Sie sind auf Seite 1von 9

744 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 23, NO.

2, MARCH 2008

Methodology for Cable Modeling and Simulation


for High-Frequency Phenomena
Studies in PWM Motor Drives
Helder De Paula, Darizon Alves de Andrade, Member, IEEE, Marcelo Lynce Ribeiro Chaves,
Jose Luis Domingos, and Marcos Antônio Arantes de Freitas

Abstract—The analysis of the transient overvoltages in a through the capacitive couplings of the motor and feeding
pulsewidth modulation (PWM) motor drive system comprises a cable can lead to electromagnetic interference (EMI) problems,
wide frequency range, which starts with the low values corre- misoperation of ground-fault protection and motor bearing
sponding to the motor speed, includes the switching harmonics,
which can reach up to few hundreds of kHz, and also the cable failures [1]. Solutions for these high-frequency problems are
resonance frequency, which value can be in the MHz range, de- generally based on filters. A comprehensive comparison among
pending on the cable length. In this context, this work presents a different filter topologies for differential mode overvoltage
time domain methodology for cable modeling able to represent the reduction was conducted in [2], which elected the RLC filter
cable parameters variation due to skin effect in this broad range at the inverter terminals as the most interesting alternative. A
of frequencies. The proposed technique reproduces accurately the
wave propagation and reflection phenomena, thus showing to be
LC filter placed at the inverter output with dc link feedback
very appropriate to transient overvoltage studies in PWM motor was analyzed in [3] as a very effective solution for reducing the
drives. A new alternative to represent the frequency-dependent common mode phenomena. Particularly from the EMI point
cable earth-return path is also included, allowing the computation of view, this topology makes possible the use of unshielded
of the zero-sequence currents generated by the common-mode inverter-to-motor cables in industrial facilities, in most cases.
voltage produced by the inverter. Simulations using the proposed
The effects of transient overvoltages were first verified in sys-
methodology are conducted and the obtained results are compared
with measurements, showing good agreement. tems where the motor is fed by inverter through long length ca-
bles [4]. The voltage pulses applied by the inverter travel along
Index Terms—Cable modeling, common-mode currents,
pulsewidth modulation (PWM) motor drive, skin effect, transient
the cable to reach the motor, and their combination with the cor-
overvoltages. responding reflected waves can lead to overvoltages at the motor
terminals. Transient overvoltages of up to 3 p.u. (1 p.u. dc link
voltage) have been reported in the literature [5], [6]. With con-
I. INTRODUCTION verters using modern semiconductors with very small turn on
time, these effects of overvoltages have become observable even
ULSEWIDTH modulation voltage source inverter
P (PWM–VSI) electronic converters make most of the
topologies to drive induction machines. Two main problems
in short length cables. Very fast pulse rising time means very
high frequencies; therefore, to accurately predict the possible
overvoltages, both the motor and cable models must be appro-
occur with such systems: 1) transient overvoltages at the motor
priate for a very wide frequency range, up to MHz level. Induc-
terminals and 2) high-frequency common-mode currents.
tion motor models that incorporate the effects of high frequency
The transient overvoltages at the motor terminals appear as a
are found in literature [8]–[10], where the basic idea is to use an
consequence of the continuous application of voltage pulses,
equivalent circuit whose frequency response approximates the
originated from the electronic converter and reflected at the
measured values. An important aspect of these models is the ad-
cable endings, while the common-mode currents are due to
equate representation of the intrinsic capacitances of the motor,
inherent inverter common-mode voltages. Distinct and un-
which, in high frequencies, represent low impedance paths for
desirable consequences can emerge from this situation. The
the current generated by the voltage pulses. For the intercon-
overvoltages will mainly compromise the stator winding in-
nection cable, the key point is the correct inclusion of the skin
sulation, and the common-mode currents, flowing to ground
effect in its modeling considering the range of frequencies stated
above, as in a PWM motor drive system the voltage frequency
Manuscript received April 23, 2007. This work was supported by the spectra starts with the low values associated to the motor speed,
Brazilian agencies CAPES and FAPEMIG. Recommended for publication by
Associate Editor P. Tenti.
includes the switching harmonics and go up to the highest fre-
H. De Paula is with the Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais (UFMG), Belo quency components associated to the pulse rise time, situated in
Horizonte 31270-010, Brazil (e-mail: helder@cpdee.ufmg.br). the MHz range. Since the skin effect in the earth-return path is
D. A. Andrade and M. L. R. Chaves are with the Faculdade de Engenharia
Eletrica (FEELT), Universidade Federal de Uberlandia (UFU), Uberlândia
very intense [7], the correct prediction of common-mode cur-
38.400-902, Brazil (e-mail: darizon@pesquisador.cnpq.br; darizon@ufu.br). rents is also dependent on a model that takes into account the
J. L. Domingos is with the Centro Federal de Educacao Tecnologica (CEFET/ large frequency spectra. Besides, the transient overvoltage os-
GO), Goiânia 74.055-110, Brazil.
M. A. A. de Freitas is with the Centro Federal de Educacao Tecnologica
cillations at motor terminals can go from some kHz (as in the
(CEFET)-UNED/GO, Jataí 75800-000, Brazil. case of submarine systems) up to a few MHz, depending on the
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TPEL.2007.915759 cable length. Thus, the model must correctly represent the resis-
0885-8993/$25.00 © 2008 IEEE
DE PAULA et al.: METHODOLOGY FOR CABLE MODELING AND SIMULATION FOR HIGH-FREQUENCY PHENOMENA STUDIES 745

tance and inductance of the cable in this wide frequency range


in order to assure an accurate reproduction of the transient over-
voltages in terms of frequency, peak values, shape and attenua-
tion of the voltage oscillations.
Several works attempted to reach this goal, but, in general, all
of them present some limitation or disadvantage. Some are able
to correctly represent the cable parameter dependency with fre-
quency only in a limited frequency range [11], [12], being then
appropriate for applications with very long leads only, as for ex- Fig. 1. Transversal section of a cable sub-divided in “n” concentric tubular
ample those found in submarine systems. Others involve com- conductors.
plex mathematical procedures [13], [14], being of hard compre-
hension for the machine and drive engineer. An efficient model
is presented in [8], but it requires measurements to calculate the current in each sub-conductor does not vary along its way, the
necessary parameters and that represents a serious limitation. expressions of the voltage drop in each sub-conductor, including
Fixed-parameter models with resistance and inductance values mutual coupling, lead to an equivalent circuit with infinite R–L
chosen at high frequencies (generally the cable resonance fre- branches [21] as shown in Fig. 1. Because infinite number of
quency) were used in [15], [16]. Despite their good represen- branches is not practical, a simpler representation is in demand.
tation of the overvoltage amplitude damping, they fail to ac- The simplification consists in defining a finite number of sub-
curately reproduce the attenuation of all other components ex- conductors (branches) for the model. This circuit, referred to
isting in the inverter output voltage. The simplified modeling of as the “n-branch model,” comprises for each branch, R–L el-
the cable just by its lumped capacitance, as in [17], can only ements that do not vary with frequency, but are properly con-
be applied in drive systems that employ a step-up transformer nected resulting in an equivalent impedance that represents the
at the inverter output. This is typically the case of submarine cable resistance and inductance frequency variation [Fig. 2(a)].
and underground mining long cable motor drives, where the The problem consists in the determination of the n-branch cir-
main resonance occurs between the transformer inductance and cuit parameters, from a given set of resistance and inductance
the cable capacitance and not within the cable L–C parameters, cable parameters known for different frequencies.
which makes this strategy inadequate for study of typical in- The procedure is summarized as follows.
dustrial drive systems. The method proposed in [18] is not very Considering the particular case of a two-branch model as rep-
practical, since the parameters of the model are calculated on resented in Fig. 2(b), the model parameters are determined an-
trial and error basis. In [19], the values of the various elements alytically [21] as
of the circuit were obtained by means of a mathematical solver
tool and the frequency range analyzed (starting at 100 kHz) is (1)
not suitable for motor drives studies. The difficulty in obtaining (2)
the model parameters was observed in [20], but no solution was
proposed, neither was shown how to determine the values used (3)
in the work.
The methodology presented in the present work overcomes (4)
all the limitation and disadvantages mentioned above. It is
simple, accurate and fully adequate to the requirements of
(5)
motor drives application. It is named “N-Branch” model and
is based in a ladder-type network. Initially developed in [21]
for a limited range of frequencies up to fiftieth harmonic order (6)
and used in power quality studies, the modeling technique
has been improved to consider the skin effect in the required where:
frequency range. The paper also shows a new equivalent circuit — are the resistance and inductance of the
for the prediction of common-mode currents. This equivalent first and second branches of the model, respectively;
circuit, which uses the “n-branch” cable model, does not re- — are the input data, comprising the re-
quire modal transformation or any other complex mathematical sistance and inductance of the cable known, at frequencies
procedure, and is therefore simpler than existing techniques. and respectively. As seen, from (1)–(6), with two
As will be shown, the prediction of both differential voltages known values of resistance and inductance of the cable for
and common-mode currents is achieved in the same simulation the two corresponding frequencies, the parameters of the
using the proposed circuit. two branch model are analytically determined.
A better representation can be obtained if more than two sets
of cable parameters are available. If “n” pairs of cable param-
II. “N-BRANCH” CABLE MODEL
eters are known for “n” different frequencies, a cir-
To include the parameters frequency dependence, the cable cuit with up to “n” branches can be drawn and its parameters
can be represented as an association of infinite shunt-connected calculated. However, the calculation of R-L circuit parameters
concentric tubular sub-conductors (Fig. 1), each one with its with three or more branches cannot be made in the analytic way
own value of inductance and resistance. Considering that the shown above. It is achieved using the equations for two branch
746 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 23, NO. 2, MARCH 2008

Fig. 3. Cable equivalent circuit with “n” branches.

the frequencies , by successively


applying (7) and (8) derived from the circuit of Fig. 3. It
can be interpreted as having the external tubular sub-con-
ductor of the n-branch extracted, and calculating the new
set of parameters for the equivalent cable represented by
n-1 branches

(7)

(8)

3) With the n-1 pairs of and determined,


the inner equivalent conductor formed by n-1 branches is
completely characterized. The n-1 set of parameters of the
equivalent conductor can now be used to determine the
(n-1)th branch in the same way as done for the n branches
conductor. Steps “2)” and “3)” are repeated until a data set
with only two frequencies is reached, when the inductive
and resistive parameters of the first branch ( and )
are evaluated using (5) and (6).
When exercising this methodology, a concern that arises
is related to the optimal number of branches to represent a
Fig. 2. (a) “N-Branch” circuit and the corresponding equivalent R L
impedance. (b) Two-branch model. given cable configuration. One will find that not always the
highest number of branches is the best solution. In fact, the
optimum solution is the one that requires the smallest number
of branches while delivering an accurate representation of R
model and an additional procedure called “sequential circuit
and L frequency dependency in the whole range of frequencies
order reduction.” It is explained as follows.
involved in the problem. If an excessive number of branches
1) From the data set consisting of “n” pairs of resistance/in-
is used, it can happen that some branch parameters come up
ductance for the “n” corresponding frequencies, two
with negative values, even so, the equivalent resistance and
of them ( and ), related to the
inductance of the model are always positive values. Inves-
highest pair of frequencies ( and ), are taken. Then,
tigations showed that adjusting the frequency range of the
the parameters of the n-branch model corresponding to the
data set and/or reducing the number of branches lead only to
external branch are evaluated through (1)–(4).
positive parameters, which is more meaningful in the analysis.
2) To proceed with the model determination, the n-branch
It was verified that a data set given with proportionally spaced
model is represented by the equivalent circuit shown in
frequencies almost
Fig. 3. Note that this equivalent circuit is not a two branch
always lead to a good modeling.
model. It is composed by the external (nth) branch and
an equivalent impedance ( and ) that rep-
A. Obtaining the Cable Parameters for Different Frequencies
resents the association of all remaining n-1 branches for
all frequencies. That is, the total impedance of the cir- There are at least four options to determine the cable R–L
cuit shown in Fig. 3 matches the known data cable in all parameters at different frequencies to make the input data
given frequencies. Therefore, it is possible to determine the set for the modeling: 1) using the “Cable Constants” routine
equivalent parameters of the inner branches association for of EMTP platform, 2) by means of finite element analysis
DE PAULA et al.: METHODOLOGY FOR CABLE MODELING AND SIMULATION FOR HIGH-FREQUENCY PHENOMENA STUDIES 747

Fig. 4. Resistance (top) and inductance (bottom) variation in relation to fre- Fig. 5. Errors obtained for the model equivalent resistance (top) and inductance
quency. Results from models with four, five, and six branches. (bottom). Results from models with four, five, and six branches.

[16], [19] (where the proximity effect can also be considered); wave propagation and reflection phenomena that occur in the
3) direct measurements and iv) using the method proposed cable endings and the associated voltage/current oscillations.
in [22], which uses very simple equations. A remark is to be Distributed-parameter models present this feature, but the in-
made about direct measurements, which are often difficult clusion of its dependence with frequency, in the time domain, is
and/or unavailable due to very high cost of measuring equip- very complex to be implemented [13], [14].
ment, and aside from that, requires special attention to avoid An alternative solution is to use a lumped-parameter model
exciting the cable natural frequencies during measurements, associating its cells in a number high enough to “capture” the
which would lead to mistaken parameters. Using the equations propagation phenomenon, keeping in mind that these cells
and methodology proposed in [22] it is possible to obtain the must comprise parameter-dependency with frequency. The
cable resistance and inductance matrixes for a given cable “n-branch” model fulfills this requirement. The higher the
arrangement at any desired frequency. For this, the following number of lumped segments, the more accurately the dis-
information is required: a) electrical resistivity and diameter of tributed nature of the cable parameters is reproduced. However,
the conductors, b) dielectric permittivity, magnetic permeability an excessive quantity of “pi” cells leads to a prohibitive com-
and thickness of the insulation, c) resistivity of the ground, and putational effort, and thus a reasonable number must be found.
d) distance between wires and from them to the ground plane The key point to define the appropriate number of circuits to be
(see Appendix I). If the cable is shielded, the parameters of the cascade-associated is the relation between the wavelength of the
shielding must also be provided. The equations of this method electric field established in the conductor and the length of the
were incorporated in the “N-branch” model software routine, cable. The length of each lumped segment should be calculated
making it possible to directly obtain the parameters for the in order to make the electric field variation negligible or rea-
desired “N-Branch” models by entering the cable constructive sonably small in each “pi” circuit. The question becomes how
and geometric data, along with the desired frequency range to define the wavelength, since the PWM voltage waveform is
and the number of branches to be used in the models. The a summation of many harmonic components, all contributing
program also outputs the equivalent impedance curves and to the formation of the electric field. The highest-frequency
the corresponding errors for the various “n-branch” models components of a PWM voltage are associated to the pulse rise
analyzed, as a function of the frequency. time, and a pulse equivalent frequency “ ” can be defined
Figs. 4 and 5 show the results for the resistance and induc- [24]
tance representation of a 3 4 mm cable with the proposed
modeling, for four-, five-, and six-branch models, from 20 Hz (9)
up to 2 MHz. As can be seen from Fig. 5, the maximum er-
rors obtained for the cable resistance and inductance are 4.4% The corresponding wavelength “ ” can be calculated by
at 2 MHz and 0.25% at 500 kHz, respectively, in the case of a
six-branch model.
(10)

B. Wave Propagation Phenomena: Lumped versus Distributed (11)


Parameter Modeling

The computational analysis of the transient overvoltages re- where “ ” is the pulse rise time, “ ” is the wave propagation
quires models that represent the frequency dependency and also speed and “ ” and “ ” are the cable positive-sequence
the distributed nature of the cable parameters, reproducing the inductance and capacitance. “ ” was obtained from the cable
748 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 23, NO. 2, MARCH 2008

Fig. 6. Transient overvoltage simulated results obtained by modeling the motor


as a high ohmic value resistor. The cable was modeled with 60 Hz-fixed param-
eters (a), 500 kHz-fixed parameters (b) and by the “six-Branch” model (c).

impedance matrixes calculated using [22], while “ ” was


determined by the ATP “Cable Constants” routine.
In the case of the 3 4 mm cable utilized in this section,
the propagation speed is around 1.3 10 m/s and the corre-
sponding “ ”, for a pulse rise time of 80 ns, is about 33 me-
ters. Let “ ” be defined as the relation between the length of
the lumped cells and the electric field wavelength. By means of
several preliminary simulations, it was verified that a reasonable
number for “ ” would be around 0.01 or 0.02, leading to “pi”
circuits between 33 and 66 cm. It was then decided to use two
lumped cells to represent one meter of cable length.
Fig. 7. Simulation results obtained with (a) fixed-parameter model at cable res-
III. SIMULATIONS AND MEASUREMENTS OF onance frequency and (b) “N-Branch” model.
THE TRANSIENT OVERVOLTAGES
In order to validate the proposed modeling technique, simula-
tions were carried out using ATP platform. The system analyzed produced a voltage amplitude attenuation very close to that ob-
comprises a PWM inverter, a 3 4 mm , 95 meter interconnec- tained with 500 kHz-fixed parameter model. Additionally, the
tion cable and a 2 HP three-phase induction motor. The PWM proposed model was the only one that could reproduce the pro-
voltage pulse is approximated as a trapezoidal shape. The cable gressive “rounding” in the pulse edge during its propagations
is represented by a cascade-connection of “pi” circuits, which through the cable, as can be seen in Fig. 7, showing that the
series impedance is the six-Branch model shown in Section II, model is able to provide the correct attenuation corresponding
whose parameters are shown in Table I (see Appendix II). Each to each one of the harmonics that compose the PWM pulse. For
“pi” circuit represents 0.5 m of cable length; therefore, the so- the same reason, the undesired spurious oscillations overlapped
lution of the problem involves 190 “pi” cells. The cable shunt to the main oscillation due to parameter lumpiness [7] were also
capacitance is 102,0 pF/m. eliminated.
In order to observe the attenuation of the oscillations due Fig. 8 shows the simulation and experimental results of the
only to the effect of the cable resistance, the motor was re- transient overvoltage. Curves marked “A” and “B” correspond
placed by a resistor of high ohmic value, resulting in a reflec- to the simulated and measured voltage at the inverter terminals,
tion coefficient near to 1. Fig. 6(a) and (b) show results when respectively. Curve marked “C” shows the simulated voltage
the cable is represented by fixed parameters. In Fig. 6(a) the pa- at the cable terminals when the load is a resistor, whose ohmic
rameters of the cable at 60 Hz were chosen, while in Fig. 6(b) value corresponds to the motor characteristic impedance at
the resistance and inductance refer to the cable resonant fre- 500 kHz. Curves marked “D” (measured) and “E” (simulated)
quency, around 500 kHz. Fig. 6(c) shows the result obtained refer to the voltage at the cable terminals when the load is
by using the proposed “n-branch” model with 6 branches. It the 2 HP induction motor. The simulation shows that the
is observed that the modeling with 60 Hz-fixed parameters re- cascade association of “N-Branch”-“pi” circuits led to a good
sulted in very low attenuation of the transient overvoltage, far representation of the transient overvoltage, showing good
away from the expected result, represented by the 500 kHz-fixed agreement between simulated and experimental results. The
parameter model. On the other hand, the “six-Branch” model motor model [8] used in this simulation takes into account
DE PAULA et al.: METHODOLOGY FOR CABLE MODELING AND SIMULATION FOR HIGH-FREQUENCY PHENOMENA STUDIES 749

Fig. 8. Voltage at the inverter terminals: simulated (curve A) and experimental


(curve B). Voltage at motor terminals: simulated representing the motor as a
resistor (C), simulated with a high-frequency model for the motor (E) and ex-
perimentally obtained (D).

Fig. 10. Proposed circuit for common and differential mode voltage and current
simultaneous calculation.

Some methods overcome this drawback [13], [14], but they


are quite complex. In this context, this section shows a new
method, that makes use of the “N-Branch” cable model, for the
simultaneous determination of the differential mode (transient
overvoltages) and common mode (“earth” currents) high-fre-
quency phenomena in a PWM motor drive system, by means
of a single circuit, with no complex mathematical procedures.
The cable series impedance and shunt capacitance matrixes
can be written as
Fig. 9. (a) Zero sequence and (b) positive sequence representation of the cable
“pi” circuit.
(12)

the winding-to-ground and winding turn-to-turn capacitive


couplings, which, combined to the machine inductance, define (13)
the frequency response of the motor input impedance.
Thus, the characteristic impedance of the motor is not con-
stant, but frequency-dependent, and so is the reflection coeffi- where the on-diagonal elements in (12)
cient at motor terminals. Besides, these intrinsic capacitances of refer to the series self-impedance of the loop formed by the
the motor play an important role on the dynamics of the pulse conductor “ ” and the ground return. The off-diagonal ele-
reflection phenomena, affecting the shape and the frequency of ments correspond to the series mutual
the voltage oscillations, as observed in Fig. 8. It is thus recom- impedance between conductors “ ” and “ ”, and determine the
mended that an appropriate model for the motor be also used to longitudinally induced voltage in conductor “ ” if a current
bring additional accuracy to the simulation of the transient over flows in conductor “ ”, and vice-versa. The resistive terms in
voltage phenomenon. mutual coupling are introduced by the presence of the ground.
Reporting to (13), the on-diagonal elements “ ” repre-
IV. INCLUSION OF THE COMMON MODE CURRENT PATH sent the sum of the conductor “ ” capacitance to ground and to
The determination of differential and common mode quan- all other conductors, while the off-diagonal “ ” refers to the
tities of an electric system is usually performed by means of mutual capacitance between conductors “ ” and “ ,” with a neg-
separated circuits, where the three-phase voltage is decom- ative sign.
posed in its differential and common-mode components and Considering a continuously transposed cable, all the on-di-
then applied to the corresponding circuits. The modal quantities agonal elements in (12) present the same value and will be de-
are thus obtained and latter recombined for the calculation of noted by “ ” . Likewise, the off-diagonals will be
the phase quantities. This methodology, based on the modal written as “ ” . In the case of the capacitances,
analysis, uses a transformation matrix, which becomes fre- “ ” will represent the conductor capacitance to ground and
quency-dependent in the case of the phenomena studied here. “ ” the capacitance between conductors . The
750 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 23, NO. 2, MARCH 2008

Fig. 11. Experimental setup for common mode current measurement.

positive and zero-sequence values for the cable resistance, in- to include in (22) an impedance equal to and a capaci-
ductance and capacitance can be written as tance that cancels the term

(14) (24)
(15)
(16) The proposed circuit configuration is shown in Fig. 10, where,
by means of a single decoupled three-phase circuit, it is pos-
(17)
sible to directly determinate the common and differential mode
(18) voltage and currents, simultaneously.
(19) It is to be observed that the value found in (24) must be
multiplied by three in order to make the voltage drop in “ ”
where the subscripts “pos” and “zero” refer to positive and zero equal to “ ”, and not three times this value. For the
sequence. same reason, the other impedance that is included is “ ”,
From (14)–(19), the “pi” circuits representing the positive and not its triple, assuring a voltage drop of “ ”. Ana-
and zero-sequence parameters of the cable can be presented lyzing the proposed circuit, it is seen that the positive and zero
as shown in Fig. 9. In a three-phase cable system, the posi- sequence currents, flowing through it, produce voltage drops
tive and zero-sequence circuits correspond to the differential equivalent to those expressed in (22) and (23). The mutual terms
and common-mode circulation paths, respectively. Considering of the cable impedance matrix (“ ”) refer to the earth re-
a single “pi” circuit, the voltage drop for the positive and zero turn path, in which the skin effect is very intense. Thus, both
sequence, according to Fig. 9, are cable “ ” and “ ” impedances must be represented by
“n-branch” models. Following the same methodology described
in the previous section, a new simulation was conducted, now
focusing on the determination of the common-mode current.
(20) The cable was modeled by a cascade-association of the circuit
(21) presented in Fig. 10, using the same methodology described in
Section II. The connection between the converter and the motor
Replacing (14)–(19) in (20) and (21) is made by a 100 m, 4 4 mm cable, where the fourth wire
works as the earth return path, as shown in Fig. 11. The fre-
quency converter is supplied by a modified 15 kVA distribution
transformer, Y-Y, 220/220 V, being the fourth wire of the cable
(22) connected to the neutral point of the secondary winding, where
the current clamp was connected. Fig. 11 illustrates the capac-
itive couplings to ground existing in the system under investi-
(23) gation. In the converter, the path is established by the capac-
itance between the power switches and the heat sink, while in
Comparing expressions (22) and (23), it is observed that the the motor the couplings are through the stator windings to frame
positive and zero-sequence currents, circulating in the corre- and to the rotor axis. Since both the motor and the converter are
sponding circuits, flow through different impedances. Both of not connected to the earth conductor, only the current flowing
them circulate by “ ” and “ ;” but “ ” does not flow to ground through the cable distributed capacitances was mea-
through “ .” Besides, the voltage drop on “ ” produced sured. Regarding the current measurements, 1 V corresponds to
by “ ” and “ ” are multiplied by different factors. The 0.61 A.
idea is to elaborate a single special circuit, for the phase cur- Fig. 11 shows that the common mode path comprises the
rent circulation, where its differential and common mode com- zero-sequence impedance of the cable and also the impedance
ponents (“ ” and “ ,” respectively) flow through only the of the transformer, which must be included in the modeling. In
respective impedances, correctly producing the voltage drops Fig. 12, measurements show a common mode current of 90 kHz
according to (22) and (23). To accomplish this, it is necessary with peak values within 1.4 and 1.85 A. In the simulation, whose
DE PAULA et al.: METHODOLOGY FOR CABLE MODELING AND SIMULATION FOR HIGH-FREQUENCY PHENOMENA STUDIES 751

TABLE I
PARAMETERS OF THE SIX-BRANCH MODEL OF THE CABLE USED IN SECTION III

require complex mathematical transformations. The results ob-


tained from the proposed circuit showed good agreement when
compared to measurements.
!
Fig. 12. Common mode voltage (upper) and the corresponding current
(bottom). Experimental results (1 V 0.61 A). APPENDIX I
In addition to the geometric characteristics of the cable
system under analysis, some more data is needed for the cable
parameter determination, as mentioned in Section II. Some
information is given bellow:
• Relative permittivity : for PVC insulation layers,
; for PE, ; for XLPE, ; for EPR,
.
• Relative permeability : since the insulation materials
are considered diamagnetic, .
• Resistivity of the conductor , at 20 C: for copper,
.m; for aluminum, .m.
• Resistivity of the ground : depends strongly on the soil
characteristics, ranging from 1 .m (wet soil) to about 10
k .m (rock). The resistivity of sea water lies between 0.1
and 1.0 .m [23]. Information about this parameter can
Fig. 13. Common mode voltage (upper curve) and the corresponding current be obtained from the project of the facility ground grid;
(bottom). Simulated results. if this is not available, it is recommended to use
.m, an average value obtained from a great number
of measurements [7].
results are shown in Fig. 13, the transformer impedance was rep-
resented by a 0.1 mH inductance. APPENDIX II
As seen, the peak value of the common-mode current oscil- See Table I.
lations situated in the 1.2–1.75 A range, while its frequency is
around 120 kHz, which can be considered quite satisfactory re- REFERENCES
sults. Using a more sophisticated model for the transformer, ap- [1] A. von Jouanne, H. Zhang, and A. K. Wallace, “An evaluation of mit-
propriate for high frequencies, better results can be expected. igation techniques for bearing currents, EMI and overvoltages in ASD
applications,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 34, no. 5, pp. 1113–1998,
Sep./Oct. 1998.
V. CONCLUSION [2] A. F. Moreira, P. M. Santos, T. A. Lipo, and G. Venkataramanan,
This work presented an efficient methodology for cable mod- “Filter networks for long cable drives and their influence on motor
voltage distribution and common-mode currents,” IEEE Trans. Ind.
eling and simulation, suitable for the study of the high frequency Electron., vol. 52, no. 2, pp. 515–522, Apr. 2005.
phenomena present in PWM motor drive systems. The model [3] N. Hanigovszki, J. Landkildehus, G. Spiazzi, and F. Blaabjerg, “An
is able to correctly represent the cable parameter variation in a EMC evaluation of the use of unshielded motor cables in AC adjustable
speed drive applications,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 21, no. 1,
wide frequency range, up to MHz level, thus being appropriate pp. 273–281, Jan. 2006.
for this application. It was observed that the cascade-associated [4] E. Person, “Transient effects in application of PWM inverters to induc-
“N-Branch”-“pi” circuits reproduced quite well the wave prop- tion motors,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 28, no. 5, pp. 1095–1101,
Sep./Oct. 1992.
agation and reflection phenomena. Besides, the simulation suc- [5] R. J. Kerkman, D. Leggate, and G. L. Skibinsky, “Interaction of drive
cessfully represented the amplitude, shape and attenuation of modulation and cable parameters on AC motor transients,” IEEE Trans.
the voltage oscillations, characterizing well the transient differ- Ind. Appl., vol. 33, no. 3, pp. 722–731, May/Jun. 1997.
ential overvoltages present in PWM drive systems. A new equiv- [6] M. Fenger, S. R. Campbell, and J. Pedersen, “Dealing with motor
winding problems caused by inverter drives,” in Proc. IEEE 44
alent circuit for determining the common-mode currents was Cement Ind. Tech. Conf., 2002, pp. 65–76.
proposed. The methodology is simple and efficient and does not [7] ATP Theory Book.
752 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 23, NO. 2, MARCH 2008

[8] A. F. Moreira, T. A. Lipo, G. Venkataramanan, and S. Bernet, “High Darizon Alves de Andrade (M’87) was born in
frequency modeling for cable and induction motor overvoltage studies Monte Alegre de Minas, Brazil, on June 23, 1956.
in long cable drives,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 38, no. 5, pp. He received the B.Sc. and M.Sc. degrees from
1297–1306, Sep./Oct. 2002. the Universidade Federal de Uberlândia (UFU),
[9] L. Arnedo and K. Venkatesan, “High frequency modeling of induc- Uberlândia, Brazil, in 1980 and 1987, respectively,
tion motor drives for EMI and overvoltage mitigation studies,” in Proc. and the Ph.D. degree from the University of Leeds,
IEEE IEMDC, 2003, pp. 468–474. Leeds, U.K., in 1994, all in electrical engineering.
[10] A. Boglietti and E. Carpaneto, “Induction motor high frequency During 2000, he was a Visiting Scholar with the
model,” in Proc. IEEE 34 IAS Annu. Meeting, Oct. 1999, pp. Motion Control Group, Bradley Department of Elec-
1551–1558. trical Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and
[11] A. C. S. Lima, H. W. Dommel, and R. M. Stephan, “Modeling ad- State University, Blacksburg, where he carried out re-
justable-speed drives with long feeders,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., search on new strategies for modeling SRMs. From 1980 to 1985, he was a Lec-
vol. 47, no. 3, pp. 549–556, Jun. 2000. turer with the Faculdade de Engenharia de Ituiutaba, Ituiutaba, Brazil. In 1985,
[12] E. A. Vendrusculo and J. A. Pomílio, “Power cables parameters esti- he joined the Faculdade de Engenharia Elétrica, UFU, where he is currently a
mation in long distance driving of electrical machines,” in Proc. IEEE Senior Lecturer. His teaching, research, and consulting interests and activities
IEMD, 1999, pp. 410–412. are related to design, simulation, and control techniques associated with motion
[13] L. Marti, “Simulation of transients in underground cables with fre- control of electromechanical energy converter devices and new developments in
quency-dependent modal transformation matrices,” IEEE Trans. Power quality of power. He has authored and coauthored several papers in these areas.
Delivery, vol. 3, no. 3, pp. 1099–1110, Aug. 1988.
[14] F. Castellanos and J. R. Martí, “Full frequency-dependent phase-do-
main transmission line model,” IEEE Trans. Power Syst., vol. 12, no.
3, pp. 1331–1339, Aug. 1997. Marcelo Lynce Ribeiro Chaves was born in Itu-
[15] S. Amarir and K. Al-Haddad, “A new high frequency modeling tech- iutaba, Brazil, on October 03, 1951. He received
nique of travelling waves in long cable PWM drives,” in Proc. IEEE the B.Sc. and M.Sc. degrees from the Universidade
32 Annu. Conf. Ind. Electron., 2006, pp. 1119–1124. Federal de Uberlândia (UFU), Brazil, in 1975 and
[16] G. Skybinski, R. Tallam, R. Reese, B. Buchholz, and R. Lukaszewski, 1985, respectively, and the Ph.D. degree from the
“Common mode and differential mode analysis of three phase cables Universidade Estadual de Campinas (UNICAMP),
for PWM AC drives,” in Proc. IEEE 41 IAS Annu. Meeting, 2006, pp. Brazil, in 1995, all in electrical engineering.
880–888. He is a Senior Lecturer with the Faculdade
[17] J. Rodrígues, J. Pontt, C. Silva, R. Musalem, P. Newman, R. Vargas, de Engenharia Elétrica, Universidade Federal de
and S. Fuentes, “Resonances and overvoltages in a médium-voltage fan Uberlândia. His main interests are electromagnetic
motor drive with long cables in and underground mine,” IEEE Trans. transients in power systems, insulation coordination,
Ind. Appl., vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 856–863, May/Jun. 2006. motor drives, and quality of power.
[18] A. Kunakorn, J. Hiley, and K. S. Smith, “Frequency dependent time
domain models for calculation switching transients in PWM drives,”
in Proc. IEEE Int. Conf. Power Syst. Tech., 2000, vol. 1, pp. 205–210.
[19] Y. Weens, N. Idir, R. Bausiére, and J. J. Franchaud, “Modeling and
simulation of unshielded and shielded energy cables in frequency and José Luis Domingos received the M.Sc. and Ph.D.
time domains,” IEEE Trans. Magnetics, vol. 42, no. 7, pp. 1876–1882, degrees in electrical engineering from the Univer-
Jul. 2006. sidade Federal de Uberlândia, Brazil, in 1998 and
[20] B. Revol, J. Rouder, J. L. Schanen, and P. Loizelet, “EMI study of a 2003, respectively.
three phase inverter-fed motor drive,” in Proc. IEEE 39 IAS Annu. In 1992, he became a Lecturer with the Centro
Meeting, 2004, pp. 2657–2664. Federal de Educação Tecnológica de Goiás where
[21] M. L. R. Chaves, J. C. Oliveira, J. W. Resende, and A. M. Lopes, he teaches electronics related subjects. Since 2003,
“Time domain cable modeling with frequency dependent parameters,” he has been an Assistant Lecturer at the School of
in Proc. IPST, 1997, pp. 275–279. Electrical Engineering, Universidade Católica de
[22] L. M. Wedepohl and D. J. Wilcox, “Transient analysis of underground Goiás. Presently, he is actively involved in switched
power transmission systems,” Proc. Inst. Elect. Eng., vol. 120, no. 2, reluctance machines and drive system research, and
pp. 253–260, Feb. 1976. his research interests include solid-state power conditioning and motor drive
[23] B. Gustavsen, J. A. Martinez, and D. Duarbak, “Parameter determi- development to automation processes.
nation for modeling system transients-part ii: Insulated cables,” IEEE
Trans. Power Delivery, vol. 20, no. 3, pp. 2045–2050, Jul. 2005.
[24] G. Skibinski, R. Kerkman, D. Leggate, J. Pankau, and D. Schelegel,
“Reflected wave modeling techniques for PWM AC motor drives,” in Marcos Antônio Arantes de Freitas was born in
Proc. IEEE Appl. Power Electron. Conf. Expo, 1998, pp. 1021–1029. Monte Alegre de Minas, Brazil, in 1970. He received
the M.Sc. and Ph.D. degrees in electrical engi-
Helder de Paula was born in Uberlândia, Brazil, on neering from The Federal University of Uberlandia
December 27, 1975. He received the B.Sc., M.Sc., (UFU), Uberlandia (MG), Brazil, in 1998 and 2002,
and Ph.D. degrees in electrical engineering from the respectively.
Universidade Federal de Uberlândia, Brazil, in 1998, He is currently with the Industry Division,
2001, and 2005, respectively. Federal Center of Technological Education of
In 2006, he joined the Electrical Engineering Goiás/UnED-Jataí, where he has been working to
Department, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais establish research and education activities in industry
(UFMG), Minas Gerais, Brazil, as a Lecturer and application of power electronics converters and high
member of the Industry Applications Laboratory. power drives. His research interests include high-frequency power conversion,
He has worked in R&D projects on cable and line active power-factor correction techniques, motor drives, multipulse rectifiers,
modeling for high frequency studies. His main and clean power applications.
interests are motor drives, electromagnetic compatibility and quality of power.

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen