 ushered in a new era in which the
industry has reached a level where surplus production after meeting local demand is
expected yearly. The cement industry is considered a highly important segment of
industrial sector that plays a pivotal role in the socio-economic development. Though
the cement industry in Pakistan has witnessed its lows and highs in recent past, it has
recovered during the last couple of years and is optimistic once again. There are total
number of units are around 30, from which 4 units are in the public sector while the
remaining 25 units are owned by the private sector. Two of the four units in the public
sector had to close down their operations due to stiff competition and heavy cost of
production. The cement plants are located in every province of Pakistan.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 7


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

The province-wise distribution of cement plants is as under:

Province Unit Capacity in Million Tonnes


1- Punjab 12 19.66
2- Sindh 8 10.105
3- NWFP 6 12.96
4- Baluchistan 3 1.99
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total Units 29 44.715
=============================================
Source: All Pakistan Cement Manufacturing Association of Pakistan (APCMA)

Three additional cement plants with installed capacity of over 2.1 million tonnes are in
the final stage of completion despite the available excess capacity in this sector. The
following table shows installation of new cement factories and expansion of the existing
facilities during the current decade.

The industry is divided into two broad regions, the northern region and the southern
region. The northern region has over 87 percent share in total cement dispatches while
the units based in the southern region contributes 13 percent to the annual cement
sales.

1.2 Purpose of Study

The purpose of a Research Study can be exploratory, descriptive or explanatory. The


major purposes of Exploratory studies are: the identification of problems, the more
precise formulation of problems (including the identification of relevant variables), and
the formulation of new alternative courses of action.
Descriptive Studies often involve the description of the extent of association between
two or more variables.
Explanatory Research is used for Studying relationship between causes & symptoms.
The researcher tries to identify the factors, which together cause a certain phenomena.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 8


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Our Research study will be descriptive b/c we will find Financial Analysis of Major
Cement companies in Pakistan involving various different variables and their affects on
the companies’ financial position.

1.3 Research Objectives

The objective of our Study is to know the past and present of Pakistan‘s cement
Industry & to highlight the future prospects of the industry. During this study we will also
be trying to do the financial analysis of top five major cement industry players in
Pakistan.
We will also review the affects of changing prices, inflation & other economic issues
which have impact on the cement industry of Pakistan.
Our aim is to know the reasons why the Cement Industry could not deliver the benefits
that it should have given to the Pakistan Economy; despite some good year’s
production wise.
We will also be reviewing the Government regulations regarding the industry and
whether these regulations are fruitful for the industry or not.
We will also like to give our suggestions on how to increase production and exports of
cement industry.
Pakistan’s cement industry has witnessed many ups & downs since 1947 till now; we
will try to review those highs & lows of Pakistan Cement Industry.

1.4 Research Methodology

The research methodology gives a set of guidelines for how information needed for
research should be gathered & processed.
There are two general approaches of a research; Qualitative & Quantitative. When
conducting a Quantitative research, statistical methods are used to analyze the data
and a large number of respondents are selected. either randomly or judgmentally.
During a Qualitative research one or few objects are studied in depth & the main
purpose is to gain a deeper understanding of the problem studied and to acquire a
profound knowledge of the studied objects.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 9


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Since this research tries to gain a deeper understanding of cement industry; a


Qualitative approach is a more suitable choice.
Two valuable sources of Primary data collection are Documentation & Interview.
Documents could be either internal like management reports, meeting notes or external
such as market researches, journal articles, and news.
A face to face Structured Interview would be conducted with some responsible &
related person of each organization.
Secondary Data Collection will be done through:
Newspapers
Internet
Books
All Pakistan Cement Manufacturers Association Reports
Economic Survey of Pakistan
Federal Bureau of Statistics Publications
State Bank of Pakistan Annual Reports

Institute of Business and Technology Page 10


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

2. LITERATURE REVIEW

The cement industry in Pakistan has come a long way since independence when
country had less than half a million tonnes per annum production capacity. By now it
has exceeded 10 million tonnes per annum as a result of establishment of new
manufacturing facilities and expansion by existing units. Privatization and effective price
control in 1991-92 ushered in a new era in which the industry has reached a level where
surplus production after meeting local demand is expected yearly.

A recurrent concern raised by industry groups against climate policies is the fear of
competitive distortions, industrial relocations and carbon leakage. The recent entry into
force of the Kyoto Protocol is unlikely to reduce these concerns since developed
countries that have ratified the Protocol only account for 35% of world energy-related
CO2 emissions. Unfortunately, although the existing economic literature came up with
fairly consistent quantitative estimates, it has not been ale to bring the debate to an end.
Ex post studies show very little empirical evidence that existing environmental
regulations affect trade flows (cf. e.g. Raspiller and Riedinger, 2004, and reference
therein). However, in some carbon-intensive sectors, the climate agenda may generate
much higher environmental constraints than existing ones, hence the need for modeling
such policies. The problem has thus been analyzed using both top-down and bottom-up
models. One of the key points to assess competitiveness and carbon leakage impacts
of GHG mitigation policies is the representation of international trade. In this regard,
most models are based on the well-known Armington specification (or on similar
functional forms).

This specification assumes that products are differentiated by their place of production.
For example the chemicals produced by different countries are not perfect substitutes.
This imperfect substitution has various grounds: products are not homogenous
throughout the world, consumers have national preferences, trade policies and
specification all these obstacles to perfect substitution are merged in the Armington
substitution elasticity, or a parameter with an equivalent meaning, which is at best

Institute of Business and Technology Page 11


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

econometrically calibrated. Then, the market shares of the different producing countries
are driven by relative prices and by this parameter.1

The Armington or Armington-trade trade representation is widely used for two reasons.
Firstly, it is convenient to avoid the “bang-bang effect”, i.e. the fact that a small variation
in relative prices can lead to drastic variations in market shares. Secondly, it is able to
account for bilateral trade between two countries, which occurs in reality.

However, this comes at the price of a lack of transparency and of control, since all the
factors justifying the imperfect substitutability are merged. Furthermore, the econometric
estimation of the Armington elasticity is difficult. Although their representation is
probably the best compromise for most sectors, it proves to be rather debatable for
some products. Let us take the cement case.

Cement is a relatively homogenous product throughout the world, whose trade is not
much disrupted by trade policies or national preferences. The imperfect substitutability
among cements from different places of production is then justified by the existence o
very high transportation costs. However, representing these transportation costs by a
constant elasticity of substitution is a very crude assumption, especially if a single
elasticity is chosen for every pair of countries, which is the case in most, if not all,
applied models.
A second limitation of most existing models is that hey generally do not take into
account explicitly production capacity shortages, which may lead to overestimated
leakage rates.

There is thus room for improving the representation of international trade in models
addressing the competitiveness and leakage issues, especially for high transportation
costs products. Since most GHG-intensive materials belong to this category, we
developed a spatial international trade model, GEO, that:

1
www.cesifo.de Venice International University

Institute of Business and Technology Page 12


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

• Drops the imperfect substitution assumption among goods produced in different


places;
• Makes explicit the transportation costs, for both road and sea transportation,
utilizing a spatial representation of the world: 47 production countries and about
15,500 consuming areas are identified and geo-referenced, allowing to compute
a realistic transportation costs;
• Computes for every country a capacity constraint, which is not fixed but may be
relaxed every year by investing in new capacities. GEO is used to estimate the
construction of new capacities, which occurs when the average cost of the new
plant (including its fixed, variable and transportation costs) does not prevent it to
be more competitive in at least one area than the existing available capacities (if
any) of other producers. (by Damien Demailly and Philippe Quirion)

In 1994 the manufacturing sector consumed 23 EJ of primary energy in the United


States, almost one-quarter of all energy consumed that year (U.S. DOE, EIA 1997).
Within manufacturing, a subset of raw materials transformation industries (cement,
primary metals, pulp and paper, chemicals, petroleum refining) require significantly
more energy to produce than other manufacturing products.

This report reflects an in-depth analysis of one of this energy-intensive industries-


cement, the binging agent in concrete and mortar—identifying energy savings and
carbon dioxide emissions reduction potentials. We analyze the cement industry at the
aggregate level (Standard Industrial Classification 324 (3241)), which includes
establishments engaged in manufacturing hydraulic cements, including Portland,
natural, masonry, and pozzolana cements.

The production of cement is an energy-intensive process that results in the emission of


carbon dioxide from both the consumption of fuels (primarily for the kiln) and from the
calcinations of limestone. In this report, we briefly describe the various stages in the
cement production process. We then provide details on energy consumption in the U. S.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 13


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

cement industry, and estimate the cost-effective potential for energy efficiency
improvement.

Cement is an inorganic, non-metallic substance with hydraulic binding properties, and is


used as a bonding agent in building materials. It is a fine powder, usually gray in color,
that consists of a mixture of the hydraulic cement minerals to which one or more forms
of calcium sulfate have been added (Greer et al., 1992, ASTM specification C-150).
Mixed with water it forms a paste, which hardens due to formation of cement mineral
hydrates. Cement is the binding agent in concrete, which is a combination of cement,
mineral aggregates and water. Concrete is a key building material for a variety of
applications.

The U.S. cement industry is made up of clinker plants, which produce clinker, cement
plants that grind clinker obtained elsewhere, or a combination of the two, an integrated
plant. Clinker is produced through a controlled high-temperature burn in a kiln of a
measured blend of calcareous rocks (usually limestone) and lesser quantities of
siliceous, aluminous, and ferrous materials. The kiln feed blend (also called raw meal or
raw mix) is adjusted depending on the chemical composition of the raw materials and
the type of cement desired. Cement plants grind clinker and add a variety of additives to
produce cement, while integrated plants both manufacture clinker and grind it to make
cement.
Portland and Masonry cements are the chief types produced in the United States. More
than 90% of the cement produced in the U.S. in 1997 was Portland cement, while
Masonry cement accounted for 4.4% of U.S. cement output in 1997 (USGS, 1998).

There were 119 operating cement plants in the U.S. in 1997, spread across 37 states
and in Puerto Rico, owned by 42 companies. Portland cement was produced at 118
plants in 1997, while Masonry cement was produced at 82 plants (81 of which also
produced Portland cement). Clinker was produced at 108 plants (110 including Puerto
Rico) in the U.S. in 1997. Clinker kiln capacity varies between 75 and 1550 kilo tonnes
per year (RTI, 1996). Production rates per plant vary between 0.5 and 3.1 million metric

Institute of Business and Technology Page 14


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

tons (Mt) per year. Total production of U.S. cement plants in 1997 was slightly over 82.5
Mt (USGS, 1998). Clinker is produced with either the “wet” or “dry” process. These
processes are discussed in detail in section III.

Clinker production, cement production, and materials consumption trends are quite
similar. All three categories experienced gradual growth between 1970 and 1997, with
2
prominent dips in the late 1970s and early 1980s. Clinker production increased from
67 Mt in 1970 to 74 Mt in 1997, at an average rate of 0.4% per year, hitting a low of 55
Mt in 1982, and its current high in 1997. Within this slow production increase, the
composition of clinker production changed significantly between 1970 and 1997. Clinker
produced with the wet process decreased at an average of – 2.7% per year, falling from
a 60% share of total clinker production in 1970 to a 26% share in 1997. Clinker
produced with the dry process increased at an average of 2.6% per year, increasing
from a 40% share of total clinker production in 1970 to a 72% share in 1997. Cement
production increased at 0.7% per year between 1970 and 1997, rising from 69 Mt in
1970 to 84 Mt in 1997. Portland cement remained the dominant cement type during that
time span, maintaining a share between 94% and 96%. Materials consumption
increased at an average of 0.5% per year between 1970 and 1997, rising from 115 Mt in
1970 to 133 Mt in 1997.

Cement production (0.7% average per year) grew more rapidly than clinker production
(0.4% average per year) between 1970 and 1997, which may be due increased use of
additives and changes in clinker imports. Between 1970 and 1997, the clinker to cement
ratio (expressed as clinker production divided by cement production) decreased from
0.97 to 0.88 t cement/t clinker. The number of clinker plants has decreased from 169 in
1970 to 110 in 1997, while the number of cement plants has fallen from 181 in 1970 to
118 in 1997. Thus, average plant capacity has increased. (by Nathan Martin, Ernst
Worrell, and Lynn Price).

2
http://scholarship.org/uc/item/9bd095q0 Lawrence Barkeley National Laboratory

Institute of Business and Technology Page 15


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Chest radiology is the most frequently requested radiological investigation. In spite of


recent technological advances, chest radiology remains the cornerstone of thoracic
imaging and is a valuable diagnostic investigation.1 The chest radiographs together with
occupational history, usually allows the physicians to make a presumptive diagnosis. It
also helps in early diagnosis of different diseases in various occupational workers.2
Occupational diseases are a result of an imbalance between human beings and their
environment. The diseases of the respiratory system are induced by occupational dusts
and are influenced by the type of dust and the duration of exposure.3 Cement mill
workers are exposed to dust at various manufacturing and production processes.
Cement dust is classified into 2 main types, natural cement and artificial (Portland)
cement. Portland cement is a mixture of calcium oxide (62%-66%), silicon oxide (19%-
22%), aluminum trioxide (4%-8%), ferric oxide (2%-5%) and magnesium oxide (1%-
2%).4 The effects of cement dust are due to its irritating properties. Cement dust has
irritating effects on skin, eyes and the respiratory system. It induces atrophic and
hypertrophic changes in nasal and pharyngeal mucosa, chronic exfoliative bronchitis
and slight tissue fibrosis.5 Cement dust also has hazardous effects on the gastro
intestinal tract6 and nervous system.7

Methods. This study was carried out in the Department of Physiology, Faculty of Health
and Medical Sciences, Hamdard University Karachi, Pakistan, between June to August
2000. In this study, 2 groups were formed with 50 volunteers each. In the first group, 50
apparently healthy male cement mill workers aged 20-60 years were selected randomly
from a cement mill located in Karachi, Pakistan. These workers did not use any self-
protective measures and worked 8 hours a day. They were matched in terms of age,
height, weight and socioeconomic status with a second group of 50 healthy male control
subjects selected from the local population of Karachi. These control subjects were
composed primarily of shopkeepers and salesmen. Subjects with known cases of
asthma, diabetes mellitus, cardiopulmonary diseases, malignancy, drug addicts,

Institute of Business and Technology Page 16


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

cigarette smokers and subjects with gross abnormalities of the vertebral column,
thoracic cage and neuromuscular diseases were excluded from the study.

After complete exposure of the chest3, subjects were advised to stand upright with their
back to the x-ray tube. The chest was pressed against a metal cassette containing the
film and the arm were positioned out of the way. All subjects were advised to suspend
respiration at total lung capacity and an ideal posteroanterior (PA) view chest
radiograph was taken by Trophy Radiology (N-50057, France). The cassette was
immediately transferred to the dark room for development process. When required, for
necessary quality control purpose, the radiograph was repeated. Each radiograph was
clinically read by 2 radiologists and 2 pulmonologists, they interpreted the films
independently of each other and without knowledge of exposure status.

Results. Anthropometric parameters for the total number of cement mill workers and
control group is shown in Table 1. There were no significant differences between the
means in anthropometric parameters of age, height or weight in both groups. The mean
duration of exposure in the cement mill workers was 12.94 + 1.00 years (mean + SEM),
range 2-28 years. The chest radiological findings for total cases of cement mill workers
and similar number of matched controls are presented in Table 2. In cement mill
workers abnormal clinical findings were found on chest radiology as compared to
control subjects. (by Sultan A. Meo)

Cement is considered one of the most important building materials around the world. It
is mainly used for the production of concrete. Concrete is a mixture of inert mineral
aggregates, e.g. sand, gravel, crushed stones, and cement. Cement consumption and
production is closely related to construction activity, and therefore to the general
economic activity. Cement is one of the most produced materials around the world. Due
to the importance of cement as a construction material, and the geographic abundance
of the main raw materials, i.e. limestone, cement is produced in virtually all countries.

3
Saudi Medical Journal 2003; Vol. 24 (3): 287-290

Institute of Business and Technology Page 17


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

The widespread production is also due to the relative low price and high density of
cement, that limits ground transportation because of the relative high costs. Generally,
the international trade (excluding plants located on the borders) is limited, when
compared to the global production.

Cement production is a highly energy intensive production process. The energy


consumption by the cement industry is estimated at about 2% of the global primary
energy consumption, or almost 5% of the total global industrial energy consumption
[WEC, 1995]. Due to the dominant use of carbon intensive fuels4, e.g. coal, in clinker
making, the cement industry is also a major emitter of CO2 emissions. Besides energy
consumption, the clinker making process also emits CO2 due to the calcining process.
The cement industry contributes 5% of total global carbon dioxide emissions. Therefore
Ecofys Energy and Environment and Berkeley National Laboratory made for the IEA
Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme an assessment to the role of the cement industry in
CO2 production and to carbon dioxide emission reduction options [Hendriks,
forthcoming].
In this article we will first discuss the historical development and global distribution of
cement production, and we give a short description of the production processes. In the
next paragraph an overview is presented of the CO2 emission related to the production
processes, followed by analyze of CO2 emission reduction options. (by C.A. Hendriks,
E Worrell, D. de Jager, K. Blok, P. Riemer).

The basic constituents of PC are lime (CaO), silica (SiO 2), alumina (Al 2 O3) and iron
oxide (Fe 2 O 3 ). In the manufacturing process, they are crushed, ground, proportioned
for the desired composition and then heated up to 1400-1600°C. The inclusion of
gypsum (CaSO 4 .4H 2 O) controls the setting time of the cement.

The resulting product consists of tricalcium silicate (3CaO.SiO 2), dicalcium silicate
(2CaO.SiO 2), tricalcium aluminate (3CaO.Al2 O3), tetracalcium aluminoferrite (4CaO.Al 2

4
www.ieagreeen.org.uk greenhouse gas control technologies conference paper

Institute of Business and Technology Page 18


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

O 3 .Fe 2 O 3 ) and dehydrated calcium sulfate (CaO.SO3 2H2 O). Small differences can
be noticed depending on the manufacturer and the location of the source of mineral
extraction. In chemical assays of PC, the components were present according to the
following average percentages: CaO (58.5%), SiO 2 (17.7%), Al 2 O 3 (4.5%), MgO
(3.3%), SO 3 (3.0%), Fe 2 O 3 (2.9%), K 2 O (0.9%), and Na 2 O (0.2%).

Wucherpfennig and Green report that mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA) and PC have
similar macro, micro features as well as biological behavior. Comparative analysis
shows no significant difference between PC and MTA with regards to their composition.
However, MTA has bismuth oxide added to improve its radiopacity.

Studies have shown that PC has an efficient antimicrobial effect. Estrela et al. observed
that the antimicrobial effect of MTA and PC was similar. The results obtained with MTA
on S. aureus, E. faecalis and B. subtilis were identical to those obtained using PC.
Sipert studied in vitro the antimicrobial effect of PC on several species of
microorganisms: Enterococus faecalis, Micrococus luteus, Escherichia coli,
Staphilococus aureus, Staphilococus epidermidis, Pseudomonas aeruginosa and
Candida albicans. PC presented antimicrobial potential in all cases except on E. coli
that did not show inhibition of activity Mendonηa et al. report that the addition of
metronidazol to PC did not improve the antimicrobial effect of PC.

PC has shown good cell proliferation induction with formation of a monolayer cell,
satisfactory inflammatory response and inhibitory effect of prostaglandin. In vitro studies
with cell cultures have been widely used to evaluate the biocompatibility of those
materials. Saidon et al. compared the cytotoxic effect in vitro and the tissue reaction of
MTA and PC in bone implantation into the mandible of guinea pigs. Results show that
there was no difference in cell reactions in vitro. Bone healing and minimal inflammatory
response adjacent to MTA and PC implants were observed, suggesting that both
materials are well tolerated. Ribeiro et al. evaluated in vitro on mouse lymphoma cells
the genotoxic and cytotoxic effects of MTA and PCs and observed that none of them
were cytotoxic. Those results seem to indicate that MTA and PCs are not genotoxic and

Institute of Business and Technology Page 19


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

do not induce cellular death. Ribeiro et al. investigated MTA and Portland potential to
induce DNA breakage in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells and reported that those
compounds tested did not show genotoxic effects in all concentrations evaluated. Min et
al. also reported that PC is not cytotoxic and it allows cell adhesion and growth. Braz et
al. evaluated human peripheral lymphocytes treated with PC at concentrations up to
1000 mg/ mL (-1) and did not observed damage to lymphocyte DNA. They concluded that
the exposition to PC could not be able to increase the risk of genetic damage in
lymphocytes.

Portland cement (PC) is a hydraulic binding material 5, which once mixed with water
tends to harden. This material is widely used in the building industry and, recently, its
use in dentistry has been largely studied. The main interest in its use in dentistry is
focused on a possible alternative to mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA) because PC is
less expensive and widely available.

Several studies have shown that the composition of PC is similar to MTA, excepting by
the absence of bismuth ions, which confers radiopacity to MTA. Furthermore, PC
exhibits others properties similar to MTA, such as antimicrobial effect, induction of cell
proliferation and inhibitory effect of prostaglandin.

In dentistry, PC has been used in dental procedures such as pulpotomy, pulp capping,
repair of root perforation and root-end filling. Studies have shown that PC is not
cytotoxic, stimulates the apposition of reparative dentin and permits cellular attachment
and growth.
Despite its good properties reported in the literature, PC has undesirable contaminant
substances to human organism. The arsenic quantity in the PC is one of the major
concerns regarding to its use. The purpose of this article is to review the dental
literature about the PC, its composition, with special attention to arsenic content,
properties, and application in dentistry.

5
: http://www.ijdr.in/text.asp?2010/21/4/591/74233

Institute of Business and Technology Page 20


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

A literature review was performed on Bireme, Pubmed, LILACS and Scopus databases
in order to identify studies reporting the composition and properties of PC, its application
in dentistry and the arsenic presence and release. For this search, terms used were
"Portland cement arsenic release" and "Portland cement dentistry". Descriptive studies,
case reports, literature review, in vitro and in vivo studies were included. Exclusion
criterion was papers published before 1997. (by Talita Riberiro Tenorio de Franca,
Rephaela Juvenal da Silva, Michellini Seycias de Queiroz, Carlos Menzes Aguiar).

Institute of Business and Technology Page 21


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

3. CEMENT INDUSTRY OF PAKISTAN


3.1 Growth

Cement is one of the most important industries of Pakistan. Limestone and gypsum are
the main raw materials for manufacturing of cement and they are present in abundance
in Pakistan along with ample supply of Natural gas. This great potential makes the
country capable of producing cement not only for local use but also for export as well.
Pakistan has been exporting cement to the neighbouring countries like U.A.E,
Afghanistan, India, Iraq and Russia.

There are 29 cement production units in the country. Upto May 2010, the total installed
cement production capacity is 44.715 million tonnes. By the end of June 2011, the
installed cement production capacity is expected to touch the level of 49.579 million
tonnes.

Due to political instability and lack of availability of funds for public sector development
program, cement industry of Pakistan was in the recession phase and registered an
average growth rate of 2.96% for the period from 1990 to 2002. For the period from
2003 to 2007 cement industry of Pakistan had registered an average growth rate of
20%. Another 20-25 % growth is expected till the end of the current year. The boost in
cement sector is because of the rising construction activity in the country, reconstruction
activity in Afghanistan and increasing development expenditure by the government.

The cement demand grew 19 percent and 13 percent during FY05 and FY06
respectively. During the first nine months of FY07-08, production increased by 30
percent as compared to last year. The demand for cement was forecasted to grow by
26 percent during FY07 and 17 percent in FY08. The per capita consumption of cement
has risen from 117 kg in FY06 to 131 kg in FY07. This rising trend continued in the
FY08 to FY10 and it is expected to take the same trend in FY11.

Pakistan is rich in cement raw material. Currently many cement plants are operating in
private sector. The last few years have been a golden period for cement manufacturers,

Institute of Business and Technology Page 22


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

when the government increased spending on infrastructure development. High


commercial activity and rising demand for housing on account of higher per capita
income has made cement sector to take off growth in double digits.

Pakistan cement industry has a huge potential for export of cement to neighboring
countries like India, U.A.E, Afghanistan, Iraq and Russian states. There has been a
robust growth of cement demand seen both in domestic and exports market during the
fiscal year ended June 30, 2009-10. The industry achieved an overall growth of 32%
with domestic demand of cement increased by 24.95% where as exports increased by
111.86%. The overall growth achieved by cement factories for the year under review
was 111.29% consisting of domestic and exports markets at 71.02% and 335.12%
respectively.

Pakistan cement industry has been successful to capture export markets of various
GCC and African countries, which are new markets for the country other then
conventional export market of Afghanistan and Iraq.

The main factors behind increase in demand of cement were: 60 percent higher Public
Sector Development Projects (PSDP) allocation, seven percent GDP growth, increasing
number of real estate development projects for commercial and residential use,
developing export market and expected construction of mega dams.

As cement capacity is increasing to cater the rising domestic and regional demand, it
started facing a tougher time because of price fall after the first quarter of FY06 due to
increase in supply, energy prices started surging and higher expansion led to mounting
finance and depreciation costs. After reaching Rs 430 per bag at the retail level earlier
last year, cement prices fell sharply during 2007. Average cement prices were Rs 220
per bag as on April 27, 2008, as compared to Rs 315 per bag in 2006.

However, the cost and exports may be affected due to weakness of the US dollar
causing coal, electricity charges and freight prices, comprising 65 to 70 percent of the

Institute of Business and Technology Page 23


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

cost. The PSDP allocation has been cut by Rs 75 billion and feared further cuts would
curtail cement demand. Major capacities of countries like India and Iran are expected
to come online by FY11 and onwards which are likely to convert these countries from
dependent importers to potential exporters.

Moreover, this rising trend is expected to be short-lived due to higher interest rates and
inflationary concerns are likely to make it disadvantageous for investors to enter the
construction industry. In addition to this, to control real estate prices the government is
considering imposing a tax on it.

The recent wave of flooding in the northern Punjab region of Pakistan and displaced 20
million people and also left the area isolated from other parts of the country. Many
industrial plants and logistics operations were also adversely affected as a result of
massive damage to infrastructure.

Analysts expect that the lack of infrastructure, would lead to a decline in sales and
prices also result in a decrease of RS10 at Rs20 per bag in the next few months. Sales
of cement are influenced by rainfall on an annual basis, but the damage to the road
network has deteriorated and distribution industry, agony and hurt exports.

However, you can expect the industry to see the light at the end of the tunnel, how
could experience exponential growth due to massive reconstruction efforts in the
country, once the flood subsides. Although the extent of the damage can not be
accurately assessed at this time, reconstruction efforts are likely to last longer in
comparison with the aftermath of the earthquake of 2005, due to the nature of the
disaster.

Investors will likely have a significant interest in cement stocks on the back of strong
future demand. Even when the government announced a 50 percent reduction in
development spending, the United Nations, World Bank and other donor agencies
pledging money for reconstruction activities.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 24


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Cement industries in Pakistan are currently operating at their maximum capacity due to
the boom in commercial and industrial construction within Pakistan. Consumers face a
tough decision with regards to prefer which brand over which because of the similar
pricing of cement industry. The formation of cartel by the cement manufacturers have
exploited local consumers a lot and this has led to the concentrated degree of oligopoly,
where the firms are acting as a single unit to perform their monopoly. Their combined
market power is simply a diluted version of the dominance that a single firm with a
monopoly market share can exert.

The demand of Pakistani cement is expected to continue to grow at the rate of 20 per
cent for about four years to come. It may then follow traditional growth rate of seven per
cent per year. Announcement of major dams will dramatically increase this demand.
Deregulation after accession of Pakistan to WTO is expected to open the window of
competition from cheaper markets.

There may be no tariff after this deregulation on import of cement allowing its entry into
Pakistan from cheaper market at lower rate. Cement from cheaper markets may also
block Pakistan’s export of cement to its neighboring countries. Global market has
vigorously taken up the advantage of economy of scales and multinational giants now
control more than 40 per cent of world production—(China not included). The recent
acquisition of Chakwal Cement by an Egyptian giant, Orascom may be a beginning of
such an entry in Pakistan by multinationals.

New avenues for export of cement are opening up for the indigenous industry as Sri
Lanka has recently shown interest to import 30,000 tons cement from Pakistan every
month. If the industry is able for avail the opportunity offered, it may secure a significant
share of Sri Lanka market by supplying 360,000 tons of cement annually.

3.2 Current Scenario

Due to political instability and lack of allocation of funds for public sector development
program, cement industry of Pakistan was in the recession phase had registered an

Institute of Business and Technology Page 25


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

average growth rate of 2.96% for the period from 1990 to 2002. For the period from
2003 to 2007 cement industry of Pakistan had registered an average growth rate of
20%. The boost in cement sector is because of the rising construction activity in the
country, reconstruction activity in Afghanistan and increasing development expenditure
by the government. Presently, the cement industry of Pakistan is heavily burdened due
to levy of Federal Excise Duty @ Rs. 750 per ton and General Sales Tax @ 15% on
duty paid value. In addition to Federal Excise Duty and General Sales Tax, cement
industry is also paying the provincial levies (Royalty and Excise Duty) on acquiring of
raw material for production of cement i.e. lime stone and shall clay.

A comparison of taxation and retail prices with other regional countries revealed that
taxation in Pakistan is highest while cement retail prices are lowest. Housing sector has
been looked upon as stimulator of economic growth since there is a large estimated gap
of 5.38 million housing units against annual addition of 300,000 units in the country,
many tax exemption and incentives are provided to encourage new construction.

Contribution to National Economy By Cement Sector:

Direct and Indirect Taxes Rs. 23.50 Billion


Value of Fixed Assets Deployed Rs. 85.21 Billion
Loans from Financial Institutions Rs. 79.53 Billion
Shareholders Equity Rs. 80.00 Billion
Employment (Direct & Indirect) 150,000 (Approx.)

Source: All Pakistan Cement Manufacturing Association of Pakistan (APCMA)

Demand:
Ever disastrous flood in the history of Pakistan has crushed almost everything that
came in its way. The flood emerged from the northern areas of the country due to
record level of rains and melting of glaciers. Most parts of the Khyber Puktunkhwa

Institute of Business and Technology Page 26


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

province have been badly affected causing a huge loss of property, standing crops and
infrastructure.

Flood water founds its way and moved through Punjab province and ended up with
devastating damage in Sindh province.

Huge loss caused to agriculture, housing, infrastructure and industrial set ups. Although
correct damage assessment is underway but estimates are that losses would be in
billions of Dollars. This huge and wide spread damage is expected to affect the
economy of the country in years to come. Federal Govt. along with provincial Govt. has
given indications of substantial reduction in annual developmental expenditure. This will
off course hit badly the economic indicators of the country. Although this natural disaster
may turn into a great opportunity to build the infrastructure and residential of the masses
which will provide demand stimulus for the cement industry.

It is anticipated that reconstruction of road networks and infrastructure across the


country will generate a new wave of economic activities for next few years. It is also
expected to generate a lot of new job opportunities and number of industries will get
demand stimulus for next couple of years. Govt.’s announcement to finance every
house that was either affected fully or partially would yield multi layer demand of goods
and services which will bring a new life to economic and business activities.

Contribution to National Income by Cement Sector:

The cement is contributing Rs 30 billion to the national exchequer in the form of tax.
This sector has invested about Rs 100 billion in capacity expansion over the last four
years. There are four foreign companies, three armed force companies and 16 private
companies listed in the stock exchanges. The industry is divided into two broad regions.
The northern region has over 87% share in total cement dispatches while the units base
in the southern region contributes 13% to the annual cement sale. The per capita
consumption of cement has risen from 163 kg in FY09 to 183 kg in FY10 .

Institute of Business and Technology Page 27


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

The cement industry of Pakistan entered the export markets a few years back, and has
established its reputation as a good quality product. The latest information is that India
will import more cement from Pakistan. So far 130,000 tones cement has been exported
to the neighboring country.

What Is Going on in Related Sector:

Pakistan has one of the highest population growth rates in the world. This has prompted
a sizable demand for housing facilities in the country. According to estimates of
construction industry, there is a huge backlog of about 6.25 million housing units in the
country. Bulk of the current demand of 0.6 million units needed every year is for urban
areas. With greater urbanization the demand for cement is expected to grow at an
average of nearly 7% per annum. .

The construction sector in Pakistan has played an important role in providing jobs and
revival of economy.. There is a lot of scope for importing latest technological
advancements/hi-tech building materials. Construction equipment & plants with the
latest practices adopted in the developed Countries after varied Research &
development are badly needed to be adopted by Pakistan as well. Quality Control &
Materials Testing Laboratories & Equipment are need of the time. There is unlimited
scope for investment in this sector.

Globally, construction and engineering services industry is regarded as one of the


largest fragmented industry accounting for 10-12% of GDP in many countries.
Benefiting from both public and private investments, the construction industry is a prime
source of employment generation offering job opportunities to millions of unskilled,
semi-skilled and skilled work force.

The main factors behind increase in demand of cement were: 60 percent higher Public
Sector Development Projects (PSDP) allocation, seven percent GDP growth, increasing
number of real estate development projects for commercial and residential use,
developing export market and expected construction of mega dams. The operating

Institute of Business and Technology Page 28


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

capacity of cement in FY05 and FY06 was 18 million and 21million tonnes, which rose
to 37 million tonnes by the end of FY07. This trend continued till the current year.

However, this rising trend is expected to be short-lived due to higher interest rates and
inflationary concerns are likely to make it disadvantageous for investors to enter the
construction industry. In addition to this, to control real estate prices the government is
considering imposing a tax on it.

Tax structure:

Instead of providing any relief in the budget, the sector was further penalized with a 3%
increase in sale tax to 18%. So far, the manufacturers have been able to pass on the
increase to consumers but the situation is unlikely to continue. However, the possibility
of formation of a cartel cannot be ruled out. Since massive investment has been made
in the sector, any reduction in price of cement can reduce profit margin of all the units.

Formation of cartel and fixation of price at a level high enough to cover increasing cost
of inputs and ensure reasonable profit margin may provide short-term relief to the
manufactures. Such a cartel may be against the interest of consumer but can help the
manufacturer to survive with some dignity. Formation and smooth operation of a cartel
is generally difficult but in the case of cement industry it may not so because the only
restriction could be on the level of capacity utilization along with a modest uniform
reduction in the price of cement. However, the units are in the diverse state of financial
health, enjoy different level of competitive advantage, and therefore need different
prescriptions to maintain their profitability.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 29


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Strength of Sector Which Attract Investors:

Availability of Raw Material :


Abundance of natural resources makes it an ideal place to set-up cement plants. And
which can give high turnover to foreign companies in cement industry.

Duty Free Port of Gawadar:

Pakistan was previously relying on its Karachi port for the shipment of its imports and
exports. It was over crowded and expensive. Pakistan has built a new deep sea port at
Gawadar in the strategically important Province of Balochistan bordering with Iran. This
port has been declared duty free, on top of this cheaper labour makes it the cheapest
port in the whole South Asia region.

Pakistan’s Foreign Investment Policy :

The investment policy regime has been liberalized with most economic sectors open for
foreign involvement.

The Government has therefore liberalized its investment policy, promoted a stronger
and faster enabling framework and opened up almost all sectors for foreign investment
while offering tax and other incentives for investment as well as enabling 100%

Institute of Business and Technology Page 30


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

ownership for foreign investment in many areas. The new Investment Policy provides
equal investment opportunities for both domestic and foreign investors.

The Government has decided to give “priority industry” status for foreign investment into
information technology, oil and gas exploration, mining, leather production, corporate
farming, livestock and dairy, financial business and trade, infrastructure, tourism,
housing and construction sectors. Complete freedom of choice has been provided on
where to locate an activity.

Problems faced by Industry:


Heavy Duties, Bills & Taxes paid by sector:
The Cement industry in Pakistan has to pay Federal Excise duty at Rs.950/ton as
compared with Rs. 750 / ton, 16% sales Tax as compared with 15% and high utilities
bills like electricity, gas etc.
On top of all the issues is the harassment of the industry by different government
departments, industry sources said. They said that Pakistan Standard Control Authority
had filed criminal cases against the cement manufacturers.

The Competitive Commission of Pakistan is also chasing the industry, accusing it of


forming cartel and initiated cases against a number of units, sources said.

The adverse impact of slow exports of cement to India started to emerge in December
2008 as lesser orders have been received by exporters.

In the first quarter of 2009-10, a spokesman for All Pakistan Cement Manufactures
Association (APCMA) remarked that any setback to cement industry may increase the
price to as high as Rs. 1900/- approx per bag.

Price to manufacture one bag of cement has risen to more than five hundred rs per
bag in 2010 from Rs. 450 per bag in 2009. Electricity has risen by 20%.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 31


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Ministry of Science and Technology has levied an additional tax factor at 0.1% of ex
factory price which amounts to Rs. 3 per bag.

Affects of the flooding:

The floods did not drastically affect the cement industry in Pakistan, but they have had a
dramatic effect on demand for cement in Pakistan throughout the first two months of
FY10/11. The manufacturing plants in general were not severely damaged, however,
although some were close to the flooded regions. It is expected that cement sales will
begin to recover in the second half of FY2010/11, although sales pressure has
increased during August 2010 and there is price stress in the north. Prices are expected
to hold for now and improve later in the current fiscal year.

As far as recovery is concerned, the cement industry tends to rely on growth in


agriculture income, along with government spending on infrastructure. However in 2011,
there will be no demand from these two important sectors. On the contrary, further
fallout from the flooding will result in large demands on the government finances, while
the majority of farmers in Pakistan will have limited funds due to the extensive
destruction of crops and the resultant decrease in income.

As the floods occurred immediately before the month of Ramadan, the cement
manufacturers within Pakistan had already built up a surplus in imports so as to have
sufficient stocks built up at the ports within the country. Although the floods decimated
the country’s communications, it is expected that rebuilding could begin within a few
months, possibly in November or December.

Latest Situation Mar-Apr 2011:

The latest situation is that the prices of cement have increased once more which is
affecting the construction industry because they cannot buy cement at a expensive rate.
There is a lot of demand for construction after earth quake & recent floods & increasing
population; but due to heavy price of cement; the construction industry cannot make

Institute of Business and Technology Page 32


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

new homes in abundance b/c they cannot sell them at a higher price due to lowering of
property rates. People nowadays don’t buy property at a high price.

3.3 Production

The cement manufacturers added eight million tonnes to the capacity and the total
production was expected to be 45 million tonnes by the end of 2010. It may result in a
supply glut of 11 million, nine million and seven million tonnes in 2008, 2009 and 2010
respectively.
Despite an excess supply of 11 million tonnes in 2008, it is estimated that the price
would increase in domestic as well in regional markets that may surely boost the
profitability and give relief to the industry on its new investment.
The cement demand would increase in future due to government policies as the
Pakistan People’s Party’s (PPP’s) slogan has always been ‘roti, kapra aur makan’
(bread, clothing and housing). In this regard a statement of the new government
confirmed that it would encourage industries and construct small dams.

The sharp decline in cement prices were due to domestic competition among producers
has dampened the profitability of the industry. To cope with this situation the
manufacturers have strengthen cartel to set minimum cement prices. The example was
marketing arrangement that increased cement prices to the extent of 20 percent despite
coal prices have gone down in the international market. A study of the cement sector
conducted by The News revealed that the sector has been adding capacities since
1995/96 when the total production of cement was 10.173 million tons with the local
demand of 9.43 million tons.

Cement industry is divided into two main regions; the northern and the southern region.
Northern region is producing 35.18 million tonnes and southern region is producing 8.89
million tonnes of cement per year.

The production capacity increased to 30.250 million tons by the end of 2006/07. At that
time the domestic consumption was 21.03 million tons, but cement export had just

Institute of Business and Technology Page 33


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

started picking up and crossed 3.1 million tons during that year. The cement production
capacity increased to 44.82 million tons by end of 2009/10, the study revealed.

Up to May 2007, the total installed cement production capacity is 36.841 million tones.
By the end of June 2011, the installed cement production capacity will touch to the level
of 49.579 million tones. Due to political instability and lack of allocation of funds for
public sector development program, cement industry of Pakistan which went in the
recession phase had registered an average growth rate of 2.96% for the period from
1990 to 2002. For the period from 2003 to 2007 cement industry of Pakistan had
registered an average growth rate of 20%. The boost in cement sector is because of the
rising construction activity in the country, reconstruction activity in Afghanistan and
increasing development expenditure by the government.

There are four foreign companies, three armed forces companies and 22 private
companies listed in the stock exchanges. The industry is divided into two broad regions,
the northern region and the southern region. The northern region has over 87 percent
share in total cement dispatches while the units based in the southern region
contributes 13 percent to the annual cement sales.

Types of Cement produced in Pakistan:


1- Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC)
2- Sulphate Resisting Cement (SRC)
3- Blast Furnace Slag Cement (BFSC)
4- White Cement

Main Utilities used for Cement Production:


1- Fuel Oil , Natural Gas and Coal
2- Electricity
3- Water

Cement Plants (Pakistan):

Institute of Business and Technology Page 34


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Source: www.cement.com.pk

Product type:
Since cement is a specialized product, requiring sophisticated infrastructure and
production location. So, most of the cement industries in Pakistan are located
near/within mountainous regions that are rich in clay, iron and mineral capacity.
Structure of Cement industry in Pakistan is as such that there is not much
substitutability to buyers. Which shows that the Cross elasticity of demand is negligible.
Geographical Area: The other factor i.e. geographic location also doesn’t affects a lot
considering the flexibility of demand. Example can be taken from the fact that if DG
cement in DG KHAN raises its price and MAPLE LEAF CEMENT in DaudKhel will raise
its price to match DG cement’s. This is due to cartel of all of the cement manufacturers
in Pakistan. Thus the customer has no choice at all to switch between two brands of
cement. As the cement market is moving from a virtual 'sellers' market' to an over-
supply situation, it is expected that when prices stagnate and profitability becomes a
function of volume and economies of scale, location advantage and proximity to
markets will become extremely important factors. At present the freight charges are a
massive 20% of the retail prices. The plants located very close to each other and
tapping the same market will have to expand their markets which will increase their
freight expenses. Dandot, Pioneer, Maple Leaf and Garibwal are all located within a
radius of 100 kilometers and are selling bulk of their production in the same areas and
will thus face serious competition from each other. Market Share: The market share if
Cement industry is as such that since large number of manufacturers are in the market

Institute of Business and Technology Page 35


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

and are targeting the entire market through the formation of Cartel. So the dominancy of
market share is yet to be analyzed by us. This dominancy can be attributed to two
factors: 1. Brand name 2. Product quality. Since pricing is similar so production capacity
can provide a vague idea with regards to the market share of all the players.

Production FY10:
North Zone

Institute of Business and Technology Page 36


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Sr.
Name Of Unit Installed Capacity
No.
Clinker Cement
1 Askari Cement Limited - Wah 1,050,000 1,102,500
2 Askari Cement - Nizampur 1,500,000 1,575,000
3 Bestway Cement Limited - Hattar 1,170,000 1,228,500
4 Bestway Cement Limited - Chakwal 3,428,571 3,600,000
5 Bestway-Mustehkum Cement Limited - Hattar 1,035,000 1,086,750
6 Cherat Cement Company Limited-Nowshera 1,000,000 1,050,000
7 Dandot Cement Limited - Jehlum 480,000 504,000
8 Dewan Hattar Cement Limited - Hattar 1,080,000 1,134,000
9 D.G.Khan Cement Limited - D.G.Khan 2,010,000 2,110,500
10 D.G.Khan Cement Limited - Chakwal 2,010,000 2,110,500
11 Fauji Cement Company Limited - Fateh Jang 1,110,000 1,165,500
12 Fecto Cement Limited - Sangjani 780,000 819,000
13 Flying Cement Limited - Lilla 1,140,000 1,197,000
14 GharibWal Cement Limited - Jehlum 2,550,000 2,677,500
15 Kohat Cement Company Limited - Kohat 2,550,000 2,677,500
16 Lucky Cement Limited - Pezu 3,725,714 3,912,000
17 Maple Leaf Cement Factory Limited - Daudkhel 3,510,000 3,912,000
Lafarge Pakistan Cement Company Limited -
18 1,950,000 2,047,500
Chakwal
19 Pioneer Cement Limited - Khushab 1,933,571 2,030,250

Sub Total (North Zone) 35,713,500


34,012,857

South Zone
1 A.C. Rohri Cement Limited - Rohri 230,000 241,500
2 Al-Abbas Cement Limited - Nooriabad, Dadu 450,000 472,500
Attock Cement Pakistan Limited - Hub Chowki,
3 1,710,000 1,795,500
Lasbela
Dadabhoy Cement Industries Limited -
4 504,762 530,000
Nooriabad, Dadu
5 Dewan Cement Limited - Dhabeji 750,000 787,500
6 Javedan Cement Limited 600,000 630,000
7 Lucky Cement Limited, - Indus Highway, Karachi 3,428,571 3,600,000
8 Pakistan Slag Cement Limited - 157,500
9 Thatta Cement Limited - Thatta 300,000 315,000
10 Zeal Pak Cement Limited - Hyderabad 342,857 360,000
Institute of Business and Technology Page 37
Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Current Situation:

The industry is now calling on the government to step in, as profits take a beating. High
energy costs for all, in addition to the cost of transporting imported coal to producers in
the north of the country, has placed a significant financial burden on producers that has
reportedly left many on the verge of collapse. Though the cost of cement production has
risen exponentially, it is difficult to pass that price rise on to consumers in such a
depressed market. In addition, the plan to increase exports has suffered from the high
cost of transportation and the failure to introduce a subsidy that would benefit the
industry. The APCMA is asking the government to get rid of excise duties that add
Rs.52/bag in taxes and to fix a minimum price on exports to Afghanistan, which are
currently priced very low due to the enormous competition between northern producers.

3.4 Consumption

Unfortunately, Pakistan in the recent past was trailing behind all other developing
countries in the region with lowest per capita consumption of cement. The domestic
consumption of the commodity reached 23.5 million tons, an addition of 2.5 million tons
in three years.

Per capita consumption of cement is an indicator of rate with which any country is
developing. Unfortunately per capita consumption of cement in Pakistan is less if we
compare it with other developing countries. It is about 145 kg per person annually;
whereas world average is about 270 kg. This less consumption is due to the negligence
given to the construction sector. However in last few years consumption of cement
showed some rise due to increased commercial activities, infrastructural development
and increasing demand of constructing houses.

Local demand of cement is rising not because of higher local utilization but due to high
exports, and hence less availability of cement is pushing local demand and prices up.
Construction of four large dams will generate demand of 3.7mn tons as construction

Institute of Business and Technology Page 38


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

activities start. Extent of demand generation will depend on size of dam, type of dam,
and extent of relocation/resettlement activities required. Bhasha dam will generate
maximum demand as it is RCC concrete dam whereas other dams being
Earthfill/Rockfill dams will require less cement for their construction. Resettlement
activities for Kalabagh dam will generate maximum demand as it is located in a highly
populated area.

The resumption of countrywide construction activities after the winter spell has
skyrocketed the local consumption of cement to 63 percent higher than last January.
The construction activity has shot up both in public and private sectors besides the
Northern Areas, and the cement demand has received a sudden jump.

The industry sources are expecting further rise in consumption in the days to come.

However, some circles are also carrying an impression that the cement manufacturers
and the cement dealers have formed a cartel to create an artificial shortage of cement in
the market with the rise in demand.

But according to the All Pakistan Cement Manufacturers Association (APCMA), local
dispatches during January 2007 rose to 1,853,487 metric tonnes against 1,141,443 of
January 06, registering a phenomenal growth of 63 percent.

Cement Consumption Per Capita:

Per capita cement consumption is one of the denominators of the development of any country.
Per Capita Consumption at 70 kgs. in Pakistan is one of the lowest in the world. According to a
study conducted by Q-Consult, 42 countries of the world having similar per capita income as that
of Pakistan have DOUBLE per capita cement consumption than that of Pakistan. This is
indicative of the fact that in Pakistan resource allocation of the Government is not development
oriented. This problem needs to be addressed by the Planning Division in Islamabad.

Earthquake rehabilitation to boost demand:

Institute of Business and Technology Page 39


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

After the earthquake of October 8th, 2009, the demand for cement rose manifold due
to the rehabilitation and developmental programs. The conditions that constitute this
growth due to earthquake are as follows: Earthquake losses were estimated at USD
5.2bn Reconstruction work boosted construction material demand Some portion of
development expenditures was allocated to this project Reconstruction work is expected
to generate cement demand of 4mn tons over next 3-4 Cement manufacturers in
northern zone will be the main beneficiaries of this demand growth.

3.5 Exports

The cement industry of Pakistan entered the export markets a few years back, and has
established its reputation as a good quality product. The latest information is that India
will import more cement from Pakistan. So far 130,000 tonnes cement has been
exported to the bordering country.

The last few years have been a golden period for cement manufacturers, when the
government increased spending on infrastructure development. High commercial
activity and rising demand for housing on account of higher per capita income has kept
cement off take growth in double digits.

During the financial year-07, cement sales registered a growth of 31 percent to 17.53
million tonnes as against 13.5 million tonnes sold last year. The cement sales during
July-February-08 showed an increase, both in domestic and regional markets to 18.17
million tonnes. The domestic sales registered an increase of 7.2 percent to 14.4 million
tonnes in the current period as compared to 13.5 million tonnes last year whereas
exports stood at 3.7 million tonnes as against 1.8 million tonnes in the corresponding
period last year; showing an increase of 110 percent.

The prospects for cement exports seem bright in the medium term due to rising
domestic as well as regional cement demand. Pakistan also achieved improved access

Institute of Business and Technology Page 40


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

to India after the complete removal of the 12.5 percent custom duty on Portland cement
imports in this country. Showing improved export opportunities for Pakistan. India is
planning to import more cement from Pakistan to stabilize prices in the market and the
government wants a balance in demand and supply of cement in the current fiscal
year.

The targets for exports for 2009 and 2010 were set at 9.99 million and 10 million tonnes
respectively. Currently, the export demand is expected to be from new inductee India
along with other countries like Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries, due to rising
oil prices-led economic growth. More countries like South Africa which imported cement
from Pakistan for football stadiums for the World Cup and Sri Lanka also approached
Pakistani companies for cement imports. However, export depends on factors such as:
ability to produce cement at Rs 85 per bag.

Export strategy should be made for at least three years , after which new plant will start
production in the region. In the meantime industry should explore new markets for
export or ready to lower prices of cement in local market. The latest information is that
India will import more cement from Pakistan. So far 130,000 tones cement has been
exported to the neighboring country. The government is considering allowing further
concessions and additional incentives for cement export, with a view to increase overall
export volume. These measures will immensely help in promoting and protecting high
investments made in cement sector in recent years. In the wake of its huge surplus
production as a result of massive capacity expansion undertaken it rather seems.
Imperative for Pakistani cement industry, on one hand, to sustain existing export
markets and, on the other, explore new markets.

Rank of Pakistan in Cement Export:


Pakistan has already joined the world club of cement exporters, with 48th ranking
among a total of 116 exporting countries, having attained recently an export figure of
USD 33.24 million. Some of the big players from Pakistan who can possibly play a
major role in the export of cement to India are Lucky Cement, the largest cement

Institute of Business and Technology Page 41


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

producer in the country, DG Khan Cement Co, Maple Leaf Cement, Attock Cement,
among others.

Export Trend :
Growth in cement export remained slow down during FY05 owing to the fact that
surplus domestic demand has surpassed supply as most of the local cement
manufacturers were operating at 100% capacity and still were not able to meet present
demand. Presently some of the cement companies are exporting cement to
Afghanistan, Iraq and UAE only to maintain their presence in these markets. After
completion of major expansion plans in Pakistan, there would be a surplus to export in
these markets however , Iran would also be able to approach vigorously these markets
as its most of the cement plant will start to come online. At that juncture there would be
extreme competition between both countries to capture these markets, especially the
war-ravaged countries (Iraq and Afghanistan). Iran would get benefit in terms of price as
cement prices in Iran is among the cheapest in the world as the price of cement in Iran
remained between $20-$25 per ton. On the other hand it is expected that being the US
ally, Pakistan would get most of the favor in order to keep its market share in these
markets given the fact that all the construction activities in Iraq and Afghanistan would
be taken by US. Despite the fact that cement constitutes as one of the basic necessities
for shelter, the policy makers have subjected the cement sector to the highest taxation
in the region. The levy of General Sales Tax (GST) on cement is Rs660 per ton in
Pakistan as compared to Rs320 in India. In the light of this tax regime, it is said that
Pakistan has one of the highest tax rates on cement in the Asian region. The impact of
such tax and duty structure has resulted in almost 40 per cent increase in the cement
price per 50 kg bag when compared to India suppressing demand for Pakistan cement.

Pakistan cement factories continue to make significant progress in cement exports.


Now Pakistan is ranked 5th in the world’s cement exports after a huge increase of 47
percent in exports during last fiscal year. According to the Global cement report, China
maintained first position with 26 million tonnes in exports, while Japan got second
position by exporting 12.6 million tonnes of cement to different countries..

Institute of Business and Technology Page 42


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

We are leading exporter of Ordinary Portland Cement (Grade 42.5 N/R), Sulphate
Resistant Cement (SRC) and Slag Cement from Pakistan. In recent years, tremendous
growth is seen in export of cement from Pakistan. Our competitive prices, experience in
shipment handling & flexible payment terms have made us premium choice for cement
importers around the world. We have ability to handle export shipments of any volume.
Our popular export destinations are India, South Asia, Gulf region, Afghanistan, South
Africa and many African countries.

Export FY10:

Export of Cement and Clinker


|------------------Cement-----------------| |---Clinker---|
Afghanista India Other Other
Financial Total %age
n Via Sea & Countries Countries
Years Exports Incr/(Decr)
Via Land Land Via Sea Via Sea
|-------------------------------Quantity in Metric Tons-------------------------------|
2001-
106,620 - - - 106,620 100.00%
2002
2002-
430,332 - - 41,500 471,822 342.53%
2003
2003-
1,118,293 - - - 1,118,293 137.02%
2004
2004-
- 157,270 1,565,170 39.96%
2005 1,407,900 -
2005-
- 91,165 1,505,159 -3.83%
2006 1,413,994 -
2006-
- 1,096,995 390,973 3,213,494 113.50%
2007 1,725,526
2007-
786,672 3,045,995 1,106,127 7,716,620 140.13%
2008 2,777,826
2008-
634,455 6,061,035 908,690 39.34%
2009 3,148,306 10,752,486
2009-
4,013,671 722,967 5,637,163 283,436 10,657,235 -0.89%
2010
2010-
2011 3,277,159 382,271 2,905,338 159,289 6,724,057 -14.46%
9 Months

Institute of Business and Technology Page 43


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Competition in export markets:


With regards to the competition in export markets, we have observed following
behaviors of cement industry in Pakistan. Cement exports started in FY02 to
Afghanistan that is still a major market Iraqi market can become a potential target after
peace is restored India and Iran are the major competitors for Pakistan in the Middle
Eastern region Upcoming capacity expansions in Iran and other GCC countries will
create tough competition for Pakistan. Export prices are presently touching USD 75/ton
in the exports market, however they are likely to come down as new capacities comes
online However, the cost and exports may be affected due to weakness of the US dollar
causing coal, electricity charges and freight prices, comprising 65 to 70 percent of the
cost. The PSDP allocation has been cut by Rs. 75 billion and feared further cuts would
curtail cement demand. Major capacities of countries like India and Iran are expected to
come online by FY11 and onwards which are likely to convert these countries from
dependent importers to potential exporters.

The export reached to $ 500 million increase during 2008. Data for the first quarter of
FY08 show that Afghanistan was Pakistan’s largest cement export market. The
prospects for cement exports seem bright in the medium term due to rising domestic as
well as regional cement demand. Pakistan also achieved improved access to India after
the complete removal of the 12.5 percent custom duty on Portland cement imports in
this country from January 2007, showing improved export opportunities for Pakistan.
India is planning to import more cement from Pakistan to stabilize prices in the market
and the government wants a balance in demand and supply of cement in the current
year.
In June 2010, sales of cement in Pakistan were counted at 2.09 million t. By July 2010,
however, a reduction of 16% in cement sales was recorded, with the figure standing at
just 1.75 million t, according to data acquired by the APMCA. This does not go against
previous trends, as cement sales typically decrease during the monsoon season in
Pakistan, which occurs in July. This trend is further supported by the sales figures of
July 2009, where sales decreased by 12%. In 2010, however, the decrease in cement

Institute of Business and Technology Page 44


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

sales has been more dramatic and can be explained by the increased rainfall and
resultant floods that affected the region at the end of July.

Export figures also showed a decline, with a monthly reduction of 15% and a reduction
of 31% y/y. There are two principal reasons for this decline. As far as the monthly
figures are concerned, this was a result of the lack of an inland freight subsidy. The
reduction in yearly figures was as a result of higher overall prices in the sector.

There was no recovery in August 2010, however, as a direct result of the flooding, and
also due to the slowdown in the construction industry that usually occurs during the
month of Ramadan. The sales recovered during the beginning of the 2011/12
financial year; this is due to the fact that extensive rebuilding will be necessary in
regions that have suffered severe damage during the recent floods.

Prior to 2011, however, further decreases in cement dispatches occurred . In August


2010 for example, cement dispatches reduced by between 20 – 30%. As a knock-on
effect of this decline, the sale price of cement during September and October is
expected to see a reduction of about Rs.10 – 20 per bag. Prices should return to their
original figures once rebuilding starts during the coming months, while the cement sales
figures should be restored by the latter half of 2011.

Dispatch figures are expected to gradually recover, with some slight improvements,
although dispatches will remain low in comparison to previous years’ figures.

Export Outlook:

There was sluggishness in the growth of cement exports in Pakistan during the first
nine months of FY09/10, which can be explained by examining the slowdown in
construction in the GCC. However, there was significant growth in the cement export
figures to other African nations, and so many Pakistani cement manufacturing
companies are actively targeting this market. However, this has encouraged local
cement manufacturers in Africa to try to hamper sales of Pakistani cement in their
countries.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 45


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

A decline in prices internationally has also contributed to the export slowdown, as has
an increase in inland charges, which has discouraged cement manufacturers in
northern Pakistan from exporting their commodities. An inland freight subsidy has been
supplied by the Pakistani government, but its effects have not yet been seen.

The export of cement from Pakistan increased 52% in initial nine months of 2009 to
reach 7.9 million tonnes. According to All Pakistan Cement Manufacturers Association
(APCMA), local cement dispatches in first nine months fell by 17 percent to stand at
13.9 million tonnes, though of pace of growth has slowed down in recent months.

The consumption of cement in local market depends a lot on climatic conditions


therefore, on monthly basis local dispatches went up to 1.7 million tonnes as winter
season has worn off and local projects have gradually started to gain momentum.

Export has also increased by 10 percent on monthly basis to 1,032,000 in March. Based
on estimates, exports have crossed the 1 million mark first time ever.

On the export front, depreciation of rupee has rendered Pakistani cement as a highly
attractive option. The north has primarily contributed to the impressive increase in
exports.

The exports primarily increased due the demand coming from Afghanistan that
accounts for 28 percent of the exports (36 percent in FY08). “This is because the
increasing exports have primarily been directed towards the cement thirsty UAE, the
elaborate construction projects of which have yet to take a hit from the ominous
economic slowdown,” an analyst said.

Demand from Middle East and African countries continued to drive exports, though
there is a risk that global economic slump may affect future export orders. As a result,
share of exports in total sales rised to 36 percent in the first nine months of FY09 as
against 24 percent in the corresponding period of last year.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 46


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Exports are expected to register a slow down in growth, as the global economic hold up
deepens further reducing demand for housing and construction activities. The demand
and supply gap in the international market is expected to narrow down further as other
countries gear up with more capacity, thus reducing export demand, analysts said.

“Pressure is being exerted on local demand, primarily due to macro-economic


slowdown, high interest rates, sky-high cement prices . The local prices are currently
hovering around an average retail price of Rs 355 per 50 kg bag (Rs 7,100 per tonnes)
and a retention price of Rs 255 per 50 kg bag (Rs 5,109 per tonnes).

Studies have shown that cement demand is highly correlated with the growth rate of
GDP. Recently, the ministry of finance has further revised the GDP growth target
downward to 3.4 percent from 3.5 percent, which will further erode cement demand.

Pakistan cement factories continue to make significant progress in cement exports. Now
Pakistan is ranked 5th in the world’s cement exports after a huge increase of 47 percent
in exports during last fiscal year. According to the Global cement report, China
maintained first position with 26 million tonnes in exports, while Japan got second
position by exporting 12.6 million tonnes of cement.

According to figures provided by the All Pakistan Cement Manufacturers Association,


the first seven months of this fiscal have seen both domestic and export sales suffering,
with the former down 9.63% and the latter declining by 17.03%

Total sales for the July 2010 – January 2011 period reached just 17.2 million t, down
12.01% y/y. In the July 2009 – January 2010 period, domestic sales had increased
14.7%, contributing to an overall sales growth of 9.3% as exports fell.
Pakistan has a massive installed capacity of over 41 million t, divided unevenly between
the north (which has by far the greater part at >30 million t capacity) and south of the
country. A further 2.68 million t will be added this fiscal, as Fauji Cement’s new plant
becomes operational. Domestic demand in Pakistan is comparatively low, with the
majority of capacity intended for export, on which the industry is highly reliant. However,
capacity utilization has been falling since its peak of 90% in 2004/05. In 2009/10

Institute of Business and Technology Page 47


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

capacity utilization stood at 76.53% and that figure has decreased to 71.55% in the first
seven months of 2009/10.

Companies exporting cement from the land-locked north of the country via sea have
suffered the loss of many export orders due to the debilitating transportation charges
from their plants to the ports.

At one time, the rate of growth of export sales was phenomenal, registering a 140%
increase in 2007/08 and a 39% increase the following fiscal, at which point export sales
stood at 10.75 million t. The 2009/10 fiscal saw a small decline to 10.65 million t.
Exports in the first seven months of this fiscal have reached 5.19 million t, a 17.03%
decline y/y.

3.6 Future Prospects

The cement demand would increase in future due to Government policies as the
Pakistan People’s Party’s (PPP’s) slogan has always been ‘roti, kapra aur makan’
(bread, clothing and housing). In this regard a statement of the PPP Government
confirmed that it would encourage industries and construct small dams. Pakistan's
economy, PACRA said grew impressively during last five years with an average GDP
growth rate of around 7%. Cement industry has a positive correlation with the GDP
growth rate. The major domestic demand drivers are public sector development
programs (infrastructure), real estate and industrial construction.

But on other hand there are many factors, which can create problems in Pakistan
cement industry. According to the experts of Pakistan Credit Rating Agency (PACRA)
the cement sector is currently facing severe challenges which originate from a wide
range of socio-economic risks including contracting economic activities, and high input
costs. These negative developments, along with the prevailing credit crunch and rising
interest rates, have further constrained the industry's prospects.

The encouraging economic environment not only energised the local demand but also
provided momentum for capacity expansion. Resultantly, the industry added significant

Institute of Business and Technology Page 48


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

capacity recently, while several new production lines are scheduled to commence
operations shortly. During this period, the cement manufacturers also established export
operations by catering to the growing demand of regional economies. This, while
stabilizing the local cement prices, had a positive impact on capacity utilization and
margins. Although the local demand reduced significantly in the first quarter of FY 09
(around 15% decline), strong growth in exports has provided support to the industry in
the form of largely sustained capacity utilization and price stability. However, given the
global export demand is expected to come down.

This would negatively impact the margins and put pressure on local prices that could
lead to a price war among producers. The looming supply overhang scenario in the
sector could potentially worsen the situation. Profitability of the sector has come under
pressure due to high energy cost (comprising around 50% of total raw material costs)
and increasing financial expenses.

Keeping these developments in view, the outlook on the sector is negative which
implies that PACRA perceives downward pressure on the ratings within the industry,
especially for high leveraged entities. PACRA, as part of its on going inspection, is
monitoring all developments very closely, and may take a client specific rating action
wherever it is deemed feasable. However, the cost and exports may be affected due to
weakness of the US dollar causing coal, electricity charges and freight prices,
comprising 65 to 70 percent of the cost. The PSDP allocation has been cut by Rs 75
billion and feared further cuts would curtail cement demand.

Future Course of action for Cement Industry and Government:

Related governmental regulations:

The policy of the Government is to keep a balance between rapid economic


development, on the one hand, and social justice and consumer’s protection, on the
other. There is a traditional conflict between these two aims. It is, therefore, necessary
to regulate trade, commerce or industry in the interest of free competition therein. The
Ordinance was promulgated to provide for measures against un-due concentration of

Institute of Business and Technology Page 49


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

economic power, growth of un-reasonable monopoly power and un-reasonably


restrictive trade practices.

Thus cement industry too is monitored and answerable to rules and regulations
developed by the monopoly control authority of Pakistan. The government is
considering allowing further concessions and additional incentives for cement export,
with a view to increase overall export volume. These measures will immensely help in
promoting and protecting high investments made in cement sector in recent years. In
the wake of its huge surplus production as a result of massive capacity expansion
undertaken it rather seems imperative for Pakistani cement industry, on one hand, to
sustain existing export markets and, on the other, explore new markets.

1. Govt. Should improve law & order to support export

2. Ban likely to be placed on cement import

3. No changes in cement import and export policy.

4. Crisis: Country faces energy crisis, Rising prices hurting


industry.

5. Short-term measures:

• Duty drawback

• Port charges

6. Medium term measures:

• Abolishing of / reduction in central excise duty

7. Long term measures:

• Infrastructure at port.

8. Pakistan could save about $70 million on the import of furnace oil per annum.
This would result in a low price per bag of cement and would ultimately
encourage domestic demand for cement.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 50


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

9. A comparative study regarding taxes on cement indicates that as against


Pakistan where the taxes on cement are 37 per cent, it is nil in Iran, 7 per cent in
Thailand, 10 per cent in Egypt, 10 per cent in Philippines, 10 per cent in
Indonesia and 18 per cent in India.

Cement manufacturing in Pakistan was never as optimistic as it has become in the


preceding couple of years. Though an oligopoly, there exists enormous competition
between members of the lobby. Critical success factors of the industry have commonly
become utilization of idle production capacity, additions to which have started sending
hostile signals to market participants. Cement manufacturers have undertaken counter
offensive strategies by introducing capacity enhancements of their own to capture extra
market share and achieve economies of scale from production activities.

The cement industry tends to rely on growth in agriculture income, along with
government spending on infrastructure. However in 2011, there will be no demand from
these two important sectors. On the contrary, further fallout from the flooding will result
in large demands on the government finances, while the majority of farmers in Pakistan
will have limited funds due to the extensive destruction of crops and the resultant
decrease in income.

As the floods occurred immediately before the month of Ramadan, the cement
manufacturers within Pakistan had already built up a surplus in imports so as to have
sufficient stocks built up at the ports within the country. Although the floods decimated
the country’s communications, the rebuilding which began in December 2009 helped to
settle the issue to an extent.

Right now, the future prospects of the Pakistan cement industry are good. A manifold
increase in cement exports to African nations and the Middle East should occur.
Additionally, there is massive reconstruction taking place in both Iraq and Afghanistan,
which should rely extensively on cement imports from Pakistan.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 51


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

It is possible that the cement industry in Pakistan may undergo widespread growth in
2014, as a result of projected regional and local demand. In the last ten years, cement
demand has risen to 33.2 million tonnes, an increase of 235%. Production, however,
has increased to 44.8 million t, leaving a surplus of 11.6 million tonnes.

While extensive damage has been caused by the last flooding, there is a definite need
for planned and directed investment in infrastructure, transport and construction within
Pakistan, especially if the nation is to achieve its ambition of a gross GDP growth of 6%
within the coming five years. It is essential for the future development of industry in
Pakistan that trade corridors, highways and dams be provided.

The overall future of Pakistan Cement is bright b/c after Earth Quake & flooding there is
a huge demand for constructing new houses. The population is increasing rapidly
creating more demand for houses & cement. Moreover people are moving from villages
to cities in search for jobs & better conditions creating more demand for housing. The
government should decrease duties on the sector so that its price becomes low & it is
consumed locally more beneficially. There is also a need to find better export avenues
other than the ones they already have. Power shortage also affects all industries
including cement sector. There is a need to develop more cheap electricity projects to
fulfill the demand of electricity by the industrial sector.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 52


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

4. GIANTS OF PAKISTAN CEMENT INDUSTRY

4.1 Lucky Cement

Sponsored by well known “Yunus Brothers Group” – one of the largest export houses of
Pakistan, Lucky Cement Limited currently has the capacity of producing 25,000 tons per
day of dry process Cement.

Lucky Cement Limited is Pakistan’s largest cement manufacturing company with the
production capacity of 7.75 million tons per annum. Lucky Cement Limited is also
Pakistan’s first and largest exporter of loose cement and is the only cement
manufacturer to have loading and storage terminal at Karachi Port. Other exclusive
attributes that allow Lucky Cement to stand ahead of its competitors is the
transportation fleet of 77 bulkers as well as 2 ship loaders.

Lucky Cement came into existence in 1996 with a daily production capacity of 4,200
tons per day, currently is an omnipotent cement plant of Pakistan, and rated amongst
the few best plants in Asia.

With production facilities in Pezu (Production capacity: 13,000 Tons per day) as well as
in Karachi (Production capacity: 12,000 tons per day), it has the tendency to become
the hub of cement production in Asia.

We envision being the leader of the cement industry by identifying and capitalizing on
new market opportunities, meeting expectations of the stakeholders, contributing
towards industrial progress and sustainable future, while being responsible corporate
citizens.

Our mission is to expand our business network by forming strategic alliances in the
global market.
We endeavor to equip our business with the latest technology to produce quality cement
while conserving energy & recuding co2 emission to reinforce eco-friendly business
practices; thus meeting international standards.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 53


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

We employ the latest production techniques and the finest quality of raw materials to
ensure optimum efficiency at all stages of production.

The efficiency and the effectiveness of our production method(s) help us compete in the
market and meet the growing demands of our customers.

YB Group has diversified interests in the fields of textile, cement and energy sectors.
The Group was established in 1962 and today has a strong and sound standing position
in Pakistan and around the globe. It owns the largest cement manufacturing facility and
the largest yarn manufacturing unit in the country. It has to its credit the honor of being
Pakistan's largest exporter. YB Group is driven by the needs of its customers,
shareholders, local communities and society at large.

The Pakistan Cement Industry concluded the financial year ended June 30, 2010 with a
decent growth of 9.4% and achieved highest ever total sales volume of 34.22 million
tons against the last year's sales volume of 31.28 million tons. The industry witnessed a
handsome growth of 14.6% in local sales volume and achieved the highest ever local
sales of 23.53 million tons in the history of the Country in spite of depressed public
sector development project spending by the Government. The recovery in local sales
was mainly achieved on the back of private sector, coupled with recovery of rural
economy because of better agriculture support prices. On contrary, the industry
witnessed a breakeven in export sales and exported 10.69 million tons of cement and
clinker as compared to 10.75 million tons exported last year.

By the grace of Almighty Allah, your Company managed the highest ever total sales
volume of 6.63 million tons during this financial year and witnessed an overall
handsome growth of 12.3% over the last year total sales volume of 5.90 million tons.
Out of the total sales, the local sales volume witnessed a robust growth of 26.3% with
3.12 million tons over last year's volume of 2.47 million tons whereas the export sales

Institute of Business and Technology Page 54


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

volume witnessed a meager growth of 2.2% with sales volume of 3.51 million tons over
last year's volume of 3.43 million tons.

Your Company is in continuous process of improving operational and cost efficiencies


and has made huge investment in recent years. Alhamdullilah, during this financial year,
your Company has achieved another milestone by successful operation of the Waste
Heat Recovery Project of Karachi Plant which has replaced almost 23% power
generation related fuel cost of the Company. With the increase in prices of oil and gas,
the benefit of cheap electricity generation from Waste Heat Recovery Project without
any fuel consumption will enhance the cost competitive strength of your Company.

4.2 Attock Cement

Attock Cement Pakistan Limited (ACPL) is a public limited company, listed on the
Karachi Stock Exchange since June 2002. Main business of the company is
manufacturing and sales of cement. ACPL is part of the Pharaon Group, which in
addition to investment in cement industry has diversified stakes in Pakistan mainly in
the oil and gas sector, power and real estate sector.

ACPL is a member of Pharaon Group of Companies operating in Pakistan. ACPL's


project was conceived in 1981. The project is a Pak-Saudi venture and has involved an
initial capital outlay of around Rs.1.5 billion with a foreign exchange component of
around US$ 45 million. ACPL's manufacturing plant is located in Tehsil Hub, District
Lasbela, Balauchistan, at a distance of about 45 kilometers north west of Karachi. ACPL
has attained ISO 9001:2000 and ISO 14000 certifications from Lloyds Register Quality
Assurance (LRQA) in 2002 and 2006. ACPL is making substantial contribution to the
country's economy and deposited over Rs.2,646 million (US$ 31.5 million) in the form of
Excise Duty , Sales Tax, Royalty and Income Tax during the year 2008-2009.

The Plant's original capacity was 2000 TPD of Clinker and it was the first plant in the
country to be based on the latest SUSPENSION, PRE-HEATER/PRE-CALCINATION,

Institute of Business and Technology Page 55


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

dry process technology which results in substantial savings in fuel and energy costs
besides balanced plant operations.

With continuous growth in cement demand both in local and regional markets, the
company put up another line of 3,300 TPD of clinker in 2006-2007 at a total investment
of US $ 61 million. With this additional line the total clinker capacity of the company has
reached 1,710,000 MT of clinker per annum.

“The cement manufactured and being marketed under the “FALCON” brand is of the
highest standard and truly the market leader.”.

To be the leading organization, continuously providing high quality cement, excelling in


every aspects of it's business and to remain the market leader in the cement industry.

To be a premier and reputable cement manufacturing company dedicated to become


industry leader by producing quality products, providing excellent services, enhancing
customer satisfaction and maximizing shareholder's value through professionalism and
dedicated team work.

• We are committed to produce high quality, FALCON CEMENT which not only
meets but exceeds the international quality standards.
• We aim to maintain leadership of our Cement Industry providing premium quality
products and excellent services to our consumers.
• We work as a team of dedicated professionals, who achieve excellence through
training, development and continuous technological up-gradation.
• We aim to implement and continually improve the effectiveness of our Quality
Management System.
• We provide safe and conducive work environment to our staff by ensuring
stringent standards of safety and health.
• We make a contribution towards the uplift of our environment and inhabitants of
the surroundings.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 56


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

The Company continued to strongly support the uplift of the local community, as they
are an integral part of it. Basic education facilities, medical treatment and availability of
clean drinking water to the masses are the few top priorities of the Company. Presently,
we are successfully running a school in Sakran where children of workers and nearby
villages are getting free education. Moreover, with the cooperation of local
administration, we are planning to upgrade the existing school in Hub, having all
required facilities. Sensing the dire need for availability of medical facilities for the
deserving, the Company regularly arranges free medical camps for the locality where
treatment and medication is provided free of cost. During the year three medical camps
were arranged where nearby villagers and Company workers' families were given free
treatment. Additionally, the Company embarked upon and awareness programme on
Hepatitis ‘B' & ‘C' for the local residents of nearby Goths. The Company provides
transport in emergency and financial help to the downtrodden nearby villagers on a
regular basis.

The Company currently operates a Primary level school that imparts education to
children of both plant employees and also those from neighbouring villages.

The Company has also signed a Memorandum of Understanding with The Citizen
Foundation (TCF) a non-profit organization for the construction of TCF primary and
secondary school located near to factory premises, which is close proximity to the
surrounding villages. The total cost of this project would be around Rs. 40 million. This
school would comprise of 2 units primary portion and 2 units secondary portion. The
structure of the primary school building has been completed and the progress of the
project is on track as per the schedule. The school would commence its academic
activities from April 2010. With the completion of this school at-least 1000 children of
this area will get quality education free of cost.

4.3 D. G. Khan Cement

D.G. Khan Cement Company Limited (DGKCC), a unit of Nishat group, is the largest
cement-manufacturing unit in Pakistan with a production capacity of 5,500 tons clinker

Institute of Business and Technology Page 57


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

per day. It has a countrywide distribution network and its products are preferred on
projects of national repute both locally and internationally due to the unparallel and
consistent quality. It is list on all the Stock Exchanges of Pakistan.

DGKCC was established under the management control of State Cement Corporation of
Pakistan Limited (SCCP) in 1978. DGKCC started its commercial production in April
1986 with 2000 tons per day (TPD) clinker based on dry process technology. Plant &
Machinery was supplied by UBE Industries of Japan.

Nishat Group acquired DGKCC in 1992 under the privatization initiative of the
government. Starting from the privatization, the focus of the management has been on
increasing capacity as well as utilization level of the plant. The company undertook the
optimization by raising the capacity immediately after the privatization by 200tpd to
2200tpd in 1993.

To meet the increasing demand and to capitalize on its geographic location, the
management further expanded the capacity by adding another production line with a
capacity of 3,300 tons per day in year 1998. Design of the new plant is based on latest
dry process technology, energy efficient and environmental protection from particulate
pollution according to the international standards. The plant and machinery was supplied
by M/s F.L. Smidth of Denmark. As a result, DGKCC emerged as the largest cement
production plant in Pakistan with annual production capacity of 1,650,000 M tons of
clinker (1,732,000 million tonnes Cement) constituting about 10% share of the total
cement production capacity of the country. The optimization plan is still underway to
increase the total capacity of the two units to 6700 TPD by mid of 2005 from 5500 TPD
at present.

Furthermore, the Group is also setting up a new cement production line of 6,700 TPD
clinker near Kalar Kahar, Distt. Chakwal, the single largest production line in the
country. First of its kind in cement industry of Pakistan, the new plant will have two
strings of pre-heater towers, the advantage of twin strings lies in the operational
flexibility whereby production may be adjusted according to market conditions. The
project will be equipped with two vertical cement grinding mills. The cement grinding

Institute of Business and Technology Page 58


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

mills are first vertical Mills in Pakistan. The new plant would not only increase the
capacity but would also provide proximity to the untapped market of Northern Punjab
and NWFP besides making it more convenient to export to Afghanistan from northern
borders.
For continuous and smooth operations of the plant uninterrupted power supply is very
crucial. The company has its own power generation plant along with WAPDA supply.
The installed generation capacity is 23.84 MW.

DG Khan Cement Co. Ltd., production processes are environment friendly and comply
with the World Bank’s environmental standards. It has been certified for “Environment
Management System” ISO 14001 by Quality Assurance Services, Australia. The
company was also certified for ISO-9002 (Quality Management System) in 1998. By
achieving this landmark, DG Khan Cement became the first and only cement factory in
Pakistan certified for both ISO 9002 & ISO 14001.

4.4 Maple Leaf Cement

At the time of privatization in 1992, the capacity of Maple Leaf to produce Ordinary
Portland Cement (OPC) was 1000 tones per day (tpd). A second plant of 4000 tpd was
commissioned in 1998 and a third plant of 6700 tpd came into production in 2006. It
increased the total capacity to 11,700 tpd. The capacity of White Cement has also
increased from 100 tpd to 500tpd with the addition of a new plant. This plant also has
provisions for doubling the capacity to 1000tpd. Presently Maple Leaf cement has 9% of
the market share of OPC and is a leading brand in Pakistan with a diverse customer
base. It is also the largest producer of White Cement in the country with 80% of market
share.
The plants of 4000 tpd, 6700 tpd and of White Cement are state of the art and have
been supplied by FLSmidth in Denmark. In order to ensure the highest efficiency and
process control the plants comprise of equipment with the latest design and technology.
To maintain the highest quality standards a laboratory has also been set up at site for
the testing of raw materials and cement. All Maple Leaf plants comply with National
Environment Control standards.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 59


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

In order to remain competitive in the market the management at Maple Leaf


continuously re evaluates its business strategies. With the increase of furnace oil prices
the company adopted coal as a more cost efficient and environmentally friendly fuel for
kiln firing. Today the management believes that the future lies in exploring the
possibilities of alternative and cheaper fuels such as waste firing. This would further
reduce production costs whilst promoting a culture of environmental awareness, health
and safety.

Maple Leaf Cement is committed to run an efficient and profitable business and
therefore aims to employs cutting edge technology to ensure energy efficiency and the
optimum use of natural resources. The visionary and experienced management drives
the company to set goals that position Maple Leaf ahead of the competition and as a
key player in the cement industry.

Maple Leaf has developed a niche market for specialized cement such as SRC
(Sulphate Resistant Cement), Low Alkali Cement and Oil Well Cement. Maple Leaf is
the only local Cement manufacturer producing Oil Well Cement.

4.5 Lafarge Cement

Lafarge Pakistan Cement (LP) is a part of Lafarge, world leader of construction


materials. The state-of-the-art plant commenced Commercial Operations in December
2006 with an annual cement production capacity of 2.5m tons, thus becoming the
largest production line in Pakistan.

The plant is located at Kalar Kahar, District Chakwal in the province of Punjab, an area
rich in lime stone reserves. The quality of lime stone in this area is considered to be the
best in the region. In addition to Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC) the plant can also
produce Sulphate Resistant Cement (SRC) with the packaging options of 50 kg bags,
1.5 tons, 2 tons jumbo bags and bulk carriers. The advanced plant laboratory is the
most sophisticated in the industry and ensures consistent high quality of cement.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 60


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

LP is proud of its product PAKCEM which is the leader on all quality scales. PAKCEM is
the first cement in Pakistan to comply with European Standards (EN 197) and Indian
Standards (IS 12269) also far exceeding requirements of Pakistani Standard (PS 232).

LP’s aim of being at the forefront in creating foundations for a prosperous tomorrow is
backed by the Company’s philosophy of providing outstanding value to its customers, a
safe and stimulating work environment for its employees, superior returns for its
shareholders and special focus on social responsibility and environmental protection.

Strive to exceed the expectations of our stakeholders through sustainable growth and
high quality performance.

We are committed to providing outstanding value to our customers, a safe and


stimulating work environment for our employees and superior returns for our
shareholders.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 61


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

5. FINANCIAL ANALYSIS OF CEMENT INDUSTRY TOP PLAYERS

5.1 Profit and Loss Statement Analysis

Profit & Loss Ratios:

 Profitability Ratios:

1) Gross profit margin:

Gross profit margin is computed by dividing earnings before interest and taxes by total
operating revenue and thus they express profit as a percentage of operating revenue.

Gross Profit Margin = Gross profit / sales


2008 2009 2010
1- D. G. Khan Cement = 32% 16% 17%
2- Lucky Cement = 26% 37% 33%
3- Attock Cement = 22% 32% 26%
4- Maple Leaf Cement = 17% 32% 22%
5- Lafarge Cement = 13% 12% 12%

2) Net Profit Margin:

Net profit margin is computed by dividing net income by total operating revenue and
thus they express profits as a percentage of operating revenue.

Net Profit Margin = Net income / Sales


2008 2009 2010
1- D. G. Khan Cement = -0.43% 2.91% 1.43%
2- Lucky Cement = 15.79% 17.46% 12.80%
3- Attock Cement = 8.70% 17.54% 13.26%
4- Maple Leaf Cement = -8.65% -6.45% -18.95%
5- Lafarge Cement = -16.70% -15.73% -13.78%

Institute of Business and Technology Page 62


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Net Profit Margin Illustrated in Chart:

20.00%
15.00%
10.00%
D.G Khan
5.00%
Lucky
0.00%
Attock
-5.00% Maple Leaf
-10.00% Lafrage
-15.00%
-20.00%
2008 2009 2010

3) Operating Profit Margin:

Operating Profit Margin = EBIT / SALES

2008 2009 2010

1- D. G. Khan Cement = 12.11% 18.76% 13.89%


2- Lucky Cement = 18.14% 27.41% 17.31%
3- Attock Cement = 16.57% 24.78% 19.12%
4- Maple Leaf Cement = 5.74% 16.28% 3.74%
5- Lafarge Cement = 0.90% -0.29% 0.90%

 Interest Coverage Ratio:

One of the most traditional of the coverage ratios is the interest coverage ratio, or times
interest earned. This ratio is simply the ratio of earning before interest and taxes for a
particular reporting period to the amount of interest charges for the period to the amount
of interest charges for the period.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 63


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Interest Coverage = Earnings before interest and taxes (EBIT) / Interest expense

2008 2009 2010

1- D. G. Khan Cement = -0.14 0.30 0.19


2- Lucky Cement = 21.13 3.72 4.19
3- Attock Cement = 2.83 12.47 17.88
4- Maple Leaf Cement = -0.37 -0.29 -1.25
5- Lafarge Cement = -0.83 -1.04 -0.94

 Earning per Share:

Earning per share is calculated Profit after Tax divided by No. of Ordinary shares, it
shows current rate of per share of the company.

Earning per Share = Profit after taxes / No. of ordinary Shares

2008 2009 2010


1- D. G. Khan Cement = -.021 1.96 0.72
2- Lucky Cement = 9.84 14.21 9.70
3- Attock Cement = 6.03 20.69 11.74
4- Maple Leaf Cement = -1.96 -2.78 -6.94
5- Lafarge Cement = -1.01 -0.97 -0.72

Detailed Profit & Loss Statements of major companies provided in Annexure A

5.2 Balance Sheet Analysis


Balance Sheet Ratios:

 Liquidity Ratios:

1) Current ratio:

The most widely used measure of short-term debt paying ability is the current ratio. This
ratio is computed by dividing total current assets by total current liabilities. The higher
the current ratio, the more liquid company appears to be.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 64


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Current Ratio = Current assets / current liabilities


2008 2009 2010
1- D. G. Khan Cement = 1.59 0.84 1.19
2- Lucky Cement = 1.06 1.30 0.71
3- Attock Cement = 1.51 2.43 2.62
4- Maple Leaf Cement = 0.81 0.52 0.54
5- Lafarge Cement = 0.73 0.31 0.26

2) Quick Ratio :

Inventory and pre-paid expenses are the least liquid of the current assets. Therefore
same short term creditors prefer the quick ratio to the current ratio as a measure of
short term solvency.
The quick ratio compares only the most liquid current assets – called Quick assets with
current liabilities quick assets are those which can be converted most quickly into cash
the higher the current ratio, the more liquid company appears to be. Quick ratio should
be greater than 1.

Quick Ratio = Current asset – inventory / current liabilities


2008 2009 2010
1- D. G. Khan Cement = 1.56 0.78 1.12
2- Lucky Cement = 0.99 0.73 0.65
3- Attock Cement = 1.09 1.89 2.28
4- Maple Leaf Cement = 0.75 0.46 0.48
5- Lafarge Cement = 0.55 0.21 0.19

 Debt Ratios:

1) Debt to Total Asset Ratio:

It highlights the relative importance of debt financing to the firm by showing the
percentage of the firm’s assets that are supported by debt financing. It is derived by
dividing a firm’s total debt by its total assets

Institute of Business and Technology Page 65


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Debt to Total Asset = total debt / total asset


2008 2009 2010
1- D. G. Khan Cement = 0.42 0.51 0.44
2- Lucky Cement = 0.46 0.39 0.34
3- Attock Cement = 0.40 0.31 0.24
4- Maple Leaf Cement = 0.68 0.74 0.80
5- Lafarge Cement = 0.50 0.50 0.55

2) Debt to Equity :

The debt equity ratio is the value of total debt divided by the book value of equity which
implies how much time total liabilities are greater than the share holder equity.
So this ratio should be small because if the large numbers of shares are outstanding
even than there is no obligation on the company to pay the dividends. But in the case of
debt the interest payment is must therefore debt equity ratio should be a small number
as far as the management is concerned.

Debt to Equity = total debt / equity


2008 2009 2010
1- D. G. Khan Cement = 0.73 1.04 0.77
2- Lucky Cement = 0.84 0.65 0.53
3- Attock Cement = 0.66 0.46 0.31
4- Maple Leaf Cement = 2.13 2.82 5.07
5- Lafarge Cement = 0.99 1.02 1.21

 Asset Activity Ratios:

1) Inventory Turnover Ratio:

Measures how many times the inventory has been turned over (sold) during the year;
provides insight into liquidity of inventory and tendency to overstock.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 66


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Inventory Turnover Ratio = Cost of Goods Sold / Inventory


2008 2009 2010
1- D. G. Khan Cement = 23.62 13.73 13.09
2- Lucky Cement = 17.76 13.80 27.15
3- Attock Cement = 9.49 9.45 15.59
4- Maple Leaf Cement = 14.96 15.82 21.18
5- Lafarge Cement = 6.82 9.87 9.64

2) Total Asset Turnover :

The relationship of net sales to total assets is known as the total asset turnover, or
capital turnover ratio. Measures relative efficiency of total assets to generate sales

Total Asset Turnover = Sales/ total asset

2008 2009 2010


1- D. G. Khan Cement = 0.24 0.42 0.35
2- Lucky Cement = 0.61 0.81 0.64
3- Attock Cement = 0.85 1.22 1.09
4- Maple Leaf Cement = 0.30 0.59 0.52
5- Lafarge Cement = 0.34 0.41 0.35

Total Asset Turnover Illustrated in Chart:

1.4
1.2
1 D.G.Khan
0.8 Lucky
0.6 Attock

0.4 Maple Leaf


Lafrage
0.2
0
2008 2009 2010

Institute of Business and Technology Page 67


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

Detailed Balance Sheets of major companies provided in Annexure B


5.3 Cash Flow Statement Analysis

With regards to cash flow statements Attock Cement has the best cash flow currently
(FY!0) with cash flow of Rs.427109 followed by Lucky Cement Rs.333629 & Maple
Leaf Rs.73625.

Detailed Cash Flow Statements of major companies provided in Annexure C.

5.4 Statement of Changes in Equity


When we went through the Statement of Changes in Equity of top companies we found
that D.G Khan Cement has the highest equity currently (FY!0) with over 26.5 m followed
by Lucky Cement 25 m & Lafarge Cement 8.8 m.

Detailed Statements of Changes in Equity of major companies provided in Annexure


D.

6. SWOT ANALYSIS OF CEMENT INDUSTRY

6.1 Strengths

1- Availability of Raw Material.

2- Imported Machinery and plants in most of companies, which provide better


quality to over all process.

3- Pakistan already established its position as an exporter of cement and clinker in


the region,.

4- Availability of foreign investment and loans has also played an important role in
softening the demand for bank credit. The moderation in fixed investment
demand in cement, construction and textile is more of a reflection of the fact that
these industries had already expanded their capacities in recent years and
floatation of debt instruments (e.g., chemical, cement, real estate and ship yard)
in the domestic market cement, real estate and ship yard) in the domestic
market.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 68


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

5- The compressive strength is a very important factor of cement. The Portland


cement achieves its maximum strength in 28 days. The Pakistan standard PSS
232-1883 (R) & British Standard BS 12: 1978 provides for 28 days strength of
5000 Psi and 5950 Psi respectively for mortar cubes.

6- Cement industries in Pakistan are currently operating at their maximum capacity


due to the boom in commercial and industrial construction within Pakistan.

7- Effect of GDP:
Following effects of GDP will govern the growth of cement industry in Pakistan:
• Higher GDP growth has positive impact on cement demand
• Cement demand growth rate was double the GDP growth rate in last three
years
• GDP growth is expected to continue to have same positive impact on
demand growth.
8- Housing demand to grow:
Following indications have showed a considerable demand of cement in
Pakistan:
• Housing projects consume roughly 40% of cement demand
• Currently 0.3mn houses are built annually against demand of 0.5mn
• Low interest rates, post 9/11 remittances’ inflow, and real estate boom
have helped housing sector growth.
• Easy mortgage availability and announcement of low cost housing
schemes will determine housing sector growth in the long-run.
9- Government’s development spending shall continue to rise due to:
• Government development expenditures count for one third of total
cement consumption.
• Increase in development expenditures has helped cement demand to
grow at very high rates.
• Increase in PSDP- as announced in Medium Term Development
Framework 2005-10 - will help cement demand to grow in the country.
• Infrastructure development in a region triggers private development
projects having even positive impact on cement demand.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 69


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

10- Pakistan cement industry is one the largest exporter in Asia, major markets are
of Afghanistan and Iraq will be after peace. Its increased GDP by exports,
providing cements in Large Dams Project and earthquake rehabilitations
projects.
11- Laboratory testing facilities meeting all American and European standards and
Vertical cement grinding mills.
12- Cement industry called major Performance Blue Chip in current economic
survey 2007-08 because during the first three quarters of the fiscal year 2007-08,
the combined paid-up capital of ten big companies was Rs. 91 billion, which

Institute of Business and Technology Page 70


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

constituted 13.17 percent of the total listed capital at KSE in which Fauji
Fertilizer, DG Khan Cement, Lucky Cement played major role.
13- Today, we find a relatively better scenario as compare to past. Most of the
cement plants, that used to operate on furnace oil, have now been converted into
coal system, which has substantially reduced cost of production.
14- The most modern selection of production equipment possible in every major
department of the plant.

6.2 Weaknesses

1- The stage of industrial development, in most of the segments, is still at a very low
level of technology and the existing industrial base is very narrow and consists of
very basic industries such as cement, sugar, textile, cigarette, edible oil, fertilizer,
soda ash, caustic soda, PVC etc.

2- Since cement is a specialized product, requiring sophisticated infrastructure and


production location. So, most of the cement industries in Pakistan are located
near/within mountainous regions that are rich in clay, iron and mineral capacity.
Structure of Cement industry in Pakistan is as such that there is not much
substitutability to buyers. Which shows that the Cross elasticity of demand is
negligible.

3- The customer has no choice at all to switch between two brands of cement due
to cartel of all of the cement manufacturers in Pakistan.

4- The freight charges are a massive 20% of the retail prices. The plants located
very close to each other and tapping the same market will have to expand their
markets which will increase their freight expenses. Dandot, Pioneer, Maple
Leaf and Garibwal are all located within a radius of 100 kilometers and are
selling bulk of their production in the same areas and will thus face serious
competition from each other.

5- Consumers face a tough decision with regards to prefer which brand over which
because of the similar pricing of cement industry. The formation of cartel by the
Institute of Business and Technology Page 71
Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

cement manufacturers have exploited local consumers a lot and this has led to
the concentrated degree of oligopoly, where the firms are acting as a single unit
to perform their monopoly. Their combined market power is simply a diluted
version of the dominance that a single firm with a monopoly market share can
exert.

6.3 OpportunitIies
1- The local cement industry faces high upfront fuel costs. In order to facilitate their
conversion to coal, which is widely available in the country, the government has
given incentives for imported plant and equipment for coal firing units.

2- The demand of Pakistani cement is expected to continue to grow at the rate of 20


per cent for about four years to come. It may then follow traditional growth rate of
seven per cent per year. Announcement of major dams will dramatically increase
this demand.

3- Deregulation after accession of Pakistan to WTO is expected to open the window


of competition from cheaper markets. There may be no tariff after this
deregulation on import of cement allowing its entry into Pakistan from cheaper
market at lower rate. Cement from cheaper markets may also block Pakistan’s
export of cement to its neighboring countries. Global market has vigorously taken
up the advantage of economy of scales and multinational giants now control
more than 40 per cent of world production (China not included). The recent
acquisition of Chakwal Cement by an Egyptian giant, Orascom may be a
beginning of such an entry in Pakistan by multinationals. New avenues for export
of cement are opening up for the indigenous industry as Sri Lanka has recently
shown interest to import 30,000 tons cement from Pakistan every month. If the
industry is able for avail the opportunity offered, it may secure a significant share
of Sri Lanka market by supplying 360,000 tons of cement annually.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 72


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

6.4 Threats
1- Unanticipated increase in interest rates or less than expected demand growth
might create severe crises for the sector couple of years forward.
2- Lack of demand or depressed demand in future will prove to be lethal for the
sector that has just started to recover from the miseries of 90s. Lack of demand
forced cement units to operate at very low capacity utilization in nineties. There
was a fierce competition among cement manufacturers.
3- A price war was witnessed which ended up with no conqueror. Similar
apprehensions exist for the future when there will be plenty of excess capacity.
Any hurdle in the growth of cement demand may force the sector into the price
war. Yet, we expect cement manufacturers to act prudent and learn lesson from
the history. Any mistake, similar to the one made in the last decade, will again
coerce the sector into the era where all are losers with no winner.

4- Main component of the cost is fuel. Pakistan's cement industry has converted
their plants to coal considering it to be the cheapest fuel, but its price in
international markets has gone up by more than 300 per cent in the last one
year, which directly relate increasing the cost of production.

5- The demand of cement falls heavily during rainy weather in the country, which
directly affects the running cost of a unit. It is only the rising levels of cement
exports, which are sustaining the industry.

6- Instead of appreciating the marketing skills of cement entrepreneurs to explore


new markets for cement, the industry is being pressurized constantly without
realizing that any reduction in cement exports from Pakistan will not only deprive
the country of foreign exchange ($2 billion this year), but will also result in losses
to the industry.

7- The burden of increased input costs has to be borne by the consumers. It is only
the government, which can provide relief to the consumers by cutting down or
abolishing the central excise duty.

8- Problems of oversupply situation:

Following problems might arise with the oversupply situation in cement industry:
• Lower capacity utilization will reduce benefits of economies of scale.
High leverage will also adversely affect profitability of new plants.
• New plants will gain market share at the cost of older players, which
are not undergoing expansion. Large idle capacity is will create panic
in players and this may result in price wars in the coming years.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 73


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

9- IMF Package in Future can cause to decrease GDP and economical


development in Pakistan. Which will also be cause to stop development of
infrastructure. So it will have huge effect on cement industry also.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 74


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

7. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS

7.1 Conclusion

The law and order situation in the country is deteriorating day by day which affects all
the industries including cement industry. The economic crisis which hit the entire
world is another element which is making the cement industry business to
decline. Due to the declining situation of cement industry; there is a direct affect
on the economy.

The investors tend to avoid investment in our country due to this critical situation. The
Government of Pakistan should make a concrete strategy and control the law
and order situation so that the investors invest or start some projects in our
country. If the situation is stable in our country the investors who want to do
business in our country can play an important role to raise the country’s
economy.

We did Financial Analysis of top five companies of Pakistan cement Industry along with
a brief overview of overall Pakistan Cement Industry. Our Financial analysis included
Profit & Loss Statement analysis, Balance Sheet analysis, Cash Flow Statement
Analysis, Financial Ratio Analysis, and Statement of changes in capital of top five Major
Companies of Pakistan Cement Industry. According to our analysis Attock Cement is
one of the best with regards to Net Profit having a net profit of 13.26% Attock Cement is
also the highest if we see its Earning per Share in the market which is Rs.11.74. Attock
Cement’s Current ratio is also the best right now which is 2.62. The Debt to asset ratio
of Attock Cement is also the best or lowest which is 0.24 which means it relies on debt
financing the least of all the five companies. Attock Cement’s Debt to equity ratio is also
the lowest which is 0.31. Inventory turnover of Lucky Cement is the best with 27.15 %.
Attock Cement has the best Total Asset turnover which is 1.09.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 75


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

With regards to cash flow statements Attock Cement has the best cash flow currently
(FY10) with cash flow of Rs.427109 followed by Lucky Cement Rs.333629 & Maple
Leaf Rs.73625.
When we went through the Statement of Changes in Equity of top companies we found
that D.G Khan Cement has the highest equity currently (FY10) with over 26.5 m
followed by Lucky Cement 25 m & Lafarge Cement 8.8 m.

For FY 08 Lucky Cement can be termed as the best with regards to major financial
ratios b/c its N.P & EPS was the best of the five.

For FY 09 Attock Cement was the best when we see its major financial ratios which
indicate that it performed best for the year.

We can conclude by stating that Attock Cement is the best cement company currently
(FY10) with regards to major financial statement analysis followed closely by Lucky
Cement.

7.2 Recommendations

The Cement Industry of Pakistan is one of the industries which is in a better state of
affairs compared to other industries. The demand for cement is high both locally &
abroad. The future prospects for its augmentation are bright & optimistic. We
recommend the following measures to improve the industry further so that it’s
production & export can be increased for bringing foreign exchange in to the Pakistan ‘s
exchequer:

1. Special Rebate should be given to the Cement exporting companies.

2. Import Duties should be very low on the import of machinery & other equipments
required for commencing a Cement Manufacturing Plant so that more
companies enter the Cement Market.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 76


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

3. The prices of cement currently are very high & the demand for cement is very
high too b/c more & more people are moving from villages to towns creating
more demand for housing projects. The Construction industry wants to buy more
cement but it cannot buy cement at a high price b/c people are not ready or
cannot afford houses at high prices. Also due to population rise there is a
increasing demand for more houses but since the prices of cement are high;
Construction Companies are redundant to make houses at high prices. The
problem with Construction industry is that if they buy cement at a high price; they
would build houses at expensive prices too, considering their own profit
margin also but a major chunk of people cannot afford houses at expensive
prices. Therefore cement prices should be brought down substantially &
immediately.

4. MFI (Most Favored Industry) status should be initiated by the Government &
Cement Industry of Pakistan should be given MFI status in order to boost
production & export b/c our Cement Industry has a great potential to grow in the
future.

5. Pakistan should try to save money on the import of furnace oil; which would
reduce the price of cement per bag & increase its demand locally.

6. The power shortage affects every industry including Cement . Steps should
be taken to make more small dams b/c a large dam like Tarbela takes almost ten
years to complete., Import power stations from China & Iran at cheaper price ,
low dependence on thermal power which is costly & Special Consideration
should be given to Industrial Units with regards to Load Shedding which happens
almost throughout the year.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 77


Financial Analysis of Top Five Major Players of Pakistan Cement
Industry

REFERENCES

There are following references through which we have conducted our research:

 Damien Demailly and Philippe Quirion, Venice International University.


 Nathan Martin, Ernest Worrell & Lynn Price, Lawrence Barkeley National
Laboratory.
 Sultan A. Meo.
 C.A Hendriks, E Worrell, D. de Jager, K. Blok, P.Riemer, Greenhouse gas
control technologies conference paper.
 Talita Riberiro Tenorio de Franca, Rephaela Juvenal da Silva, Michellini Seycias
de Queiroz, Carlos Menzes Aguiar.
 The Daily Dawn
 Economic & Business Review
 All Pakistan Cement Manufacturers Association Reports
 Economic Survey Of Pakistan
 State Bank Of Pakistan Annual Reports.

Institute of Business and Technology Page 78

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen